Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

FORTENBERRY, ELMO RAY Jr.

FORTENBERRY, ELMO RAY Jr.
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided October 30, 2015

FORTENBERRY, ELMO RAY Jr.

Opinion

<l4./0J-O{ , .'! • ~ - . N~'O \~ £-~(~ - .·.._ . ~~c;~.~~~\).~ ~~~ . - • IN B.~ co~' r:i c~ () t\\\'l Tt. e-. O&frc:L_C7=--F_ _ __ X/l..J _ £.L~_a_For-te-~Vb~rC!j ~\.,\ 'b ·· cva(.~-~cl.m_,t~Lc&L. ¥~~·-_-·_..,'-'------- . L) l .. os\'d-· - ©fE~~.r=.:~~J~n n~n r_e"tLT_r_atve.L_ ~e\ ~c · /} 175 ·L~lk~~tr;e!1JI Uu\·.J ---- ~ -. · . ·. .. - (CQUlf\T.Of CA~MiNAft~-"""~~"":.s..---~- -----,---------,----------L....---'----G€-T-l: -. -~-,----·~/'7_-~(!)-:t~dt<-/ -fi£ L e;gv~ 'r.t!LBL~ -· --:;.\--:-----:--:--'------ _ _ _ _ _- --~/t &F /devJ.~~. Ailll®~~(C~~~f, "~®r~.

X~- TIt e.__~V-A-0~0~ ":.__~/:_11LI!I. L. Ju r ,Ls_d_,_l_c~L/ ~ ·fA./· C9 ·r-=_ L_h_,_e_~_ ---.,---~--Ct2.v..LL "F CrliVlt(.IVLI{ /1-Pfl~S__c_____ _ _.,----_ __ '.

_E_«-(2AI r e.r)h eflf!-/JJli .5 L( cf_____5_ ~2-d~LI ~tt 'It c, (C.~g~_/1 l 'l? 2)----c---.-_ .-rcq_eL!le.f:_l2e&1_t!.d_i±T f1.J__-r/rc. r n~d._L~~/4-L. Leu_e........__<c=---c- /FKfl/1-iT J;4~9PJI./ ~82 5t-V2d_ _ .!)·~_!J_}_~ 1~23.7A-?_£o)~ • C &vrL£e..E..~5_ed r..o· C.~av..ildcr t!J-/ ~-l.LL_g__&d.)~£-eCl2~'t,'o'L./

-/1_0_L tvfrrl/t · T<:J j i~, 4' /.U /}ttJ r o_E__ -m tif-l...&w ¥- e / /l.M!v-ddiJLJ~f--r_ (!}

_fh.e_ /1Pr-c/ w/At-) ~;vd .tk"e.ve/ tild'tiru:..--:-t±O~tLY lltJa/ ~ F/Le _f1t¥:--ELOJ!2/J.~ {Yr Lh!J-1 ..L ret!rk_~_/_.J{!td lbc.t t,A.T-r;p 11-/J_fJiFt-t- IJ_~i;,4vf2L / ~, .

-tAce_Ct2 v" i7 ;vet/c/ S/-1-Jd I r . !LA-d ·JVo 8~(;~-t 7 l;P &/)fl-U~L---_ _'U_e__C_~JIL/LJ!_c 0 (£ /V. & A--{df-_&_t) ({ l~ h. T to _~R/2 .L ~ -r__JL_~--•~ _pCLrvtl)b_fLYl.~i2{~ s~·e_ /l_e_fJL/X~~; JoEi_f!/}6-e_--:-8_ J_,'IVL_ /f2-· _ _T_ I ffl g(-J T Td 0 "-<(-'flf)~<.L.ThYit~ /If e n cc/ ?(;I, TY 'fk!"' }e ~£io' -'=¥- . -~-~---11 ~~rd. wh .ft,~ 1 Ltflt i£ttr~ tit. tJ 5 e 'f-tL~m ld-f_J_·I!l_~ ~) _ , _&_ ? l.. 2.. L -25-o/- ,_f~;-i~r- c/!J~Y-1!. vI" £. Ly_ft::z ra. 1 CD lll7f e£L. r.t-vv~-- __e ~~~ erv_e -L1~ ,<~ ce-'f/loLti To lj.~~ f2r t H c..J~!_ YJtt_,~A .:_ /i ~ <!-m .id;- -~-'--ILt-.!¥4._tL/)_L_Lft.A:LtJ _( /l,.:_~_6L--::l_- -t;:;_ VJ. of -f! ~re_ fo/ ~& / r 5-.e-[~ - ~t2_trv 5~'o,L~ / ~' '1/ #J-· ~~ e .£}_!_vt-~_f!_c/ /l.r.J~~-~0 · t_e?PJ I '•'

• The- dvty_._p; f='#fLy~tJd!LI5L T£-LC:Ue-~Y ~~"-""----,----- ·_£fpp·~~m_lf1Te ;---; . _·-~---'--------------'----------_----;-____ . ·.~ ll/()~:_&"m fllb-c- LIQE" ~e_/l_, /{Jec, h:>Fl Lflve- . ~~;-2-?-~111 ((_LAw~/!_./ lLLe veL__~_ Cd___12:1--_c A n--f!-: z=::~ Le'f-- - !JP,-vL~ t-tZ-/ _ ZJ_c . Ct!L~,-T &'12 II_e_ULB_:i NPL_L-6-~,-~-- ~-L:- t/(c..r_ ~ et9-__T_A._ c_/_,. li-e. C-t:7v-£d fl/0 {t~ {_4/6-dl1_t_Ca~1 :3D ~v~h ~r?CJ /' Ere-~ /YLore. T~J:v//V:€'14/tL ~~~ /+-e....A-1' c~ flL_t'Cj _id.L.LJ-t C, fF lle..crl'-e~---------~ ~~r·; .;4-c.0_~PL-- tv- [_1-bt!~. e~t-C/9--ed t4 Fc:Jj/l,cL'-c-.-~~~~ ~~r~L~t-~~P~/~lLt~L-=.-~---~----~--­ • . 5'e @_ ,· /l(t-5'5 /J/1.," re -c.{ { 5 7~C/'rc (q 7~)_ . c.2. r& t> 1_~ t!J 7 .P ~ -L---==·6."=-t:~L..-~~ ~ . ' :'

_TI). Tt.~--illL~&£Allt. t_:f/L5~rl+j 41 F' fA--.':d_C_a_v/' l rA.,cz__ ___,___~~- ' - . _Pe])~~~~~L-~6~~-LL.~_C~uct_&ec~v~_-·~~---- . ,.t:f-l~V:C!._ L~e.f±v· e_ /feltvf",'T & F Reve 'e u-- 1!>-JA---fltl.~ {/ ~o£/_c~_ct-'- - {nl c.-, ~ C ,/ ((2/' •.. - . '. . . ' .

~ . /

- 1eF3 - • fj_&u ~:u_ Nt?T:u_~[5o Tll_.e t...-ovtL(gr fhe JUL1-L 51+/S tv_rv e/1-tf-7{0 1 L./iv-e,2_ -c_ ~~~d_,'-~{-T-"'lU-CftJ-~-Rr-Lc___ _ ~~·-c.L) (V-1.~ -fl{:L_L;zr_'""C-A. e. t:_ec&_~~e ."-"'~ILL_, ton./ t'-::_F ~r.JJ...:.e.."--.· _ __ __ck(i:rr 2 eT & L"U / e-y~7-,-£Lt= rj_c_ e lb i' Lh-.'- e__q_f±/d' TtJ f> vtz-15JJ ,_~t1.._,f£ 1U C( . . , )) . . , - . , _r_l,. e ~ 214 l 5 ::C "11-I'X. U/ ,((L::_~tl-IZ2-. F()_{Lo. c...v £.1t 4-T ;::_e__c_t3J_m.""J'l. eA..oalJL.uif!J u_ '

. lvorK:-~_&(ld~r_ NtJ /1/tq_h'T bl! lf/¥-'_l!-.4£ Lt!)_IIJ...-_/L·Ier,·&~-~---- ~e~ k.Lj_~.t:J'iee-vTaf ' 1 J11r 11'Lc_C_JJftTh v~f_fl~\~tlll-e_L6~1_ct_ __71.c e2.iEe/ w-e e~><Te~eJ H£~~ rv-,_f~et.Te5 1~/2 evA-7- - - _)_e_rL_e/V -c(-.e..-A""'-~~-cJ_,_-?nLtit!Lf>-~~rr:.z. CLLe_~t ~-ls_/;~'2 ra It- cc:- ·~p7 ' r__~ J+-711 5 T" "c_{ /11-0 . U/ /le"'l/ e 6_!_LC:/ q,_f.tlJ~ra'----,--­ ~/2/2-.t. &~ · Lo 1/i/v>c-tc·<C~_/JddJ/ /2 'd Jr $eA.~& 11 WAJ/U ~-C_&Jyl c!J L - fJd r.v/5A /)'\. c ~ -r E0__'d_e~c c:!__d!. ~l#-"·-~'_ __ •• /YiJUL. 3e e.:- u/A~/ e frl..·f:-. ,4-~.r/V'e~- · t!l.fJ!+~VdJ)/Vd_~t?L~e~------,- t+;vd_ Itt nc 5/lM.C £/in_C Le-T T~e. ~vrt.Z~--___._(V?J---=---~­ _fj_e.UL_t?vt-d 11/t?{ l3e__lilL/~r-ffie_ B:J-1...-.~_n)~ f1{3ot.Z- _/±flv II fl!2ett~ 4 &r ~ .1?/rti. rs c: 1-/t>t.V ·rC) h/!&1}& ~__-_ __ tP ,,·~~f!!~e, L-f-J {.,'A- -e :J. / 1_;2:;2._ 06vt't:Jv5L'1-;-L-e. c /( w/4/f/C' ilz_·___ ·~ £J - . j ( t( I~ T ·ro l1f1,121Lt!I:Lr TOld· ;'L.-ol_ flteA- eJ J'L- C.c> A--t/!c T~ ~~- . . . ' ·_5_o · ~fk.d_&O L_ L-o tJ 5 · T_h, I.J-'T /l ~ ~ T ·(1 r T__h· c . q--U d ('{. u~_ '

tJu () c/ /. d__ . t1-/1 v/L5_ll1i12 pt_ ,' T It~eJ. r- WtJ v c,j 1/J?t/~ , j, 'tt tV ~LA w/9-t/d IP_ F fll_qli d U/£ :cit_ T./JiJ ll.ClC._ ~L~m.pk:rv 1/~ i~·<t~ ':fJ_et~ 2-J:. tt!JD_'f_(ir~t ct)\r L'(lt2_ _ _ _ _ _~_ • ·.. If rr.D~JL-l.f-PA I~ teLrP c_eLL 7 A..c .ii~d.-~'1- @ ? CLct-~~'t::(LilR/2~- w(J~d v. 51A-l"c._. 7'1~ 5~.vJ.:dc 7/?¥_/i:__-e.~ e,.r#V\_ t~+f//.ht'f ~zj. vl\.ttuf"£ · '· ·. . . ' - ' . .

_f'b ~}7Te:-d__r_o W.t''tlt_dLJAt.t.:t_~Th:-c. Tirtl'~ a-rt-~,-~-"-h.AS' "c~"=-.L...=c__-~-- L.' tJ F '3 "G 7h e.. /f~/1-t!JYA-/;le C~:e F Ju 5 ·T~ 'c e ft-1'\..;)._ ifU )7/ c e S &F TA..e. c~v/'l ~F Cl'lM.INAC !t/JfJeA£5 () E T~,

J"..e_e f?vLe 'f 'f, J.. '6 l-< E // o_;f'_ ; 11\..-_c, {~ CA-~-e-'5 _ @) {b) f? e.(/ e 7, ,1(

((_) __ _ Tl..e-,v_ C", Co P, 17-rT, · lf.'t 1 f.7 4ppe.u -ro ~dJv/'_t Ht:?u-_ ~tP~_o/fii!_J_ _ __ (3/J.-S ~2 CPA-L-.L( 6' /L/ _6/'_r_c;_!( _fl_~f'[eG Ted_ ,'- ~ ~e C-_t!J._/:·_d_5 • Gme5 /Vc>IA./ !3Lrvto Fdr TCFV"b'.e,-r-.(. P<---r,c;,'o~e/ Se.ek_,'~ Re..Jt'ea,/-- tP F TA.. ~ /( e e-LJrol:S /-t.~Tt'tJ ~5 A--tA-d _d ec~IS-~~~ K-- L> ·F rr,/cl~c/ c" ,-.a--Ty l}/J-J-ild CtPI/f'Tl u"'J.u £-"~/.f .. l).•u<.J~O.. /?,,"qlt' l_cJ /tp{J'f!f/11.,. IJ'f--~~ £;< Plflre ll-x t.L ·r~ /7_ ~·7 P/oi) r TltJt-1 /rVl i Lfl-w't i!!- c- tv.ev e/ TtJ Ld m.. ~ /+1'\--t'f' T_ltr'4 -. (+-13 ;~vT f(J~l. T~ _'[P "TPPt.-.rt-L lie. Ut/71' jV()~ovr-L /l1_t: li?lL;/_7:Jt.fz<!-G~v---;-- th e C.Pvc t_J __ Ti,_e _/{:~7-flc.t/_1 . o f c ·JVeve/ ~flJ:' ol I t/Ad VGtJ q t r; '{;P/l-f7f}~A--L 5e--ec£1/(cp 1 RecL JpF) 1/llt:-~'t L. A-e_ 1~-2--:J Th.c-.L- /1-CL.

76e Ctt>v/T f4-·y ~ c._~;Jr- JTPP~47 ,' 7 Tt...c SteJ-T~~ I ~f _f-t>_e _PI1tf-c J _ p, (P~rfl/P /j /'; ~ Le'vv-e. 11 2. 1 ft~ L., 2. -~ , ·8ktc Tt:> R '11 L/Vve 1~ 1 17 /VtPtV . 56!.-e P. ~q'l L~2-l? n.,.tP7iz.(;~ ~/Jpv-/f)ILyl(~'-e4·TO Wk-Fl- u~vt'~l~ fJ_'t ®~< .. __ ll-c r,'£? /L; tP P FrA-vel Dcf Ill t( LA-t-V {I eI II e dJ J d A/~ T u_e:; e t=.t><4 i If,;r -=if 5ee, ttc.p,l?c..c,. lpFJ PRo:..e:- 5tJ1 St 1 5Z ) f, s-o L, t5 2]-:Lr, 7h~

. P. St,t.., 11 ~ 1 N6)u..- Jw?/JV'f t4~rt:I-1h--~ C:>v/r_ J_,. { 2. 1 /J ·Tf71!."'- 5'ePL/"' 21~2~ -5 e> E' P, 51.. I ( _, (, ll/&:J I:E.P<- It I'(J n-; =#=- -~ I1f, c Fee. Tt'vC' Ct!:>v/L;C.e L !vo 7:-tLd ejJ~ ,,__ d._ e-u.7=-.J:-:JbV·e.5-Ti' flPT,uaq(_; - ~l<.t:!.flt l?ec, I" F 3 P&e(3tJ L t'A- e. [ q -::Lr H.e._t/4.7- /L ivi-/ 11e e.;;.~ [C/ -- _c_~t_?_5t2~_/:LF TAc :if)6~e..l CP/ Atl-C_ "ftt>u c..~-r tA-t/efft-·1'.~--tu_/_T_tJ/_CI..'/-. ..>ee/~--

i. - --~-------·---~·-· ... ---------· - ~u fAe.._/:Jeft:!/y f<etJtJl~·~IZ ;~e/Jollll I L/~tlf}_IU> ~i i.f 5 ( ~d: . _ \\ Mvz/:ba~t\.1~~ n..u~kd ~~--{ ~OW\ec:. 'N 'l\t-J ~~rce~~ 1\J~ A-N d ~ 11_ h+~~~~ ~--~-~f\..-1(~ +R.lfl ~£, _-+o pu<&h. bepu~"l CbctAAe. 4.... { ~ e .. \~-e{Ju'L\ f<-e.ro·fLf '- 3~ ~to p~t <:,. I qJ P144e. ~ 1 ll ' 11-/ ~) ·, . . .· -su ~·-\, Aloo,l-e_ be.pv.~'-( C1oW1e ~ ~e. Y-l-+. Mr2 if::ett1efd~VL~ 1rJot f;;(L{e~~tUe1' t'LV-S~\\\Jt_~ee\,l4:y· GoiM~"Z. ....~-\- o-t:' M~~~~ ·*Ynl'_'rJt 4-,o y.>u:\, JVo4 .... pv ~Ue.i.. \ "-' .~-e. C ~-~~r{}_VJ.) k ~~~~ '-"-' penzvn.ted -fel3f,MoA1r m fi{loi}J; C.& 6\1 PIW~~{o.z "T~ aoWit?~J . ' . :. ' . . ''A; Ue '!.4~ Me. Q. ~~V<,.u.d{ '-/ou., l~owd ,J he _~-i-A-1 k -e. you.

A. t.\ediud~ "''-~~~~ ~~ trzi~ 4-o·~\":"ll\~~ \(\~ ~ ~-, .. · 6L ~\c\ ~~· M~\.<e W\U"h~e{\ f!\ • \f.vt/ (Rfl, V9l. l.'of 3 f1Jt l., 3•q.).... _· (A\~o ~ee.., gupTVA. Pz" 331 1-.r"-le 3..,.s); · .. · · ·. ·.. : ··: . · ·.· ..-, . ~ ·. ."l.L . .· . ,/, 0er.L~\t!f5)pui46 --fh e, .:fJeAz~?rty. e f M.f ~~~lt;~t):!./£6£ (l<JJf/;c4 t:;_({g-lj: ~/.~ . :'f!?XIr)( · ).:: I~ /12J ~KJie/,. ~owPveAr1 )hey !,~ I!J.fvJ 5 4fJ ~ +t~\IJIJ&J?u~/Je l.o;usf,:Py ~r::~; PPAc.;elf_ ~ ; .:; pu ~~., ~~ f h 1 -~ JA_ ~tud & ~ 1\.1 VV1: ,_~_ Pu bl1c-:\.l+crc' ~1.1:u,v1 ~?l-~~~-:·Qrof4; ··\~;:~·.p~'''~_+; · t/.+1~·~ 4he'\ \ 1eA ~~{ ,..{,. ..J,C? Jvs+d\ +heut ~-e+,ot-t ~ ~J.I·o~'j p-\~~ "-\ o*~~~ ~ h~ Q.D\\>.'-tV2..~c\ '<=-'he'::'"; (\Peo l":_LL.11~ [Q -lo'l \~c.\ ~>CUM~9 rt +I)·. ~t;>t~A~-~'·-'~' QJ g'( f\Aa., "(\~~~~-lf_\ ~--\<~,{ ...Mo~. V'-th_e_~ '(l!>U ·~.~'4-_-e ~~ . , ..., :~ · ':·y·~'"·:· 4-hea..e...1d I cl "{DU.pM.\\ Oll~. ~ct ·.!!\+:\~"~{ ~-q M ((lke C.OtJ~f · · ' , ~-· . \f\.1\{h.,M~,~Q.cfeN~ ~A.~ d~\f64o4he e~do£· -}_he. dn '"e.vdll\.ft 4v_L~Lrv~ ~ukl~.lrl-Nc\ ~4-~e.wp*.e.J ft)_ . .:_. _. '' M,tA-\-<-e. eJ;.)M+~f \f\_tt~lL hI VIA:· (Q~. Vol._l oC31 Pz. 3~ I-lk .. fi> lb). · A:."J:.{R~eJ --\? 'i_~ ~\IM 'o\j ~-~~ ~ --\l? \k-IvU~ ~C)-\.~c. . . . ~ \ct·e 9~ *"'e. fLO AJ' (~,Q, Vol\ I oS31 p~ ac, /. . J q .. r;.o)- .. \.' 'Gc:. \.f..ld~,,\c\ ~~~ \"-to~'5he.ph~'coMe. *oM·,·~& t; . _ A, 'I~ 'b\'Q../1 (fCR Vol. I of~ r'l 31~ l •. -=< l--:J ~)¢> ~€ <2. hcou...~ 1 b r\ , ~<Vt-\d )0 CC,·c. eA\.. 4.-c be;~~~ ki·e,Nd {t'f ,. l

''A ,fhe ~f.l-t\.-t1UJt\<=re. he '"-'A.~ 5p~kt"'-'1 +:c M,(. .. l:fc~~~d~'+ \At~!\..,{ .fD \l\~'s V\le•1..-- he d,J,_, ~:.t- v'-tt!\tv'4 Me 4-o ~e.Jy.rh,IM . ,,\J\."~k ~~e ~;tulll~rDtu ~ ~~~r~t\~ P? 3~ 1 ·kL ~·l··J3). .. .. _ aAy \N e-vL~ ycou o p~ -f-n\4 ~t...td ~fl. eo/ o ~ ol yo u(L ofP,~ e. . _ . .· o~ e-vv.p\cyW\eAu~· ~ pu~b·e.5e,f2.\Jlta..l~~(~up~. kl \S-1~), 'P& \-lCDu..> Co\..d cl ,he 'O_e 1 he-.\< ~eu_; :Z: d. i & No+ \A-1 ~~uf'~-~~lk +6< ~ ~ ~ ~ .\-\€.. \A.c~ ~12Lu,;l ht~W~·O"--.,Me..'·h=> *~e..~t€-lu+. oC ~s~-"t."-'\ ~ "EJcld•( o,r·e.(Lcg;rp"~d he llll'r.Jketi'up '-loMe .. · _.,. · . · .. '' ~-e.p~~'1 Q,epMe.~ v~t.rul kc..J v p4~.;:. M~!btt~e~~!~ (O,ep, Qv>{,_g,ftVors'' Ap1-~ ltO) '' .\.~"""" '2 tu4 b.~ 1 ., ., 'io " 'i'"'k ~ ~l!>t<~l ~ ~ I .. ~.,~:, :::.· I </,J~) . ' . . . .. . .. .' .'. ~ .,a( . . . ··. ' ·•· .. : .. :- ··-, ~ ~ ' '. ~... ' 1 .,. • .. • :

...

'{:t'::~t~tu~i~t~ ·~v:\V'e h~.d ~M h1 IJoA· t~t~e:1h;~:e I l'..lee.J - - M <:::, o \ 4-he. d\~·P·~++ ~A'-1 \I NeeA o4hext ut-!,4-?J fo70 . . ~ CO v ~ ~ ~etz~.? (~e.. RJ, Vbl. (of3 P1' '60 1 l k c?-f~) ~~~pA~c1_ \~ Yl~~e..)·~VA h..,..u;~ .. lhe'Jolce. 01\..l-.f~e RIL'dlo 'AIM M.Je. .. T~e V<0 1<:f.J 'flA-':::. ~~u'h( e.j·,~~~M~Z.. .. Hou.Jc.Du\d i-.\- be..dic::,~A+eL WheN ~A· 1S +~: 1 1

. ··~,

o . . d\.( dtr::..p~t~ oKl. ~h\L\i- ~h,C--\- 1 ou +~~-\ d\f.\'-i 1 fov-2..~~+· C:Aa-tL '.. . 1 ~

c~ . ~\1 Mt~4hi *~ ~v'hl Mv-Hl'\t"-le~ . . · ~ &o 0\{A"/,• ~o, you. AeAMe.vv:tbe.<. \1\.lh o b12.0r+dCtV-t8+ 4he ~!!.IS~. 0 f! of.Ctce ~ ?A. ~et!>. Q. lf-,.1 ~(0 ._

~. .A' ~.~u~~\ Cb<o~Me~/1 ( RA~. \/o I. aof3 p~. '7-~L lo~lb) G

:;i::P. . ~~I .Me~rL~~"{ ~~· ~u'Lt ~Arulh~~ . '& .. At-Jd . v-.thi ~ 1? you. R~o~d +o ~he ~e.std~~ce.? · A.Jrte-Yte. \AIM A F \4-~A.\- l.-wl-e\ ~-\1\e. tl) vt _pru~ 10u~ o --\-h~~ I pn. e \II lOU~ {lO V\1.\ '-t· Ae&pC>t--.\S.€.:1 \&titt 1 ~ ~€fl'··A\ g~VV\~~h"Ad. Ae-c;potUded. X. dm"-1'i ~.wJI \J\( hll\~- th;: 0~\~_.l~,v.J .~l\ -~~>-IA&l ~LA-\- +~.~t, ~f\\~ ~- ' . .

4~ J$tt~!~:~~f~~~!~+Q:0~;i~:~~9ce·"' "" .···.···c .. ·••..

.. I . . ~~ -~~·:' ~s 4h~ £o~) .k. 1~14)(. · , . . . ··~, ..,".

A,;; A n-1 1 +~c: pw~to((. Y--\-\\Jd d,whte- 1 A-'!. w~t A-t;1 My f-l+4-orL~e~.f 1 • ~ee. ~~e. lke ~ cg~.IA~e \1\.1\~Ne.,'b~: /.WVJ·~tQ}l~e \llc'-1-,:~! Depu~·\1 ~oWie-~J VJ~d.tob\H\11'~-4.d PeJ/l_ll)~ ()tu 4he.. ~4-IA,,...~q· A·l\Jd· d IJ 1\..lo~h, ~l ~ PI~ Ae,Jteu.J ', 1 ~~ . . .....

··• \.,'- \

. :' .. / .· ......

. . • :·1 ·- · .• ..........---=.. -~~

{e;~'-t~\·r ~ i rvl t~ Peru_"''"t Pe&.,k I uS. ~ ..wh'( d ~ J'he ~(!)* '~Wl e *eft-,~I c\, 4o how CJoMb~'·h.ve ':::t v-.1~ .'A-1-..td .4-he.. h-dp he2v:.we. f)~ 4-~~i ~\ReAJ~ ""~c\ +~e ~·\A\ R·\~2e_.d ~ · ·

'"Th€R~ M-"-f~) ~h<9w Y-ln"'-cl \\) ~v-to ~~f. c...ouu~ oue of~r.v~~ ~u*~ N1~a.-f~tue-"t,... A-Nd' 0''-' 8-t~tW '1: ~ Ms.~\~ "''\Ae"-" ,~( Ok< \'-\-1\J· ~e.. hA-d *o dow~~ ~oloi;:c..-e. ~ra. ~V?~·*eu'llu~ 4~ ~dl My.''~«>zi, M'i kiJs'~ ~ )(l)f· ' ' ~.S:;:\;1bf~,l,\H~.~. ~J<?'l-,f!\E?.C,f•~e:.·'? 1\l(p, he w l'lc;> ~C)~. X 1-1. "\:.J . · ~ eeJ: ~ ~ «:H.A R e,tu Cillu ~.A~ea. \A:I he r-...t L <4 <D l ct h' M I w '-' 1\.1-t ed Shen,Jl£ PA tl\.l. +~. \J~l.A'-\ 0;~ Me~) Ki'Je.v.J he. \AI'r;\~~ I\.Ho4 Ac.-4-.\IV( ~1\.ld~. c.o/ott of .lr+W~ .l~e 5~~--fe--~ \4 \C\~ 4.rv~ _ l 1 -,ll...>*~e4rL.AM!!:.C.tttp~srkdidi\J 1 + \1\.tV-lk.,+ Me. 'i:o l,eJp lt11M \J\.n4~ 4-he ~ ,-tuA-.\\o t0 •· · · CQ. b1 IY\e~<L*~l -+D ~u~~-( G(Ot'VIe"t-]· .. "A~ ~e.· \v:\-~'-"~u~~e. 'he.:\f\..LP~-s·c:.p~k~~14-o M€. He.. d \d tJ' ~ · \J\,.1 1!\-f'-..A 'h::> Ai\...\~V\.L ea..-- he d 1 d r...1 1 ..f. \1\.11(\.N.~ 'Me. { o h eA.~ ~i VV\ v-.l'l{k ~he; ~ ,·~~t-i"'lo LIJ o ~~ . .· .· . _. . .. "' · .· ( \/o\~ ,\ ~:~~ ~·l p.; 33 1 ~l·lt-&3). . ·. · , . . .

D~I,A··k\ aoVV\e~ ou~~tde..- +he. c.o(C0R·of·(~J ~~IIUq l~tv br'\elete 0c '~. · \·'::. · f\..IOu.J ·· ·· (, v:.\ · ( . ·~-r ..•. ,• l .. '

. '

. . \)( ' .. .

:~~-~ ~;1&1~~~t~ ~~~~:i~fi:~~!l~~~~·~ . . <

w~ Q. ~ .A colDII.. I'!. -1-h e. &+tto;.e.A !', ''l tJ I I{' ou n,.Q_ e... ' '.;.. ... . ~f.\·Q~I ~.(! NOt>.t~.IV\~It\l~~IMcd ~Vtv~, J'l.-o~ ~ 'A < . ,· ; .... c<.,~,. "''• ....

A• 1:.4- S GQ.Cwt-J, Q...Ok~r·· /4.Ad fc; 4helt€ A d,1?£~tJt %~'Q.~~~ ~\~1\.A e.olo'~ ,C,a •V-\ Mn~~~+l!\•\ue.~ ~~-.(.~ RoAcl) . b~ o~ yaua --;A. Yeo. &--p~,,utf'k~~wledqe..

A. 'leJ:> . '"The·/r<e, h\ue.". ~-~kAy~ 8o-,4~e·" Red. b~~kt celoR. ' \Nro~ld ~e 1 .~-:"" yo-un. pe~~-*·~.e 1 .r:l-~ ¢l M.1tH~d Re!St.dvu.*·- M1cl\~Cov~4'f ~V:.lJ~..(J 4\,-e, \'(_iJ e.olor<.. · \~\..l~u\d C.,DlA.l~'~( f<..oV4cl b~+ "-!eM- MA~tJJ~·ru£d( \D-e..·.A / R,.(~*o (\lo\~~o~31 p~·f-1S 1 l.~·q-;J5+1-la.vtlto 1 l ~)~ _ . ;':. ·v<L>u 3.ee M'-\ \~\1\.1\fef<. kf\;leu.J r+bou·,~ 4-he. eolror<. oC4-~e ~\Z'"'~:. ~e...'h,f2.1\Jed . i.4-. Cn:{OVV\ G~UJw~ {lD' Re..e~ct·,~~\ BQbuJu To~~) be;CACA..l-~ j(.'J+ !\U chf. \A.iVter..J ' ch-\s. \--.\4- '1..\.- i ·,-.\.- +ul'l..~~ P-ed.. · [Q~ 6\1 tv\a, HoDSV4 +c ~:epv'h GaMe~] ''Q.QkA'-/ .. "-\ow 1 4.~\!h Qor.\d -~do you 1'"\NOUJ \1\.the~·~eAt .

4-~,1'4~ ~ t::\ .pu.~l' e.; oft A P'"''lt\+e.. IQ·o.qd? A. :X4-'5> A publ~·d,r

Mf\~u*~ :~e.& et.:>vr...~-t:\) R<D~~ ~ Q. :I--1--w·~ s A e..ou.u~f fl.o~1 t~At · ~-e. \A..I~ D""-? Ao 'i'~ 1 Sit(.~C\-\-'s A CJ)ul0~"'/ &l(I'J., ( \If!>(, ' 0 f 3 l .p s ~ / ll . I I- (s) k.Jco c.t.Y Se. € \A,\ ~A~ he Lu h~ ool ( ltD Ad be~((' e • f

[ &o b.'J"Ma.:, N)t:~a.,J.ky 4-o D~u.~~o( (;owre;~J· ,, ~. ( Y?;,l 'Me, ·fV\e.:~~~t,,) Ok~·'{t 1\louJ,If,.l keL\.1 'fDU czo+ cou-i 4hev<.-?J d 'd., you pv.-t\ overc 14-1-ud V-\~·~·eMtfr~ 4-o· M~l-v? c.o10+\f\.e.4 \AJA·k. N.\(<, ~Q+et-.t~? A~ 7_ Jri.oll'e ·. .

4t) 4-~e et-.Jd ·o·r 4-he dR-\\t.euJi~l_( .. +uQ.Me:d f-HWutvtd · ·' · "tt<.l-r..Acl.A+te..Wr~i,e..J 4-~ M~C~ke C.0\'4'"h4-c~ wl{l !tJ'l.V\1.'1 . · ( ~.e \16\. I of :5 1 p. Jq 1 l.;. &>-10)~ · ...: . . ' · ~A4 RoAd/dRhfew.cly dVAde"-'td~ 11/a Ac.R~ rV-l~+ ·~'l hiOu~ ..

L Q h. ,_ ~ \0 0 S.IA -\- o J~¢p.~·!*'"(,lb;;10Me ~~ · . . , . , o .'' Q ...(Ok~'-( (\"->-d 4-·~\s•·~~·e. (:~-:\:e., J.t;,~+'~ .4.huz e. 4o +k·e.. o

P'--~b\i.c_.-- 4-\,.;l.$dilC..{/ pu\o\~~,R~AJ? A_.. ~~0~ :~ftoll ( ~1e \foL lof3 1 P(·51 1 lLJ1·.~)''?.~' ?.~ -4.o:-YLk·l,;;t '' ~v.blic..--4~\~ dire..-\- pv.IDI!c_ R<DA~. A. tJo 1 .~i,~C~

:[ ( ~~ \J<o\. 1Qr 3, P) s ;~, 1....~.1,.~ . ~· b,L MeCAA{(.4;\.t '-to· D~v-+'i Gf;l.W,Ie~J · . . . . .. ~~ \ b'l fV\R. M ~(t~h'(~o ~~v4\l ~oMeiJ} L~+ ,w.e., ~-:C?{J l~·~h~~e. x~ 4~1':> {.\.\~ R~Ad -+h~4'JOU \Neae R~p9udltVl ' ~o? A· Coa.H~.C.. A+ 4~1'\~ pl!>1 M+i.s v-,th~{!.; 'I -tui'LMed· .QIV-.l-0 '4\1\~ RIOAd~ ~.I.~ ~H"~ie. t'#J~ .soa+ or ~~{e. CQ_o4h~~ .. ~bC3.{(C...tJ{'.'tll11'-A 'h.) q~e e~U4~c.e.. to -4-h.o.~. Qot\d b\ock)v.c; . i .t:M? A '1 Ot+ o '\\ ' II . .I. II ·. ·1\.~ c.:>l Sill 1 ~~e..n.e. '=:..~.lO"t. . .; I · · 1 ' · .

( ~e·. Vol. . L~f~1 ~· l.o1, ll. I~-(rg) ·. ; . · .. ·. · ·, ', · . ~~ ftcnll'IJ dco~ . \\.lo{ l:n~ve'-4-¢ be bloekeelo;'<. ~~()-t..e.d·4o_loe pr<'•\IA+e. .. lh\; V-11+'::, 4he_ 4e-sf, WIPf\J'-/ o.C. f~ I (;) ~t ~~e.e; 0 ~~~ Cerus .~e-l-k,"'-') ~ou:~ C.O(Qf<·.b'' ;~·f~(IJo the\~~~ I. ~e.<+), La. d~~ 4-he~l ~·'~ t{ off..:,Vou~se~.+he ~lor?.. of V\d) v:td ':> 1(_ N <ON K )£ ht bi4 .i 1. \A.Ihe."-i he, 4-uQ.I\J ~ OII.J4o wuN~~· fS<DAa.t q1-.,. i, 1 ~ • • ' ' ' . • \ ' ' ,j_ : - <

'. ' . •, ...... .·: ... . ... ·./- · ., 7:. "

·, . '

..' · J ,J •'

III..J ~.·. .. ... - ... ...._ . _,..-· ..· /'· MO • " ,' o"O. ·--=·~· o ' :X IV lhc.~r~f~~!~~"e~~~t~!!t:,~;<MC~~~~yJ ,~~~~e.. 5> ·(t_o ~N~~~ R~-~ \-\etZ.e..11 \Adte& ~c1 ~e~~km~ ', I M. 'vot'-hl.ll'"-'1_4-o h1de ~'{~~'tv\ ~io'u. Ju~--\- . kee..p~~~a,-\- \ •..~ VV\\M&'1 {Ve\.:tof·?J 1 ,p.~+;L 13~ls) c,~~:~~\ ~VM~~AA b"I;,Ml:r.A~WL~/~~J . . . . I '

k: \ u!.\-~ ~tDME·-~'S --\-~'tiW\01'->-\{ \A~;· \{f! ~~~ ~.1.1~ j't . \4e's ~0'* l-..l() R~-~0\1-.\ "h~ Le. (Vol.:.tuf3, r· q~l ~ll9-1~)· ' ,~ 1\lo R ~~OIU ...\.·~ cze+ -4-h't ~ M~ \.~U 4:1'U:lubkJ tuol-it v._.·t, v:\+'!>OevG?II7,.1/ , ( ~vp1L10. k d.jl)} . . : .. · . . ®'~ k( '--\ \:;\ ·pi?..Q)~€.<'.'-~ --~ ~ ~ ~he-~?.: QC ~~ W\ 9e +-h IV1 (!) ~~ Clvvo.iuue-( ':f..tJ~ '::!. ~~; 1\.1 , l1e~v,!. *"'e-~~ ~tn._, 'f \J\i ~k\* -.\-o he\~ A ~t.J,t'te4:~ S:\JotJ., V~u. ~~..aJ. ~~\.t-t~~ M'(· pv+aat)k e~~~ce; 5 'I ~A~ •. I '":lA-~ 0,~,{2 ~~\Q.,) \6u{ h~ 1~ 'ike (!)u~ -4 hK\{' \~.'-\ kuow A f-leA!(. 4-~e.·~11'V~4· +l.~lMe.8he-n,£e \1\.1.~-";. 01\J 'T.V, ,::r_ \AJ~ rv()+2(JII\J(, M€ 4-o 'te4- he.l y.)t ~<.0-M·+~e~ • \~~e's MOr2.e \/,'Md•'e..f,i.lc, \OM~~~o~.. .

C CJo.~' ~1 b, 1 Mt~:V'L*kt] · · · · · '. / ~ . ·.··· '' flvv1a i=Drde~~~lu~fs IIJ:;ihbo~'c;, hou~~4 (v(!)t.~.J.~ p~1 g-b 1 k-:2)J~..,:. · :·' ' .''c, ··- '"" ~~ <:. ·, ~ 1\.\ o+' 1,.1 ei.(l, bof2 S. h~u.lb-Q.. 1~~s. r~ ~t\A V-l-rl ~i:cr2K\~e, !>\tleel ID·~·~ ~·~·IrA·~··~ ,,._, P~ ch:

~e-.teA hi.? ~-t-~..t~t :c.. ~1!:>\d h't'IV\ ~'* ktt\e.pte(!e. 0f l"'.tJJ~ c • • • • •• • •• • • •

cc.tt0~,\.J~·.6, Me.e~v.?A~~. j 1 1-4. {..Q.~S'~· ·t\·\l .. ' . . · . · · · ···' ·· · "' 3he_ i I er:f, 4-p 'fOt...\ I() {Svrn·r.~ 1 !{ ~~ ;~.:Jq). e .ft WI €.:& "' &h~ \ o,,~ :h iVI/\. ~he. love;i h'tvt'\ ei\J(!)~.·}1 .~(!) tv~!4.k¢:'\~&·q;:~··' ,. ·: 4c h'~yY\ l 4:1\~\ d e«~~k, d~ ~he~( \l)'~{ ~t\~Vs' tq_ d+rviof,~.~ · •· .~"'Ire..• GJ0W<·. (~oS'. P'\·~~~ L "1-t.,) . / • ~~~:~~~7~k~~l'-=~klho; liu., ~~~·,J 0tl~~ .B'v<- 4i Me& t:'"\~+ 1 o~<:.. 4~!1\t o pn-&~ oCt ~.ke_ lhhe' J.. ~'1ed 4G be.~ -e\.'-lJ vnu-l- 1 ~ ; 1\.14-cx/~4 ~ ·~·hC!-i-e lo/b ~Qh 1 k1 i D~ l\( h 14d t<\ . · ·<rcv.f\L~ <.?.:c .~e.(~·~ l.' r- J f df~ L, ,.,_,;_{.'): · '· ·· · · · . b-e.~' -l~ ~~ 'D a_.'30 IM uv{CS·· t ~ ~~V)j( 1f ; -ko·'£: (!.A{J._[JI plu~J>· ':J_·.Jw,J./4 ~hoi \7"-lU 1 r.J

0f \1'-l~l'.sl"\~~(, ~lt\e ~\,c\ ~·l\J':')--\- k~-wu)vJ t::\AtJ(!) V.--\, ·~\i\"~ d·(I)~J J ·.~ee..p U\': ;~,~.~·h M.'-t . e,f.~ 'l\~0\.(-e.. ~I ~~d tc_~!\1.3/41~./()eflo_~~. s~1/emf}N'1 f:UWJ hcySln~t 54~/ZlVP!f

. c. .,eto~~-~):b\f. M \IJ;~.ff?.r:.'J .. . · . . .. . ..... ·. ""eA>.l\ ~he 4-e.-s+,C,eJ Th~\.A'k"'t UoMt::-r.. \f\;t·lf}~·kt'4- . ... '•·~\.lju~ ~ Q.l.~..· \1 1 ~.· e.''\A.I lf.\2:1.:.. (!,1~ut~1·<Th¥:t+~.·\ \e• t-J.VW\~, .~vpl'4~ r· t5.·. \I l r%-~0 . () C 1/1 ( 0 . \ C'>iC .... · . ) ' . . tov-K ~· I' . . . ... ' '

' . ·, . . -~. . . ·. .. .. . ~ ., ·- ;•.'

. •' -~ ~- . . ·. ' ~ ' .. ~ . ., ~: .. •'' .· ·.. .,

• f ,?;,... ·•··. .. •'• :- ,, . -~-·- . ·. :: .·. :.. -~ . ,_-;_ , .. ~..·...-. ~. .. . '····'"•. . \ .

. .......,

C9· by W~+h~ C..\~'-(J ' ()\<..A\(' -1-D:z!~'JUJ'f"' ~d-~1 h~\..1 '/ 0-t·e.d 4-k.rl{ ~e. \IU a.u. {eh-L .q\\J~~{ LG)e4 'tM(vrt.c.J] 1 ..\~lt'l~ \tvV\-SU'f 4-V2.t.l<:' 1C.OMet.-t? ·. ~. :r. "'e1ea. s.vx.u +\A.€ c,rc~,c.-ex~... ;l.of-3/ P"' ~~. 1-.Js--.lo p'l1¢ 1 L1-~) . · l <s~e. \Jot, Col't p6:>~ D~{,,u~ ~V-\.lk 4-o h~ tv.o4- ~u.~.._lOe~'VIec:... ~6 she. did t-J.O~ K~tovJ e ...,.., s. ', '=:. ~~u.\e-1\J,* s*:~i.,e»V\ e!\;1.* ·\:n S--A· 'A·te/'::1 ~+toa..tJelf 14<["-' V-tN & ~.e.. 1-< "''· ew i 4 11\J 1\.\o{ o~t,~ \~·he.. u~~u( \(1.'!'-ld,'c.··h\,e. 41AcJ,e~ 1 6u4 he.·,~ ~ll4;vdettl'r-.J1 f\1\1. 1 v. . ;,ee_ ~h) 4ke c\~·Jt?:'i • · . . .· · · ·~ L ~\oS:.,_~-~ b"/ ~ec4v~J~;~J , . . , x P\-..\ leM-~~ .e l\1~; o~~·rc..tzl1~- ~. 'e.c;, *old kh( :r~d~ flCQ+ei\..1·~~, (~eVe\. P-~:3 1 P· l\IJ~ Ito) '·v-,t\'\e..vl.e ~ 4-~e.. t'<.0A-"-=>oun-~4- do4-b ;{'l.~f.tV;J. L.. 11) . ~\s.\s. v,:~\c\~c.*;\i.e..tVU~~ \o\1 ~"\O~e~ A-+-4~12:1\..\e..L\· ~.lmv.;.~ le.~ ~.:oui\J-~~ ~-l'l-e..

·4 \ VV\ E'~ ..\.~e.. ~4-IA...\-12. 's V-\--1>-l o Q.u ~'\ . cv.vl k.J 2:-.~ {e:. ; 1:~ ~- ,\ 1 (L... t:-,· ve ~ 1w1 e s · 1 1\j _(,) ~"· e p\0-~~"~ \.\ow ~~i -.\:'i\N\~ cltd· ~-"r\~--~~ ~t~~·-k\ Q,(OWle.-(..10-1t'e-VL 1 7.f!..f2.J0J' OR. ~\)~ \.-i,\f\1\~.J~I 'Z~ 1 f:\~1,£\ltvo . . . .· . . . - . ' . . .

' .:/ . . ·. ' :. ' ' ' .: 2C\l: :. .•. ' . .· . . - . ' . . . le4- ~ 1 \oqk ~-+ vv\®Q·e ~s\s+1''0s ~~ ~Y<.\~4-.·o·u ~9· \V\\diV\1V&. :~ ~e... ~urt.t .. ' .. I I~ L I k. f',....\0 IL d '. .l' D .:. 0. \ ~:~ ;:4f~h; ~J{h~·~:::~~~1~~m-l$a I .. I

;;·::;:::.~;· -~ ~-~~r~t~· ~~~ ~;;'Tke ·i~~4h ;,~ h~~~t ~. ~~ ~, ; t V\.101-5 .- '""S~.~ M~o0e.e. •. ""n,e-_'~-J &ufl~·fJepeJIP~i ~~lly 11:1~/1 -/~irUJ ~o ./nk~ ~/111:~ o~ ~~R i~1-?t7.?.!011~. ·:- ~L-< -f'tu e-Csy. +o {!.J)v.~'/(,.-cy; 1-hn / Ih r )tc IIJ-/v~m~::, 110 13 $ ~~ ?.>~ Jl! ~' Cou-YL'1·) · 1"-' ::,..{ e.A4-cf- · . ·; r(.

0~ 3 ~ $i1 ~·, ~~t?..':c. ~- Cour<. ~ oJ' M:;d 1~%-~d dou~.f'h{. ·.M\d llt\1-.Jd Cou "' 1 ~ ,,__.'d I ~Ao.P . · ; 'L '(

~4· "-'O~~\tv~_{o \1'-.t't·u. lQo.k ~{ sowte. ct _~he ::A,~>A-te~Me"~~:;. ~\-1,;~(-el~~·':~,:.,; .·~~~:.:· ~~ ~~ .,\..~1;./.\JeAL ~D.YIIW\ke.. ~1'?.. +~1€.-i.Mi )\Jo'-\ l')f'Wduee.. 0"-J \Lde.o "1\~J.e \W•_· 0G'{i~~~~lYM2. . .. ~; ()~:.~:~k~ 4-he.Nv\ p~du..e.-e g~.J\ A~d 1'0 otv-: phoiVe e~l._ ·:.-'·_ ' ..· · ·.~·\ :, . ' . . ~~.-~>I ~cbtJe~-.C oJ d1!~tid•j•ct~ete'"~RI·ct~~·.%'*'fJ D~v-~\ rJ!\-~~1':-'u{'_~J ... \>~·\'r.":'l·''t,·'t,. NcA· l~.~-~eiR M~\u~ll.\~ ~;-1-!A{t,_ oJ~II>Jd G~.~~( .· '*-'~ \(U~:d·e\t A-"-'{ 4- 64k~--- t+ ~foi?3~.r'4· .. &top·~- he p.().\!'l~le . . .~·f:· M\d,\-tLXw~. ~,0~~·1 ~M \oe:~~ 1 ~te/~0v-<.Cuz~ 4~-b~~i~t~c~ . . . , · . .~:~0f'~.~~te~( ~J:(c-ei ~-c·p,.rW~~~~~\'·r~·''1 h*? (v~ ~;..10t31 P; -~~ ~ s-8J) T~_~A ~"''·( ~~~e~t,., ~.. • .w~t,\ 1 ,~,e ">'-~uld,hke. {o ~Qfl.;l(l\;llll'~h·.V\1\ ~~ . . $/)(p~d )1\.t~\(te~ ; / · _·· . .

__ ') .· ·hn~-~~1\.1 ~ts:.B7'~'2if\)Cel b·~ k~ourb~~ ~,tf,IJ:SofoR ~~~~~~£haw-- {~rn;rc,.:Ji ~;). 1- J 3) \. "'"'~" )\A i Ivkvve<c "1 A I '" )\1\ "'k \:rt -4 \-ce: ~~-.~1'\ lo~k I<;' ~ cl 0 "" 0 ""o_.," ( ~ . (:4- . ; .. · . : ; ... ·--~·.:,··~:· ·::·.'· ··-·· ·, :~ .:·.·.·... :.. ~- ::·. i:, p~~ :t·l.·,. > . . ' ·_.· :. tf :·· -·/ • ~ .'• •··~~··:.' / ,. ·: -'~' ·. :\.:.•._<·:~.,;-~/ ".\.'.,\;.": ~ <•:-· r ~~.~ ~: ~ •· -.. , ::.::- :~;r.~·_. :-1" ,, -, -;.' . ~ ·•.. ' -P~~l~. . -~ -

·• J >

-,-you kl-\o~ --\-~e. 1~. ?~b~\~. bei4.eR -~-~~ ~e Jo¢> A-Nd yDu kNDw .

I~ A P€f'-OD~ l~dv<.\\lll\_1~ ~,lrt.\-e. I~-\.O'{IC14~c..d),-,*ISt-.to~:l4deEe1US€,.-.\-o r, .

~h-e. f!..JR. 1vv\~ b~ ~he. p-er'-&0U I~ ; N.-4ox; CAA-b.J ?A.Y~J:Q-~WIM~~MI u ~1/ ,so p~~-a, kl, k',l'-' e<J. J- 1- ~ 3 13upaA" · . .. . . . '' \\/\\'<., QoCSNk:Tt~ \/\.lel\ 1 we v-.wu~d hke4o dei,ltJ·ll-\~e_:. h.;vwv-l-S f\1..1 ~~+~ . v...,',,hJQ.-~ 1p~ L>fON ~~s. ~?BQ.\eluee:. 1 h~'!. k~owl~.e (!)r f~ef1cb5obf{lelf- , of ~ow--~' 1 · N{OuJ,1 \f\1 h'i ~=--?'"'"( \ 'A-uJ~e-R .bu\\d,'~( up A s+l'\te..\"' 1+"-fess ~~ \lvheru2 he~ d6 wo "'-'~~( ., A-1\JJ l 5. 14-N .91(.,~+ -fh 14'4- I!?. NO~ het pt"-'j ~he bEeeU~ .~e 0 ~-tit ._\-hi "'I~ e. \1\-~tn.~~-J £fLO \'\A tv. e t.A.t'M> VVI'j 'IJ&t;>N(>Y,.

Th~ p·,~~k,4h\tv~A«:,WV-\--~ ~Of~ ME roe,\A/14·:':> (\l\l.fi/IAOt-J€y- N_cUJ,Iook v.:-'1+ h\s ..

3-t~~-~%~u4 I~J(R~ Vt,L. ( oC9 1 p,; ct 1 1 kD J'-1--~5 . .. . . . . · · "''S>3ue,-: \ . AW ,.. e · ·. .· · · . 4- · ·· + ·~e ~: · I'LD~'r.· ~·- ·i;t~ ~- ooy R-y: ¥~,-fl do"; •+~ee ~-l\1'1 p:X~~~~:r~···+kt~~·~-. MQ ..(<o~tJET(: • .• :~~ ':: l~lo} \~1~ I,:=L, IA~~~._~I~A:? t~('S ~ \Qtl-\f\0 Hi{4,( a~~€ .:(R.~. Vol._l_qf3J P· 9l, l.?d.-JS) M\1 J.~~;~/~-~+ ~ 8Ktd\. S!Atd he\~ ~\Q.~Y. CJD\\J.~I,Ic:+~c. . . .: . · . '~Mc:Q~-~+li-ij_··~ Yb:, ~ N\12.R6oSV-\~ T\1\~~\,~H{ be.C,.'-\c& ~~\~~~A ~drk ·, . . . ., ·':)~~~ ~~th~if+(~~"c:~,~;:~,L~a~~-~~~)~~eh,~cl·o.fPou~ ~h~~,·rt. Rril'Pk., Pe+~1l;.l~~e·:~~ y-2111~ 6,1 Ch~+"u1 A-1'-1d h.aviPJ( hdpo hcol":__alc~·~~ we ~e. .V\Aic·~e·:;: --·· _ · '/ \ tv\R. RGB~'k:'JT:·'J~e...,·"'!e \Nou.lc\ M0ve· rot<. A ~&:~%~~~~~. .b~ ~~~; ·~ :o.: ·.·.. ,,c.. :.,',;., '· the.~* ~'A-\; ~\;I.e €\!;de.IVC 6 de&u&J ~e-wJo~e doeo:, 1\•.10+ Rt ~ ·h, ~e Ie~·, e..L · · ... · · .., · ot 'beyoucD ~-p_~·~-~-~d~ub-t-.1Ht2 roue~~_OkAy~Thi1+~J_e~i.J. MP.. : :: .;-. .

AOOOA:. 'Th~\'~-'s .Ci IV_e. 1-.ju:} II\I:AN4ecH·u ~e~ i+ Okl ~€.U:Jrtd 4-ht:l~ v..'ef\>k-fb.tL'd._ TI-le WL!fl't: Oklly ~. .. ( A_,Q.\Jo L Jof31 p, J8 1 ·~ {4-J./) •·. ·. . . . . _..·-~·····y · _·. · ..• · · :...:.·' .. ·. ~- r. · ·· · • . ~bw,+ho5?R ~~tJ~J~ s.hou\J h·~ve &+A4-ed 1.t'.'a phy~',uJ ptUDo~~~~ .8~RI~,-~! A·Ncl h~~~4'iv1 c_{] ~.· ~· IS. whe.tee.. he. wA--~. ~-heue..k A-i\J..d h,4 by -4-u.-4-tMoMy fl!tt.JN _R-epod· ~""'& A.Or.dll\vt'·L ~l()-:1- s~~ck _1 E_J,\'t~.;, N. plu~~~~,~~u'(of ~ .. ~o~ez.. ~ ~ .· · · ·. _.:' . . :_·;,; .. ;.-., T_s8.ue_;.. 8up-deN Qf_Pa.00,P , . , . . · . . · · _:·. :_' ·: · ·· .. ·;,··,·-·~:;..,,,,;,_, M~ ~ ~'~'ve-rL ·di:~~·~t~~k~!h-~~~~+~ 6rl'a_N7 prioo ~· ~f r.w.di o ~~~d ~~-i~¥> ·~~~ :~·:.:~o_~·!i-~~ ·· ., peQ~u~ ~4-t.Wlbl\.i(/ b\} 1:::·. G,~WteZ. 11 A.-~~& +he ,t<.o~& J.he'/ r.J/ K~eLU '~·"''~ pf2:tyit\~e; · · ·•· .,.l

M~~A'~-'-'h4t~\~:( ~tp+~eou~{·~/ 1'\ll~ • t--,+1'-\,"-\.eJ. , · . ·. · · · . . . ·. :: ,·· :· · ·. ' "· . \c .· , The. pu~~o{~k\.~ \~1'2:\~ oreevleu_; ~foR+~~~ Court_t4-o de.\e~waue ~fL-R~\!_t~-~ DoeK 4k<i: ~ove. ·e:..how 2B)) ::c...:,et?Eee.-t;'" e A-ss~::.+f.hJc..Q..Dt Cou,._,gJ1ttB) PcwsMM'·h·o,~ v.J M, ~ei)M&u.e.'h. ~ 3) f='"r< ~d j ~ 4.-) Pe~l)t2.'t: B~u ~:I. d ,·J "to+ U:HIA~\t :..kh't c:. il re.; wt e .. Se-e. M~ _,~; ;·:t?e 's i~+t'Mof.Jy·~_ 1+4eJI&~e~.w4h . Th~+l~·v..tky,f:.at>IMez. pu+, hi~ c.¥~~ A-''-''d' h',M~-~ , be+ wee f\J M e.. 14-Vd f\1\ ~ l.-t b u <6-a:.. / d~ e I h r+ve. r.J ~ y ptD 11\J kJ eu ~ L:~. r.uute..'!>ti +, No4- ~v+tk 1 OR. A-"h·J 4-k,,u'i ~;, ~0 &~,cO- 'lou ~~RJ~';hJllve +h:ls powG?-~>~·.?• ~.J,p .

Y+ru INNOC:E>,tu{ Mlk·i~L /.\-evJ ~ 1 M ~-k_,,v'J 4-~lc;Couw..~4--o~Jp f)/1;~ tV6UJ .. . .. . ·. · · . . · . . . ·· . ... .·. . . (&6" N) , C~\.!,p~leV\1\e~t P~-~·1'e: ~.J. ·~<'""'.w"'~~~c

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.