Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Morgan, Larry Joe

Morgan, Larry Joe
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided December 4, 2015

Morgan, Larry Joe

Opinion

= VS¢ ~rr~@c+ NG 6- 3%~ 010 113)~ 17\¢/‘?3<=15‘ A Wf<-<s‘s 611-cm <33(@2;/0’2. m ‘T"HE.-. 6OURT OF c;mmmAL APPEAL.S OF TE,XAS' AusTlN ibiv¢$low AN[> THE, 6%§&,@0 ,Q F APP&AL S Cou§TE)E,UMD|AL S?§A*?$R lc, T F 'FEXAS DEC 04 2015 AEEH>AMH ETQB LARKY ILEMKGAM \\ l l am Lcn~:~\/ T§c>e. morga~ amd' l QRBG|A§@§&MIF¢;A~+ ;N +'hfs gase,,l am over I£? years O~F age, a/v¢l 60m- pe.+em+ -Fo make 'Hdi$ a-F"Fi'clavi"+,"'l" have, Pe,rso~m| KNowle.cjge. eac +he., -F~Pnc,+$ iam ‘ans a-F-P:'Aavs'+” LARRY joe V’?ORGAN ST*ATE oF ‘T"e.xAs, IN PECOS COuNTY;TExA:; `0\ \O\¥?\\O\W\`O\.@\

v F”l"o¥v\ 'H/\e,' +;me, j was 'Fi)"§+ r`c|>'re,:; _';e,~‘_f€.d by m\/ +'r~’§o»| a++c>r`~a\/ S¢;o~H u)ulke,r` f iN-F`or‘w\e,d blm ‘F‘“hd+‘» l -F\m¢\ ac.'§'e,cl ;N SC~iF de-F`GNSE, i»pN -/'MS 605'€ mud +Lm+ l was ~l‘her~e¥~`sre_ No+ gur'|+.\/¢> l was No+~ '."Qware_ fi“l/\Q-l~ ;N order +o usa 'Hme. de.-Fewse. O-F 'Sc:l-F cla-Fe~se, l w'oulcl haw¢»_ +0 -l'e,s+i'F\/.. a-¢~ +L\e, gu°l\-\» \>L\ase. o-F W\\{ +'Va°o»\¢M'\/ Q+'+Ov~,\¢e.\{ Néiv€l‘ mmc\e. W\€. awmr‘€. O‘F 'H»\is CruCica/| ;N-FE`)s~mu-Homc l ‘~/*'Oi¢;\ m\/ CQuN.Se,/ mm Wal\<e.r~ *["Mcz,+ 'l »-~wci~~l*e¢;i ‘i"o +es-Pi'~["'\/; /Z`\F-F€m call o-F 'H/¢c.‘ S?Lm‘fe."$p_ wl'-»LN€SS€S karl +es'(*?w(`ie.d duval 7"¢»\1»:, S-fa+e. hc¢c{ I~~C.‘S;“F'€,c/l:./ |>€.|e,cxv€_., +/?16¢`/$ bu/’le.)v /'V)r‘ Wa/K€,Y~ amd 4/41$ iN\/€Sf€@a+or~, /"Yis 6»/~'/}17¢2_ Tom~ez. 6mv»e, 1‘~¢ m-e.

D.JI‘H»\ UPQ€N(,'\{ +0 No‘/ 'f'€s{=i-Fy» mr LLJQ[/C€,r`

A-FF£DAWT Foz- umw [email protected],~_ ' ¢>Me, c ` ’AFF\DA\/\_T 5 QSSUfed YYSE. 'Haa+ ‘H\`e_. +'r.§o\( wa&+ L,»\Je.ll as i KNE,W i+ _cjic) b~ec,mu;e, O~F all ‘H/\£ CON~ 'Fi ic'.‘\‘i¢\\g +es+ § `moNl'e.$ b\{ "Hn e. 5 ‘l*a 4'€'§ wi'¢'l\\©$.ses~ CouN$>e,.\ also ,+o\c\. vv\£, NO+ +o +es'['i -F\/ mud 'H" l c\`i¢\ l would \>e. pew/ug gusH'\,¢l 60\_\\¢§ @e,+~ up +¢> q"i \/e,m~s, bu+ l¥ l did ND+ +e§+l"-F\{ l will _b-e, d -F`ou~c§ No+ gUFl+§/¢ /77!~, walker (Neve;r~) +o|d ma he was +akimg 5'@,/-?

Ci(?,‘P€/.N$'€,, FbeCcLL)SC /’1‘€. KN€,uJ. l LUOU[C.\_ hO\\/f/ (N€,\/€,r`) agreed l<Now‘iNcJ `“Hw»‘\'.~ /7/7)‘ walker _KNe,w l' was fm C>E.D Classe; wh'\\e iN whdh mr\¢wa`;l(<€,r~ +ooi: ac§\\/H»Mag€_ O'F i'v\\/ lil'ji"€,r~mc.\fv _ LJPb'“ »[>“*-‘> 355 U/"C»l)vc.e, amd ON/y wll‘/'h /H'$"' `_'QSSUV‘a/vc',e_ / dual /\1<>+ ita /<€. “fl/\c. 5h1ch QN¢/ was Fow\¢c‘ quzl+\{@ H¢:¢c/ Ae, A/o?l“ /Du+ F€,a/r~ i/\/ . _‘W\\| h€,o~\~+,al>ou‘{' 'Hf\~e_' qci \/€,cu~$,cI/\/c{ wDUiA _;'\_CWC. +0\.¢1` W\.€., l/\e_» u_)a_$ ‘['o.|<img Sc./F clc-Fé,»/Se, C'F*F 'H»\v:.l ;‘['ogl>-|e_,/ wo§.)i`c| //m\/e. +ooli ‘H\€, 5‘['0~:} QS l hold +ol¢l W\\/ `i>¥~`o‘}l/»tx~$ iN C/'\NS+ back m ~['Me_ P.oci ';N ~H\~e_. [>r~oule.r~ C¢rc,lf;,/ ha\/»c:,,| a Swm~N `aF-Pf¢|a,\/Y‘/‘ o-F' -Hm:l' F`ac.+ i.,ul-H/\ a Nuw\l>e,r _' 010 S,rg~ok¥uv~€.$ ¢L/QJ /w:. gave me ‘{'lAa Nec:.e.,ssow\i I'N-Formm+{o~ '/ would have. 'l'es'l‘¢-F¢e,c/ 'i“o er_| é,'v':c,~f$ o-F -/-h¢+ af-F¢r~/§:oo;\¢ /'N -H»¢e.

So.rv\€.~` Mo'LNNeJ/`\ {H,‘H/m_+ _l zli’cl' .dur‘l)/\lc_§ m\{ PL)NIS‘ F\w\e,)u+ [Dl/»o»se. ci-'/? +'l~ia_,| as v¥c.cor`cle.d //u +A-c.

/&T'?'F¢Ja',vl+ Ppr Lar‘r~\/< W\'Or`gc~.~'~ ' ` t P“S%j» _AFF! D'P\V l_|" +'r‘io\\ i`€_c_or‘c,l~. lt _ l v 'Ti`/\e.v\e_ LU-€,f‘é. QH. C,'cxl\.€¢¥‘$ _O~F 'H»\f, €\/CN+S GF 'Hac_ ap+cr‘mob~¢ i ke,ar~¢]. Sav~€,wa\,\ dallsl<bu+) C\M€, S+uc,[< Qu'é' amorf_ ~H/\a~ +L\e_. G+kc_.,r~.§ H` was Vcr\\ las¥ adl\'e,v~ c)~ -H/\e, 6D~R0'm ~l'l/\.¢;Jr H»c.

CO\JNSC,\ [>lo;\{ ad, W\\1 610¢)~£¢1 h/l‘r~..buoL/l<;er~e i ‘C%uo~l'c_ 'HL¢: ‘O¢\q SLN_ descm'l>ccl miami -={'*1/1+:. assa- Ha.N+ was wmrs':yg ;\us+ as wall gas wha.,+ l L~.ue;v~€. u_)_ea,r~x')\\cj, Skj¢. Sa\`cl f wm§ E~e./N `cx‘\'+wc,k'e¢\ 'a~¢l +L\\e.-_`N SL\e. Scdcl I€.+ l/\e,\~ QQ.~{" around 'H/\\':.

610r~e.r‘ 50 'H/\c.\{ cou\»'i _<.c;c. vv\<..Tha-l-'s whom W\ 60u~$€,\ '{'m~)~\e,¢:\ L~" c>+"F.,l Nee.c,'{ -{'a wake +k:s pa\~‘i' \/cr‘j Cle,ow 'HM:. -FOFW\GL+ o-F +l/)E CD¢ROW\ was ‘H\-e. las+ Ca,\\ev~ was -Pu'v\s-F amd 30 0/\1 LAJ'€.\\ ‘H'\£_ lc¢,.s+ cal‘\'£.v‘ ON ‘{"L\~E. CD'ROW\ u./CLS ‘H/\g_ assaila~"'{"$ q;\-l»/ -Fr~cJ~LN¢|, ww'c.@\. W\afes her a l'\/e.v~ beaa¢_use. ~Slae_ _$o;:¢l She. was .)c)s+ LBQ:H" ;NS '{*|M:.rc -F'r~ow\. \Lum~l<,(i:u‘\“>$l'\€_' +§$+i¥?;d ibm +Y‘f&,q ‘H/\o.,~+ 51/\€_ was Sa-J--I~/'NS Né,x+ qLo +AL USSaIlaN+ wl/\.€_~ [ cavv\~c_ aN;l 60+ him wl"H/» /M'S leg C,(\os$,/-/ow€.ve.r? ~Hw's 1'§ Ajo+ +AL caller l ’l:)e€_~' SPQ.&L{NB 'QF 'H/\'e.s'e, /a.s'/ "Hv'o \/¢3¢1¥1`5,l +1/\£.6`.06{\€,\~ l FULW\ SF.-c.o¢l’_l')urj 016 l'S ‘H/L£. /d$‘{' Cal\\~e_vl~ P\o»\{é.c£; QN ~FL€,'C.D?"KOW\ LILW'I'N@ +ri'a,[, Tf/»i; comm may wm I<NMN mm gsu+) sat did No-l' know Me_,(lbu‘i') l/\'~eqr~ C.C¢_ll u_)a§ FZ\\/m~- a,/>{€_ +o` me;.l¥/ac{_ COuNSé_/ /'c/e.~‘l('i""f`/'€,cj' 4/)€/7"

AFFida»v'c-f ‘F<>v` LCW"\¢ zWL°f`B?~N l ‘P"”'F)e' 3 A~F.F'\`D'Av `\T F`r~ow\ her pho~c. Number~,a~c] law+crvfe.wed hcr~. mud 5-‘\_){>{>06~01@6 'I/)cv\, 5)'\6 wou|`cl""have, ampi¢'?\"ed id'<c’r S+a-/-cmcm+S C>/v'-/'/qc CaI/'/'{Cr` /;I€,sc;r"\t>-HDNS was 'Hme_ 6\/6~+3 as ‘H-»c,\{ bue/ft +o\l<i~@ P|a<;\;y mud waS' also 60~/"'/‘0¢/~\/")‘0 ‘fhc: S+"a+'r;‘$ wa'+Ne,sscS.

C.ou~$c-:.l hac/ 'Four~ addeg+;o~o\l _CL§*KO/'fl$ a+ lms dcs\do§ml, (I Sau.) +he,m’) w/')~€,N /)6 501+ 'H')cm am 'Hn:_ -i~o.L>le. ia€,¥~`orc mca i lbe,i¢’c,vc'h< haul evcr\/ lp/\z+e,~'}~i'o~ +0 Pia.\/ +é\cm Cbu+),+`{or~ SOh/\t; odd .F6cxso/\1 /\6 cjfld NO'/‘., / Ec>_/fevc_. NO+' _Pia\ll'~@ +/m; G¢IJH'/'o~o./ C/_'d--/ZC)VMS -wa$ QNC>+» H¢Jr` carre/versus d-e.ais/'o/Q¢ _‘,Al>\>lfc,m»\.+, +0{¢1 60UN$6/ w/>'»'e,/v"/?)c was a++q_c.(<c;d F>\' 'H@\€_‘ assaila…‘\'$ i'+""`was be+wee~ 3:“/§_‘5»1»\ amd L/“‘/S va\, “l'l/\Cr€,por`c,, i‘/". w6r6 S+r‘aNg'e.' u.)/'\£-N / was Y`6Vlv6c] {b\| I/Vl6cl5‘fa».r‘ O.+ +l/\c,' 6,7`:vv\€. 566/wi l‘{' wOLS cj_L)$'{“ défk VM¢a~/N 4 l'/' was aldeu‘(" ?}~IS" '>vv\@/N Augu$'/' i‘l' 36+2 cla__v~\`l< abou+ OI?O©PW\ 50 176 / L,uca,s l<~<>c,l<c;¢l 'L)N_¢_a:vS;/ous 701+ as _/01+6 as .§“'.“'L>O,Pm hours ,cn_\z¢l L{S"` l(\/\¢"NU+€.S 495 lJ/V&66ouM-f'aéle 'FOY`, l +0\¢1 ‘HM'S ‘{'0_ fou~$e`// /'N (§USQN L//>a)\/ GUY" \Oi,r\-$+' vVV\\‘_’.€.'l~/)\)S,j ,a/\/£/ 613 .\`/ob dw.'¢"l’l' S‘€.€. f mc'~*{'i'oa\¢s 136 wig/v ‘H\€, a+-l~a(,¢\`€,c/" 4/'6++6¢5,

H.FF)<i_m/l+. F'of‘- é-GM\¢ MO"“¢.)@~ ' _ PQ€§»<'>'L¢ AFP}DAVIT ' _F'U'f`+h_€l`,( la'/'$ lab Pr_~o bal>iia"f'y_ ‘)‘_'}`n:=,__A Fi'vc, 613- R_Cm 5 _u.)n°ll- Soi_\/€_ +l/\£,` loss O'F‘ 3 hours v amd ‘~lS" m¢°»g +uc_s -F`or~ +he appl{ca~#, am ¢{’ -H’\c. 'COL,/r+@ H"§» a Fac_'l"= "H?\e',' S€,c,©~c/ 'ffi'w\£ '/ `was S')"'a- />[><gd l was U/\¢co~$c./Ouso/`?L 1"5‘ a/$o a fac;_+ / SQLL._: '/"/16 60N\F\afua/u+' _|`>looc\ ON Vv`\y S/')ae.‘f" rock KN¢"FG, ‘F_`r`<:>vv_\ cle.-F€.~¢(s“~g i/V\Y.S¢:/'F" ,'F;~c>m lsc- i's\z@ S+ovv\}>,e¢l haa\):'/\/ Q-F-Fe,r~ he. KNo;k€_d m€,_ +Q_ H\@, @mw~c:l. ' A@&i'~ +he.se. C/.d'/€CM discs /)ou;e,s forman l+a~l'@'(>\e, ldN'F?:>r~M'a'Hor\/, +o l<e.'c-=_/> ~H.em_ will />6_ v gre.<zb+ i'N'-"{_?\us-H'c.e,' /'76 ~H»e.y 'ozr~e_. mo UNC)o/v6c,a.,/Ed» Wl\/ 4'£0¢_)~_<_.6( i/V)/~, S, walkcr\ 4<;;16\/61,\/> 616/1'\/,67"6¢{ my £//lc’;/\l'f ‘F/l/€S 7¢0 W\€_,»'?£¢)€,r€,-/`or\£_, mm LLJOL//C'cr` |'S LDN+INL)/Ng +o iivva/>e.cl M\/ case/1 accord- ;NB +.o -H1e._ T6xas 7/3‘om~¢/ 010 /§)Jsc/'/D_//'/vqry i"L)IP_' /'§/‘-/ .Sa-Fc. lCe¢e./>/)/v€) />l_io/De..r"/`Y C/d'),/')?m‘[l_)MOL//(€.J` ShoU/d' hav€. 6/€.//'»'6¥‘66[ 1446 //Vly C'//eN'/ F}°/e.f _,DPQM f`€.,c:\uc.S‘/".. F'L/r~‘lL//n©r~h’)or`€,v,…/ howe docp`MeN+' 0);+)'0~`,‘/‘¢'\¢1+' Saz'd /16 has 'lé>/_ l'+€,w\$ ., / have ,matrle,¢{ l’V)r~, LAJGL|IC€.`r~ Num-e.r~ous `o-F’ he ues+ -For~i my"é//'€,N+ 'Fi/c 5 a/vc/ / `have go+~_f@')\~/(/`\“/o re..>_i\/D; AGM'N 'H'u'$ C?// C¢:¢//€'/~ / ’$/_)e§a,'k| 016 was 6 i"cpre.$a/v-H'Ng Ha_a'{" /" was 156/mg af'+¢ac/:‘e,d» 4 LUUN_§¢:',/' -Fe¢l"/e.c/ 'f'e /c[e,/v"/~i’F\/,a/v¢/ /'~ve,$+‘/dga‘{'e,

1/ML*F/dccw-z" few `¢*“""`Y”"°'"S“N w n ’°“9"' 3d HFFI'DAV)T had 'H\o's Cm/v~c>+ he coN.s'MeJ~ed $ouNd ~H~i'al S'H`OH'€_gy`¢ 556 "he;lcl ‘F`éu¢u“~m\ iNFor~md+s°oN dz'§£io$- i'Ng l was ;N F'ac_+ 1365le cu+"l-clc;[<e,¢] bY ‘H)€;.

S`i'a+r:'$ C['H'Cp COm/>fal'~or", who iia-N+ ;”N HM°$ ma+-l'€,r~. \\ l wa$ +hc assa- l am umal>|e, '_+o @l>~iai~ iis-l~e/v'~f'o Or~ crea-¢~c` m {"raMScriP+' 06 +W$ Calfev~ wz‘{*l.mu+ +Me.de's-’ closure o-F +hc; +ria_| 'f~€.(>m~+er~ v\e,¢;or‘ds, 'H/\<;v~c» 'For~a. f cum ls~e.a”~c$ l°v'v/\P€=»¢'le.d' ‘i'c> cia ca W\€.'c.a.)\i,a')\e§¥`un M»OT, wv~i`+ 016 Hal>ms 60¢‘>\.»3¢” \\ _ , ` . r- l 7"1£»\¢6 P\‘e$e.m +'6¢1 W\cz.'('€,r~\awl ‘F_mc_,~(’$ ~‘HAQ.+ 15 S-HH UNr~e.$ol\/e,,¢|, am¢l irs ma’sre.,>'r€,$e~{~e,d [:»\/ T`r{a,\ Cour\l$als as -H\e, 1'5$ue.5 CQW)/>Iai'~e,d O-F, ‘Tr~a'c»\,\ C@u~ Se,/.s penalch -/'o l'N_\/es~f~/'ga'h© C<ll +-A€, ’?II 6;QHS 5';>6<;{@!1\/ 'l‘he. ome. me.~‘['~c'o~ /'/v i/\/)\/ i'Vio'HoN "'i*o cc{>\/cwvc;e, vv\\/ H,O`V amd /)e,_r~c.i')~/ VfA'/'S a~FPL"do»\/l°+@' .wl»\a°c. h is Cruc¢'a// 140 _~H)c c/e.f`e)v5’6 0'~6 56/16"¢{€.7€`@~$@. amd "a/se a d('_<. 1'~ "{"er€s+€a/ +¢\wvd chr~+\/ ,” "Hacl -mn,wa//<e,r\ /;.s-f@~c»;¢l a/u¢/ u/uc,/c,r~$-»£oaél mc. a'_~ m\/ clas<:.m'/.>Ho~ of H.e. avenva ha woulc/. hmv'c. kNow~ '7%6 60+ '0~ '/'Ae, Com/>./a¢'ua~f‘:$ ,._/e_g was cause,¢/ by ‘f/?ze 60)14/0/@,"~¢4~7£ S¢om/;>-` 65va mr;, -/"L»£ //)'6€// 076 __h/'s 160<>1" werc, OLISO ?N:\we.d, i haul No »f¢].e-,¢L -H/\e_ assailm~+s -wa_s rmi/ug -I'-c>" a++ac_{< VV\LQ(T/}\e,\{ ha,c] /\1<>v ‘Y‘€.a,§o~ +o)@ liFFodqvl-f' For Lar.~r‘\{ W\or‘gvs~ p€l&'-)€» 6 AFF~`:DAV!T .F~`Ur~ll\¢;r~, lF ‘l~le assallcw+ ~l~olJ /-Hne, Pola'c.e',; l UUa§ c;l#»as,l~g him Q.S l'\e. cll'cl, l would z chALl +o. ldc a ,rco\\l\[ Frlq.s+ Fu~~e,r~ 'lio cu'l" ON 'H’w_ lm$i`de_ o-F h?s /€.g , as /'1~:_ +o/c/ -/'/16 polic;,e,. _l:'ur‘l‘l/\er~, l +al¢l Vv\\, 60¢_))\/5‘€,/ / have. “l*uue. Plc.vl'€,s , a)\lcl l`S' Sc_'r~e,\_,us i'N vv\\, f\l'g h+ le.<_:}‘ l‘l~$ ilvv\l>o">%i'l>l-e__ for ma +o rum ~Fds‘l‘, W\\l il Y€,av`s O`lcl clau¢I‘l'l'\e,Y~ dam C§L.){' r`UN W\~€_¢ A§alm ills haw¢l `+a ¢l-e_cl|>k¢,w 601_//\:56/ ransom -Fm~ -l'-`o.'\luv-c. O-F:, Sul>lzoc~a_fmé +L\e. avrt.§'l'l'~g O-F-Ff`¢cm Couwse_l 'Fcu'le,cl ~l'o qlv¢ b\l$ Cllie,lv{' am C*)Ppc)l~'l'um- l‘l‘\/ ‘l`o Show ll>ky§s'£a( €.vf-cle.~c;ls ld\{ No‘l" doi~`cj / DNA -l~es+a'~c_:sa F'ur~'l"kev~, W\r~, S@lmzar Sfa+eme./v+ z/v m\' lbON cl i`C.cluC‘l"lON l'\£O\Y`l'NCB LaJ(LS CVUCl'Wl +O W\\‘ Cl-€,F€~$c. o-P SCI-F“cle,-FCN:»€.¢ l/\\Closim_c, all -H»\e. Fa<.-l's l/\e.r~e.~e'~ awcl /N m»\/ WLO'l"n'n/\/ "l’O ab\'a~c,€ m\[ ll»G`l Shou_)fs C/£a..r~l\{ Cou~$€.l:s' . C.N`ON€,ouS' P€.r"l"c§r~rv\¢a'mc,e., and C/Mr‘/\/ $/IGW.S i'N- CF-pecl'lvc assl$'la~c;c, 076 600~56/,02/\46/ +0 add 'l*o ,l~l* 6`00,\/$@./5 i'n/\Pe_¢l/ivzj w\/ appeals b\{ No-l' cl-e.l-» lvc.r~l~@ me. mg clz"e.~¢~ F:’les as rec%ues'l'e.cl Sc;x“ m¢…\/ ~la'w\e_s@_l'lm'; fs ~¢+ acile o-l:’ rmso~ablmess i“l">' §§l;o‘l'a§e_,,a~<l SAoulcl l>C de,.Q.l‘l’ wl-lk‘cis Spc_b\¢`B\{ vv\¢:, b-e.i’~g a'l+o.c,l:ecl lo\' 'l'l\e ‘l'lw¢e§_ l>er~ P€+Fm+aw$‘:'+[/\L Covv\':laa')vo\klof` ‘Fl'¥‘$‘l' lD€,cL‘l’ YV\!.°, c)N '-l'c".\/> W\‘\/ l’\e.a\,d u.)¢‘l'l/x l/`al$ 'Fl'$‘l' Caufi/Nj S`e.ve.r; l:l¢:e.¢llwg 676 'H/'a 76`/‘0)\1% par~{i'o)\/ c)-l-` Vv\\/ l»ve,,o»¢l a-F-fe.r~_wa»zl Sfal>é.ilw::j befor~c_ l<`/'\,@;,l;'~

AFFIDAV¢T poll (_ar~r~\/. Morga~ - PQS€,.`I " FlFl:lQA\/-lT lNg rhe_ L/l\-Jc.om_‘$c,lou$ l:\i 'H/;_c. 'l'lal'rA P6r~50wf‘l'l#ls' l>l<>u_)“ was l~ ‘l'l/\c_. l>o\c,l( o-F m\i Hco,cl L¢_)l/\llt ‘l~L~e_ O-l'b\e.v~ P€ml>€_+r~o\;fc>r» waS liee.Pf/\¢§ mc Eu$\\ S'l'cLBl>l-NC§~ ci'l' VV\€:.` 'l"l`o‘vv\ °'l”l/\~C. 'l:"l"ON`l'¢TlAl$ 6¢1,»»$';~5 `vv\e,, ~l“v howe <;l'l\r¢e_ macl'$ 5 Sl~aple$, QNcl 5+1'+6[,16$ apl~€,r~wa_r~€l$/ “l‘l\c.` hold +O[b h {b<y\r~_‘l"{ON vc:»-F m\( lwm..cl was oNc:_ blg`$c.a$.)¢ `\NQL`J l l'\av6 S_.l/\o'r`l` 'l~e.rw\_ VV\C,w\.O'P\( lOS'l‘ A\'"l”l'\rl‘l"lS llN ‘l*l/H_’__ /}xcu~lcls l //\~6.lcl L)P 'lc'l"\ll’/vzj 'l'cd gle,l-’¢,Nr.( m\{Se,I'F@/chl -l`~he_ /;se,r~[oa+r\a_+or~.c is ioi<">$€, ‘Fr¢;€_ +o ccl"lac.l< Sow\c_o~e_ 6/$€_, l am f\c. ue,S'H/\zg appom~l'w\f_~'l‘ 016 fou~$e,/ /'N ‘l’l\e_ [N~l'c:r~e,s'l o‘F §`us‘l~n'c;e_@/l@al~ m\l acrl'ua_l I`C.ltC,'F l§ gram‘l`¢~€‘j w\\/ IlO`7 ga ‘/’/4&‘/' _lu$+l'a& 7 wall l>e, .Sc;vvc,¢l l/V\\/ Sec.o~¢l form o-F relief llS “l'c) €r*cwu'l' V\/\\j Al:.Ya/vc,€_,a/vc/ a/{Ou._l m€_ ‘l”l'\£. T¢>c>l$, uul\\'c,l\ ls V\/\\{ Tm"a_l r‘€_c,oy‘cls' as _.l`€.chue,$+c_c.l 30 'l 60¢~ ala a meaN/'/\:£)]'-Fbl ll»O? iN ‘lL//»r; l~+e_rr_s~l~. o-F j'.-.J;‘l'¢"¢¢:_¢ vinth Cc:n\.l£/LJC/€_ l/l/l\/ Q'F-plvcla\/l'+, VER{P`|CA'{`|GN - l ,L~Amc\’ time W)olz.r>h~ TD£S-/D# /5>"-1716_2_ [>€;i’g.~ prcse~+iy i~c,m~c;e,m,+e,¢l n+ james A Ly~augh uNH' o~F Tbc',§ declqrc_ UNcle,r\ Pe_~al‘f\/ o-F Per~$ur\[‘ ‘H\¢u'l' fha ror~€_.gou\a¢j Fac..+$ AM. ‘l`i~u€, am cl Corr‘€,c."l' cul~€,.l.&..a..`l_l.©l$:' qu? S HWY 1037 FT S‘FOC;KT`QN /X., 7973§`°

/}FF/:onv¢'l°' F`_o/< Lmuz\’ Mo/zc,n~ g Page, 9

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.