Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Wysack, Michael Edward

Wysack, Michael Edward
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided October 20, 2015

Wysack, Michael Edward

Opinion

/039-/5 -Aca^joLLz.13 - oloA&Z- ~cfi.

__ LSMJ0±^±^U^^JUS ggngr-oFCRIWilNAL-APPEALS- HOM STO.Y\.J-X*>x.c&eS- oenKrtw*" Sftir.ha.-eJ EDv^A^D \MySACk AJjjeJLa+aJi

Si-vcf-t. oF rt)^4-s_ .^LtR*J.tJte.

S)„ft_^p-p^-C^l^Lft—lULJA-Sjt-/M,^^jO_ .JL3J.d_JLU.0- \£jjc^±^^SJlXjXdtr-jCjOJUUC±.j^±(^ r^f-CCS rtoMo&A&LJt^FJiAA/K-tAAm^

TDCX&oltrk°tl3'$

T-6 n Q*lS&^_^J_<w#_/Jj!(Z_?3rjKkb- Pro - SJZ ^0^_^CCL^I__A_tC^i^/rt&nt ij£Jte.oM*.si&L SJLil TEL.T ..TMJDlEJL £43^ P'our-tleS -to rh-e {&$*, 3=- TjyjJL&JC_oJLAM±korJ±Ajts —^~ __^JzsjL€.^.eji±—oJz__cjuS^ — —— y~ ^^Jj^±*^JLiOdt-aJz_£ciu-C±s '. -^- _^jp$Mlcu^J^£o±nf—o£_£Yj:oJC —&- ^^AjJ}-iA,M-*j\32. _ — — * W<p^ C.0J4.CJjia.J-,j>J±— — Lf- f roLy-cr 13— AcL£±l€-C-t&-t:/ije__C-aJ-*- ^A-EL&JJjusJJ _jaJ___zm.&_L Jc U^\^ccjc.U.-^^yjjij:Jl- ^t±*L/___L/_j^/__4^_^ /V_ /" _ • ELCkfl-fc^J ,_. t Ecu ley Mo-UA ton, TJr ZJO.&f J3&leJJMMe±_ Z/;?___£i___/y_</_££_ .__£t£L/'_xy_^_/_^ Ma,sne t H-eft-h 6-./f//t°^ „_£$-«' kAJa£-jd&ix^—£^ltejJ^ J^UcU.CL,/3j_j_-aC-Z7-G-^-- T*fv£fojr_ej_fe^_£20^£0_££^ -_^^j_<fcl^___t/.?___5___V._

APPELLEES —JTME-J±Ate _&£. JZEXAS. . _^^ r/k*)< j^.__tt^ _<______£_,' &&./L±_£j_rjfc/_^#_A__^*-^,d_^_^^ _4_£jLt5J____£__^£,_W/^/^ __l_^*Ll_____l5__^_;£^^ _^^_/_e.7___^_y_/____Z7_^XS: ./_:^__^.__%Z-f-J=:-£^^_r_/_£:^.<=

-grCL¥-0r/rj. fvUnty r.r/sni'yia,/ Oft fr<c +• A-H-ar/is*-y_ _^^^___^jL;_JS_>_^_:£.G/^^^^ _/._/-/£..»-._-o__. UJt^JRjOjo^aar-M^itzA- -A-tf^JjeLto-M-jJEkL-ZZJ,-/ r r./jyg/a^e ^y;y- M*i-i&z& .____tJ___12L^_____:4^__Z-__?_i_:_.

o* r C^*C $ TA/C\t=V OF ArLATUQb £TT 1= A p_^s ___L/^./_,:_^__t^^5_7_^Ji:_./_^^_i«J^^ A-l iSCO rasflp \S. 6j-u4~*'^ 7 7C~ S,f*s, J-e( p-dCrcy. A?f. -3_^ AiniDnlO /?£-<», P<eJ- r^f'J ) ____L_2..__l/_jg:..i«_5.., \st ai-wre.; i(rt *./•, j></ ^s^cr^r, -/-/^, A^p, __s^/~J __j8______i«_i________r.i__^ 1$oy}»?tV» Is, sf*A~V; 7,?F- g/>*^. %,e£ 704 Crey.*pf.~l-ho>U5tvy\0+"> Diifffl I9?<?, Pef,r*FJ) _C/f^_#_______;___^_Z£__^^ _____t__*________</_^__-_w^ 2ZZ4LU3P3JL __ __ _ _Xj^-/_____:/_4__//__/^^^ G~wtrc/£u Is, 5 ' ^ ?Of Stir, _V £;_ Cr^4cs Ar/> - S^/i A-HPh't\0 2~t?0<})

F* pa,rf i#>Jh*r*,- 7!f<rs,i~<,id y°7i (r*+- ,x#*"i .^y*. life) Y4*ry) rj,r\et-eZ> IS* j faTtv»/ 726> 5.PK JLfiT $~3 { 7~&C. tr~t.<K, st-ff, I^He ) Hlfi- jst cte^Hij tt i*~, Set (»c?7 (T^r.s^r-/*. -sU^Hm t^o/V^r- rriTV) t-yo*t is, A^cceH-tr, ?70 fr.±S yyz-7 cr1"* cfr. 17W sHr^ir+.-n is, <a-m,++ I7f, S.hsr ^clfr-r? Cr-^r. A-f>r. - rasT Woy-th JU?Qt, ) -w4____l-__A-J-_-^-_* &/'SSatt_.J?3L2LJ<iJ.t-ZS'7 £ 1*77°) sn;l/^r^P.i \s. it*,ihrj 7Z-3- f.<K, JL<£ r°(£ Cr^.cH/n, A-pf. (Wf) JXUuugjCLatuu^u^^ OlAS-fh f Is^Lts&feLf-fclkZ. .S.VXXi/ ill C*e4r< Cri/K . A-fta >W^l.

PointI k A-**-bu-/net-J *•*•? ot'5 t V^ f/q*o.)

J^^y^^—\s_^}4rg.p^/-(s^—^^Jxc.^.cl_7-^^~. CT___..^f/»/t. - Ccih-p-tSLS—ah-r2iUJZ-L^O.£-ll^-t.„Ke^cl)- jRoh i ft 6jOJL-JuL,A±ufc£-,Jl(* S>. US' ^JtV^CJL*fc^C.tllL^^^p.f>t.£-0-dCL) £.cd.et2r£k£-J^±*&$3LT,'fd SjiStXcLS3<> CEsfajcr/zn ^.^jlcxlX)

. \sis~-ecc1-h^s-hy \s, *trut>>t Ct.4-7 S.hs. A_/ 7^9 S r-cfr. rr.'^n. A^/" Itfa) consi-;TL4t;o/>i<. ...14,1, casic,f-rJ AsQ~e*d<;r \/t cunttXI \A

T€V, Cad*: oris* /__^___^___.^._L,__fe__-t_3.^-3-2_ _Z_____j_^_i£L_:/:__x__tL^3 taJre. sine-h-T n~£ -Mi- z r sa <; *> £_£L_^J__i__L__jU£^_/_^^^ U!L^jL£jbcjcLjcua--£2j7J& qo_lljs}TS. a-f c^f&^rt^ is^-hod. .<*jew<_./ a *».< o (A /1 X^-fi-f-6u±A~X,—Ilh e. gj£j____Xt^__g_£_l, ta*LLep*&d—jJB-JsjxJsA^^ ^l£0J4JLtU^JjlL0-te^ M-i^^—to—%3--y-*<-fr/^£ '/;si y°/n*-sn.-e,fisf- ,'a? rhe r-ftr* f> /i^^/^^^ o~A~ _C_r/_r^>#W__jr/_^ , us St+1 Xh~* A-*hi-*ri6*4.< f-o r-i*-* £_?•? ^^Z-^^y->___^./^_.t_^)-,-,4^^^-^ __ */ tLpa-e.(v/ tLS-u^i y^,W</ ort Ttt/y/&,Aat$ ;Ccfl / &*-<>*/J„ __ ft ?-*. re ^ ^it- {? f- F^sts X_____5_2?r^fa_5—£/i/C£ gAJJijB>J^.f &- co/:/>ar*vj__ _(__/_:7_-7__t__^_fr/ltf^^ £.IAol. j^huhe/o s^fZ h-rr f-r^o ^_.__-;frVi7Sf/y _>•/- ^-A^g /r/A^t.<• *V//-g PatiY* 0-erpct>r1-sM-c*i1-t C/{R.I **''t-9^)' At- ?-h* j-/sriyz j-hey sn e ^ /5^<ft, l^_xi _i^_/___;j^_<__^ ;_>^/:^-<st-^^_yb-^/__^_^__^^ -C.CLiip.CLtJuL 0-C£.6_Us //? f-olT/ri^rf- (E\s~6c 1~A*i>f- h t s~ £t-~^~en Sy l^cri^fd Sljp±z__k£.. ___A_t^_t6—-^2___-£^____^^ — iAs-yfur.h ~^,/ K^-A-crs-^d K&r f-o h^f-^-c ;V^_ Yct-ia ^//-A /-*,/» f^c^r/A^id, ,J-CiUc^-t^f^Kl^^^£Tcil,J^

Sfie&/lL Xcf-h±£z. cA/j.c/.rt-'x.. _h~e,c*LM*.-e? ._&.«/T_&_fe-^£_____l.__£^ .._ ._k_«>.jL_Cfct tU-hf-h^^-ttf, CKR\ ^tAf)^ ._... .._ .

AR&UAA.en+- A bef.erida,trfi.\.ln-cu crim',nu.i rncuf hc*s The.._._"/'Hht to CT-fccti\7<. _CLliZlt_^e_(jf.x.o^«i:e/, U,S<..Co.#J-t.-A.M&#-df..-VI-JU!iJ-XX.Vj Tex. X.OJ0ST..jjLjrT. fj-SCCAO.; JR.pjus&U- V. Ato,bc^syic^j ^r7_u,..St.MA~j 6><*(FiAX).

7r/V/ CoiAAScf Milst ccc^t within Th* tft-h Cf._ _of competence.. .._ ^e.Mj^ja-d^d—^.^-cc.f^..A^ja.e.y^..ija..crJ.^i.^^J _„>$_•$« A(\CAf\o^hft \A. R!cku,rdsohr JAfJUU.6;, .7jn%r7J'tUl570j...JTh€ _ scu***.- st-er«.U&jrsU—.**f/J-y-JJ!i ...tVAujM a*.Tl.r\.fj.. Tb.^-Jr^p.r^.5j&.ajha^±idtL/-bM.1z-£.i<^*i—^- Sit*#/_'_ -CKroK. ^EXpatt't-c Eel-tony FIT S.w. &d 733y 73 U CT<-*. cr.i/n, Afifi.MIl) , Xn .. . . cl ddii-ioti/ c*~ d-c££.*i-oLa~*T ih a~ arJAninuuLjjrrtu-l cl_qes_naT n*-ed To object &t ^Jtc( fo Cou/iS ^ls lrf eiA?eZtiis_<L^ts_y*sje4*Gut!oh TO~ _ _ Jt.KcSjcrjrc-Jib-€,— isS-K^J^t2_c^_AfQ-&J^LA$^ v.-. s-t&^t^j 16*A,. kt^.A-dAtoX, _ _•/.? (T-tX.Crt/rt.Afifr-XOOQ). _ Xn ord*er to ha. ise __ con s/ictiOM K€..isenr$je_d on— «^/?/_£^/>_^h <£/3«e//«t.r\ii ../tfMAi-:^SJjavs Th.^T-Trituif.CcH4H4AJAp&r_forst>i-Cctsic^ msc^s oicfic^^it ..-Cuhd. TbaJ-jth<__c/L-tT\Lc^ftA^^(^tiriforyvt^r\c<.jec.AMJ$^^J9—fiJ£Aj-u-______ .To The d-cfe-HoUutnt- by d-^pKirin^hJ/yiof a- ~fcL.fr Tr/u~/ i*s/t/i ___€k//_^i?/:__^«^^ _ ,_TA_i_^/?/_fe/^«_)__, COMXT--/*i_4*_t" Ju^e. T-f-i-a-.l--C0-U.nSj&CJ- com.dlc.Afi bo^5r:d ._ _t//>0>_ _^.«__^.^_^r_..«7.fe/r.___«r.^"tsL. rf jzct^&h _..£#,x-e ,.X_s/..__„.. b 10... Tb-e. _ .-Cuy/)je.tl-4,*iJtL.^jnj<lti Sho^hs^^jTh^f- trijcj_ c_c\ah £yzIs re-prv^e^T^tta^^U _. . b^io^Y Ccn . .0j>j -ectir-C. 6Tcusida.sd of i€.u.Somc^b\^heSS .Id ct~Ttett.

Xh d-ctmrsn thing ihe.f^e.c.TiiS't a.f$ ictcL. nc*> of c_o. u.ftS-e Ir. th •*•. . ct^/fie-llcunA syu4±st J'deitify. .c^ct _o.r_-j2./*\J L5.Lo.t7. s^bjyAzrla^L-CjLun$-e^i . •i-h^t {As<.r-c n/rf- The, results oJ^tCou^O-h-C^bX^-^prP-feg&i&rt&•( j-U-df-sinetit ._ .-tcnU-Wicri^ occTfid^c _T_A_e __r^«^._. o£~rK0$~£.SSlonc*J\y Co /npe-t-emT ^-a,AsL$T*s*c^-'£d,-C^T-<i>^ i^pp^liconT mi^^t She.^^a,.. . _ . r&c^zoncL-bl-c f_£0_b^bJli'±Y-±h<istj b-U-J' tox^_ctunseft- Uhjt>r<>-fes$t't>ri^L , -errorSj-t-h-c r^SUtt of Tlt^ froC-e^d'n^ vtsoutd titer*, b-e-en dtif&rent.^ ...J d> clA bfyt^ t Beckon cc-biz, forebcvbl lityJ $._^^proba<hLl-Lliysj<t£^lc\jtyst- j±<L—lAn.d.£r-/to-i'.n4- Th^ Confi d-&tice Iri. Th^e a-U-t-Co^sm ^e... IdtALhe. _. ^S'Ta. n decrds ol-sinoUri C-e.d Jft $TrilckJ^^d-<kJf* ^ /? /y_XO ...Cir.i *\\n au\

y XjM.jijeLS.-Jja A~^Xecs. s.e-e.. tt^rh^^deT^ \r> .5-^_w_cv_.j?'^.4--i._H<-./ £ d s~3 (T^r, Crlsn.App..MECX —XA—±h.!S—CUfS^.j. D.etA/hs e- cg«_i__cA /jj_ ^ *^0jA£_._jzj&L0-r£-jJ>m!bJiajgjd~ ___iz__ _-_5 -'-/f- /./-. _"# «. ecpp e //<*_ .. t r-e c €j_ir/ r\X} i-VLcftLe. zJzlkLje^c^ss/sT/^tr^^.. .of CounSet. Those *.rr*r$ Inc4icd^ec/\ lJ.F*rJ-ling. tA object Te ._. . ... \7i c . /.-i J/rLpa^cT_ T-e$tj_/iti0fiy. cL^f...JTh.^^M.u.i\lt7.Lki.i!i..o.c-e/ix.^..-phcc..^r^ _._of iiricclj £) -fa.i/,Ag To object- To hveersay.j 3.) p-cK-sn.,:t±in r_h._?.__ ihAJL.O^AMCtJon_j)J:^XATrccA^eoMS _<*. _f_;. M. ~fu>itJfty _ftJBSjbj if ._•_-_ _____#/_./'_p_< ta - TeST'Ai oh _y Aeyyct,rdli\0The dtf e_n dusj*TJ.-QM±\T^C.hd- Th*_t<?^pl^'iHju.*3:\.._ ^ TrierH.fM(h.ess'J fee/Liny to record Jifr^ Se/eci-.'onj £) /nAsTa-Tiny facets l _ \tn cltfsiny e^r^usnenTSJ a,h d 7) failing to object To Th-e co^tesiT Off &-pen.it en victory _pct~c ^^f* - .__ T/l C- ....tjrtorA. ccr-e diSCUSS e.d ift detc^J oc-6 follows', .— • * • 11 __•_-___•_•_••_-- W I- nwiw mil I -———...—i.— ••— i m «^—•___•»«•_ •!•- ••••-..- --.!•! •

J_ ViLtiAA ZsnPa.ct Te<+i/nor\y outth . rru;trA.n* pettier rhccSe, _/)^ft_fiJA caJciU^t._{-cc<U&d--TO- .obJ^cT ..jh__ _"./!t_ri./n iwpcect _« *fv ._*» <?/I^_ -Jh.tJ-n£.pf•£.$-€>nlhCrt- cct The cjujt/Innocence phase ofAJbje.__TJCjJkU - , £*"«- T-.y-//r/_*/ b^-Nr^ The. jucry, dtcrJnj The guitTSinnoee/ice. ph<cS&t. .^.oJL±h-x, JTSlcc.tjTh^j1_^s^r^jL ^-. j ^jiAtT^e.ri^ejljtjh eK^pyj _£>___j__^.$__c.*c TTt nyy h^nS^eff^cuhdAhe k- .Lt^^-, T- Co^s^tt X#_^£„^a__,_&^^^ chjdren ilk*. . h^r^jCAlij^c^T^if^^^^) *.R^^i^tt^ *>/-0 Testi-fiedy w/thocct ohje<L-L_ -JrJjM-jXhAAtZ*-Uccycc \*sooilU cut he^rS^etf, CfiRl c^T lOZ& io*)e __ 0_uTS..id-e-.oA. Tht Cowt-e^T OF novryJcid-e Co-J^S, isicAl^i i/tnpa^cf- .. 4\ri_dvA.CA_.J,5. .<y-eti-e--rtctty •d-cFi'hvd c^-S ets,rU~e*i£-e. T-e^frsd,'?*& 'cThe. -..-.pky6tLaAor..p.6.y-.ch.ot0&'iC£ct * AAecf .* F The. er/'stn-c en Th~e~ ._ls'AH<*tf- __JT/) ^ W^l" Leohe \r, StT^t-Cj rx#- $>^> £d At^LjH t CT-*->c. crt<~>AfA_ . _ --/.5_V-J.AAi-C_h/_»_il^ny_A,£_tz^eJCld e/iC-e. / 5 J^n^r^tly floT a-y„_ /<_ _£A- i.b-T.h-*'—£-M'.i-lJt/J-hnoee_nCde y,h^ccJc oA. the -rrltts/j- bM.T- co*!_4'€_--_/^» /tT-eJ.^ ihJthe—pj^J^Jsh./n^'^T y^Las^t i»_.^.e.<i ilh,ttAt~ €__/d^enc^ -&<cs--£0.*i-t-~ b-e^t,'/,«,___ or? /"/i-^- d-eF^n det^nT\ ..p^rA-0-Vl^lAr.&ypert.sib.l \-tjt-y--Ci,-*,d- <^orc^( Ccdpa-b '('Fy»~ f-ttrticc&tt-r-r* ste^T-e^, //q j.k 3d 7a(. 7^r CT-*4r, A?>/?. -*^^to ^ootrHT,..

i_ ^_,^Cc-F\d)., Jilting J*u(gu_Z-o~s \7. stu.te,y %£> s.*s. )(£ 33oy,$$*r-rT*Js. er,Ai,App?. ._ s\0P.£J; \A>xTij>*^LZfJLsKortyJA-pt~€. /.*_*_<__. y -»W/__< __*_^_?_7___*-_^^ fo _•£#.<<-> e it dfi-e^ hot Tvi.d—to ^n^tne.^.<*nor-e, c/r less frobc^bte Th t_«*_kte.iif_.. . c~e of c^txy fu^c-f o7~ con Sen M-en c-e cAt~ «_«.//'/"_-. in _c>_^_. __<__ »__?-_*./_£/'/-_.... . . i/. /Tta-f-e-.//_ _.^. .V ^f-7 .V. ? _C Ty*J£.^jAf.yL.^.£mrt h^rTn^Z^oS^Jj . __:<.-f*reh_cf^^_s^ll_l_ArfLTSL-i_._$-J_*3_e>f.Zf:p--£• <*r.-A.#_ fc_f^/..^Cl<r_fc_^i_,__L._4^- . /_f_fg-X_X/_____a_AtiM-yJth * ^7?/_TgJ./jl±^_ _g__<?___,_? g-Z/A _tk&T—Th^L-jtn;.ad_ Co ccrT - _./)&._<// it* d^ cre.1~t _-»/ by ctA/oifSttj^ T/i<^ irJct/sm of <-- S*Jf<4a^( Cuts.ttJctT-Tv Tj*sA.ifLy euftL^J^LLT/Anro-C^nC^e. ^_^rz_7_____/^/^___?^^ _/i_e^__^_i__*_.#._*_e3 OJjfuTkje, enlsx-e. hu-js-^ h-u^d <rn /* _y___£^/<__>.__7__£//<_ Zjf_jtlil}_C£uteyJ^\/:^—j*^d 0_s__./«_// AlS—±c£*k.i-*i04*y.- _€ £^__^/l/^__t:A_e ._, a,ftcr^^jff_€.c.T§ Tht*st.. Th-&-—itd(jejpjedss*iS.ec kfitl. h#A. h&d oH-2~t^-d&~/ «_.

L5___C/-_«.>_./V l_7£ 7_<.'_^t /ss\/0e*seLt T-^S-Hsi^.(/tqy Th.&st~ i^aisu/d lr\,g-is-e- l^^-d . <£.--_ f fi^-e.c-T on The jtA^ry'j d^Lb-er e^T/p-tx cri qui Ij-AJhrt^c^^iCrtL^ !A4<^&_llQ-ifiS_JLn.y t^iTL/n.o:H-y—0-T\-A-.b-u,-*i.do _-_<___- Th^^-t^jJbt^p„/iac$^e_ ^j-fJrrtAst.: JCSjfc*Att3s OjjL^y_f.U Twke ^«.^ u^Lttan< to CThe dp^pjc^/m z_„y-J 75? h^t/cf. h-c-r In. .e^ny ^*>s~tL.y j*s~/.Th. Th/5- syi&AhTerjj-tuny_____^_ £L>_L JJeJStMA^L-M-a^S^jLzXrLc*. S_.«_ -ZAbJ4nAo3J^yeA.y.Jl^rojDjK^_ ht.rrts!3_±J\. ejc^yy.,.

4XM^€^J__Dx/__/<_^ ^kjLj^t—yo^uKL dccuffiter^ frny ThKn^ ThnT Ahe- *_r*_-5_ deijnjs^ tO—hjr_r_6^etiA __ iLhj*st^cjCL.j^j_^.</__yc'14, concern?. - XdkhjA*AlJl _>_e—-__• _:_^c^^^^-cy___^_^_7b_/l^^_/_Z_^X^-}_: A?^. £jit_4i__7; — £__J_/je_i »__< £:__/__= ^^__l_l_/___0/^__cc_^^ Thcy_ccf^e f-/*Jr-,_*_^i*^--r___^ <-.i-^f—*o/_t #_jr/_f_c_i-__v_c#7-*)r i_t.—*v«_ ——rv-.n •«___ sn_'_^. i w i_i i A. P/4 __/T" __>/_/- c/nUahT^r- U^z_,C r/*rfyi0?

^AJbM&d0lA3Jhj^t.Jik* .Virori Trying to C0sn^,f Suici(/fj &te^%A.—£-\sc*-_A-bjAjLiM-0-)-JL ph-yti-CfrJ—0-£-p.S„yJLk.olo^/c&-t-^&jA^€Jijf^.oJTlA=h.e £i_/./_j__«_*_J_3a- _tsdcT /\_*v h€ASetM^^Pl.... Ab i^rtdoA-Tesi-i^tOfiiy^Js^ c/^^eiy_js\ic±i^^/^y>_u.c.^ — 7____^___^___y Th^uTZ-i^o_k^/-d—h.t^.kL^e. h"^<f ^^ ef-pe.cT ofn th^e_y,_u.tlyJs-. __ JLeJjJtj&jr&JjM)j!L^jteL^ *jl<2 ^____<_7_iL„ -HoJVJ&^-£^Azs,„A-bundo- -*/«* * -Te$Ti-f>jedJ\nL^coicrjtJi._ ~J&u.aAbJJ—&y^jfrj£j?e./r_ *0^. ;/? order._£pr_ h-er To^/.oJzJitLtAJiiBM^- .SEL±\_oA-AXTEsV\lArTQ^ SJU^M.J/^^1zh<^lJr^5-_0Jt)^oJ^^ M-e^pJ^oJthdi^kZd-S—1^£0-r>i cj&j^jn.j-Xh^-0+SA£.ll£eJ -y^_e_5__//«,/_7__ 0jjfj>tshtAt .yj.4LJte/J—tjti$_3L&^^ _- tj-0i»s*.r-cr/ 1~eSi-fxyHfiny re^c^rdi kg Th g- fOSy cSiy/ejrJCc^f li*ty>u-ct Thuu^fff _T7_t 0jffe.AS.de h&S^hi^d ^-JTfi^~Cd..<ny[_e^^ _/_•£/_/. _•_; //'ij. . /7i<?/- cfo.'fdr'tri H^-e h-*/-___v__5 Lj^p_eJL/o_c..C-Ayr5.-tt.-^nay—^ ,__fArL—y-^.JjTdiMn^-C^^CjAt ___._/)_^_7./W/Wj-_TI_i£_/-_»^ 77?«. UsAA-en t,~ff~ecTs^ ThuTt. The * outLey*.-eA' .c^.ssa~M.lT—keuSAbc^d_0_ri_2r-c^dK.y-£*. >_s_ c i-e^r-ly \sicti^ T^SAJ^fi/iy^.- -Thto'T ksoiAs/d ad to viso-u,(d—h^d^c^n. .£.£j_A*y__tf-tf_)b^ .-0^nc^J4.iJT/-infD.(;-C^en^ie, __ __AfJhe tJ_r$J^bJsT&.CJt^c^u.eT^0jLAbp>,A __?_ <?^ r__Ar____S_ySAzu^eS _*>_*___ , T_A.C_ \rLCTl^^^i/^pa^T^TesTiy^0ny—JS -&^fiJ&-r&J-LJEf^e,Jj£:eLCu.nJr- *-T /jr/7j__ - (y Ui It pht^i _• t. ^ _-/!-_•. -t-r.k^l b*e Cci. is.s ** if- gC^es i*sf- T^^d t0 s*tu,ke> ^ryyffr%^ojr_l€Ss p t-0 bcc-btt.. The. €y)S tenc-e. of- ccny fu.Lt Q-f .

Con£-e%u*!ric>e ^t T/r-e. <j~"-^e r _

r tl-OJ#JJCrer.jA5~_h •€ ~t1Z Zftlsnorty b. V£o c<,nd Du-nJeJIc^ STH^tje^d x_^_^> r /i^-^-^e Zej^^-^cygc T~-elT,fy of ctrty h-er svi -€^n. ri e S ;V^a.cf o f ~JThJL C.^-sA^-t^svSCo.h.itt^<—Th_e_ _*/!_«_ fze«_^^/*_T____ _/L_y_^___r>__^ /fce.

Ag_*/ Cpeyi/n Jj^-ed f~h-e C/f~_i^ri. e. - *__/__-*/ _ <_# _ A^CTt /4_t_*_ _=i 'jJA^-pJt-y-3dC&:t—-u.r-/-S-y-CA.e-/0-^sAlc^/_eyj£Ae_CT-—Ojf- Th^z C/_A_____ _£____7__/_e__t_#L6l7t/,*i_j_ _/-/> *^v, y&/V&S?,_/__w__e ^ 5t&AAe - $_*_._ __..__',_^_^_3,-_^_V_/ . . M - _ _ .

lR_,_c:_/j_-,^,/f?,/J/ ^-A^ d^e-A^^A^c- C<yu*7*-et'._*ru>* deAjCLt-e^T . __«_/W//^_J.? Abj^CT* ..

HFAqSAY TESTT7V\0/dY ^-ti€-r/*JJLTLn_g Tb--e-—u^d/nJs5joy\^o. P.Jft.ci<_aLsjLirsSJAl^^^h < CutALeL,y—CJ!u*i—-- — VLSl-O-iir) 7__ /:«?- Jnefffecti ire _c^As is.Jtcun C^e. 07__. £? tuns*,J. __/__suXTincj i_#..._ft_ _r___l•e_//"__"_5_A _.Ojf Avu_d-9-sn.&t3Jt.-.-Cc,-ri.d t~csin, ct^ri_d .-AorJ- «- ft -e,^«< Tirio^^^JS_^di^J.n^ir^Sit^f^y C, .£.$__£**-,-_.-d ZXrJLJLT.**:. XTfL/ri^App-JXPt-). ____J_£__ir/_/_*_/^_Vj_jfLeJ2.A-e._e:^oo-n-6jieJL^£^i.t^M-^Ta—oJ.^LecAz^ to_h_2jcar-JAJy- - ^—,—0Jl} hu/n^tCo-tcS__ oCC<c_5LoA£ ,. Corp~o ra^lAo-cMoa t^a^s^cu t/ 0 **^ed -T&-.- _r_£_:<l-fVy_i3_/l^ Li Hie noThinS-~^f<-^=S- be.in<y dent To h^etfi-^erckiid} no oh-e. ._ _v*_ft<5. lAs.Teii-irt-q. 1~0 her Si-ory)CLmd £/>-e \ascl-S je^Tt'tna^^ The' KcC^i. „^r0-U-H~d<-CARJ-uA^AA.&_(l3A^ JoH„JA^hAAlJ^jLs^_cc.sJc--ed- Jt.^r. _.77 Ji.fi-efiuJc ToJ^Th^^e^i/dX^en b^Ca-icS __ _ M^rJ-d-c*~-U-£hA-&.rJhc<~d h^.-esi Ue^p-r-cSS^.d~cccfx-d—.i^s^.s cL.uTTA^—kerAe^iTt^, Ji&fLX-{tAt-X.qJ$^0 -th-O-U^-jaJAJ jQJ[-Ly—OAA\-ep-—L0-riAtt^.cT--$h^—k^d—y^<Jte .&_€_: ^-.n/ Thc^nk-ed he.r -for h<r A<_//o._£_/_/? /_6_/____6Jl. . _a. rl^nd Police De.fic(.rfv*. _;/. y- Pc^t-rois^^n 'Hic.h cc.-„_ Zt*Je(— j>^jty.t..TJt.esT'ijfiedJ~__._)__.oi*Jt— oAjectLon jJTJ^c»AiJEjs:a,_^ .

JkAl/nvAred Ci,r\(l_upAj^JjXaz.Cj^jjcse. She hu^d—^JAySjf_j£0-Vth^oL-.0-tA.fj. / _<^taL^:t__±:A-e__^X^ V7ouh ±td Sen *l Tfy ; nf do^ * \s* 1 edlcufe-ly t CRR\ clT j*^)_ officer _2_<_CL0Le7^_fl_c_y^.*__fc7./tf__t:_JL^/^ Th-«et. E kA^jTald^hi^^jThgcAl _$h^ h^cl AirtA h eturd a^b^ut The^_.«t_L«L_je__j_:/_._ _L iter cla^a^^h/__y^V frUnel.a^L^tAAZJ Af ri sti 13 ell oU/n . mi^Thjt forem $ ic.J^>__:f_e_r/.c_ut<ier_ ^rr_i*i-e_ __ chi IdC4ft*$ A-d. VJo.C coAjy_ C.e _»_ Ttrj^h o in ter\ri <. *r_* <d 7 cudouya^^ __ :tf_?_j_£:__l«£_/y_w_i_*_^^^ <X.LS_c/.6.s^ed-^ ^__5_^J_.^^J_^_6_^_1^__t^__/i__ ob^jeCAii.on-j-cci^T'-O h.0J4c^z.co_d£uy-CL.—U-&sA^rLLb^d _...p.^nlS., CAP. if £cTATOA.AThe SftcTe \nr-eht on To Streff Thz,Jsnfi_CLf--. __£ ___C^tf__L_£^.:i_^_#^^ h-c-U'r-fia.y 7V-/7'_yt _//7i/ /rt Th-e^iT ctoSi'My, ^/^&__«/rT__&y_>_^ ThuA~ i^STi ** orty wi-Hx _. $j3dtels_.M-x,Hlbit_/ifo.£. ccmd-yoM. ctun ft hinK a-hcict Th* s»c5T i««perta-KT T*6tiy*ohy ThuA ftrnTi _f <,//<•/^snini he^d. .$_h_e._._P <*~id. ThcuT Z*-doi.y_CL, _. LG-.dLCoAtA^d _yshtut~ SA-e _s ct^ots^ ^yWT"_ t T loolr-ed iipc-e pm Jtk € d e.~fes?deui th.

P^&.—CAfLkL^T^Lj8jk/L0jc.m ___£______l£:<C/iy__5J_^f^^^^^ _3§_-£Z&_l>-e_<_^S_-__£j_^ 7r/>_?_#^7_-£^^ 0jt_dceJtAjJL9j^e cp /_vi __• / 7*Z? u^der<#Mkj —Th.^^L^MsL^o^^o^uA^cry-Jt-^-STi/tav^ c firo-p^/^-obj-e-c-tt'tn ._—TA^Cor^obM-^LsTtnty /__$__>-_* ^-/*_^__/2s_£^^^ A-pA>L^S-Cc*^AnojfaLo_JL0oy\AL^ JLJj^-A^.J=Jju.4-^^XLV-nXJ>Jl32^^ cmoh-^OMS ct^d-s*\.L$$Jo-ft oA—he^£J6^—1^fTiJn-o.tf.y^ ..-./ri..0Jt1yAll.i-d^-CJf0.i(L-ct^*^.d-—C0-U^A.^Ia^ _t_^S-_£: _-_!«. ^__n-e___t^ - reSJdAeU_irx_Th^.. c**_s *_b&/ ^- _.i_e \rer4*cf d-** Try ,A e-ff^c A.Ar —.ncAfJ-.SjtU'-fi-Cje- 0L-f^ Co.oun $jcd..+. _ .

Hoh/jCjre.Cj.- ±k_v CO.u-Jf T of. o^pfi^J^Ls^ur-Aue^- °^t.y t^o—0-f~±Ae. jjtcu+~€_s#_t_njftj_TAj^^c_p_rfijirkJ ochdu, T*s+iAief/ on -M_,~ ±h.s^e^_r^sti^enpS ^iMU<Ji^i^jT_iSSi4.ie_,_Eu.r-Th-€-r—/irtOA--e Th.^^Co.47rJTL^oJi^C4rpyAJt/S^J^t^^.th.^. _£**>/<__-_- u/JjLi\ -th* te^j_±i^ssiojLyS-.o^: QjfJJc^tfLAL.i.e.gj^J./eijey-t-KJ—ii-ftJ^ (c.r.cj.u.-es So^-e of Th c U.ls^£^tjT}tfi.U—Tub\jt^SJ5.^^ - Pec rtiiirl,__ .-_£>* ^**_,_i^ Th* TeLiAJsKi.^ny j;_a.j^d^t0--rstAjS_e u^_/. rop^er objjs_cH0n to - CortAb'-ro^JAtntp Te$AiAt0tty' h d-e&ri'-en t .per Acr*ncunc* JThu,t - - p£ejM,-diC~e &- djtffW.jD_dec.nT*

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.