Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Miles, Kojuan J.

Miles, Kojuan J.
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided September 18, 2015

Miles, Kojuan J.

Opinion

211-15 VHZ-15 Mo',

Xa Tttfc COORY of C(^ivm^al A?P6/VL$ sr^re of ^*AS

SEP 18 2015 ^ AbelAco8ta,Cierk "^ S*/vT5 of Tw*as, ^poock^ ^

PeuTiDii f6^ \>\SC&gT(6y}A(ty fes/ig^J FILED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS SEP 18 2015 Abel Acosta, Cierk

ftojOan J. Mi\es fo* Se, *T/^&L§ dt CM&S

J- *w* V, Alo^Kc, ,^ *.c*. Hot, (^ To *' Poster V, "Tey^ <*S 5X4, iob5^<bs). -hi

16 •Shelly tf. Sfc^ tris. 6tiU 544tT«.Gr.Aft. fitft)

TA6l£ OIL i6l£S

\a T«,ca5 ^W of 1&s/wUnce ^RoU \0V (0 1- te^s fcjk of 6aiAencer Ut H6H b ~ft THg jMoftABlff CasRT oF cRjvnuw^L AP£sms:_.

jSTAiTjEf^veisiT Ree^ftbMfr OPAL.jV^om^t "TKe pe44< frcierr._y^a ts onzto&oa iVs sw&er p/z* $e i$ no)~ cu^r^.

Arao ^£(s-tAe6)r^JA\.ws_caJi±#_A6_so^_fs*bij3A£rJd^^Y—^-^- •0" J * • .* &cqS a,mrht(4:\ Uol/255 Ac. ..6&jJc4rJLe.e£ft^_5a_uiduLlA_c*iJ-_i.n -better.

_gmTgrtv/\^r of THE CASE' J^J^i&ber_Jft,_^

Jk^c^i f^)(4- flf Ham6 feprfy, Te*aS, &=i*e& ofo* 4ke jO^-j ^«fr, ^r^S^iief^eaCSJ^^^^^ IM^BBOML _V\ \Sv6?W

;4ke_atao^_e^ftOJ^ 0_pv__feb_O_Ca(V_ 1} jx£>au1* 4W \or^j cfcVupfY€^ ex \fexoicV of _4u il:w v_ac>A (>) lA.lJSL)_J^JL5^Caoii_cx0a.CS^eA pe^ Atar* era W\oT16isi T6 EfcTEKflD TWeesg. sc<>c>eec^oa6 €bUou>.

GROUPS fofc ft€N/iSvJ

*« UV\e4W or-noV-\W AmcA foadr cArtseA Als Agcr&VxsQ

ffrSUHuUftCiy 5^A-T6NVg^(

^ ceV)0-r i&UA -Hve. <k4ecMfrp. trAerflfeUA <as 4egAifWW

testing )~Hre> defease. g^abLi_.p.fsffeC-^e^£r^JLp^^_aoA.

_fod:^ife-«uJJ^il£1_d£fenSe_ <:ooa&eAJ^Ai_A scejrvL{\ak_.fe(bj«r obitdtdfY] or 6-H\er^tS6} ^rffccA-voci 4ta_£efofi &C \a4^.r_appeaL eo _cec«^e-.C-eA_Acod6i._ AW ao4bc(4« oW_ of ^W-«WA^-CAp^5-«_(-^-eflod:eds. _^Wcs.u^_Cdjic£r&*M^ e«yip Sag iy._

^A_Joas«0-<^bfiC^JIkaj*s SoYeV-j oooa ike_c^k\[a^c^£ik^_^ j4b^Jb^_u!>^^^-V^Q^_(^^- ^ysi) Ilta^ckfa^e5_(Ba&M\\^^

^b^4vle_o^<xs_i^^Spe\l_tW_?^^ -tatc ie^c*xxv|,. (id. 44 \H^« Xr> cMrveriAxdsc Abe. osfrV uaoolA W\^ 6W) Ak/a(\of^ VS \\_€AQ^_OA_4k^_uifee$5-54^(NJ. &e_ 4W-1 as J- maJ 14W 4*\ic<A_ . . . _CoOf4L_reN^me6Jt^

f>k_f,^<Yq'"4 ^ ^f2»sVA^p VrrtMP Q^-^ \H1~tH5) - gfiA ^_ ^Cfeftfre. (M.cA (Sd),

CO _ JrN^<> g&VJ64ftvffC TO "\Hff CJLMwy

_.. Other 4taxo. Ai-e^^nof-ioi' avoa 000x^5^ u>e~ Wx>^_o6_Q_rc>£<f.

f&J-^V^^^* ^^ use 4b ^odu^^jKouieuec^v^iib^J^a^oa^ 4ctx>ie^ei fuc fe^ W>cAe vo^vAK A>iW4_x»A1h4fiMk---caA _W.. \b-e^eA

SocteO<\(5kso6_«-C-^'A^vTlL_^_^ _uLe-_-aI^c? Kooi^ YWA e>i„eo \>efac£_ b64b A\.-ejL_aoA Mr*.MA*&^£er_k£Sr ^o(4i^_Car4lo*\ v$Jcve.

*ca^. ^ ftf. ^^)--— _ -

fernJ^rve _oXc3e/c0fAw^_±^uS<^ L$i^JSke__C:£vJ_eY

_MA bim 4o Qirr\e_a^_\>eCr(_(lA^Lll5JM^ e>/.eo 4-6 4W_p6,o3: _0_f__C_(>| lOd -(2& •")_ * fir A\e^ A-V»crt jj^o^J^_cv_brlaViA' so^y.AKe_e(v^>o4^ri u\AV AVe ofAug* SV>e ko<y> 4r\\g, 06Uce gqo\^ Welp Wc^LL V\U V^O) , e^ An ei^oc^vZe 4Y*l ^Ovcv^ Mef e>JeA_Ara>Ai\£v«A 1*0 . 4W*i - ^4 jx_^A^D___aVo.cM3v_j^v«. utoj- -e\ie<\4bouaV^ oJbo (v>> of- oescfte _juu«c& <xrooc\6_ joA$>i&e 4W_ ^Wlj. QQfte <& 4W(V\ aPcxaaiPe^ 4& b^ _<^ jHrve.K^rA osVvs u^Ai^Welo-Sonseooe. \<v <ks4^ -X3^- H^l^Ajlh^ _Ybi6 &-iochca4.ivfe 4W4 AI^hc^aoC^v. .uiauS Jboku>a for <x u>xu oof

Tbe&t are a,Yl 4kc4§__dC Co^^rxe m <k>ern^,r*j 4Vv£ dinumeA offense._L^Jk*A:j•'Vb«- prfereA evidence u*>pt e^e(\Wy fa&b jj^eA Aof ft4Ver 4Wf\ ftna4ioa cWnracA-ei; <y>ryfAnvu4y^4e(Y)toa

^r

_44v5c5gh^ 4baf 4ta_:dc*H-iS Sta uie£Lr5-a3jJl_.b£._4Ke cU4ec«\iALa^_fttd^r__ _aL^bdlA\4r_6ke_cs^^ Ja^5_4V 6kcfe uibot ujstaiW oC.ditaeCi^s^ £&-rs aoJts_(v\Ci4ccalk €cre^m_oGD$4j4(J_4e_^ _\> isAike^AjJe_o£qoesiioj^Laa Ca.$>4 -Hr>c<4 hah 4 ofoA._. JWiAr (\6&i0n. (jJJ^kAfc^ibe_^8£_^^

t5) <\6 m^44^C_hcto6 4Ke SkjYfe.?fci<nfcA -Hve.»r obyLcYtor^ (AfclWoY^,*fy _ioWcecY rNoAore \S 4V»aY of <* cWm 4VmA- e>$Aenc£_AS_Woa -jiffeceA_^r4^e__46ie oorPoQc 4o AllLksArziAne ckomcYer coAfermtA^^ oa(S 4^06Jicreies[ctn4. R<xa\W M- S4a4e 1 °\Hl StAi.za 7<nj£re£. ..

C^m. A^ A9ftb)_Y cYioa V^n4aor0^f <. S4cv4c ..$IQ S*ia3>7^_ 3T2-(re*' Cr»(vS.*..AoP.. .i5S..iy*. PeYtkoryec QrdensA-aruitS 4kis 4& aveao_.4kaA^e-C^^A.^_aoai^5i5,.-(A5kLch i3 4t> beAPp.heA _.acl_«u$.cW Si4oaYu>o5 ^\n4&U e^cc.o1 eYerrn tnaAvan <sf uokeYb-er YK-e.^r&ff-e.cfed e>J-vA_ence makes ec A^cA~_df._cor£^qu-erv'e ivr>> 4Vk^„ca5c^-m6(iE_^robdale ... As jsock-^Yke Yc\od g&gCY .<xksse/£ .^fe^AiSccekoa^kexa^ <^PPM Ak^__s4on<kicc) ^ a&fecmine. .re\&v£a.iY6J_ a<> YerrvarvYecY Wi MoAA^aorveTy^ tUntift NJ-aAak^Hl Sj^za _<^ 1&{. ?_r» _\Hj£^„4kecacff >^k^toAer o^jAbtilrJhdk 4rke cjo^oa* __d_o_jf>£ eiemerv^L.SA^k Se+: a3Yak^a„malCie_4^-f^S6tb/ljiy of- ^f^bricaWi^fmCfr ordbabk 4k<\ oot£_ IViJkdfi Sm>4b t&# Sixi. 3ci S3 £W f_ Com ..Art?* ^ >4 a<vsu*t(S-AvS. <joe$<koa etaart^ EWeAce Aee^--0^ k/ 4^eJ^_p0i^.or: Aspfavfe a ^ar4toikr W

^vdeose v^^-AoY^dceA ^ a por^W:_dfcec_4bacN..ckxOLc4€r .

(0 CbofecroiW..*j»o «od_jfe.iy\c4iA5> ff^e '.of Ql<U oif»«er C<DAa4t4<i4t£>ftaA gr _64?5cti4$rc| prdkk4i£<\s >xi is reU4ar>4« YVoefsce, p*44ton-£r SdW^ 4W4} Wc^e no ftktekiAopy 0c carsfrkAdYtafYil o(aV>ibi4frsn 4a \hf> \.(\4ca&o0oltor> of 4Avl cuca pV>&46ci(roioks of Al^^b^irca^ 4b^ 4o a^ete acjcvu6stb(c)4k)\ rei&feAk

mr

TRUTH 15 -DiSCos;eR(SP kH ^TdOfJfe-STAl6*f4T5 6M £>OT(4S(D§5 ofWc7£§

fHiY&f\er Uk)o\<l SobftuY 4ba4j4K& t)ncM<S4qA^_GsoisJito4fo^ l A<vygr^Mp^Y \f\ t provTiA-is fee krft 4U^ riahA- 45 W,c^far4fld ui *Ht tine JL^JMfn£J^^ ^fe^^^jaYr^SCLJ^^^

CfuA .Aft. 1%^ JJ&^h_CaMSS^ ^^ QWjf^ rvge^te. iWJhW 'm- 64a4^j 6>7<j Su^Zd ctY °l f ^Miofyer 62t<\ a4 Jvsacgre^.

w 05v4U 4W \erti Yve>Y ^W 4W LsJA*4es afv5 feAefcA cul^ jmKe^ _Wfe, bfWt W44cfAe oftjer 44e foa^4-4AoA 4o esYibb^b roles excidckfsk £viAeoct,?ram .c^^»<^4^Vrv^ • Holmes Nf» vSx^ Car6\t^l H-4, S*<4> n3\(w^V? Q>4eA &Wbs_^ Sobd&c^U J^^J^E'l-^!^-. Ac£orc^3k v^^. kMole_ W_.Wk, 3SF v4- Q&t f^Aj ^^ -AW, acaVtY 4o Yoa\ is akA^a^A L

4o s^rJe « Holies t 12% S.cY af H3k

5S5 j (ao^ Tex. Com* /W- i-e^s 5*3^)^ Yh^ Gsud-cdoAiou-cA^ J*la_fta_Mve. rficvSoA>Q4 4k*f \p 4^65tL Ccjfg SiAuoAtoM iy> (>Ahioh cipp liable rul^ of eJiAfa<j& caofdc1-* f^4k federal <basfcfeicsivd_ naU^S ) M&. 101 (V) ceaoire^ 4baYA4ye Coc^itAJJ-iotn af tbe^_ cJr^l-e.A £Ufes C/y\to% Ovter 4b^ejtJ-cnAicgy u)k* 2cf

differed NtkrstQ.ivS of edervk^ ike-cefc,ne-< e^beo caiwe 4a a4ktokj 4W crecJikb-w or A4e*aAoViq Qo6fitbU 4s fg-vfe^l paJ-dpYuJ W^-es, (.WcrrauSe me feel UKg gamete) (jUl'VMy^J 1or olA-epoc CO _jon5W<a:4io(\ (V ^eopfctgJlb^-.l-tyve^e- Sbe <kY:$bcolA kfc$e_beeQ-Q. ..p f6p.ec.._anci. tc^flct^Q^. fuA^oA of.„os6S e^rn<o<ikoa,„ ^^^t_y4^ 4W, V-oa\ C6pf4 g/vi A^pglUk, 6ajfr)£- ^-tic<mjno4«gA.)..Ha<YWV€C afaavf^,^ __anj 64f>eC^_aio^j^ a<Ys wooAA_4end A&_ coa&Y 4ate£.cmo.re^iok)^ _.. fte-Ceu/ae 4W n,(cjbt_4o c©f»(WY_aA^ xcz>&S__e^afYviAe- iS. ^ars . - wbicY is Abtf osurxkyi <:on6AYJYar>a( q^A, PoioAex, Sfro o,s, a4 tyoo %5 SxY _cd- (0fo5, pr5htbiAinci €y^.m»na4toA <ks«)ne<L4o ^e^poSe fc> Aj^ ^u~ry YV\£^ -kiote &brr\ uSWcVi \UTC>05 ^- Cc5iik pXSSibfy ^a«^ \nfecence JBlakmM.Abe-cteAikk4y of <rk-.ca*W Dao $ ^ .Atctsto t H^O^A- Jke. tef\fa\4*fcW<\ dao5eW 6<£0fecl* Ttw5 , 4bi3 ax>f4 skxjlY re*Ji€uo 4W AfYYofl ..Wau«&d__o64_aoU _(LA_ibe_4^^L6aac4„ ne4 cocickbJ-Jke_ celeiancv|iam)^$ts <m<^aAWL ^_bAooAc»of^eW.^k^.JDaSiS&rgty ^.vk.u$Oi>\£ 4Yen 7oe^ef JcLOo_ci_ \oAo vYf6 reASor^A. ooSi<^e<3skaft_$j)_i*JbeAbef Abe. A^kfrasrW—TeiaYc^_ _fc_ 4Yc ra^ ^Vv^gra^, ^^ ^-^^kk^e.J„^__Ykc. om^oce oT- absence cf c&rrabor^Ym or cot\4^cYv^Yi.Dti_4.e6Y.pooM.a\ -imA^tU _p6unA$5._j. VAbe \<Y\pofWce of Ai-e*anOOa5} Are&fimarJ 4o YVvc pf&5€C^k^X

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.