Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Robles, Orlando

Robles, Orlando
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided December 4, 2015

Robles, Orlando

Opinion

IZ 1(^(5 oRiBiNAl Ccluj3^J1^J3 - 14 - OQ^QJ5L-Cjg.

JXJQ—jA^, ^pi*/^ Oj=P /4:p^Le^t-l Sr \>r£ TnO, ^ r^ PP€ j ( a^\-\~ Rvl Cun.Jo do bl^5 RECEIVED5N COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS P-fte -1 ' CmQJ£ , DEC 04 201!

AZ*

A ppp. 11 e^. jQ^ A^3_£^qJ -£Vo^"> •TV^ Aft** b^4r^,f ^Dur^o^ Hi^r^ £r^n^JT>,

Q^gc-UA-^la-u. rr> pr\j ns±-h r^a_u ^ s feg/ • Of> (T^p-Hoo -vMgg/ -fe^ ke h^q^t'n^ FILED IN COURT Uh CRIMINAL APPEALS L^ U4 /iU.j

Abel Acosta, Clerk C a ^ eft

(S\XtUCpur-y o£Appeals•, Te^ay\<ano. DdcemWr _Al7J^DJi2^ _ . -. ,

JfcAjcL\±eJskJ^^ Fir** Gour* hf Appe-a\^ , \3lJo\\ 2Q\3 _AjfL^^olOJX - - m^-Va orrery v. S+a"Vf>v 5? 10 S.VJ, 3-d ^731, (Tex. Ocon n/. SWfe, 3lflM JW. ^>A 330, 8fi4(-fex. CrirrV. .Ap^^amnB^) - 9icxr\\e.\\cKX\ v. S-VflVe,/33*V-5.W. 3l dL \55 (Tex. Crim.

JSiadD&_s*A^^^ A^n. ^QOO) U)ooa v,SWrg., 13S.W. 3dLUMa>50(TexXrirri.._ _Ay^. aooo) : •^-Vg-fr'g.merrV- o-f the, case.

Tp~TV\e \-ior\ov^o.pVe. CourV r>£ Appeals Hou; comg.g, ; Or\a\r\do RoV>\es, appellant, a^d ChnolcV\pA. TVvs appeal 5Te.m,s -fro^a- 'c-emuicrVto»^

-Vo -hAye^,Vy (pto) years Lnx„arLC_e_rg-V\on inL^bke_

u^lcK -\rV\e. <>"byte iniend ^.d_^k>^pj^Q„djjL^e.„,^31ie x^p_i_es„jij&_jiLtaeJ^^

_cou]i i^^i^^fe -fr> 4-K^ jix^y, ~hKa+ ^Here u>ere. aWvUiy *c> rV.^W \o ex WeVjSxVp. rn'\\e.A y {Y\t>c0 '' Sg./-^^ -V-V\g-V lASed *r> So Kc\-V Vlle^a 1 ^njr, Sqlp^ p,\;ps^ <;q^, mlrto^ 1egi-H n^g-h9- -HrWy^gS-, (_RR,, Job

C-a-r. TV\^ S\~cc\re- ag^e^ a/\ri 4-Ke Cot>r4~ OyrAer^A

de-^gA5g. Sough-)- -fb Umr|- -hn^ 54a 4y '<; t^>i4neSSe,S _^fa3_Jbg-5^L^-'D-n-W—a bfeu^rbk^^JULc^Jjgg> *A 4fa_eLcx^_£re^i4- ^^£e \ <=>5^£ C-OYY\e. u^> i a^A 4-k^ CotirTafir^^ On^j f>rA(>r&sj' •fiA., 5(^r.(n euid/t^rg "fro be ^a f/> 4 ^ nu^i c/e ^"f 4 kg, _^-^5;_^4J : : : The_54_a4e -f^&_sJbgd:ed 4l/\Q4- ^e_d.giW5^ ka^L^t >as4 re, \a.-Vi'eA<5^> ^p L.3 1-V-K •••V-Vg. L?Cr-4!o^> 4^ ^qq. ^a.<£> u^'v-VW wi^le ^4\r^ Kgr u^V>p<^ S Ue l^s_S ID l»plcu^. ol,4.

JChL^_§4=C(ie—5_ocA-Q-K^-ie> lj_m;4^bj^—UX^o-dFj^cil-a^—a^_ /

1-6)4 We S4a4p. anrl De.-P^nse &q ree<^ 4o a Ilout •DNA 4p,.s4lmnny in Oi44)no4- e?4a lol^K; Kg 4ioe chain ^ C(a54q4/ du^ 4o sr.lrvf ju-li:^. cor\.-p\rc+-s or> 4nei par4 o-P 4-h^ i,)i4iA^^-s-. Th^ 4e4^^g^- s4g4e^4 -pAe/r- _• jQjeAjLgJL4aQ.qJb- 4rWe_-gAzLdjgjQ_c£^_Lu2du )d O V.U25^ j<ii/u2£ nd 4ih_o4-iJ^—uig(s ma4e^u£-L4o 4~hft,Vcqg& aS ujg,/^• QSJ^ Wolj, p^. \[prJOr\. 1-llj ~Th-e, s4__-fe -th^m irp^^yfeJ6.

J uiry <;Ku-£4l<f , a^gf" u>>fl5 g jrar\-he.<{ 4-he ^amg,., l/o( > r

Dire, ops foiAciu o4ecf ^ j~t~h ou4 i^ci'd efa-4: __j A_f4e_^ -hhe. Ca$6 u_>gL£. prinir 4o 4/lg \u.ry bp.lAq Wqia/j h4 fVv, +h^ J&-pp,ns^ loTTou^k'h Con^rvn 4o -rln.p. j url q^; v^e^g a^4c ia^ e.ui,4ip*n<f^ £>4 rt\e.d\C.g{ ' -hrggt4m<pn'4- 4or -t-K^ all pq e.tf \jir~M hr\} &r^c{ __ Otr\bv^ £e<n t;>r4--fo,n 5 of 4^. -D^-fi^ d ^^4 -tha-(- loere^ _no4,_prou-A(| a.<>_pe>- 4A^ Q*OX-£?^) re.que^j- -PiIt-of ' lAcLif-^jzJrjirs^e^ Cou^5eJi^_(fi R, uol.3^ fig", ^-?; /q. ^/-^S^ ^J^AS-)—l^3) The. d-e-fe^s<?. cx-^-C[r^e4 4h^4 K__g_ u>ou4e| Jj^jd_a^^j2W^^c4-Loi^3 4-Q_e,aJ:ia # s 4k^ uj£^j_g££ej^^ - ^-d_U,^LLY^-^ 4"ili-A I, -- : = - — 5^yv^cc^4-W Pliant ?-.- ry\5, A U^;?. 4<^f/4^><4" 4-^4 ^b^__u2gj:__3_^^_e^Qr^-^bJ-d->—^2/^d W^dLc£_sx<4^ ' ^ ^o^pux , d'KA<;4rW <*/\4vV>.. li-fo.. S\f\P^S^iCleJ±h^±^cin " 4rhf. ^) r:y JO qugS-4/0^; a4 rOug K4^_44_d4^4ql^lJ<;^^ \>tn 4^'morir\'ifiA; 5 he 1e4-4 hnm^, 4o pu.4_QCk.S-!!. ar\A <:oQa 4-hftrg q-£4^; S^g. d roue 4o do U 'Par k , ((?*?y xfJ^\^-t^p^-25}^JAt-3i o- <^4) ^A 44-? ^ ^ •s hor4 4i m<_. s Ae le-£-4- 4-4\P. park ar\g( head p.^ Inack doijo Lout'sk^a. _S4:t^£4i_+aL^^Z54-s h_g____home^________hi U 54pppe 4-&4 4hg_ : -_iigix4^—SJifi. rvo4j_c^"'4-he tXeA^rLa^f lo^lLIcJ^ u-jp.

YTAs. AUaJ'7. , 4-he 4• g>Pgr>rjr.^4 4r>14 U^r sA^UJ^c; __A.r:a-Q-g-!L_/^.a S_c^)^e4:kLo.a_^jSJie-4^s4i CLe-d^la^d^J^ : _pLLtJLlj---gL-£p u<p r___j-p Jug-ue sJ^fadht l^€'r-'ue^cie- #^d'4ti____,

^ tQ_a^!!__p.^ ff-^ /nvj keXj_!L^Sh^' S~^aii€.d ^harh oJ~^^^e, •_^a-a.m4; _5^e lae-a-c^—4e> -Peg I u^eQ,^y d^^JheAcj ^e^ _as__a. ij^a po^_jQQ-5_i__/A) a o <2 5a4d 4^h e b cAn 4 £/l4_ 4-h^e 4l\r^e5 asV-?<4 he^ uj>h?^c Wer Spc/Zi, ~Ure uja^j _QjQ-^L_ikk-^r_____^^ h e<r, LJL-iL^: Uo IJL^ftg 3 b ~31J l'rt_ 54'q4[v^a> (4*» '^ Igr^s mu h-ead j A_t/_s lr\:Uln* ^e: hb-, Qo<p.q 4o pull rwu £^o^4c o44 ll'Saiy JQQ H

aii^rcaiiov^, she, fi4o4^d H^a^-sKe. W; 4 pjr_^^LedJQ4^-_. u_)\4~W K^r kecjx, a^d 4^r^toA<s4ra'Vgrl 44,? 5amA io(4h 4~h^4 eincg. her •5rKn^4.< \uJers />/r\ r>u <? 4; 4~ha4 4-K<»..Dgrfivi 4<wf s4ue,U Wt.s -P^g'e^s tngid.. o4 h<*r. Sh^ s4a4?4 4-ha4^4^ ^jT£j^eArAk&<jfia\n\c. buHon oa Ver keu5 ar\d loggon 4b ^Vah him u/vVh -hkenn.^h^ 4/»<4:-fiW 4Act4 i/sh^.m 4A^ hhv-n Sounr) ^4 -£or -V-W-a 4*4*^ ~^h 4tio^^J he, g°4 ^4^ ^4 \\&r. (RR, ur>13', pg^k, ln/ff-fff S^e, -Ha^n Ao4m Aer Car (Xnri d/>oV< 4-q 44w_' S4ripg <? s4or^. l&fG~i~p4 n^ar-Jou _X-Q^--^^5^-4K*t s4reei^4crjD-y2^ 4-h^_ Be, 1- A.V slnoppj-ti^ ^^4£^^^^4^iA3i)_( ftR, i;o)3j p^ m/ln-^-LLZ) Once a4 4-/n< s4or<» ; sKe. honl<g.gf h*>^ hc^rn un-fi4 4-he -S4^r'\pe5 anp)oije€ (Lam& up 4b a-S5i54 he^Y She &~h*<A-ed £\_j4ae__C-gr kiL_c_auj e—she. uas nq4 toearir>g clo-tWej -^ro/r^ -fh^ uj>as4^ ^qu;a , 0RR , uo'L3 , pj^ , Lll-L-I%j In £&- 9*5; /-*/ 1^) .Soprv \\\P.rt Q^4^r; 4-h^. poKdg. fl.rr(\/pr] , S'K^, aASwJg,ir^j -r-h^iV a'ue,^4-iQtn.s j and Qauf. Gt_ dpscrip^/om p>4 : her _0.44^^^^ . fYYs. >A 1o/^i ^ 4^s4'-Pi>,<4 4-h^4 Kgr mo44w d rrw^ 4-*> piV-k k^r rfy>i>.ir\d ITad^. q.4- 4^^4 o\ n -V. S Kg. s4-a4^rj 4h-<g4 4-h g, p o IVeg, g>44Y<^r £.4 4h<^ sc&n^ 4ol/j[ h^r 4o caq foom*, .as\d 4a kg a Snoujt?r. Xa<;4^a^, S\r\£ i_.).e^4 korvnp. 4p smokp po4 , jfY^s, A lo-niz. iu><°,rv4 4-x) 44>g ha?pi'4^ / • 6#R Uo lJ?y - p^ t 5*4 - 5,5, In l~ £5 ) I- il) On cp: a4 £) o£4v?r 4 ^egion */ H-o^p^^A I , ¥T>s. A\on'i 7 ujcxx 4q1^q iin 4q an gyo.mi^od'icv foom iq h-grg.. 4-h4vA aQ^e. hgr cl^ eyg/on, SKe \r><4i:Z^trer|

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.