Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Allen \F\" Calton v. Steve Schiller"

Allen \F\" Calton v. Steve Schiller"
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided November 24, 2015

Allen \F\" Calton v. Steve Schiller"

Opinion

AJO. °^ FILED IN RPCEiVcD IN The Court ofAppeals ^&,xtriiD°.!tfrlS0tt" =^o -We Sixth District u; 1i ii»5 c oo^\ O-Q .A^«-«U NOV 2 4 2015 r^T^J^^ ' ^oc-CW Texarkana, Texas Sv*^ ^^£<W£ TsaMua\ OxAcncA- Debra K- Autfey, Clerk

M

A«* EMAILS GiX&T

A\WTM CqlW^ftJVfc* 3oW) Fm SS14 h

l£l&«^c\vi ^ $<xr\\es OA<^ Cjou/ujA "CVvi^-oVWin^^ a com^ \fi\ o£ a\\ forces. ,cu uoUl a^ VW*.

Aaorves oaA ogresses T>^c aV\ C-@u/ueL AV\^lvfHCal\on

A^nl\\o&4 AVWn&vj

A^U<&^ a\W^ T^r A^^e\U^ "T""o_*as A\WaCm &4/Vwl r

^ sso-es ?re s«/\Ve^ *> v

en ajjaowV ooWxs. i\ru c\c^vxi WVoJfo* e^Vccor^^ oa&e*«^onoV cir- c^^Wa^ o^e^Wc cai(L Qo& n^ <^Mp^\€-Colore o^-VUsyiWn I.e.

**eafc a/\*-*Were ^ocu no ^W>v^n$ ^ iw^rUe or ec*yA\c«. - ° f•IS

so a A ^ o4 Wo\ol • * - * " $' Ac^Varv^ ^ ^<^\€ ^%\ -S^X^ SS CrTe*. App.Te^W* \<$?i/umV ^cW^l » p 34

<3>af\r\^C^V C\*\Wi\$ Co. vj *L«^Ggc\SaVtfo <?>oc^^ M^f^^M CO.cor l<}"?a) * • , • < - op-WO,4-1 filter siu3^o ^^ s^q Qqi(^ . ^ ^ p.j^g.0,47 <3><x*Vc osVxfc* %W5wa^3jq orw.A^ ^AnJW> peVc^U \ . . p.J* Seeder v0>lUni <iS7 t^«tW CTev^\W^;*VOuVl WV*^v) • f' ^ &rt"A VA«Vca. Cas. o^ w.Co. mr i^ii, ol O'Wq) , f^-U fcc^V v, stW MUvWAw Cr*LA«HWta *>,| oo. p^U „ „ .fWL> ^i,A^ioWW(,^lVm4)< - „ F . _ .p.*/r

tW^ /VM-xjoniW P^£ ^ -r 2Crv^^^ a<^ A«oWiWi

c\*t*-m SW\«f-.13*1 *3M<to> C*Vhchrpm^. . ., .. „ ^i2,\Z,\i cuVdvcA-W v VrocWer 4<a Fxi Wi C^x^v w^ « * - - f.M7

^^oo^ ^ e<>*4 x7Yu.<;. sm*. CBHJ 0 f n.4l C-ocVe-2. 3^W^c^c_ \3 ^wn l-Vo\^% ^__^ 9^9 Fj^ M2v £24 C<r |S9lJ «• • p I C«v\as Cou^V^viAoljtY^ij^j^ ss^orG^oooaJ . ^ . . p05,317

£4S^>3^ ^^7 CTe^t .A#- A^O a OOO , 9<A A0/1} - 0 ,, . p.4?

0<^n$T v/ A^Q AaanV^. O^A^CS .TE^c -7D| pa£ ^3^ CTe^L \<?ts5 © p. 2.9 Xbrofu^ \) oOosWjVoq J7^u.S. MO t ftto^) 0 o ^ .p.i/l,*/.^ e, &o^JE/v6 V/V\ee£>LcJh6iA^ UJ_S4~l U.S. V? CXOOU i * p-3^ CQS« PaS^

VS^>S^ ^VCTci A^.Cor()MS CWUU no peV h } * „ « - ^p.3G

G-er-sWov/ ?*3^ 4ao^>. k>3 CmrJ - , r ^ o «i7

^om v*t 11^177^, gV *0. Ores. A«p Cecuw^A^l lo, juohU n* ^V, ^\ . p# | Groi^avii n/ fWAq>poliV<vo W Q^h Lgga Aii1 O 7S|jo3^ 4*7 Grex im}. ft«4(p Gr^eret^- *"OmdM'os^o ^siiu) x^ q s*S ere*. A>p. £•( p«t© i<?<o } c p,^ 47 ^^a^ v A^<u-\c^ ^ &* vjor vW. cJk\oV,e/\ Co. QaA Jwl^ ^a? CTe* ^e(>- ^^^ cArCifc i^^^orvVdlw^e^.tp.o^-U p.37 vW&in 0\W^o <&T) ±^\^ 1*0 Cxi* \*fto) , 0 „«..*>. 47 \\of^S\J^M %\% W^£ Xi\ CTev.AwionArA<niom»/vo pcV"^ ... p. 3* Y\aVJh n/ ^&Ai\S Q> a\ W\& 443 C~T<=* Co ^ Corpus Or& /usrA o*P n-re-l p. T7

:Ca*s.* ©£ M^n^s ?a^Q, M\ v^oVoWc vi G^rc^enW^qr a\*\£^3& <*So CTe^App. AuiVo 3-00(03 - *. (p.37,3^ vVoWctA^ A<v\ ^vs. Co vJ iwcaiV-Sion €>£ <2-o-f "7T)fA^ ^X^S-HoCrmr} - ~P' 5*?

V\osc^ OCov/x^ o-^vivj^o^q %l^SooX^ 701 CTe*AVP- Cw^Clari^ \99Xi . (X3*4 V-W^WV; LacK 487 u«s.au.tp (.WTO} o ~ - . p.^S" V\c4^son vj vvjWaVU^ 1"i^ faros'? Cs-^oV i^r ) . * - • - p-^

^ToW^oom SV^3ce \sli^3^VU GTe*. Co\^ App. aooM ) c « p-30,iT ^^u g iUU ^ 5^3^ l^(5T^.A^.^AoW^ ^0W3 . . p. J?

<G<^ MG^V-eU m^-^S tm^ <, to c r ^.37 Le~>\&o &«***£ $>i<\ £a^ \Us* Cs*Hc*r \vn*} c c , p.Y?^

=CaA^ o^ JW^o^W <?a$£ W Cases p<A<li

OA&VUK vj\\oo^> ir7FXfc^o CZnivCir (<=*<?( ) 0 0 p -p. 3VJ * rvx^er ^ C^M o^ cW.^30 MoM u.s.i^^ Cl<nO ff e c - • p.M I

m,Ye\eS sj u3cm<^o &^u.s. <| Gc<?9(3 « «. , e . . •p.3* ^^ ^ S«creVarY DC -^Ke XJo^y ~m F4^ IUM ( 0,o. 1^1*) * - p,l7 owe* v vwWne 1*1 F1^ c^.u^ciV ^^ e 0 , -p37 ^a^Unn^A vjC\ose. -SHoa^.7^ CAoo*6 « . . « c . .pjo,a| A)tWi ^Vsoase^ ^7^i^^^^ Cr**m*0 . c * - - . p.*Jf ^jrviTC Cor9 ^ CqnoJCQ^ ^ S^S^. tvoS CTe<.Affi Seowvt^nV 200^)' p-'-IQ /Ju^as Go^/^ w f^usoi 97J^o3A 3-° * CTf-LAgp. Car^d^^ JouiKwa^ ' />25,24 e>$e\^ ^oW *xifiA tasu>c s-doair wo} * , , . _p.a] ©<-e\Wl ^^(ie ^S ?3£ 2*? CsVv->arn?s\ , c , « p-is-,17

fi-vie vj W^ iWfc*i sas f^W IS^trmu) • • - p-(l 9kAUU \J &ax>VU ^^ S^k MX( GXe^.>(yp a^^o W^ux^XA*^/^ 9re,\i«TV (Lo^rl^Z. MAV U.S. HIS CVPl) * . . - , ^^i^iH^/I?

Gases 9<W* U^Vc GAMUVm CcWn- uCoW 7S4S^X£ \*\ CTe^\<m ^ *- p34

U^\«rV \j \\<fc*s SS5 ^.iv^p 7^ G.Aj.oaio«^ mo) „ ~ - . p*Ji ftAviowrK o iV*^ *bH~> F-*^ U.S7 CS-VHar (<n7 ^ » » . - -p.Hl/31 fcWuarVC V iW> Cell fX&Oill CS*wOc\r«o) 6 , „ » .(p,3?,<^ <UmV*tO WU \VxS^3^ SS4, Cre^.Cv^A^ ^o^ - « - ^-3?

5^«At WWr^ <£W«\ ivo^sm e-re^crw A<?p. \<J92j „ . ^ p.3^

\<u\°\i ^erv&fss o^Uw\'w\<+ SV^ S^-oG parens <*X\Fia MiaC&Mr£ir1sVlL 12,13 SqoAo«cmsVoA^ laa$\>jl u<^,6-GTc^fti scav.s^.7^^ cw-ani mo} • . ^f/0, S\^^ \y *-<=w^ S41 5ooi^ S7<* G~Tevc 1<?^U * <- ^ -pJS" S^edtP o-Te^S «e\^,»i<- S£5' -S->-^^ Cts*. IT79 ) c o , -pj^ <A«*J? rS«n 60-^iMiS wVLA^Wct VlHSwiA <o*<.CTrU<M) . . , p47 SV^-? 0<^V.WwM-S o^ Qub.Tro/fcp, s/ Gon2«Uz %X*^3«* ^^zCveNLaooz3 - p<J<) SUe-G^ ^S«r^ \ODC3^~n^ Ct^CatW? J - - - . • -p-M7 I k-

-T«toi \JeiVJWA Ccua ^oc U^vi i*W> VW14^ PWoJ*c ^

^oorrv8" \J

K^k o^ A^&aAei S>*$<2-X ~7oU i^^fc ^<1 CTe^A9p« v-Vo^sVon i-i^^J1 to^M ^co^ll ^u.v*tf) Cmaj c . . . . . ^V<Wl

VAX CoasV Ap^a& \J"V * a „ c •> - --«o.3? u,V Goas\ Arr^A^ YAVJ ^ „ .. p-W3*W^

^e^ Su.Cor^ .?. ^\e 1>:lUO CVj 3 ~ * - . ^ p.Q.0 \% u.S.C. ^ 3UtU ^ 0 „ , ., , p. Ma.

2T u.s.c% *2U4 c\^C>K& • . . . * p.3^ l\ ;u u ^c. i ^^ c^c^Cc^ • * " ' 9 A ^e*. oC AJiW-Vw p6_s/Z_ XI r-.

W>^-VG i xx^M 0 „ , « , . &t LO

Mx u.s.C. ^HT7«C^ . . . . m „ . . . . .p.3*

Tt^.toxi^V Coke VaA.0\^ „ „ , „ . p.)(o ~tW.C5vi*9raiC. |U~ Go^.g \ \o\.oDA «, w „ , , p. a3 •V^%. Go^e. Ccvorv ?(0C Ar\ \\.07 IM &\ o c * _ p. 5C -fei. C^U Ccvtv^ §T0CAc\ O-0lC\} «, o c -aDO Tw. 6-aoP. ^ ^ a „ c . . . <p.<M"? "TevtA.A^p. 9. Oaa.Vli3.1 „ . . , p- MG? -TeyL. SLAffi*. *-Ue VUo<^G$ o , ,n3o -r^.^App.9. <uj^ a\.lfeic0 _ r m yf>is-

=&\kv< &C >VHKo^ei pc7J)C X\\, r"*\

QqvaVs AV^iaV fl?ge\WU 0>oet tCeco<^ M^eAUts OAci-tf\* XU, U- o£tVorti(W& ~tWe are ^Wc-ee S*tt«r«/>k CWyi O^coo^ rvTc,^ U^\We de.u>r&on A^aV* \aj\AIa eacV\ oooArcumng one 0<W>e . -five InAtaV CWVk Oexor^frte^ cle^s. $&,a>^ Vs^zh or> 9-3HC oofU ±>jl cefe/re^\o belov^ q^ " UUvxfP

^KeM^ -CK*l e^WitU op -Ov^ >o^\K A^W G^pWn\ u Yk<L iiv>e 9\«^vr\s * G>o\^ ^\l b^^eWre^-Vo ooW^eo^ oVokoAi hereto <ve ^a^_ Vo tf>e co^>\ou'A\ c^iaiy e-jcUtTiV ^^cki H^eVo, fieo^e \v\ \W\i Cour\a Oe Ah>sao <Uoieu> ^tvy ooniA*T -Qqc^s i>eA-CoP-Vh >xo eA- 9WA ;VicV^ See GocV^c rr^ui ^e vw^W^ ^ «?M9WA ^ 47 C^c,Nrl^OCn^o^AWV^o^9l^ U^eev,ei \o iacU&e <*y uJiVWi

-Vion ^ rcsooV -Vo oc sdosPCJL ^Wose octunqcy ^a,VV^ rcqj,nqUy 9iX€- iVton*^). ftaaVW dC^WM rx<&i* are. ^r^U, c*u ^.^ qVj^ J^^p 33b ^ 37^,379 CS^Cir-2003) OWWnj -VW* a co^-V rv,^ \^K ^ -^^^

C-Ue nAii(oU ,^,. (LX;,. P. 91 Ak ^l.jous 4o (UJu „(,]c^.^.

G*otU\v>£. ceVo^^cvVioo Qa<^ VfcW* o^ An €tUc\\0^ Af>pe«\ - *e«_ c<LOoLl preso/\V o^o<?rj*. e£Ce,cV *UJcjtcviV^o^ AWhV Ch.\W>"\ ddeiuv^- ~T>^ i*nju/)cVi>€ (JjiVe^r ^ooi^lnV \n$T&bf\ -

rAtn W\o c\a<W qa^ in,y*/\c\>vKL c-eUe-^ ua^qj^ <-uuA1C^\cft3„ on S-PH4 -Wve OxsVocV Co^A ^COA\e<^-Mr\e OeW^OA-V XfLi^es iWon £ellsr* /*-Terri e Uailn?- "^Tuj^VxcVJon -se^cvX-OcU ^.qo -On n-i-W TKe oaVcfc* Cooj>V oWei A^tVWVs, *V^noO ,£cC J\%p>xc\t*sQA\ 0^ Gouas^I ,i^eQnc>o\.l p.K<>s . Oa OrHS -tVe 0\i\<\c\ Cout\ ^coaV^A 5v\€*>e *c3x\\l<*ri ou^VSoo^-^ oum;^ Put^jloaV -VoOao^T \4 of -Vto C\\i.9rc.e. (U-^.OxlG .^e€ C^vroU p-4SO. On k^'S-IS" C^\"VoO -C\\eA K\^ rw>Vvon ^rLwy« To A*^^ aA/^<Su.£f>)&qe*\ fAis fW~ c^n^ vWiVa V*«. -Mir*^ A*^V£<^ Co'v^WirA a^ S^ff\e^eA1c~Vb-^Ysj2, Ajm+K AotsQa^ ^WrvV.^e a^S^p.CtUo\.\ p.(l-i7- OA7-^-lS" CdlW^WA Pbc i-e^^ To An^eA^ cW£> S«^i\«m«a\: V\\<> ^\eak\n^ ^\Ma -Kmi ^in-VW

^&>vy^ WcA

va)WY^€T- VML \xaoV 7T*^S-e *.C.ceA ?* jco/\Vin$ Oe^anV ^W*_ h-

z3Cs.^pLe A)o,3_ vaA^VW^ VWL \-c\<A J^je -exreA \a ^e^'n^ CivUVi iv^Vioa &>C ^A^^ovrvV^eA^ O^- Cou/i$>el, 3Zssv>e X)o. *4

t\°rfc3- ^oj^Vo \V\e €^Vro,or^-\A&j-cv Oa4 e*<jLpV\^AcA coccu^Yo/yUA c>£4W

T"^s^> JJo, vp

9co^e A^\\oa\ ,AUwfM C^iW) GV>^eatU^ CavUnor A^elW\X^- \vaC-ouSQ. XJo. fc.%M3\W \n Vr>e 2.\31a xTm^xcM CourA o^o seaW)<4<^Ao tife -VWe. cvqVv\ Vo A^4 oa S-ao-o4- OdWa-Gle^ Uii ru>V>a oC Agjpcql oo 5-Xo-oM. Cy-^. nAs Oa^oo Por free fafwrVi fotcoc^ ga^ AfWctovVo? ^<\o»W\wf To 9<^f tor C^^uel o^avV Cbp^J^ de<^^*3qi^ 0-vA^u)Q3 ^coAVeA V>M-W»&. uD^oic^j co^V on s-ao-oU. $<jl C(L.ocA«l ev^hWo tq\Wn <>euuvH2A noo^ d4V\nC.W\€? A^e\\<*4 GouMe\ G«tr^ AVtor^Cjr\*re- a Sri^J- -/\\Coc^ ) <^a*s. ^r^ -^U A\io^ on C^iU's WW£, Att«r re^'nj SotN^ W\e£ CmW, o^ujA oo s-eWe/ices oc c\Wioo$ i-o^re. c\c,Ae V-o-^

^a,YW.AV^do We $>da>W erroneously &W^ A^\.-W^ retonU dvWi ^^re tn^ua^nj q\do«V mac, wy.AVWA. vjOete o,own,n!

A^q (J.C0W ^^ ^W^.e^ C«»\»*A on a/, initioeA <v,*> .W-wM*. record or, \i-O- os" kHU-e_ Second OuW-V o4-t-«?*.c<s. G^w^o^ Appeals.

A^ >Oo. oa-o4-J^C(L . Cal\t)n £\\e^> a wr\V °£ l^Wear Corpus 00

ai ^ ^ ^ otvWjt ,w^Wr x'0 -yvM co^ <ajr>Y *JD. C-aij-oo^tVciVUlicX- A , ioau>s--S-.?o-<37, s-ee ccotoH «^-tV ^ its-is-? cv^"W aA f. toao-<oA2 AtW wurAOnji ieoW UVW* Vo^WS>,Sd^Ur ^^.Wl^,^^ »a aa a\Vr^ Src procure VM_ «Wx>A--ce.u>r^\o no Quail. ce.ecft.odU "<nU"

£o!\ek-Vo -VroAiu-^e- ceV<waA\ preWoY ccco^ ct^ik^ ^ c^Wi. \s>^oe^ \Vs. Y^cvA oo'^or on, \1-7-tQ^ -Gxnk-ln^ icJM\*r v;?oUte£ (UJuL V.C^<^V*^oc^rA9eW\cQ-tl^oJL-ico ^<JK\\WU ^ai\arcVo <^cepo^i V^an- ^ccVv^s -for 9ceYc\a\ V^ep^VnQj AVvaV v>>ej~e pco^ftpU ce^M^VeA W{C<A- Von OnA ^>\i -Va\\ux-e -^o ona^ C€Cisoaei\ole vn£u\c\es aW>^V VKe e*\enV 6t^e- record. £eec<HJoWl ,lV(W c*V ^ X^Sr-^7 Q^^^qiti" oA p, sMV&sV, A^W ceouuvrvs SxSKttteri respond &«Ye^ 5-a<H^+C> C^\Wu U^Wa\ H>q^ Was rv>cAe-wiUi AVg, C(LC&. uJnicVv CAI^oa r^e- QjU^^ on ^'\3-U- GM-len i^a/i JftlfQj <joAs o£ iWoeetf Corpus jecWft^ ^>oMa oa Ou\'0^T"\^3L-~Ap(?^l cmoIor A Ateu3Trtql cW Vo W\k kircO* QfpeaV ooa£ cesoVa^ onQA^^o^pUU oa^ vns^&uenV record, ^e vaaV bs-^o -K4W^\n ^-^-S9<rt7,vW^er^<w^ CsWoM -A^ecAs, (kekneA \o \aKe oa<-< ac^on on. *VAit <jor"^v, £.«_ o(L*j4,1 *VWaV 9, S^>A qa& ^9^V1 aV Q-Q>X7 - C*vWi -W^ &ouSV* Wqo^Co/>> -W- ^i-CMa Gico^V U^.CooJ^V 0^ A^pcaU Ao £W ^ -WaJLuiu^ O0r.v\ Ao-g\<^ -VV^ X>aoWi 0\^v^oere^. e^^aL cJeW** ^. W^Orlion on MHI-I^Go^- «£<*W\u$aV ce^or^ ar& -YV-G ocwn'VW^- Os^^ ^oore neU^o^ -fopO/i et^cV\v^ {C<Uf o^a^ OAeoAlA^C-tl appcaLike tttMn Gl^V ^GareA GUton \<Uur^Vo&ka ^e^era^ feV\Ven o/\ u-lf-lS. 1n u.sM. AJo, 13. ||0*I 3«e t(L. >JoV.\)^-<V>P<a-V^3CO-3Ul qa6 *91lv' aV f-^xs-bau - uAwU/i ^UtoUei ^Ua^ c<uW\ Wu no ce^e^ ^ V|c^o tWW (iaU><u Corp^ 1V1 ^V-dUoj^ p«W«l Co^V, .AVVCo^WlV \i un'^^UA icMUr^s inc-of*.pe\$0V C€-r- por\sa$ pr^cAsuL \a VKtl prepv^W\ o£ record-foV appeal to* ie^n^eA 1a VKe OvAocV CoiapAt i-en^a^ :rr^uA<Jhm^g. (LeAie^ on 2 -X0-)4- -X*a parA^Vxr G^lVon s^^lCs. ^ c^m^l^e OA& iu^U-eA.\: record on cwweQ^ q^ qh/\ ov4^c-o^-Vir(Ne-o^Acc<V Vo eCfetJ^o^Lv <aVS\t2.e £<&& t-ei-orci -V^ ra)^ \do\Ia(p£&. ^U^VAtd Spe^^T^v^l Oa^ ^r^^y vjToUV^O cJc*irv>ftzcA v^n" r- "K\\e A^o\^/n€AV o£ Cou/u«-V on \0-^V-\M »See C\\ vjo\.\ p. W0-15"L JTZa Su^poA o*i ^<vv^ fY^V\on Cq\\oa fee^QA qU&^V .We-3TA<i\- p. i^A-| ^. C<q.\Von °t\s^ £\\e^ ciAQ^^c^o\V o£ vn^^w on /o-ai-W OuVVio^ \WlGout\ or> n^V*ULJ(WA V\e^o<^ \oo ^oo.r Vo <vttor^> -Vo W»VfevJOUASC\ .GS\h QViO ^r^CKT^A. Q-CAn^fee^ CO^O^ \flfc \t\rwkll .\C^VU^ accoo^V &V*Wt oorArWnj a U«/*x o£ I 0.00 in \nU acuuA\. We. \v,V ^^ C^OoU f>. M-0? oao «Anc So^p Gp.^U p. 5\ C^-Wn U tv^WW \\l Qa^ U WftA ^Iojjao^ wxWv rvx^or^e- 9ce^s\on -^ ^HcK*\nc Q^We^ <*^ U^criv*^ a *^W*U\ *«•"* o^ ^cWoV^G os^W**rtf >^ee GCLuoU ?.i*.*«* n^cWW pr^*As C«vW, 4co^ e^UcW^ YA^aVhj ^ do^s ^ 9^^S Wu ntfnVs, =r& aVq.\X3-aLV. oJavcJIa c«^re* C«\Wi m^ca lnecan<^UrA\^^io rCAcVp-\gt^"iaS:* lW>eu«rCa\V*n co^ovjVo^ ~-on^ qaAocuIA ftoft pcu* fcAU^ 9r\^AQT4 ^e co^mAs&ar^ W IW Vk*, ^^ +* ?**"**- ^aVr i«~^ ^ ^^ Vo 4ell W* t<*>o V*^ £>o Itjol auUVa*« .x^ ct-V ixH-vxs:, oao oooaV^ua^^ <WW> (v^uJrvS iWl^P^ '^^ vW^f * A^sdS otWi /^^oaWU ^ an aVV^V \o peosecvJ^ ku W*uA ,^a\ iXf'W^- ^JaIUa po^es 0 ^\aiWA*«l fv^Vo Cq^o'i i«&4y cvxAvu-dlWop, rfSec^urG od*«nUlVon ^^ V^o nn^M fc©J«s o£ ho aaqjop Ae?cess,V> /meAvcaWi c«ujues> U/n V^ e^i^^ &esire Vo wV Wa^mA-V \n<^G CA^^cVk^^ on^«A)cuiWn5-VoA\€-^^^ p.iafc-U"?©^ ni-m< on s-x<?nr 9uriuoA\"r^^Ke 9<;^on m*v\w cuj^ c«riW> ic^AW-5 AA^onT^ ^i^^-•rCt^ o4r P MS"°.\4^^ej^r -fer ^<u=>n4u/i~ WV^.^onS'kVs G^vW> Wvs x»\r.^.AoJiA^cA co^UnA u)as rvoV €k w«^rtec r G*nV\\ G>-\S-\r. 3Z&<\\(o[H0 oo Cp-i^'I^CMWA^rva^ cec^veA-tf-e. -TcscA CovxrXs, orW^ d«\e<^ S-39-ls~ an& G>-|-ir -A<**\ AeneA C«\V)i rw-oA[ivvi for A 9cm£,WmViaaj .IXnyjiAcW'i oa^ ^rcw\e<k ^^till^ns w-o-V^oaTo 0\S^a^So See CavVoAs tv>^oV\(r> T^ AwGaA ^o\-\V\ £<*cVs <~onWneA -YAen^Vi S^oorn -Vo caa^lt AVe_ ^^a^vV^ °^ 9^0^* i€€ -^A iuppCd.viol-l jp./M7- Spacifec«AUj^-«A. f.U- AUo .*« sfcu^ oo&apj-eCLvJoLl p. 4*f*<2^ trO cespec \isie\v *AV w>Wm Anrf^e Q^vW-> prepared a^<A /v\<a\eA n\s, or^oVon "T\s Aa^A o-n G>-(C~ir . AtW* b^oe §>u\-an nwcs -HictM^v^. Vo o^la^ <-ocu ajul^gA AojlVo ^Via^..W\S A)\nVV) A^«nAeA Goo*p\aAvV umWa s**z^&cu{S 04 vkG.

G>-HC k^ar\A^ dole.TA <*V ?.\7 - CooVs^portvtfA^sl^^eA «A*h toVk fvv^Yian Pb^ Le^v^ \"t> Atwla^ C«\Van ^\eA kis \e\Wr \o-Vk4- \S3 r^ Cour\ Coor^naW. CGe^vJ^\i>\$ a^V\e<wiV\2 Aa±* ^% Co-JVir OA^ie p^oVaoo . Asv>oe\\ ens, V»i^ AjcATcX o£ vU^-iVi^ fy £Jo/>^ion-for s<^A oAso pCocnAeA -*^*G Co*ajA G-oooAio^W ^1 oopy o^saiA CV-cAifcn Qa^-Hv^. ©cA<LT ^ co^pUa/icJl to\V\n"rqrroAV G»wa^/^oc«»I &aU Aoctfcj* A *-e- quiuVt Vo doWafng -VKfc. ctjJtmUA ^earfV?^ ,&<** jr<i q\. pan.A^iWlly C^i 1W1 p^t\ W-cAnaV Co^rV c»urV onAiYecA n&Vce °£-%U -fil»o{ c£^oti rwAoA. oaA Vkj2. c^-^^ <o~x<?-ir kwrin^ A«*^-.3:A. «V f XO- C^tW^obo Ae^a^eA VU^"t VWeA-ri^l CourVcJiL oy~i ^;3 /^^^on forU^'T^ A^a^v .***- cQ-O0L\ p.^A'S- fe5|, ^OCtll^ C^U-cr) -QUA On Ap^JOAQ/|CyMV- ooar^eA Vl^Vv^l CoiaM a top^ oQ-Wv. o^€cWl-Vo^\<Sa\ Gdup\\ -failure ^o (IaJol on kvi tvv^non ^or le<HJ-$T° Ar^\A k^ Go^pWf\\ ^vM^ Afe TVj^aMa -A**^^ Gor^p\aiA\ ,W e^L.VJoV.l (p.v75-^7i| Su^mcv^ G>^-~X\\e -Ac^ij^^vT (Po\nV °-£ gccc^ One^ -0rN^Tc^a\ oduaV ecce ^ io ^iwii^ C^Wi cl^W

A^^Woa^ Oooaaaj Sr\e-C p^e7^SO r\

-VW. ce\\e^ ^ovA^jk^ A^ <\A- &£*-tc Vo cW,\V<2^£ ^e-Sacv o^<WaVono-£ W\S Oca^a^o^aV* -Mor o.\6 CavWn see-V^. oe\lt£ 4WA oj^u\As irv^Vt^cVe

££12V_0g ftror T^Dl TKe_Tcva\Q>^\ eeceA vn Aiv^iu^ C^Ws ^\o5^e C^vv, fv^-on ^-cu^> C\<*^a.S djcUA-S\ StWA^T A^^V^ta C<h\Voa; &u4lA ScSa\\\«T* \aVy\S xo^^Wal c<xpciuAw,\*We_ CC^rniOJ ovAW^ /vumiW^lQcU O^AAWas -ScMkr v^QS<\o\ enV^^-Wc^inuM O.C 3osRrey/\ tmmuuu^ - fro?* 0£ Eccor ^V^l T^e T^l Go^We^ ^t*i^^AffinV c, ^ oaA aolnMn^^A/or^-ss Aoses o^ki's ^ WiVis oaA riMcte 1a€«IHa onA^iteVy ih <a/ift4Wp^- -V-o prosecuicc IaK ic^iuij-. .A/.A- Jko^G PoYnV fr£ g-c-rer Wr* ^THctl CouA err^A^ Au^^ GdVksm3 e^or^o^ cvrcu^A^UAai exiiWA <^b A^ Vo ^a/e bWnj c c-o^Ute£cti- \ucc ©V ^kc s^W) i.e. C^iVon tos no oVUer ^Ae^M r-€^e^Q.V Wo.y\V

9o,aV O^ ECCOC^^-1 -CVv^- VlaV cxxatA e.^e^ W( rv^V recoos^A^'nf CaAW\s c\ou3(\/\s. <^\W- fmj Vc\ V^k\ o^YWi ajIavIa Ar*w^ c-crA- pWA VWA ^>Q5> \tW^f £A<ek ^uriuflA-V V^-^ML- pmon mail W cuJjL anA Avxc \o VWjl -Q<*A C^vWo ^ ouj\^ \ea^ Vo <\U Yv* ao^a^ A^^i^i Go^WnV.A^^ ^vau Vs> YWft/e -)o,s no &W*nS o^ surprise- oj- fC-G- ^uV\cjl- ^Wov^n ^ ScWU*/- oc eo^n o^ a\W^ Vo^°^° -(W^cA

AfP^UanVs, 0$e/vn$ Goe£ fGpe^DtSO r

""Vke. Tc\a\. G^^A *s-f ce^. \o j^aAvn^ ^V^eSdUVW-S r^Vion""^ £> x^-oaa^s. A.^^.W.oaVv, CW<vvs> ua Ajlt \ l<f&3 SVcaAotA C£ ^.eO\G^ •oOken | <*s> \a -tfrvG 'va^VoaV cnse , °^ \n/v\<i\^\auisu\V *U Aum^ed OS -CcWolfcu^ -£oc Wun<vj nt> bas\4 \r\ W^ oc £<*c^ k»A ao^atV ke«rtq$ \£ WeXAy-Ww^ CoiaA-s ceu\t^ -focuses on ^ke\^4T M\t ir\(na.VG K^^iA t\as> an Qr^vxa^Ve l^xs vnW^-^e &co\\ \J Golle^Vftr Jo<7ju>3A a^aKo vaos an ar^vAaUe W\^\n \a^o \s d le$a\ x^^v>n -*v>A k veoU^ei de aooo, ^^ Tn re \WpkfG^ W^S^aXA 4t^,Mo4 cTr*. o^.OA.fuWp Ce<<?W^<VS ^vj^i^oru^Q-ViJOJ-e Ae aov;o\"Tk<- sco^o^ ceuie^U \iVv(VeA VoAkxis.e ot^uaacAs ra'v^eA, \aJ<kG pr^on to Ovy*\\ss.S*e &*v^f\\) Ae*t<\o, CaS.. QaASuXoGo.- ur T<HVt3/N'$s^UA 171, n^ Cl9qoJ ^X ton- Aoc3oa^ a cevj\eo3 e>£ 4^e oma^WaV ,ArWvS. CoiaA fwuA V«ne Vcu-C VKe. -CscWav «Utja\\ons v'^an incvmWk pekWn anA reo\eu> VKe. Vypes o£ ceke-f c*n<^ ^vAAses o£ ac-Kon 5>e\ ovj\ -*k«/*\n Vo ^eW^'nt Kok<Akwy as q /vo^vUr oJ; \<^ ,-vw ^eAiVion &WW^ <* c^se o^ ocVon -vWr^uvA c^vWorV^e c<Av.cA*WJi S<~oA xo?Sxo3A «A ^^AcU'm kai no ar- o^uaVoVe SoetVvi. in \c^>o v-G A ceVv.es ^on an vnAiip^\;<aloVj£ OAer-iVW^s "PaoVW \Vn's GoujA "vsVo V\o\A C«uWu 9\*q&w\$& \v> \<AS> .$Ac\<\?e\\ sAoaAoP^s Ainan -formal pW^A^^S Ac^fVeA k~< lAA^er^.See feVxicsA* \j fc^cvir *WW .^. "AV1,4 XO CV*n;0,<v\A a daw s-kouvA ao\ ke Axs.^\^eA un\e^ IV a-^ear^ V^onA Ao^A VU<A d «\<ua-V^4 » C<XA Q>cooe r\o s«\ o£ -CccVs* \o sa^r\ o£\oK cAcuW ^WOa u3ou\>s eAAVcW^-Vo ceUA-See Gon\s.Mvj G\Wn *%SvjuS, 41,4 5--^ 09$l)

Tine \asVoaV case l\tsoV>A\e 'vn\<irs.^cV\fcn c£ ^u*» fee\\\c sources. o-Q 'V-tAeraxGxwV V\Y^W)-~tVt e CisM ftVjVfcs AcV -Uu.sX..^ IW ox^A F«Wal ^o»- voee*s Coc9us $Vc*WW 5^y.S.cA JA^4- Gotf^ o? Wv^e pcoo\Ae acctu, V^ ^eAsrql Wu/n Vor cWoas o-C ^coAiVi\u^OAa\ keeA«eA aVW* IaoaAs c£ ^v^ oCAaaU U^^^'^Vir s<u>pe cm^ o?^0/1. x^ -Hi^1 ^ii^i^^ C^WeA *e osWnl^ UUe^ Wt W protons, OaA UeU-K** K*Uas Gorp^ ^VWL e^cUut^ ce*eiy Vor * ^ ^sa*V ^ a^m^M. *oc* or Wa^on oft Ws oxvfcv***,^ o*0 s^ics '^^i^ *4««W reU^e; eo«n A^^^ Qa<u^ ^a^^^ ^,A(UiV) ii'Wof W**{ $tf*2 n<A cereA^H «* v^a^ o£ ^^r^C^n s^KS not T^e- AiaVe. or so«eA\ei~ create W»4 n«prpli. r^i/* ^ i • .

l^W c^r^s caW p<We c^W, a. om^.,^^.^, ^ ,

'Wa °? ^ rd^ ^^ ^V ,J, .^ee ^w ^rc, ^Ureq ^.(Ss^er seevu ^ v^c\V oQr VAoWa^ Gor-^^s oa^ £cAs. Ao q\Vqc\c A^e vjo.\\VvV^ eA Vvl oc Wr &^nW\u2. oc W\e_ \*AaAk o£ Vus. or V>er ca- sVoAv-j (-W«L ^V^VivcV CqwV WKs -VAt £<^^<5_r 2>^ a^A^-ec^ rwA\*n ^iatU- AxcUqa Vo \s>Uxe 4>Ke uDrAM CC.T^lor vj Ua'A^A SAAes. ?«Jo. C>Q-CiUL 4o<* F3A nau COX. Xot^).rhe So\e ^uacVAo^ <A +Kt ur'^ c^ £<*- be<=»s Coo^^s '\^ V^ ^ccxa\ re\(e-Q -(com uaI^&A* i/v^ma/meA ^r CM.iV^A^ / QA*h. CanAoA W M.se<X -Cor oa~ oVhtA purpoj-e.i^e QierrevV vVrk*>3W£8S SXS F,X^ 9X3 Cs-HnCir i?7<*) -fYve Ccmic ©£ £cK-v\Uns Co/AenVion in k\^ ^fwckon TO 0"^*ivs v-oo,s, VWr C^vkm cW^ V^aA no Wis in \c^or-f«cV/ onA+lo<A h\s> C.Wnrv& un^.*r^l9*3 c-ou\ AoA k-e i^WaeA kscoui*. iV oecmortly VAn^\\cAVeA Vke vj^kAA^ A kvsA\n<A c*>o^cVon/p«r rtecv.^ (Au/npkrey Svd.u.s.^7 cvwi .^ee C(LA)oU p.iu%-W •ScMWi ^eUiwceo^MUcJC'i AAii^Aai ket^j-ue VV\e relief CmW\$j*£^ in n(\ ^T^^Ma o» ^ A^iavIa A** Y^enAeA Cx*wf\<H<As cioe-S r\<A Call h\Yo ?vA$ikon DT Jf*v^W««tal VKe vjaR- A.\Wf A kt^ £-onvj\cV\on or s-enW\C£ , ice c(i.Vol.l M<nV\"ctV p. -2to*-a70 CwA^-nn,'cV^S33-S3S'' M*o s*l *\-Uc\o , tu^xcu SdiJlWi reY*a*<x *n ^GVarY,€M ^adri no bAW <^on\v\lic^ -WacA Q^A -S^lV^o^ layAAcVv^L relief Qre n^>V ^^a^« ^A*r %V<i%3 {£ AW aoVuy*. o£ \k«. feffe£ ^ouvx\A \rv^\ic«>^ -We V/<»UX\V-( cA OCr^Aal C^o^Wv U€ C<L\K>U f.><> 1. \VovO- 'C-Wt1' vAjaS cJnalUnji^P « OoAUcVton VWA iVl^irAe A4VorA ynjqti*0 o< V^e vsno-VWr?AsoC \e$M rcArew^ forkoo oC <^^Ve 3-ex AeU/#*nncAi<in+UqV a^cuCn ooouVA oe biAAtVy^ on c* sW*-£ c^urV vn ex iuWtuM\ ocVon- 4aa^^V-«3^ ColaA oouv^ c^n\vj c^oAcl^^e +^Act\ Gv«^V^ UcV> be^n e*,AlJrcV€A e>^ oi^V^n3 Ck/\ tAAuaA^VW^noaql cujj^.^ee eVar^e vj3\q&Uj- )s:^F3A V<tL?tv^° CsMnCCsr ISI^CeAba^cJ -^eCo^rV v^ e^V o^ Ao r.^ U»A it cAorVLe'i e^on^ve^on \n AA>»e AUU^Vatw^ v>3ai V^ieA on an UA<^asVxWWn<4 cJSl * rrVooo^\A beM>e s&A o4 v bWoois. AeWA^^A {^<i^ e-iV*b\ukeA> r eiMA^ io nMttifrctkon D-t -vke coAu^kuo t^r ^ nV \^o C^'nj eA^oc^As \y Af{e\\oA^ ^eA-ir^ Gc\ct ?6^ \\*&t^^ fcaVv^o*. in S.-GV \S^4 ,\SV& GW7), AaI g^ g* ccsmA o£-iV\\S. -We v^ C-WYje," <-©oA oo<a\A r\cA ^coa\ U\aa ceUA "b*-0*8"-*-^ A^en AV\£ SYcJc* Gooj-V ^««A^ Woe no dho\ce W\ *o sVvvlc cWU-ei ^<Ak- ^n«A <v\A refftiWJG^ V^Ci j00^-\i^e,cesu\AAC«.k^\^e iV*\e ^)*^\A be an e*-e/c;se A -CJcAvkf '".See i«r\o vj aa^Uaj iA ^uUw.i^ate ^oar^ <A QopAoas *X\^a^ mx,IU1 CST-MnCir W7J .

G\arVe\ ce^A AWAVbe xNnoA\ceAs A\e<5<A ce Aceu^rkn A ?^m^ UkecW^ ?aciaVlv| uacoosVWVono\ ujq^o \rNarWf\eA w\Ah V\\s cei^V VAc ceAocAxen <A \oA a^Avrrve cceJAs on^ A<*^fU;U>oA ceso\ukon oV Vtvjl i^o4s ^ecJLUOvr^ Vo AAuWne A^Wer vL*_ x<noH\ce<»U «A WqoA ceAcety" <?ocW» cA UU^ \)ifc\Ae* Vkc_ VatA A^eAA^enA \a)-oulvA |\n ef^tV v\£ VoooroLbVc , va)ou\^> ouAopaAo^ eA\V\-£ cA<*r|<e A-o c;ev^VciJL^\ftA Abu\oA g>oA-\^ ere AAi .Wit CWte JS4f2A<A \9o,-CV\e uoA- uo-eA-on Vo ko\A <K wcJU-*+-n^ ^eWn^AAon wouA^uUonL vA^V^" Vke \r\oc»V\AxV^ AkU puAak'A^A ,^t^pV\?0 . *C\\tU^\ k*VA-VkA becoju^e cWVe k^s r\o\: k^A kv& vv coa^Ic-Vvio " inVke. Auu 9W1 <\a, (pr<icu.- Av^ ceomeA ^G-^^uA^eA oc oA^voo^e &ecWe'A \nvjcAA kudcM^ ^d^-vKe vVno-WeA^ cAA-ejM reAceu y,^or\ion *A P-A^ "ts-fqcioiU UAConjkJAVfcl \s c\o\ ^A aogrui^ble In a ^\<m acMon .^c: ^ &A \H , A ucjEAoickon",-(br purposes o^ MVWcc" t lacluAes o< cuVC-nj va <\ ^\^n AoupU^w^ prouuiA*\?

VvA ceiuvVi ir\ a. cJka/\$£ VoYke ^uomKs s<enk>n<J? /incLAV\£ VKQj loss <A o^ooA-^^^- ccc&As .See ^A*a**tA^ U7 £-G\ isV?} sW\e-&e_y \j ^ccoei \XO f3A7i<6pXL C~7A^C(r 1117)0* *CV\e c©notekon fn Vhe prison AudpkWf £en&eA\ We -£<%Av\g <A $m.\AA on Vke A\yi$in<*Y v^W^rje^ a/^i-f success eA ?\^nk(C4 secVon h«i cW^n ^ec^siar'iV^ v-oo^vA iAp\y \-Keia- VJnVA^ «>t- -VkA ^"ioAin^ VKen l^cfc- ^o^ri >dAe cV<^f\A uA-ki ^^acJa VirtvG Q$> \\ect Vve^ Vke AUkftcVoo \n Anj?. o.M\kcr\V^ r^\\eA c^a by ScSKAW ivAln\\ (vA^To^uw^ -CileA on (-Jk-ir-i-^ecQ^oU <p. \Wp-)7| os\& \\^ ^(Uplvy" AoCuWu 4VCUipoAs€" -^Ve^ o/> 3-3-is-3eecO.'V}^U p. \^\-\ci3 • A\\ o-( VkG aAAM\ovik/ re\i«j G|> t>M ScJUMUr f(\ua\y^ C<^iG^ \joVi4J<z_ wx \?W<AA-s &o^Y\V o«--?>nQ^ ^cwipu u^W^ i9^3„^i^koA ~C\rA\nojoin^ VkeiV c-onoloWu ceoerjeA ;e^^j^i or o\Wa)ljfc Ae- oWeA \f\vw\i© £.eec«L.v>o\.l pl(p4. :r„ *ke ctvWoAv>e-We ?WW{vA Soa^NA ceUA *to\ «i^\A ouAwAacMki enAA\^ -Ya4^\ Ae> s?ceA\en or t'm- /v>eA\^Je reVe^se -3:A<A ClMoU $• 1<U , A\Vaou^\n +hc owv^teV* an A •SAkvAeA ce<-o<A C<*\W\ seeVGr oaA A>£ <S Aoj e <*>* eA om\-oC- AWe-Afpea\ Vo uVA\2.£ 4<*\A cecjorA •XWWvck.wijauVA fi^&rA Cct^W^V^G loAaVeA oppoAuA^W -Vo pr«vs V>^\va IAs. £-colA\j OioWVicn QncA PAtVA V^^e^TvvaY Mioic^Vion cWros on appeal. \aAu<Ja ^^ enAcv\^ GmUA -eV^WAvj tor ^aAiej- CeWase/Yke. reVve^ C<*\W\ Siee^s. in k\S. Va^vA ciAs- nA creAe c<*vWu enVU<2flAaAV4-a eM\er release, A,a^A \S -*k* ^^ o^vHs.GoiaA W\Vs Oe JoooO o^-AkeinsWV Case Vo ooAixA^-^ -vke AAxVA^n \oekoe*rt re\ie£ vkA s«etcs. A-» xU<&nWK£ ^kYv^VlVj^fcr carU^r reVeasz e^A Vl^V->^a\A xvcrea\e ^V^^^nV^Ao Corker reUase . As. n^AeA *nx,S%r\o" <-^en cWiA^ii^ c* cl^il^e WAte^ra- ceA^res e^o^eA in AeWAAv'n^ pmonons eU'3'A^ikf -for poodle ,4^ CouA e*- pWr\«A MnA Vv>e/) in sooa€ bcaaA -kn.seA aVkciu fcesda-Uon o£Ai$ &cW alle^Aions gaA \4*f\ izsuJis neuAiarA^ V^AcdAe VU £m3 cWh^oy <Yl e£\«A ooA-o™Ac<*lUf enkWe oneocn^-ore cUi'manV Vo im^A\edte orsp«e- AieT reWo.se- An^ iud» cWa-U rvNU& be pu^aeA 4fcrou$U kato-eas. Gfcrp^p i^ee^^io EX\ FAA <A UW, "One ti£4<^ CiccmvV ^^Ae (V tAw -&rA*-e U^itr CooA* \A-vheVr c^WMn<*kan cA «&*\ker res^Wkon o-C o dlou'nn uj-oy\^ cxA-on^AcaVkf eA\We a cJLau'iwe^-^ V<5 \A^m<.^\«3d? reVease •+Ke ui«^\^'' CouA e*$Wr\eA Vk«V Co^aVs rwj,sV co<ts{Aa^ vk<> A\A\nc*on keko^M <lWwu WA—>«uvA AA^ebj enka/i(-£ eA^ikV\y-Cor earlier r-etepse aA -Wosg MaA to cm\A crec^ enV^VWnfcA A-o corker reW>se ._r-^ <u \[\q S<AAUA c«Wu2_ or\ "O^rtc^ u AA;^AoUg -ProAA A^-iasUV cqie be^^use, '^Cj^rte** »-oats so inV*rW>vAeA ^ov-Ma^e ^e^otpA 4oc cesXo — C<x*i\*n A loA ^o^A-V«ve creivV^S QaAaIa«=iV ces0\n\ion o^^Wisiu^es {\e.ces»vxrv-^ Vo AeW/^;ae «-oVe\Vx«j^ -Vke xAo -W.eeAs. o^ Ve$c«\ reAceA' poAxon cA 0-wAjl 3 M\c\^a.^ A-Vn«_ f\cA A*y^aA^<A <ojo^\^ \n e^^cA A -t»4-or*VJ^ , a^WAsccAkj eAMe UGWAV( -Vo c^niWfcunA A ^oAA^G cceAAs^ee cWUe, ^4 ^3A A 19a A ce^AcA^eA o£ GlarViks cyDcAAAe cre^vV^ ^>o^a\A sAoA^n cWli'i i^Wice CaaA^^mvA vCce«Scjc en*AW A, VyU eaAver oe\ec*se rfkus. A\AA^uW/ij CW^G -Croy^Mr-e. ^rxsX^Vccxse. ^bc ouAko^W AirecAV^A qo\Yx-V \4NAke«4or\^ xj $Av*aO /r AuUa inAxAo^Aokv^ -Cccwva \V\fl- AAoxA Cme c-onWoeA •VVxc coAroo^^ VkA A rw-ore, AViAv-o^eA ^x^A^e aiAAniAr^Vxon tA-><ke Ao^. A^peW^G CoiaAs.. See S47 f AA. \X%1} \zsc\ tSAinCi'r l<Ol). fc.N&VxV or> poxA oovA<a vAAWuv^/' is. Vkjt CocA^A CqlW, Aces noV. ocs^-fer oaaj ceUA -Cccyw kU s^Unt-*. A^U\\nc-koo norAoes C^Aon ase_ Vke.-WA GoaA Ao ocA^Wno ceWeA 4A<v, coAnen<A oC moli^ ,Uoa^ QSfeA,-^G03nAAioas t>^ con^A^en\.4rAA lX$-<? .'"^s^ °A^ posAU. e^vec^Ak\i Ackon ^AW on d\Wu c^nkcx^A ^\\l beAWA tA Wcan oAain 4i^ VwviscrfpVs Vx> o^eo\ a^A AV«. ce^WA ©vA-cAArv^ -<M»^t cwA Aa>u\A ^U cx^oi be ^uc- ce<^( , C<t.lWy ^>o^vA ^^^coa^OmA onAV-e ^Wks sen.Wic4< Ao^eocr G^\\-on ^ouV*> noV e^ca()£ co^^m\ ^o k( orW o^ T?\A GouA \WmV AsWA as n result o4 a Aecuion okWA^A -f to^ *Ve Se^onA oAncV (A x^as G^Ao? Ap|*«l^:rAa\ <3S~?, A± Vke G-ouA k«\A A ^ucU c< uVclvaA^C? <x cWm \^ ^m^yx uaA^jAWU,.

AnA CalWs'.S.HS^A-VarAns^^c r^kV^uiiy £UA (sen^A oaA A omI A b-e ccsoWA e>n W>e aa^/A^ »:5rA <^V OS*?. .ScA-i a$An$V c^tivj^rn/vxea-Vql <^lo/eo*S SuUa as icJhU\*r cxrc aA poAiv>A<Au wAcom/Aon Avke R^VIa, CvccuA cwA k^ue bee/x con- SvAereA c^U ftjiQVxks acVons* i^n ^oqio^us case A^ AW wk>*AKe v£ QmA\s> O sWi^O SIS ^X^ Z\% C^A^a CxV i^7^).^Ta QvAalU , c, ^Vofcp pri- Son^ri , ore9^Ao("Y ko -klir^g ci ovoVsda ^rCo\WWA reUe^ ,re^o^sWAof VKeCoiArV GV^vc AVe. Co^A oC .se^^A^ ki^n <-opi«s o^ cccorA^ A OAoAkar- £i<*W Vc^osAV onAo^AW^conA^WA^r mo,ml OaAVTU.TW (U^us^ ^ons ao\ acV^no^VeAseA.x^t prx»rt«r a Vie $eAaIAAml records ki ^o^aV\\ ^ece reo.Aou-lu m^Ae ^oaiUkJ^. Vo o\ken *\\G^^eAVor tv\ooe\ar^ ceUeV olaA ce^uvre^ Gn oAer AxrecVag Ake cW\l Vo oro^AG VV\e xovk^/vxcAxon ve^u^^VeA. ""Oml Ov-sVucV G*>ujA A\s*<w\\seA A4-e co^V^nA osvnAV*- n<Aure gV kab&as Gocpvxs0:xh revjerj^ ,AKe r^-Kn GWAyA\ -fW. saAcvcV GfcvA-esreA A As anal^su cA a^e\\As co^pWnV^GG ?cexsir HVV^.S.M7S ,9iS.cV a\ Jf^toWcfc proves AkA a 3ka$=^ Cn<vv&G aao^ aA uV\\ue YkeGioU l^VxVs AcVW ekail^nje k\sco^Asonj^kus k>^ passing Aabeas Gotdms pcx>aLAures oaA -Vke, ce^vMV«AAeA\.s tAe^- VxajuA\tvx or s\ccM revxeAxes^-vVve V=\vAk» GircvA voAonV^ A^.^ ^•,s c^e ,afpe\\oA \soA cA^V^ing kh G^noxtV^n oaA beAs nAse£- Waq^ ceAecxse^corvn coA*A^ »vAe as cWrVA^MAAA kekosWen WA ^cce^\o cecocXs.wk\dAore An^Ae o^'Ub^i Vo cAiA^ri cW W been ^^ecAeA Vo AxwxWnAoc^ VeA"xeA^>er€ ke Vo pr«o<*l inAb^ acVon -><We Go^A^ 09'Axon oo^AA nA i^^je \n oa^ a^a^t on vke uok'AiVj A U\s cci~Mn«v CoAOxAon , oaA A^e/eW VA>*a* corpus u nA ^A ofpro- pciAe r^Af qao vu> sAnA <-*-A* rek^ce on 9ceU*r U^pUM.se^ G>^U$» S2S t*A qV3\=?, "\>»e VAA<n Circu'A c^r&uVAUi Wcss AV^V A **a. £c^orakVx AAerAAAxon u]ou\^. r\o\ auWkcc<^ enVI\e AKe ^\Sqaqt Vo acciAe- cAeA reVease- Xr&- prc^p^r vjeWAfl- "is t\ £ l<n5>.S^A\Sec GrelWnvj rG^le G?S C3A a 1,31 v.SA^CirW1sJ ', CW\scn siTtsWon U2-F3A Wj^l Utfo C\V 1117) (A^ AAiajt Corson k^s^Ue^e^ VkAsucJU cec,^Avl6A\ £coa~, aAo^<vAsAw€ sejro^nAon <_oouxA Ax^vekiV> ek^i\^e Vor p&raW , ke k<HS rAMle^eA "ktoV SvacJU GeaiSsU/»AeA co^mAA co^V^vAxt^llw s»korAnku ^enViA02- or \«^A Vo InnnrxeAxafc-Q r-eVease-~OrsxLpo^^eAeQS'ion vjOoM\^\\k becovMn\n V^e A\screkon tAAse^orsle ^oo^AJ- Xo^e ioAoaV cqs^^k^-Mier CMWx vO\\V V>-e ^caAAeA cxas^ cgUA onku seAiAC? or cc.Ao\c-kon vm\| b-G \n Vke A'aaeAncn cA Vke AppellaJbf ColatV »^ec^use C^\\oAiucuss AfP^^ 0(j&v)a^ Cc\e-t" ^dLStA^ t-r

va^s. Vcxaos-hV on \n\s \4-fln A^^A^A cWmi c^atftA ^ckMer -***VA */\*ce\^ enAoAC£ ek^kVi Vor *CcA*/AeA ceVense oaAaVws MW>eon. ir\\\recV eAee\ on Mne ^eVmiaoVutt oV ^oWAker CaVVxcan o\A<wn qa^ reke^ tr^AA cv\ A$(*AV«*ji CoiaA* -WnA oaou AoAen k\A> senWxcG oc oO^Wn W<* <-<>AovA\on . Ace co^r.v^abL^ uaW iWW.^eCwH. vj TO^ TcaAS. 9\ga.^. 37 F3A IW*,U* CsMnOrVWjC^ec^a^ a Suc cess Vm\ ,wA^>*>uxA nnerekj eAxoAce Av'3'\V^ 4or ocmWAeA release oaA AkusvAn.s 'xnAxrecV e^feJcs, on A\sjl AAer^AA^n e>V ^Wa^qtc\ cWmaA toAAal^ recuse (*fcro\e/'n^e ?s^ Circ^A ke\<^ AWA VkiL ^xAxavxW k«Akc^(}V\\ o S\W C_WiAj A^ ^A\G a\ooxML rvxjulAlQ^G "ftf^xC^cA opinions VoAain.

AsvjoeAca HW«c\Cu anAVVe gelo^ cy^wc/U ^^r^n^A \1a\tA Aevi^^°' ^vjinMn oaA OX.GiroA FcAqa*( Ap<*U«fc| Go^As, m^ diiem CalWs conWkoo MnAk^ \M-v1a Ay^AAN^VcX^Miaret-o5niia^.uAA«rSl9\S U AAeAiWious ,^eJL.Aec\A W4K.GV &VX111 G:rCAk*A^A vvuMll no\ Ae - nn^oOSVtr^fc^ VhCAoA'A'kj ok <VV| OA^VOA^IA^ C\AfrAlol^uA$AA<<A\ o^aCcxA *ke ?Wi\fc« ,-*kG aAon Axou\A W o|Uu)eA "k> pcauMJ} Ceoc^eo\cJ0 vj sVcovUSS *~77X PAA (07^1 10V? cskdr mdffnWicJCAiAc*. pr\son<*rk success inAxe. VAjAoo rox'^A tncreo.se M^dU^ce-for ^^^ re lease Aoes. nA \c\ AsAt ( VccxaAoCai AWL ockVi \nki V^abeqscorpus \*jUjm- \o<r\\l Vxrx^ ^25" £iA X3l/^qX(7^ Cvrl^HJCCoarVnAo^'H^VZ^AbfiA n^t>k(ir AirecAly cJasil^oeA Vb« (o-c^ oQ-ktA oookA4^>6A^ norsou^lAV <* AeM/^AAxvvi -^Abe \$> e^W^A Vo (m^eAlcLfce or ^peeA'ier rescue) ."five C_jc>urVv^eA canks oAe AbAAo cxt^ujlavA prao£st;>ns 0%-vkekraas^iiH nnAckV \na\j-G resul-Ve^ \n n succe&Au( cx^peal <A £u^.k&A nA(A/Aeraanoic- V\on 1^ na~Ar'iq| OaA possible Ci^W <AA -Vke/Gb^ wwU tooe vnAi- reC\^ cA^AeA YbekA ©V kU CoAn<L^eA./tc Vo specA^ in <=< (k\s- CjCn^ctn taskton AbA pcoAAes Vo V«aom4 ca bnsU AocAke AeWrwikAon A^Ma^ an acVxon pr<^JiA^ cJkc<r^cA^»AeA cx% oa excciuslviG k^b^^^ Got^mS acVon .^cA «\ Dm.AVs^i^eff- c^VckcAle xj Prot^AAJir 497QA <^(<m-\4(AAvA Gvr l<n4jC^ ?cei*r fcs9W.*v\ rA^.nA ap- - oUcakU A^^etiA ok fcuon ^scJ^noA, ^«c*W* on vJ AurcAon oV ^WcxVtts s^WfiAi NAeW^AS-,^ecA,\Av>G oaAmU- AeAA W r,oMei S\OxTX* ^3 c^Ctr |<n^ r^ ^^^ SecreW^ AAbe n«voM ^WA 1u>4 ,3^ -^e^G l<Kv^(>Ai,y Vk^V pcex^ (^U \S ofp\xeA \esi AoxcV^ in c^ei AWA Ac noV f.ooU ^ v)AxAi\v| or Vke ccWaA AA^^en^y Ako .sejLGvAun m9^\a <DG>vA i^iVo^^^dnrK^tx^tt^S^ VdWVlcA ^bAk 0>m*e \nWnjs tAsW^ CouA Gou\A W pcArsu^A ^^^19*3 bee^cue. Vk*. pWAx(-f A\Anfc\ 3eeNG reVcase^ As, ncAeA \n "E^^1 /3<^cc< ,VU> A^re^e G*uA moAe cW AkA ^cA(fxarA^ ,a prober-for ?r<*p*c^^ v^uacVv* ceUA^Ul aoAacuv- .Sarxkf xoAfjkj^ MoLmv/AikiVj oV preAjiox^ loss cA ^oAAAjl creaks G/xA So cacxa| pco^JLrl^ beVro^A vaaW ^\W,;x^xAA^uA«bx4 4A<v> A'hG PWaVK x\n uEA^wAs" VkfiL \A»aaAWg ceYAAAWi Sz&te VkA rV)CuykQi>G on ArAxTecV xVi^A" °o Vke x'AAvkf A V\^eono\cVxon -3eG_°<"eA \ an u>S\?3AaAA* OnWU eW<%nS in k<S> ^WS^A t^fkinW <^e- Axon VKe u^uoo^kkAkAo.l A^\\<eM px-wjuWe Allied Aun'n^Ws PirsV AfpeA Ai A /v^\V*roA QU^k\ conA-H^ e*c£SS\x>e Ad«xy q/,A ^absWi- VaA ceWAAA oAWn^ qJJtorAeA q on^Wi^I o^eaL See C£vj0\A ^-vAn" aV vX *S3> -^sCp qaA " Tft\M A p. SxT>-SSl\ *AA^Ake ceUef cA4<y, SeeKs *-u\l\ A no u3c^ iA^p\^ -tfrve. \VMU&ikf A AW^uA^-eA i.e^e/vWue o r GOAOxcVion on CqAk>n\ cAWp^A (x^A<^ Cc*e ConoicWi. ^ee J3T<i -kV oA p. X^-P,U1 cuaA^-Oa^cvV p. S33-S3^. ikroxAjkoA VKe \ejal ^oufne^ £po*a ^o^en" Vo ueAaOa/v^" AWionore^e' G©*/A VxqA tocuie^ on. AW nJt£^ Va e^ore,-*^^ s\*Jt* prb<ym v^secnV^ \rwb*«i& Corpus (oriv^iWjVdb^CC^eAieJ AM A4voy^eelc VoinxJ - (iXAe e\^ MrecM^ Vbcoujk an .^m/kW) c-o-ptU^ s«*« Wr*Ve*Vor o XnAxrCcVl'-j AWo^j\n ck ^uAviA AeVuWaA>oA AxnA oecus<AUf idrives Vke wvWa-tA r\*vS o^AW ^.VAfti cuis\oA^» xVjas , 9reVver VouA cv) tvcn.p\v«A -ey.- eepkon V*> |\<m'5 c^^^aje ^>Ve^ VkecAouno seeyu noVA«rc\V\Uj}lu ^V^WiVo7' "cooe." Vx^beos ^ek'c-Q j I.e. ^>k«j-e a.sW*_$.pcvSoA<*r re^u^Vs pres^A-or 4UVkAre cAea.sc. s<sl oo\x¥_;An>n vj oA^on usi.cV Q4.3. iasM CX.OOSJ, ~\>£ ^fe^ Co^A xA <^oo\Cr xj fXAC Ooaa«V\ i\\% UuS. S3^ tV17*0 A^aYes ciiiPsr AkA I \W!> reviaias c^<*\AdU.Vqc ^ca^A^ai d\aiU*$w xAoere s,vaculss \r\Ake q,cV\^a cot>u\A rxtA ^ecjLssojA^ j^\\ vWie^cXe o\- so-^^vQ-T reUase toe W* pcvAon*r AAVcVG^apm ^peutesVkA a pri*- <N«T GannoVuve ^ mi Vo ck>Wn Ao^a^ ^Wiwcau -oo^vA neOAW\kf im^^^^kWu o?q r^V prcvafouil^ ^vwIAqUA c^ono^cVon oc seA«Ace. AaA "EAwOarA'A^rci , uvLe. ^uoMff'.^rq / A^ewoAsAfc^^ AVA WAoeqi *e»\eAve4 do aA i»^i im qcAUas xAx^GSMcctss invkeG^\\ £A$kVs s^iV v^c^A aA n*ce^xankf vj\W* VkG WyAAnj o^ nA preo'^vu^ \koo\;kUi &AqU t^^eA AK*.s-e c^se^ V^V-^aqaA ce^A W«^e\k^/ inAit*** 4AA asYdGp prbo^A JWW Qckon U WceA a\os«A o, ^Ur \nx^kUkon - no aa^A^ ^e^eUA S,ou^AV (A<vvxa^es oreAU^ ceUeV) no aa^aW A^-W^eA; <A-Vke pCxSO(x$/\S SvAr CAo^Ji <-oaAmcA \«A\n£ V^c-OAoickon o.rir&frcA pcu^n ^CCCMAin^ J- t SvacUSS in AVA oCVqa ^oouvA neOLSsorik Ae^o^iVca^ Vke in- \jAVxW] A coAA&AeA or As A^nkoo Aeexx>atiAiQo ucs^Wi-ui/^.

A^«-firv£ Akl«- £cCnd$€S Vo Akn vnskA caie,+k\s Go^A xkou\ci re*- MOnaUy cvoodxAAe fn \Vs ^ O^xyo reoie^i AA«=tV U\Uni l^m A^MAmeA daivis are Go^xiavole xjia^lt^ WV3 Q«nAAUA A^ Ao aA tnll ^iiAkin-tk* j/v,pfctU Wakens tKcapkon • GqAWxA&ev. ^oV seicV- re\tef UvAvjoxW renA&r inv/ol'A -AVG SV<*^ praU^^Ares vAseA xrAxrecV A^qI procuAxAjsop AetAtA^oA r^cS: KpO-eA pr^caaA<n^ or AxreA' o^Afeo\ pcocft^AvV^j rexiveoOpr^^ uWe^ri <^V \x*A1 O^Vinx Goo^^opr^ ,q\ ss^ssr). AjorWs Cc,vVonsw«€^ an vn^oAcVi^n o^A<^ik^ nU \A"^Ai<£^ orxp^e^er re\eqxj^

A^pAWVs Cxv^AXtx^ dcxA pa^Gl^oV SO "\nVo AAn-e Co^^xavaa^-re A a\ t^* CcxVin^ Vx-e^or mi u.s. a^ soo-j WXoXQt ,s.v>^srn oiVSS4 J.Aniy av\o c^o\A (^ca. i^ ^<>rA>kl O^j- yxAenV w-ou\^ noV ^AeUSS^iAw \«*\p\*y AkG VYoAvV\V( A GAWjS CW xj\gV\^tx or sen,WxUL.^c AA 04* CcvVin^ \kLc\c,s^f<i^V^7)AMcas^ VAcGAkn in V»u cWaas uaW ATO cWei. noV r^an \r^m^^\<J^ rt-* Vecse -Cc^ta oonk^e^&vV ora AcA<lt sV^ A prxson^V be^i <-e- OeaVnaVkaV <A <*-os>V C<*A>n ^A\ &Aa\Uf te, pcouxUA HJt pre- Vri AceuxcA^ V>e WV^ cetv***A qVA^ Vinrve A t^Woo an A AnG WWW App*A Ao Aikze ^aA ee^i^ Vo e^isd ko-Hn «* *^ vj.oUUo <vA ^AVoA^A^nAotolA^a-^on app,A. A,A vo V^g x-e^olukonoV^xA^ ^ ATpeA 4^ Amelia* C^V xA As Ucre\w> ^ofM^ nA cwvw AW ^..An^ C^uA*^$^-*-^*A^ ta4*.0>»A A^A^caiifor DAW A^^ -^n i^^VAl cel««e^^^or^ cAoxVr Aoh ^ ^kon, A o^vu aV oaoA r>e^ eU^k, cw>«-0 , ^O^Oa A r^oA -AW sp*eA c^nixA^akonS cA qne^ parole aipkcA00o Ssjicct^ tor ^roVxAion a^oas A n/M&V ^ f\fl^ parol-ek*"v\j> AAx'cln okxo ?aAe co-vAxovAes cv^/m A<*A A^trAxon ,AecW Vo xWWn Ax^ qx-x^oa W*a.) <2>e^cu5,e G<t\k>ns cWrvnS QaA <re\iA ce^vA^WAu>cMA noVrvjjuSscxr^ s^W. i^eU^r ceW*, Us gW^ Ao nA li'«A^e Cor^ W*W*s.zrA °A o4* CeAiAa fctxsrVir c\\\a.S.c;\ W\<t) As Ake fwAk^<2 S^^pr^e CowA <A AgumU>A A<cm c^nW ScVvUeA ConWV^ UAA^A <on*A ^A C^U cWnnS OAG nA c^anaaUle w,WiW3.AA^U ^A colaaoV rectsonp^^^Jo^ OeWooo r^U AkA Aa AfpWokji ecoaAure A yAo^UlWvi^- Vence oc mAeeA an as?«A ok \4v* senWx -H^V C*vW S19W clcAnS, eox\V :t iucusAA/^A\ \<\v*A\^Ae-A«J(ke S^ce^e GouA Ac* ^rwUwdy tounA ^ ^cK cxa ^v^i^oA ^nps/\s«-»ns\v>G VO cvxqnqlo^oux, CjoA^NLt , ^ iUL ^xAVAAs<xn \XS SGV ciV v:i4% ^To G)aA\,u v\ec\c"^^^u^« APxJ«^W\\ OpeAx'rx^ ^^eV paj^\9^C ST> V\ve_ vo-or^, " ^eAwfc" Ao ceW- f\A Vx> pr\son procedure* tWAVo sAoAoAx\rG ^W*«A<%Wvs OS-\o A\e V^ajMa o^ coA'ne^eAV-^TAciV 1X4^ LAkno^ ^Ax^^A \> G\ose s^o ui 7^ ,~7S*| o.l t xoo4) CTKe incaruro^on ^A rAaAW^ oaA.*t Ntect A \k«- xncorcarAlon oAwA ksAkG oc\$inA ^Mo^^e-A oV c-onvnckvvA A crUinq\ ,yaA$Ax-*AV o^en*r<illij VncWAe^ W>An V^ convrtcAnoo onb ^enW>U -See e.£. FeA-i.

Conn. 9, 3XCVAC0 C^ crxVMna\ j>uA,J<nen\ <^asV sA tocM^ Vke tfe^-Vk ^jiAr-f vj^aA\vj\ 00 ^Vbe GoiaA^ VxaAvajs i-nXfi_ aAiuA\cAsonyO/»Arke $.<zriML8,'l) -Tea^iA-C x^ane M^ u.S%-rw, 3n|rv3k (HtttJCAi. ^ W o^uUMA/q Co*An<A a/^Aj^caV r^-CctssartUj incUAAitS A^SSaW^ xAvposeA ^onA^Ae- £AA«At).iV^e ^c^.c.Cri«vx.>p^o Aekr*es M^A$/«0All 1i« 9°^ /O^AVe U>rAW\ AecWnVon <A Vke CouA AgneA kw^W*!^^ oaA <A*/eA \r\ a cetoc^U^ QeonwiASon or^^A\A oi-Vke keUoAoA-S-t*- ArA. 42.01 U^ *rW U^V <A CrW aov AflwaU kaS consVnMo Vke U/Acfcrx- uicVW V> <vve^n- ^n>iA$~A tA aAAV^ oaA ^tflU«^^ <A puA\sk- aa^aV. *ee £*wVe ^vjcvis 9qAu^ 0^ 3,uMv*-47 cr^cn,-, A?p \^^ o^cxtAAq^ vAkeV\<v2A oor\^u/K>/vvAvon oV-Vke pctii.eCMV\Vx ''/ " VktjuAy/M-eA or 4<£aXAa<-£ VbA Ai-e. ^ccjase^ xi ^u»Vkf ^ScJkargeA '' <dcm j^ij^A o-C-^uil^y {a *Ve <*sxtsS/v\eA\ iA o^vAyn-eAV •-=c A- oA ^u> -47 , HAAke A<WA c-ss-e c^vWs cWtle^e oV v^tA^ASkV<kV\c*tf L A 'TKe A^AIAl? QfoaAure uYilized Au*?n^ kA AxrecV op^pa( onA4i<^uk- A°^V\a\ r A^AcAxon, o-Q 3 A\e<vxVfW-(ul o-^p^A.-^^ \A (\010cw <* civtileAfe Vo VxA cjor\\^r\^c\ , &excuse G^xWx, Ws rxoV c^ll »A\c> ^^esVA -ybe.v**- V\A*k<f A A>c pjo^ec-iVon 00 Ake^u^rveA A cyAV.cCjtr AA vVlxo-tn.

G^vWx's c-on\eA^n U Moa\ kis cJU;*^ waA^t $\9tl are A-orecpK^Ae A«p\Ak j^Ke <^W^AA vA ^3o\tt v McDonnell,sopr^ j:^ ,'c\ec|C"JjinpMt^CouA e^reA^ A'Ao^msUA ^o^vA l/x<^n^^A 10*« cK^il«AfeA vu erc^iwr€ \o^ AxvOn vke \noA^ coas A-e^e^ ^oA k^^G Cre Avk »° u;o^" iAAATn- ^vi&kablc tcooA VKe xp.S\qa\ co<S<. , V0ooWA q cAAoa, ok-He c^niUUiVi^L A^G pcc,aAxArGv ^oV &>r r-eack^ Vke ^^ re^lV i.e. Ake ^eai'qb^ A^WoaW O^k^ fccxA pqj^ ioA SO QypciVVvrtxe^eV^s. See \Veoe. uq.s..c\ <*\^tS7o. JOoc \^ Ab<*re oa^ '^AxcaWi \0 ooo\rr/ocoAH reason Vo WVxe^>e j4^tAAke unconAkAanaVik/cAVVe oT6- ccAures uA^kA Vks ^saIM A $ocAkA-ecreACA /AvusWc cWoas avU^eA'm v(jOo\AU VnAAA^MSV\«l^ Vco^n Cc.\Vn's ol^oAS iorwVc^l irAo <[v^sk'onA^ Vo^kt\Ajess Akvs conVoujA^ oonkAe^xenV o^\ h> Atvus. b aA toATrp^ b^'fUcid' XAa\ £$70* V«/4Mr AV-eM lUclC1 Got^V ,e*AAUy ^V^A AWc «-Oo\A cWaaS A\A csoV xxcoA^nko ^vAJtsVon YkeWAAxess oC -*k*. ?WnkAl oonko^k^avA- Vin^^vanV^ oaA veco$n"n-eA cW*ltay£* ^ Mv£ od^VAAvxpUkj o-£ \G*_ frcceAur£S, C-nAvir AVx^n reacKinjj Ake uorono cesuA o^eoofni-Lablt,-nr^^\ XJ70/L(ke- i^ise ^ vjcIa cWaa£ A-© aA re'A^ exWmskan. Sjul ox&V o i «Ae^ SXIFJA VXtvp, IXC's, CVflnGSr \<iVd CAx^cV CjoqA skoul^k-/ $ WS3ockA QW- Avn^ eA**MsAon °^~ Aab^^s Corpus c-<WveA\<?s tf£ £aooc^^oi. reiM A>-^oulJ esVAAsk XN qa \ueVAAM cA^hVa for e^k or ion(yxj?Ai <xks reteau ^n^*/^ VvAse^S'l) • v,Aec^_'1 ^ues. AW ^-oocA ^enWi'-e^ VAVtrdhaA^e^U wv&i^udk oWxer W^ns. <xs vv coAa^aj CoAkne^xaAb ,y QnA vk^prbooA>A". i-ae liecK £>a^AH^r,let a\$o ^A^«rAA',SL»pfe, oA S20Ui.«*V oqr,^ Oe- -^eccxcxo Vo \AoctV\^vV^ oV Vkje y-*A$ «^ ^aV^ or Hp^Mxb/n«A\i*vvpoieA^J0So VAAA^^koo^ Vl\V€CVL.//r\i OOAS\i\eA ^vMAoMoa^ COii^i pOTrrviVVr^ po'lSon^ Vo W<A$ "i V^%3 exalte* $fcs A> <Av>on cA^rvAcAu-e <^ec<v,i&A^-^eje-ej(jc>oVCf HI^XJ^ c<V SS^-S"S" > AOmWwvxiA SMOU.S> aV "7r4 ', i^ji aKo JST Aq\ 1% 4(ce — ^ecVxo^ xv \Ve A^\sV«V.en oie^o VbA \WcVl &pp\ies CAW$oric«illvyVo o|| WAa ^^vAeeA Ae S^pra^jG Gjo\atV\a«^s ce^eokA^ pv/"AW pcbooA {o \0rxf\3 \ \^%-S ctcVxoni cJk«l\eAj\rx^ Vko e<nAxViV\S oVV^eir confergmgA- c^aA'xWas vxaA,^^^^^ rAA 0f\Vke"v_oxx^A»n"o-9iAA ^jlA becan- AxAire^ po^AA Vk^^^AWce^cee^oiUc^Ason IXs-j.cV aV VJM9 C^Aa^ C^.o<sy o *?<&-$. ^n^vAs.S^^ Cx^^J^ujil^c^AJn^ vjS^o-eAsan Hoaa-S.^Lj^acI G^7tj, A>^> Ax\A inWp^Wkon ok'\H" is const^A ^xAl^^A-o^^s'^^^ Wut o>oyV ke\A Ave pruonftA's iAV iWclc- b^e^ nA bec^uie i'V s^A n^A^kcaVon okAVe A\sop\vr\^ proce^w^s k*AC4.AW nuVU^c*kin, oCa4^G Vkfi AisuA^^^ ocfauAiA/e\S vjj^vax^ \eA neccsia^tl^ Vo x^esborA^n &Q X?^\W\s O^Wac Gc\4()a5ealo^ 50 \ aooA-VuAe crcAAi cu^AkeA'ue ^oux^ ikcAeA vKepcxionenj .s-eAWice.-£-«<_vjoilUjfl.

Son XaS"S.C\ otV 1X4S CcAinj ^wa^i saouS.aA U4^*XXAl-e iAS\aA.\case r^u.V\xkco^on ot GAWU CvnconsVkikoAol Appella*^ PcooAure ke\A in door' -VWA Aili^eA a/> in^^e^c^ c^A tasuW^ueA cecaPcLoovU aA A\sW\o GAkms co^oick^n or iWWi c«LVon'wenW)cG* A>oc^>it| c<*Aon.\o-G enk-^fiA Vc» \^eeA\er ce\easc -fconn cju^VsiA^ .>AxA*r okWA^ ^ve i\n* ^unoW€ reVvG-V ce^^Ak^ \e. AAe c-eWiaA fr-eWl ceoorA^a/tc <xr\ oA~<A -Ti^-A?p^<tl Vo uk\tJ.e sAk cecorA-Aa^ Vkoreforf a^irtve Aoou-G oaxAv-oo\V^ c^Ar-A^ ^jl VA CouA erne A A>Qn ik A\snau.j£<ACqk V^a-s ^W^lcAo^An d^oinsVscJUiiler, ^ee cGvjo\Ap. M^O.

"TkeTcX;aV GdlvtV ex;ceA in ^coaV'a^ S\e^e SduVU/^ aaAxoaTG* £Ks/vmss AppelioAAs* A^VcCovM/w)n Z^o cAckVxa-s SVoaAoaA QJ (loex3iiexA> ^a) V^as \A-Alne VoAoA <^ne ,an ifx,rwAe U^sAV \3 A^A^^-eA as A^mdWs -tor kq^i'ag no basA iv\ Woo ovAncV buV no -foA KeoWnj is Ae\A , VCd CouxVs reoico -Cocuss^s on ucUeVUer Akc i/vn«dtA («uu>.*Akctf an a^^uQ^e fcx»si* "m U^.^ Cc^V -to* S003A cAx^TKe i^u* o^ A*- AW cicWnn Uqs on arjuaUji beA, i (f) U«oua teja\ tu«Aon A^A vk re-

relief oa± onuses oC « ^ se.VoM.-V +ko^!v, i_ j * • P rae reU.v.^s^V -, ^^„ A Aa ^""^ ^°~ Af^clWVi o^«a^5 &vAeV 9^jG21o^so "2^-(e7. V\Aa\\^4k\S, Lovj\ \'c \o ko^V OiWvS pWAln^. Vo WsS &V«>AjeA sV<vxAgjAs> AVnqa Vofrv>aV pWcAxn^s AcAWk W{ W*o^a/S r\ee vWoes ^/o4 a£ *V 4Xo / cvxA a cAairv> j;kouVk a<A be A^a-AssA v-inUu it offeA/A ke^onA Aouk\ -HvAo. ?WnV\xt can pcou-e a^ .seV oQ fecks va 4v*flxA ox^Vxs AouVs, uJUvOovoowA e^VekivV© c«\<A. SeeCoA.\e^ i^u.s. AMS^k

"Xn k\^ iwoVvoaTo Oxwass ScJkAVer CenVnAs. aVxAt ^oxoernrtAenV <x\ enkkes oaA W\cXr e/^p\o^<?es ckcVnj VnAk^r oAtcA copaAki a^e lm- nnune troAn-SuAs Vor W*^s,Mfileu ArWeU <ja e^l^A ^ivHr AWA- **,Wkf . AnA VkA AV^ cnl^ «**v>*r A in^«*0U,-Gor « oejl(j^»<J c^e A ccVxoo v's. AVGT^as,TbAG\a;<A AtV AoA A^aA U i^^kae^V^ PWA« Cause oV ackon AxAkxn VLe -cfe*.Tor\ cWnrv* ACV vVx<ue n^V bt-<v»a(- \aAoo oV V*4\k< foyv^ wx:WeA-vkcouStA Please oQ- « o-oVor -Ac^en ^ekxcile or Akroash k^G e^AAon oruseoV r«ri or parso/wl pcopeAv/- r^Q Te^Ciu. ProcanA ke*x.^Ae %ioUOXU ScMtUr ^>eA anko <^>a~ / ^ VWA C^iAoO k^A AA^e no ^lle3Ax^o AMaM:Ws o^-WmIo Vke l,WkA ^. ^ 0q jfVe TeiCv-x>A GWVxS ACV- AaA as a cevu\ A^«/eo£ AlN*re uias a, oV oaw ar $u AJl* \oa\s Wui xA \avJ or tacV ko xos^esV oa^ moi^tr o xr SdMlWs oV-kual \Vi^Aikf VocAKi^Va^ Ca~^> CkiWus pltaA^A by C^.|ko0 See CxVVJoU p. 1U?^aA\70.

V\ow>eoer, CAlUns eonUAvi vs. Ak«V <uiiiil*r ^>«s *x>xA <V kfs Axii - AuA Ccxpco,kf u^aA^ SW^f Co^o-on LpcoO.Tke^?V-oOe Cq-lVon iu^^ Vo re- Coo $J~* Aa^^C^S. ((on S<J^ll(^T / OaA a>oV"T*xrr<>A GouA-ty/ ^^ kiA ^-o^a^ca U**0 £\c^£ L~*o cW\W ctv, pi«A i^AV\§vMsAiokKoW »a M-C E\jk+k anA A/tA-tfn, A**a^«A GorxToUnVs.S^e C^.vjol.l "W aA p. ask-^r oa<^ "^"qV p.sa|- S3 0 „Ap\*'AkC( nrxa^ s^ o, ^vj<rn/vnAA e^pl^e \nkis ov^aql coptA^ \a oa vaA'wi^uJ copncA^ or (a k^Ak copaeA<?s ..see A/ueces G^^W o vr^suson q7 s^U Xor ,x\3 G^e^.Afp. Corpus cW.sV ^oo2r Ao pA>l^S o,^ ^voernoA^A e^U,ees -in aWp O^uol cc^Ae. orf ««*? a.A Go^akes^^A^x(i<.^nr4^ u^W*A „A «^A 4^ A^e\UVi O^ e^er oG^alASo 0£-Q\exAA one-sAx^ an^>\ker ^o^ (A ^WA'u\g an acV\on qjaiasVAke enAxV-j °^ wWkVj A^e Atuax a^eA \3 e^^o^eA, ^eeTexQS, A. cxaA CA On\s), v» ¥L.oie$lu X33S^3A%3S, %H4 GTW*ooT). T0 a &u\V c\o.cxxa^\ a^ ossein YnkxS <A&uA GopcxovVj jAke reaA poAn A \f\- \vueA vs Vke e^pUA^S Q^om^enVA eA\Vj ~x:A qy^h4-AsAv\: cftonin^i- Qi ^os$oc\ \n V\A \n&\AxWa\ co-pa4c\V| / k.ouiexjAr ,see^S -Vo \Anoose p^rsoaot \\oku\kf on AkG \ nAxuvAuol k**Ag SxjJiA -^r p-sirsoAa\ cckons vj^Aer cdor o-? Sk^ \<x+*3t 3-eje Cer\$xUxV> <t7 5-osA <A 2\i\ •^One Ox-pocxV^ xn ^S^Ors \W xnAxsiA^cA ^ s>u,eA A&cVs Vke Ae^enses Ao V\akxV\kj AVA ^°>i ^e r<*\seA , See TkcACson u AxnA\; ^^x s\AiXAM^,50O CT^A<?p.*l<?<»so m*/, nou>A).-3A an vaAAxAmA \$> SxAeA \n k\-S cVkuA CapociVcj, Ake employee m^ rq^e oa^ cUC«/is£ VkA toou\A be <*Mm\<A^ Vokxs employer inclufciVy Ak* fceUise o^ i^xje^n ifA- mnuAiVif - SeeTe^. \W\Ls QaA ooAAlife VXepV v £*.£. 2-o-o^iry (Ual-k ,G+A |SS Sv^3A 4sU,4sr% C^r^.A^. ^Qc^^k^W^.^A^Auals l^e S*Jk\W AvoaH? £xxeA Vo kA "inAiAWl cap^V^ ,kt>oieo*r, axo? aA rel^ on^ Ae^e A coo^re^^n t^nnuAq kA aao^ CO\se Vke A?Wg ^ oxAuq\ ^MuA/Af.See fcc^xASOn 47S^3A <A 3.XS, A a^erorv^cA e^ioy*>-e U ^xk\leA Vo o{6qA \Ax<Au*tA{ AWx.s> uA ^atVoc^a^ Aucrekontv^ c^Aies.AkAare GO oo^;n^e £coa* cVkv^ oua*Wikj cvnAC3) p<^fcfA-ftA vn gooA VAi'Axo.lieeCxV^o-C La^|- C^sW vJ Ca^Wj^ ^i^^aAv.so^sJ C\rH) .^^^eW^A^^eAk^ScWl- \er ^ \A-x-uAAe K^ony AWeA;A ^kbe c kW^Aioo ^eW^i aurV ^kQ\W V -3as p^Womv^ A^crckoAcv^ dAex v^ken AKe^iepeA QcAs anAior vaocVw occurfeA \* AW prepa/^^ o£ Hve tUcc^ ^ a^ Tox CAlW &'reAA?<*ak Seeck^A v ixncVUnne^ x«s^3A 5x^33$- ecdt A^-A^Vn ^007). OUcceVonar^ acVxon-s cxre en^leAVxs proVecVan ^Ajit oxAuAAmrw^kf ikuV WAiiW^ial Qc\i^ one (vA.ieeaQKctA^AeuCko^^a^ ^uAA^-S ,Xac H^ivA)3^ M\7,Wir CTei JL-oo4JAo ctkon u AauW{Q( i-f ;V,r one AkA U AetneA o^Mo iMcU predion -Vk^\ no Ax^crekon or L^' vxAenV \^ \A Vs>c AW ack^r , jt i, aA ^^s- ^ o^^ ^orAs ,'A A^e A- tfuA Was Vo eoA,A.tV Ak-e ackon ooiYrvouV any ciwia in ^^fi'noj^^ A?pA\an\ OfAxn^g Grxct P^^G ^Mct^"^ h o.cV \s mYn\Aer\ ql\ x: A a\ *AXS . Ao«ievj«j- (A A\e oi^Mon c<?^res ^x o^soaA AeVvk«^<^Voo ,AtcA^\on ( oa& ^xa^a\«aV^ Aken^A\< acAx^n A A\ v;(j~eAoACxr-|. X^ a\ 4XS\ Stoker a$> Axe cAkidal. O^A xX^poAer o<A \k^ -3x31^-3-1^^ al 0\A'\cA Gdo^V aV Vke V*>4 A ^ujeAfon-^^ A.a\A a ce^Acxr salary tor secoxtxs. asa GouA tAepocW\ cee £>a\AasGe>ank{ \j A>kexj &7su>3A $S2XSS3 tTe-Oosx), Asa park A k\v. <AkacA oAes ke recof AeA Vke cA^aA preVxaV WaAnes as ujell <^s He Vriox on Vke AAenAs o-t Ate Cas€ ^^\odte opT«<qs vj AV\<wfa C<Akon GcouJ-S. ajd. 0^U3 \^ bejvAmk^ on 1-^-04 .aao OooCx^Axa^ oo S-^o-oH • ^A'A^ Axo fr-^w^A we. Vra/i~ scrv VeA AA^*e pc^Aj\U» ce.u>rAeA cecocV^.To keuklizeAwi per-fte- Vin^ Ate Appeal tor CoAkoA A^WpkA AA.u/A<ir UAo(cVonAercatW\A re^xusV Foe A ^ree B^orW-s CUcbcA cvaA~Ox$ c\oauicVA^ GduAs o.r&os> £ca/?Vno Vke iowvil. e(L.Vo\.\ v,^1k"A p.3.7MU-7C OaA "Trti" A 0.539-s-VO , FV pr-apa^kp Vke cecepA scWUr- vA3qj p^'A q .s en^ra^p-fte o-t o^n^Vic&gU 8 3;OOO.0Q •Ccorv\Vk5 3«A<inal -&aa^ oQ- Tarro^V Cu/ify-A*^ (Aokey ,?7j^o3<i a,A %S3.

3^-v AVxis OouaVs rexj\€^ oV Ake x?\ecAiA£.Sj vA *vxmA: otfcftrVaAi 4Ge-Wa4. nAvAre o£ Cq\kA cWoaS olaA ao\ ex^AAofnn ox/cr ^ukskvicG* ^J2<z- C,\oiu2 Vi-Qto ^H^S^l^ ST??, S^ CT^WWi)* A\3Av«^Xa C<XlW> noaVleS C\«.<M- \^A ScKA^a'-o&s. SxAeA onk< \a kxv, cAkuA capau'kf w\^u- £m3 Ao o<*rf*AoAon V^> oW^xn xo^ck^ cekev>u^A<u~ Ve^eral \au) OaA CviUn Sx>-e A-Sciox U<2mV) \n\^» \rAxoxAuA CopooV-f Vo reoDvjo^ cvio^oc^A-tA At>viaja*s £co*n ^cki\- \^, S>€e cxX.xjo\A ^vcV^VQA^^A^-tW1 a\ p.^o. .^cres^cVA vkJL DWkA V~A.<Wl Gourse otA\*. p^ulAx^" VfOxcaU^ ^V\l inWAe AW, a^VcuG o-V o^ Ajt kAAxkf ^ou.^ Ao b^ xfA^oscA . ^-e-e ero^a^o ^ ^WvA ^^^u.s., MU^ U^^^^/T^creU <2< ce^ £x;V^? ovVTeccexV vj S\s>a \xvs^»s^ xh\( zr\«„s GTc^A^p. Te^^KoAq. 2.003) . 3T^ \> t>Ak Ake ^VMa Oa^ AyfAAiA A^^ci Go-^^VwA^ A\0\ i>re (aAvsV<\^uUW^oIc as> V<xp avi We alU^qko^s qI- \e^eA xn ^^ppoA oV -Vte. AcAj^ -L<w> C\cxOfv\s ,i\e Cru^ c>^ CA\kA<; c^Vc^ Lau) CV^xaas a^vfxA ScKAUr ^vl \'o^\y^ acVs c^^lor <^vA<i- SxQns AAaA occurreA o^^^Ae oVVte Os>^AVrooA-\ oaA ^oevv n^^W" VkG VcxaV xa ^vAeAon eAAeA on s-^0-04. ^or e^o^^l^ ^ckn\^ A\A >\^e\\A o^a^ G^eV 9«^e asA&C> ' VNoV i^c^^are onA t\\e AW \nc^~vp\Ae O^aporVA <UoorA vA Yk?, G^V ^ A A^peaVs uaVx\ n-Sr04 o/xA U-<H>* respecWh .*"• G<L OolA »*«*," cA X24 ano^-tV' A <jAV?. SckAA nx.AerW AAAAc^reienVaAon ^)<*s f\oV <vnaAe VoVke Aet^nse ctnk\ Wis conov*A*>n ^\Mn A?<>€4l«fc* to«/i- S-e\ fWa. A\Ur^ on or a^u\ HA-or. S^tfcOoU *V<W'A?. **- ,2.03 g*aV"<V<W oA o,4^-4Uo. A\sosee X^a\ "viV Ap. nU<»A X-&\ oaA^-xV1 clV p. s4V anA&4S"»:x>\ AtciACnj Ax.e\k*T AV>e k<vcVs OvS OLWejeA ir\ Vk^ £\'$kMA ono ajAAx Ao^eA Co~pVA.s. $a,\\ ouV~ vAe A\e suop-e, ok cA&uA AcauaxV^ .AkA UuA fw^A cetoJn^^, V\acA Ate WA> koc Vte AlUjeA VaVAvkj U ^iWi t<Auoe Vo pre pare oaU'A« ^ co^^Uk oaA d^kkvAenA cecooA appeal ^>^ U-3-04 a^b \\-<i-cA A^ x>oe\\ as. Vke VoeV AlnA &c1a\\\*/- nncAe q mAe- c\aA AA\sr<^pfe^^^VcvVxOn -Vo Ga\Von °n or a^^\ 4A-os\ Ykese al^sAons qs cAl^geA \aWovxa a^ £\«V(VxaA.c AjIaAAa A^JLA^eA Co^pWnA ^-onkr^n-S AkA Gq\\on k^s c,<a<vAcc c\A)AU c*<\a,;nA ^<Jn\\Ur Vnk^ xnAkAaal ca-pa,o\kf tore^<A\ o/x/A txj^ sVo^ji Lct-o <LW<n pi* A.s-e-e*c«LAJoU ;'v\V' oV p. i«H- a^l CXaA x,ci^k" aV §• H57-S3^ .-Akcoo^AA- Uv^ (A^ovn^s GaIW| peoekvAw AAixes. Ave ^orA '^pce^AW1 ank Yk<? AA^oA ^ VoW-eA V^ prepare ,toM\A aAA k\e a, sAk^eA OaA oon^pUU. re- eorA a/A A^p-eak ^« <Kjl eA*kW\ Qn'A AjtaVIa A**ifceA Co~fkAi ^enVA\L .C\LOo\A.1,VCk"oN f. 114-271 a/^'rWoV j-4 s7-T3^,Xn £<A CMV,A &\nce txWo Vvs. co^WA ^vXAa Wjl ctcfi. tn a«a.Two vws U- Aore 4Vaq Ax^ MuA^ q\vo^3 c-o^pWn-eA *WA scamXWA o-vs^qa - r -\i0- Vo ?rc-pare <^A -CcATMsk CcaWx. o. c-o^pWU. a^A sAW*A ceu>r^ ^ Z\«l=« P^kculAT CcvVon C*^W^ arCWA ^^UW VD.SM^-S44.As -ooW,eA \,H Ak^ cax.^ ^ *^^.wk^ k^ A sokAl^r mvi^koo o^ ctU. Maw) Fock^s Xau^^aio 9a,- \<oa Vo <?C^oSZ VcaA^ipVs -x^r erA^l ke^ojs \kA ^^ pr,^ re- a^AeA V>M C^\Un anA kor VaAaj Vo AA<,te ceasoAQ^oU f^uirxes aWV A^eWcvxX 0^ir\s arxet x?=<je 3.Go£o"0 Vke. e*VenV <A Ae record .See. ca. \jQ\A Mv\>>u <A p.a\sr-XVl os\ &" <ttW' oV p.S»tt- SSl- As Akxi \crekA«iVr>V«. ex/xAenuL concerns. VKicru^o^ CqVkA c^o^WaVs kaxje <\\^°*jS vaaAvsqAc^I^ p-erV^vrtcA Vo ^UaAUrs ^c^fAoo". or Ake cecorA- C«\kn kns a^^s AcesxeA>M>^'' cxaA <?WeA ^A^A on u Pc^w-Qkon" ^cV\\x\qt\s Axa\v^ Ac-o ore«Qo^e oa^ ^co^xAe CaxV>A a. Co^vpleie r-apor- V*A ceoorA oA CaWoA ce^vA4_A ^<xs o*A&\Ae o*J s,AnVers o^kuA AxAxes VoVte CounV-See xAAse^ V7S^3A cAssUGc\Va^ \AaVck xj &ouAs» U>^\S^*)iAHM3,MMxj» CT"e<.CiXi.A<»(>. Coc^ui cW\A \<U\,xorvV fc('^ ft.r.e.)CU^i'/iJ 4W\ cv od*A .ft.£p?tW~ Cc^A ceODg^r oVWa^A W-f k>^ °t sAV \axJo\xjvo9 p\"e- po^aVvon A a cecooA k<^*m* Vke, cWrA <aj^ AAdo p^rio^l s^xAce),^-n X/qkAo-tWe ^C\ AkA ^v\kA\5X x^lQiS GolA orA^e A'Va Qcapcvre o^V^nUk C^vVon a <sAkvi<A reoo^A on A<?pepl a\ s\<^4 e*.**/ue SvaAaMs A\x£ <Ac\ VxaA %<X\\\kt vjJai noV fert*T(w\A3 a. AutxeV^r\cxA-f AxA|. See c\XAJ°kV '^A^ c,V <?X7C oa^^-^AV p. *40. A\so<>e«_ xWke^ Vl^sA ctVSSl CvA^AaM p*.«p<xr Aon a£ AVe ve^cA <^oes noV <xeuui\Vafc* *u use A A\i- ereVoo ,WV A m^e\n>e .oAare <A r^auVnA oc <\ oo-AmAc^VWe Vas\c.V=^ preporA^ ^e ft^r^^UA ' ^ Aoes aoV «**roUe AucreVxon ,xU\ ^S7.) AAa^llvx x, \^Wsoa 4?*faA u?VMf C^k CvrV?l4] Cco^rV Mf^U/A AA^ CS ore rvuVmWiol UaW a* Aft «V AUcrtATDiNaref A <\A^e) - ,, x TnW mA<vA ccse <UMAUr pr^arcA ^VmiKe^

-A A o^>nVeA 31a Qv s\wW . A An * S.O^Qo P VAf^rA txV -G^\V>aS ^V ^\ ^™ ConWiV^nAxnA ^ck.ll^oQtS ivMi^Nnere^ ^ Wi .Ax^al ca^c^ A^ SaF^ WV Opmro-nS A?\A\oA-s o^cava^ (Ar^eQ p^^e 21o^^ r mAreXcs x;^«c*> 5C3^u.s.U\nlJ <x/v& ^o rnei V •O^U HSH u.S^i 9U<m) v^korcAVe S^rewi c^\ sVA^ «>kt*Mr ^ QtV u^Wrt (or non^u^l) CAa ce«\x\^ loe itUr^^ \»M4ka«iW€ A Ak£ o,cA <-G-keW,^ Ais a, -twxc-Vion nor^al)^ per-Cm-/we Ab^ a ^Aje "in AU_ Cjdo/A roo^, S-te rvuT-eles Sox u.s aV *1 / ns conVrasVeA Xcoaa ^Vlner "•AiwiVuAcAv-e, ^iA<A*e or ev<ec^Vxre. cueks-vkA ^vv^oly k^ppen Vt> be A^ne k^ o^A^es .3^ s^Vfe- SVer tfSK u.S. a^ 2X7, S>dUW!s oA^A Aukes ace.Ako.e p^W~eA xoy kifA \A Vke odiaA roorv^ 1£bce.** Sc^oUrs Akaol cop^cAf AAie-S arc <*VW\_ A,\*n§ ail coc^rVstxsfoAS/ recooA A^e. prouuAAes , <wc»<pV q^ ^^jc cAAtA oxA^-eA in eox^vice AiWn^ o pcouuAi<\3 oaA Aksn kle Q-H c*A>ikA^ AaVx, We V<;x>\ Couj^V cVej^K. axVWt Vke protjLe^A 5 gaAs, S«?e j-S/jvxertL X (GAp |3.1 o/\A Govj'T GoAe I sx.o<4^ .

SckUWs. oA'vuqV ct^cAkj Q^-k <*oe jtfaAse fen-k^A-tAk^ ^tlAill«r cWvnj^ ^uj-Vcoo»a procAAiinjs.cC.T^fllrjear v Correll lH^S^3Aso^ sqs~ C~^^.App. ADMiVon^'M ofi\-3 aoot{3 C^^A nAia^ ^U^v A is a ^cwckon nor- aaaiU p^r-QocA^eA k^ ^M^jes \n ^ CoojAro-o^ v$ Aisoo^ikveVo Ae-Hoer v^G acV iS, A,aAvtA<A or non juA'iualj. CoAxj-v^elx^ Ake pc«pan3&on o£ Ate. re^or^ is an aA<vx\aAcA\v£ ac\ AkA^^A kofp«^^ Ao be &oAe A q Co^V (UforVe/ feA xs ootxevi a QftAxofxeJ. caAQceU| OaA i\n all ^rAA'AU fi Aoa^C oAsiAe o-f VkG O^urVroo^n. Gv. Fofres\*r 4^4 <jlS.oV-2.17, £"o-«r^ aiUj^^o c-oAatae'A in kAk AVe ecckAln oaA AjiA\V\ A^a^A Go~p\aAs -See cCLOokl "^*xVaV G f?4- a"7| 0AOl,clAkvV A a 4s7-S3b* fceAAes Vo o.cVCgas V^^^a by Sc*\\.W o^VsAe cr w^ oou^VrooAA °^A AoV ^>k\\e scJb\t\Ur ^>as pWocrv-Ai Wis o^kual Au- V^eS . Per/^iAx'n^ V*\\i dou^Ao reotsonakly ConcluAfc-tfM-*4xe -X-Cx>G. t\ci\ur£. ^ CqHoni cWnas as Q^Vle^eA ^\~c cVax^s unA*r s^\a^ i.o a^nA SckWVer In Av^ \n^vj\AuA ecLpad\v| .s^c p^v^U %^s^z&,^nX Ckoiimj.

AiiAV^e cwxasV AeVv^iAe VcxM A^V^re o^ CjWrxk^U c\oio^J. ^e ^V<mA" Ca^eAs. ce^Ax'^ AAVM^u.\skeA t<;oAA MT^cre\\ \J SxslA b^c^uje A^e <*\(e- c. A^s a'lleje^- b^ C^vVon oxce. -foe ^ro^AoMj or o^gU^cX. ^^ s^cKAl^r \n ackons cvxAlor o^<>s\oas ^cJU^tv \<oo)L in hi^ pvsonc1 p-arsoaa. A;le per- VoC/-A^\3 p-arJ=>Aal s^oitj^ Oa^^xuS ^-^eV«VL^ oAsS^c A kUo&ti«A to^o.clki - 3-eeT^rreAl o Sxs\G vkS^3Ac,V 2%\- %X CIvovAvxo Vt^V^TuAje v^a^ ^^GA \n\niSo^VxU A eo^Adk^ on\^ kec^a^e a/|( ^llejq-k-an^i^ $<l~ VxVxon °y<reot cVgu^/v^A ujro^W/\j ac A^U^ce k^ AkeO^^JG vn ac- A^4^Vi O^eaM^ x3Hek p&je A^ ok SO h, Vxons W ojcxs AkkW^e ook^ keo^e o£ ku poukon as c^ p-aUxe ierooA/V^ o^A A\A rv*A <^\le3e cv\<^ 0(Aoas Ac^m oxAs\Ae Ws of-(\(Actl C^aukj h ^xA^VcJn^ Vke WV Ak£ QiAoACow>V evreA A Ai^iviiA^ CA- Vons A<**4 G^>vw/vxon Z.cO G^yv\s a^caaA ^ckAW oAxoAAC.SjLe ca.xAl p.AoO . <3eccui^e 3ck\\W <*)<& r\oV enk\l-e<A Vo sadden c* o^uoliVm- r\\\y isxjJiA xnxni-S vnAk>\^ua\ ca^t^t-i vAx'Ae p-v (ofW^ /vwnuWiA «cVs.

App^AanVs AkxcA goAVcA Pccor -CV>e Tc\a\ G>uAerceA ks x^aAiVt^ To AppoiA GA^umd X^Aj—rke (* $a\<< IL A Appe \\A-To *&\sure VkiL pr&aLcAxA^s Qj^^AeA aAo^rj<viA OaA x^kose WWkf xs a\ Ar^VAe. £A<xnA°^A <A \Xeoiewi An A^eAAakjp Coi>rV coi\\ cex>\£^o AkeAxiA GouAs cekapl Vo a^oA CowA^el \n a cXxjA CQ^e Vor akuse o£ Ax^oreVon .-See Cnkson xT\b\WrA 10X ^v^iA^i^n'l Tec^tfo^AteToxaV GsuaN; akuses A-s AucreAion ^AeA iV rea<JKft.s a. AecisioO MsooAA\"arw o-aA unreas^AoloU as \o an^ouAV Vc^ cW^r oa A pre3^A\ua\ -ecrop oQ Va^o^c s^se "S'Avuoa vj £©urMo CcujA A A^^aU 7oos^>XA ^^,1)7 CT€1^^sJ0jxa AAe/^AS ^kcAkor Ako^e Uan akui-t A Avsc<eVxon ^H ^AxAaV CouoA.Aa A^eAV<A^ C_x>uA^>Ml Aect^£ AeWw We VAV Co^/A acV^A ^o\M^-ou\ reW^u Vs oa^ J^iAks cxAes gaA mAuoVs .sucAa VkA x\;4 acV U3<xs arVvko^w oaA UAreaioAcAAe.. Slee 0^-^- nerM A^uawWiAX Opej~Ao0S 3^c ^0\Su)U 2^^qHZ CT^l<Jtr).A Vt\a\ CoutV oAo^e^ xVi A.\s<-r«VoA ojk«^A**Ai ctcWWrtkj , CAp<-<<Jo^i^ oG oovNVxA ceW«n<-e Vo 3x^103 CxaJju of ^Wpl^ .S'-ee Gr<u~>s_r ^ Co1(1/u «^r~? wU ^V}, ^^X. GTev.App. VUv^Un £\<VoA!l m3, aovotAJ A,x- ^U/A^vV A AxA<mc\ >»m.A9€ cxAO>f op^ovftk CAua^vVj oVUaA \o vVji OcM i-toU parV^ ^.kxD/xA^^S <vx atk^^o'x^ VkaVkeUkoo poor Vo e^loy oouAsel Vo q\W VoVWLC^use .SeeT<rv Gro^Ac^Ae ^ 4,oilo. AUoJ-fie GM'WA AxV,AaA oC ^r^^i- c^gaOL. \ ^V. Su^p. etx. \Jok\ o.4-lp qa'A r^^^ Xcva^V fUA^^c<^uAA^WU^M.k .•Av\A S^-^-'CCkvJoUl n^^Ake S\kAi A^eAAmA V^Ate u.i dnik <^raA$ ApoA\cA^ Op^xniAP GcXeV pa^G ^^ A &> an YnAx^enV cc\^fxai AA>/A<vA Ake. c\okV V> cJo«-v\je(l -Ma<A A^vAA&^s \AoV o-ppVw Vo c\xj'\\ e<xxes . ^^-rrusrxzj- \J <Xjoi*ri> *3\ S.cV iSV?, JS/r-XOUcilJj^ •XVxAeaA ,»-o\Ak onL c<xoe e A^apkoo^ , ^ p<\f W *-s no\- -eAAAeA Vo CowA Ap- pAnleA coLMidin ^cwil case.. See (A'Aon /oju^sA nY 7U - A kxn\ GxA kas A^sxreVl^n Vo a^poxA oouAse\ Vo a c'iv>U l'A\^^A \n s>otvN€Ave*<-«.p~ VoaaA c&.ses^ ^V>qre m\ve p^Wxe oa^ ocU^M vnWeA-s aV s.V^\^e ^G S^.cV\A\aA- Vke ot^/vx\A\s\rdVion A ^uAc* m^ WesV W ser\r^A b^ a^poxnVng a. \cu-o-f3T Vo c&pcesenV oa ^'nAx^A cxA iA3oa\ ,S-e^ TravelKs jx^^.Go-^ AACoyfiexA *?xsi^^A S^-o, sr94 Ore* .i97(J .^ s>uOa ^ C^se ,AV»ereVS O.. pr*_Sx>—^V\an A\a<A oa \nAxjeA Vvk^QnA kas a r^ifA-lo G.(?oo\AVeA CjDuAse\,vD^V onkf ^o^ ,1 te \o^a , ke r^ay ^ ^.tpri^A o£ kis pkAca^ \iWVv.^-eJi A.ciu\Wr wo«fVA r0^ai 3*txa. qr.ivj.s. \*, as-J7U?*U Xa Vke \nAoA ease AkisGouA iku^ V^e^Aiuql noku <A Ate-C«A •VkA ctVAte»va^k CAvVxaxs CurreAkj OneayaraAeA - <"A |;Wly \.S AU A sWe- deoxuse i-oiAv-oA 4te ^wV| oraMeA Appeqk^kA'-s ajjj-^A V^> AU«rA C^A'Wn Ake oppiAAk| Vo A^lta^e k\s ta^s <A YiWtw-S^ c<*is»v\j YtJi Vv*>o <^*a\WWs cWAi 00 cyf*.al AA>A Cc*|kj/i ^)qs preclude Atroon r oiasAj AunAo Vke \a\VA oppeA cWcV-o VkG lvmssi&o o^ W-l prekkl V\eankj recorAs /v>«^on«\'iu/i^ 4^^ dai/ns Aee c<gvoU 1,vflVlaV p. xxs^ xxi ^^ "«nw' <A e- ^^ "^S"- CavkA ItWAuk, a\ <\a^ Wc^tie ku Ae-okf yoA^eA o-p^eal ^oil( ^e wxA'x^^uAL AA^rAr^MS <*/A 001H reiuA <iA a n^o Vcxako^e Vo vke Ussan^kr AeiVc^ckon oV so^eok VU ce\*ocvV cecorAs. See-rr (LA- P.3^ CO*A\so see cOA/oVl ^H^k" p^ou -acrt, p.xato,p.2** anA"^"^ p«*W-m, p. ^g^/ ps3X -Tkoo^ v^ken ""fte V\M oo^rV W\MS Ax e^V*»tU. orA^_^q^ CaVk>n t«-^^r^e^ °^ o^koCA^-Appl AaiU w»"H oA-ecA A>AU recocA c^A /-c^ ^r oa «UvA Q-nA^keA^WW^^ wVll-f^^i ^ v^CeK3j AaA toACjL-vVe. reVeoa^V reaorAs are o>n&o*& Vd We, U>A OaA \C f^V^^k^ V,M We uD^iC^n^ C^urV * ^° AxH A ,A p ^oreSonecDA- cVmsM .ia^A^A^k^ ^vs^A^sa^^^^^^P^^^'^g vA^Ai^puJC-eA -^oiA^Ace oonkr^xs Vtere are recorAs ^VAkq^qre ^ces- <,ar^f k>r We. ap^q\ cesol^V^ -A«G 3cJnllcA /Akr A^fci'A "7-JO-U *CP^lAA Aff£\\A's O^Jo^ ^cxe^ poje SOASc) ' ^"V A e-X^ Q/N^ W<V\V <A psra *C^t-Vt>n eoAtxAes AWA ku xA- kr^A^e *V>A ^ Ao AWn o_ ne^o\?\ct\ oac °Al ^coWoAAj ono^ ^xasA be enVAWA V> W^s^e . OojlVi y^ \0sx o/xAior AoAcoAvin. ot so^etAvke recocAs. 3«-e c««nAo\A %> vxV," oV p.axu> o^b ?.i%% oao *^-<\au oV p'*J*<l onA p.<>sx."Tk\i XsS r»A Ax^QoixW-^. W<^ouus-e c <*aVqa xn A\.s \ \<^3 co^- p\o.A ^\A nA s«-eVL o\ nevo VvaUjxA G^aWi \s <AVocAeA A asu^ Vc'A vt v_o\\v be ^ ocAaTokvVe App^MoJcj? CouA Q^A *A k^ Ate. eoAAAe orA^r sou^kVtc^nA VkecoiArVW€\^s-»o^ee (A>euA/ic s^7F X£ a A- us?

CGoaJ^V nAxnj eJneuaA^ Aoes a oV Qi^toCanx| rekev tc o^n kis i^Vence \n ^kis acA-Un , nor Aoes ke gu\c AWts GooA orW ki^x ceAec^eA too a^ Coo^^^A or /v\-oAxk{ / \A Oa^ Gii^ecA , AVe ooa^Voa^ o4 Co/AxA^^y -Cke Goo^\ ^«a\ oa VoSWkj? Vke oaU| pouiVA* e^A -*kk ackon *W$VA-We. t>n eVx.uarllA cu^Akn^A-^i^teAV»A j\xr ke Can okVcun Ate -Wawripks Vo ap^eA ;oaA At>u\a kv^ o-fpe^l be. jucctssttli ke unwiA esco-pt oon- ^ag^i6aV / oa Ate 3Vo3ae senWxce. i4oo>eo*r/ kx^>oM\A noV Ao^ob^ ocA<ir<Avk^ CwV •, W>A «**• °v Accisron oUwWi VA<~x Ate A^-ell^ C^xA o^AUSWk_c oA Te«cc<s srWVxiS"?. A\so s-ee ^AGatoka \> Cv*a- V^aa^ S73f 3AX*4|XX4 tSAlnCif JOOlKtouA aAin$ AVWjo ^k ul^<^ c\ oqV o^ L^\s \S A> oAcu)n ewA ceoU~a oV kxs eoAouAxon. A* ^ QC~ V^cutl^ aAacG^ Vke. SW^A Wwrt Vo c^pl^ ^v-W> Vke Ay«nq de- clV\on as x<v^\q/A<AeA \>h ****• <3>^k oeaarak-n .AvA^e toil! nA re- aaice coA^ V^ A^V/'vOaj^ pekkoAftr's Akriir t*jAvo4$J AVe. i^AAx^p^cteA euiAeAce eonkf<n^. Akere.^3as c\ S^ceAv^ T^iA kearin^ <on ^-ia-o*4 oaA S.n!A W<v\<V2 ^^-omlizn Vke coo- xj\cV\A^ coxa/A* A,-eAva\ o^ GctxVon'^ OA-ckon To ^^^ X^op^ajqa-^ of S^eeA^ T\a\ -S'-ee e^carpV p^-Pe *? ^A ite Coao^Aa^ CUju^Vi tVNfl^or^Acwn.Pn- Avo$* oV VacA ^GoncV-usion o^Low^ oaA otAat Aso^A an i-9-07 m ce- V^renu \o^r'A AOcic e-a\3-oo-7Ua -o.^3l\o\-f\, A«^e ^Tu^st (Uk^V G-ll( C^-peAe^kj czWs VoVke a-u-o4 Vcarxn^ . See ciil.'vjoU W%A^M QV ^J5)? cvxA 'Ank" cxV p.^vW .-Ake v,A^pe«\ (U^I<\Vbi /y eAw~povse-s ko^ ^Akr_ rxAOAce oaA ceOe/iQ\ cA AA-e VcxM CoojxVU ju^m^\\, ^-c£ G^orelU Q^oAtij«7_ o.^s:s^3A7S«nv.3 cT^Aef.£im-OaOxxA^Xoo7) .Asace^\\ otHeu ^cVx anA Af^o^i Operas toek pa^G^OvSO A- { GjAkAVf \n So^pp^rV Ak^ecA WsWn-s Vkere \s <\ pceiu^pVon A<n<A Ate o^WvnWeAV «A obuns-el ^j<xs ooojrcAeA ^aA^t Ate Ateor^ AiiA c^lUns lib- erkj u3oa AAeeA aVA^e.

AAAxV&agW^ \ke oppo\Am«A oV Osuasxi ^-><*a v^cxroAVeA Au^eVo We Mu^i^oJL Cxrcvw^V^tftS^ ot Ate xnAcA cnse-AWv ^oere. keyonA e^- Ce^kviAA^« ^n -eo^l^ <AAs c-okA on\^kV ^^sWWM e*<JLpkv\Q\ ciccwa— S.Vc^xuls ,acoA x^ A-o <~ons\A-v VKe ^xm^vag cvcu>AiV«/iLes" ©^vkecase oaA AeW^Vxe AeVk^r Ate Vrxal Co^V k<*& nno reqvoAc*\cLe aUerAoAivrG kA Vo <3^o\aV couas^I " e^uipkoAQl cucA^uvoVo^oes A k^ i«.A-iAvk^n Care a^h UAuiu«|. 5^e C^^^n ton. 5^3^ «tV7H. Gcyoa<^ A*A Ate Te<a^ 3*- pcenne s\***Ji \a T^^Ve^ :x:,x<>*wky Gc. <?XJ J>ooOA <*V S^X-'lke CouvA kqs nexjeX <^cesje0 ^^.^ "e^o/wl cxccu^uV«AceS " u^croAk'^ a^f olnVeA coun- 3e^ <w{qVA W. As We Co^V o^x^s ^ GA^x>To\uA /^^^ aA 7U.VWqV aa^ ^pV, ^ bec«Mie vAaaV U e^epWqlis k^ Ae£nAc0 rare «o<v c*n- ^sual vs s.oooe-Mnm^ aoV xAeAk&eA kH Vke o^qtqI cxaxC-.O^ bY eu«lM Ai'n^g AkeuAi^ ^rcw^iVa^cCS oV a ^ixjen evuA case Ou\^ c Co^V eo «n fceU/v*MV\«_ AbA A k«s no rcawoable q\WaA^ kxA Vo ofpouA <^>unse\_^:i <*V-?i3.r>ve CouxrV coenA ©n Vo nAefm skoA ,U Is easier V> AeWArxe A^Ais cxAe*- Ge^oAal 4Wx pcon«*K-G a^ornl pco^kkon on xJinAAo3u^ b* eKc^n , on Ake xxnAup^€^ facVs o£ Ate UsVaA Case -Vke «*«pkoncA on<X ^i^ GvruvvAsWes coasroAkA Vke ofM^eA o£ CouAiekspeukcally CaiW) UA.eo- •Wltf AV <-ovAln a< Aia^AOsls oC-ono^oP AepreM\on x_o\V<n prv/O^okc £eAu/e3 vJWacaa precuAeA G<txk>n -Ccoaa e^Ux^V^ VxVt^nj anA prajecAVx.j'kvS GW'ax^ eTKM^ A^\S cvvji\ atfcon ^>as cxA a^^joj-^l A all retao^UW^Gu* AoVkeVacV aAaA^Vqa C^\k>n tey-es Ws pi^cliAro^c A^Aic^kon^ a-s p>reicrikeA c^A^r^ C^vAur, »a ao^u^W qaA aoA&xseA A<^te-AV-AiUakke CqVkm CAAaoV c^vtftAVr<sk? (aaoJaWo aVc«uA oV AVoM^WAfH^^)CrA'0A^liy op C'esesvch le^lx^ue-S.A'Ae w^erAte^ft^aotku prcscrikeA psycuAr^ic ^ (VnQ^ — ^xdkaAS CVaA pk^/iiC^l Oirt/vx«AVs ^e^eqASoAS Peji/neo .S"-««.C<lOoU p. I2^-u4 ^cv^sccvpk^ c^ML A\ W* cUvUn \n^^ p<^ ^Kol0 pcUo,^ k!sto^ Vrc^s Vo ^?oaA Vo AcOaAoA pU.,A.kSs OaA prepare Q\e^n^ -ftUAke/ ^^- vn.AnAasn cesMavk^e^ kA Ao ^s Woo(^e, a^is i V^oP a-aAVu. fteau,^ C^ VaA a. u,^^ ^^^ ^ ^^ A,^pe\\aA\-\ OpeA^n^ 6,rxeV p<sje 32oV SD Ao ^ooAer Wx& tooA Vra^ Abo \e^al avAXsXoAce.iecc^.xj-^A p.iaq-a^ p^q^ G^capWs U-iT-Xa oa aAWpV Vo vnos*c^ Jvkx^ lonoiu*A C*aWi e\\W k<*A\o aa\<a m^\\iQ\e f^eak a Aa^ asa, <resM.IV A seWm^ku V^AvAcIUujj pc\Ao- v\ens Vor AeXr \e^a\ ke\s? or G<A>n kaA Vo <xaas.S Jexwd Aoses ok kis ore- s;cc\NoeA va-ye^u<i\s0r\i . \okx Ja pA-G«xWi <sA <a xjen^ ki$k cUKoV jju^tiA^'l ao seW xa^ia/^ kAaxj'^r, 3ee c<Lxjo\4 p.m- 1x7 Qar^r^ 9-17. C^iWs^eW- V\VAr>9. S.V^3^ ^oklVe xaaW Vke Xrv-tU^ce oVAtet WaAc^ UsV A pce^cnkeA vxneAx^kons \V\ck,AiOJi ftu9*w$on .OiAx^k^r^Ae ,4AopAM .Aj^cVp^lin-ey Z_xs^o^o\ , fwecK^ke (. po^raAoU exy\b <UaA AiVxe.-See c(X.vj\>\-l p-isO'^l.

Pc^ia^A C^xVntco^vx nno^VaWoJ VkisGioilAcAi^noVA oxuMAukonA C^^porkAO oaA^oa e^uiU>U> o^*/^ QtWr.-CVse^VxipJL«i eui\<muifl Anke cecorA 00WA «bov>e AA^es cjUaT A4M uWi ^a^aWI aVA pW/stc« I ax.sAA¥\e$ p\aceAk^ A An UAreaiOAckxe Au^ycAtegecyvA prek\<-<t^A, AnA^AkAAi Ake xnsWA c<^se &\A a*A ^aiM^n Ake QiAo«Aio^u\ in n^AiAre re- ^^ir<Ax^ V-o cAlaCo CV Ao ke e^uVab^ ces*W<b ~k>r all pAie_s i\w^v**A oac* -fee -Vke nA^A\ Ac<A\oa oV^^Ace ^en^AiL .. "^VC^excvs Ax^revxe GouA x-eeogrv\\eA oaA <v\<Ae Ojic^-^^A W4> e*A Aence o£ eicxro^ocAxAOvaj clcuj*A>>W\ceS ^e^u^eA A-o cuAter^eAte o^kA vaqaV oV eouA^el xs <=t V^cA WseA v^-Axac* -vkAx^VeA oAivAis/e^ in con nect ^oxVVa eacln s^e^ke ca.se.Ake VA-W^^k^n eo^WneA in W-eAC- AouO\V XA ^x>-p^oA <A kxS fVvakon Vbr-xArxfi. A^o\nkv>eAi aQ CoaA^ekCaAS^rvMia^^ kasi^ ^>c Ax^ ^ ^ Aro ^eW*vMte MaA VWi ^a&*A c«^e u oa e-icMioo^l case <*te/e j^V>e aA^aAcAoa A^vaAu oOcm\^\a«\>4 ke^n beVW^erxjeA \>H afp0Aa$ c, \<x^ar Vo c*f<eseA C^vVoa-J*-^ c (l.xjoU p-i a\-WO ^n^il^. AV« sjzjl AA^6e\A °t^Z Sva>X^ ol\ S^U.-cke^AAispuJaA ex^AftAU* <>^^ ftM\ko^ e^VbV^^ ^q wx^AW ?>K l^^ q^oA^A oV (^ooascI v^as, OACM.AH-Ur^- OxsVA^^AkA^ ^« *a- S>\-oa\ ccxsefeo^ Vne k^il^in?' See ^^ ce ^-°5aa ^-00^—^A^p, ^m^W?

CC-oA n^Aift^ Crc»r^ Akc_ (Aic/v^tel k'ire; ^e <^a,r\f>o\ OacX^^C- c*s q /^^^Va-oJJ V<Xco AkA SmC^n eAvaorAxfxor^ CAVcw^u-VcnotS o^re ste«?^ uaou \^ rt<[m>e ui Vo oC^ Vke CouaV \o A^^o\Vx\ GoaAsekOuA Aed^ia^i ooAkis \iWxk-A v^-cor^ Aoei a A tA froxATje / prtcVAe VVve G>uaV G^^tV -(ro^ AoJao so A IcViJ"- .rwxA^ vV Vo be op^ro^r\^ ). AVeVk^V c^o^aaV erreA o^Avj7o\«^A v\^ AuV-| Aro eAxure Jv^^tAAW ^a^\oa\ cAse «-oqm\A ce^vtuk V^\^j aAo^janpl Ap^UCs Ope/uVxj Qc^eV pa3e 3So-C ^ A mWe \>A^*AAAte^^Myx\V cx^WoaVoaA o€Wa*A* *u*a ^o, iee 9AUc uk^ CWa i; CoW 75q so^A \i\,m CT^lwJ^ **ms- Cx^M \\V0A^ <VeCo^\ &V**a AVxcA ,"~nW e^Wl c^c^k^S,^ p^kkc oaA prioc.w iAectsVi <A iV^xie ^^W^ch-^^j^ aA^auV^fcan _°^^u ^^7 be WA i^x>eA k^ afp^A^ atkuo^srV) c«fres^V on V(\&yA <^A UVl3oA. S^CAson l^su53A^V7ia.:^EA WskVo£ ,(Gnkscn'A U oe^SA^ Q^p^eAV JnkActVx4Q\ UvArV&AWenV p**«r Vo oppcAV oouau!

V3 AecessorAi c^nkaoeAcn ^ qoAA ^aA; ^V-AAms o^onAke^- A«nC* <* evc^pboA.l CxCCU^WeS- M« VaAQCs reaAilu exA oic**oneA bn Vte «^^U^ *3** AtU~A C*_V, ,U pWI-i3L7 p^,^ j.^sm.

AxAvWA oj 3^5^ vA.S^p.c^A\ p.M-lP/ «aA aA^ ^^-^^^ f^ Ac^V SVWV -fe-ar^ VoWec^v 00 jo-i-h^j ^k^mVrf Ak AepoA^Aokwnsev pUAnjs ^leAo/x ioo\->4. AaA Su^ctL.'x/oLi pSAke eTCo^onal cxccu^AonUS o^vte tAsVA caie irxciaA^ GwWi ^^xVx tyAs- WAtq VkA p^eoeAeA kAWo<A consUVe^kj c^Ae(fecW*^ pmecAno k^ c\A mA<A all V\Aes cv\A kls Acaro^koA ^>^ioA'\eA Ate, a^oiinkv^Ml A CovAAsekcQ. -\ksseY J*CauAk( otvi\cW\^^Ui^XA7(i\/7bS crre*.A?p, Corpus cWxAx Wl ) CiVAnj C\ruA,v^AoAces(i^On ovS iAp*u<»~>eA ,AAOy^cj^e ;V A- 9osi\k\e VfcOoAiV^cA Ar^ represA Vv\>xjeV£. AdA-lkAis so ,couAie.\ i<> re- ^u^AeA ,<AAte ponxA oV \os^ ^G o^^orWikf (\o\AjaAe Ate ^xSGOc^tei', ACrASWoA ^ ^QA^le ^H\ S^m S3,S 7 tTe* Afp."-T«*arY.o*< *.<)?*{, ^>^\ WA }(a.

AcvcA Goua\ cAcmscs A-S AucreVon onV^( If Ate inrA^ kaAeoAe-iCeAo-afY \oarfe^VcoAn pcGseAknj Wsc/u^J, ;x-C Anis couaV AVc^s V\>e An A Co^As o^Vs^eA \AAke o ^ poVnV o^ errors caXseA WraVU ^sVaiVu Vke *CacV AteV C«\W> coas e-f- iecW\4 WneA omV oV CovA oaA Wk$cA»<xj> •Vteg*ieoaocje- Co^e.VoVKe \VsO)A- Vcovjerklole -QaAs esWk\ls\A Ak<A 3\eA>e ScJk\\UA ^ACo^PeW\ r^orViA^ pt^c— Aas cv\A ^^V\a\ <vvu^G^rcs«AUk'tyn Vo Ave AeWsC-^eec^xjol.l'oAx" ak p. X^ST xm o^Ayl^Wx,< aV o-S4^-tS|.x>jQsVkJL^recA CcxuseovlC^k^i 0\recA Aq^aV Vo be VAAeA aAAAke reAi^n C^\\-on kxs v A Vo ke A(- -JUcAeA kxs Gonsk^koAa\ (U^VA \o a a^qaA^W A(>pe^ .3rnvj,olA<m o^k^n ckzuAses or AVg ^^bMAVhAvJAA/v^vV - 3uAaiAv^ aanb. 4^cA avxVSqI CouAs A^Vo^0^^ GMA^$Ga4oV So pr«.y^tf«V a/vA tV ^V^ osuahA* Ake *«nfcfc*n okA^C^co^j^^^kS^ TXV.A.Q. H\A(Aja),-CW ceoorA k«re.*n S^prAi VV^WVoo^VsxxeA AAAAe- rv-\eA <A\W iwkxtn £or A^AWhV oVGo«Afel 6/1 U-H4 .-S\ejL C(lud1.| pwo-irl anA-^r^ <sA p.iO>xr,

-*<W OxAucV CouA e^re-A kn A^r^iaj G<uV>ni e^ IJX>^c^cki>e (UUef (U^A oaWs. **m3 cWW WAoVte^A^orAWf c^Ae*cftpk-0rfi(cJr- Cu^A^cJ^ *A Ate (asVoA caue a^Ate Co^e\e -f^arCo^ ^ *^Wx UC c^xVoAkas no oxA>er q^^ r^e^ qVU^-avW, iV A u^ptf^ Cc^xVoax GDAiktetex^l O^kk uxJire xjici\qVeA* S,VaAAcxrAoV OLftoyeyJ TKe CcqaV or cetxsa\A a pex/A«r,oA \oxuAckao xvoovAUn -HvG VcxA c^xxn\\ SomaA AixceV^i aAo/c^afPec\ (CeoU^^rj^^^^^^Vs acMon ^ 'UoAeA Vo t^eskon <A ^VeAW vte. acteo conskW*A c, cW cxWse oC AucxeVxon.See SW3^ .Te^ ?eV Vo.A ^c^u^A Soo,*03 CAW^ <-^oA<Axon xs> Aka\ We\& enkVie Ao cfxii'l ^n^uAckye-ceke^ onkii I X<n3 c-WVxS, specific<t\Lf ne sea^Cs a ooo^ek- <*A'^-i^^iu«^- A^r-o o^i ^eu o^peal A-o M.kWie £<A ceoorA., J\s ce<j^-es\eA ^ kisMA -VKfi &'$ktfn <sa& A;vyHi A»\ao&e^ Co/a- pWak, -**e okOcl.1 "W/'aA ?*Xt*9-;U,<? ayxA "^IV^A plJ-SI'l.AliO^ c^Wis aaAioa £br 9ce\?«Macv^ js\^uAcA>QA/£'A*itAi °^A AC^^cwA \'a s^p°rA-tk«re&G sjuece.

UA\ p.3^S- ^\3.A>.e A^ial Ge>^\ -ecce^ b^f 4-<?/x^ir>£ CavWt iViUAcku-e ce.\{e-C b^f or^-i s\^neA on s'-a5-'S'cv\^ <o~i-ir. ^-etcd-x>oVl p. m*** G^Mro.-rv\,e-CacVs as o-VU^eA esA<AWsk Ak<*\- n to^-ete iaA^re o£ vwe smWi k«u ou.u/reA.Asco'x- tvc<wA bH G^vWu oAW$\ Vo oAqaa reliefVo <xo c^\ Axx* Vo Vke proceW}( k^ruers o^ C.Cx? AxAAVtfU HCa) *'3^v,.sc^2l,v| c^'AAkeTevasAUefi^ cOcA ocAsT enWeA pr^i^sl^ a^JA-V cA\Voo , ukiA ^e unu3Aikl^-k0A.<?i on ttce AWA Setter rwa&e « *^WUI ^a^^^ ^^^.cd^a ce- fes^W.O^^irtve o-viVWi record -o^ (Neuu^A^ , "*-w+«*«<"V v,v \>o*x hi, EIJM- <^ M/n*. A-^e^ C^A^ ^^ v„u ^ ^ J \W_ ^wnsV^Wt <^\WM procure- a*±M^L onJoiV^ AtWu o^ iuUd i. | ^W c*J ceU^ * ^wrUjto ftfutfu ^x\V lie oa TO ^dr <Wy aXX«« «a&s Wx *«&* or Te^lUwVu^rt^ ^pMi,^t(,,Uo,|

i^ss OAfe ^enU ra^^q „,ve ^ ^ ^ ^^J Tote. ^V^ Vo an v^Vk.0 ,a ?W^ rwA sU^a^cA a o*V*B A^V*W «Ufc« -ill,**r W^ w^ . „AeHte ,w A^T sko^AkM vkfi. W \^ ^^v,-eA ,Ate vke .Ww ^oua k* v.. ,, PUA*tC WaS no ^ ^^ A< J AIA^ ' ^ ^**** ;n„c. u ^ec E^d,^Se ^c Ml u.S. SW) JW (ao6kl A^, ^ ^^ ^ ^ °^ aX V^o .w^ o& rv^eW, cic^ses yace i^te^^^\J WJJ^ «•«*«*'»« t \ As. a preWtna/M mAVkr \\ \s. wAAx^pu^eA *AVvA a ^xoa^VA acV-occufceA ^<JK\X\qt k^ <AAU<^ Vo ^oo\^r^ CaAYon oa \^coo^\<i\e record o>A te Ue«AiiA$ <2>o^rA Vowa^> Vx\aa ^uAfy OaA ^^^pelA&cAtesa/Tve* Se^ca^voU *v<b" a Af> - ^^\-X^x, a*c -X^7 a^A "fllK' oA 9- S^-sm^ aa^ <?*^-srvrl.-rKusAu uAuoAeA AO^V, S..cJk;\\QX sA in Cw-okoo Ate. cWo o^.eyftxVs AkA te W\«aO or (UoionabLfiWlA kaxi-e ^xooo ouovMA kar^ CdU fteM esWuk VKe Ct^»U C^sal caxn«.ok»0 VUA s<Jk;\W* incxyvspeVACft oaA ^rapreieAWWi ces^iU^ vneavVoAS a\te<A Ap- ptaV Vd be x-esoV^A on an irtoor^tete oa^ ;aw&m«/A reoor^ oa^ -Hvjl o-wivleA re- oocAs w«ire (\euv«AY-fecop^e.A- &e<^se Ak^ ^^^^<A^eA eoi Aence qa^cWVaS C^lVon -oas prccWieA £<-o<a ro-kiAP on op^k 3^c c(iod .1 ^" oA PaoM^^ p^5--JLU oa^^IH1 <A p.lWtvl/ p.M7t-^r anAkasaUo ce^ikpn *te .SuUWVxcA AeV^ oaA eeWAAon \n CAxWx oJcWa^ a ^n^lc^eaV ^ee ivvorrvs ^ oe^Wne m V3Ak*7,^x CsrAte^ W<?J An A^wxoVx^n x^ a o^re op?Wnon o$ e^UbU re\iet, cvxe wfc^ b- juncW cekeV <~aA pWA c^A x?rox>e AVxc^Vkek^sno «^*** n^eA, A V<x^a one (crepa^^kxe iny*"4 A AkreaWeA-See co»*l\i*"A& v Co^^x^ssor^ £ng':s Coco. -no^s^^^^^^qT^CTe^Afp. ^^U^LHlViOisAl mb u*A c<A'c o.r.^J.Vbr pur9aiei A x^uAck^ reJUeV, o/>«Aetu^ c^eAM <A Uu» «*As AoaAU*xW?W) coujA Vo W ^x^oUeAAs \ncapaUe a^ Wa^ ce/vteiieA k^Ujol /weywxstbte 4awi5ei -Sj2X V\a^w Ato*^ca\ fA-jor'xVe cJK\gMa Co. 9^1 i^XA-»x"8 ,7;?ocTe< App- G«rpas OaTxxV |^//iOPtv A.'*«naeA w.o^X"^ $A a^ .ajuacVca ,^ /vu^sV jew*^ sko^o ^kA voov ^°aV kawe cvx Mcvie^ua^ c^eAy oV^ ^ -okch vxjlqaxj^A cxa aAWA A A^^^sGs ccAkor rekeV^>\Vl 00V prAecA y.o^t.;Ue ^ju-ok x> faw^JL Sl-iCX^ Ulceus CSAinGxrv^^J-AV^u^UCAVkn xs iu^kj Aor <Waj>es wvAarA&jj Voaa3 lA^AitTAke so^e seVo^ ^acVs U aoV AU^AVx>G,-\kc ^\^-e A«=kck Ak^V e^c- nOraxc A^*xaQjeS ^ackj be c\o<MlabLe e^oeS oo\ ^\w^>a^^ an«^i A^kA 4 ceiweAv Aki^i \^ v^^eau«Jtf ^ Vo^ e->t^>-pl^ Ate 3^n?r<i«xe_CoiAA Vxa^ Vo^aA -H^At a c«^e^ o.V \ci^i A ina^^Ae A \t°f{ re^vess rw^ be oU^A^A ook kf purW/^ q n^ulk- pkukf A qcVoa-s . ^ee Gee ^ 6wteU X^luS-MiTj^al C^jqX^G ore/uoV \n UubV", A^ ^v^ikp\.tclk( A ^ckons AeUU«^ Abe ceAcevi-oQ. Vaoi 1^ s^kueA V^ opko\A Ag CevxeW b^ "inyvxcAonJ.Ako s*JL xVWc mSr^eAb«r3^ XKi^3^CS;o,^rl C~T^^Ap(?' Aui\xn xaow) CVk\^A2 nn-oAtt>f AawAj.es ao\ ^ko^i Oa ^^e^wJ^ c^e^ aAla^> . -pxrve vA^w\ck©A i-aqs an q^^x-k>A V\i on^. ^oqs a A ^ A^p\ica^ cdV jcw^ cujoaAo^ •v^oAeW^ Ao^a^es an^ Aes^AeA Vo qcoaVVI^ appjeJlees eow>\^ xelief.AA GyccwkA^ \AyAAokxrG ceVeVxA a^AvkoA. Vo c*-oa^-/<vy A^^qj^ «uoe^A ^ niA Af^tt°A$ C^eMkj Gx^e^ pajti7A ^° ^ oa Ax>sc A Avv^A^vx ^a Ak'xs cVccu^j^rQAc^j.^roVVe^cxsA^ case-We iA^A<Ai\>e f€\ieG o^Xus l\°i\l <-*i'M ^>e ^xereb^ <v\a^A>i Vo c*4kanAWi « Wte*M °£ <^y ^netey Aa^AQtS O^c^AeA oa Vke3\rJU! A^o acu:^D UaAqt \\^\l tAlVon OsAaoV obW<0 A^nQM A***S« ^^ ^ °^^ oe~WoAs *v>4A k^/ei-n -nAe GeUAcvA ^j£i cxce \™mcm£ tr©™ Acwx^^e i-^Vs. ^e. s\y^p^ v sparvcm«/i 4 js-u.s. u^Cmy QnA C<Aon c^aaA ^ecoxjcr A«~a$es -Pcom ic^aUruAWSmi be^A^e « cA.se. lqo7e(ej. pcecU^ pcUaWJ V<ro^ Vu\$^,p i W\? cWens Voc cvoag^A*- AA^^es u,\ikoA a pr\or iVvo^i.^ ©t pW<*«*\ in^/re*^ c*^o Ao«iao\«ll^ a &*^&$-e e^c^y W o=™VwAsc>nq( WAs^se* cA^ot Ccoj^aU 6o«illn>n VfU i^i^ u^i^*? Gxee \<?9s) , CqaYqas \AakAA Vo dA^Un ^eVlA u^WWkeai eocpaS \n A-<=te or VeAeral Co^rX ^\i0 ^^ppoA-i k\s c^VAon, AkAAe U &^\K<l Vo cvA x-A'A.C^ vW\s v/Sks** %nsa>^asi^^CTr^Aep.3^An- V-ooiO V^tl AOpeVX^AxAJ AAkfVo oAaio pOi\'COAo\ckor)Vxpke^S Oaop^AS ce~ UeV XS VaAoC Aro ooaax^T A $<<Ainj akdfcfl/wflAk uaW (LAeJtViJ} (Jailer \J ^Wq ^aXS.-OX^ 3IH(33S(Xet.Aflx^ArA«A«* /^kref'A^Cs^ve]/ AV^teujk G^vWi Axc noV Wn A Yte-kA -HaA As AkecV appeal x-oas AecAAe^ on an xn<-o^lele cvA \AsAkueA record ^aVI ^-ij-n-Ace , CO-.M Al *<£V<A JV^OC" <^A *<AlW <A p.-*4^« vte reutipV oV 3<Jk*l\«nj rei^e daVeA 3-^-txVoG^xWu c-o~vpWn\- ^-oasAA^s nax^kj ^ucaoonfA e^ooa.jee JA l,%xV A ^.x'ikx^A oa& ^<kMA p-S^r-sr^^^V Aces <nA a^lVA^ sW\WA A xt> u.^e <s xa^A ckAc^AC^ an&CVAtSiCcJ oaA UlUn c-owlft ^oV oA<*in Ve«.x>e Vco-^ *we Pitv^ cWA Vo £ile n iuccessk* &cjyA cooxV A Oa^ K^aA- See.CO_.aoVA "Vtk" <A p.SfcO-Mol oaA "iTVAp* (dXS"-^Xx^. Aao vk i^ o-poareAV AWA VV-e akast ^V xjOcxV orAsir enWeA a-c^oi^sV c^xkon Vx^s leA Atee Golat\ ok cr^vvVAq( Appe.et\s <-o\Ak A-e iA- press»30 AaaA Gt\Wi V^s ooaXx>eA cvA^>/or o_So<v\AoagA cvx^ coAWikonW aa^ kaxi< vA cej^^ te bis a.vWpWA rv>arAer ooAoVt-kon -i^-e ^rA<A ""s~\V q-V p.3^>X cvx\^-Oo*' <A e-^i?' Abo bee OA>V^ccu^k V33WX4 Ce^3\«>-alA"7(3 7K CTcnE Afite -App l^^r)C|+DlAinj> ^u.A as OAe a^ abaie Vke^^ ^ VA^^^'H^ Cor^S AA^^^^k \a^I v^^.(^^ O^^ eboAor\£^ O^Y ">nWk*"OA Kt. /wi^Wi^. \\n cejoM Vo vke v^xsx-cA ooooicVoa) or \n-\ke ^iV^-Ack'^-tl^ Cox^V aao^ be re\wAsj on cVs pr<rceA<A Vk^AtelAj; ^te u?r^ c^AAO\b^ mxroUeA Vxor <^or<L sVsWW^ vrrtjA^nlieS xA \te §roaAiA^x keL^.

See c^aAe S^^k-^r^ ts^U, 3voaA S"M.\, S40,CTe i^vVx^A^f. |?jj) A^4kfl^ A p^AVAs OpaAAAj G»ne^p^e3^A-aO A^a£ ^oeaV u^Ask^uVA ntf\ be u&eAAo bVocJL? "^AWi ^aAo"te^A kao*£ keon caused or\ A^retV G^eo/,See £^^Ve rWKS ^tWwaA^^^T^CriW A^p|cg^).CctckA^ akA\ £?>r sckVlkcr's M^>v-peWi^e (vkoA^Vo <\ u/oiAiV) eA TUA-x0. ^-(AO-^A rwaA ke r^iseA d/^ ofVA?A^ee.jk(Louker^ 3kfc9 //0^volAsst//^7oO'( Cnnr^<j>1^A^joo3j;^5;f^1f2_oSWtp Zo-?J->3AJ^^. "?33^35^ GTe^ Atf>. SoAAnWnft 46cV?) .l-k>u>eje/" w^ Apfei|Jb? cwitel 8a/f^ A\ferA c_©nsuv\efe o^iVt^ SckxlUr, sdM)i*r rvnxVeA A\k>rA c^ACajAoa <jJk\dn preduAtA Vke iwoe- -CroA^. Wa^p rais^ on oppe^l in *te \n\VaA case „soe cavroVA MvtV»"aV ip.jac*, rW (Zt[--.oa'A "91k'--oV ]p.S*ll, SH^SHS; XOAft SiCdGfD"^ aAa\e A«teU anAvteOoxxA Was rea>^A\-ceA Ak^V a.yMqfe/ic^c, sVcAe sAakAetrt^^aA'ts not q coa^o'xZAble cWnn on. \n«*te<*4 *See ^* xW\e Oxx.€aW| "T^f jvoa.fcfc*o;as lore*.CnV\ AVf \9Si)Cvj;oUkon oS* ArW&JL :U. AoX ^ ip*« ^yTVWI AA ,»'.$ noo^i vAick^ncl AececV)/ <£*. ?^U*rovur <?o( j-o42± M«4/ VS^CTV^cn-vnApp. mOCv//olefin <tf aA- XV-13 noV c-°5r^a^Ae uA\ess A ^WcJ^AckWAA Agouiqa A-» pl^oA <ju<l/k(J To sAs-k/Akc s.eaonA e\cAAftA.\ o^Ato !f\xxMcAv>n AanoATc e^itei n*uA <U~^nsVAe AkA A Vxe vs. AgaxA <*n iny^cVon/ ineparaiate kaonouz/f ce^tk&e AAaAo Al*\ Xas, Co.x/ WccussioA oQ (Lo*f"7T?FAAf90,?f7fSVhCifi*?«£).J5i s«/«/M \oataa is {cfepaT<aU^ x^b^re. Vkere A fMo aAe^ua*^ c«^eAa Ak^o iuclo as mo- neVo^Y Aft^*jes ♦ 3ee O-teAeA ^eA CVi. x/ cAy A Geer£e\A (kacfin fewf^cJ 3M/S3^tSVinCirUukfi{^l)*CalUn,i inakAtiyVo r^e Aie tfrpfy x//<Man ca.A (k3A*x~DSpee A "x*r*a\ vhoUtei CWaa an a^eoi 4a\A are oAe^ori^lu-eA m jte^Te- ViA recorAs VbA ^j«re o^iVVei, £c^*vv Ate reu^cA on QQ(Xa{- t-hs cewfl^A* -tfe etfeess-jxjetelay Qn^jubA^kA cek>rAAion ot appeal -o/proadJu^ Vxiielx^e yew oaA ootMk^o 'StVicje calkin •Wo'ely A(eA kis nAte oQ- Ap^aion s-2&~o*( .Sec CP-xyst.l "-stb"^ p. 373 oa^'^-h/A p-^3t.A& "^ a*AW©Q tew^/Ai-e conWiAJ Aepr^Aion oV «^o^VVa\ioa,qI r\^As con^VVAje i^cepaVAekA^^A At* £lr«A x/ Ga,"AS HXT utx; ^^,7i 313 CV»7|el -"^^ Ukeu^VL vJ 3Vv<v>o ^X^ f:U X^7/3oX CSAt^Clr mo), QcWA ^vgAsAcVArt/VKc FiCVW Circa'A re^^ue^ Ak^V a ^Vtffcje ct>u\^ oiol^dcp iue_ practss A iV s.tAkAaAkGllLY AeWe«^AVe op^dte proass \\ orooiAe^-forccAoitieA Co^iAai AeUAAaAks ,AUoS*jl AA^Aku xiA^o^ ?S1^^^ ifopn Cz^arl??0(^iA ^A V, ^e>,k^ a Sioan Ae^^ coa^Ues, *. ^ pr^uss x;,0Wkxon ^u^cxo- teAAkAMne anA^cA ^a^e^rt ^ VooAi, in «^ter o^ayo Mo7u.L6f4is Apfe\\As Opo^Aj GiSeV ^ajje_jo0£s0 '" qaas&<*\\h oppVcalole „^^2. ^oJeA o^xe\lA_5 AeVo^s oV *o-to^e<vs eKcc.isix>e)fkr- Ake° vn We JOvaMa A^j/iktA CAv4oa kas pl<A oA o^co^a HVe oonknuJo^ , preseA^o' - xj erse eCk"As v-c. Ate on^A Ae\oA# oaA-sAAoAxA reWAAsan A a A*xu\tko~ £A op?e«A 3eeca.oolA l,r<V\u A $.Slo-SiAAke y*u>x\ pu^oje o4- \^t^cAsx>e re- UeX \s Vo WA XAiron^&t^ acVs VkA are VkpecAe^eA or Oa We coo^sJto% qcaonA- A&WneAj c<*\ter Ak^A k^ 3ro\\ ccke^ <=*ScmasV p^A aoki»!Ae iajayi^s or Vo pceo<2nVAte. aCnnAM^\on A «-Oconjs fxA tAoM^enVlw AteeAeneA J.SfleTeTca^ lAAAV> Oxre^kto. Coua.u SeW» fecnta fWxnc <H sx>o3A tMl^sS cver*A?p. A^^a 4O03J .MStteu^h iV\v, iAnA\spuAeA AwA ^ ojron^l ac\ Vy*s occujreA »A AVe paA.(ojue.Vo Vte ^cAavA beo=aAse SctUtar -ftleo oaiVwJeguwte fecocA*.

CqAten coqs nA a^VocV A<? i*s«ftuA^ of^AqaA;. &mA ap-gal locus ua<-oas\A VASa^ cesoWA. 5;eece..Mo\.\ ^V QV *.J%Ha*3L,A<JS-2*7 oA^MnhMcAf.

SAS'-^io (SHl-SrS"!* PaA e^^oiune Vo»l\e$A <-oooucV Aoti axA vk Av*A &.te^ a. Qrei«A ease orooAt^^ ceyxAvao ^wacVxtG reUA CV UAAccorw^yaAi-eA bx^ a a^ coAinvu/iQj fresenV a&o^e «^&As .wo'jk^ vcAkeVoA^W^A-^) M<?S'%>G\<?"7ti).^nVk.. ins\anVcax\p Ate k^TAA ,is nA naerekf W*h«ArA\s. ac\uA Oni^ cx-)go\n$+S*Jl aJoaTC Coop v/OnQUoe WxAJA.^S','^? CTcsLApp; 6<*u,rvtA XOo;?XGouA nAin^ Ake Um ii <w*reAUai ik^kA AooaS acW oa^ ongowjj^ T^or oxjer ot cAv^ry Ate. ^v>pr^vxe CjouA kas-oltooieA -s^As g^oiAsV y^akJi AkuAs V^r oros^A^e \A\uncW *e\<er Vo -enA a c^aVa^a^ vjMa- Awn A -feA^aVlo.^ cuvAqt Ate ^ocAnnje oV £"< xWte youno xo?aA,iaio?oL) CAllen *-otf\ conVnvAe Vo ^AlV k^^ "At W* ^ proo'l<UA « oo<m<l&U oifc&up- -feenV ce^rA OaA A0"0 appeal -k> Ate* ^<hA x^uirAi Vo ca^se Vo ufcbte ConAVAo.n AiftA^lsun cUW a^k aA^lVc^^^/^^Ave ^^aat 4«tVs,V<i sAoux xcreO^aUe Vn^iArLj ooUl ktM^^^01 p^-waA \f^uAckan.3eeie- «^ox^ xj ^oua^ S3H?X^ x\\CilU3CSAlACxc^7^yxavQ>ea5Ate esseAsM -ftnAxA^AxA rv>MSVb>e fvx^e Vo vs.Sx>5 Q^Prdx^cv^ Ja^uaAx^A ts iffepcv^b^ U^ur^yjJf^e^ 3eAAx^V ore*e<jMsAe V> par^aA-A Co^tAAck^n "'^ Ate w^cvjcMloUlikv o-? an q^— ^uaVp Ce«x? i^ *\V VoA^*-::LA aV 11-^*1 •orW V^i Ate <-oa<j^As oV Hjrrr^kV-cy^ ^n^wAf /f c^ ±AJ oA^e^ucffM ft-«^^ ^^ AV/^^°^ one |axV Akj>u)skcbxi Q-0^ CcxA \r\ ^anA^ecqA c\oAk\rx^ ^^ x; foi*Ne^A\Ak^n (Loa^A M^rx<Ai^r facar \nijf cCm^ Mis: ^-k | CW7*i) aCtixooUAseA Vke ^e^OAV ^A^ka^itokili-t^ tA A§Qe\VAs 0-^nj GrveV p^^4oA SO ^ xjoeA on-Vo ^o^ ^aA -Ate XjCcepctfaxJj? \n;**^ cukxe \sA<\W\A-eA Vo ie- ScAte vte oxa^uV-j or se^vAf o^Atekar^x necusw^ VoV^gjer es^A^bbe (nWvj^Akonwzsk conVcaA (Ate \V*oe^x«c^ ce^eAy locate* M-e poss\k\\iVe3 6^\Wa^W w\xAes oV ce\ieV ,ko^ex>*r Aeo^re AteiAvk^ ^wy-^TAA ^^n.*?. _ : C^l-kyx ">ill UAOxv.pa.\e^lv| preoafl on Ate ov2/As. onkiS. \\9%1> cAcJnS. •^e.c^u^e C^Aon k^A a ikUkr^ cmA <^nsktekoAcl C?gA Aro a cA^lekG GAih sAk^eA ve<^o^A aV sVM expanse <*£ <an 7aA< j*aV apfe\kA«i*e &a(6n U 3T\knox^ 25\xa,s, iXC^s(e)"; £* P^Ve -pYcuW l*lk/33A3SS»is<? CTe<.cr,v,^Vf. ioosO A\&o SJift CavWx's aA>xv\ £or A^Vefc (Uu&rA «A CocAs orA*r $r<MkAy^ ^cxv-e .<JU£eo_xjoUM Vx>V'a\ ^. XTM7S" oaA *91V1 <A p- S3^-s4 0,A^-nn?*qsO>f\- S\\V*Wi ^cvxAs a cHjkVko c?pp^l Vo aMcAuf cvvA aWna I lik'ycAsAeeAJ^son Vj VCxmAqa (crm^^^m CTev 19^-Ox>e process ce^c^s AkaVj oi<4 Ite $»\c*A> /^Ace Vke A**u? kascreAe^ Vke^xAJA o-£ appeal, (Vy^A ,Mo^Csx ^QC^ AekAAonV a Wr op^orWAf Vo oVWa an aA^xcAuA oA Vte rxnoAsA^ cappeak A-ec £\AVs s/Auc^ )0C 3.G\«0 ,VU Cv^O/xke CoaAxIuWI Vouck- A«a£ \\vkA Ate op^ell<^ proaA<-ue axaas\ V^ox;{\n we co/npon«Ai A<?as- cc\r^ VoC <veaAM9-C^l ce^'ve^* A SV*4 <-o&uxA A«^ a A€&aAga\ *uOa a.

M^aOr o<?9orWv\u y/\C vV ce WA Vke op(*A Va a ^eMfojV^xWcil'' bM ien/iAj YknA Ate iv\ea\s Ao AUckvrfA^ <?reis k\3 affiWafc? ariu-jAs, *-«a on^mt ou^kilay- Von ^7i u.sM^^'jbti^ilC^WaeA'i WjW U ^AkAeA^^xWAJ-ltee- ^re \V\ qII ^Hx We AA< oVwe3k^-? A Vo pcoo\Ve iaAcjAs as aAe- <fuAe oaA ekfeAxx^ QA appe\l<ifc(> c^Ve*^ oavV^A g(xjG^\ apfell Ai A-Ha -CtAAAs. . *rA«\ 4<^.;x^ \4a~\s TjV<AkA x~ecorA/Vk\3 a^j^sas AteVAkJUk*3 a-aasV Ak>fA Ate xnAigeA aA« cecorA A sAku'A <^c**pUW*S'^ Vo $j*/,A eoasv^qkoASoV k\s ckviAi .3T± q\ M^« As Axe S.ojprfi^e CowxVke\Ai>i AncMervGv^ ox; cKrc^go HoU U5. \vf 11«?^ CW1I ^ Ca^n ccnnoV beAenieAa xvretorA ox: w«xu<>A ^^\eW« ^ Vo ^m\V kvte ^^r corv'iAan^onO?

IaaA ^vA VoJpcfi^Tr^ VJ'^kkon qaA gtq^ vj(iiUv\ da.Wvs. jtA^\9^ ^a Oca^^ vvaJcoW^Vva Yke^reAc Co^V AvaAe cJUat^A c<^k^ gj^Yto s^e^-rxAAV vii^ftVx eW^vs vteV^pe <A cA^rvx avA «t«iui^s pr^ou^A vv'kA^. teaASCA{pV.^-ee Oro^Jir 3^au.s.CiVM^7.

ApQeWcAs Ope^A^ SrveC P^oC 41 d2 ^° -Ave WceAr o^Vatoa VoCc^xVon ©vA^ua^ o^ko/VA AkA ^A <*,- c u\V Vo StWUr \><cc piiT/v>v\A ^AjAAcAioA' Cq,lVon's AirceV of>feA Ax& aoVcorw poA ^,\Avn we o^aoaAs e^ AG H1k Aw^AmA- <dGOomxJ2 Sck'Uir £UAon {A<^a-^p\e\C oaA (ruA&U^A cea^A--^ ^eci ^oj> "JkeAter Vo <J\CaA oa ik- ^unckon, odoAs* ask- xJneVter Ate SxAIAa^ cAAle o^xmAj parVj f£ cel(A A A.eAveA uo\\\ oArx^'^k Vte .Ju^saYvj oV WJc. aiwtAiaoGA o<*rkf A xeKer A ax-<vxVeA -Ave p^aVA WxA caWxi*eV^s \s esyenkaW^ <vx orVm cjor~peiu'oj> S>6teVllr Vo prooxAe C^xVon «=t <~oi^le\e Ca A-SHtkcieA rG^f AOaA <? aevO GHj^eA V> cikkie *a*A x:eoorAke ^WAe^eaVWattes reW CmWa i'^ets ^ ^^Axf a. preexukn^ dute iWA^a He u.3.c^nsklAft>n ^3-ee.£uiAs VL^&i ,s«a?p<\\: G-<Ak>\ v=ni,/voiX jcSa^roi", Or<Y*^" V<-oqj\urvjWl ^uprq.-fb^ pet)^Oie^ reVe^'xS r\aroxo^V^\oreA Vo r ^ ^ * \ ^ utotakon o£cAkru CcasVAA*x<A WgAs cm^ V= ^r^tA W>e occuSreA<-G A iWparoUe Va JteAAu/e- cee I**. xj.^.Ci 3Uav xfA^A ^\\\ c\A C«aas£ sck\\l*r cv\y ce<A k«/"Ai.

As ^ ^«A^ax A\AVr,Ate ^oAAfc xaVaAAs. <Axx>a^ ^o-cWscr^A ky pAecVvAP ^^te ^n^kkAoA«l KojkVs (A <A\As r^e-vste^ S»ee. fctx' aeA v \\qqs. £<£S F.^^a?^ H~l7|4^lCs.0.STou>Qc l9*q)j S^cuAc*^^ WoaVb Ige^uC v (icwvfc ofTra' ^Vees soX ^.s^p n%<k<5o^<-A/-o.xn m°^ C£aAia$ Mn^ *4te <*vk'"^te pA>kc AWesY kes. \n Ate pcokckA 0Vwe GonsW-kteA<<l r^kk A^ x^WaVIV <***A!J ^Tke ^AteUWeS^ 'is aaA ^ca^^A 1©^ UiUa beio3 Ae^e<J> kAi c^nvbAAon^l P-araA te ^ Co/^UGt cxaA JAkueA -TCttAScApk oaA Iaax r{^ViA Vo a (w«.gm1Au( op<>eaL Ake ihtA\ A^£~va/A ^oTaAfces QccvWx<u AefeAioAV pu/teof a^ftA Op^a as oV ckjA OV-Va\A V^rrwA. Sa^Uo^Ai neCfiU^ Vo f-vA^-VWAc^al cl^€?m^j? oao AXcckx^ . See G^Abn 3SlUS,aVao."xVJc 3^pra>re Uw-AkaS ^\c5)C«,^ JeSaA \A "\S Ck Cr\A\A^l ci.ev^>A.«^\i acaSS Aro We xTecor^ WyA ^aJCeS (Vxy o^>f^\[akJi r*v\eW 'v^o*Mrt9AAl .Sj^ CrarAAOr uGql,(brAk ?^3 U.S S^>7f 3(A CW^^}, A\exAAA"xi9vA^A^A^ coa^vcr^ Cavksns ^ V9^3 cVcfirA^ are cwMU ^cteAcbbe.

Ox^V»We e^cjL^koActl oaA e^Vfaor^rsoA^ cvrcu^xAaiai ^w!/^ ^ c^|^ V<Aure A Ate sqsWi- C<uV>a lAas.b«^Abojr^^ ovaVo^ Cou^\ in'An aVVo^pAte ceA\kf ^^Wari AAAl-fea^canue. .jxicre-ifecVx/G oA Vte ^acV AkA We <vA- V^rs iAv>o\v>fiA Vx«/eiA (xao^ be ca^^AereA -^-AAeA aoW^W^l cV^cv.s oacA- Vons Oxrec^ A^peA oaA CoAo'AVion . lAo^eo^ Ank-^re te^neo«A keen a ^e^eco onAte a\&aAs oaA\V\^u^ wxMa Ake. -e<c^>\\on °^- bju'n? caa- r<z^r\^M cesol^A Vo^^r^ASe <loWA Gilt rel^.bj on Sck\ll^i aa\s- AefAVaA^s opeMA^ xlde^ pa^e 40. o£ So v- ceoceseAcAnCin <as we, V^vaAAa A^te. cxa-aW ,s-*ec<c.xnAA rtwVvav f. i^sr- ^*>7 oaA'^^Vx" ck\ 9.(020-^22. on V3q-\X ^cMl^ cccoaVs AVuSse -QAse •taAs rekeA or\ V^ -cTiAjjl (A\\ . S^e jh A"VW nA e.<ni-rU oaV Sik" qV p. MM^-M^I^'AVas Vbe \As\oaV CaU xs AxAa^sWA Vco^ lfUnneA<f *>ik*- 9V.eS 33biv^3A7MC/1S"l-3'4 ere *.App.Te*«nCa/!<* Xolt)(<-ouA SkAn^W^xe aiA^ ace xrv^o\y^.A v^*\V\n VIjSA'xeA^s -£<AeA oo\Vc<kral o^Ateclcs onkA <^°Aoicten o^o CvTe n*oV CxMAk QCkor\a\cijL oks^AV e*Va orAia<Yw ClfCUrvASXr<viUtS Sk^tjJi'o^ QCC(A- ^lAe £<xx\tAieoVAV4 s^Aa*a/- €>ec^M.se C^iA<m u^li te ^V^AAe^* is nok fA^eb Axv.<-©nWA Wc^Mte nis AvrecV appeal oA-^axsA \te VA cuouAk ,)u^/vv^ oa oa wv-o«vMplA£ reooo^ pre pare Ab^ an inoo~^AeAV oooaV ccporVr. CavVja U AkconWAA a^Ake <2oAaA<-e eA<A>kstes AkAte^ns A^ceA Q. fv-ea/viAjfA af^al te a>o -(kMlVotAfso^n^A aV~^s4 CsVA<M KeAAeA,"v3 AuconV*A Wkc,* rA-be,*ntounA ionQceA-lH Vnas avleeeA noVkAs VkA «x>u\A j^ikkf ciuil ceUerJ. fkek^lte^ V6 ke solely a\V\k^\eA Vo ^A\*r Ate <-ov*/A c«poo\ar Abo^e aa^wM **vUc a-pre^teten Vo CaVUa preo<iA\e^ g^xVoa Vcoaa c^xkas V^ovj^bu c*wkkA'xv\A Ai/nwW eWcvvS, S*4 C^AToU^'V^'aA p. XIS-2 2A OaA "<r<k,,<A p- HTC-M 8ST-- 6cx**U* Ate recorAs w^*rV«Aaing S.^ c\cAaas ^veo^VWA-Cr^VWAcecorA onqjptqk AVW^k *ke cet-ocAs, ^oxveVaaA^ ce^W a/\AAAv3e/Af sa^vA Wj C<uWu vlee cHLVjA.f1 *\V cA p. 2oM~Xor, xSk-^A, x^sr-aV? <vAN1V'A p mo-Yut, s^r- sm* , qq <?- SSl. Ate JnsWi\ Mi^ Jaot>\v^ Gcw«ro^eA\-A«M <^frviali /nAe- rUl AAv^«H?rfs«AVc,V^n VoAte AeWse.^Wk WAeA ^vU °^e<l.-rWAWs c*>uA coa reASon^H <-oncWAe VkA eAfAorAikor^ cvceu^sVAcn e*A as u>e\V as Vbse oocwpWVe VaxWe oS Jfte'^A^ k«s tec^sUvon U, cmW WskxWne GhvWa\s eAkteVooioA ceUek ^vVvOAe^AAU or^r Vo te iv- &x>ft* <uif>\^ WA CavVoA W pCoutt** * c^pUU *aA ^Qky'eA c^^. -<V*A v^tW <Ak>rA G^xVoa Ate ^pA^ky Vo ercs^kvs Sr^Ay v,oUW> o^A Med^ a\ appeal ^.IU^^^^uVWiAh -n ik^T^^ a^^ W^Aea. ^s^e A. c^.uol, W,v a2,k ->^X o^^^lk^A ^.S^sr-SM^X^^As^nv^^ <?7l f^ lo^,«WS - L^XA CvrM^CsW^ ec.UA ^acW^^VrnalVoAteA€We-A^reWA- cxUe u^vKi^iVi/ o^we WVU b^^ o^ Mut**** u>e\l o« ^c^xje/A-A *A \er(W^U^ C*wiVtoi. AJ^A-F'ec.scaAsd) preo^x^^ €r.M^xj^ o^WeCl^rA .A^elW^ opiiaw^ xlcxeV paje*lSok50 v>Owv-^ Ot-<U fte-ri^cv, "Jh« CcuW, *^VA ~ oaV-o^-^l -Oxa H«o* ^W." ~W CvUa *ou5VA Ca^ VcvaJ ,n WWMV^^

A\so s-tt CkVUr, v S.V<>W ci\i.\ A<V*m J^o, H:il-cvj-n^,«<--IVc.v)-'S«, s.-tA c(L.>oo\-l "vay'^V ?. s^o-sua aAi "^-fVdX car- <*a7- W o\ a^ttW ^,^X.^A aV ?.U- A^ V,oW,^S* 00,^ C^V, ^W vJ^ere ^Tu^e mcU^ n<Ae-^ «n VKc ^ctt\ iUiS, *ka\. V^u^s Wcfco4 pUfc t«ilu* «£ VW s^V<^ .Vv V.'jtM-^ ^* ^<M>^ £«cAs *t*e .VuVo^ ro.lV °S a S^^o^V •&«*& incxn^tWw -PnnapUs c£ n^W S*""" **«* <?aio l<m »i=> ukA) A re^sA &<- ^mtoW*. reUe-C (voices go.wA1^ «t^

/V,«VW-ot ^o<Jc» F^VU,^ C^U W^t\ VU. JW.WA U> "Ualn Ciuil fUtVve^ as. e*p\-i/\«^ ^^t -CiUve-C -cT^!^>_t A-ocri*" J-«. g^^ll^ i<eone^^ V/ Affe\\^ ^Wg^AojE^r -<ke Vc\aV GoxxrV ecce/A W aoV ceopAn^ Vte cue Vocjoa/xAv-CA- WA cWivu A cT$VA oSfVke AJMMn Aw*a^A Go^pWA \^A^)A3kwkj Ale AP^SxAOaV Vo AteLpcktiA Anai\WkA«: OAoAxAeko ovW SooqV\V \e^x*e Vo cwnCaA <**^ Vtece «-oaS f\o, 3Vxa>->A$ A surprise or ^f^M^vcJL $>WooA<A xA^Jl^A ~(te StentWA c( \teove*-o oQ a~TU<A GovAs pteA«vA ocA*r or xVvAle xAA<A ecue a AacKVbereolir \$ A>u$e oV AkueA^n. i*e-3-o\nnv>n 7oOi^£ ov ^Cl. A,c gUrtAenV -\k<AxA<a\ CoA akM^eA xks A^<jA\on W ce-tA'A^Aio cecorutAeMk ;sxA<^\enA In k^A cA G<ukA JoinAk A^xeAAeA C««$WA Ak«A ^*xs.-G\e^ oa s-XH-K' pu.r$^oA Ao \ckfi. ooxw/a rAoilkojrcvAle.TVve S^ce*^ Cj^A orecAe-A a ipecUcA roJdb&r prUoAftr-i vJk-o &\p papers b-{ fAetfl .iee ikMsWi \jUcx- ^67^-U^, X74-7XpC(<r SO) A ^fose orisonA qo^uzi are Aee/wi^ &leA AonAk^ are A^reA oo«^ Vo pv^on ox^xkuAs . 3ee ^^r\<ir\) GAqas. US"Saos^ W*A, U>%^i CTe*xoo4) cvkUTAAVV&b onA. ecx^es cAeA • XV \s» UAAAAOuAeA -\kq\ CaVVon WrxeAkiJ; A/.AAb A^jla^cA CAcipkM oxaa Vo ^xx^oac^uaVs on s-x<\-ir* 3«ecxx vjoV.l l,Wa\ p.sjG> ^xia^^-. t^fl , AsVnVs $Cth>£ AAA^eS Ae^r UvknA-^^citeAJ.^ A^^ie^ GtwpWA ootr Vo pJUOA cvfkaAs on S-XG-iS'.iae JC c A p«i^b--Tkis x^oca Aeclq- (^akon *>VAiV\£ W^e -tiVin^ A**^ o-Q S-x^-\r A«AUA -He WaAi/i Vo saAUn\o prox>e \ke aowpblAoAk^ ^likj. ^eeCqlA^ell i/AwjmA 30F3<* 11^/^030^ CvV \<\<Hj- WM\sr i£ i(te VAA CoxA- W*A a ^sVoa oor»a/Au\s VtekweUkess o*t VkG-VAAs A-SnA Cor^WAA»Akan Ate CauA sW>m\A kauG <^aAucATi* anexA A^ko/W kertAA^ Vo pJl/AvVAke Co^rVk Aa<*Va2 q £aAuA-Gao^S Ao WeoW- Vc<*tm ^^ ^ sAkAeA eox^AeAkcw^ ste^A^ bn J«ke oppos^ pckrVf. S-ee FSn-e vj upolkA Co, <tV*>fx;* ^S, WCAAkcir ma)*^oX*^ Vi<A couA AxA <A V<wsk Vi^ue acoipW^ cmWu alU^Aocx ok we s-x^-ir-fil^ A**l? ai VcuG.j=r^.qV n„^1 ^"CkM^ Vke s-x^-tr -CA^ ^«\e ^*as Vwo Aa^ bek^feAtekxaV cowvViSivieA As orAer AxS^'vssvaj cnxtens cW<v\S o.^0asV £cJMUr_s.«e c<v\>dVI p.»4^0. ?br cew/M UAbe\CAO^nsVAo C^x,\oAJAe/j«AJrtn Go^pW;a\. ^^ (voV-^leA /vw^eA uaVxI xo-xs-\S .34ece\JcKA p.MS?,Ate^xn o<k ^cotekikkj s^b oo^pWA^^^ n oV oorxsAwe Ab^ Ave cWA or> ^A -iC ornA nk Voc Ate\ oa^Ua, tte \V 1x>e te prese/x^A -foe xopcjAV^ c*0\<O ftx V^VV ot C^Wxs o^eAwx Vo jrt^e, CoxaaV ^leA QA/V -^oc^^ceAVoVVe bo^koA 7-<^-ir-3JLeciL.xjol.i?^v- 0j74/\ANe (x^Axon x»as. kro^k\ VoWeCov^W ^Wvkon bx< c^iaWxs A<^x»a^ A \eVW £ocsoov/Ae;A Vo We. Co*A Aa*v*A\a.s We GouA Ao c^jie on saiA oA\*n> See :*aAA^.CA\joV. pAvxO*ArtG. \«u-& ou<us. bco-^kV Ao VkeuovArVs aAA^A, Ate cakaA cekuxeA Vo cxAx qa«A c^vkon oVjec\eAVoWeGovA\ rekiipl oa4 pre- ^qtnaG^ We vssxje kor oppe^l. 3*4 xoA? 33.1 / Gc^^A xj"TeVr ^W-03 ^ i^7/ 44<?- SO CTe^App 0>p\te^ D-OUnO'pek) AuuAvtn^ cvcq^eAAxj AteA cx^Won "vo oArw\s3 WAgp Ke\A on bAtC ooas c\ Vc'vaV, xaj*u\A AAaxye A rxeusscvi^ ^r Ca\Von Vo s^e*- Ve^x^e Vo e*^A K^S Oo^WA or* S-X<V |C cJUU/i xS wjVxvf Oh A<vi pcepovTifA W*X OM>k^fof XesxjG \o ct^JU\k kii ^le^Axrx^ OaA £or^cx/^e& A^e iov^Vo Ate CooA-on OrlCAC 3ee Xn^-Sup().CCUvjo\A p.U-l'fc. C£ .Sos^q^ v/ A^cVop^VvVaA ictO onA-LooO Asa1 n "~iS\3^oXa HVI^iOC Tex 19*1?) C<^>A cWocViLa? ^^o^TA^A bearing as ~CVA "£°r p-^ote* <A TW.axkj.G xos)« CaAoo .soxi$iA le<<o-P o4 GouA Vo SAe k'A AJinVk Avoa^A Gon^pJa)^ os *ooa cm ke tes-«u>\e cLuo^re o-P jvyeV^A \j2.a\rexjjas AjifiA-cA» xAk\<Jn^oeu on Xp-i^-ir Aicixis vte Aol*c? c^iW) xreouvjeA Vke U-viS" orAicr ^U^ss^ni kAx. tbiwi ag^xsV-ickiU^JeeJMoJvpf?, c<i-.vJoV p^^rO^U^ov^A skuc,uV^V^V^^-<Axaq| nokcft -VteVAU-fkcV* C-oAtekeA A AVe (v>^>kon~o A^ttA& o^eJ>v>oofA Vo ^A^aT Ake ^L/*Ute o£ p*rja/y -JX^A V7."1Ws G^km lo-ir-iC recJpV Aafcj? okAte_ toA-ir°cl*r Is -^cteslaaA e^^vdcA- oAA^xAXsWosAte IasVA caseJJco^A "Gru<tfe^e" A CAVWxcan cWaa A^xAVkA covatV ste^ s^A<ua WA<AAte.Vf<al cjooA aWieA "vVs v\l- .screkoo ^o ce-tuse °"M ^^sxAviroArvoA, o^Ate aj^vxa A^-^AcA Gj^UoV.See 6ue- Ce^xXG xjnVv^sn qS3SwOXA IS^i 4^3 CTe^.A^f e\ Paso 19r7V"C)vMrVsV»Vnj In a AAC?AlA S^^A leavje A couA VtAVe Ate A^AeA PA^Aa. uiAtub se- vjeA A04s. A Sy^^^-f ^mo^^«mV ke<^tn^ /A^ellAi c-o^»o^ell kc«ue cicuWx&A We Coo-A «Wn^\Vx A\x^rcV^*>A bx^ ceWinj Vo cooi\A(ir Ateo^LAUci pckkai bejc^xA^e op^e\l^s QoiVeA \o ska-o Jur^ie ^r o\kor ^e^MAiCAy^vkeCeurkoo-eAV onko sV<ite V<u>«AAse A^eVVAs f>e^er ce<jx^jsVeA leox>e o^ oourV te-kleVte Ov\«^^eA pekkbOtVkeY Veiled Vo nvJlA Vte AWsAvo\A rt^V^MAo(lTes.. d.c^» 9.0>3 Lcv\A AW Ax aI CoxjaV xj^^ ^oAJo Ai AvvxreVxon Vo x^eWe cx^ consi - A<i/Ak>n. cA Vke tvAen^eA pleAk^.J+r^^ A^>1- "TA^.xI.ax).p. U3\e U>1 AW^JU ^ 9<A\'aA pank^ PorVies Ano^( a^enA Vtexc p\eaAvk^3 ;Ce^poAA V<i pW^AAxaj on ^l-eo^ oA\a^ parVes a^A ^\e 3^cAn oV\nQj^ pleas cu Ak^ Anay A€.iice ku £\uxo A^I\oa^0^a^ €c\A paje^bo^^O A o.oicVi p\eaAv*oi ^^^ Ate GWvc <A s^cUVnvG cxs noV Vo opaAA^os a ^3u-rox:Ae\-o AVe opposWe (?°A(W pcoovVei ^qao^ \pU^bjs^.sponm^r p\eas o^x>e^JV^rkkbJ' v-o\Aaa\V> Seu-inAa^ d£ Vte A**ce gVVuaI GrVk*re- AV*T i oc a^Ur iuOv kxA-J*- °*£ f^^ be oroQ/eA \>h Vke A^Aft cm^v M^'K^e/ 3kail be Wti onl^ oAkrVe^^o^ VkeA^JGu okWeA, AiOde^Stetf ke S^QAkeA \m VkfiA^?* cvAess AWe \s n sU^^ vk<A SMcMkkn^ x^U\opar<^G ^a 3xj.e,prke VoYte^asAe pa^kf« x*£n^a,c^(\ U>3 Te^s Cooa\-S V\Qv>G cooaWaA Vke ce^^eAks o£ x^e^ xA-fa^or cAAte rxabVVo a^enA.3e€ G^et^ ^s*^^ o*qxo3. OAce a paAf ee^Ai Uax^cAcotA Vo^Ve an<w^eA pl^A'xA? ^Akio iexj^Aa^oVWl,** <*iA Wxs ao Avxcrekon V> ceW *ke a^eA^eA pxeqAinS «aUu Ate 0990.1^ narkf A^ncasAc^ss VkA wntAir ixxcotbe c^dux<v (reiulV/oruAless We^^Uojle^ Ax ConVox^s ex c\Q.x^ C*ojijX oQ- acAon orteWe,uki(A cQAloe cxa>I - tteS pce^uMdal on As Vace.3Ae ck<^AonA Cka^O vTeyQi SqaA oaA CcavjeVGo. ^AO^a^^A (pUU^S'CTe^W^^xi^^^C^ **** c^uaseo^ <*c- Vvon oc^VeAse cen><^ Vke o^AeA p\e^iAj-CaeAA^ prey^vaql koVke. op^A* ^^^ 1Cfl^W> ivjLQjeA^ AWAVke 0*90^ p^k( o^sk okjeckAo Wve avhenAec (?l<Ax<x_$ oa Vke bas\s AWA a .s AAoaVx/G cjW$e k^s bee/\ AnaAe^ See VWAxn 0\A<wW\ s^7-s^>^ WjSIVSG Cre^mo) IxkUloj A\A no\ rr-o\^ Vo Ac<*€ ^Anovte qa okjcAon AqT sW4 ur^tAe ,-0^ Vx\A Cou^V ^xV <vA \s.soJl «n or Aer sVxV-va^ -VU AAaMa An^A^A c-o^pWA.-xVe bxA/Ae/t ok skoxA>V\j .s^piAse or ^re^uAvOc vs onAte_p<Af CesvAxA^ cwxenA/v><A *-X: A«V s^.^TWas SOAlv k<u ^>c4o4^ <*AAJor -WeA AocrveeV biAwAoA. G£ A-ftr<vx AnW.r/.cv >\Wen vos^ift U9, *3(Cl?y im)C^o\V<Ag AcWqaVs ^\e^ Vofx^JU.A IoxatAqa-Vo^Veq^U pro^ lt/v>AA*n ^e^uue VKjl^ Qre^ttAVeA no Su-a<a<*^( ^a"bo$«xeAA proo^AbA\AV^ ^<ue <^q- A'xuA V~t ?teAk^x rwnj / o^oIaA q^A ce<\a.t*fa$ ok^ ?WaVA Ca VU ^ekknj A Qle^AiAO asieAx<xQ q nc^> o^uxe okaekoA *•<>** <voV rv^ye A ote^uAv C_x<A a.s^x rn^vW o^Va^O \o Vte oqqA^ poa\v^ *3ee 3WM <3aro£TfevjAS \j V.v\paV\cVL ^7«ASxOj;^ br U^sr* CTe^s^iA -AVe v>€aAtA^oA<xi\ be eo<?te4eA \rK W\e ccn^A oA Vbe r-ecocA okVke eA^re caie^A A ^r*-^,-Ax^ AAV Gout\s error vs c^o^^^eA dx>e Vo Vke 0^1^^ ia^WA G^AWu ^ vwA k\^ Cuv^A Vo ck ^o^eA^ A^e^l xx)cis vjIolAeA, vte A/^+k A^i<wA Cof-^\^A conW<x^ We <WVLarxju^vA^ Moiu3. ^w U<nAj -focVjrs neUUfvy P1 V-O -SuAoivA Vk\i \e3Ql Vfsa<ocH - S-ee Wo. Co^-pWA C\XxMA p,s^o-slX pAra^copkS X3%-\MA- AJdWa^ AoaAxa9 W^L Vib-VuViV^ C-ouA* xj\«^o 9^>^e o\e«Av(\$iAUce^>reieAW*A 9\^aVxA\ ore aoV re\ie^o e>V VkttAr oIoV^VoaVo cAxe<\C -SuAkuoA -QacV^ Vo Sx^poA a; ^a^Kx^JL \C «<A cWaa -SeATV^Ior ^ ^ooV.s A onAUoni^c X5K*fSAn<*,3T% CsMaGvc XooO.)/ A\som Oteu*A- V/ xJko^o vjX^ VXA X<n, 3oXf.^\vACxr\9lo^(ox>e proccxs ca/vke AeAieA A fl/uy ^^xXoaVxA reWAAxVx. okXkeAppcA^q process. ma*AA*n£ antfu£SM*-«Ae- \<>H vAW^xWa^ We A^olaso-vo^ «A\esW^ reasscv^ {W*te c^\eteno£ cca. apoe\\o3c* cecorA}^ <V4 ^>"A ^j^Aonko Vvd\A *kA Ave fi^Var AcWiare pcek&^A since i<te <;eovson,s Voc eoAsVuia^ o<\oe\ldy AeW<s QAolo$oui Vo e^Axx^s ulaAqt 9M\oiftS yVeS^AkA^/*^ ^kk VoAS9eAjTei<A^rc<A;3o4. furVkar feat«uie A *-oau manAakoc,-| Voc C«^\kor\s pleaWo^s Vore- •CVecV VWtVkU ackon <>*&$, Vor pro-ip*ckx>e \A\uAckx/ereVxe£ 0^0- no\ <a*M^ uxv\- AoirA^ oV oaA oonAuA Vo -enkW* c<aWx Vo CA^/icte>e ceUet. OvlVon jx^A SdbAW" un/A-aT Sl<Wi -£>r 4V\,cee AuYlfjA cWaaS te-G^ for VAyA$ Vo o^eporecAc &V« a co^plelGsecor^CaA G«aWA cp^l b<A.j ceso\,u^a@nAk<A Vnuy^bAG ee<-ocA oa^G} Aor- Vke wb<AanVA Aete/ o£ a /*JaM*$GA A?pe«l,Uecevfc\A "*W«\ 9. \qq, Isq-asU GAA^^teV p. qs7, -&WS3L PcA e^ooiure VovWesal coaVucA &*e& rA \n A^eVt ste^ <* **e**A case or conko- vj^rru ce^VxnP V^wacVx^G ceVxeli \V uAaCU>-vp<vx\eo b^ ^ conkWnf r pcex.eA <*Ao*/je -eUecVs. 3u O'SkeA 4i4UA <A H^s-<?^» <W on$otA\j i^bA<wVxol ceWAAxon A a <vnWax^I<\X*A confers, a*\>\% <\^fa*Uy,j Vooe\xre s^e^-i -sIaul G<Aon -S^Vo^Akec kxsAi«A^ ajAo. 0$ Appeal on s-xo-cA< iJLe c^ooVte^^k'AV <>.x-i^ qaA^tVA ?.sn .An^A^Us CaVWi <C\$W&<*nW Ate WWaK A^^AajA Are <udaVvwa* Vo loexjifc- YAeA -CocujcwV eA c, A^LQAA^^kl Aee^-See ^ ^ qsTf^oiVi^ CueWvJL c^Ve^ Appe\l<fM ^tV^sot b-\0 -/eo^^ exon^\xreJ,-we^ocW^ ^WtOjA^xoAi \n Vte Ay^aVk A^aAee Coy-p\^a\ i^VaiA Wxare \i Vke conk- a^m'^j vpr«seAV cv^^^Ase ekfeA-s rs^uas,^ \o ^ooj-voaV xNnv,tvnckx)e^elxe^, 3ee GvVvoAA *' ^Ak'AA p S70-SQ par^ropte ii^-»4l • \Axe xcA<A<me xs. <?z*X\\u A\^^^\s\A«Vte-Cc^^ ^x^^^Vi^11 cvxA Ak\s CoiaaV con x:«oxs,0~ vn«-bV| AeW^Ve oaA eontUAe AkA Wx^L skoyXok^vG keon 5^<vv\gAoa^ We ooxA sVvouVo W^xrG cec^n^AqreeAVi ^aA^^CAk K VvjkV 0t*U o^H\ A^QA^eA Go^\^A- &ec*Hse C<v\k<n ioa^WV Ufty^ Vo o-sjiaA. VteA<W .

A^peWcAVs 0^$ ^e«- ?*je « ^ S° r> See Oo*v\\t\t>v/ Qro^ceuWr* c_o^\V, •v^.V. rc^s. u>, sus^ii. ^w^-m ere*. >Vpf. A^iV^n xxidO, peVAeoJ C^eY?j-„viAiflJ AV^V ^oW*-re We VvqV Coat«V d\& n^oon- iv^nj" ctMeA^e^ pWaMn^ o^,^ \e«v^«. Vo -G\£. v^ooii ao\ <re^u*i\£^ /a»iaiAe<i

boW\ \epw-S-Vo ck^QA^ cw^ S^p\Awe/v\ V\^ Q\eq^WjS ^^^u^i^ A-^W Co~^WaX oaX $.^p\^e^ V W* Ah^W> A~sAKe£ Con^pWoV.

Vo WWV ^ p\e^^l v^*x 4U Wp\o*M Vo ^ *,/i*> A^Ud uo^A^WAW allJA Vo aU* V>is ^WaV^W^W AAoA A. «**^ ^ ,rac^ o^ WlorU* hlW fr.^1 orWi Vo'vVi UVHV\5 **fc oovAA Wtcroue* ova\ YK. w.ai W p\**A vfN i4 or^.^^^ ^ x^C«.Xn,U <m*. A\to^ e-%. ^*j \««* Vo el** o^fc*- ^1$ Vo <eu^l.r Ai ^V<j^ vo W^VV ox- Xk*-VxVtX^ &\*& Xj^oVU A^AeA G©-fWWr-

An A?C*W<5M UA^ reox&O <>£ &\<vaX U»«r& cuVinj oa <v*te*-V* GoniaXe-i. 1^i^3A 1H ,31*7 CT^iOOaj

7T.VA«V —W ^ -A - W A* px^pecA^ }*w.d** **(*«- AVlfiA ^^x^xa.S. SXAtSHI-1^ <A<*V<)A<aVoa ^*rek( s>oa$\A vnxwAx^ A<??A\<A\ 0^*vvn^ftr\cf pa^eHqofS^ l ce\xe*c £tQ<n Ate,^A^e4JSeeCvVUol4l^-^bf' l^-Wk aaA Mlk"1 A p. 4svMS<?, A pWnVvA rxAco^ sVoaA on bU ^WaA^S iA \ke k<*U_ ok A. <>\e<x Vo j^o<te- A\on xAAVessoA^ ^aVA <* oouA UW^^ AkAVkJt (teA. Is /wonUnMus, 3eeCoAf oVGaaa^too *J &so^n ^oiwo3A sq<5,5s-<? GTeS^ooX) ^^Tn \(^Ao£ -He CoAk OAOT AeW^A/X^ AteA VVjLAA^jei ^>VeA U>qS <v^«n\Vor\XiMS,3eeGAv Uokl fMO G<*aW\ xs enWleA Vo <=< c^a^A te A^xx VA nAe<vAiVi£*See "Xe<QS AqaAoa ua\xj s^i. v fcosee^We a"S3 i^sA^ss^3c' ct>*xoo~7X

xjoAeoA^ pce*As.es o=»As\AereA ,caikn cespA£u1k{ pc<^ cvA rw<>x>esAlif£ G-oorV Vo ox)e«rale Vke*k\A G&oA orA«-rs. A\frH\ss\Nn3 GalW!s dcWto Q3<A\A OefeAA<vA<» ^x>eA Uirexcv <*^A orA<u-^\ke causebe reo^ieA cxaA cenaAAeA cxao \ke V<~xAl ke orvVxireAA1 t\Apo\VA oau/vsel, CqiWi ^Aker A^ooe^^te 6<>lmA &*c a cGaaoaA ko AfocA ColWv an oppoAoA^ Vo A^eAAkiA. pleq- ckVx^XoAten CarVter A^oxj.eS. Vbis CouA Vo OrA^^e,W«l GouxAVo Css.xAje.CV pre\i(wvV\*v^ m^u^ckon anA\AsxAe oa e^aiVakl^ ocA^4*T<Aenja*fls defenAatks evvi MvojI VtexV <ack in prVvAV xA/tH^ Vhfin +"0 9^>"*o* cvl-Usx c? cx/wiukG <Mi s^v^U^A recocA r*-wck oa AoA-oxVAWC^3p^€ql ^ wl^liAe. £<n'A re- CorA.* T^vaaII^ CAlten <vx>oxjes £>c any oaA oU oH^ar reUer aG^^YJ^A be. e-nAvWe Vo- oexiLralk^b>^ \c<oo onA e^AVy /">keVk*j an/u^x, o^: .special/ ke <\Acu^be eAklte Vo vaaAxaWs ^Ab^s #nA fke e^fAncG ik^aA

-Xr/AWwf'C^Vk^^K^^1?*-^ iVi^auaaUA oA^kles ulA,(k-re^x>jon (jxvAyTTx. k^e.bH auA^ ua^peAgxk, <£ per>u<V^ Weo(A^ ^s Vc^/xJLA aw+o pruon c^oAs b^ A^ik^ W(j^e jn vteA'^a a^\W in<t posted pre/xnA qa- x^clo^e aAAre^A te Vke^HvO^eV co^AoCAppe^k /^A;pnHASVdW i^AG.

Sua w\si\1yW^kiT<.7^70l oniHVir, .. ^eoJaAon \kvVUT afiJLD^vl,fi( CJdcw^-

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.