Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Carlos Bernard Smith v. State

Carlos Bernard Smith v. State
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided October 26, 2015

Carlos Bernard Smith v. State

Opinion

FILCD r- 4- -1 IN THE COUHT OF AFaT^';.

AT SAN ANTQMO.liT*-.'-: S'- I ^ I 2BJ OCT 26 PH ^ I V 5 J 2 s |-^ 5V ttkElT4E. HSTTlt.CL^M •5: aI U|4i <0 §,<11 ^ I- '•ij i CS <3r <s: 21 \? ^ 4 ^ I 'i 3: K 'jj 'Ai ?- 3; c ^ 1^4?-'; -r^ TIs i i h <sc S § Ui •X "3 \- f 1 I $ -% 1 I I <s? r( QC ti •i: ^ s lu o ^Ui 3I si I; o ^ A O £ f- 3: a i i«jn LQT)vcn <0 I ^ •? i4^ W. tu -S "S 1 i ' H "s «<g a •« or i 1 « j-> V -T' 5-.^ Q 1— to S B , »> ?J| tI % if P Ul •J hj ^ 11^ h; I%l3^- % u.

Q o i. § iji ti" ^ -A- s •4 5i 1"5?- fi I T§, ^ Csi 1 4 P " ^ I c^ Ua CG lu <1.

Q- :i: W j- % liUi-s ^ ^ 57 2 ^ I. K -t K ^-C 3 «t: it-5 S?

Ui 1 r~ S i 5 Iii I'i. 1-^^ 5mv ' rUfiT ^ p'""'- ' "•I- rt«( -R. iocA^ ''TLLf!!2^ f^lS-ffiJCT (UMm< Se^uzA^ •j'tt^e^ i/)/)r C/l'&jt^-pi ^4 /^^l / ^iiAtfT /^ViLi'y'7^ ^4, -/2j>L/^'/'y UJtUff'^ c^nyj^l i^n, j ujfu4^ fy'f-foM/^i^ fom-o^ u^'fo(i zrV& uj/i]it<^ <i^ 6»oIi^ f)pfisl/4Hj7^ 9 /}s oJ- •H'.S iPUif 44yJ ^flottlP^ C^KAiU^<^ ^IL C^^jSoli^ UJff^ />1£.# S<L»?1 HoVce Cou^j dF fiPP00l^FTTomt^f T: f^VoMS of^ sy>hy^zil uf/f-L V^cjf/W ^-P i^Mis <UpiFij^r>o^ Us pii^o4U4 ud Uitf*fU ujjA/ ky pjm'^iJU Ryi/i^^i^-hi-iof/. 7^ ou4com<. {x,ln^ -/^/^t/fUf^ uxx^/d IrU^/P ijzju> IP iS"^ cIoioPa^FzkL ^ijd- OcfhsuF^ ujjH" fipPiS/UtsI p>iuA^All\i CAVApl&'iU F<>t ^heca,^^ A/po\ffp<l A-hfafi^i Tt OJ^ 6A*t»'lA4f pA^udoU^ ^•icu, I.OS! Ca)j )A<od+6 iiut. c/e«//e e>fi 44M- f^fpOl^U A^sntu^ f^Atfzp oOjifyje^iM ll,0,QlS'- ~7^t-»^ h^s ^ /3^ A*y lMl>sl fiL pSfo PhfUi Co^Uci- coM So {', Qii^ u^Mj /m ^ psyak ^it> FdJoc^ f^UAuA^^i p/un*i htS Clk^^ did Af>/^\j id pud- IaJ iM W\t'^'l^ fiA, fdtUJ p/iOCMi\A^ Is lou /) yv^kiij^ CcffSMi I 2) Ooudrvijt AU /4CC«J^ cUle^-hs lOtips 2) lou OuM^'ni^ A-0 Ad&iuAd<i^ OuaSoHa^^^ piu} --ffijiSl PtOOa^f^ ^o^lchidf e^oow^h -p ^ f^zf>A^ pMc \ SA^J ujAy. loy Pollcn^'ii^3 ^ p/loViAloMS j pu/iSo^ P piUickj A&>oH(Sm ' Afui l,OS'l&) Cif~H>*' 1^' Oxi^ oS- PteOcUi't*. fifptlkfA fll/kUj -pm (jj'Ak (l^ud <>fi fif/^xls,-tnM^ OAcni %+a<fe-Yu- ie«W," /W ^ ^^ Pfi^jS^v^ 1*^ iJixd •

a/ ^ S,t^. 3J f1^j y^//f;2- jpifiAOfl -fo/l -Pi I}m3 ^ rfh/L (OiiO "T^iUf A C/l/i'/Otl of 4 piioOisiAf]^ Im iulr'tc^l^ dz^((MU^ /^SS/<ff^'^ &fCouio^' •/y<2^% onj /J r^oilo4 -fail fJ<iMJ iili^t IS fPut -fo ppssud io ifi^MCoufd Ouuh-y fm4^ fh^ A»y /r nkup r^^'j ii) r^ki 4 p2c^ ^ rmH''t<s/^/i^-f^ 4Muj- fAOj^'lC^ -fiif/L f\Mxu /)€iU8'>A^ a5 0^!^ i4\^ picf^i't'^ iz> dtii/^o0t 4 P^cctd -fo ed^^4sifi^dli> ^iJ fiS^iSfi'yUC'i, of dout^^d f^jd- jU M^^itmf piu>uHt<m '.M MicU:S /, D^iC4 h^ deofiW;^ <5-f^My^/ /e;jto H> pu/ipi>^ ^ U^-.rt-hs of /UwJ pilco<fdlhi^ /k)^;W ^fi^iu fy^Ks T^/e 4 Soksft-Mr't^ii 6f

"^Tij/ 4^ ^ f/UjkScvU^ ^y ^ c^jshi^ kiVfi pfitfieai/iS'thz, ^ppeiifd^ R.zvImJ^ "Me O-f A tc//'// >/^/e iyMuAlllj UY^^ IqZ^ -/t) pflS^^jH ^hJ Pr/P*^l i/f A ^udf^lai^ -fisfi C^A) ^/Vc^dAf/W -j^ MtAi'f'S l^Atuf^AS p{l<i}^ /\/eoiSSfikspoi-Iuy(ofi^'ss" ijL/ suA 3^<sf^ 0-f f^j^/fif' -fo CoiM^^l '-^ 5c) -^o^^A-fntvfh! "fo A j "4^ dctLfSirhdioiJ CA^40~f it)Al-^ /V uMcf) CooAfS^^ diux^h ^yPe/e^ ) p^tSf fy-fpiH decWfojj Of> 7^ /yju'ifs, OiO 4^ ApP^f Ak>ip)M^i fbtp^eviiiyf^oif M' -hl'lA\ pkPi^)»^p Cfis^SfHo^tdt^Mtij /f Pa^ ivho^ CoofijiM ^ "fo piu>i/iM PppusLSz^fA^-'iOfJ ^<5 /fi pc^iiiofi -fhA-U Hi^ iu(^A Aa<S (2'dtM^s<i,{ /irf /^//, — •/v/cj/' 4^ t4 -fhmdhfisi is Kkrf- /OjjuJ<CAW Im fiiXceA OJ/H fifboCtSS q^ jAU?

PppillAi^ /Uot^'Aa^ €//yec/i^« /hSS/ff/^AJC^ ^ PHomij- ^ Co^ii^icfAfJ 3/ -(fitUvR^^ 'h dcmfilif l)mJ<l!i4otiip^MOAfS of a^c Qad^ &P^ Ci^M]f//^l PfltcUf/nib 4^/o- M' tAj(7ofd (UH pci/i iJffkcftfir c^u^icjj ^ f-^mn dft. PPxjudk'i-, StmJfid V, SihH'f 933 flfpdififji: OM>ld fkff^ /^yte 'fjoh fUCCfwf U>ki^ yfA) (Alf^CPod -fk^ CooKt^lj 7^ <2^pfiilSS p\A73dp /#<J iA**^Ovi-</b ^uuduld A£>pZy\t^ SiK^Ci mU/ y^ WWp^mU^ Jj <hMkf Ui//W k^Al S^aP ^ ^^fixUd f)plkffiJlvi3tkj,\jl>]H>, Qcfc^i^-Jopt^dd /^55erf^^ 'd- (4^ Cm4 - (]plttiiA/^ hpP*^/ Jy© F. CoZ CH^cJa ) \/)/HGf<BFORIz^ PRFk^\SB3 CpMSibmFb^ /}Pfi0/pfot Huu C^(cr graut^ ;^\mM^ Meno^-w Coo/ir m i^musiotmi-ou, 'TVtl "idl^ Pt^SchiS p^ohosl^ Sid ook <A/ id} }J n^C^TloM- f^esp'^-^ullj c^ktn/ffcd ^yX .)4,x PiPPe-LLmy

4/ CMjms G>eRMfyRt> T//i^ dam of /iffieuLs flPPeuMT § I § FMTU Su/mrMW SoOiilAl hlSt^lcToFl^m § TBF ST/)itr OF Tms § AT swmoFfii&byAHCic'-ry Tims

ORbER On +(.t ^ciAyof C^Mb-oM TO fiiT tr\olioF To Mr For Red,ns0^Tic^ in •/•*«• FUxVi, Sidled Aiod njuv^tfiul (2«(je, F\a^ 'fhtCdutJ /Wii^ -Me SMir fs oFfh^ dfinioniM fyR>i'/c/S Shoold iM All lol t (hRRR Tt-/) bllRli^b

=)t/06ir P/iFSlttlMd iJtJ^LOoM he-CL/^RA !ion 3^; 7? )(jt> M'^ T^^Xl" /«' -/iv ^ CcM^i o>^

6P SSRl/ICl^ J!J* h't'tMij C<^ify Q^N of iic^ -7& COofCT l=OR l\tPCon:>Si OenATtcif/ O^-J flA^itg B- 'aj (j- s- VIA/1 o/L> f(,}s ii<. 6f octoBen.^ -xois f^iuss/rj. -Jo- cm Ct>orr DF/^PPmis -/t^t\/es STusTIc^' 3^^ l^hni>sA ST' -3jlh? /to %xoS'-"3^^!

(Ciidfo FILSD COUin OF ANTONIO. T-Lt.;F ^0CT26 PH2!ZI; •^.HOTTlE.C.'^St^l ir-.

a

-o I %-t ?-) c\ c ' S <<:

^ t ^\k =<1

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.