Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Clinton Donald Johns v. William Stephens, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division

Clinton Donald Johns v. William Stephens, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided November 20, 2015

Clinton Donald Johns v. William Stephens, Director, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, Correctional Institutions Division

Opinion

FILED IN 'STCOURT OF APPEALS f_ ftV*c\ c£ W^Pr\fi "W AW HOUSTON. TEXAS W^ l^\s,\c'\f.\ c£ "\>*(v* fl\ \WsVfrf\ NOV 2 0 2015 CHRISTOPHER^,^ CLERK \kl¥vVTOW 90f^9MA?vfr Tfr VAKY\rV AcAeA \W™Wr V^amS8

To\f\\ rAVir^: \Slik3lisWi: (WA: d \W\s C.Qim\\j

^VAu^s, 0uAfc5it6c/if»ftg. iflu> •k.^kftio 4-LlV 4Ws £WfV W jnWidrion auer -rims appeal. is rliifl. hVilbiV (Mfl'p flrTfie bt jfle. fla-fie*..

Ort Hflr/^ ^OftK^app^/UI-Ry/? fatWThfMnthtl^ police repots aaA &4rU^ rg-Uv//}ft-\- Qtid<A££ -App^i</?n-f-P. 1^/1 w faabgas odkt ^ U\e, 167 -Ha "DivlrMe.-rfftii<4h9 JWrts ftomftii y^kif^ relief irAiyi tmmluhWij rtnd Illegal rffvfftftn-l- AT Ills

\V± WiiS tS^W'Al*^ AftA^l/mA.l /^WaIaVr 4W. difeii tesul-t- ftf x/afcl ju/Hginfl&ivh U\>n\$

\t£l» (jfl Kprtl llpilffl-.'nuft Lau.p1 issued an apinioA nffiprti^Tn^Vft^Jud^....,^^--.^.^^^^- by W\£. llLyHn "bis^fici CauA i&itiftoirir deAcrmmma, °if -r^e. \1U 4h bu-rricT CbuA in fact |f\&A suV^e-cfr~W(AW^\v<vsAicAvo<\ 6(\A sWiAl% T& aiij'uAaoig, Tfle £flsi.» Th£rg.Qf£ NJ6 miAs and em/W/ tn 4"h& rtcbrd sWumoq 4Wi& \Ww\$ u>a> v»\a4e.% Tlv/dWe^tn^ tokAb fo Lsitict £.r>nf4 fi/>JbgA t^ttiiftiA jSukajkeirjfHaM^g uiria/iift-HiNtt \t\.enr)n &tJfaeS£ gfiiitefl.

te£_

\& M6\A ?) J

o\isV\ \waoA v^QA f.tt<t\wv\WeA SckeW&tf ^cye. ^syr^pse. 6\ flWewoWv^ \& procure, sub- TrcvuA mas^uAWtfeA Wife, CcaiA's 6p\mpr\ mSkWogAe mbCpjme^WtteA moxA JuAynfofrfe- l\ppe\\a<\V sV&\e£ ftflftMX \V\q\ V&\ft\ fta^gjcAr \^Wy«^ CASfcAa^, . \M\V\ <vp*or be. OjinA gtxf^iA W %(nq\ jS We. (Leu A Xoc.WA SQ^\gjcv\ -ffyqWf^^uvvs-

Cci(\ <mA AiiftV^y AS Vtr>q\- p&<s,V /yvr>MveJE\BOS vi \W.^uAo^pote genderA V>\i \V>e^ VMfA ^t&Vr\'gA r^vA.<V Q.oA \\t\g, QSXVftywiV^ rs^yf\v^A bX WW d&u«>\ U^e*^ Cf\\f^_V \|QV<\- H^pf»UAr>V t<\ ca\<3>v<v^ W>vq> \^^>u£, ar>A rr\f> <>dV W. prg.c\uAgA ^rom A&\c\^ ^t>.

SAL CvAl/> 4dftr^4r^ hb\A -f^fl-t" steady QS /l nj>n\pr><*(\\: oft ^iKj'gd--tY^grjucisA\rAit>n)pr4r\ ncfr t>fc \jJ£Hue/{ ir\ -^is tasp Ar a/w a-fW fllsg. /?n/j may he. cvuse/1 w 4-Ug. ws-i- 4nm^_ ftn appeaJ by -Wpp pflc4lM fir ky-U)P &&dvjLLl£*as EmpUymgrvl- f/smm'ft \j. Xfyfrfrnfl-horml Llniftn rif f jgr.j ftft/JlftftfvJ MAdfl.W6rkgys,Uc./ll Uman No. 183 , [{/.STp*. (35" A<T3 S^\.&A 35a,&T^ Cw/XSakjegj fnf,fkr juasAichofr <S an tssue tiici nruy be CAiaeJi tq^ -Wit Tir.sl Time. ftA Appeal/ iVfflfly^.ki uWmrAky-Hip patAigsJi Sgg /?Uft RfSUTg^.KlT^eA^t>)ftr«TUtyirHrilK fill, &on»*ier\t £ G«iaa).ld. ^_ ByopeiWfc lhas tyus ri^lnV /esinW i»4 Ihe. peiri^&A tW uMJt o£ Uctas corpus sgekudg Sfelttf ^ri)tA •Hx^&f- V/fa\A ^uAa^aV Qg, \Vg fe/LP>cA W\A\ ftV\ma iQQclWA ff sbAdS T^/il.'Hftk l^m4 ^mro'i-rl^ll /i4urvAQ.w\^f\\a|^y^f |^lv./x if re/vie ftp'tft<r>r> afflr/niAg 4iy V/m/A jud^rmrti of 4lr)P_ \1L 46 *hkfade4 £aa<4: This ^oiirf dt/Ji yipf i-ftflutV/. dr>/4 frm*^ -fUe, ite/ior/1 aa<\ (AeAzdHMne. tak&AtC stihitsJt -MA^tor^\ueisA\cAt*/\ WGS

/if^ifiyii^ -Hog. Opi/4 ju^ivkfa!" afi'kg. iQL4i\ 7^i^fr^4 ^au«4 rTtM<; tlauftfr A\A ryvV injury. <Lt\A

UiSif&ni: AhToiAss'o o? bus. V.Tex. K\c CbrvVrsl fcA, ^pr&AKdn c>f*pian \s%ixfcA id a cn&e

Se^ E4W vj.Vv\o^-V,A(o% U.S. 1^,151,10*4 S^^B^Sj^AM*^ LJ^LlA 55(,-(.W^.TgxQa

2>£L> WrtWifr V>inAvix$ %e, pa.Aves.XA.)

vV>iW«>\W-<gfftCf\ oS^cm^i^eiy arA fwrKvVusweAy aWsvAS 4WA frW CL6u<4 rg.rsAg-f^3 frV>< ra rycA«»A A<^ •Va(NAoLHv>c\froA.) 5a/L also NlLJ V//»fIc Iinde.ft.Aflift's C.Q. V. S^g^Tl,, 333 S.L\.^j( Uift<^4y>fl-f laak a4? AppallA^ju<i^>H'r>A *a fWiflroeax-al grrnc n»\ii^a In^rau.w infrgriYte/ii/iiy. flourf I/ft»kMyirt«i\cfr'»ftft. \K)tHv iumAygfrvcvviy *WftSo<4 Tu^Aa- •tdc cxicx* u>'i^r>&u.\ ca^Avx^-v^ a, <y o\<? ca> \e>< Wfon ex<-o \9 -Woe cfto^ \?> oc& ftfese/v/eAJ

m<H^A AW^/>£\\VwV UiftSVyllA ii^AVifrW. V*v\A gpuAlASl V\\"^v&V\'<l>V Cf^A <£ lU*vtS csW>\a ,AWm\c^ AW frWAvcvy qcnA r^^&^r esi\&*s\Cf, ^eAvrvpjA AW ^vic\^A\cA^a\ iflfiyry -VVyA frW SenWrAr^ (*ft^\ eR \W, Wlg&^\sW.A(W<A- ^ Wa<y\«x CWvAy <\MpA vaMWA SuV^^-tM^r j^<v*Aiickvofv f\(\A ^WA^vaiva f\oA g^V/^WWA AW-f^f- ^<nr\e^uy^i/f>iA ^u^yxmfrs To iaWcVa AV>\<; £y<^V C&ix<\ A t^ypeids g\\\<vyy-a ^\r> &hse,f>r.l CX\ \ W U\iAy.^Kr»fAv|\&\ftDn e£AYvl V^lfrWfrv^AncA tou<\ C&waiSreA ^ur>Aarr>eriVo\ €{ QC\A aWs^oH Aft-V-fcWo V>^ x^ofr VftbW^-VpfrW yoWAvr^s $\ kppe.yA&.^Vs VyfJoeas claims "W AeAe^Xtt\cviV&fs c£\ftr**ui<u>Ai> *&£ " sJc^OLh <vsa.^c<?.^ A^A SXVsV Vj^'vVVx Yc%pgr3 Ao-Wc VuA^vpAs- xW^vvA^ft. svm^Vvj ^g^vxwfcA Vy\rxV VW ^M^re^y \j.^i^\{<ng\ aoA ^c»V ^v^ \1U*V> S\X£>ACu\Co>Av<\%. VVw^ Cj>>uj\ AvA A^(\€,\lgy^ fit^tf^. VWsa. ^v\n(\/^ ^W-rsp\(N\r>A<ft^ \\&.^V<> ^AAc^\gj>\<^ v^^fg-V\t\o\ V->Qsg^V orv'A!s opvmor^ ^tU^fi^vj^n u\ V^^^ , A£U IVAS bpvnvLvrA \x>&% tss udA K( Ilits £Wj fx)& Ttuiei^ teas & \b se/. rP Apoellfinfs hfilagfi-s clow> raises -M& (Ssusg df suiajpxf m*^ jurrsrficl/ft^, U 4 i A £53ifa T^sfrn.,1 IW Altai Kfaf cu\a GhiAicd. lis

This LWi" rifls akx tigW&nfr Ajjy Ifr teuieu) 4le- /£g£di (jphg/Q jviMsdiif.frio^lI issues &r£<uU&LThd CpuA rvxu&fr frlxaik w&k^^/ippeJlflAt's pdMij>a and c^^^cuc it trx ^ppglUrAfr's W/q^ Ceo>e.u^ -H\e. rta><d. C&\\\<vVi^arA fro Agfr^Mn^g tr Am.{ &naWK£ ftupjysffrg frKg--^ar-frs, sAle^p/j bu kp^-HgioA. TSll \J_ SUfrg. ^W,<^\ P)lAl afA'Jf"^Co-,

04 voWfcV> kpp&i\&nY ts> he\c^ \\\e$&\Ay &^A^Wv.ft\>A\\| {efrWxniA act v/biA AvxcVo Vack o\ SuV^qfllr >m<-iVtfjir VAj^UAycAtg.A 6r q \iyb\nVvr»rN <W*-<•_(>*v^p. ^ V6LafrV\fifr Ap-yp^vj^

^^pp\V&.rvV Wg> ypcDMvA^ SvA^vcyfioV ^rt>c& Vo cneAfr Cjon^AlXoAxfrO &£ Ws> cA&\ms. ep\'A\g W«nV&^£\ve^."\W^Vf*r»AACc\ c£ x?<ht&VS Wj a ypo(>,f\.A*s-woofc oQAW-£^iAa-{\cg-.

KxyXWA Ws. tf\g_V Wvv^ WvcApxn r£ xpcr^ ft^frVy (£Ci>>cA uS\X\ Qyx\yrt\&Wie,\N| &6jAQ*&~ ArnAg- XC\ <e.K\\e\Z> •<&, t^>A\dfW xpgVAtr>f\^ArAmc\Vr?T'g^u<> OrsA V^vln ^.i^^VTV^id-

_^ftpg\\p.(A S>VcA&s frWA AW> CLkuA W^i/x^AvcAxkn "Vcs yA.y\\ \V\i &li&£ fxautsfrM

SoP lo WUL\\u^^ >^ppp_\\fl(\fr frffii^ -iWfr Uxis Laik4 i.\M\ ac.fr in its ntV^diS/^pi^Vkru, (niiibfr^Qai CAp&cifry and : SEAUf.ia tlfyg- ejt\V\<t <e.tb<& OJ\d, woki. aV\rvW% AWfr ^-jiiifla)Mfervfri4ce. uoirl W acV rf siJpj€gA^>nafrVg<-jun^A^iioKs; a. feratx'V'H^ r<J<cj ^ucsfrgd in KppelUnVs habeas e^puaJ A- Aov ?,VA.cAf\ cyfA Viv<^cW* <y\\A as\\{\&.c\flkvA.c<^ t&\W f<ivA_y_ cv\fs.vj rimurg..

VX%^

Xv^y^cyycjA

C.e.A'yVco,^ cR % ejc'Myc.g, T W<e\a^ Gg.cV^vj \WA CL V<vvg_ <VO>A (LcCtegfr CfNyOvj ^^W^brgflpie^ \M\tHrft

2>0\ ^cvjt\OXf\ ^y-t£e\ VA&va.^ct><v^g^ c^ Tlftc^- ar^to U z

&p^u**^\;ve*** wo*" ^ppe.XXo^ivX-

/* tff LP ?^e S 3, a

'A I (A

G> x o

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.