Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Hartwell, Ross Allen

Hartwell, Ross Allen
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided December 30, 2015

Hartwell, Ross Allen

Opinion

V. 5 Tb* 0755-/5- 0R|G|NAL TKjl S4-&>Ul of \c\(x3 J "* From Kml\ Mc? iyi4-O?0Y7-<^ DECEIVED in" DEC 3 0 2015

~?^K \>\SC?xLT^A?W fevMEL*T AWAcoaa.Clerk Woaor&bL 'SuAtes OF tUa Court 0£ fyp^ls; (!o<wrb f\CM 'ftoS'S /\\W HfiOWIeW^eAiViOAcr, WffclA. W- res^d^UW files 4\^ Of ^U.TSole-5 Of AppCi U^?roceiuf ev A*vc\ tw. SoppcH ^^K«GODWI^pMAkv'8P?€ALS Of ^ offense of /Vgjr^jaW^kry UC&cA^i^i^\M^-!^^31 s^yle* V)>s4r^ fox* of A^'Mk ftmv/.cW via* AFFllSHP^ &*A«^ sa^"**

oa (ko^di^-^ ?e^^bAcr is net enMW'k V^fcrA irep^^^ »* «Mr

for \X^fcto.wy W^ oa StfWitr lfe,&>/5&ul iU«s;tu* &y* ^ Cr,^^( TL

Uriefj^taThif^^L V.V.ct fo^ta Appals \Mpnptrk, appVed £Wz&V, ^-WVe, n^vXf.tfvi, b$p&oi£) k ocAdc\d "t>£FEA 4k cK'.ai beCfci/^ "-^Vw ree^vis f>r4f,&l ftxMsek toui^ct &> not £pp*fir k4k ceeorcl &*v<\ * (s ppssibl€ -\M kr foi^txt CoM Wstvie b^j2iA_ grc^cle^ k le$iVtiwrk4r'\e4 sta*4eyy ,v* fe ^jSaytf ul mlMviV^ Vlkw re-ev/aVj»cc\i>Aip 4kLSD<LC<'f <^s 0f4^ (i^n &\ \jw\& ,V\r\»Wr irtspeaJi/CUi fefuc^ 4Ks CftXt \(j? CowsItUr 4k f(?(k/Y^ 0 4k. R\l^v\BL\a\t record. IV^ viwTie^ce. frc**. tk4 Sta*V<^M v/c^s "'& oJrAaeo^ -\ta-f fto Com-pe-Wt &4*ori/i£y ^^^ ^avle- Qm^a^ k it." -sa^s \/« Strk, \\o,~o\-\ \- ooqXo-cK CCv- of i\^. \ss "bvsi. &V5 )TeV. Kpf U*^ S\ 3^ Z/'Uwtor 4k &cM of4W C&s<l\ mt £k llevuM* 4k^rc^-pec4we_ jjror or at k&s4 RsV^^a- CcMdI \(4k4iv/-e tfues-Vi'c^s *u/a>A wTt tu*f£ taW &ccept&kk kkl sStaW X/ftS^flz V. SVttU.^fl sa^^^ HexXV: Ap/>.flfl^£w\ H?k>UOX^( wfifc&Sl is nc* 6^cuW^('M"vv[&3^e^j3P5AJ^Aat W-/.

3. Afvv gcAr\ewvp-V 4o 'V^'S P^3 yurfbrvKAt* k (^k^oc^Ap, wkmev/er -Vk 'f \Av«fiOi4;«vvi^ ^4 evIlAeM Pfl^kfafcrA ftrYXi*£«*4ed forHV fir^rV4«>^jf]eilV aifcrre^^^lW4e^ fcXiewJ.. hft*e l,kk v/Aki^s re^;noikS,p^ fox*5 auAr'^ jyy SW.*W 4V*k '4k ^pose or4k effccWt L&^ncjiy^c Of 4W5'^ MMA*g*t h>n^4o i^prWe4k^Jrk ^ lyl rfcFre**Vfoi Vir^\M,Dfe4\Ct,H'4(€f^a4Ul (5^Y^\ ^.cOmAty.W^yH^VSMkimUMV Msc^XA^k S-pkt of CoaSGCvjioo, 3k\ick\ feSoar^s ?e^kWr is £V4wU<»-*\o sInpv/ 4k Cdx4 4k4 I7r\ir 4k Ci^vusw^ ^ces&rWA ,-^Wi^redt Appeal &vier\oc ft^s 4k forect D/\c4t) "perSt^c his ^fr\cko^S clcurvv of keffecV«vjc asslsitace. of Q^Sel.lWs^inct'pU VUls founAa(X k rA&ssw V.iAS., 155 L.Ea aAlN ^73^^), wh«dvsUts"vJe.3<? w+ bid 4M \e\effe4ls) e AsS^nit Of C^cAtSei Claims mus4 k fG5erV^ ^r federal rev/IevJ .TVvre *v^Y be Crises \h WKi^4r;&V Caw^s u^ef^cl^e^ss h So ^parm-V^m 4W rec^A^hu.4- &p^Wk ftr\^ W^r >l«A?re.wA^ flf? wcVvatenoA 6^un^uedh0n£^ for AMI rcwo*v"c\eiaiAa i\rtA«coUsim> ^eitSow^loU M4cr^ ^Uavie »vfot «5ucK V.'^ /kaWs"C&«rtb&U V« ^V,^ Sa ^Alft^ Bx, Ae^riL 4Ws -parVIoJlar C^for tol\«x4er^ fft.ieM ,*k RppdWV Co^4s ^e. Cfi^oj "urtr\eC€SSar^VA«cia fca^v^vt^ aW<k oh41^4d^ C^^s of WAIaj ^ l m fiAcWo ,VlWfc-evlc4u^iaj 4WlSpecifics 0^4^^^°^ &fo^^3Lftr ftMiM^'^^^ rev^(^s4W<; Cb^4 4M ^a (^toS«'o^^4VvjfVW^-Vea^H. (W4s &c^ue^^^4o AVvL^s^fitV (W4s bW^nf v/iolffW d^ 4kTe^%?^fe of px/v^^<^ ?^le ^01 UW of Gic^/e^^r^ls ^Ho^kr, MPT Foft "b£LAV CLKTlFiaTiP/di nKiS HcAIoa. \s acoo<\&nK \w-\V\jl Sax»& feisj^k -\kt Bl s-V^c4cxaA eaor to \<l&c\ DCOoCfck vfkeV 4W ^^4kre;^ &(cS CEu;S<l CvK. ttflf^Y 4ri *l. ^k&l {cSooro^ \loo[k tx\V[ k boftoe^ <W\ lovf &kkr ^ViWs^vfciHs wA *ie>W> \f4^S Cox* te> no4 mit*t ew\b< 6r/*^ opk.'oa ^kC^^W- T Ikss >\\W VWV-e^ CecV.fe^ 4kt4k5 ^Wfcr?*Vv^^ DFkWcx^r ^scrcW/^ ?\e\Kek i^cbr?«U <V^O of-\k?vk§> 0f fyp£kMroo>A^ cs ??nAV Ek vJk/e&rc ,-p>ce<v\i^s Q^vsiAweA, v>e4{4icwar k/^*v prays4k4 4U- Ccuk v/a-AA. ara/rf 4k Mc*ovm^ fe^s4 k? to^r /tev/icw &^ £MMT Vv*> 'kkW {or ksa^W^ Mo4c'oa d«w Currently kC&r^^ at 4kLVkU&*v* <LW,As UmVof t^ T€*g* A*<Uo k/ek ,f/ee,k &(A& MoWWv\m ^Uda^cuvkr ^l^ °^ pGft^ frxfc tW Ws of 4U kk 4kk 4W fcrt goL s4*W** ^V,c a*c\ Coffee^xClkcS 4W4 ^We^Sonal KVicMte^-vW<a>f.

^SespcAf^vk &dss UarWeAV *&\a cW\£/ik UmV XM THL CocW OF CIS HI A/AL mtALS Of T EXA-S

T>t>** 0^5^-/^ Tk Skk of Te\ce!>

jAEMDkMDu/A \N ^i^op^r OF fAQF\cv4 HffxISEfHErtfl/A/fir

klkss Alk(^V\er4vi£V\ikk4(Q%riiA tynzse. k^e file<\ &Mtc^ ^?r ^VsoteWu*y 'k-Vli'ek k response *0 4taTVkW4kDiS*f «o\ C^t^App&ls &A\i&rs«_ c^iVon.

CoaCuntrv© Cuki^ efdOiTS k kk AppdWs ^r,£^ TkS WzMflra^uW k 'oc^omkkA S"4-sAt<Ywv4r of ¥&cM> ^k4vjp(£^(k£^ks W4c^ K^k ?k(k<Diwsl)e4r'4tbK-fer Mane^D/w^ ifov/'M Vlftre fr/^ueA 4Kr^k 4W Ap^tWu-ts (M W/s") *ndt Appellees £&ck\ k^fs ^ 4taTW4eMk^v£4/t64 (k/t of i/^2& k TKlTkke^^k Cou/-\ AFFIRMED ikCM^'tM Cv\A ^\Ev|iSh5£!^ irk Sen4cmde/lW 'PeAAW/' 6^&ix^ K-s 4r»'«J Gx^ik u/^s <krfe£"k<? ik<T k< lu/t, 4d s4w U WCk l-'e^ kbi&seA &•& unFk'r ^M<^i/na^k4-kW>r \>ifc shovi/ <^C&«™ Q^l kw 4o Sifpprt \t& ClcuYH fV" ^.V^^^ar fasten^. VKW«r^«*<V 5k^-f .wtavx 4k, (kifect app£&( MeiAU'C ts ik C<?r<rec4 6^ 6>r tf»< ^oust- Tk S-kk &/vMk Tk WwVW. kS*h<k (k*4 rVst-AmA (oLf rt£uSowlrt6 4ri<ec\ ftfcwSek ck^^- Cck$ VuK)t- ktvL ^4iwkj.k waotA/6- HuvJev/£<pj 4k rectr<5t reffeok 4k S4t^t*fecf }^a(> 4k-Skk Aor 4k?TWr4ceiAF^ £W4 \a (ks 4k *crWIstoiWj i^k ^^ •\o ok <-TriaA CowSeX dfS^pc^S or erro-u^L sfcA* owl<Us ^t £ccS4c /\fe\VW Ck^ 4k*kloCTkr4ee(^tu (Wk Jtas<*bn fe ^Kou/^vitr ptH^u.j ft .*r, CulpL^ *^< sWw* ^^A^koo^ tfptioX^M^o* tAEHPtk\gk)/k toM

To rtot ewkrtkk xWN^~k4k~o^f>r kscrcA'OvTtt/^ rcs/£c-v4, 3k (WV<* Cr<«w^vl (^^eals oku ^&k^4k*Pe4<kkv£/- a_no\ h& ^WaV-ois 4ovJa/'&4k_k4£fts p^otess £*A b^cnC k*t9^k or^u^xl Cart wkck&oVo&iW^k unfair^tIa\ bu mot ^usiotita* tW>, \M(VDp^ buplav4, \/ekf^rv^^^LtUiLfcr5t pkca^.TV^THcV^^<W^^ AppealsTopiVwoi^ PA ^&S(A, wdc WaM d ^ vtntan&*vS Q^W^t by onk ^lUi^k zL\(e<v Sm* l^ ^ort'oa of 4Wl VoifaLvt- 4^^^^TkCOor4-4^de«V^ior eXdv^ fo^t aoU* 6y\ot cMWjkq of $4fi £n& 4k \rwpar4fek \jeikevh&w k &k^ 4kii4 wk-kw^ k<n 0. SfU#?C ^^ CT ^dW^U y^r vfag ivO* ^uv^tk Cle^r d^ 4k V*r*re -prest^^ovL^W T\vo\e*Mk 6Vk fcfcxan"*? .$ u^^?^^ ^taik^ri. ikoVt.

Lwd* eve^5. .4^1 &*ftls wuVtaife or i^p4n,s5 1* riot cMto^ §V.^ or be^k ^Lt^kj 4k Venerea Wk rkfeA 4ks4<ak^ wA y^^u*^*° ^ "v NKiLr C^k4ktitvlo^ i^^tAWsCo^rt^teru^vv-lo^e^^tk Tbft.o* *l 4k viOiVAc Cc W^ai>kW ftU>™ W4k4k ftt'prW U, cto^ 0w*W«W K4k Wto-t &r TXsatWj U^. ^ ***** X^ ^ to kAWs fi^t Mfcuis ft^ WX^&i of Mk^-k 4o ^t krcleA <^k Actons of Wtf M^(A^<u baA 4o \U W.H*u*s' ^ a^M Ik+Ws ^;^ tejax* ^a ^r _vi r*/dk ^oute&kk^W*^ bu

4o s^A toA if ** Co^<Wl A«*(s <tots *kH ?"«w ^^ f Tk Spkre 0f i,vfV^vrx WU16W JA5l;kWs4ktv(^of Uvkor or ^issiM JHU^ MstciAcI vl,U onk ^fo^hcVco^o^^^o^AUCDo^of Cri^ml ^ ^ ^ ^ rapedrkUu rc^eM^ ^s Lou* 10 5mi^ly . Z5>"^ t^J'-4 -r-f-- i>,^k -^ ? t, c < ^^ i

f&

__; ^ t/\ •\l {.I.

as F^ k -J x <c> ^ -4- ^

\

k

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.