Perriott, Ron AKA Ronald Kevin Perriott
Perriott, Ron AKA Ronald Kevin Perriott
Opinion
1: =\ f "' »// \ _,¢¢"1 ' / ~_~ /_ v ap .
1 /' 'z.;../» ‘<» ‘z’>?’.~’ / .cj£»i’//y,,< ’/6`/¢ /4 / 1 . `/ ' ,~-“ " , ., v , .~ ,/‘”/4,. /#z‘ .¢_';,,-z//;/lp»’/,,£{b/~,f'/ (//‘/»1) /,f ;/;f~/// g_///__',"",¢;,,é§ ~‘:"-:-"' A/~ /1’ m n .... /. , /' . _,<//¢. ,,r,"»,€_¥,/ ff ,//I q f ¢,. q_¢ ~_.... . »\’ ,/,¢/>],'A ( ,,,;..\» »..~ '~ w 1 ./ _r" {.J""" ¢_,WJ" ii ) 7 "r, ."‘-,K< . . '/. _ / ,~\=~...: 1.
1 UJ l ""' /W}""' //<':/'/"‘1@'? ./ //" ’/. """ / ' //‘I /// "‘ f .v? _,/‘F /»‘ .. //; /'/'/ _ /'.'" If/ f j _/ "' `.'//.‘ -‘ ,.. . f . f _ ,,'“r"/, /;,/ fl t/df¢ //£Z”/ ‘1}5(/{/' }\/ // , / k ,)' . , » 7 f v-~"’ er 1 v ,- '"' . "' 5’§" “'¢." ~" /’ "F ,.1/ ,/'-,'z',", . , 'l , ‘. »": / ._,~.~;.' '¢ ~~~~_ / .__ _ ___,. ,,/"` /<_b, h / /,;.. l -\; ', . . ‘1" n ,;'» s :- - ..-a' } l ..
2,» ~ ._,, , / /,",g»'//¢,'#{, . j[,,
`/ .'r"r ‘? "3 ,/"’ /" /'"/',' 2 _./ /A' ';:;"7 /L_:`F»? w » »/ /"" .. ,¢ _ . ..} K ) fpc ,/:¢\{*’ ///-j`- z/j
.»»~*‘ . /" _¢ ap /' ` '_ /"'" /.//:/'/ § 6./ l W,, J, /.
This:.document contains so_me WMW¥ pages that are of poor quahty at the time of imaging. . .r "" " » .. x y€'/:: 'x/;€‘;//»' / » ';-‘/ _; '/".q ,5-~ f / ..-J.-r , ~.__ l f ` 1 ~ ' - "" ‘ .r",- " ..» //,.,.:: .w.~/. ,~ ,/ §/1§',?. ‘ .»' 4. w "»-...r' / » /.7` ,. r”' /f'/’r / v 4 ,..; f /,',.y y of ¢ ¢ _ /" HE©EWI§I MN COURT CF CPIM|N/A‘L A®PEALS SEP 2 3 2015 At@@iA@@Sia,©Bew< , ¢*9/"/3!!’/ %/,¢; /LV,¢?,¢¢/é’,¢">,,y," ,);’3//:2 2723/if }{,4//&{ -._:,.;v' ' "`:"` ' v w ' 52#’;6;7
/3222@221222;', 222 222 . §§@§/_ @ _ ;1'_'.‘~.€ §%2:¢2#22222, 2222/22 .312'*’&°5`22»» FOURT°FCQ'M'W 25):‘5§5§5; /BZ,FM)’/"?Uf;¢ozmv ' ' * ‘ 11 7"'22*2 ~~ 555 33 2015
l 4,<,,22» 252/2222 245"4`€2222225 j 255545#‘“5 "%SW 55§§,©11@2 25/2#2222:)22 223/_2W 2222 M/%.¢AA/M,/H?/f%# /7{/%¢222'2~243 ..»¢~ 2 2222; /~2-1 634/22222 //?22¢ v 5"'“5;,["/¢:~`5/ 7;~'2?»/'3’47 %7"'2¢.¢"' f§p/§':¢/ /£’f,££?////J)FM/!¢"»wf/ 5.//2:2'5;';.2/2,,2 ". "-'>~ / /<7/22{2/3,2;,5 ??`5~1’25 ;2)2§"2",2” 2; 222 2/22 2/222 ,2‘~»:2%2/ _ _, /}'!/5‘*’ M;`¢ :7.:£/2{2@?22’?”5’2?20,3¥22;22% '7"";,)’,3§".? v` ~:`.-`T” 5 4”/5?7 2.§'2§‘“¢/2,/¢/2§/¢¢€422/ 329/222.)»//2/2£2- 2a »"m""r"* ‘5* 51 . ~ ._. ~ » 2 222 2 22 ~ 222 222/72 222 /§67/ , ../ 2#!/4,?22 :£',7; 222/4214 f/r/$»'{ {/'.`~"~/Z,{’ ,¢/ 42 “/A; x 242/)(/2'§'; 222 //)’/2,¢ fA:x¢MQ/W’ /’/)// /23’{"/’2'/' §2""'[", ` l ,/"2.5~;‘22/ 2/,2 ,22/ /2' 221 2422222//~.» /., ,,// d » .,& rif/22 rfW/I// 242 ..s'/?/W¢:’ ffr'/,“'/.~¢' 2/‘ 342/2d 244 //1)'/ ’2?"¢2/ `”j// 4 &Q//,;#c ._ : /" '_ 140'/»='{"{21 /O")'/ "é»// 2224/2 2215/22 222 2/,51;2 ,222,¢;22 /'j _ /c'z,,~ 242ij /¢r¢é%#»f/_ 222 545/2 544/202/2‘.2/2"4%'~'2?2/2 2555/l 722,2‘/53'// 1222 ..2 :;,2;¢2214.:2 /,¢Z@z.»:?€#?§;é 2%//;/,£1,2,24'2¢22"22'2 1242 257/ 2120/24 M °/ ?’2127`22 //2 242/72442222 '2‘//" 242;2/21/ ///Ab~¢y/W 555 *2-'»”// 211/52 22;} 2422/2222 2 4 2452 /_/" ,'/ /)5‘¢§'5"<-._//~ "::"27}£4{(2’/5: "4>’.~1%:;5 /2’, 221/fri (L;’“#f»¢é 22 "')" %‘W' 524 " 5 2715 /:/2:'/! ,22_/“' 2222 /`// ._/_)2/22§2/ //2‘ />M"ff’ 2""2'2// /X J!"?"",S¢’!f&/ .;?,/3@_;-' .7_ ‘2., /,,:;/: 27! 7/! ?M/;:’;£S/*!W 2242/2274 A,D,»W /,'2;22/’,0’ /%¢"” ,47%//>/2’///.§"2%¢'@ ,,4»"./{2;: fw¢~'/’f/ °
2522 2 2222{22/252222~2%. 222 22224222252/2’§/».5222v 2'2'2“"22
232/22 . /W,/,, ._ . g 22/2/2/
%//N/p&k/Aj /11""//// / / /2///‘7§…" 27//;/22 /!/ _2/{7){¢///
` "52’~"/7'.22)'/." /5"//£'2 /Ir?’!%¢#kk?#¢'¢f,_?,:," yB¢ A, ;/; 2/2;{~ '/%/_Adr,z?£/A ,2 /"/)// 044/147 .4 5 4 v 7¢122222//2/ /¢f//¢I/ / r~¢@¢w?Z?/m 0/52///£22/22'/.2)¢/55 s -'///'//f`/~//y/a/_ }///#>1¢[22>2; /Q/,;€¢.';, z v v l t tr : }/pd 213 5 ._ 4/2/ » 2 25 W/,j 22/22.//,"2/ 214/f 2473 z /_,
2222/2422)'.,22.2’. ’2/%/222/2/ 22437¢`¢2//2'2/2'/2'<' '. b 5 " d v 244 62?@ 1 5 _ » ` . ‘
.`\\\: _,2 //¥?,2 /,‘2’2’22.29 2 ,2:%», 7122 222 2242/2 /2;’2222‘ 2/ % 2222/2222 4»#/!£4/)‘¢"»'/// MJ_Q:»~,»///»¢{ 7/ %22,<///222/22/ 02'2<22' ////¢é//¢mrd 75.;___ 4/ /222/2?»2% .£22_2?///./ ‘2'?' 2'-2°?"7 . _ /2 ,/f)» %/z): ,é»*/#f 2227////22'24$/ 4 7//2€/ 2///.; //’22/,‘7¢ ,//?"?'/¢/Wf»i¢§ %".2»2'2//27":’7*’£ &('5,2/: %//»"/?44/7;/2£ /J/”/ %’42‘¢‘/?/ /;§ 756/329 /¢z// 7/¢/%/..2'7{/¢//~7% 5__/€‘1//%/2. /2;2 '2¢’// ”~);{¢2@ 252 ¢/2,2:22)-»222¢2/ 9 v 5 2222 2222%2224 "“/£2£¢/¢“ l
4. 535 M §/{y/Y/?¢/>z:c , ' /?jn;;*_/ ¢€Vf%”c€/ér//Z@fr[;fr /'$¢?.,i¢i ///?> é"/€ /?z/¢ / ~/Z;¢ 2 %¢/rww/; /'z/c 6 /'33/!/%¢/; /Z’C 5 9_/}%/0,¢/<’; MJ/M '/’fa»/ /§;Zé YF(*’MZW/:c /’#¢zel
gen .;¢rv¢¢/c?/I/) f/T< L¢“F 7’ l /;/ 7'¢/ //':'¢@/r?’ 9/%.,7/1}6//¢¢ /F/W/r,¢'/w?’f/i /?/»¢f , _Zé//i/;r¢% ry />%¢'l/ /1¢}/ /Y//r/¢/mf 75 754 .j¢:¢z/<, <>AJ. )n¢»`/c'/,;/A/ /5//5/§¢'///@'/MFWJ//zrd/z7éo x¢/./i/ /¢¢/Eaca/ /7¢ //¢¢/?//?“¢/ %’,/7}¢// 775/ir é";"/.r“ //,'f¢e/c//% _ W/%w'<m‘ `;."'Z¢ /&/J[`w" ja /hLLJ % W&/l¢//,/f/£r;£/ /éc/é/?{ /p)r/Z/¢/@¢/ 572%5 7 ,¢7/¢’¢/¢ /%¢h-';%’ " 70/.3 /7/¢ _HW/ ¢/FW W"/% #M/le% 779 ` y \:JT/c:/_¢€ 57%1‘_7/&/%7@4,- JAZ§/¢/(%M/é/%¢,,é `/}//? /,;? />-//?/w////hz// 53 z¢ ,/,2////£» 7¢?¢1~ 7.):2@7
&//,//% ,~;¢//¢é,//», %'F/m/W%»¢¢hw;é %/M/ Y/H;M /'¢//?/{'7/¢//¢ :~ §”'5’%" 750/0 {7//%//»/,4~//¢¢ viz ” %/%/éz/ ~ %W% 7@/; //~/y' ¢W/ w% dr//,_/Z¢%/%¢¢%@/ W%/ Mzw>@~ %W/,@Mz AM¢@%'/ _ 5;/%‘ 7/{ /z 744/1 /é¢z/(////>§ZA@- 776 ////My/ %W 97¢7 LZ“ 5‘/%//#¢ %%//¢/F¢///cém§m; 3200 M»,/.é’w; _2;// i"`%'{'/A//*?'Bj/ W//%/»¢AM?»/yw¢/¢?%sz%/%}Z%/d/(”# 754/717/</,%»¢,%@
g£/¢cf 4/'
/ L .J f § / d' y @ // /L /5’ if "`""/é . /1€ ff ja Z(' ..: /7€ 777/6 ngfa/’ cz/.W/¢z/A/< 7;721771; ._MM__ ézI/YA'ifa/'?f 251/777 1/;?721,/' 221/1127 gm /&»UWH j717z’(71 1072222'/('@2(<’,%//, 1115/117715 ,f/V/&éz /1 Q/;QZ£Z?¢ ('79'//¢22'7)/ _ 77/%/@_7_!/~170/£¢ FI/ZQZMLZW /ffi/ M¢Z'C_Z/;/¢M;Y/ _L[L_ gm KMA@E &é¢ @ ZZ¢ZLZ 5&@/ %/7/71,_2§/171;¢ _ who/75 151/771 ¢~7///// Q£/ 1725@71/%¢2£/;711;@¢ Z'Mé/ d&£; '7 /¢1»:75/17¢%/77’/@7¢/4£:;%§¢ fi//¢g£;/J/;@_?@zé)é) 1 ' . ~- 1/. ,;.,/2// 727“3,2/ §2§)@ , (Z¢ // / &Mz/¢/g/W / 511/%;57/47 () //€//c¢€ /'@/¢17 711/r1 7/7'0/%/.¢/%5!/`;7%/ 1111/1/ / / 557/117 '///( ~}/ //1/71£ " //,2`1// 7/712;77{721/¢11 7)»&11¢4;7/2'11 7//;%1_ 177772§ 777’)2:/_{ 5714»:)>9 5 2"/¢ 777/0) 1 `/;7/ )%52§§”771/wj //' /1`2,75/7§ %_711#27‘% 15 77//7/5'/512'7/;91»7/2? '7751//»%77;£<»;?'{¢5 775 755/c %777¢15775/7'/17475!...
7 710 .¢;1,7,1.1/2227522 1272 M /:222//221/,11¢7,1/»
'.Q%?/i//?a/WW'/éj/Z fféz.c'/Z/dg£d£f iff c?& §/é';é£r 54 _ ` Q;,jc WZZZQ§ ér Q Q¢z 7/ 7,5 /2¢0@/ 7/€%¢717/[)/)1§’/ 571/§¢11111/171/%/ fmé/¢z¢//f?~ 7'77 @/J/Q (@ /7¢ ¢7¢/75/;71)¢%%'7157171////;//{/ 1’¢»/ / 1 ¢/71¢2/ 75 ‘ i/" //% ‘¢ ¢ J k/ /ZZ 77 712 g Z 72<2272;@%,12/2;22 275/11 11 111 1115 ;7///1»2 /7;/¢411: / h 1275 257/7222222//122,222//22/11¢57,,;0_¢1211;
/ZMAJ W/?/Z£m//I,L/ /7/17//”/// ]//7/271.£(@/’7¢¢///7/ W/H*? %/‘5!7/76 705/71%?1€;¢'/%/¢/ &/JC MQ‘F€/j///d) /W /)1!752'2///[’//70 . f/€'/¢//#Azj 5//1/!/ //////Mél/L /1//207££4./24/%/’1{ £!/1§(/<$_£§_4/£¢§/ )é/
/ mm\@\.€}&q`w`\.
C,//)r/%'.¢ / _’7 %dr//é)`/Id?{/¢//M/a/;LMZ/,,¢/k/c{!%¢ rdc.,"` /7711272’7`7/7//.7“//2,7’¢/7.}¢,,/7, WM¢,/é/,,/j% 000 csi/071 F. _
//’7~ /`/»:¢/é»#%
.@1721)27 227/72 2072/2222 ,22222.22 0,2/77.:2 17 772 2
757 7'/&1//2222// 221/227 2%'€21'7-7/3 C)(JJ() 711<¢%772/1727}//7,( /,1¢¢72`2
571 //""4£’/17/%//I!M/%f’é€/M/M'VL///f/M-Z/W/ /`/<.
/M»/ /“¢7771~/ l H£/)//czf£Z/M/¢// M//Vf/// 7 75 77~//¢[ /7/1¢ 27¢'
/7//!7»1 ¢/7</
1'{'\\ l /9 %/ /z;/?// 71 , Y'Y /7 /c//u 177/77 1//{777/¢///; 1171ch 1555 %'11#”¢*7%/164§£1¢7/{( )’.2. 772
é‘?, 7347£/ /¢,177/5/¢/7 // /p/¢¢z/ /%/¢71»4'¢ 7/// 5’”@)_(5), //17¢{/ /7 53[$) /%7z /// 71 771 7 »1~21/22/222227722_2272_722271_ __ dog ¢'%)L/’N /‘¢/1"7¢¢/711 Y/¢ myo/2/ 27 717///2¢/¢¢/ ` _71//’7//~/2¢/7/72/7///6' #“4/07//5//2»2///777///4/ 797¢ ' “`.
277 7 - 1 2 7 777 72 227 772 2227 7 ` (}W//KW////Y/vf///% /7 /¢7¢%7’7 577/£%‘£’5 i/,zz%¢,, 0//7/¢; 375 '
7/7771/7172/2//)¢7_777.2’1_/5/5//€1/2//75%£7»77777/ 173 ,
/)// 77/;£7755£/¢ 271/71 7 /5207 /2%1%¢7//6”7€:[%1 70 72'7,(`7/7/1 7/
*"Y 7 717 7///////7 /W.¢/%/¢¢//y 121/27 ,,éZ//zg@/%/(;,, 09
\\\\“\»\\“\.\ _\_' § " § A/z /; ’f’ /)’ /; // » 2 .2' § dr ,Qw}/ e/< z 425/¢/4< /ZZ/ /w2227:/2l/ 2222/225 2224/22 725//5/2’ y
622//22€/ 2273/274 652/722 %//5/224) /¢4’2///227 X/;;£/¢;%;zg _,é/ ¢%2/ 9/_ /be/) /(2/)'2</7/2; 2//4’2/¢/ j /23‘7"7/ 724 /)/;74 27z /5:/ é///éM///Mf 2225 / 12/ 7422/27 272 544/2415 2
22 22 222 2/7222/2/222222//2 2212;22
M/22222222 222 222 222/222 //2222,22/ x _/_/222 2247457/4/ é’/z%W/A'// %2/¢:2 226 %Ww_/ ;;22/¢¢)
54/ '¢/ ' fall/456 ///¢f/D é/¢/M// ,/0/222/74/%4 22MQ/A,Walj/al/ ¢a//W/¢///%am%aa/MWQ',
)12/2262/,122/22: 7422/2/2§ /@222 2/7///2//%@#///2/
_W// 4 //‘/667z //¢';' _/:2/¢/ 222/°5/,2/ 22 I/zé/ /// 252/22 7{;/ j>'/f¢ /%/22 427 2-/ 2%5~.“§ 7/./2/2///(/ /2/22< 2/6
/12,</2/12/¢ 152 /6,2‘r26/2/27% /$//</€_ 2552/17 //¢21'2/ %'5221//7,<4'
%2///// 7///4 7’_///252¢/2222 §474»2 25257222`)) %%¢/122'7 z%%§L'/”%'
%/ %2/ /22,/¢/{2 2%5‘/7/2)
522/222 £2€22?2 222 /X%/% ¢ %Mrrcé/ ////2222 2225/7sz
/» 522 /D 212F7 /2//)2 2/2227% 7422/222/7%2@//2 /»/'Z) =_/~`T?
// <W f 221 /2 /2?2('7/ //¢2/2 242/c 22 2//22222/242,4 7/¢///¢/% %7/724 24¢2@"22 22 % \' //2//%/¢2/
_ fw 5527//2 /é'¢ ;% 22
/$2 /25/_221277* 1222 222/2262
/22727/ 222 /2£<4//5/77_/2’22
/»’/1,/; )W, 57'277/,#; /@/r-/Qe¢f¢/’f h ,&/”7;, §///055, §/Yz.<fW/”/? ~ L?z//z)Z/%e/d%%;/f a///z%);>'; ,,__7;/ //%¢/72 Yf/%/w ¢Zd,w;;; / ..)/lg._ f/>’/JA/€ y// @é,;/ L'Mc 75 ge /{a¢rc@/?/,J'¢¢,@/`ey /¢z;.y ;¢/7¢¢/3§,<;/ ,¢ ;//¢%¢//¢MMM., ¢/,/,7“ 4"//¢@/7 757}1,/& 5526/775 M%/Mc _%.<///¢ ..' %/:3¢/7&& ,£/ d %c){/¢ Z/ c/ 7/{7£ 7/1/£)7/€75{4/”?£0{7@%` §§ %f//"¢ ////5/;7»¢¢%<4/%7 7/1////¢¢/75/@% /)/j/////?{"" O//df/%f/”q//v<zé¢% //¢/7 %4¢/<~@){ 7%,0 /Zc?§/Jj %%v}f/%£%Wm/d /'€//’7 /M¢/'»’ //:/'%/%/1// %/7.977 % 771/m “Z/{/%%§ % W/// MMW ih‘é/`?/€ fI§//ED FK/Wf/#é (\_déy y/. /’Z 0-_-
/j¢xx¢»¢z»/ :j)?¢g,
1!
,¢i
w ».¢~ ,_`.q. _.~ ~¢» -.e~¢.-»~»r o~A annum --'z
, ./ , f ,J“ " . ."’ ‘ t / /‘7 /_»' '?‘f' ¢¢"' 1»-‘ ,r ,i~ ': {'r» »_r'-;r' if .,"`,' ' -'7'_£. flying .¢~.»..._ z 7 z w y _.. _,_' . " /.</ a"--_ v..~ , ,» ,.~ `» _.~" ' _,'/!. 12 , _{ ‘, .l. .¢~' ¢ ,)f'=/." ~ f ~"'~.' f"f ~-.», ; ",." ;.,.} /’
\6 ~» ,l‘-' .'. .W jj./;`{,') C:’£/<`¢ .s-»“‘.'* 1 . . » . -" ")".J~’»’ ;/'z,’- 755
»{-".,r”,~. ;' .
W` ¢»~,,>~,,.r q.~..-»»=~.‘sm=u~» » r,/“_b.¢; 555
m~»
~» ann
.»-»..~.. __,:. ,'r»u-..W.”. ` “.
_IF’ if ‘Q' , e,f'.»'z»/l:{.wf ,,;J;.', 4 _.w /. ' l_\;g;_¢' /',¢ 4 “
, ' .l'( .»f '¢" . ~/ ~, 1 1543 r.’.' -1 , y » /. -” .v ,- _. ,", ,,r _.'\,,¢ y - » mem <»- »~WF»,{_?FE..WV,.‘:W»
:.-m.a»-v.. _~~W~¢'~---v»-.“.
.1,// ,r`:‘f/'
§ ¢‘ » _,, / _ .
4 /:, '.’. /=/`" 1 "
», .\.,» v W\»-» ._ M,<M-...,.»a:» ~.<-~` ».-e¢~`..q...~'.<~¢!\ L="é m3- ~»»- :¢-.:.'\- n»~.n
'W";n `
\, ~ \. w `, :s~;:;=: 1a v -,- ¢~¢'
w
3.~.~.¢~» .».... ¢¢; a'f.¢'/' me \ . / .<‘/“' _:3‘/‘ z./ wm eli/f ~ "\ \ ‘. ~.,».n~ nm- .#_ . q , tx .»{ " . ,; _r . .¢* ' f\..¢ /' »' ’ :"'1'
"' `/;:"x.~':§:~$ /'S'/,_/"" -"'F/`,`f'rf.;,`.»'" ,~'-.‘,'~M ,,' /e 1731 *'r-;,".“;,.;
r `»~»c\~¢¢»a.-..v¢m..»-.»` ,‘ .~m¢
f j /'- f .‘ / . f ll 1 . f ' 57» ¢} .~ _! ......... .¢/ ' '€ ' v ~' 1 .» / h -""`*="*"
a_;;,;;;» ’/,',1 _:////’~
¢1 ..»,- .~///~»;». /é-/ ,// //.
/ ,¢..~¢-'..,\- 7 . tc r, . I.` .( * .r . _) §
\-Ȣ )'
: 1 v : - "mz;:wawd¢~-A~v:;x’
,[.
_ \"`l . ‘ ` ’°' - la w ` "`" "’"“” 7*"~""'~.'5" ,/.¥%w"#?"`.o/ ,w,:-:<ow,.../,<,:,/ x/Mw'/~/. ` ,, .. j ~`”’/"'5""_;"»/ 5 ,,»’,’,",.¢er 53 ' ';'“ " / \ "'7::,"~ n sign ,"~",'FF"'//// ;{ ,»/.' v .< -€`l‘~,¢':,‘;; ja ~ ';:t/)/¢" KFF’A¢€',.`;}' ZMM 4 ffa‘; "z"'}" ""?V‘__} }\ / F / g z l ' n ,.
L;/."z ¢f,»‘." :/,‘;_ );'.,. =:f/';'}.‘.fz_,/ f‘;/{:¢:/(/ {7;/1//»:£:( § I"';;F/€ ;;';S’r _{W,,'¢{g;.‘§:;‘;r°];, ,-"/;;:‘f;_/"f é:;._-/ }Wz_l /;i:,~.¢';;}, . . 'r/ ; » l fl iv f f / iv Mj/Z: A/M"?"~/' é/"' 1')/ f ”"1-" xii 32 “ "'*‘/ 45 1 /:~xr#;' t?,:f/"vw.»/;;, 15 okl _-,»,,3.- 2 w
. 1 j .w ,. (‘ z , ,, ,;)'., , , m, , //,F; . "’“ »' ¢;\ nil 3 ,,_.‘;" ~ ,_f ,»~,.',;,) ,A" :, ,/,»/!,¢,, ,,¢/.
" ,q' ," '. ,. ', F‘§:i.,ngzFC¢_/A{Ai'~.', _);`» ,,1//'7` /'/;¢>./?» »,,d»//?/.,. w
g k " »74/}’, j /’ ,¢'5?)/ }/' " . , »¢' a - . ',. / . . .__, - "' t "' !:"' ’/'f/ »*’,¢“7 "":7`:/'{»’?'.¢";"~5/(;:"1_.,. "/»"`~`; ~’4 t 4 )j. 1'/,£ .» ,/)r'"{
` \
: 1 y . ;F' ' ll " ¢~"' w .~.. ' /f / _ ‘/ ' ,/ § /, , ‘" r`,‘!.,fjf:._/'.J¢;>z»`. ¢./:_ ~-'_» :‘ .. '»d"¢°~,, ,4,,.,..~,._..,£, 157/w n "->/_ '/l,,.‘¢€;‘ `,,§/ ‘__,;_(,;; .r;j¢»' /;/. §/. ‘;;(/;5? :/tdu ',\ )/é', l g /;;:=‘Wl*`l _, , . ,` , a
1 f l z /"'»’ z 4' M,'/ ,/ _ ,. / n -/-! _.4.¢;/?.'1:`:5,'.¢{*'~'"-”- »`"'r{/ n"/~.¢?/'»'f/ /;»? j / ';; /;)f /»1'» ,.¢ /_,~ ,/»(;':~.»' ir /§_;,»’,¢ »‘ f 3_ , _»/, -, ._» ;,¢~"/
, 4 ' l » 1 } \. ` A'; ‘ /’ './/:: ~, ¢ tr . .vi_ ,¢
"\ _ ~4'\' ~ \_. '\ § §
¢ . z .' ' " ` " ` ' .....¢. ¢- . . ,. d , 1¢` .»F 5 f .- _ _..L _ { ` '/ ' / , § ,i~/.. ,7.’;'; ;;"/ _,<)‘»¢;»,.;;(-‘/ r',r,/;/k:;',-; 55 ,- //:,. ,/,.)~;{v,., £‘,¢_,',~m ;.. .__,,,,, Z¢~,//,',/, ;~; _}_ ,,/’ M,),f:_ l 1 a ‘>a`\a
3 / ;z f '“"1 ' ‘ ` - . » . / " ‘ i. ' . . " / ., » . » /."‘" .f',- § » 'f/r"“ ».¢\ 61 {7/`// /f_/Fj_,.//- //é; fr,j '/ lfj;~,',,q,:_,/jj `{ l f l { _/ w .{.. nny '_ _ fE:~‘ <{~"-Y~'. /}/”1"/ ‘/ "\ 4" . '- - 1 ..»rif>» . ,- ~ 1 .~,....’/r ~"',». z ~i~“" -i / .~/¢ l.'/ .; /,P/iw,_£ J¢'r ' /') .`?’ '.r¢»§’ ,. '_//;' *'_r.-(' rr ,~;-,-' /,! _;49"" ;"" .¢‘/""': "'":,.~ ~»-.-~q-'
f A 4 l _¢L- / ,/ /,¢ ,;¢/ w ,,,~.)A:. /2> »" n _¢¢» `)»,-',»'.-\'»-`.- ._. ." ;»q.':./,Vy,'_ »~/r;" ry/ f df/lqi.¢v“ r,,'-_r/'~ »
l law r "~)\ ¢~/»‘ .» J/"/. }/¢': Jy la . ' ` ‘-‘"' ‘ ""' ' /é!.,~.,: le 1 … 1 . .;.~y Ij»‘ v ;{,,A.,. “, ,,¢»W,l{f_fé{f? k ry l ~_, y g ;‘]`“;;~; ';,lv /(¢f ‘.V;_>;’.;,’,/' bd `“-[1{‘/.»'¢',in
~» " ` ' »c'* .-). \ _ _ _ l ?/`} ' 1 ’°/ // 1 .- \ + / /¢Z'¢ "{':,’ "»i','.,'{,§' 4,’!» ";//! ;4:‘,;:#'.1;,"” '_fq-rx'//,'j /"/~; '! S'_;';_~} J/-'/[ l,r[{j'//;’ nw .-/ .,. rif _
'/ ,-, 1 /. ' ,» ¢?` 4 »//1 van 792 ///‘ ' .#.// nw >.- .'/F .;»; ,.¢-/ … ` , v / f" ` 7 f /;@-/`Jl/f j /~" jl/ if/` 7,// .wt =~ ~’//"M'/'; ‘.f‘;' _.~', " x ~...,'" ' " " »* '»' _;,.,.¢a¢¢..._.,,..,.,....,’.
rr
rv§/ n i::./ "' ¢ , _, ,-,» / \4'~ / // ':*/!f. :-"`"#§,_,Ji;‘ _¢{’/_/,')_ "'f;;_.’/L»/ll/ /)‘-:,3`/ , ' ?[/'. "`L.:,-, "' /":{ N_'_ :[:7!/' 7 f
,' -:.'lgl._/ ,,(, 57 `_ ( v ""' "" l f?" ."»'*-”": -('F "§`-f/I}T/f#'.’(' /;J/FJ;?’; #i,” /"," (f'¢l,"/,"'. »"`-‘, . _,./.h.,;¢-... 1 71 ,,r,.,:\, .`
..:“¢5' . k ;,-// i¢/»_,"
,¢€,/
/ M~.,..m.-.~¢M
//if"””
, / 7 ' .¢ j . _ . _ _ ~__..4'/£_ _ __‘I _ M" ,::,¢"f,/;f / §:’/'f_ 7"::"£'~‘ -3` '*'-'v' ,_`_ _
` __ -,/ : 1 , ,. . _ .:‘5_» .» _/,» .¢. ; ,"/ l_f./ 77 /:’/_;' _;»4: ._.c.’_{ ~/ ,~ v.;. A_ f _.»2'=..: _ '& w / ' ' ' / f
/ '~*' _/ /‘ ,- / _ .,_.. z ":»//' ,» ~'»,-'”_\ ;1" /.?/ ‘,'_-‘?’ usc/g ’,;///;.///z;' _,» 1.1»§‘_/"/... ;. _ -_,\"‘_/
.' "z<'_./ /..¢ / . ~ .
§ ‘/>/!f ‘,}/ ,,,- - ~ _ " ` '07' f 7 _) ` ; "7 ` ' / / '“ 4 ‘ " , " .' 1/ --.¢/ . » ' _ n - '_ ' . y /‘~‘»_,»'. f.:'¢/"-?/.. *‘?.Z>"' /"'-'»’_'* 4/Fy/ f j";'/*-/~ / " //~2. `/)' ’” »` »/&~_~» j*/' )"_:J '»£[email protected]’!7‘»';:? “ /< //~» _ ‘ _ _ _ _ _ . 5` '_"'M' . 4 ' ,,. '75;/",/.7 7/§;: /.r ' / /’-‘/h 1 " ' ' ` § ‘~` " w% .. . 4 , , . _ " ' l ‘ ) iv .` / /, ., /' `~ // ". _ , _ 7- ‘ ` .'," /)‘\/“¢r?" . l~'//’ `, ,_-’§:/‘¢'»""! W'.¢"?"/f-" '-" §AF/;/M" /i'.<')' ./w'/#’-:»'§ ~" ~’”<i' ’ /"'¢*k)"'<{ ,‘ ' _ .{ l _ ,., . /? '“ / j » » ' " " / f ' "" / 4 "” -' "- \ ' . " ~,', /.. / '":)"'"~ _. .z_ _':r¢*'/ /:4 f'€/»"w.'.,;. /[1'»_¢;, ',»"r"/" ."/,¢’,»_: _/`/;'*Q_j'. ’\*v_,])/»~,()(l 7 /,;_)(’5)__ ,4;~<;»; 2’//¢: __i.r¢‘r_l,_';&:.{__',f _,/';:§~.A{W» ;dw;$_(r /,,/)_;, _ _ . __ _f _. __ .. m `. . _j ,,. , / § / .....__, , _ / f _ ' - . , '. ’ ~' j ~ " ,¢~ . " z ~ ‘ »"' 53` §j *»5:25__/"@5~;,/?; ;/'f" ) xix ;.€7 /£{ s /,/ 75 »,»-,;.»»r , _/¢.7_717 ,¢»,»»1.4,7,~.,»~ ,jfy 755 w¢.-A~ r¢.»/¢,g»_ ` , '. _ __ _ . . `, r . __ _ :/ / 1 / ___ _ _ _ . _ .,__` _‘ _, __/_1 '/v‘ _ n ‘ / < l _/-4»,_,1', ,~_;_,' , '/ /',;.? 91):_7:’;?.'.’? __§)..¢f_'¢},/ri"~j"f.i’,~?`-"Ff' /` ¢\Z/"¢./'? -'. ,\'/:/=é “ .. ,` . -. v ,:_ § ,»" __ ,. . §§ _ _7;) ‘ . __ ' /' ': . ‘. -;”f`r¢ /,£5/?€ 7;-‘;"‘..’:# .¢// ,~/¢» ./ /.r. ij 75 3" vi ,z~,,,m»»<a.//_/ »7»,:)¢ ~ 4 _ 7 /: /."` z //'l ¢ .¢ " '7!- 155 /! d h /W'/J{ f;""»;/; x_, ( '°1' r'r‘ r 3 v /.¢-`“ ,' r»'f"~; t.'!"/ " }'-\j" ""' . , , . 4 . /,, ,. ") ' . , ,x."*‘l` ` . » _ _ 1. /'.7'.’/{ *"'",'/H/ »'_-:_r../ 7 /*{,’f` .L¢I`r,}./. //,/ .’/7 .-/ ',‘_“(:&/{/ .,»\ `;\»<:~- //` if - < /¢<' ;,/// `7./ 771 /f»'.;;» .x "' ", ' . . ¢',,) .\ . (,.’ /J» _~.»./;/;'._:=»:' .. , '. , v \ . , , , , y , . , .,' ,, . _ \, . __ .;.»#’ cf §__., _ , .,"' l' .- ~ ' §/ .4';* "1 ' / 7 / f/" ‘ ' ; / / .;-“”‘} ~’","` ' ~/'. z`r.,‘ ; ll ":i"¢ !". *‘2 ~".§' z ’,~ l"?/: .' .){ / g'./ l"(/(!) ~'~*[ / 3:'. /. /»u¢> \» ll ‘?‘>6`7`!£;' »~): cr //z! »!/r _‘¢' 31 »~ » _' f _' ~_ v _ _ _ _ . » » ~ - ' _;' 1~ ` _',1, g'\__'§' f "- “, _.`.,\- _;__J,.r. ,J. _ .. ` _ ‘_ _ _,¢ _ f ` f ` _4 __ v _J _ if { 70 ,. - ,g!-__ /,,. 7;,/_,,».,/;/:.~, ),,.3~/, /__,_ _,;,. l/,, ,L»--Q .»:,} // 7 ' - " ' ' ' ~ 7 j" ~ ' 'W. r-' .`,- ~.1 -"(___ . .-,f'“r, ' ' ’ »- < ` - ' / 1 »’ J r./:/ .. ~/' ,‘ J'i~ /¢* . ..'.` x" __.)’) -.; "[~ ~r..""r ‘ ~-; vt ,' "~.;,""f) 'u"
. /, . " / 111 . . ".»_':-'<;/', /’/~,~_i'!,*-’”/,l?? ' . » ,~’ '
lf',.'
\ , ____ `» . \ v J.»x , _ \ _ _ l ,,.` . _ ~ ~ ~ "_' _` a A>’ » ~ ` r't` -' ` l \', , 7 .‘ . , . \_ I . . \'.r. , ,_ ~ ', ,. _ _. , 4 \ 1 ' ,» .
/ 1 ‘,;', 'J‘ , f r !_;/ ;=' f£,c ,,"'»,~#
,J f’)/F x "/'r’“ 341 `:V
f \.=‘“ / / ' , ' - ' f , ' ,l' ',~,)g;.<»,¢//r'£¢':,’fj ..'.»;,-"~ ,"fz‘ '
‘» `,»`\ .¢ |`§/F/' /f/:f’/ /`" 4§”¢? F~, `
/"'(
`, _ , _ sw _, _,.' ,v ,,=` l /' ‘ ,,*,.~" -_,. :,» . "[,! ',;
md
,,.,... , J¢:’ .
11 , , ~.... 4» ,..._ - 4 .»? a ..,
y » f ,
§
_ ,.‘.\.~
,/\ ' ~ 511 - .»»' .»'~.._»» /</j/y fg/é.’/<.z-,/?/ / {j////[:, ll’l v'_f "’,"’3’ ~ ";,1`3?/“’//.:’? ' /é//
/z/,/,‘-£;:,< /;;?/;>'y_/."' :. .y...._.\ .».._¢... .-». ,`.`. s ~:~¢::»
/:}?j' '/_/',:r 7‘.¢ f
/¢,' . /'//,v _ 1 ’ _` .<rA ' . / /¢¢ '»‘///f. .»<’/,'¢?~/._4 '/ ,: .":,,s’/‘;’~b.‘/"'.,/ f/’> ' 7 /'" .,", ~" '/‘ /' .é . /:’ , . , l / -'.- / 7.. ...- _ /1~ /' ” "f £`:/?/f .f,#~” L./,- -,"*‘V,'» 7' "'
/,’.:7/}/"/»"/:"'/? /£f `~.._»,,_....-~.¢.-~.»_,. ..~_M.¢'“:»:»nq_ , f /~'/ l __` .,'/ z / / 'r'»( /)~.':'r/, "'¢ /¢ %éi' /;fM r »;1*“ g V»/," /$’//_';:.g I/" f* ,y// l;/‘/ _.»',~ c _,?'T€:~“Y‘ ;1";:;»
/; . \ //," j {/ .:»r;;,.
/,//'///,};,;'),/V_,.`»
l*'/ *‘vav~,.a»~---~ / .7 _ , l / /,/ /` ',r § j ,W.,__M_ ‘ / , »:’. /~ / “' ‘:/' , " - f \ .,. v -"' . ' .// -/ (;//» » f ’ /.»5. ' ?" 3",»; ,»<iz;,-;,_»i¢<§i".:,f? //'~; ,4,.,.4§»4// 7_»“?',) r¢§”»,/,/¢€/.d/ ,, , , " "' ”" ~ ./ ' 1 1 § f /;4:;', // __¢,/ ~ /,,', ',-' .,:€:-/';' /'_q} ~,' _/;, ,' p':;/F'/ ?C,,.j,~_,,(,,; ,_;; 4 ,¢//, hj,, ’M{; l,l_,,~{ ',‘!:;J_, /' ' / ~' /' 1 ' `9'/ -~ , A f '.. / //' "//"/4 ~ I/ , .l f ll f _/ / .:.,' /f';” r/:')",’c_’." .‘ 7."¢;""(/ l l /;;l} -"" /7' /N:, "J';:/:;/'l ')'§,:;; f/ 1;'}°"}5;//‘?"{; "‘r"-'":; ‘;';/*/.;';7;?/£(! l f .~s . /" - ' ¢ ./7 /,/, / // /"/`?` ;c:r.‘;@./ ' /{¢/ il l. z ,\ /"f'#»>//%.// c ' /1~.»’: / ¢z’£'» W/»<,./»,, /?z,*¢/¢/ f-»<f' if ¢»/.<€ .~:?'/ ~' ¢~ , /// - b' ’ ,W l , '/'I _,,r _, ,.., .,,--, , ,. , ’,,.», /, ,";/.~"_ "£ ," ~'/""~’- / 'j ~ /"‘:-Ji./ /”:/:¢':/ jr ) '*W_~W ~' r' ' ._.,.,.`,' ,_ q_ "'_ / ",`*; //} _/‘:: .r-v ¢. ....~,. .-..
-_»~ ~__ -»` 4\.
..,_ O.mF._.=n_mU _<_>__Lg _"~mOm=wu_w . `bo§mm=.n. `=m`.` Od.`$.. 20 `:m=~w.:om .oo<m~mom d~o<`.an&
vom»mmm m… my Ooa_=oa nom m..w w v .
IOE_.: mmom€» umw m Am:ao_.memZ mmnc:m& \. w ~ va mmmin_mh_ Om=<m~< nom . , Am:ao_.wm=.m:» mmac¢m& .\.l\\.\ ._.o~m_ _uow»m@o w mmmm $ w ®X …W§“z §§\§\_ 3m d o.. ~ M§M§\\§§ \§§\§ .WW
?ULB L?lU UDDL UWWU U?qq‘
mmz_umm OO>\=u`.m.`.m w.,I...`M mmO.`.`O`< l oo:._u_m~.w _wntm 4 m _m:a m. >_mo ooBu_.m$ _$3 h a mww=_o$.a Um__<ma`. _m amw=wa. l §§ <o_.= =mb msa maaquw o: ~:w G<w_\wm mo §§ <<m om: 333 »:m om& 8 <oc.
I >nmo: 55 om& 3 ~:m amax 2 5® Bm__bmmom. o_‘ o: 25 *_‘o:~h x w_umom vw_‘:\_=m.
1_. >n_o_m >aa$wmwa § .
Q§..R .\\§3 \ER\ \Rm\\»_\\,\\\\\\\x§.\\W. \\»\\\\\ \\\~\\\\W§w\ \\…\\RM.\\\\W\ N:
v z 4 oo.`s!..mwm +:`m,mm..o:oz._oz o.m:<mn<
_H_ >mm:~ _H_ >n_a~mwwwm
m. mwnm_<ma c<_~v:.:~wn >`mSQ
O\§ Um»m 2 Om__<m_.< weU
U. _w am__<wQ maa$mw a&w_`w=~ 33 _$B .$ _H_ <wm z <mm. w:$_. aw__<m_.< ma%mww cw_o<<. U zo
\MW: »\\\W\.\:\ \\\ \\\\ \WN w w %s\\ww\d\§ §§ w m. mm_.<~nw ._.<um _U ow_.§mn _<_m=e _U v_._o&< _<_m__ mx.u_.wmw..
§mm_w§.wn _H_ mmES mwww_u» *o_. _<_wa_._m_._n_mm _H_ _:w=$a _<_m__ _.l._ oo=m£ o: Uw=<m_.<
§ mwwio~ma Ow=<w~<.~ ~mx§ mm& _H_ <ww
_m. >_.~_o_m z_._.Bum_\ Q.B:w»w~ §§ wm§.ow `muw`» 1_ , . ` . _ _uw _"o§..w§ # ,§< 35
!.J.|!! ,._...._n._: Uonm~_o meE mmom_§"
_uow§@m w mmmm _um_a . cmnm Cz_:mo md§mm _uomq>_[ mmm<_om __ _ _H=A-o_mmw _,~_.m\= ..
Um_§= zo. O.S
. wmzamn _u_mmmm §§ <oc_. :m:._m. mQQBmw. msa N=u+% 5 55 cox.
§§ R\\\\ _K\ w\\vc\m § \\\\§ mw® \R§\\\R §§ \\m\w»
g z m§é§§_zmz§§S§§§_€;T_"W
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.