Butler, James
Butler, James
Opinion
^3-'5 courroFouMiAfAL. origina APPEAL OFTLXAS "3am£S,BuMcc The 5TXTE oFTexa5 received m * *, ** COURT OF CKMNALAPP3ALS OCT 05 2015 ©I Accota, Cto?
Tcxetf owl Hk tourk of App6ab PtTlTaiQN ibR Dx5CRrTxoNARV RtVXEW FILED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OCT 0 6 2^5 Abei Acosta, Cierk
l£*io JUI^ jto.. JOTISL rro-Sc COufTT- or CRX'MXN AL OFTLXA5 .v/. i • v
^ STaTL oriels : 3^-j-k Dafr.-d; Coutf. of
+WCOU&T oYAppz&\6 ferthe 5Mprcw\€t)t»£iic.;dl D&tft'd of "Texas PETITION FoR DiSCIteTiorWRY RtVXCW T6 the..UdMd.Rasli juDifiei armCoufiT OF CRIMINAL APP£Al5.
OfTexA3;
Uam£5 Boiler; pcfi}.'6^5 tiiC Cgu4 to r*£V;Coa lUc Jada*i£nt uJW wA*A io dcliWr-in <!0u$£ Mo.?&a-hm ,&&. , STfTEAAEAiTRE6AR,DTAl6 ORAL AR&UM/tT Uu\AeA s\&{cs f.^t5li'(u{Condi (A'oldf&l.
Statement or case /ApP^llavi-'KBuWtr) uuaj dnW4£A toy I'wdfcWvit fe^ PCvn&Uu a.ft>u*o ll OL*tinrlnknl to dliidtr. H£ <^tf £ov\v//d-ed bu JuAj an hjocfe^b^/a.^i^ and. ${jv\ke#\cd Vo^fu-lfVcCbS) u^^iVtUc fof lk£5cum*\D.^iA^ o* Xk> 1', ao/5 5TATEMEAIT OF PRotCDuRAL tftfW TUe Cour4 oCaMiQLj tendered ite Sectjion affl^.Viq pcM.\tOJaCr £Awid-;ov> On Julu T 3.015 . No «v\or;oi/t tor fthfia/fag U*tf Clod
IS "TABlt orCoAiitATJ Pogg- ~Lv\AeX afAulWrfe nk
tmdex of Authorities •jy feu^ i/.3tak ^75 3.uJ,a4 k*f (Toe.APP.-Ciftiic !«). 7 Bamazs v. skte fla> IlJ. &( #fo (4 PP. 13 DtfJ 1^5). (0 40 Bcrwdd 1/. jfok Icfl S.ljAA 353 (/PR 14 D;i( mO ^ BwU v. 3kk TO 5,t^ 7.5X ("kx. APP-IW** 14 D^l iwl. q awD** 1/. State 134 i.w.3^ 254 {la.A??,^f;\\a%m). (, - C^iW^te 33 5,^.^7^ tToc.APPAiMflAaatf). 5 DfitfS l/". 5-Uk IG5 5.uO<| 3^3 CTcv //3p.-G/&u*»r0.2*>6). 7 Hamj 1/, Slate 124.W3i&( (T^^pp.G^.u.o^^O . ' <Ul X*uu>ia5M£ *lfe 5.cu,aiW xT^.WP.Toca/Wa ft<u). t M6^noi/^kk4l5 :^,3J2JKTa,Cr^,APP,Ml <j 3ddl^ iy. 5kk <k)i5 5.cu,^ 215 (T<a.XPP-!WUtA 15*D,^IW) 3 ^dl62^i/. 5tetl&>k>5.LjM 341 CT£x.APi?-vW»A(lo mil. ^ 5drMiA6 i/.J-W^ 133 5.u;. 3d .53 ( Te/ ^p^ Ausl;* 3^3"). 7 r CoMJ7XTuTXOM5 ton 1,5 V5 5TATuT£5 Am RJc5 Fl^6L Rules 6fCRKWIMM. fWdufi Ruk 41Q U ( The diva's Rttov-4 lju.'U lac oh&as <LR" folla^&d ^ HiC Aaqc jau^vi^ a^d ftc/b^k^ Record t-oill be cifd Oi"Kil,,fo{l6uj£d k)a \U.c \jb\mM&cuAA swaL v\u><A«m/'^ &ROUND fi>R REV \LW ~Tik £oad($apfl£ak Iffib .nlklziind LK^I CouA ptepesltj teQtStA k a,W liiz pdrihciMsJ wtakw k^a^/v^s dak -IU ;lT&ral Pfikf G^ £AV I, IUlJOSscL uAj/Ztowf &<s+ uj&s »3iU£d (a/4 &£. /teJ£nC£ of 1W u.aA&1 3kkj di/\d \rOL&5 t/>\A5k\aki6ux.lUe dflr?dd«/.4 dd v^l k ^kkvvu(i/\£ fikw/t CdiACvite 0p|U/dfH^W4- t-uoa -tl<Z £ui/eL4J£ £aiMyo(l&l.
Pe^cf£iV6f 5s .TUjC dPRdfivd' i5 w>l daffit,*^ tW^ tUd-Vokl.'^aPUuL •K|A k^ffiavil-^tfi/ ttuiwd l*jo&*A m&Aid \akctMMHi &r (tYML VU£ul-B -he SiftqA vuazi£ u^&j gJljj loCihh^U fltyldddlC COu'jI Co* Ywl tE^.Ht£. dp^lkiAk fifftddi/.+ Hit dfFIWJ averred VU<^ uukk lo^K.uq
i/^CLi^b ke d.'d vul- Ua\Jt p^obMc caute Wciaculs Li^/d oPke \ota\io\A fclfcQ^d 1-U.t 5i'4n.'i4fl 6-vHLul dfYMdiAh (CUau^ k^w^) RftXX foTi, Q. 6Ul^. k±> WW ef Farf Ute fiv^ \km£ ^6u tofca/fcd 6&£>uf 2aS, £a4 3UU sW-l- tifi kuj dau5 kk/ luU&^ u»au v\kh£ (jou/1 aul'dau.-r?
Q, Awd Ju3+ kkKa£6/ u6u dll V\aA \acjW Ue&M fiC^Tavv»£5 Qulldr . 6r Qvi5 ca5( 2)4-(U if^d- pA6^ k flidi <d/sk''»^ AU^V e^r/^ttj ?
TUt enuir\- a? appeal! AtK/wfA apQd\citf\H HtMu.'cWtiiA\Ja56 e>\A -(-Lid /all^d dDnkolk/d pu^Uai£ .flifit QtCufrid q\ ex d;f$tt\At lo&KoiA Laia 'XKOA 3/dIL. r5f/^ktu<L effi'^l Pc.'l ^6
RftTX U, 0, 6K^ilj.molo Jupf la im£. d^ 4^u IU;5 *.l*ja6 fU£ ^U^ k/ A. GxHAClk c\aIo> \owl5 a\ I510£a3f C/xvtdl \Uj> pwALS jSufakcxAid\ t\/'idcjAC£\UA Wac 5t£>ftL LjGrfWji/i4 afftd aa+ £k %ul teldiucji 2\5Ca5i 3(ot, 5{rm\ ; ldo& iiaJl»PP.,c:^^ k okkll^L fifaitokiLCcutii* 1\al LduA flPdp^£6U <lt^ ;ia ^ciyi'cujiuq lUe ^^^h-Hie, fiflftx^-cl/iditez ~Itv£ flft)<ai/\k 3kkvt/i6/ik «V\ dffi'dtf i/»4 uuas ."ia &^A(jT k dteuW <a/\kuj k Hk Io^Wch^/ CJUai/tZ. 5\(*\lA \Ua\ \ac &Mtiv\&tA Gx £a*f/klkd uj l-Hi £>la Q P/£l/.'0 Hi £> ccas.Wi. f(LR p. IoVJ Tke, 3uloJ&4 r.U;a> uoqj k-'5 k</Y^4 U£ UoA v\a/Lf ulid }ks 5ak)<id hdbfiL ,aM iAa(*\ cyAi'C by k'l'al C6u/4 k p/Y)du<!£ [lid Cl^aA £>P TM 6i/\£ p/Yjl/.7>u5 fiuMLU&6L k><W/okWVsk U-b p/tofeabk ddLtf/afifl^Jf l/\£ (LOald wet p/odu<f£ llid rCpoCf.Hid (a A5 d/fc G5 flllroo*.
R.RXX £1 0. OKdy .\k yu Uzu/da /V.p/>/4 P/£>wv txjU^fc laol* IaaA <ZU(jT pu/CU.^^d/Vjj^ P/crw uuIa&t U£u fl^-l- i(A Utfu/^ 6^Aa\/'xt. Q^L Uau ££/kli^ eku pij/yj/\fl<£ dtuy(fb>M4\A:Lo\a2CM\UA? J J l A>Va. RdXX2(. q. 6\tay."L IWl 6 teficA :Punu puAJA6.sc \/c>*A eU)c&T6tf£6 a\ lead ALpi»/4 GiAiUdV< J A.TUd^c LAjouid \qc .feui- l.kd X £*f9ki/^d 4 , 4coulA be uj.IU fl»e infinMflwi A. ^K^u^.:' : .:., •:;,••••.' ' . -.-/.c - Uy ^i'1 :.. • -. r*. <Q. M.'CMatl CUfii/£z_ iM^liiyi'dualL ,ki£/VL u-»z>uld Idt d npcrl ?
A. TUf5 COWLdl -, ^ , n . . ., '. io A. L(§MUi.ijj&5 actfaA uc>uA UautiL n A* "Ti/iok ComcL J IkC CouA cP apfic&\5 CJtfid \v\ dft^/vuii^fl G/jpdk^k eo\A)/;ckb\s\ Par- lk£ ri)5u6MC£ ora5<^A:l!o i^JdrM^V (o^ ^I5£d5l 34^t 5^4.
Tli£ dUkvk-. -t?kkd. kf. u^iiAi- k dvco k^/« k^uic k _ad duioo k faK^ U:im k fas «MLa\erMu\ Uo t^l«"vMcut^ ^i/^ib iJLA KU of ^ped- Uf u^Tpr prociduH.. , '. , X.1L' '^£iAt •£>i/£Y -Ha^ u-»;+U ^£ Inf^-iA-H h QCt elilLO \o Irfife yMi\C w.5d6t\\tr. J Q.ujUixfi \\aA iaox iMLiAf-toiAid QiAuujCii^^ \\a upu.r rLfiaAcrWcaul'AcuT k/\ J5He*\al\s\ \^j^rrau\r\ . in \ , A.X d.'duCf lU.'uK k^-H l^q.6 6ia Iimpc^tfint par\ \or Vu«4. . ~Tkc COuA tffkp/taak LCMiA \v\ dffi/w.ka d^dlk^k Co^^cUa^ i^ \:gU\ e>P .Ikgalk Mcu\a£<\ ewid^rc rsd^Alcd a{ V/Yal 4Ud aPQccr \/xLOLf C,Qo\6ur\m a \\s\\JLA;a&\it>v\ e>r^l^vliW^cl &a \kc Pe5;r1^£, Hid aluddi/4 ujd*) 3'.\oa\ dm h 6\Ay3UcA du&AiOA Ui'tik t^kxU &\cha<j\{amJ 6k)ou\ \Wi ddAfC5S.
RRl/al hi>. O^uJLtL you GuuafiL eP \i(A dtefd/VSftf cxa 3^i 5tsid flfitoc lo \L&¥ A, Aid) X UJ06 Vld\ .
Poiuf a? effort, IkUC uote v\C uJ6y iltd *Aaa?sWo\l eoui/t kfl . fiLMd ^AcvuftAi qr- (k acKtal dpk,TUd tfflW, kdAd ddk QuVat \kc aWciauA toy* 065iAd:{ \v\ Uti nfioA.^d f&LAtfiaM tokihd \UA \al uj?6\L \ujo d;ufc/W j5kki/wd</ik lu fkt aWddJi/.l RRviiiM. Q. lOu4 &fUt?
A. Au ^aif kd 3^J WdiAd, J_ VaoL uAaA ujL CjsI! - ^UC dlV.dlk.Wd/ for Ifcf1 e^ L^\AAbrto\jcr kiuu ujaIIs 6^mkbiA rd/dwk RR XX.U 6. £kay, &u+ Iia y^u/\ aflfMai/,4 ft/xli&rcU uwaW ut>u <YPd/v>dd k as a eo^Wldd p^dAa6L Q>/ £^aiL/id\ ldkid' kkd! Corrtd?
A. ikak dom<A, to\A\fb\\EA pufLUci5<L\U££>mc.£J* feil.'fkd as dud u^dc^CoxJcr Izjul, L^/blk fkd aWcer did i/t^l- Vuwd t&v\\-*a\ ^udvfhc^^^c^!
Ikd^ctlAJdd cx->a6 Mfif 5€^*cU<id 6.\ di/Uj 4tt/vi diipA'd)^ k {ltd kd ipUiAdulbC lJaIlU &KQu^Ld liA COv\{M) lA lAu>y5<'(-uCihc>u5.
RRual Uk c*. All /\<glAk/ku-> iu dCdiatMUA tana &r& ecAMled paA-LaM IW^uflh au\d i\/\lor\l\/{aiA\ uou t.xj.Td fkd ♦"tApo/'yvKaj/if? &. Tu^k dt^^Addk AlaA l»£>m 6£ja^cU \\aL\aa Ia «AA^k^ iu/Y-Radu dOrt\- \/\aJUt 6i/\Lk \MDU\£C\ cJUtjT tU&iA lAaA <Lj-Ou (llt/L \k£^ A. \u.flk c^>^ddk dO, A\aA U.DU 5iA^cl/\\\AL\r^{o \/\/\ahL ^uri\cahaOL\AO A, Xuak di^^dek Ta£ (^d)u/l- diPa^dflb ^P/^^d ,v(a ik QuAoly4;i :M Adq^i k hL COI^f/6/kd pU^Uftfd "fttdf «-J MciHd'itA GflfMll&iAh TUc Gffidakl Id ^;ki/\l oa k if Wc dffkt/i) 3dd/dkd<4 fkc ^k)dd- k be 3a/d ,T flu 3uk)d"d4 k^d /\fi/ddkc3 oia Utf jdOd^A^.
RR \/iil M, 6. Dta^ .I* Ha.'3 £&$£ ,£U.*60 u^ai ao\ 4£&jc\agA vtf IW &>MEct ?
A.TlAflb CMP&A* \ , .m n . ' i , i . d)lA UllAA p/iA/1 k IkC Pu,/YXtd0d £>A t/\*4 do C»4>U ?
A. Alo .T <4a/U . J TUd. dtffWI; ^i^d/4 kskfi&i \UA hissed cUico Wd? uy^ e>LA uiA)s«/i^t-»:^ paA'<? .* p&iA\ Wl^kk ddddd kdf 5kk w\dc/\k ~TUd C6u,/4 gP £p|)dd3 <LA*dd ]\A affkm.W GpfldJllcnAi tCM\/,'d,'o^\ da k Hit Qlkqdd <fdvukolkd pu^dkdLte +LI a ^kkd .V\ Hid afftdarfl' fUe/£ lo&3 i/U> uuldLuful ;uc'dki/\4 lUfit 6£LuMLd &<: ^15 &bf3ifo ikd^k , „ RRXXU, 0 .Ok&L* MbuJ lMLNj did i/u/\k/V>d$ Gdkallu d.Vd Uou tkd date A, PkhUaa 0>h\d\.
6. Bddk ai/\ Cd^£1I.X.a dollUif u^ofdS , \UM uj&S n.oT>aui$6.c4fotf hdkjddAA 7vl/4^d5 Qu\d U6tA fUd^d df iki ZlokilbiA lod^.'ok?
A. A/D. J "Tkd dW)dHdV\i I/\dL0 p/ttiAdldd kd d^u/faP.CAWVidl a^fi^lS iouaf^kU Hid kafk ftkltfuf WiL dVdv-vb 1U Vtid tf(ftk»iJ,4 ^-d yut l$!/& ptotoakik eauJii \of hi >55udv\tL ova SLa^cU uj&McwA fb/1 iid r^/kvi/£ \ocAtid a{ %]5QMl3hlU3if(A> uj&S k/ I6f0d^5f &VY!#( \osqLkiAa AaICdW^ . ftftt/lll 1(5. & Oh/kj. >4iAd Hid fd^DtA Xdtfk fci ,/'H l^/^./1 3£aMa UJ&S/6VI+ •\\/\DLu\/\ ficAltlpaA kJ^6 pu/dLi6it dTAj^^ pA6tv»^ Ili.V^ p^k-y^r A,1l/ukdd>/^d±, Iac k.fll Icd^ivu^^u r/ovw dflfl^f-cLc^z i'f? uv\dtse>AU 4 ja/»oj^ tb\A\Jick»*\ b&M-A &ut We. CwA+AtA ..p ix^cU^t \uA ujaj mA TUc aSfid,ai/4 go fln k skk lU^i- adfi^^+ ()/bi;;ddd 3adkd4 U,^ .da^d^iAdu Q>^ kd mW£U&5£ aCcoea^c teajL Q&aaa 6u\aScc\ l^j'M iUd a\M5 r.QV"ru3/d£ flid /ttted/acdka'i,
^ a\ \WdVti^d <sf IUd dilddj/d {wt/tfadtcort.
RRl)f &?3, &.6lkSy $6 WiLMt) l/\0 l\j\AiCjAiny\ &P 1JU0 AAATW&? voA4u Ufi\/d, dV \M4J n^ Ua\/d pu/^k^i£ dojOt (v^tM ;u Hiaf te«jW&/A? ^ Q, ViS.
A. NO* .
0. All. r«4^ A^ Xd^T_idX duull/:nd ;u uw 6™'d<w.4 gp\vkl+ou/* rdpD/4 uoUd/d dWdO JStfy*. b\C PlxHL[aC3L C6CC^\6 Crowi AaAlS l)l4\£^ ,<?kAkd» d^.bci^/Xil^.'yuJ Stilt/ Gd/iukidq ;n mar !/i£u3d \te lAdU>d^<dM ^tfq 3pd<L,T0££.Uu ujUd kdJtaauSU+ ^ O&im'• f.'S {\aA doNlA7. J J 3 A.~TWdk tsA^dk Ia lUf Ukl4u &f \\a£ CifLutM5fovtt& anaty#5- fla afrcdda//\5 iwiuPPuUtAf te> <£6kidl'ilA •,dV4tofltol6d*4aj<L Ht^ <^u/t £p .^iM.'rtdi ap^CAi'j Uaui tfm^{*A\u KLuLiPicd d(x5c 5;^;}^ k a^pdkuM \y\ao\ ]uA hh£ .r eW <sf&4u^k Htftwi \lvd e&dtuud) he TUd dJp|d?d:l/dUA4 LAwddYUkuf Murl cJaX* lt£ dUlldwadJ kd i/ol.'d.'k df 5£&<rdA uu&M&iA QiAd uXiv\5\c\i kk>dudd5 PdGtftk ua\:d 5Uksd/uj&WaA VVl Wdd<A aCpr&oP tf a»a a^elki/il k qd> £kuWd ^;k. &//ddud£ Tu d^dk^i4 pnzv&d toewid &NAtwukWt dkuk4 M Wc^c^cU Lufi/wanf- aPGdauA; cuaJ dtfkAiot u/Ad&P Iks pfol/kWt C(\c6i v^d|cuv^i/wdwk<3p|itd Uu\^ed5k\a CpiAdlMi'ow 03 ujiil 05 Ht6 Hid eRftc&rb adi'o«A5 dV\d. 6kfdw«d(/\-b /'fa a fc$u\\- aPslMpk V\£d\la£iACl (&\d Hid b56uV\4 wladiik&k cult«II y dida^dai^ hd^ d^kd^ddl \AA(\v\<ALr b££&\M£ ^AL^AA & oMhcP skvviiZ) (kr "lid .(!d)U(/4 <sP tf^dlddii d;^l £/uf dOd*4i/u*V\£ l-kd CmI.V^ ^ddcrd Attld&M \u\Mcad 61 d\p^fy.ua Wl \Ae\\\uieRhfCifCM\M*>{A\AC£3 tcA uuLcm 15 u5id \6u^ htfrc S\d\br cadAS.
IaL dpDd\6iA fltep ILA Hid douA LuoAd Qt&MiwL ts fdCO^d Pof- ikd kva-ki (%\A tMdkt &Y^aiaA c10l\a\ dcCtiu .. . _ . 0)A,
ReA50MfcR RlvieW Tk£ dffidldjJ.'t \\a&\ tx)(kh kiudd £>/" y\\^Qko\2L^\^(A ujrf \\rtJ$GbA k &kbbl/i jOrtJtabk dML-tiiCtpuA AfrtflptAb k:( k> &k>ftf-!k . . kkl4u 41 Hi! <LYcLwMt>W^ \m fW: bhcl ,totf\ J e&Abite AuA jW3J mo CApp .13 0:4 M3V TUd: Cdu4 6pQp/)^i3 '.A fljfljOMU^h tW (If 4o 6pplu IL^JtW. &A&\aS;6 GS-dAtif dOoAd ^ &fip^6pttiULaiuiMA^^c \jLfaity fiiAd) WMft 6? IWdJcddj^ efp£ftD\A dappiuiuA WllUd^aa iiAi^uUAtiDtA u5dd Uu d^PiaiA :u '6upfloA &\ JjCAstU uoarmA atL h\lv&A L^\6,dL$eAtc*A \ka iLiVuZttii^Wkk-kl^y oP-tltd CfrUMto.*)\LAAi& 3ina\uS&~ CbftiotAA v,5kk.l34-6.uj2A^Ctac.
Ap/).Avud/;lb5io^k Tw tUd ^(Odkuk Atf£ JUf id bcPorl hi tbixA Wjl Sitkdi AiA^AWbo'M k£ kd&^y \v\ hL QrkxtAn kfp ,IW£. tuAi m^ dWc)k>^kak3p PazJb 4© AtaudL i\>\A!c;a &( /d;6kUk\ na^Ai^cx^kip.
DajL5\/^kte.lt5.5.6jJi3^. J Hvd &)ui/4 d>P dJXVMii/tal dfJ^lj kokal Hid kkL'fy dPkd . dUi/Yui/VLikt/i^ Addd^dcufl iuvfifi/u/skfiiA Co^r&lutA i\A he affldao'A, lid tOuA 6? df{)Ea\6 dLCilfoA CiWXpl'ti co4l\ ked^u/r &( 6'\'t,M.WJ fi^cAi i(,\ A£dldwYta k kd dtotabl£tfau# rd^kdaw^k tfP k<L~((M. £ov\ AAu koiA .rlUc Ltx*A &P<f/cWlui 1dyp^n U£ld lkA+ fit6 afktaat iiA Tvuo uikk, d.'d iaoI 6\At uMma dd+udl JalL &Ojl*J<NA &*d 4 ol*w ^jftetfMd. k ddwsM'ud Abvvi ^-\kt/vb diPdPfildd\a4 LuUduo l/idiM JUUkfii ikkd Wt au\ddf<fo^d:r p* (Aj%5:dLu\CL \A6ia/(M k &PPvW4 curtthtv 3»4 U/>ui£ QA'or \o dilk^k ^:dy\«Ww d5iH'/tALj4. Xia^£> l/.J^f£RHoS.oj.Sidy'lt (loc.kpp TdYA/kA^dP i^^r). 5&rMuid) uMAl W5.uJ3\ 53 pa^L^id: k^ pkdZ 06 \1\L.4&\kaL i(A ~LvW> ^.^{L^UL 7£xtf5 Cj)aA aP£.Avm'haI fifO^b IUS5 Ad^dlkka i/ld/zl k^P dii/ld ^fliddl/it uuUt'd^ dz>d^ i/l^t dfiiMd)M5kdkaj|^tti£dAM.buj/L\l w\£Mv\A Uh pkd£ b. ''^L,fT-dkM4 fo3cx0faA&sua<AC£ Oka SC£irdr\.LLAfraiAt~£»,\i> U^U\L%^d,uJ2AL\^ClQ(lk^
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.