CAMPBELL, PATRICK LEE Jr.
CAMPBELL, PATRICK LEE Jr.
Opinion
_ » .~ _ 7 - ‘ ' ‘ §§U", O%"'ol' . k y " v l \\_/"3> /3@\§ ‘ b QQ\<<°\Q`\_<Q ' \_.. Q&w@\oq_\\ `SC; 'T§Q:§' \&>. \*\“12,@\§ UR¥§FE§%§!|A\£EJI¢:\)L|~';PPEAES_~_* °§@'\, emma O¢&~<* ‘ ' 2_\0\ QD§~\ 'é\.a°\ \§ 'i@m i~`@~c\< /\Q>@_% ‘IL§L:\ Abe!Acosi'a C¥erk
a“\;D‘J 09 2035
Q?:; 92 \Q Q,Q.;<\`C"§ QL\¢D\`)XXQ`\ _\/(: %YGX<;% 309§>\1.0~<_4\)€(3.\ l Q‘?
PZ<\%L,SQ_S` Pz¢\§> _"g \Q\&\ £>2¢\§> §'Q;\DQ&\ (><`><)<Q\` <\¢.,.C)g P§‘§<n\z§@~\(n\\<t% `/\é> \\ -O`_( (>?Q(\S\Q\LC`\\©<\ q€;(' ?OQ<’“ wC\\(\L`\°\<:DC\ ubc°\"< §§ \5{0\\$¢_0;% Q_;@r@\>% 'C.Q~o%e._ S€>‘, \©Cg_@%k¢%°\- <L>%»~\
KD;QC &\r\v. P;C,'OV€Q:,O` y k l . ‘ . \ 1 ‘Z€\Q,\o%£_§ Q\La%w TD“.§> N§€~>\\LQ~<\’~`<S @‘L\Q\:\’€e~\_` "€}\ "‘\</\1. @<\Do\c<_, %\“\Q¢> &‘&> §v:\~\czq.<~v¥ C,Q»Q&><_. Q\¢_Q&Q. Y>\b_‘§ ‘“Q\% c><“\¢, %c°\<\:§ “i~<j._\c `-Yu e\>><\‘<u\><@\ 09 _f(M. Q,QQ¢’<`. _ ,_ ?\¢_;>%¢. <><\%0 \Q°\\\ -€\;. %Q.\;\Q%LB %<§< @‘<`§>Bc_z.$%@`a~, Q¢%><Q ._ §§ ¥::\qk\<>:>z_. %U\}> w<, &`>~ %>€O®~©»`.E YL\¢_}> Q.c>ou 0<§ 'TQ<\% C,<SD'\<,§>_ \~Q,\\€.L,< Ae,\o%¢b
%y\<\¢,o_r L\:.)
. j 2 - .C,_A_o_%p_€<>;\@¢czra\‘$w _<za~\
€d» QQ&`<<_,€> ' _T£¢\*'\€w Q>O\S`<Q{)\Q_`< Q.Q)QC\‘ §§
Q¢e\\\¢°~%\<m w\>\\\:) riggs
§&\<9\¢€ \, Q;,\W`>\w\\ ~§'é._ '\z`z§_\§ "S°`Qéi\@;>@\ \~B°\Q<<°\ g\#”
¢"\0 c\\°>c.e\<\’§ %~ Q\QQ¢¢§RQL£ %\€O§<~`% wp;>\w¥e`\ é"éx\%l®<,§ ¢\¢\E `\'E _,@\\ Q°\Q~\ ~\’Q~\® RQD;Q~\ P?"<"<QCK\L:;& %\,;>QC<\ A§Q°&>o.\§<\~ 145 \\.I>“L P<Y'>Y\;m\\°~o<\ '§¢§ v(Q»;>%’<. Q,@<\\&Q§<°\QL\JDC‘§’< 252 \VQA\QQ,Q`B Q.QC§-o&
` C,&>W\<.E> \(Ob.§ /"'€4, `~P\’§}>\()\Q_Q_<\s<` "V£ QQ,(;\J>€¢`J &&X& SQC©\L»~L.A£<O`\ . R¢\%Lba,c P<<'\,B "'(L§g \B`\ F~?<\B PZQQQ_,Q`\ (Q\\(Q<(\W\§ %®SQ<\ (5~<‘@0&¥,0. \(Q\&S \'£r\ QL%'DBASK. `TE L>?Qz\z\\<.o`\\‘<% \\.©"K _ (Sé;\>;\>\\c_&>{’\wm A:>< \o%?<~ usc\\§§§’®c\ Lb€\\‘< §§ \S<&\<><_AB Q,gcb\'>~. _‘ "TJ§~`% ~/p<°\m\ Q,Q>QQ’~< \§<Q.% \><cé<~_h *{¢\ %c;¥ q§\\\\') \,\\ Q>w?)\\\:`) `r*;\¢_ e\@@\"\vw\\<’ »é€\& Q\>Q, ‘"&\¢_\\é< \[5 §Z@,\\§< ‘<i.’ ~{B_<\ov\<\§ `<‘<M, aem§\°$<d€\m\c\\ Y§cc<>c§ `<L\-» c>zg><\\`\c~_o_=\\<& Q,\Ol\v\ \f§;;\-\\o,\\ @\\\\\<,B `j<\b P"<@@\\LQ.\€Y \'\'"=', \é`<`o)e<.e,% Q@c@\z% QQ,C\Q.Q. ~'QU <_'~>oo @<`0<»,@.%% Q,\uo%@ §§ "'§”\.,, \\¢\` mm md»»..\ 'Q\¢o\\>`&»% __Q\~., "a><o.’<@, ~<£ %e,c»s¢\\ o\>*< <>e\\ "\é:\<‘\§m,mu.» \S`Q\€ QA<XLQ~\ `¢:\L<§>~;_<\m\. jo §¥03<@ @Ce\<°&~,q.§, *A<\.,_ P<@@\\Qb.\\\' A\\}g \\\% "\‘<€°\0.\ \_o\\;>\\@,( \S\\\\ @<\\;3 - Qq<\w\ §§ ~\/N_ iL9 9§¢$_“@@ %¢;M\ -j€w <>m>< Q&Q\><z \;;>\\\Q\\ ii§;l\\>§mb `-r€\<, w;\\c.w\¥< “%C'o\\~ `-Y\¢. wo.<q)m;mL_ Q.Q\c> GQ\\\@\\ \,00~§ <><§>Q$\\<\LE iam 'K)\$\EAAQ,Q_. (><¢\,. O<\>¢- &\*\\,§ QQ_.\\L ©<\ \<) %-\"'"\'(r\e, %\G}<b P'\)€ KQ?\\L&“X\\_ \t\O\\
. "_\'é w%>\é;\<\ P?QQ\°\QQ~\\\` g Q_Qn\\£ \Qs';\Q<\ q>\`q\§, %Q_KQ( L`\U_; OQ (,( S\SC`\L&><;B `(A::%X\Q\'v%l ‘P<\< §§ ‘C\O\\ Q_,Q~ <\\\ `_\_'@\ Q~\ 9<\\,¥) (\) _"\>=>%Q, \sQX<.\A _ \,b\\b _`v£\ ¢&Q< . 3><0)<@,§, ~QQ)< ~J€¢, &Q@\z@.\\>< \;>QS= »§<3< ~©W ¢~%%Q\\w\>< @< wm£:v qzm%\\§\¢, <"a"¢ ~e'§,, QZO\O\DQ;:) pz.\\¢> mw¢\>< ~£\ ®“Q>\ ~A<L mm __L©c\\¢`\elw}) <><'<\`§> %Q_;\KU\Q_QE> \’T\\L r><rg\a\»gs>_<\\ Q>Q ` 'TQ\¢, %}<QX@ \J<c\c>\,o\\§:\)\q ¢><\»L\@ `i’,\><o_q\€\_@\\e~\\“ @<<>\£`\§,Q¢ ¥<§<L e<¢©\”\m&<»' \s»\.&» \\\s ~r*§° \q\ \`u@:§°§ \4;3‘:\5<\¢\ 9<\\»\ Qb<¥`\m\ QQ» ‘TEQ, ."é\<l§»u\c.<z, %Q`m<\ ;m\~\ Q\§<>v QQ_%¢>\\‘ `v`<:*< @Q.\o&¢,: `<"?\L_QQQ;?K~QQQX few `~\Q., <\~0`2\)0\;<,&\\¢. m_u‘> v <\<»\o \§<>\'€ '*\‘\'~@ `_E§~,U\>$\’<;\) OQ -\%\L 0<\\`\<\_1_\\§‘\§§\_<.¥> %o%?¢.@< \_,b\\@<;<_, -®\&P<` Q,©;\><Q.\~\\\\QX<.§> A\C;B%LQ\ ifiwmu_ ~£.,, _VQ><Q. max <>e“\> Q@\Wz m ~<§~ %Q%\@;\<\ _§SQ_?_\“\QQ`<\><'% LQCQK\:§\>\' w<\\c\_;§@v\ wh %U\><m;_g“ ‘2¢\»`, ‘S.Q‘R.`L %QLQ§LQ\ Q»L%\>Q<\Q¢§\\‘\\\._% <>C 4>~< Q<:@w_w\¢¢" S><oe<{§ ."R @< Qb¢;;_§>\bc \\<Q~x ~¥K© Q&%\>o(\%l\§\\"\&<\§ ""g %U`, 7-'%\09< `S@%\\QL ‘<Y<¢ Q>:><\¢,\ 4>`>§\\¢> \Xo\< §~<-c>\q`~€ \ <>'<“ c>"€\¢,~cc>¢e><<.. `<Q& Q\L%Q<>c\§l‘o \\° §§ LQ&Q\§,% \Sé§<\ _\\;\/ 02 \SQ<~/\\e<.< QQ ‘"DO@_QT_\§_`<°\Q, o\e>\\qo;\\©<\% <>`<\-0<_\§) "’Q~<,%A, -<LS"\'@> m `*'€\u¥ §§ Q@C%®n ~s.% `~Q<e.o§<o`.<\<}> L,S‘\?\\ QC %o\o\~z.®rq.,§> `\'@ ~§¢>\ @\<\©?% §§ er Q,< \\\~\<\&\ l @\`o%e.c_o¥‘l©c\ L,S`X~<\a:>o‘< Q@ec>¥> Q_Cx\>%b %J`\J‘;iq, %?c<>’;\~_ Q€&\`> P<\\ G‘S<§&v~\&m@,` ®Q><;\) <><a Q\Q§>`;§L`b 156 ~§`.<L '\\>QL ?<:ou»,%% Q\Q\>%<. §§ \é<~., \\&"§’\ (>Z\~/\Q_<\\§\~\U%€ “'€ %m<<§.\ mv \><\\ ¢>\¢‘2&<\@`, <>€¢\\‘>"€ ?<SE>\F\€\,Q. \`SY\¢- ` P"<Q\:\“\ C,OA\\‘ 4>`<<\§> \;K\?> ”‘Q\Q;\ \,_QJ-.O\<>>§_,<’ >§<>‘< Q:\\\X \JD\‘<\\ ®)§\>~'< Q\Q_%`>\¥X "Ro& @*L\Oézh\c> ">V~L <>'Po(>\\<‘.@»<\’< item `\\\.L,_ _a\»\(>.€>€):c_\<\c. L\°\© rSo¥ `\’\‘5 oe\°§© Oco\<'\§>»z, ~r\»e, e\;>@\`\ce`<\‘< <><r~.\<z> \\\<§ `<<<~&\ \.c>~c)»¢r \,;L\\\ `<§?\_L `<)_¥Q,<\\°\X\ \4§4, 0\\\\@@>§\`@ Lh %\\M>LQ< bakqu C>,_s_<>< Q_o=\*<<w~\<\®< Q~¥> `Aiv`, j §\~A&Q~?l\<\¢_, gki`@ \,b\§\ ;\\ *”\S\?\Q. %\<0§<¢_, d>`<§:>v~'&§<<_§> "`~\"§'c\><w §§<¥UQ.@ ‘U"d.\\\& o?\\\) QQ,\ES\_% m wo Qw\§\®\ f¢;a@&§, @e§§;\<\%~< ~<\`<;@. H?\xm\>< \r% w%\<~;<\ _¢< ®Cbm&;o§ :Q,_Qq\w`\c¥\w\.e<\<\`?:> S<,¢\><a.<\cg . "<\`_‘v;§¢,?b§`<b¢., ` (>¢@\\;\`\Lm\\'B Q,\Ol\v\ §§ Q®L§,®D§"\O\\ '¢&\%w\hoéé< ~§& \c<>.&°\§> . _ ` gin `T€e_ (>&Q°< X&w°\‘< ccc 'Q“Q&\<Q. O<<Qc\cbb°\`<z. <>_?Q‘D\`\LQ~<\X§, "€\O\\ QQ_\<\%'L\,_ P<Q®\\QQA\X“ @<SQ><<,% ‘_‘1?\¢. 4>'<\\¢,0\0?< \O\\% "\\0& Q<q. <><_<\\‘> Q\\% "TDQ\%~\ \_D`LD\\LC `de.£_°\\~,gz> "T§&LY\\Q_C 4>~% (>'< 940;\\<§ ©Q`"`/ \\"\O`\ %\<Q`QJ<LQN` `\'@ _§Q\_¢_¢>_~§<§L,<~\?K~ ' ' ' <‘zi>
. ““€ Qz,)<@,§w\c\§ "Y\:x<. ‘P<§\§&\ L§<\\;S"_\_§_§\§) (" §§ "~*Q\L §§>S \1><' %0`\\~§\<;.. '§)¢\ __o_~_o_é_<§§_c § Y`Q.Qé< \clo;\ \,§\D§\j.c §'®r\& <><<<><\§\:)\k~r_ %L§§s:<\ _¢><§§ §m¢.‘i’< %<\Qx;o§ <>'e §§<S<\\§< oQ \<B\\ Q.<§§§< ~<L,\ \~€o§< \§<<_ \;>§O\\s> ~5<\¢. P<Q,X§o;\ Q,§<\><€\\Q\>X§¢ §§ ~<P\¢_ §§M< wm§\§ §§ <>< m®<\<<f §Q"L §<<Qe<§\. .§\><\\Lc C)<) \ ?\0~\ \ (\"~.O»\ \,Q`\.}du\<,(` &\'\%X\‘< \£><(§(\QL,§G\\‘R ""7';% §~'>%*c "~Er\<_¢:)w\(;~.__’<e.‘\¥ s_`>(` Q\§%§\W\o_\&‘ ';<t:x\§(`&<,c.’<\\ro`,. w ting @(` /s‘€\¢_g£~ ig ;§`\§\q\,\'m` "£ _’(§\., _Yr__;¢~%\~\\ _@_w;_§\`}§> §C `<[;\-\ '\,;Q°‘\\‘\<S “<S\>\oé< QC§;§§ `\Q`@, {>‘<\\U`o`¥`\§=\§ §§ {>?§D\\QD~<\‘VB
~<Q\a\ \~§\;z;\)»`;. \RQ_<_%OS -<i'i% \SQ\<__@;§~>_QA°\§§\\$\§ ~%.\ w §g§v>e §§ \_mb P<§Q»§Q¥,\<\~\ ;T@ @§\¢_ <’é,,§z. Q,§Q . ¢2~`¢> ~<P._ w\\¢_§>u\‘§.§ ~'~Er\ ~5€4. <>`5§;§§€0<` §§ *\Q'~o~\ \`§\b&)§cl. 0'\§.<\& ('>§<'§<\§\§°c&z “¢ZS <><\§S§\§X».\(\B \é'<@_§v&o§. "C§§’€\ e<§ YD ~5\1\§ m\\ccm‘¢ ~5<\¢, €‘§§\“\c.m\’v" \¢3<\ _\\\§ Q,\Q;\<- §§ *<):”}\§&§Qx\\u_ <><%%"&\<Qm§ §§ `£\m\ \_Q\§d\xq_< \\o% %><03<<,\> §<>\\;m<»` %J\' ¢§QS¢§ `“~Er\ SQ§©§€\* §§ \\`\% Q.\§i`w~ (><<\\§_ "'\’%v., Q"v€x\%\\w\ Qu.§€`§% §§\o;¢\m>{‘\@§v& F<QQ\LLQ`<\’<§ 'il§.d<% b§\"<\\ "&§ '~`§Q§§ov*< §§ <\»\Q.<\<Q e<§§<\o\§\%~c` Y@Q’\\L§\§§& P`<‘§Q\XQ\<‘EX \D\\'\Q\ Qco@g ch ._%_<.\_1\0~\; §§ P<Q'\§\"\ QD`\\\' ‘€_§\'g§< l \'vlm\ \,§LS»\LC \<\/\Q..C\<Q R§§<\§w\‘s<, '\§o&, "E¢\ Q€`§¥` ~€L<§§LQ&"N<_' fin P<§§\`\Q&<\\`§ `TD §&\ bob `ré *\DQ"\§\ \_§\§a@\x
YLS.\ O(`Q_ `_\’& \\C\Ln_» `QBU\\&\<_X> *€\\z___ O<\\§<s\\& ub\c KWSP<.Q§< \)O\\§"§<_Q\S`(’\‘ \',QO\% ©v\ "T\¢\<'_-, (\/\§O\O~Y`°u'\b L\°\O `.T<;\O\\“ \QO.% _ P\_“§>§'\\\\<<,\b \%€\*<O ‘%:¢<\§>@Q,Q_> "'“§ %<. G'b~cr\'d) P<v\,\® Qa_\\ bb .©$`\ (\%»\ "<`?\¢..» %\<Q><<_, "’€> w%\'©l\\\ 99 \)';>§`b\\<\§\;)\ Q,QL\\L'\Q_X\§¥\ P?r\% %~z,<\\‘u\€..€_) (3<0\(1\<\;;\\9`\0~\ \&®A§? § Q_,\\o_<\\‘\"” `T§\<L_:
4><@©\`\@0\<\`< `/€LO`\ \__Q\_DQ\Q,C .(\’:;S‘<Q. ©'Z\`Q<\O\D`\\<L "VEAO`B<_QOOXQ. L©\>\\"§»`$` Gev&> Q§§\<§%§\\<®€~o{\ §§ “<R». R§‘@\\Q§<\V %Jd§§~>\§§b `£§ §§"<Q,§\\~§ ccc Rz\>‘§\°§¢_§<\\(§ `v(>v"\e&. _’L\ rkm\ kung <\/\Q&\& s>Z€§\\§b';§\’<~c <\><.1\`\<,\:> wm\\ma&‘§ \<>X\" @&\~Q.<\¥>S\~§<\¥ @"\q\:\\`* `Y§ @§9@§§0§<@ Q§~>\\%Q.\ ` (><'.\\t> Q\Q.Q>G`§¢L:\*<O`\`\§'\ . \D\\u\ \§<e.. R\Of\§ Q:Q.\c\,e,%j §§¥ "’£é ?\3§§0<. `N”\» `§§‘»§\\\\\\\ §§ "\¢)\Q. m§»>@\ wo\€\§>>§c <§; §§ §¢S<~ %§§\.L § »< m<»\<\<§ §§
\Q\u\ <,‘z>)
. $3@0_\5@<;\\5¢`¥¢, C,OO:\%L\ 02¢\\> %Q_CQ_%Q,\\>KQ`\`®¢\ R\%m <§Q,Q<`\\c<,\c, ;£L _¢§~§@\f\m&€ §< \\\%. QD<\%><`\\~\>\`®<\Q\\ Q\§\)\\*< -p§ Q_C®%%~ 'V€><Q~v#\¢\¢, `£g \D&\°\é.~z.<.\`<"\§`\g§> %_DBDLQ`\* \JB\Q%§_Q\)§\R \>"~>\€>\\Q_. \DQ~% ®'§ %\\x%\&$l~\ ii `§,w-\L_Q. "% %Xo&e. \>%»_\e ¢><¢\\@ Q¢`\\Q_§ég wm P<% ?\N,\%\Q&x\ §§ \§,¢_QQK ¢>`<<\0~`¢\%’€'“9~&, P<Q®\`\QOA:\X "Q»~ §\'\O\<\Or¢‘lc\._J a\°\© \D\\\Q\\ 05th Q_®<\\oe~'\<\ok~;\,_ \D\’c\\ (><`<\ %\QA\QAGLDA %0%§>;@<% ®»§P< %0\:%¥0`<\\\0\\{§ “\‘Q\u*’p \@§X\wou§ §§ \Q\L\\\\»\_ `§;%@;\QQS@_\Q» \_D\\o' "((/;z%\`&l gx 0€3€ <*<'Q\\>\LLQ`<\\`% '“<QQ'\O`\ "'\S§\ok w RQ@\°\LA<\‘< ` \;;30~°¢ \\`U\# '<<iq. w%\>¢d< @<' <><%%,Qi\\m\\€ RL%@@¢\%“\\Q\<, *\EEJC `€C\L_ `Q\@\Q\¢¢%. e-<¢\§> <><%%O.\>\’<~*£Lq§eu, \\<"/c°\o& \`0¢®%<_€ \\/\0.\"\& m<\o®°&r_ YDQ?\\\>CQ_ *T€S \><mu Q_' “~i:_`§>u\¥\§\§\c_ "\‘%~L. ©\\?§‘)<.c\\<`&\z_§> %;>NQQ_Q< "\§\C<)o;\)\~ Q>\S€Y V\.%P`<`Q}¢\ Q\`Q,‘:\J<>Eag<)b` `YQ\'<LJ 0\§<&:»~¢, £§- P\@q\;\`\ Q_Q~<x’<'§~ `T£e>\o`\ 92<\§\3 '\EQC*§\~C %oc>;>@<*<"§ v>‘?©\>\®\\k‘&. 'Q\O"\v~ §§ *'\E<\ Q§;Q.L\°\¢L <>&%\%¥<o~<\w/ §§ '£`\u\ _L®<>“%L\ `\'RQ,C<§QQ»`.\ Roa\`\go`\\‘s% <‘_XQ;\M § _<)i<\»_§§ .Y_Q&\qb wgz\x&w\m . QQ`_ \v`\o& Q_Q<><\%A ‘~€% \LQ`\‘L};>. ’3{/\ ~/\Eo_, &§KKE;\&’€ @Q "§Q~~B KBQL»;>’<<_,~ \c{§\.,_, c'§';?;>\"\'ag~v¥€ @»§0>€@,§ ~T\:<;oi\; _N,¢\DQ¢Q`\' &\CX'XQCN:\ "§dwb§ ®¢>Q,¢>Y<@ ‘éq»,<` .\§Q~X> 99 Q§CQ:”EQ%% '@:c .<N\D?<’\QQ\£<‘% ®\QQ,Q< ¢QQ;>;&\ . ’N\_ ~<\i`\b <>3@;;»,\ ss;%\<o;<\{z.;x week x>'<§§§%&o.\¢°&> "§m\.§ Q`>Qg;§ '?E>XO»‘<~`¥ *&oé; \\Q, '\:\é<<.¢“<\~ `\<\¢`,E) `T§<\o&< P\\\ Q>Q‘< ")§'\z, \_cl’§~<d `§,n><\o¥,oq§’\cr\ §< »<€@ »\Q\\¢»_`\L\~ Qm~\¢v<\,w <>\<\, »&<S\ QQ<\Q`;Q<\\.><~V ffcroc. ¢>@@¢04\ w<\<<>w\% _§Xwa_<> QOQ;:A<QJ ';§p\~_§)_ e\ '€z('\\¢o\oo& %Q\LQ "Er\"` \`1\@., Q.O.%Q, cg A”D@\\QQ<\\S_* \B`&¢_QX e`\s;"~p;u\ Q_\c>;w~\<\<\ \-<‘\'¢\o.¥ `“{.`, %><cé<<, \.C>Q% @LS.~.>‘;><\SQ\Q\@' gov §_\ Q\r~\-C_\<>%\\\:) “T\’\a_ 'A¥~\%\Q_¢\LQ_, §§ {>< Q®\\Q.e ~\‘£¢\ Q»O\C \L\&.Q)D O(\\q )S&_B&
/. */\/\g, €¢\\> §§ SSKQ`\Q,% ®& R_Q_\ "€:\aav~~<\&\\m\ "“(\KL(<,\>S ®¢_c`>¢q\\s°\<\:) `5`§¢_, e\<\;;>\\u>\~z<" ~§<\.~ 'é<§@gp<l>§<, o.c Qg%~@msmq\°@m O§ <\\\ §§ '~<K¢_ %\'<@~><L% L>§&\\z._%%@% LQ\\Q "<!€%\Q`w_§) @Q"\o\` “’g "€\ <3<02<¢`.%‘ '<§\%C_\O%<)§z_, §§ _\'&¢, ._ \Oo\\€_e.- "£z\» Q..O& \£°L§»_uo QQ,QBQS\N\ <-'\m_®\`q'\¢~r\& \Y\.__ K@Q\~QQ~\’< §§ \¥\% YDQ>¢JQ`\ ew\§ %ko)<z. Q\o\€<\ `<’<§ <>@e, <?KQU.%%. :>2\\ mg ;?¢\\co\cw% c_Q\>§e, @o§»\§> o<\ "r€\.;, @§\)\§\@<\ *<E%%QL§> `&9@<\@, zo\z.o\l %<j _\\?\., mm 02 . mr\z;\>u>c\%_ n Q£;c 9\£\¢, `Té£`:<%‘<» O`~S<€\Qk <§ `Tg\¢m% * §§n\€¢,§», 9<(<<&< 4>%~?@\`\¢§>:\’<§ n _v\"Qlo_~\` \.Q..\D;\j£,¢ %'\Q~C\<C &>?~'\`o<\`c>\§.BQ-\kz:w QA»LQ,\DQ,\Q> *£¢, Q<>K\m.~ `~§_/\\» ~Q_,Q;< Q°\§,LO \‘ Q__`;<,L¢\`\wo_.§> `Té’ "£<\Y<Q<>§p*c,e *""\E‘é \\?'\¢\`lv <z§<QP\L\¢> WQ\QX ~\§<<, \\ `T€"\O~\ \_Q\~_b>)@».,( ` wayne a<<@a@@‘i\¢, \\<>\@ §O @\§\U;\:\a<\ va Q<QLR\§\“S va ¢\agu;§ QSQQ»~.,.\>< "\‘§ c ‘Zi>c\\.,¢ w@@m><s _<s<_‘@p;\g$m>€g ¢\cil\»\ vace< N>z>\\@<><\_‘<§ \1><?§)®\ R><\:o\`<\% `SOA§`Q.% ®oq,o’<_&*@!l% Qr><\%\\&o\"\m\o`_\\gj <\Q§QQKQOE<<, <>~<\\x ~€.\..é$§@s\¢c vfp f ¢»®@\@Q<c .m&\ r-Q'vaae,\% ~%; ¢<>:\\“\M va Qa'§@ P< QS\A\§\ o§: `”£<\C§Q¢L&_\\<@ \£\%% \%XO.<\Q_¢_, @Q v'p`\&\ Q.oor\%ck P\&m\\%\* n <><D‘>\LQQ~\\\`% ~ 20& \_m:)a&< moch R<Q<\<>L:>é<z *’€;§ ¢><\%o W<P<\<\M.Q WC\% mc>\`\co&\‘% Q\d®~ *TK®< <>RD@\LQ<><\\‘S e<c>c>w\\ \>€\\<oc<\L-\, `S@o`\\._;®o;@\<b §§:,\¢LC ‘<YO~\Q> dS< Q\onc¢\u \c>c §4:?< NE>§><<_%%\N\ *'\’€@ Q)X€€ %\1" \BU\U_ "~fr\ P?QQ_\Z_Q,Q»\\*<‘% (>'<`D:>Q.o~\ @(`:LQ.B%. F%09e0`\ ¢\X‘\<QC<\N K%`\\~.,% WL§ '?>Q`w§ ‘f¢\ P?¢`;?\\Q,G`<\X% I><QQ:\><Q`\ 'PYOQ_&_S§_\AQ% j\>\\(o\c>\:,%o 4><<\‘€~> '%§TX\\Q_S.` %\>Ypo<\<% .` ¢>€Q;,\\Qn<\\‘x @\Q;\__M v\§~u>¢ (»<QP\~~QQMS @'\;>@Q\ e;»><><§¢<\.,:\) ma `i'<\&?w\\m -£¢\ ¢»<'\3?\1@>\\\‘&_ <><.QM\ ‘?ceu.x%. \£L< ._§20<‘<, \ \>z@_@\x@.\\\<; Q\Q;\\\§ §§ YKL§C&¥\¢';%@%S\%DA;L ,®\; a<@@@“\ <>‘<S<><Oca% viz M\“\\¢> ` 'P\\%D( (>\g>z\->~,c.>\ e'<\<\_n;<\._:§ `§%\<~._§ ®OL§\'£`,` %R®<q_\> '~'Er\ `\\\% guzman _<>'§<§_§&§§<' `v%<>>e Té§;_%,ucc RQ;_@><Q.\S ga vac %\<>»<a, .‘ %0\\\ QM(\._\KQ,§ asa _Q¥_~>AM\_®_@_%_E\>\_QNL R&w\\c§> '-&\ v£:;b "\S(§>c\\\x wm <><,Q;\%l<>r\ @U\ ~£/Q @P\\cdq\`§ ~l>z\\a§<l>€\m\x acts ~‘_prb \;:\\\C>.\ ix §Q><v‘? \ mt %<>\§ `€?\ `SPL>%¢_, \;QK<,\O\ `v@%\§\&§ \><’< €`\&\ "TL\§(Q\<' `\Am. ai'\p\a\w`e§\\<_ ~ \>QS §Q\< \r<¢<._ <>¢%%ol\\w\\e Q< 335§>¢,§§< Q&Qo<\$;\\o\¢ Q;r “<QN, €O\¢\Qa;<_j <>e.\¥ _@%B)&\V ,.‘ wax \\Bb§‘?< '_\§;ZL\C><LS\Q_¢L_, kb\{\c§\ §<?9».&\ P€L<`<*a¥<\v...:\) `SQ&\\'\§% ®\'>QT®\”QJ N>p\\c_m\>< \L\ Q¥\<»\ ~ ?&\\Q¢> va @<§,§Q\:eg§ ~£.“ <><-Q-\>\\Q<\\<'% Q\< Q.Q~< <>‘<Q;>Q\ §<&\L<
%§\Q%Xo<\>€\©}<-§ \L\G¢`\v\ `§§S<. \c_o£e,\of& `~'<L::°>&"\<-m\<j O<\ ‘CS@\\§\\§\< leg MDD\*"\QQ¢\\<. ._¢>< _9§#&\ Q><:<;><<\¢.S M:\W,x ®OL<>*¢Q_ ¢><\%Q %\<Qk<,\, YB\\%¢“ vf,\ \&\3 wo\`r\ G<Q;'( _é>O-A\r° 96 5099©%@.§\\4 Tjé' "‘Qu %Q,\J< cg< \\\l% \<Q:Q®\Q_ m<>`. `“5\93< C>\£(*< YQ><>R\Q> _.Q\\' Q.\<)\\<“\\ *£\<<.<\~% \,.Q_c<><` %J\ `_5¥<@ @¢<9@3§(&’<9»< mu\§_n`\¢>_ <§3 _. `T\\</ P\DD\\ Q.Os\\< \§\\\Q`_\\ `Y% §0\< "/€'c>¢.`r(< `r(<`. _<>‘\\€\) <\r\G.XQ_\\ NA\A,L §><\ @\§\<\<m& "i\w\z \.&»< %<j »&L QL<§\>¢<\Q`\O< v»@_\w_&.;@ Q,K\\® m \\Q;¢v QQ,\~QQ.\<COE<®< \,B\\§ \§Q.S ."EX_Q,\\X§\Q¢\) "<§;v<>@<\:`\\ ®£<>€ §AAK§N\ 0`<% §§m\~ d ®os. \\s.$\ QQ&`\L_\;' zqu \\Qb N?@_\'\Q.wé\. ~\(;<g, `.6<:\>§;\;®~<\’< %@\\L\c-\\, ""§;e$€ pQ;¢\ <»z\\<><\\% K%\\wx ®QU\@ ©Q<@D%L\:) <~\Q~_h_.g ~&@ ‘v<‘§\w.¢ %>'<o><¢.v\a_¢\><. “ii\ \é\\% S\AQM\' ¢><§&i\§»m“<><~ \.C$\X\\' `TR».. _fr\*<`<,§\\<\m\x 99 <\;;<O\@,\;\.\S ‘~&<,_, ~ mw »1@ ¥%c><\mg appch §§ ‘z€l\%¢& mow' ¢>z%`<\§»m\&¥ 'P<&Ol\<\%\# HQ., \>'$Q_?_\LLQ,&< ¢‘€<\§> "\€@ R\D<`>K\ QQ.<\\‘&. Qq;\@~z’\~ Fé£<§c QRL\KLQ, ~£r\ ei\_>\>¥\c_m\&‘§ \K.c>“\. Qo%\# §§_B\LLQ.‘<`\@<\ \S§€\\< §§ \é\c>\>¢,a§ wC©Q% `”RQ_C£<@CQ, & e`<D©\L<LQ§s\‘< QQ,<AQQ,%X% ‘~_Q\cée "`<Q»\% Qm\`\ \Z<Q\% _MQ_§>_Q\ \9<¥\0§\\~:.5 \5"`9&¢»\.2._% Q<)Q_D><g ©<¢Qmo‘\\<c§@\b ¢/C ?Q,C\O?$ `19¢\ \\~0.‘<€~:\:3 5~»0.\ ¢>\ €\BL. %3<0}<¢.\»\2.\\>< `Er\ §\\% mm\<\ 92qu R(m& .
mt ~_~\@ jr€§ `€&lq.\x %>'<<£‘<¢E Q<J¢<\ 253 "\?~Q; M;,;{>\‘~Qm\\e -`\&b P<Qx\>\`\cnr\*<' ~v<<"z£ <.QQC'Q_ Qv`.w\©e.x\<§. ""\`%\Q’< \¥\X Qe,\`\¢§< %;_ QAQQ\"Q,>>,
QCGJM &.. Q QNLQOJ&L § Q>E<Q"\_Qk€ \,._Q.Q_v;$g@\\ ~S?. ' P?Q_@;mu¥ P<e %£. "T\§C&”§o. \*vzzo\< ~§{:\A. w\\¢<,\¢> \;><\°A~ Z.\c>\ {m. 3\¢% \Q ~<fo\.xi #Q;<J,»<jws w<o;s\:;
§`s‘@®
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.