Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Davis, Finnis Ii

Davis, Finnis Ii
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided September 22, 2015

Davis, Finnis Ii

Opinion

"§;°$ §§§§§X§‘§Z§§§?§:;§;;°°““§OURTF;§§§§:§&AM mgqu . , ' ' . sEP 2 2 2015 - v\wi§ sm~\g;:_ ‘“> @qu’b\b*\‘®@%@o%*&\@#e% gm <\c>mm\m

~ F'T\r\ <:4 (>,§)Q\\mvi`€ 0\>`3@¢‘€5 to t\\e. SX&\€F;» Ye,\?o<\€€. `\~n oyposs\v\ows to aQQ\R€.u<\*€S @<§Q\`\@r£<`\o‘\ Q¢>‘< wv`\\; § Yvi\>eas cov'p\>§» '\h€, 6\'¢1'¥&, ~P\"r>~§) o§r:z\ &`mc\`mg€a 0<<` caa*<`_»ec>w_\\>s\ms 639 \clm 06 me,\\ bag,-gpp\\mn“\' wo\ counsel o\z?lc\avi’i. `m ve§§>cm_.§e_ aa‘oc;\4 (JI\S\)WD\~“QA by ‘r.\\a€eu>`vc\. “\we_x)\)\)\{mn’\'_\ze)'\evc% \;‘ne Xx\a\ Cc>\>r‘\'_ ch <\ adopt \Je_\‘.‘oo*-v'\m thc §§b?i>§az\%\n}m\g§ 'BQ Qacjmnéx ) O_c)<\(;\us\cm§ 159 \Cm\\mm§e, \1\/ '\~_\\e sXa&c/m‘r\id\ Sae}n ig?mo€ ` "L¥`\/C»\€D\)v\se,\ A?Q`\,C\£L\l ii \9\&’€£\€3"*610\0 \m\lm§beer\ Qomn¢\m\\c\r)\v\ ’\'_\ne. apQ\Xcuv\‘L’<‘emvc\@ 'The_‘<e_<<?z>ce_¥[email protected]\>§\i mmi¢;%e§‘.. E></B~Qc‘ce..

G\€&C\\;l:\\ wab; ')1>\-\ L@\%(:\C`L w HQQ 100%\» \5\0\5 §§\nl>w\ \r)‘-{ (WQ ?\c\&\l`\~‘; ' lmv_;‘\?.n-em\¢\’chem§§\&mn`< (>‘Q:\<¢c_*r_’u> \~_\;.‘txiu\ Co\mSp_\ C\"v`@`\{\a\(`\¥ C\.S CL mhb\e,-\\zwose `\"r '\e>un€>u\?§m"m§ ‘@J ’r.\neve_€'.c>‘w\w 'T‘<\ea?§\l cCA\n\~ SX~Q>\F)<\\Y \')c;\'\€.\le$ \'_‘C`\&\ QL>\)<\%C\ C\\?\:§A.c\\l’\"< SY eu¥\§&®l<\'\e.\!`mé.\c§<§\)c. `\<`\cx¥u'vc; ’L‘Mcx\ Cc>uv\%e,\ mm e,\m>_c\ X_c> ‘c_\nc$ucir -\ %UY‘§‘OY Xec§~ \3/ @QQ\~ 4\` mut max oQ \<vi\oea§ cm§)mz Nt> .~ c;-'?>%' l>\c>¢©€\» \\C\O\\A\l-R\ ~"dw; -\;he,c.??\\wnt€a\ec\m C\q\m am wx\\\am 3 \°\om& 0\30 a§)€' `\i¢cm‘v Qc\ec\ e<>m§d\cxm`c 0%¢1\§\§;\`<\~¢\9~0:@3 Un?ro?ess`»ema\ anc\uc;`\; Auv`m up\?\imv\’c~_ )¢xco\ m`\‘<\<\ \~_\'m, 5\0¢\;.~» %<m 09 Te~l~o\$ »`m \ng 00\ 520 n 1 0va cwa Ac)» 65 &;10\ as me,\\?. ® ac\n lN 1\>&_ 3% Bls“vi\\ ’c‘_‘¥ comm @F TRY\?\A\AT <Lt>\m’¥\/\ "\`€_X\>c§ E)LW\¥\TE . , . mm c~z%’ o\ov\¥>@\;»\\"\€\ \\\W:R Yi m\!`\£> W=\\V\§ IS_ A\>\>\_U.\\\<.~€§ e>w;um“§ 10 we wm _ . \?mm“e>§ § ¥<>d~_"i ~s\\\w cnm_\um\&§ b% mg wi mmc>m&>\x u>\>\v< §§ c\>\w\z_w\\, \\?? e\\\b il m>me_s aim '¥`\m\\\:‘> §)<>N`\S`SX'_ V\\cs `$\p\%\'\c_un\`!> b\)(}e_c.'\wm ’\.D ma Lom¥@ ‘v`mA‘wBs cz‘v` Qac;\c_&nd CD¥\C\ bs`\ons b€ mm wou\h$\no\b as§ {>\\ m\D_">`.

DEY:Q:\;\~\"\ vi?\‘€sw\`-\\A;§._ u&? ou“A'm°c wu“ae.\ \\\x.\e\cm'\$ \Oa\\§§\ic_b zw><e, ama §rc>om§€§\' <e,\\e§ ©\\c,°., Tr\u\ co mm wm\°\e,~wa\ §,ché<¢§ €;e_c;\e.\+>v\ <\@<, w\¢\m a <>_K\>L \)cl\\\:X\c:> €'N“\Z\~mcx`\\<\ X}f\\§ C.u$e_z. x\b Q,\I`\Ae_nu.§m‘c GC\\) A`\ 'ia\|\ov wmv¢\\¥‘<ed ¥\G A\>N u‘oc>u\<_\nt>\» w\ce\$| S\\G’L'> m-v,‘(e_ Q`\vc. 9 \\QQ\:LCNP< clan cv\\ 5\\@., 3<\0\..>@§ 3d1th \‘4\@ T`Lc\ \or had cam\\\`\\‘xec\' ‘{e_< A\w} §<bm ‘€<\€_ ‘<e,cb`<é» \»§\ab en\# mm 1 ‘o\>\\e)< ms?w\& ah >dm_cxw¢sw\e, z Q\%N>\.”SSY @ ¥\\<.~\\u\'<\<;~ add `me>u§ eo\c\\s %L?e< `\ux\cz>‘_\\u&§w{\e \oe'm§\, S\(\e'\; 0\¥.§< c%\>m\\\l (\.0 md feca\\ am er_‘<\\l I\\r>\s mm`l 3\\0>€. we;<_e,@\rc.§. \`<\s.\>~mv\§ mm 9 We.‘\<\c,`idw\\' ~UW‘L_ m Q\ Ci)` B{)P\'\Cm\\_§(`€§€l\j\. \\>ded\ X\_oa§<. \\{\S`(a`|\¢_\.‘r`£, (xI‘_U>\>v\X. 0 ® mm <\c)°\;`\'<\c§>r\‘a\§\ e_‘<\\ us`\‘d\ 1}\<, C\l`\A-Qx\c.c_= 'T\m»¥_`\:> t~_\%\§\_\\??o\~’cec\ \Yl ~thu€€.€_b`rc\» @\\BD twme.\ \?‘Cx‘®\": `\‘:~.» 60?1`\¥\%‘(\@,`\5 "Q@_\’\ Q\\ ’\{B E_\/\u¥, B\Q. CLQP\‘\ mr\`\' ‘_)\no‘i_ V<\o'€€. ¥)nu’\_ MXXM&@ L)A\f\ex\ Ene, evié)ex\€l}©.';‘<h</ \‘Ems>wk shst Bu\'. amc §\“Q')e.c,\\\e. web \`@_C_D\ICC\ _5@€1§?\\\;0\,5?\,,33> ma 'Ya‘l\or em\u?s€\\am\i_$‘<\o‘;me<` §»`\\re,><sm® 5&§?\9\\~®\.=\¥ \>WS TY\‘). `Yu`/\m‘ Sm’<cme.nt mm W>°f. Cz>v\~:>\oufe,\{z§ \o`i 5\.‘3\&_0(`\&!\££,» T)&e, "’ ®Y?'\u». Q\r\r\§Xo\)Y\av wm ’u;z?v\mom fox w\e,A \d\s£c \(\‘d~ \0\>\\€35 of \)u\\ek ‘m>\es max z §Dm\§ even c&>(¢r §ea\-c_\<\`\ng Bq¢c_¢>m§\@)<e Aez<§§xa\ebv U`\(\\e_ men SCQ.Q~&\NB\. P 1932 \‘1:1‘5> 1\-§:> <\S\‘<\\@ umwa ’cm‘c_u\¥\\ \Y\& Thi \o\' accounth i\w@. \ne,`\é\e.r\i\'_&@r \`(\<. \\0&\§15 w sod <’=Dw\e‘v.\\mg \x\e\e,¥hr‘c y Srm.® \mm wanda '\Y\r \c\am$ ‘\`<\\\e§¥\g>a‘ceb X)Ns ma,., P\\§L> m\'\p_x\‘fml \o@ EMMX\QM §Xa’\_cment“\d\¢;\£&\q a(`.\?¥\\`r_cm \»_S\\O\'. L\Ne,\` -' § \\te,~&vme,§ &4; “\§\¢:m L.>\m\e Hr\e,\l mug `\v\. \`{\w \?x>v\ 01 UCQ\* SC€_@\Q\\\ID\‘ ‘\Y\\§‘\~L‘D `\\'. iam\u§ fha ¢\\)‘(`I w\‘\w\c§ \ demose, *crw<\§€/\ (Y\rv\>\cr<\‘i$ t\i?u\e£ &¥3225 to ’c\r\mh 30 t\\e,‘\\> d§e, €no\.k\ X',~L\\ X§ncr.\\)\“) -A`\‘:‘<‘&%M§¥&\e_m S\M\cmev&> "'K\\m quXexv\¢v\Xb \§\+rg__<~gj\¥\)\i wm°f_\)ecau&c. X)r\z,wc~l w %n`w\`€w mg diaz w GYY\R mm was 5\\¢<>%‘\\¢~ M‘< mm ~X¢m e‘>\ 05 X\\@s“m,, mm as Hw, wound mpw\_ 09 '\\§\Qcc\\§ e\\c\ becausam\~§nc,`w man ~ ®Y`O\m\\)w\s t:».?`\r\\`\£)(\ -\5'\<>:/ US€_.J`:.WM §§ch SX€B(QMQ,\(\XS £0 a@@x~cmeh 1;\\&. flw\\cun‘r_ coh\r\`c,\\om Y\\s<> SQLM\B mva cz\f \>RQ¢@\S ve.\\¢e\ on ’€mm §¥u\'em@_n¥_% 'Wm’c. UQY\§CCM\ 5\\0\. m\>\X-\Q\e. \\w\c£, 310 gmm Q\P\\\U'“)( m¥ex\[.\ 23 ¥B\’\l\\ \)v¥\n "Yn`/ \vv find Q\ov\d,, ® mm \\arv‘\':> QDY\\\>?,A\»_A mt`\ ’L was §0:>3'\‘“\@, ~‘¢\m`t Sc>\~¢\e. § 15\@,5\“@"€5 Q.`\i§r\o_\' m‘\§‘>ec\ H\e, mo c\\‘r`\~.<‘ Q,\\| m pusseA ‘r_‘nfou§§\n \-.\n& cs§e_(\ m`m&>\..>- `le$ mm \\arf\:z C~‘_cm\e,»u§ wk\\'t¥\e%e.¥hegr~} 09 L,:,\cu\< ‘no&\)w¢& to ‘\:¥\¢c>’d\<’_r bu\\e§t:. T¥\c§.`\§ c\e.‘? ic.imt”?c&'ermance,\o‘/` mv \\M‘<\'§\‘ocm\)se, _ C\i\d?\`\¢;m\*\_ U>Y\Xu\\f, Jérw{‘c D. l ‘iea\' \0€§0<‘€_ \cr\a\ ma$ e\wcn§e;’v a\%@`oe§c~>m ‘d`\o\ <svaeA aq<{\vz:uv\~\_ mm\~/ XD\A “\r \\b\\\v\$ ‘m».. A;A-n\ :”>\\<>‘< \`(\x %n\<\e>/ \ A\$o o?§)\\ LcmX_\mA A<e\.> amm§m 0\3 \-be_ emma wave a\~_r_\\\v§ W\v \\M\c“\ 5 m\\# s>xr£c¢ Qo\mh csm.\m\\c;\_ mendez @Qg\\~mv\¥ e>v\\\l :‘>\m)’< am e;w\/\<>. \\I\'< &\oxr'\s§cx\)`rk w mem `\X \m`€~ \\Y\e. ‘ms 0sz C_\`\m`< maf> 5\\§0\`\05 W\M`c_ bC\rwu\"\ B‘<\:;A_`\me.("\r \\61\'€\`5 AQS>XYG`I€¢\ ~\\\e, ‘dm>. »'LWY\\ mm!\ am\'\\>\\“\¥~l 139 bus& swo’cm\o§ @ue.'*<\me,» (\\§D‘.X:r\ ‘©<\n\\m‘\§ c§&\mxa;\ 2b g~\`{\\< \Nm\§ »§m}\*<k\e_.@.\“`\me comnas amy 0?€'\w de\'&\:;& %§m-\-. -\y>‘<\r\?mo§: w`\v\hc~>\os ama X\\e_§me 69 '“\K.Q\o‘<\ej£a\` mem §§ E'.v\ \ T`(\o§ `\‘c_\.¢o_% %m\<c Yggg`\\;\e_ &_\mé<_ gome, \_\w. 3§\¢‘\5 ~c'\\\nav mizs¢¢\ '¥Me,car.er\‘\§ve,\\/ ex Qa‘S§;eA ’vk\wg\\\c\ne, own .w\m\bw§ an \0¢¥\1 sacks 15§ X\n e.‘ccwe~ T‘<\\§ BXm\me_v\‘r_'\€> unsup§b€\£§ \o`l ‘\k\e_reco\”és §e,€.§?\?\\\{o\.‘§ \P?_‘LZ 5» \5) \`v<\a h ®:<‘<\e, \.\S\r\c\r>m§ `\‘<\ 3v_\(\e,\re.\r\ac,\'e_ mem L'>Q en is § \`\v\c. \:> \§‘u\; mwccz\plkl "l (~"c.°(w‘c u\\ 59 X)r\&m§ ‘Z> &.\.>\uc)m>v\e,mas .'a\o sack ?‘A’(\. `Y\\¢Ymc wiv\Ao\J 1 O~J\ +_\\L me rem door °. \® 635wa wm adam s ?1\\1\<¢1@§ 5\’\_ emma kLS\X\<\ XX\Q_X,\Q<) §m\a‘< dow w\~'(\¢;\z>m§ §>p€.~m` \;’> X\\ex<.u\,\w>‘< zx\?oss/ § X\;\`\W ->énc.,£ c>X§nex 5\<\£>‘<‘) wm M\xe/'i \\X 1065 cian `.\Q_X¢\~i .\L\wo\) c§)\o \\\¢ ’cm \m\\\~@\>-‘c 511`¢<\&¢3“@\5 ¥\M-XB'\"\¢\€§Z \\D\X ie§» i’)o\c \'§c\e,?'o,c.‘< s\:\\ §\w&,$ _ 'L\'\u’c. ¥_\r\e C.‘C‘\me.§€.cf\€. S<’.u\“ c,\n C>\>Q'i<‘..cx Q't>\>w\,d m\\~l @vxe‘o\m\`\e)r Sce®w\w\\\\\m 15»€\)» _ k ® - 155-mdc deed c\\\_ "c_\<\c ‘0\;\\€_}<5 v ¥c>..(\:`\v§’r_o? Y`{\\'chbl \0\‘ 6\‘\<\ ne>+_ am upg\<mm_s‘mt\i§`§§c (Y\:> “\a~# \o\~ said aqq\\mm 5th at wm w\\\\@ aug \.>e.w_\<\w&<)<_\\e,\s max e>c¢@w\m.¢\ w\» \§63 mle ind @P\'\wvi €\rv>’c mm 9\\1€"3’€. *c‘;\<).c`c\<‘v md ~€\IU\_\\L miss` marc A\A ‘&xe. 5\¢\§¥§ 35 113? 9 ba\\i§\’\aex$?ev”¥_ mm\§>\me, Q\`c>_§a¢\`\_e& '\§na ¢§u{\' w`\"\*\`\ CN\Q \`\<;.\'\r\g €\l'\r¥en€.c, 03 -"Lb \§‘\Q,U‘W\YCK` S\Wb‘% ae"‘ma\\\/ \"\ve§\ Auv`\<\a i\\a %mm`\s-§\m S?Jdr\c. Cr\m<> usw\¢\ \1£\\1€, onc§@xm`meA W\§T¢#\o\` <\\>mbe‘( § 5\(\0\$ .§\1€_ za;¢\‘mag §;QA at 35th L\\e.®y\m\>< .,§Dm @\m>< >e@@ ms 5‘<1:>; \`e§°\é\>c mr ‘<\<m\$ SQ\A `\5 A<>_X ec;\ chs\e,, \c>‘<\\i en ‘én Q/ hawk 09'\9€01?\@. w\w kave, 9“\<‘¢§ ag\_\n ':\\z)m do \Y\r \'\(Aw\& \'1¥10\,> "th"\$ \\né:> w\@\’_ owniin c.§ er<:r¥.. §§ \Y\{, \\acr`\$ .gg-L-Bm¥ `\-r\@c>rw\‘c`\bv\ \`mm oka\\'\shc. 912 Qrt\"\‘<` 50 W\x\)rw(<"§ .S\U>\& \'\ac\ ‘c\\c m %a\\T§Xi»</ eipzr+. 19 L\D a¥€"\c\mf\‘c_ 10 MH; S'\ maxwean .`P\\Sz> ""\'Y\i_$ Q§v hymch igmre§ Lhe,cue. \aw \m>\hmg wm@s`\\mca\\{ mt (\C>\\\(lg.a\@\/m\~ on a _ch m\H\e:,s §§ _ am -L¢s’r'&~/ to cbs BQWQV\ gm mm\,@ '€.\‘59¥\ "\5 `}3..\\`\¢3‘\)(1(’_" 9\>3\'\'\ B‘{ \`/Xn (\ »\;e‘?>\'.\\"(\m\\\ \g\(-\L\\\UX aw\& mss \1cL\le. \'\e,\§~\GLK\)Q-\YCM\\ D tv 0\1\\1»%\®$7/.

Q;mom§§o< (c\`\e_§' T mm ’Yr`\u\aour`§_cc>v\c_\o c§.@_<\ X\n@r¢ 13 K\@ evidence °dr\o“‘<_~<®\',\\urv`\s 5\1{>\_\\5\(\;\\:¢ maria u\§ a>< gm @_\(m\\.mge,, pluth v Bne.c:bbns?.\ Qc\`\\uves 3m §>Yb§§ €'»\’\`] '@\Q`JQC'XNN rg[zu¢§rm§ g %a\'¢_=m\ C,\‘\a\\enga w -'\Br\¢ SV_\“`\‘€\`\Y\S C)? the€m\\/ K::\\/W O; §§ q gm , (X\\(\@q.. "\r_m L\mm§ m\m> mm 5kle \1&`\&\<\~1>\5¥. mmc @\<\ `-\\”\ t\{\cxeci' \E£\f;"t‘ L‘,BL)\& \\a\lc. '(C£.\l\) €,b’<ec\ 6.&\(\.'\5\:§; \`\ K\SE>§: '\'_\\€_ dow ' ,\°oc>\_ d$\§l\\(\ B'xe. c\\>§\`\r_un“f_ mm K\E>‘c`\_“`\ru\"\mm\ fig\n‘<_(§u&(` Gm\eA b\/ \;\\a 5 Cmr\ \‘\*“Y>\m€_m\me,n°(. D? ‘vl<\e_ N><\%\"\X u\`\tm X_D\oe_‘d`\€_t§` \b`i &(`c£\\r § mfg m)¥ i a\ dod Cm§`\_§§&`mg 09 Qu‘w Aemc>§)§ ao\\z c.e>‘€ ,¥)r\e < arj\a\ ma\‘~\e. » \>Q 159 ’éne.’dne, Cmm’d §'<e»w\ \A>\\\c.‘<\ ‘v\e,`\ 5‘0 e,`\r\£§ X<KCB 10.\’(‘,€ M\\ (`,E§\>Y`e\`] 15 <\E>"<_ r§\\\' m\(\§ `KCSZ ‘ En>u_m§\ QDV fd\`\ e§ T‘r\€ce,‘; Tr*\o,\ mortg x:>m\& sami mms e,\ \`(\\'. \\ as ns maAe_ 'Cm%vm\o\t.. *‘U`\C\\ &"Ym‘m§;§( Aee_i':>\on mt w teakoez’cc»\ comp ' ~€_¥im‘j haman o§‘cer app\icu'n\; <>c>_.*mvn?m'm X_\\¢ &Xc£< doer `\w\ mm \:\oxr is Ye,\`\'e¢§ em\\>e)`\\! L:\j 00 Bnexc,qov‘r_§mm \/er‘c\on s¥a’\c v \/\c>s§`\\'u\ Ln\n en m ?m:_.’f_ ‘(Y\C. \~X.a£f`\$ \MA w‘>vc_si>mae$ a"c\r\e.'~f\i ~f;\l`\_ :em.e. w‘¢\e. R\\‘<_c> 0.!><1€\5`\(\€_€ X§\U\ Au§\q 1903 53@<@_\\05§)1\@\ §m(_\`mg\$ ®T\YY\`\F_UX haw Cl’m»fjm>§§ m`\’<\n \);1`}3\\0’¥‘€ ¢‘_w AZSG*&¢T 9mm e\§f’x\/ Ay;§e»r“c_-wat €v&\\mX e,_ a\§;g\ic_an¥, ®\\W\'\mn‘§ hoc\ a \0 ng\\.\§’cm*y 639 ch\\ a\ `\\\m.:z:\ pm\{)\em& and ‘oe;\v\ g y &Qa\a \ w\X\\ mwm\"\'_ masan \`l\\\\\l\?\ Se,\‘\ritc gram sBmL\/ewcs¢\ y w ` 1 _ 1<\ 2101 t\\ mm a§g\\my€v_ mm rece..z\smg a 351~¢<\@@<~ § row tm um\¢A S`cc£va vasuu\ iz~ec\_w`\¢‘c‘/ aAm\nsXm`<\on Qc>v \\M\v\g amw&c~\ » ® "\`\\f'\e§§l A'\eas. A?§)\{c_an\‘_\ms ar\m~\ie.& to S\&Yz \r\o§Q`\\ u\ *€y\ev\ ‘Z>B\ dais§~~a}ev an P_vu\\_nrrz .>r\ 9mm %&\e. S’raXe. hhs gi\u\z:\ec_\ave& G§)§\\`mvf`f_ Ee>mp e.’rm\ te> 5‘\01013]\;¥10` § §Lsc,\r\ €.`\\'.\Bm Ssm\n ce_?)\m> u\?§ how'€_§wsm§\\e§ mm \\C\YY \_S hub Y€QL>€_§.X él'n CA\Y\Y e’¥cv\r.‘[ hmc'mg m g\'_»\ eag\'_.\`nb`\)¢.. \'\ma_, two \‘b§`/<~_ho\@g'"\§¥ wet (‘enAAa\ a\>§\'\mn"\; mms€e§m*¥ w \`e@em\m~\<, ibm Pm>\» F`m.c\`mg§., 7 §FDUT\A!Q(>V Y€,\`\.€? Fi\.l€_°¢ 'F(\ &\ @DD\E\: ?@Dn A §:\»m~\'_ CGUY\S€\ \.\(K({S nw \‘€o§@m\o\ e tva u\’. '£>~X_m\ \/' c§ cc_`§§\'o'\\ Qr>€ *é\\e_ "rfcu¥men°\_ 0§ \3<1<-»_ `W“€C"\ U`\“g \€.JYY€X` a‘m\ ‘/\\`xa\au_\v"ccb<\(;\\s€\e<§ %§§\icm\`<. §§ e.§ev\)£ 007-eva ence_ w m\nz> mm"m ‘v§'\e'¥k\\eo¥e;<\`\m,\@j<\@¢_ 1 his `\¢5 a miss» s‘\e\'\e_me_x€\ 59 &§c\c>§€ad\s 9 §>\QQ\§¢Q“X;ED“XA\X§ \ne,.

9'\’€_3@.\'\% ev`\c\e<\cr; X§m‘<. &`-{\5 Tc\\l\O\“ mfo&@@y\\af§\ /SQM~ owe AM~> \m\\e_ ’L\m>. \<’:XXQ\` `m%\qe, §Xa§\c\\o‘\)ec>s 'E)<H\\o'\‘\ m\' §§1\$` §C©\\ mr. \\cm`\§ §a`\(\ ’e\m §§ Y\\S`ia\/ \OXA \\<\A div €ch.A XY)§C\;§\§:\`§\\I\Q©Y ‘v§<\c \QX§‘€;\`»\ `m \"\<:,¢\\€f_ c§<` m\aé\.\m§<§cil\eh XQ\\@< \1€, A\}; m& X§nm‘é\ wi Amm`\ -» boi?c\€§r~'\\,m`f. S\Gc\'\m§\ \>§Y`\)i\€¥\ >\'§\< 5 \€f\f\“ mr §0\'\:_`\¥@& '\X`:> mc‘é\‘\ n%\ mm\z\ \>e_m>_€ ;->< °LMLL\QQ\:CMX» “T\w§§ 51<%¢<\1@1`1“\.0? (`(\c.\€mv<§ 5\10m3 ‘§>~`\&5 `\X`§ e>\)*\\vo® ~`UC '- `\Xov€i$ w€\§.§\si_~ 30`\ XD \m;\§ th»_a§>§\"\ um"\_ »<Y<\r ‘\\tm*\%\<\e\h a\\waé.\; YQC~A\;A§¢, `\5 on C\K m\r fm &§m», 0?€@05€_@ TY)€ ag?\icm\”`£ éx\§zv\‘£ 5`\ c\m§\ sa L‘mme. ~ m\‘<\\ -W\r.\§avc:$» &S his \a`i\oer. “¥‘ms ‘r_\wcw\m;g \e;’r\ ex wm\c\ \\ave_ 5\\%»05&\€,\`\¥\5§1¥&\:'_<‘ Y\a¥u<`e. 09` WS'WW ` anas‘r)c>\.> `f\i:m So<; '\Bm\¢ e‘<`\e§ omb '\’\m \<\mA&m~es'wz$\o c»}g\<m\ ® and .5\<10\1>‘<\0€ "fmc; C§\\'ca\.@\<r \ &\\5 Y\`\'<- \‘m‘c`\$ é)'\§ w>“~< *rk\‘m\‘) 5dc\cl`\. \e;\\ex m\>\é mith “\§’\Q,C'QQ\M\\\,&£Q U\SC, - \k .¢1\\» t>\lec\\'m m@ <~“_m>me__\`(\v.\‘\wr\s Q\`\M`YL \__\ \>>b&>\d § ><wd§.(;e>m€£\ ?(\< \€\0\`<‘\5 moc\e_te_c\gona\o\e, \x\c\\ €?\< c_\.‘m§f @>e_r.`\%`\o\n ws‘L ‘U> Q<Q,%ev?< C\\.t'\\ "`\\'\50.\\ 13d A€Q exvse, ax\. \§x\§g C.\C\`\W\., QQQ\{¢A(\X_U§\{\\C(\ §§ "Y“C§o~\ ftmn§e,\ ‘mc\\RQ_ emma QXQ\¢>\“ *c£<'\m\ §§ '\W\SC»<\’G€\( c\ @,?-»eme \0\>`<. _ ?oi\e_z§ w?\_\.\\\i `\r\\!e§.>r 1361\€. 6\\ ?YX\AC\W\-'\ ffx¥\`¥ mm`<u\ »\<\\3‘<0“ mm Hovv\:§ Qcc\\ m gu\\~\>? \‘@\YP\`\U<\\ wm 65 Q' row Xk\c,\>v\.\&e B§X&§<s 50£\u\e.w1viw adm§n§€m‘s'\ on\om\>z`e, ®Q\\ecm§¥,\ms ~<e<;'\e\m~o\ wm "U`>\Q\ “11\\<1\\@1% w §:Lm\mc§ gov <e_\'\e§ s§vg§ ’Ym\ Em>\?<_ Qj>\>né\ 1\\€¢34 @.>\~ mm\ a\ §\\mz,s cheesqu <Lc>c>‘\ m‘<\'\c.\\ mv \\m“ \`£S ¥\‘<\Q.\&§ dwesz 5 @€,1 5\<££\€,\>§(£0€05 y S?\{c£m"\'_, `Qm>\mA ., <>\\¢su >ém>_ SXcB<é \<\¢>z§\m\ e\) ex\ mib >Ane_ 359 f men\ L`>Q~ O`QS`l-L\<\ 0\§€/ wm\ X"\ ex \'X\'\s <‘_Y`m\e. \_)\\AQY `{5\\\0§\\\01\{`\<`(\%&§ A\so\‘Ae_\r 605 ‘SQ€°. Ex\n§`OP< Q);\ uo!‘.\r=_v Qo‘mu\c`é<m\f\ ?>Ond"\ s ' mci Ni\f cf 336 \\e,`u>c\§ m“\_`\ n\lb\ec\ QQQ\’\U\:\"Y_X¢;\A\`(\G `\Xc»<v"\$ \\o, §0§1°\'_ ?e_me_m\oex‘ because @\q?\rm~<\)r_ md "oe.w\c><§€ \'\'\€J"<Y\‘>,As c\\m>\>\ s`\x m`<\°<\r§`s) ‘oe§o‘:e. 1515 QQQ wage \c\ac\ c>cr_u\~veé CmA "<§\u~\, b\§\e\\ QeoQ\e, 31\`5 &\R\§c_u\nif_ mt&\\\'_ g¢:,u\c\ <\`Oeev\ m§¥\\ ‘¥k\e.w\ m\<\m Bne_£>(~` §€w\§e.. \m£\ C)Cr_u'v e_A. 'A\Q?\§co\n¥ -¥§nc£c A§c\):v\§ mecm\\&_ was '"<~\<:>‘: `\r\\fo\'e¢\.\ ‘<\€. bos\ A`RX.(\’L ‘CCW\-em\:)€;(` &)C.Q`\VSX m>*r\\‘m a\oo\>‘¥. XX\LC~R Q<snse,\:).€(;msse \¢\a \nc\d "c)e_£.v\ cM-\\\‘S W\QAS.

563 §X(L a `\\u\d'ea§ \`;'i\<w\o\l< K~(\ X\m§ 63va .\\!\r \\u.‘rv`»_$ 23\>§*\ §§ \_»§<\03 Q\; u' \r\e_ mn\u§ \~c\§§§ a“\'\r_m\*<_ masso\{ in%\<\ud)$ \1\6* \»<\\1.:\€<\ cmA m\\< md¢& \<\‘\s@\»§,\é)_ e_\`\mX» -

, . (\§Q\ \ @®\)(\(\Q(><` 'KC\`\€.Q 5€>(€!\°., § T\'la\ com\'_ Cov\CX\>AQC\ '\n X\m`z C`:voo\nd l ` l &k\e; RQQ\KCU\% mo§ §L\gg<$‘vm§ '\-m§. wo§e.\ §m?'vc>§e_<>\v vad\»"\aec\ the ‘-‘mu\ Qc>u`c*"¥. ‘YXU"¥.FY\e/Q emer§ \n"\ 5 c_\?\ e.v\"s Mm\§ wm mP< %@cbx§<\”» T\\~\#§ was mt &\\e,`\z@s& wm *L\m»,m? pheava was cc> <Y\§\w\‘< clon w mm \\A§TK& a¢:\`\on &\ 50 `\mQ cx'm\s§\b\‘i Um<,gm\~m§cc\ ~app\;m@t?xg\\+_ w tulssz am ?ov \\nex in ‘<\\5 &>\M Ae%mse,.

QPP\`\LC\:(\°\'_CDMQ¥\\S h`\§ 5\ -\~>\ \'*t L)§ZS l°_m$‘c"\§s\_)\`\em\ \\w\en (§\mcy\`§$ hdc>.\'e_ v`\c>\n‘rez\ . `H\:)'z`:> @Mf)r\`\s: Gvouv\c\§¢e,&,%a’\e,\\c¢oms E)L\ni‘m’v a(€@cdav`r¥ D(\ `P\W\\`cm'\% \I€J‘Sio\n csc m\<u\'_ \‘\B\§\Re,v\ €cl ammod M 713 \®. \`\ %vc>\m&\‘x` of rc\\ § \?;\ gill d ’¥‘r\a\ UMR mud \>_v\cé; counsel mm \>\cm\"§$ mud e.. §m@e>nc\‘<)\@<<`\u\ §<rc\>l \I Ae,c\‘s\ov\ 00‘< w mc%me§\+m\; <>Qg\mm‘< `\>e. emm`meé\ °<@< com§ ex wool \J€§r¢>\€e. \€\P,\m& rao/mc c\\><m&¥x§c»\¢ “\~<.MYKS su\`A <\&\<\`mg `\r\ _Xk\e, aw\\ma"(. cbuA\><;"`< C¢:\; Xx\c»\ m é\"\ C,c»?\e\ >w\<\`\w\ \é<m,. upg- \`\c,m\‘< was acX\rB» m¥\>ecm<)>e_,\c\ewas \m?`\m~\ \31 c§‘e.\\\s`\o\ns ‘<\a\\\>c:.`mo£r x ems \lo`\c.e, <BYAP,\"N\<\)) \.<\'vm sua E\B §c> 13\' G\\\‘H *c‘o`v\w% e\§a*én¢€v_ §\UQSX¢& X\mj<_ \xzs ac§\\@\ns \A>e.€e, mm eA '\H mmw\ `-\\\v\egs 05 z>§>>§eseé w\\\§n§g\>w en&@~‘c`\\xe, cm& mm»`\o\w»\e&m¢ ?U¢><\Q\w&;o§\ Q\\ wm m \\f\! \\cmr\§ know @L\\\L\\as ms mm \\£mis \o§\c\e_ 199 *€.oe, QLQ\Q\\ mij mold -."\x:> ‘<mbm w\fé< op\{\§cw‘c L\_\Q_S *\§O`\Y\§h`\v\§ Mc§c€.\`mcju\ \\<'\L >&s‘~‘\c oeiw\u\» ® ?(\<. \>mv`\& zcx`\c§ ¥k\c€v_ C\Qq\`\ mimb Wc`))\xm Qx\X&X;\eL Xheze.a\"e, Y\¢_\l zim<€‘<oms 139 :cLQ€;<§m\ da\gm%§ mg Q§\l‘c,\<\,>>\;q,¢\iso<c\w Ae\us\w 5 <e§\>\‘< mm%c§e§s§m\ ‘oe\'m-\\ Lov &\\A>.vc>o \M\\ gm am SQ\Q ` MQ€@¥\D ogains`x XBd>Se. X\<\£D<`*/o\> \0€,\\€\$€_ orc,®&>’< W`€m 46\:\.. \N;L\\\§f;\m¥\®n \'..\\c)/ (`(\LL`/ .mt\§ol% (`.<.ikic`\§m& 69 L>B\~o&`io\> t\\in\\ M‘ do Se.e.‘,,,ma\l G`C\°\Nc. QQM'<\NA §c_Y\§?_:>Q\\*oe_v\\c@, T\ae>c:_ cwa Qim§)Xov~/\S (>»W\iccm¥ was c\i§s€\a\i'\m*\ £\'\x`\v\c\£ria\ !\'>\YP\\`¢@M A<d a??I/;\m\& avu\\'§s adams Auv`w\?§{\»m\b :5@@§,§‘<0\¢"¢\&\0@05 Ei\\`\`\)‘\§r m‘l‘\¢_\x's_s C~>ve\)n& x Emm\d Qo\' fc\`\& mmi ’-{\-»;u\ Qm;»'\'_®“ (\_\Q AU}, mi &w\wu“s< \(\C).§ ed\\e_é\*\b§b“>\)e_w\; Cb\>me“'(x`\\EA see 0\03¥0.`\‘~/\ '\`(`\<-Q\D\ne`f \`r\&Aim\ veamk\@ \oQ€¢ycc,Xxm\JY\{\ie".b"\nmwe;~"r zeme£n\vw C£\n& \-\a‘<z\ 305 idea =(ARQ\K arm¥ 01chan `\¥5 K\L>X\\\\<\QA~€LX_XWL\ \)0\\3< \`\\r. ?\m\e_j \`(\ cc§`\m\ view A\%. `T‘aexc; \A§L\`e, m ' my c',`v'\ 'Q\\`i S`\cf\mns ted i@_§¥&v w wm HQ<>_ §§ mnk\ zu;xmi“@c\ w wc\ri&<§mmv cl_v\\{` - ADC_¥¢>~‘C <‘a.? Dr’cs \1\\\ L>Q \\ms §§ ~€o\§\'\c\ `\\r\ u\;‘?\accm *< X‘c\o\ b mm `\)\D\C\“`\§ \_\;»c\z 50 `\<`\e;\:Y-e_r_'\ i\m»:>s Qr>r mi‘no\)`\v\§ X\<\ex€£@€$\e& 'é®(`_\.)mf.v\'\ QA €.\{‘\é\e_nc.e_ in ‘L\<\Q "m`\&ic\_\ ll'l_L\@c\<w Qm\cx ., \\\S® \`l\fv \)\Cx(`\"\§ \C)_ci\!_'l§\lc_jdr\a‘f.v\vcé_§&\/\\ W\x ?\BV\<‘;\/§`S W\QMCA\ YCCA‘€A 05 . gm be m §\=@ec€, \`<:\@., mm hawk §§ cwng as m\ww. '"~. "c\c\\€f§$ ‘_S\\GO\<\ \6\!\&\¢ \.3\1€,\\<\€,\` ‘QQSQQ.\% `\\‘\@`W\ m mm W.\\sz;§\\o\>\dm@;\\<>?>_ swmm><e.e» w WP\D“N ® m@¥c\icu\ rcg>\<~% wm \<\`\5 6\»>\\\ \?`\\ 25 clon §\\e,£\§?\'\co»anu§e,. ma mms \<\QAM> \es aw@r e\!U\/')‘“§’Xsa R\r\ cm§ \v\&z Q`\\€~> a\>\<o\\\®“& \/\‘m§ '&c>Q\l L>Q V{\Y¢`\\vms c;r\_‘<:l C,\’\e,n*§§`\\e_§ '<\:>X\<\\m\\,_\% fm ')<\,\ Q"w wm m <em~) mw vwag 1@.®@ w\»/; YY\<. v\\<)x‘<'\s. cw€\\séxe$ X_\\&\_‘\\\ e?€'ees\'\m<>w} cx‘c X<\&\\bas 'c®ne\%‘&€v\)< m\f\\\ m mmnd 5\£§ ma \0\) \¥\f-'P\w\&/. 'TwX`:> m\§\>qgov\e§ \X/ the (€,Cmc\ 005\\<\`\1§§ m X\<m Qcm»\"¢\ ekan_>x@}\\mow) wash wns\¢zXeoX uS\X\\ m\\(f< N\<R\nm_\/ &‘<\c\§¥c».\?c C.\cx\m ‘?\M\€;~) `\\<\;5\)<'\} i'>§§ro“m. `T\\P_ Pamm ada c. “\'¢>b'\a§ `Y`r\ef\$cn `~\‘k`:b Y\b’c\\`\né\@c>n§?\$\.@n\ w`\\\\ \(\`\€> A€$CX`\P \`\rm X~)r\o.\; mc¥\c>v\®/'~h>t»\>m§ mo$ _T\n<?c\£j\'-dc>v\e,\€`/- bv\\f’f~`% `\\`\'5 5€€,$’<`\;~»00\{ (‘,\(\Mo~t’.\e_‘€`\`l_iv\ '\\I\r\\oc\c>\ &Y\\\;\~\)~\.E\\A\\R_SL;QY 0\”*\ ’-ck\z §XUX€~> ‘Ouv c\ex\ §§ ‘?1<50? ."\J.S\\.e,n \{\.<; \ab c>_\`\'L cox `N\f `?\0‘{1€\1 xré)\;\v\l 515 C\ \m e_ mc>_fma&amc\\ \,_5\\5_\.;_\\ \<\<; A¢Q»WA as .Q brus\v§ up mca»\)ajcm \\r a\avc§€_ \o‘r\\ts@,»§e.e_@\§\\\m\¢ S-»;Q?>Q ';’1?>~7.5> ?axcm\e&w_§es"x\mnj amd "\X was ms mX <~»| mcw}> X\ao%§ \00¥\ c§\ X_o \<.\e_ mazda \o`J @L \c.e;- ch_"€\\ S\rc`<w é‘c -6';\):“<£;, 0? §\@;§3 Q-\‘ow\-@L ‘.Q‘<Q{\P_v\ windows §&C@\@\\\M}\»SSX qij `§‘f\e. `\€C\mw\e,c\\`c.un§ex~ m»'\w»_c§ \~)c\e_§\a\e. mmth N\n\%mr\gdr& ~<\c>¥.~ moss » ammm¢ m\m cou\&\r,\\; c-\~.e~\? c-L?\Q\Cc_mn\< msa Cx\z)u;‘< &_\n£ N\e_» Pe,rsw. \' er>\'v\ \()e.w\u§ §\\b\ w\Yy\ CL(`D\;\A ,W\f` ' \\l\~tQ\<>v\e`\ `w:`)m\\ maine \)\c,m; a\omv\&\nl§ Y©\c w \)Q a§r`\o`\ m\;\\%c\ XQ c\@€e'n§e.cmc) \'\Q_\Q X\rx@_%‘@<e CD\<W'§LE< \<\`\3 b\,s\d C,\`\U\X \_\5`\\\/1'0\>§. mack CL\ "€r€>§ 9 t Bw\ X\(\L \O®’>Y`\XUN ® wound Qo‘< w\`\e§ ele;[e,n¥b°° 'Yv\c\\r_@m’s_ cm\c.\uc,\u\ "`\:\(\a>f-` won%\`§ m“\-_’\;Q mp& 3m am `\:ze_ a'\o\?\z mm ve@av?\\n@ X\ne_ sbca\€§ Q\e~.~ o‘€ ‘€ex was ?c_\r\e "K`Q_S\>\)Y. §§ fw§uv\a\o\c X‘cw\ SXMBYCQ§], §§qu @Q OL\\\N§-® Y\§Lo m \`(\Y.\\uvf§& ‘{<:l;u\\ A\§C,\>§sm% <1“\1. Q\U-Q,U%'mg§“b Ab mi rzm\\ i<l aR\eu-- ucb mar -e€€<.\~ see W .\RN:§C&C-'réa\}é‘c Y~ \\. {>QQ\`\um\-_ mm¥cn&§ mm '\Xc»~…s &\,\m>e& `°c§mz 0§@¢,\' XQ w w aware L._\.=\X\\~w\» \\';0\<»_€\<_\0\5&¢:&\;3 wv\<£. `Y\eac.o’v~c>?§ civic L\s<»§ §a\)m§.r\l \>`“\’zo\l 6 €,C®R\\b\, 1 Y 0(>_`\»\“3!) C.\(\ec¥\ 6\“0'5@,& A\B X\`»E. CQQ\(CM\¥ 6‘€3\'\ 00 \;\'\IL\-C\u`<€_,@ ‘vb `YQ,BCLXCA+\\A-QC§XQ€Y Q@‘c Q\'€ ch u_~>§_~ QQQ 0€£<<.» '\\'\c>. ’§ec\§m\ md ‘oe,ca¢uz\"(\< . \\a\cr \.S \Xc\?<\‘cs> `\Q \\`\& c`_\i en¥`\ne\`€>¥ \0 \n\\- \_\m*v_\aei€) \v\x\€>£&v\¥i.db m`c ‘0'\\\'\\{\.`1 usm eX\¢\i_c_cL\\\l \X`i \'_Q Qe_\<suui\@.\\`v<v\ *cc> 6,(;@@§‘<€0 a‘?\ea Q\\€\\. `\‘v` X§\Q w`\c\e\nce. c;ga`\m\ ‘<\`\m ix ca\s¢\' m\\c\‘<\~a“‘c_\ N\M(\r. \\cm\£~. SGS<R >du“‘<_ is \\QK\\LC, P‘<aék'\c_e. Cmcl`\\< was mX \xcs ‘?mc_&\~c@ in ’d\\s Ca§<;‘)<>.e,\\cmr\§. fl?r%\`c\€;\si\ a. ‘|'9,5'¥\\2.`\< \~,).>0.§ ’O‘Q?\Q~ osgow\ C> Q`('cf Q'C>Y 'Z_(> \{eo§ b CQ\?\\\!O\\ `IR \&> 1\\0°9 \% 103 ’W\L§L§t{\`e,mp,~ CD\>\` ‘c_ <\¢>m§<\e\c\§ \§f\f>~¥ w CLQ§»`<\ €M\ ‘\-\\€~\ c\€§w‘)e Couv\$€\ \\05 Au\`| bus C,¢>\<v\‘<\’\m\’\ w\<e. § m mo»\ .-DQ€<>_Y$ cm& mos*< \<>e,o\n ‘c¢r;m~A Qr¢>_w\ \§ne. §<c>s<;w\x@>v» ira amy -Xucm§ amc\ cow§»;~\<uw\$ mt m~| \o&ai\s mck\\e_ w X\\e_a»r;r:_\>sc§ md ex.o_¢§\,\@v\ *\'0 \<\no&' \»\>\e. '<\e_m\ m§_\o@. Qx§)`-\c>v ed \w_v¢ ‘E¢>\» .>¢\\¢ ¢>Q~Qc~c was cg~ne,m\\\n cL€-m_r.{) equa¥\@\r\ ;\d<<,.» m\\e)n X\\e Af_‘€e_me couwsc,\ ` c\\`\@we ¢\ ~\ém_ §ch Xs: ci<Qm, wi\c\\~c>\)% QZ\\\‘\:>ME§ X\\e,r\é.@er\kcm‘f '\;L\ Xa\é\@_ ix m cl\\,>mw£)) \Qcm\ Xu mv\ rmle\€ `\X., '<>e§ wse couv\se\ \ \ ® _ \ ` 010 mt rem\er §r\\e gmw\‘xeb €;?°€c»_c.\`\\le, 055§3°< mae 69 coun$a\ +he. anns¥\¥u’xicm rcqu`\\~a§ VQ_\§§(>\>M \f Y'vj €S\‘Z) UD 05 20\1_ C_i¥d\mn c;\.waeB zee cnm?m\\’c>v\m§@_ §__0§\@ \: moyer 555 mrs Q;>\"L> Q_~;&@e<m @M:&xca)»

&\DJ¥€D P\Q§\'\Cmi\_€m\\ U\A \<\e_. Q=?,Y‘ch`\°¥_ ch>@ §\:\'u\;l§€i>\fl$€\ ‘C<\‘C. \\GX\”KS \:e\\\(_\e_\m\,`z w& C>\D"B\ €£“\`\\se, SXCW\c\axd (>C '<eo‘b€§m\o\e.~' 4 (\e§§ Qmw\ X\\e. ev*\Ae_Y\c_e_ m \n\`:~> `~'_L~i~\z\’\\o§*<§ mms& 09 `f`\`\§ Gvouv\&?c>‘c X\(\e_~§€<t&\ cloqu icc § c».\b\\v\<\ €`{Q. XOX\'\€. ech\ex\c£ M mm\e, \§m¢asmc§e\e_ r\e.\ exmme,cz% X\\¢\~r %<m~m® \l)u\_ `\&`S c>\{\u`\ gm m>\:\se\\`{\x.\\m<“€`\€~,"©\a@\\e\¥zh AV\A guess uv\c\ ecu\uXa u‘om§< ¥\\e z»;\iic\e,v\c;_¢>n m\\e.nw>\_\ a\\ mm §‘mA @>L>X X\\e_\vc\j\\/\ » \BQ¢ X\nc_ Xr\u\ com § ra\\<\u 'M- 30 wound &\\e&$u\\\ C\Y\L\ CN\€'\C\€Y` Uf \3\£1‘<“<\5 W\QA?_ YCC\SGM\\L Sc>\mb §*`€<£c<§)'~ `I‘.Y\ §‘(Y\§ `c\<\ \f mt L`_M W\i¢§\(w 0\\°\ § 10 \\<§ 'f>l§`“(?jr \C'\§\GU §,)LQO;<X C\QQ\`(\L»\\¢>< ma `\\'\ a¢\~e,o wake Xc>%e_s o\\\c m\\d<\'\c\" coum@\ wa& me§€ee,¥§\)e. c _Qm>\:>w§\ Qc>w '\'Q\’\é€ ?wcs¢ 'T\\Amuo§ mv\c.\u A@ A ap Q\< amf has 9 ai\ec\ w D\m\:e. 0-\¢\~_ mm<@_\ S\'\w\c\ \(\a\)c QQQ@`\MCA \r\\'w\ mem cmnse,\. `K\'\cdc l \:in§'mg is i\z\cmu_¥ Y)?§B\&‘<,`Y<\C\\SXM\¢<§\ aQY\¥cu\r\X_-~‘MACCLCGMP\\U¥ ` a\ow\ wm “Krm\ counsel un c\i\l "\A eo\ \c*>\/OL\X‘/ club .` `CRRSNNSX QU}\\\I®\~ 73 350 19 Y\\T)C) hinan c»Q:Q\§Lcm‘c moe wCQ€m/g&\n¢.

C&¥Y\Q\rur\\’ cL\:r>L>\r \n\."> `\`<‘\¢L\ mumSe\ &LKcGV\S (Y\\". \'\a\"("»§ c\v§\ '\I\E>'c W€bv\‘co\ md 159 wm §¥a¥eme ¢\\' \>\/ m%s{\\\mh‘c L\\QL`€\ &\\Q vecm~<~é\w\dgee,'-." [P\P\\ \Jo\ ')_Y B‘TS' ‘\Q Y-\\§e> '\rec\\cwv‘¥ \,sc»§ §c\ C:vmv Qc>‘€ m‘< '-\e\\‘\~@_\ \_z \\qq\\cw com\`\\\$\cw\ r<\<)\\\\ %;\»u¥ hzmu\f\) \r\om, manoqu Cmnz e\ 4 » ®

T\r\e_x\ \\`\5 X_<\u\wms@.\ mo€) c;L\:o\>\c w hamm c. uzecnnc\ Qmse;c\>¥ev @¢v ZXche, Y\m\ \`(\(.\5\0¥\‘\§ wau\}§§m<`cc\&“\i 511va <<`§Uv\' Xe$’<`\§`| mg O‘f\ ’éx\e_ §\cmc\ . "Y< m\ acm‘x_wnc_\\>c\e<\ X\ne_ mg Q'\Z wm <\\§<`Y\@ Q¢\ec\ Mo%c$b€;<;\ja _C>€DU(\(\ Qc>r`€€,\\'€§ _\`QY\`» /[`fi(.`x\tb\>‘(‘§c Qm\cl\:\daé (\?Q\{Cmr\\\’\ub _Q'C@\€A 30 Ym\m_ ~'\B:`c\i &\'\e§)usre, ijec>cv\‘c¢c\ QL\\S?.X€_SXRMN\] (X\§q, \\Y ?\§C;;m"( hub Qc{\\eé kg §Mv\sa ~`\X\c\\ Vne.‘;>'\<\\a \:cL$\QA `\:0 3a s 8.\£>3& ev‘\denc_e . @ ?\w§% @Q Q\\ .<>QQ\‘\L¢L\<\X mem-39 ~X\~'\a\ ?c>r (A A¥_te'mq¥eé Cc®\i\u\` Y`f\\\‘vc§\ex U\('_'\\ L'mA mud Cci¥\\!{r;&e& \d‘~i c»A\\\“‘|. I;(\D\Cc\er"`>@ mx\§¥\\\\\\§_ ` Hwa§ c‘_\nar§e Y:>%W\l'\c,¥`\<v\ 'i)am\§ ~"Ta‘l\o\~ mud £>S(`_a\v ?\<>v\e\i \'wc\‘:f> Y~>€/ b‘nc\% b*l .-<l(`:u‘<\. @ T\'\.Q.re_ marc nw eig<»x’_\ :Q\<\`Iz);mcmf> w ’L£’_;b‘<l?`l w 902 ‘\`/Y:_ 0("\3500¥\(\5\)53§ odn-Q.A b`/ ¥\ne, \!§C:‘<\W\ ‘(‘&O`F um‘!`~ dodd .'@bv §§ g CL\\(D¢ 5€\{\\`§ 15 eo\mc\ `m 0§\>\{ Cmv\ Xriu\vewv<\, nm\\\`mc_'\ 31wa m\" ‘&0\0€:/ mark 'cn\ \\\€> wave_,. T\\e_ ‘{m amu\<¢, (`3`_€31931.1;3)0;9_1;:_£ \\6'\€.3¥\¥~¢\0~@] C.\(\CN&'LX€:<§?,"\¥\¢\\Y\€» Y\o‘m;\l `\v\ km\/' dic\ m'&_ wpqm~i ~¥3\€_ ‘_')`Y<x’§e.§ \0-&§'\”(§€!\ L§Q ‘@\re> 531 m\\_a;n \\e,\(,{\gq\i~v,<§ ms%@m; if:`>~o<"/ gm \w\q¢'m'€,w\a‘mw~u _SCCQ~&\¥D\.ES ? 3012 23#2§> n chm'me.c\<c_ X€:>\`\m>w) $c\`\e\ `\X was cm tian \, w_m\>\m§ A\na‘c \edhe§ \'_(> hamer \o`l a \c,e_-Qccl<w \ :>XQC`_‘<-\ w Q\Q<‘,Q 156 3\0§.3 '€QL\\~\ a hf&)\¢\ex\ \_u`w\dow sed$%¥b\\@'?\\\[§>o%u"€ YQ‘_\,‘§QQ,L;\@\~ mi‘§\eaA ihe.Amv m§‘<\n @\\u€>\¢>f\ w -mv\-e:/;*\§_Sve.,\'v¥w%d~e.nu. bmos¢.w\ av) \c»u, '\?om\»\edh_‘v-e&€?\\ w Mv?\mc)}` 303qu :~+Y\um 'ma@\e_\a§é§:ceozwab\¢ on.)`oX muva \JMAS S\`n&‘< w"\‘c\<\ &(`9\)\¢§ ‘€\ne,`?*sc>§ec.o‘w mow\c\ \1@\>€/ Q\s\\~ ®\9§ <Mv\e`{\{\nd 69 dotomeu¥$ C\\W\‘<\@w§%v ?\IMQ,XC> X\<\&,~Qckmw\c¢\»<, \/\<’- was mw\§\_o\\a\ \n<-»_ he\:`e\m\ Me.mc\§>w@é¥<@§ mm X<> S\»o\n ¥\n¢ gmi CLS w;\\£\nwc '(V\r md m3 0@\7'(`3@€,>\0 ex é>\m §'>\oz,& wou(\(\" ®

‘SC>\T\_Q 53¥\5§§’ \lo\`> com 5€& C\€.cw \decao*>e, R ~f\X\r\e,\`é_co'<‘é\@&nA X\ae reco@ dev`\?\ l~`\ €_ a ~ `T\'\e_ ch>‘ze_c_\-_;\O~c C>X\A\Y\r.¥wme`/ §CLRK\GP_`QQUO i)\\.c>>¥ ¢D€CLP\‘°\Y\!C>\>\\?' \‘45"* \`\°D \»§\\vu\ +»~ marked ch><l¢_§§ D\\‘\'\XXEA f_\IiA€X\C?. Cr w\€f.'> ‘rcaswa\o\e. AQLM\ ibm A<A m>§c DX\n er L,_s\§e_ eisz ‘<\ne, Con\)it`><wv\ \\'\\>§x ha re\/@ma\@ 5<:@ -W\ecmem \¢L¢> \¢\n cm "L°L‘\.b§ \<>b 59 S¢c,><,, mann g ga \) \m'\mg,_ \&_ m § 13 .-\\ »\~' 3(33*¢_<¥ may g U\'E;&\§\B:L%_ _ ‘\..\x\xex\ X.\m 3 x"\ck\. cc>wn‘:)e.\ is\& \\m»_ Q\.\\:\Agc, \r\¢_\\f\\v\‘€) `m& C;\‘\ ua¥ `\e a\:m¥ Xc:> Cx>mm\X ?cv dm\] mah~¥\nc 3\35\3¢_‘€1“1\») OQQ\€ cmX-om§ ' Xx\&\ 'Cb\>`f\‘z' e_\ \<\C\A Cv\ Cc>v\% \:`\c_-’\ l~<\\<,\cX \_».\`O<\n ~€ML.\\ ®\\(\ju\ whom X)ne_ Wf bsac_u\m~ m\b\:za<§ X\'\r_. ¢\_.\yc\] u>\\\’\ C).\\\,\°b`\ov\f> XC> `(\N\~Qi‘\":‘¥&v\* €_`\) "\c\ex\c_e_ XN\@X ‘\X w imitch *<~\<\<,\\c\ u~\ §'\:mc\ cxw\.‘»_v\>i a\\\| wawa (i§i§%jm\ov\ "¥~\'\\5 m\yc‘< 5\&\3\€\.\1;‘3€¢\ X\<\e, Q~"\.\r\ARv\ 5 09 Q-O\Ci<.»:<\e‘c <_’~,L;p<{o\`§xec\ \b\l`\§nb<€m*& Cm}\ wrme \egc»\ 'C¢>v\c-.\\)S~§ow> Cm_& cs‘c¢\er~ ex 6~\'¢\.5 X~(\c:\\.

M ud‘<\ eve;&c><\e_~d\s\e_ uYQ\\wv\Y.. ?\” cri 'X§m&_ `L\r\'\ 3 Cc>uv*c< c»_'\c mw “ck\@, ®\>Y\\um`)fb &\0;\,.€_\:¥\0'<\3 %o.‘XhQ C_c>\>‘c“v_?`mc\"m%§ S`c'%a£:\ <m§x - ébnc_\\sa'\¢>\n s (>Q \0»3 '\’)ecau§e. .up§\\crm"\ c§\"\é\ ¢>\o`le,c)<ém XD \">az>r C_\u~`(\ af Toxm\n\ cwan .e>w\ §S€c\ \\~10‘€) »- mak w ¥}\Ci C\\A mm 3`\\/:_ &Qq\iccm% X\\e:\e,n 'Act/§ \r\c.`s cL\\D\,M§ Xc> ‘~`¢;\Qc\ us\\\»\ B§>wcj umm.»c\wb ep’< ab 10\5 X\ae~) m@\c\e 360va \:`\K\ c\'\ meza (3? Qua’x amc\ C.c>Y\L\\>S\®v\ @€ mud \\r\e_x\_ va M\l:’> \C\\e:( c>v\ SCQ\ @\yzf>\é X‘\'\L 133 c\(§€. S§Q\\\ec\ <:\QG 0\{\§ 3c1 63`\£\ \ _ X3\0..3\>€\ 3e,`*¢&\§>cm \r>c>\<\ C>\\Q,€` `~*\\»©`3 b 50 U\R\`\'.co»v\'\ 0:°>\’\ `»\\g_\ 5c3\e. M§K\B\AU t\r\o& >¢3.\@<\ `<Q\Y\xub °\\a€_, 13\:1`>&€3<\01\;' Q\QOQ ec><\>\\j zubm\\“\é<\ ', . T:)R'v\i\`\§$m\$§§~ <\>;3';3 m \'\'\O\S”><€ \"(\c,(lmne.,\\\\m:\>( "300\ 5. §'.\/m\`\©<` \?3‘¢ QN `\\\¢e,\_ “\'~1'1<6\01 'C.Q_'c 'T`\Q `\ Lo¥e..§@ §-U\r"\*le ~_ , b\\<:\nab \<)e_<,v\. \\¢\0€\\£3 ’<e>. to\>v\oQ §§ch new .a>,(--£"ne 0\:) “I‘_.`f ‘vm‘\`.nu\ `G§Qw\, Y@B¢\, `}\'\'BZJO'<S\ CCN`\\C>\ %>‘<&X‘xc>~c\\\\u§i\v\ 1 ’Y-k '1<5’1\\. ' 'Q/mum/:Q§_v;l-_§`l O'i~\"l' \?3 E`l\\r\`\\a`\ “€5 \:-"-`*\“`\\3`\* 33 1\\0€\\ wm w -»\>\w\ .-‘§<¢m wx\§“msm\mo@zx\ @\ "'<`c><_‘ C-»vm‘(\A ‘_-">`\`)\ / am\ `C~smo‘<\a\ "i Y\€€.€ 5'<@\303 E,a§\\‘<., ’E_`/\Y\\\)\\ §§ \_\§\(\\’_Y\ §\C\\t_€ \\E.A X\<'\C`\<` QKC>\ GSCB Q\n A`m(:$ 09 €&L\ CmA C®na\u§\ov\ &Q \0\\3 SQQX 'z\ m\§ `C_`/\\(\\\j \ C `\\(\Q §\3&3€. 5\0.\£\\\<\& X_\n.e_ S¥o~\e. °<`€_r_i>mme v\c)§ am SQYX ®A\"Lo\& f ,Client Recovery Plan - Full Report worth Texas state Hos` iran

Name: DAV|SI|,E|NN|S lVlPl; 277237 Epi: 2 ' '- ' - ~~ Admit Date; v10/20/2011 P|an Date; _11/8/11 ` » End Date; P|an Tyge: Review and Update _Elan Name:1 14 Day Recovery P|an Review Status: Finalized 11/9_/2_Qtt

Formu|ation; l`Mr`. Davis met with-the treatment team on 10/28/11, for his multi disciplinary case conference. The patient's primary *"*`__*/"language is Engl_ish. , _ - v Kennedy`s`ub' scales by the treatment team on 10/28!11: l t.Psychologica| lmpairment - 30 as evidenced by his irritability, evasiveness, claims of auditory and visual hallucinations statements of grandiosity, and claims of impaired memory. - ' 2'.Social Ski|ls - 30 as evidenced by his lack of soci_al'relationship`s and lack of understanding of the feelings of others_ 3.Violence'+'30 as evidenced by his history_of physical aggression towards others. including incident leading to most _ 4.ADL/ 0ccupatio _ maintain a'home., l ,. _ _,, . _ q ~ 5.Substance Abuse `- 50 as evidencedby his history of,a|cohol.and drug use.

S.Medical lmpairment - 60 as-evidenced by his history of multiple medical problems. ~ » ~ 7.Ancillary lmpairment - 20 as evidenced by evaluation and/or disposition being made for serious criminal charges such mm someone. ' ' ‘ nal Ski|ls.- 39 as evidenced by his educational levell unemployment and inability to independently ' Diagnostic _Summary and Case Formulation:

. 1. Reason for Admission: This 41 year-old Black male was admitted to North Texas 'State»Hospital'- Vernon Maximum Secur_ity Unit on 10/20/11 pursuant to Article 463.073 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure after having been found » _ incompetent to Stand Tria| for the charge of Attempted Capita| Murder, out of the_3,9_61b_District&ggr_t`o rr nt Texas. The.patient was committed to this facility for the specific purpose of eva ation and treatment towards the:'goal of regaining-competency to stand;trial-. Current commitment is set to expire mbc .. . 3. . t» 2.` Hypothesis Concerning Pa'tieht's Condition: The police report stated that Mr.'Davis alle edl‘ s " ex- irlf ' and ' the man she was dating"with. He was found incompetent to stand'trial while housed in the Tarrant County Jail. Pati‘ent has _ | received outpatient care services from MHMR of Tarrant Co`unty from 02-16-94 to 06-25~09. w 4 ‘ 3. 'Statement of 'Planned Treatment: The primary goal of treatment will be competency restoration l\_.".r.` Davis vvill be offered psychosocial treatment interventions within the social-learning matrix of activities on the`Competency Program . and its point economy system. Psychiatric treatment and interventions will include prescribed medications with adjustments as clinically indicated targeting Mr- DaViS' PSyCh°§is and aggre§si°"? medication education targeting increased knowledgell insight, and judgment relative to medication regime, purposes, and mana_gement;'on-unit psychosocial interventions targeting an increase in safe, appropriate self`and interpersonal management skill development, and competency education;,Competency Group; yll/lock Trial;. Goal appropriate On~Unit and Central Rehab Group / C|asses; and COPSD to treat co-occurring mental illness and substance abuse. Weekly contact with members of . `the Treatment Team to develop a Personal Safety P|an targeting appropriate management of aggressive / negative impulses; monitor progress towards discharge goal of his return 'to court as“havi"riglh;et the" criteria lfé"M;§;e;j;;gy_ _Lig_adqg`;n$o€a| WoH<?rto contact Tarrant County'MHNlR Services - Forensi`c Mental health, Fort Worth, to assist the patient'i developing an aftercare and support network. _ __ ' '

1 4. Evidence of Treatment Success / Discharge Criteria: Mr. Davis will pass a formal competency evaluation. _ / _ 5. issues identified but deferred to later time or other Treatme'nt~Provider: None at this time.

Mr. Davis was involved in the planning and development of the treatment plan. He does not have a legally authorized representative Mr. Davis is aware that Tarrant County MHMR Services- Forensic Mental health._Fort Worth will be contacted monthly and provided with updated progress reports. He has signed consent for his sister, and the social worker will provide monthly contact ontclient's treatment progress and discharge plans. Proposed treatment was explained to the patient,and he indicated that he understands the explanation provided." Diagnosis; From Diagnosis lnput - Entry Date; 10/20/2011 ` - Date; Descrigtion: Axis l: ' _ PSYCHOT|C DlSORDER NOS EOCAlNE DEPENEENCE Axis ll: . _ . ' ' - DlAGNOS|S DEFERRED ON AXlS ll, DlAGNOSlS OR CONDlTlON DEFERRED Otv AXlS l Axis lll: .. - ' - ESOPHAGEAL REFLUX CORONARY ATHEROSCLEROS|S OF UNSPEClFlED TYPE OF VESSEL, NATlVE OR GRAFT PERSONAL H|STORY OF OTHER lNJURY BACKACHE. UNSPEClFlED UNSPEClFlED ESS'ENT|AL HYPERTENS|ON l CC\@j /\`\(\\` 9 3a é;Q<-]\ , l \ rr . . t a e of 5 tet\nib`\’r (l\\ tex E>fro\s\'v\$ix 1 tex Grouv\¢).”\\\*<-e<§:%<@mm,\dap 9 ‘.

~{201 1

SHAREN WILSON \ Criminal District Attorney Tarrant County september 2, 2015 Mr. Finnis Davis II TDCJ-ID# 1779538 McConnell Unit 1 3001 S. Emily Dr. Beeville, Texas 78102 RE: Davis, Finnis ll - Writ No.: C-396-010409-l 199412-A Dear Sir: Enclosed please find a file marked copy of the State’ s Proposed Memorandum, 'Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LaW in the above listed case which Was filed this date With the . Tarrant County District Clerk’s Offlce.

Sincerely, '\. /¢: 4/%/; Frieda i\/chillin Litigation Specialist POst-Conviction Enclosure

401 WestBelknap ' FortWorth,Texas 76196 ' 8]7.884.1400 "l=`~ti\€\`\\p`\`t “~ §§ -- ___. l- lL L) THoMAs A vviLDER TARRANT coun`rl\)'.lsii§)(<:,i§RK

_ No. c-396-010409-1199412-A SEP 9‘* 334 mae §j/j/B¢'M/ EX PARTE § IN THE 396“‘ JU¥)'LcLA,L._//i”£ nequ § .

§ DISTRICT COURT oF . § , _ FINNIS DAvIs n § TARRANT CoUNTY, TX ORDER The Court,adopts the State’s Memorandum, Findings of F act and Conclusions of Law as its own and recommends that the relief FINNIS DAV[S II (“Applicant”) requests be DENIED. The Court further orders and directs: g l. The Clerk of this Court to file these findings and transmit them along with the Writ Transcript to the Clerk of the Court of Criminal Appeals as required by law. _ 2. The Clerk of this Court to furnish a copy of the Court"s findings to Applicant, Mr. Finnis Davis II, TDCJ-ID# 1779538, McConnell Unit, 3001 South Emily Drive, Beeville, Texas 78102 (or to Applicant's most recent address), and to the post-conviction section of the Criminal District Attomey's Office. _sIGNED AND ENTERED this ff day ofM, 2015. ' §%GE PRESIDREGG l l:_l\\(t"\\n"\ \ ~' C, \\\ '\ \'-X‘L 3>°\\;“\ \>\& %\e'\ \<:I\ how T.t>:?\ht&\`¥ too\~\"\ v'\ T“\i)< HS EX?AV\`X ’\1` n t _\\\e. c»:>>‘u»,~_c>\o»\oq~\\@\@\\\\a-R Fa NN`\ssm\&T INTP\I>O\SU:C<>\A 'T we \\‘?QUM`V 555 E'US jo K\R‘?.STP€\ E,`e’ ‘\°\'\i€>‘?`»m§ §_;\; oP?oss'\:cD\~\§ to \\?P[SZC?<M€) A¥Y\lcnn"\`\sn‘€sa\mtw se \-\d?>ens Coroos. 'R\'\c»_ 5\. `

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.