Allen Bernard Gims v. State
Allen Bernard Gims v. State
Opinion
Case k\n*H:is~r.V-OAn(nft /& Cny\+™\ Mr>*i.sm^59 AST
„, - PB,N£
. . . JJaSA e m-zyn
^.-_2_0i^E^Ja_^Ua_.„^Si_ I—I pu5j-o H CTj>Mu < "77033 W_ nam-e_lj AT i ^^ JSkKpojal (-r\ i^K » ard Ann I nCflr^r^ 4-eJ fl;- +he PoLunSlC pyjL16iq LLd5^ Sf a C^/mjg_TJtl dLJLdjtvL-Cann *n *1;, fc C) m char.of tu i-fcb .CO_piio J MaUKd^ TJ:M IS €U^ ..Cuad. i[{jcpLL* , i> ding d^JjdU (of Oi jff'itnd of rnim^ JC dpoJS£J±^JltxdL-) 11 ^aqJuJa^JLin^u^ ...jdth&l. Ha^'iXX^ kj -M^,JS_±g~k r. o.<k k^ 'a± n^x i J2 his__ (&*Mln,A\a£L % X w -4-o MLa^/ all * 4 Xyi_Q\Ag. -*-& V -WrUsy kjLS&MLJ&DX
^. \A'rt\\ dn So, !
Wlo-£/r£ ?q i^i S-j-^ ^d i taiL n Qul: -J- Mro-k 4^^ Ba£. ^lU JT2 ^i ^ ,„ yo L, ;^^ /9 /* C '/iL- i^': /,U 4-' un.o ,5avi o umii£ A Case, mo.^ 4;i5-n/-n^ -fh -fold me,4h$± Wh«±_HC ha^/e Is a ChilLcMs r\-w-p + H . iS-'r\/-njL'H/-9. I
/^TT (P t.
i^A7"
^ P^j ™^ ^^—=fa^g cafl^o\ muiscii^ cafe gem &jg E-*(U*™\ -jx±£A±£^j^^^ 3 _.
i S J- GQ z ^ £AT-y,,9n^ Sn&T^ >ff>w ^ I rntfiUjr1 v\d4-1 hf__r,i;llns Aon wxurJ^ -^^^P/(,Xrr>7 aii-jlkk ^•~x> cyM QQ\/U d-Or ls) J>hte*sl bJ ]L±ioJiAAA u &v\a \Ajhat&J-Qts -H^IS ?,s 44^r -fW^ ^/f ct>i4o J2U ^QOu— - —r L4 a o Qua f ^J^UM^dC J.'C iqC I iH ^j^vkijZe. cod ua UiiHd aiLcLi J£V ]IZ^I_SZ_aISlS2^^ r
j^JC CULA £A c^Kth.^in^ rcfyi^e^ih 4r>/*«.aij- a lu-S. /4 h miA. f*\/ii (i h/p\^a \)lo\a\~tf\ aha WV /vu 4o 4/Yi u. and -\t) riu 4^iii /.S^ 4*VjlC 70L yvuZ ±n L^x^yi <^r_.
j-l\)ed vu-h ArUc A3..F>>4 -jorv^ -\-Ujl Wrlhof- iAaleaS 3 Case No.* H;\f> -cV-n^n/nP, 7S>
Lk3_J4vJ_,_j^jg_.r^Sg -.- A/O^ T ..,.._ _ _ i<Z _„ &,JLJ . . .- . Q?0 - - ,r. /YlLsl fi.S.
r20l0 a\- cZSIO AAA. . and sy\j>. v\esdl 4*?ftf/l M^.J^d/sisal ]SV\<?A:c*\ /j#^|w^ M.IAt^ 4^1^ 'U ^/loflf- madid KVyl q c^Urma [^j\^U 'J^I^L rjjpri '6L / ^Ju^je'f YeaajzLl^zS- \£* VrC^ EZ5 a inn \U\n-1 \n -^ ^ad&^/S k^£ iS hectfuSZ "1I- K\Jnyrr #11 pL [Afro* ~h tjWt) i v\\t> AWkS> fai-g rmn ma., a v\(\ Aha, ^2.^1.m5^/ A^Uz {4a.b'&*<? COVfuS a\nd (A$f) -^^ Ct\/A T>aU^\ \)io[g-\-[cruy AU^ ALo<U 'XUU> r^~T}-<aS gffJcM^ haM* \^?°y' £A YW(L wV/ a ICn \i> lAU A%? U- S - £_ di^l Mac *Js^( CuCe ,VO. ^ A,lJbC he. ^U rCHo3LO(&P,.
<&V\ 4- a •rne •ea d Li.C eva 1 Weyve. o. U.S. i_-a- .b}u,uf r^u.h.._£t}=i 5ol C\ V\VM> *J v,
r 1.00% ^WxJ?*/g J/urM 14+ S* -Ff wi^d^'cal ^ff-^^cr^i r# il -€^i Yndy*- ^•p^'4^^^/'per./LLiSJL A-\w\& LsltiL cm /vua Sid AS 1/ A< i -LAJb &u Oi U V? tin AXAf, ApSpu<hb^ (snn sOxpLjf itfl\ / u!>tll J/hC^ prno/JPsu CM^yy^ icjy{ Suhs-h^C-^ (^ YVUA Sl-th <( f**1 iJ^f-h ^yrtn^ ti^d V, Case k\f),^^'iS-CV-D^OC& '/€> 1-1- lUl^r-r )Vi4t> t^Yk^ pO\/P S.a\r\A jgAjz rrusi blonA PAjVoa ^ , '~ ClwiSuUpa/)^ al\ now becjbu..\Ji od- AUd a\\ omv Wua hod^d.TZ ruk*. Daim iV) Ado m»WA nf Ch*s-I- yyu/\ h&n£d£ yyu/\ b&Yi#'£ glL=£1 nrl^ez wl#win aii all oialu o(jlus f^r\ yyusi bnA^./.dn\dA:r~^ bn ' h<3.s' 'SeJavaAdd Xva^ Mdri.jAr \r\ed,ArU [all <pA- ryv<yi fan hW/9 -(y,wn Afa* Wi^d^Cj^A rj&ff Yawn nv c\ \? sJ.h Vu^<. dn AA^s ldd£S v. A-6^yin Sl(b. of &, m fned- 4W Kw\tAdjd A^fC - v^eUsx -fW<i W^eAirai A^s^ssy naw [)?aini {Siding CTd.rkd^n rrd/kSd?^, .sly sh/. Wad ^v\C 4-n Q\ \\J0 V\JsV rt\ Saiyvipd 'of- irvu/j blooA/ tfpn.—a bru$ A j- Snt pu4~ itnfi AA of'. .S \rv\ k1.1 pi M d,.V/,i;^ c rats. 4n V\CLW.-dd=ddA7tkA<?J.
4-r, *},Ae khx AAr A^ .w uln,,\- 4z>„_, y^d dfz fv\eA>£«.
AfalSz save'5 &~>~\ hodA, Z . hark. >»^uCTrt^ua a opj— Jdm\ tA^r-^ <^° I ^ f IU QJjJz. >*l d/\fW^ t c^ a\\ A P K*U/t£.
i- dry\Ji,. AAA
CUaAsS Ails^ P>.^s,1v h& ljJAS. rd\ u^skzl oldt It hdv -r u^,>U 4i^v>, ^^t^f 4^'S 4 ^ n^tW Kr* eudr-of **- 5. Case kiD:*d'\^-cV~odoca f& Cell \xndd iry]f.,4Ad. hi ah fOyyik-ima O/iSe^ nU-ird\ j ave. 4t> g±AL air\ ptfS&m 4v M~*i, lit iTVUsi frq hd <^Ad h'^'A d* S<?aSL£ Vinci) --a 4-^Sd. Sa Ahkk di A^d^ jWx$n wui, Ad, -fu <A£_ A¥L u j2L i/Y\i. do-o d^^Xi^j^^ a&#du rnuJ ._'jrUyVe\ hjsvd cm i dA\e ^aLu^lsdcA hid" try 4^ Am' ^' hew*-., Mi/ Irina.rW ALlssm P>^r^LA iSJdm d-f^^s told.. .X. d&nA KmCtllJ If aA^l p,~fol Shpd. Add-h AAA^y, anAA&_ d:^\ If 111 sd Vxiu^i £?^ mn-l-. k,C tfi m •j-hss* )d(?ddc dm fa> rdtria YYit d) hf. i n \£urwL.[ 'jjiAAA SorvtiUryuLAj^ad iS rJa.1 sick?. p r .4AAA1 wotAtS, Ad odC fnJ. u J> . Cf S£d\A)rrrA- 1;V€. tlo vS t (J£. XA-^yid .'. 'AUj^a V,g Ay^'tv-iA So So hasA do Seci/^A-UA pud at i^ma.i-e fd Ajz^AtU) yd>d. d> Arta AS? S&rrd'dUA^ f*dj? WwAr- ,i^nn^A^[Ahad44^4. \ rf,^ AfL/ I A. 0* ±4„„L- ,A ™* L?1 Us,L~ 'Vis,,, VS11
trial's . JMj? /*_ fffn^CM.A^v'S Pus*/ Ad? U-Arir>S 6/?
Ad\lAA AA«p SArtd^. v (f rhjk. rnt 4An^ ddUM PiA-h . . ^dA_S\Cin/ 0V ft'' [** •L<h? ()j^\dU ffrTA'/J a \rUA\AsOA ,Ad I*n#s aA~^<< uami mi ckfL,- $r> 4j^A'\r d\~tAA CJiUsv lie. z fsrnUlcdA*^ ?Ldda^hz Oat- <r>i „\kj°ndr v^ , \^da[d -VPu$ iS .s^ma) a 11 of ia<ha—^-L •e 22 / d 11 a hru, d hjdf .
C^ MwrM SX\^nJO\(T \aIoS \jJa.\)Ciina hewz /&W)
AU<L SAdwf. n>i\ of Aiad ha fm Vk£d & MniL^-lrrki sy/zk. 4dkp. fS4r^4g lJ Wa.Pd <*p AnrL.
AS. ^uj^ bound of helifo't <r- A/u^h dd./JZ donY jineu. % Case. km.^AAd^v-ndocnP, dh>, name, of dVe nf.xd SdresdAdviAr-CvaSSeS AA IA^i^ SAvp^A-.dpudrm AAxad VAasja CnSne+r AUeS^dA r^td^'sf AUz*\ ATI. {r-i^lytA KHa^ Ad^yj-h AA^sAis nawi^A (;Ai.S f£ssJ,d /fthd -A nhrxrWA,, dd/M )ui™ppsd m/. and Ak&oi U<r,Ad \Ua h^d rvu Up, iodHd SA'C ^Kdj <S±kX'>,, M AAdddd VY\asY)5 har.tr jOa^ a~c77Z <u..d.dA V&SjjLl W~ I & kfrmo vyi^JjP UJQQahk N\\/s fj f\Jyy itA J-r1~A*aA mar*, a. Mr, KDh^C IA7Mund dm^, )d?H abaij.d.dSif^d^ nv+v fv,m uAy^r-t fTWip^yi ft/yj LpJ>;m \\um ,n MnlA mbtZs b&rf\AfW(i> Mr.ddzfS \\C/*A )Z Vlk-U-'-rw* ^ off (of- Mlftv-r ,% Afc Av,Z h:^\f ^v^^^CCya Y\J umS fddg£ <fW"\ x-m^ftJ^. ,.,/b/l i<n^ h>S f<AWr> •/^' r^yrv.t r^\A ' '" ' A .. .•
^^^jH^&m^sm t
WlsdfAAnnJ ).< djcflnnisuA Hdf&cdnC.k yyifi-. VvL wgC, AAAl l\dfJddA/\AVH^A ;^ /V. Krh&rh lAd^usonH CJb^eS cLaJL* <ZaM. Qvxd Kfjdin [IMS, f&d SCated sf ~rJsJnrtHy.Kt.iJ \1UfA~ I ' dTdjjyulJ n^ u)a\\C .. I J .
V\Qvn~i " <j/W?2?
I 1/ I ,Lr, ilu // . iSW-^ l.drr^' Q\.,„IA ~ dtint£^y _. 3 \ij<Quid AXMdf Adnd dJdhyvMjsj dullCdn lla-, t&sd had-.amAiD^A id C&uldf'iAL rxapftfAAfJ fin nd^eO ,VmAA /W P., lvW' hA.i ^Ahoyh Id. ,s/^-.) %oiWd*r (+> )an^$ 'ft* >4* f^f Ua^e losd hi <r ^(T^.-> 7. Cade. kMfuws-c.V'naofon
h\w\ iiMa toAjAvt^^a up hlS' (inn^r..d&hlnlniA O^d td>/nAy M^^j,, Ad -tricJL Vum ]inir> glUsahiA up ..... .
JiUa* CauhL, IClll ft^d fnf 'di^./Ah's ,x\, W (Add 44dS iS Add? G^ni) hjzn&zL dvidU 3 [ju^ICS I , i A -X^v \J&UnrMs\ ch. LMJ-Lti \S . * . , fobbedI fYUL ya^^. btfuji i ILdj haJ- fVd AU n-dp-d^Oio &Lj£s30 AMJjVUo EST Scpi, Au? 3 f)f MtAy. ,W~ wo &h£ ZdMd ioua 1mJj±L± ildjdd yyusi Aprissrul M.s. KOh£A/d jdrMAfUj^fd CJrmJ.?.. dn^d fU cLua F4W- Add^A Ssdt,p a*d} Ydttr-d InJsU 'fir/Jri'f ^ 2W AAO\0 dO 10 adfd3o Aifa, ..-frad^ a-hd^3o ./Ufa. jrdd* ab^A-ft!A ab^A-h. 9/A '.fa. fa . of- of ^f ^d- YY\vvn\^0i ail A4d tis////i dr> AaSjl nsyf &y&dAU a£ H^A (s^ddDjh ,AU,S Aprn .^ )i^yy),A flsud iLSx/.A df^Tdh 4-OOJ Hk. flllcU^h- IdL/usnnd Cldda£ rx^yt) <&&£.^_ 'i'|Tpr? lAthlima rht? . AALs^a i/y/tCAviA,/^^ fp [tS, f// Sd b?dd<> \jjp\h (Tn* sSbmf brti >rdj _JqsA dzLfld&u 4& frxjov up ¥Vie d<u\Afin of M/, Hob~eA/\- ^W{m3 ^Tcthza w,lr> ^/ e^d Vh Qir^d xh/id) ' \jukl UJai/\/i>d rth/x/jj- fhJ aglkikM. aAju*, hv.lt.
AAd> bodi, ad- &h ^U&& UuddA^ bsad/i^ ml up. g&d. ife fobb. nti VnQ-,, bud QU hodnI bp^in f^Ad wo La oua WJ jrhr fvui Ad ^j* :/- 4d> I A- Cj>xJ>tn iJ f9ud u )Vi ojsjP lllAfd' faggd \s\<?ad AAd_ LLta.\<L^ h awn. A id/ rbSadeYj7<> idh av\ M psO Ul a. cSiiJ-. fdp,;)AL*/d {Mad tjlA Dadh^ir rtrtime m hjsuM ..TdAfiUP a Mlc.) foUDMlrJU.&f. Urn*** id riij? Wo npod<?d 4r. -Adit Ao iavl dobocdr AjjL \jtoPU cf AAs, rjdnL . \dpsAUJood CTrThOdi hs a <b>d fnJL ifj/JA 4d, QuMidiZLsrtL fklAi Avid cW- \\vu>oa4 ,M\dr 4iAL pM'S'ioLe Sfidr K^ Ao**..
8, ^ '/& Case m.^ds-cv-mncn CUA&j \J19faftY\A. *LjUJiV\ ,4La; jaa iredL12- '"mad .(^Jnr •medSj/kn ;\4U CjUa, \ uAoUdlrnnaS fUddd. Sn \pe> Oizz^tm. eteaj h< *> rPa*H~nt*'</ SA So eAzQlW 4n d)£>J- Ad^£^ \Cina-u) <M&. wwwr.tzwt? Knf/ E !yy^ . ^ ^ s- r as,hjn. ft J&4n ?*-££ drvS 4-m/?y dl<<dhpiwAi aisui KjuJjj^ Mr. Clm^eS Jd VAlU/v-'^ . iU~(as\ Arrulded ddU hoiAJid*™ V\&i^\<[At cALugd <diJm nU do Ad^u. Uyddd^A c\:ddd- j>\Isa-J* V\r: •j/ud Uo h Oi ISl&L mdJL&dd.
T
dfad d-pjl^ol he hjLuAL /nJln&fk Ad ho^dfJs mn \trr\dajA .* ulad.jU j ua. ? M&ca iO^Adokl daid ft \h s4-r>r4,t£* -LzA<d \ rtfjV^M., 'Ad^fi*^ Z30. £iAAA—nvfXu^ ,So ,Wlf/" 4dnaf Ad^J-• Lujg.S Lao.
T r dVU (1 ifjrl^ nf fd(,r. Jd.otijush U.
A. AAm Ad l£a.i/e..
locde ev(S h0r.4o(di iruo <fy*th dLs tTh.1^ u/^a us&A QOirPi i.M h> dJidf A'AJ-eAin fefid Ad> /vuL /vua udddr^dljsiA/jA aAnda—'wov\s\.y^<2 rt/ifrhXf. tn.n-h Aids dcAAUUa of nit.
M 1&&tn d fk&. dCfw-ed irk? a^d. df djsifd '... maid ~=p~— AddxA^ aA \i)e&.t ciS_ Ad r^,jri .T—Xat\ L. \f.*)r- yc>»nd uddl^ a Sd-ic.t . \&U M&i dzd^ddSjj)? \t)t/v\,\d nf/^A qnf a. blue iLavJrdt, a. ffj?gh. u>\duCa AI a*/> jd ^im/jh -j<dCa dISC, \j^> T {uaA 'y\dr YJ>M tag, ofS, 'Ardd^®/ . JfA,Va*nti. \\r<AA^flfi [jyg/ni £ rvlb pit. JA^/d AivL had a ftiA/^lf XL I c^z^i ipiaajI )i/i £*z/-Jsa ah#myL i/be, pi/i*ri (T~ \amA IU lu- du da^U, &£ M/<> £ob^/~/ idduA^00^ ,7/ dddd^s, ff yn Case. m^d-AS-C^-OcdOCe .Msua lo^AXnin ddt d&cj &f ryLo, aCz/s* qjgresd^ all dA?
UAdS> />ua< dJfsJal in CAj) /t4^//T U?. ) u(Adda/ Arm/jd- fcxmn AArdT/?^ _ ' dL ^h^a7~Sn^ur/irr^f~, ,xf^y^^ ,/oS/- /> ^r ,?&?/- <J? uyd?/> Uddrrss^ S'^rr //^ AA,.# rdd?A<dZ fa/>?. - ^ A- /2r/9t^H,/ ^AA? MrA,* ,D*r<A- f/f r-df7Adl,; l dtrffff.
CJiauAAi* st{. xfVy^^/^y/7^ An/A/ /7?S j*n&***'?f"rA w. 7/Ad /yr^fdpd Jr^jdn/dtd/A dA/^A - /»z/ ^/'^ fa jAA/e do Asrme dug, /tr,-^ S(7??/jz<JA?Af?f, r/^Ars^fi/t/s>^s&>A'-A^zA Can O^^Z^AdL -A- • / y - - L— r#M4/?/~- rr?7 An s 'fl/</aS <SAA?yyA^^7 sd, >Ad,/,^ /__ - 4in^. 4^~0£ •-, •^t^t^ ^ ^ddf'" )a*v ^^y ;~r^ sf-
TTkJL AA Jf^ -U&4* C<* teL^jJr.// fA/AsS'f &4AA&T. /_ /AA^dffl ^jf^g^jW A^zrS r/^AAd />*C£.r aAaiJ d?f /aa* f :;^g:gz^^^^^^-4^^x^^^a^5^ A^d?A^ ,/fs ff. \.^f^/s..f,/ A^JZe d./^
A , V-/X d A t 'n - ^ •ffAS<"<f?f -ft^rS. ////»./ ATA/Afi/f A24. -,1.,, *rL "'A/fC<P? onMAAmti. <a\ - /d&hi&j* fAi.S, SA* MaLat^. d* aa/~ /r? JAf faWAs #£ -dA?A, /A?? CTu^ /fy-go/Z /a 78 Case MQ.-*H:is-cv-ruokft TZ. my-/- AUo vse/AjZJidflfl.sKhj/Jq* ^Jyhaf 3f-7Air/., /W )3Z did #n qAj*? c^ziA j^.,a*. ^_ -f—f././J A* ^ KcAdd -tf£l 2^2 7 ^2 Cfiytfj? . Afrrs As? AA,d CgTzifjA-, J2LL Ad/d, 7Z. /yz^ A>.4'? Ay? AifO A&Asl <Ar> /y^SA .A&ZZZ2A-L ^ y ^ ^ r*4AA- AT&ecry /A Il/^/a/ A?S/>/sVj7*a tfAA JAJ? /AaA>a^ /A •? dr? \3 A/^yf a?-AJ^ dASA.s^S aaA Y. ^AAe AA £ -AdASsds-J ^/V ^y. ^^X.tfriAAAijt A /^r ^ ^ 4^ W & C<2 ^ /^ A/-s, A^fdC. <wfd/k /AAf I Ss^^a A* Adz+s.As^/ a?aaA ^/l. ^j^ /y.A'^ -iAAA^^ ,f*A ^ A "^A *dJ ^A ^4&Al ^ss*»Ax*s'As7/r./0si AA#A~ AAi< x fA^A-Arf ,SAa^A a^JA asw*/ y^ /nCd% yd&rporatrr* As**f /*-? Ms aA&AA Aa /Ad,. ArA^AfAdd^s. \ JA/Aa/ KMygy a_A/ta?aA aAA<AAA- aaavavA- yd? Aaza^. a?a Jlgy/dA pA -fdAAAd s^c? <M A^/a>A A&r^.f? 0^> fA^rAf- C?a/''^A'd/Ad/- A'fl-AtAaA Az&Ay e?r*A ov y^y,^. fir? -Are-*?', <*kS 7'Az f22aS- AaaAA^ ^*> Oyy A^y OaA^itAS.. JkAfiLydbr?// AAA/tetA{s/ At,aA /^t/ -Ar, 4r/dA, fynu/AArAA, //A/aw J4^,« /?/tp&r< />?yA^ /~ r&z^ sAArifjA^Ar /a~? -die A/A^AAAn /trdjA, A<dddh^/^Ad^//As*i>sA\Add« ,'d A^ddA Cfl SAA^^^^ZddlLL M^^AAtL^aidMj£- . Ana/,. Ac <-/£* /yy,yr^ AAz&te&A yy ,mar~' a£^ _A> //AA) iaaAma , \ A/CCJ/aaa>7A <A-A? dfors roz ^AAStlA Maz. f_^Zdd'^Af)rA>,AA> jaaAaaA a -Mas Jt^AJdis SJfA^ti jKaC jaazaLS&zz AaZ^S £>v. <>»-,-, Co, .,„>,y.^y /„./£.• r,./'C . JiAtsAf ^A^7 J7/,A- Am m*. aa/j? f^A.f ,•} / A? /hl* A?d/Ats /7J7«a. ,ah/ /A AJ AsAAAs74 /ns, -*ur^ as oAa?»w. "iB X ALLer> FWnd.rd .6riHS. X fie= 4-q a\\ of- \\\cl His. -PffdeC/a ^FfrffJ^& \ Judo pA4jva+ LLS ^-jKA+l-fC-r- flour 4 pf App^are/ n'laijp «S4reHr * Hou^4e^> ^."r^/di "7700^
has be^n coh-faml nfl-l-ga i»i-Hn h) rdh d bMU4-hg- UxftS prison n^c^Ti... amd -Vhid VJa^ \ r\ \*aa\\-\ cfaa At 4-q m^ , hera.ulP Tllzz T Alloio id. Hi)ms 35 up , qnd ocJLed d ik»- Sick of 4hi U«S ±^(t#Ara \db<er) AhlS r.rirnz An in ^4- A',3Q AM f>F GjTM< -IV de«JA- it \ I
'r h;s y j™i. of tPa^A\ Wfl-S Sr-an .nPA^d:\:ca--iOtA^\ASAr^^../Ahf-S t5 Owneg m ue'n 'a H , 4-Kg.' Mr ,5- kedjLAOJd hurfiMA of
I f9h mi. 14- 'i S -fflKiia ,' T,4-r9 4nii ffyi.4o V>y bcOUy ^r>u^J- cas? no- i.s—I ^lafcam-kn /A >&, '!& CaSd KlQ^i4dS'C\l-ndLnd-)& This 'i S -fjne \a\AJ and w'iA-U A-Uls he\^g A-he. lay (of- dhz UK as Cr)yy\)]na\ pros edare , wlfdJLAm^L AhaV _±r\ -4-nai- Ah IA <s (AuAt>maA]( a u +o ma-f- • c an a u a, m baS r - d h<z Aba 6\a/ nf Our fri.
lex, Crl™, App- APOB An flpphgflficm far a WrFf of /HabpftS corpus m'Jfh Sta+e kl&ito 4-Kaf, i-f 4ruP7wouf)d gr»4-i4le 44b< —-—• — • • • As—p—f ——— * ' - ~ ' ' "— Qpphcain— fo> InaJya.s- Co>rpu£ ~q ha.opaS Corpus re\i relief-^frd eC 4Jne. c)'dV^% mu&-- challenge" 4-i& " - judgien-A ' tJd»nIA±dnqOi\nS¥ Adne. /3pplir/3w4-<S Cr>in\f)c-)oiyt for &&£& I 3ffi ch^^e- fri.£ $,£.&-he.)r\t&.
I Her Mp. fflaCJ*5to ShJ.M^^B^ Al l.-pm YSer^ard f^lM^, 1 waSUd^d LdhiV nft AyM 4ke n^cd.010 addd-'dQ AM, r a \ n i —i i^-fi ^Ta i /\ 1/ i * i a a 4a bu 3 dWs' beddf-z AhlS -h\m& Anil ad- dhA -Arv\i . oml hid ad ad\rAd x\d. Ah aV^aSdAA Ad \f afdtY Uu±, o,?uk3 *AW \A hnurS 4fu 4-i mi> y J^ng jeaAfa •JPQ4AA /v r. Nn.o-e^ir A iQf- K -i i^Anlb ad £L'.3D A-Mi ALLiio b^Knakd (h\\Ajd.
LouA- hlo.illA' Ad Curiae. SraCfLA So^rl erv\i ^Ifiu Abo iq^AniA Ja3 ^\.)wnf^g CdaC Wad if ^,-yg pi/f niM £ H2Z3 djd AA& Add?
MX C \A)ljl SlnDlZf Adah ^U \aM1 \\Ai5dtdjL <9p 4ke Li>$>-j^g^^rkr riala pate, cm Ad l-l^Mto «\r -r
<^'3C A M> 7/^- mvjS- l«-^ 4^ SAa-k Aval me Ao dh*il, /3. rzi.se kin + dd^-CW-O^D^rs
Wh^-ip all of- dhd drYc\A* nf Texas pwsecu-Ur '£ ,amd Ad&£ C2: Aha US^d**] AFTS (KaU k&ALjaL bA. .ArhiA^hordH-I-, r-i$h~~> Hruh? #A~ Adz A-irvxe. of- Adz nsadA Woo x"T/)H^C C,A ApAp/d Aba \ Adt)\C.i fl-t- dd'-Soddt A.M.. and no\Aj A •VI flK*!4^ */. ~i fka.1 Co\ArWoo\rA\ off A. Uil 'St. Ad 4- ^ | ^ ^QUr) .^daJL-S±&A£ ofddTAJdaS DrUSQtA\ « c I ai d SA«d nnSfiimc ArJP A-irtyji /y jJX-r> 0\i.b ^^. A-n rtea<yh t to a SIX *YQ. m l ]£rx CauJ \A)hU h 4>\j^av r>y\£. ' dAa-h 4 off^d ,sn AaAa- Ah ^~VIa --n I niusAS i NO CrAjAA/ s.iir H-H-^ 1/ fl niTr f >r Y up cm. jJAAlddx u —us"—t/t-t •" W-.
A-bJ>A<A lAin^A- m/ dead o\a a Id >m£4Ja£L, amd yyw -y/ykk ><?rd(AS£ m a r\ aiii i TA^. y? a£ Aa\q V-tx\rA\S Cm.
Yin.1* iMz£Md*G-^kA SE a\A)Y\a ) , %AtMqa in S-tie. 4-ha Id f\\i<? VY\C a blfevfz of- rv\AA inyiOffA^Cf^AJrY-^. a ,h bcv \L^nA ^>>^ U2ojrAs df^ m>W fr• aHt ^2iAA^l^^ dU^\6y®*d ln^ca A ' -dndhd QU uJhn-l- Ahz U/olS cavY\e b^riS 4o Cnurb a^d {*f£dT\^ n^^IJ^lMSAJAMl E3 isdAjj vy\£A%v\OiA 4 ^ a A- Ada dlsnz XX -& Al fv\v AvdLAh '<pyUAvr -iuA\<uaoa ^jatwc\ Ah€S ojJaU , a u>w^ f A-QaW Ht fcdkOld a-ECSdAo $KM,M\M htAY pf>**i AjdiaAA re- . -2 YV\Q \JJlClL, Lk3 V\fiA* \J <Lat\a QJAM \A)/9VaJS Jjggr±j :Q£L ^Xl m-\U0JS^ \JLgdA OtVld \ J6U/V &\r.4. I- I '/ii/vi \^,^dr- G\QjjnA /^ i^n n,o ^Pg cMLl JAM j^7/<: ^ tf IsvT \\fUA\JUldidj, AI^'aa a IA wis iK§» <b &f du u«$,£^djuJ AF^'S /£ CjaSq Mo.^4;iS-f\Ao;2ru a heiSe. ad A-Uo \\m> nf A4K.?nL^U,n^,gg a-poAA, .Add dnf.idi? AAia.i r<n^ yym L^a^ dd^fh flA/twrAtn ?/*> dKoid •AAo MacAi "y^SdndA die. A^rr/dA)f^iAc. ^x- -ASlrA-AkndA AAv? t,/AAAr?*SS> JVWy lAz AdAfA Jr.'aA /y /W/ ajg£ Sjf fAm^rA /?U ata, M4L, J?*A <AA? AzzdA AlL7rr/AfAAAj> afAfrAAsS./AASJ Aja^Ja^ ^ J^^AA*
Sf^J^A^d^ <J* M,C7»A*/~ AA*f<wS*Jfe* rr 'dte^.., - /A"A~_ ZA V/zAd AA?d{v^A>A tdA^ Aa^ta (A^7 A-ta^aAaA/' aA^A^ A,As djPAz*? f. A J^.A^dAs.t?A- aaza>^,. /iAt^-JAt^AAA? ,UA?
A)*( 'Aa?A(AAaa? a2a7aAa/a^a?Aa^ ACA&v/sArA-AAA AA^e, dAi AA> aA^AA af- Mr XaA^t AA*JrAAAr/A\ Zy/, AA^A ff^AA?A^ J)arAd/ AAiS />,f,A 'AA^/Asy ,_aA*A^ y^ AArafjPaASatt? d/7j£A,A/*AS A/aaA^ ^fyisAr-A,^^ Jo £>uA AA^jP AsaA&AA, a^aAA /^AteAfAAf^ <Jd?A( As AAdAf Add^Y AdA A?? A>t^t.Ay^__ . -AzvAd )%£ C]L fAffAA /Tas^y, AaLvAt .&SAA Ar<fA^ J>AaJ <Jz A^'f A; A^fA ^^^ aAaZ^AA AAAv•^ A*?2j/r, 1Z A?A//Ag AfASo A?<;Aa7a/ Af^ ^^ -0r?9A*n/a*?£Sf AS- £A^dA^A A^— •UAcA>>/tr*7. ~AAA'a^r, AAr/A /A/7<^^ yAr^>7 /^AkzAA^^a AAaAs 'AAAaA^A^A^ MaA~ 02l A/7j?yAAdf <dAAsAf As Aryfyi Ac Add// SjzA aAs aa£ Aa nAAJAds- //^yf, ,-7~£~-> A?AAAr* A> pJAofSA- A?A /?/br*?// Aj^.AaAs /A//C V^W/ /cAlA/e A2Z&. a^y^nf^TjA AA /^//y yV/^g^ •,^ i^ y^ ^ JAf S/a;aAaA*a-A* A7fAAAA>Ae& A2jAAdL^rdA^A2AO //.XACfAA**/ Aa/jtS A^iAVA/f az^A AAa AA^s AA~ /v/a-. A?A^AAA. <J22&L aA- ASzdX ^d/ /A^cdlf/AA a?Ardyd) A/A.^ j£bz± f?<?<AAA^ /2LL^.Ani9% /snr?jjfs*ra?. As? A?, £ /A/&AA AdCA^Ad^^ • AJ2** r/y/A A~r&sA'^>? so (d7AAd),<AAr<7#A/A ^AAaa^ A^Cs. /5 Case tdaAdiAlS ~Cdl -CAdkOUrd „ Utonf 4p \y^J-J-g ApUA datiAo At^rj AlUaA/* 4AiA\ oSA/^ {aI\ cn{- A.S.AAd^AiAaA .Arjdgf'F;. .yi'mu^ AU.S Anu/Jn^<, mg (?r> ^W^fAaAuiA ^acAi^ a^d -eAMAtA UjhiAV* __ recordsr ' V>x-£ y SJlcdn tfAwd Zga.giL^jpQiL4-^ / u/i> tinners S±^rl ha 4^:S -fat*? a Aid hj> UahS ' dd-t ffi/Sjr r-eSfmpct^ryho. U<aS dAs fjr^fcms Ad ft^A h£- Arj^A um2l ApA.l Ake )d^A?6in J5P3W AM^AdkLt ppa/ArhAdriAA pUdAjfAj met kuS °ii\ £ti\,! 4aUqav<? dJuxjLXKjAf &jg ^hj? atqCf-JJu record ed ph^m Call <%t Sjx tag nhj fck .4^<f 0£.M\a\y\\ ^^^^^iiW-|^t^-? 5^ ^ ^C ^ ^ ^ AfAd T^"^? ^ii CazkL^l 21a7_aM^ UAh, J)io^il£t 33 *n
noifi ynz. ILAd* nA <Mi& AAuZ b#ssA. AJlLa A. Mr, AoArp ah// AA^//aaaIcAAAr^A'C j ^ y aA An ^>->y Ar-(/:^f rvA<f^A*>A, ALaA& jSLn/i A M^S^^2^^ei ApAfJ2L^AS£AA/'A <Ul^%: 2^ ^ |4£ <^^fA^Ajy/ AMjt-AZZj^z4 ^ 22i ^
'JlaalS £^^ iajzA-Mj^AC rIl^yA-4^^-^-^ r /4iACa±aAzAzlJA>z^ CA?A<A/SA(7fr ^AdAfAAA-^'-/AP<zfAa-**---a, y jfa sdAdd^£AA-4^ d%A2fL c^A ^2T /^X ^A/ ^A / ^ZT UA/wAnAA ef y<^ US- Case. un.^'JX-cV-nAOCoR t^V A f e ^ Jd+k MM ^'S Self A dd* 2ksz f Mf 'Y< • Knb&tAr INW^^Tl AA^j^uadd nAaafe t-TTAAA\<AAU-Tl s. SLAA1J/, cA^a^ ^. /,. t ^mrhprr^ \ ^OaZHaU A• LLA )OASteATMS} '-h-r*.
A%l tile nf cmo of U&kL adddl la>u£ fdhJA.AjiAiA 4d,j? hmd dylern hsymAi/L? (L.4^cI-/\a/a haiAt If/j^gA* /mAA^Aj^Aca/ fAJYJSTfd f> /Sir){?rs*?J-1Ze>r?*rdi A/n AAA AAJeAiAA_JA AAalAj2A rAf*rA#A/d /O^.A/Af A2/A& AAlyAAA A77U2.. *rurt f?/7d A)^f AAa .A/* , £4A (A /a y- Xa^j7 ZZ T X ' c pA/>de- AC A dAs/Atrr'S, Aia/M> AaJAtez r? /rismrz**/-'pArr^ A> A/a, AAtfA AA:f<? J£dx£uLJ£A2J-AezAULf^A/ a?^/ AA,s q^y <ZZS£. A>A /Ar<f A/ A. t^ajTaACA , A/,aA,aC /ja, rAfr-fAfitsaS testAaA. A*? A£* AAA7^'C /sAA^r SA7 , dA A& dAn^OCaLdzdM^dA^JdC^A <AS A^r^ '"' A?S< A^ f-AA^AjmA. /^ hAA Jd^_A,. A 'aa/7a?a^: A^nA^rA yy, a?AA aaa,<aA Ah dd^/^, A 't&iAtA-,*AAA^_y !_TZZxZI ,Adz^c>J AAAA- rrn AA_, Aa^*Ar /y^^si^r aaaaA/^A a*s,A lAAl grzAA/a,Aa,a?<t ^ Xy jAA_,SALld teCA/Ar&r-'f
•4r?ol Af^ /aaIJA±ia?SA .SA^A^^aA -T-J^AaA JAv jAz&dd s^f AAA&^3^ata?rrA A?,Art r ^^/ X-A uA/fhA^Aa,c//Aa> "uA/AS//A? . of &f., a^AA'AtWA^/^fA AAA AAS^-ffAArsA AATrS ^S-S AjAx ,4 ^A- ^A- AAaJ2J*£l 'AA^/a^kA^At^ f /aasA AaaAA /fad!
AA/ /A-^p/im 4/- &13a AI.Ad. . AA* j/fnWAsA#f« ACai^ ^A?/- dA-Cur#<; JjzAAsAf AAa ^c/AAn-. ajaaiA'Ate oA>^ % c*te m+4:/£-cV-Oc2Q6J*> AAfAS Ar?-Atf*?-/A<r?7*/As.
Lf - —7 AAa^lA SKA- "/7/A**, fd.AJAdJsd a AA^pAy^AA a^a^'*UAua bA^AA aA- J4r, jf/,jU>f~./ACIZs'. h4A» S7WA Pro WteJas'S a?A^a?aAa/'aIA^/ dAA^AA^^ ""' /^'-/- ^L^aa-c*y^A MA. '^^/f^ZJ?^^ *r /.r /aA-aa/ sp / <> Ar\ AA??pA?A-^_ -A*AAd r/d A9 Ao «
7 a2a227L tA7?n \a>a?i Of 'SAi-AdAdfA2AA2z£_ A^AX^r^A^AA^^^^s^^^
/tw/ . XAA X/X^ vAAa;a>AA Ac A^i^_jA/jL A^A}^,/A./y1A' QAaA? yy q^ A- Z*.C~. /^ ^y //,, r^AAaaaaAa /O.y a% -A^y ^ !«ei 1,^
U*AaxA=S_Jt7 /iff, ne'v* J^r r«a ^y^y At> *- ACs^ 4*^1* A* der A** Lsf- AA?>$ A Cf-aafia/. awi dv/n/\AfA A AxQJJ a^d CT~ '/aa^, addd'Agof- iJAfAdpdcJ(^)u7fddfC dd -?q/ - a ^ x ^ a A7 £ )n av\d <ASA i k-> 41a/ )n^lp ju.4a^ f^Ain ^v^^uic^ai r-. j i IX i X77X7T? ,X ..A/. '
.S^Ai 6u£l r\A> SS.- and Ad^L -A/X nf Afoi S Xl-luaAiV-1 ^n, 4imf IS V?f" rvyi tow Sldj^^fc^jdM of- ufoaUvt* JU-xts X 4^.o\f/Jr£ QdaSan nlf'iclcji^ h&u£ pu4~ crn m£-> — ' ALL-e^ ^fAvnasd &\\wii r \"~ ^ '-rr ' ^ "Y ' *"l¥ ^ ^"/ *"*•' / —f ~ T \dQc8L cC\in<i *— y ^ /Jan PA^ri 4 h£4^ t n 4i-£ ^x?i> n£ 44-v C Vnam C C& UjIAA 7)i/r>up. if.
PsiU. g\\ A^ m^Je we. ha/V. /\.A iA. (XA./ r4$p0yi£j> tLfn • • r-~~rjArA^^A^—^'v—lJ ^1^'r~ ^-w-n >S^A '*
- -nf) /l si a '. - Al .^ _ a, r f I.
YI _ vn.Ai^„A- i i tu ..-z*2,,^X-o A ±u*u LShaf dnn *»>- 'sdds ^A ,lkk„ -"fp-^7^^ A /S j^^ A,n aiaUaj 1 1— AJAlAIAt prgjArTa .OAnj as!
OfUUL' C^pfA^te
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.