Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Boulds, Robert Keven

Boulds, Robert Keven
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided November 24, 2015

Boulds, Robert Keven

Opinion

" ' _ TH>. gh“\c. DC Te)<a: 4 ` 709:'8€7'00¥ ' l \\’\1> fd\;r~l- I\P awm`;_ .. 3 ` 1 di 4

. _____I_m 1& RDH>»~L K P\`r\u\rl‘\ &lQl-r>r \/Sh J_ ~ ()QQ€. A]L‘>»`El-Ej-(D-?l|-¢:-`-- pm 31 3.1? Ah')h~>hhm§;;,gsh_g;gi CM,»r-L 1510 APPeghl_g Mumber~f 131~15- -/313£@§¢1 £K 31 1§~;11\1\.= §§-cg

*<” \»‘£ - n \- ¢&:;§Eb( g?»\ 4 \$P` Thls document contams some 1S_Coum OFAFFEALS ?\""' ?~\\"\ pages 1hatarg of p_oor quality h HouSTON TEXAS §§ O<' %®\¢3 at the t1me of 1mag1ng. l NOV 18 205 \°9 Mhh,h.h,_,.h hh.h.h _ \\ , `AEQL(JJ llDl’\ ]'-`_\1` Wr~}<l- ('BC M(ii/\d/;W/ ' P`Q m.mh. pm /-\nr\. Av\-{~ %|1. l\q \

we :E_g._LM 5 %@_€. 97 Th; 113 ughhhhhh\\h 1311 ge 1; flme \ ‘> 4%11%4 h &ihhighmgihh R9.]/3~H31' Clh/j 1_"3 SI< ~\~}'\ib ('_1'_31.11~~1L lab li\$ue, /.\$ M[."\Y\(leMLL§ `LB "\~\'\P (l\flr`l' (\p AD€)€/h.\€.- T-_r‘<~l- Dl.(>“*La 1 HC;U"CI§ `>1'_)/1 ' Rei\ harv 1141 40 1~1‘;_€1,1_111~€_ 31\»1<>_ R P)c.~~\»131~ -“~l»hoh 1~1‘:11`2 r~P.QU\<>.S~L ,.J cm;\ m 511 131€>131-1 1;3' C\DPI|[.M inn u_.DL.L\r.l §1/)£>133 ~\-\'\1\ \-\mr§~r,\.\\\e (L.c>ux~l -\_\/193 13\\131_:.3114532 ~CQL.L_HL§:{LN;\]___________ ' >\J.E 9\131\~’1-\! 131 il \1111\|LL\C 4~)/1:0/3£\?€113@. DC~A$W , j ' _ ‘ l __.._._._`-3`3 111/j §“€1'\ 1111/meal MC~S-__ '~'-H'\ _T ' ip(.v ` C h\'e “\_k:><cn_sw é~LmPn~l bp (` r“ct'Y\Im/.._l A|)PEL¢]$ /\g'\ TC_)(Q.S: B-LL|-LLA`

lm@r)&¢>mi>nl in _Appm| t ;:10'111:/:| ':;J$`\»I`/h..€_ RE]¢.' “Lrwf .,S /.`_L;.Y\\l`ic_~l~l¢_.n u_:hrh§ ()1 h mpd <1 11\& 1313 1 bu\ on "I"y. in tim Mnf)ul\i£hal_ Qp§n, €.€. . L\hh *L-Q_l-lli_£.h(.” \ \53.(13_-3£.,£ HECEl\/ED FIHST COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS NUV 118 2015

P/@p ::r~i\/` `lif~L`mn `j\|§ 45 CH\ `.\“r`cf\l>i`diV\/_ol`\| \A}\"l'!' (.'.,`>Q MC\Y\{_|/`.\mu .‘> C.DIY\D}FM)’\"L (~JU"'H"[" 'z~e¢l 473\\ `H`\| 3

f\w¢\mr,\.| ADP|/` i/_>n ];\r\M vii L>~p Mc»mic_»mu,§ purSLo/m~l' ~Lb"_ ' ._L ` '. 4 L LLDL_‘\.._. 43 i}!’¥[,o.\j\e C`.-$[.\\| [..DS"\' C\I'\Ll ih|~’-ICI.,' ‘\||;ng ['D|"F'PC: l zr\rl@r ‘4-4'\€. T;¥hr;j~w ibp Lr\ua"/e( EE- "C"~L UQL jdocn '\~ €r\ \Jcm(`, L.\r\/]QrT v' LDCm~L I> f_r\»S_CLiL‘_ isn L4r\rl¢>r` li\lff\n$lA§C\-\Mf\¥`:vz§5`_1"(;¥['_61/'19 Chim@p[‘{\(` /l.i'\hl.;4 L§`)§r€j?§d“a£°"_‘ l ` TMD`“°L~ MLHJQL l_'.____ [§`Y\ Y`CC{_|]R'.`_\~LL ar C'u'\ l‘r\)uhr_~l-|\ir?_ r`€'.lH-`_ ~1-£> mimman S_F_i; 4 " 4 LIL,L:NA) 614»_@_~1.;44_4_4444,1 Erm-, and ‘ - r~c~;_\i-e .,.

-_-`._ d _TL\LS Ex+mmlmu(`¥ Wr`il &‘C MC* 4’* § Jr\ {\v \'er' dcr"e ll r id :-, .~ Dpci \6_1\ ~|.~'L\. percmrm cx 6 m mLLg l 6 /` l nc~`\f /JN~ 444~\~\! €*_x_r\r‘~]-ez.l \3\\ \CLL;> r`nr_\ LL_\,\\\ hal i`SSL.\€_ -4-¢\ €Y\ 0“&(41%4444~ 415 w\ cm\l r\r%ree cle\\.AL;\\\i»_ ;%EE ex \~P: \A )~@/l@\/n` _ mLMAJ>L_L¢g.: MLAMMM,M: H’\Q.WN~L 639 Mclr\rl£lmu__§ i‘_§ 6)»'\' Chr\(‘aen~!» £/:>mmnn /_.au;» reme/L‘/) (_`;»n Brm</\`ma\ L.L;)r`i4 l.\$uer_| L\_'\_| 0_ l/\E.‘.\her dowd la fthmman¢/ & /Dwer~ L;@,_ p./_ [) perp I~Qr~m 64 130 I-‘-iCLJl-ar 6]:14~ ‘Ii u_:»kicl» he\n}l\ mm ike />'L`l`)c.ials 341 ibm D ‘\ q L.l I(;}",'\: irb-b [`dr| L;:)[\m 4`,'\9 Ll>r\\"\' i_(d d||`€.("_ .L]_Df` .r\L\W\ ‘L)\j:¢?_ L`§l')£-V`Lvl~|lbh [§D Dgf\i ;\[F MM 431 … “

z I`\(\\ l F rj‘i$t°n'~/(’/j v ground [)/1@. EL._A:L¢Z__QAA££CM§ £)_L;JL_QA;L //0¢'/\~¢/17 T CQD’)D)\/ u)l` ~H'\ MCU’\(`[H mLL §

_.Zum"£g S€C‘&_b_ 5~_~]31£1»}0¢)( r'/U~lY la f'ngda&é ‘ ~CL ' ` aim lllage./l>’_£a;imm n

film /) CQ CL`L'14L11~9. 40 21;le\l }`_15‘\#\»\ 4/\(_»1\242 ml x Ar~415 <DE£°_»L` 54&413401'4`/ 24314\4 arm/4 §’14"\'; /_.r\l`d~€¥‘\i'\(:k 44\€_ 4"442>4`43154 (_"_L>Ln~£ [\ 4-\C\rw ”,`\CDL\)'\4‘/ lTl< 423 %1\11°. F‘l 4:\¥\245¥\§3_\ CJr\r_l Lun£_\u'nir>h DC 4._211,1> l.LBl'\)`(}\ mbii\c\ 1~11‘21.11`1¢~2. 2321 4:-’_\11(421'~»4~1@;~\| h2_2.11~1r\$5» :4:\12€14%1:>4:`1.4224 4412 ‘:`mm~e \n 44\11_ \'llot` Di34[`02»1~4 2\.4\ /~461~)~1.‘> £121.11/1‘4‘/ 13;4\1`24\ 112\1~21~ 4412 213142~4- C\i(_\ 2.\'\44;1~-\24`.1'\ 2404-224 `3`1.24\4 98 QDlS 432124>1\1\.11‘3 m\l 1422€\\4 P\9R4m`1n2/42 21 high nl?ine/l 441`13 2.41~:11'1 n54m42 J" nc\c\ mpr\ 1 22;1`):12\§<2 DE: Uu< 1`22 ram 1324 02124+4,41/11)$21.41.-11\1;$411¥\€1214- ‘ A_M_ZOH 13.__.44\ 44 21 /42. e_ 13 e_ l Q€€Kln§ ex mOG"/.'.'Ul’\£)l‘v l"'l°:|ll‘°., iii \l"lllju 211 I‘B::),Sg\\:kd \1‘4~);(:.(3!)’|4)/1[:`!7~1_ §Z,‘QQ»:L_ _LL£\jDa.l_,AQPM onrlm'mi § Ru 4 2 i_§ 51 aj~jl'\pd . 1¢1\_ @[3__,:_;2.@21 132.144“> 2144414_\_1\44111115? 414 11~1.&>11¢¥211‘»1§ immoj AP)‘)B/J.s 413 21141\31“2_ 14 §`3:121§24124~1¢>2» 423 2322421~ 4412 gz)U/~/ op 441)1)22.43) 4:1'2&4 231`\~4. 413 23224~2)~ ama 447/oh 4]1`..,»5~4 219211»~/ of 4/21»)~/~/_£ [QJ,»,¢y §\1\1~2 21 4'212_4 4:il’1[4l`/'1€2\ Cm24 3n241./S1'/;h Op L-[,)Ll.> CDH£QrH/h§§ “4'4\2 :Eh\l2141`24 :4:12\241`2:4-1)'12114 22121 52 lU/Q»Clcl[@?»lé) E`x/o/./;\i»/ A 1324/1124/1 1/& AlD 4:42 %~4~211)1/3 D@41?.1 UDTED/Vl DATE UD 31‘3112._141#2 10~/)231’1/14444'12_ 431 $41~12..4 /-\442\.1\)’12\/ 13223n\4 21381§421/')22 Di$`l"/C`L !/!)4>1”/72\/»

\k,\f 4'\9..1‘944 3221 Pmm\%r‘$ M211:421 Re.42.114br pru\ls 44\24~4 4411`5 4-423'111>2<:24_\42 £1’314¢~4 322112\4& -4-4\1`% 4\/\2”124/41)/121_& 413 ann/1924 4442 Di$4r124 £2;11_12~/- 4401~213 {_,UJn-»l\/ Di§~l~ Cm.:r-\L 4474_§}‘ 413 3`1\12. 4:242.4 'F-nr41r1215 2‘1424 amdu$mn 2343 4,_(;1\.&3 ll'°\ “§~4\1$ CN 1n244 42121\ mower DD (°_.._1'~21»24~'/-\/1 lV\ 4442 name 2344- _.:L'{X4l(.£'_ 413.1~4§"2_411°_ Amp_;q z RQLWJJ g 13321_/2/$ x “` 523/773 l q 13 ,1/ ~ ! _ -(_J.D.L:l.’ __ £'\c T`h€‘°'r'eyc § ..D D)PP;:?: l"z€.$£n )/ //7[.0/‘/. dirt '»lf'..f/ 177 ‘!/I£W _‘ QCCJB¥`(_lIY\LK 40 m\l 4\4>_41`¢;£ to J mp”?[ DDAiM/`na_/ :`§1,1441"2.€_ m J~IZ_

(`;4 412 mar \¢ r ur 123:23~4\1_\ Apl>llcajic>h &r€L 41`1.1€_ ;Ln(rl §2>::;2]4 ui;iMMm§_r¢é Qj£;pzfl__ 134in l.`_---_»~_ _\~ ¢~ 5 1112

4 `P. 3 csc CF_L:LJ£[ 1311@ [\p SQF\/l[é’ :E pa e_\'“1~ /< 50111/_1( Jl.:'1/31`1719/ 1510 /’1€£€_[3\/ [.’£1-11'1[\\/ 1/)¢1~1- 01 11er 1311-1// `L"_Dr~`m:~"t)_~'y/- [,DDV [\ ~1'1’\~€. 01.\1’$~11“_ APPlic_cA-)/m 1'~1.:,_9 bean command-911 1.:_\\1 ~1111> Uni~/~e. /_ 511;1¢1~§ 17’7&_€ 1 §\15'1'1'07 /)13~\'1~61‘\€ pre~D/:n.` `1[ ~1<13~11/912, 1[1)3//1':111:11`11§ 0£1£/1~6£_»5£$‘1.

Ldurl Dp APDFQ 151 1:1'§-1~ 131 §-1~ . - 31)1 1:01111111 %T HQU<JDn,T`»E’?Wo/;J . ' ` [1:31314~! ~!.£>[) fr/m//m/ AW€¢¢L§ v 017 €_>(0__& _ _ 1319 51:>< /1;7_3’1>8';_"[)1‘.§11@/.;31&1»¢11117 . , 1 AM§»L,~N;W; A”/11»1// ;/- /5'» ;;;;' L AT `E_ KA€;¢_5_ 5511511_¢?/_511531\ 17\`1:>131°14~1 /< 1319/dds 17‘/3`117,€/ "13."1/1>-1`%/

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.