FREEMAN, WILLIAM HAYWARD Sr.
FREEMAN, WILLIAM HAYWARD Sr.
Opinion
Da'\'€‘. D€C@m\o£v \O,,ZOCS iv _\/\/`;\\`\QQ§SH md\:re,mai§)»§v. T.D.C.T»Q?W 1\)@: \m>ylz’ ' _ ¢_.NE¢\N §gl\m$§\/.\ @§\51`)/\15§: UJLF)h¢\)"T§' . C.OURT OF::ECCR“\/\\NAL APPEALS ., .‘ 0 ' . , .
L\V:NQSXOM,TE¥&% ”1"|55| , ms _ , v . _DE@_Z‘-\z .
R@;,_Qw§_@;\§@ \5;1.1;2§7-¢\ \/\BR~Szgm--©S , 4,54\1\€¢)1“: R-¢:wa\\aémuablwma,Fr@@mw,$r. _ ._ />\be\.»“\cos’t&\.,.C\erk .
C\_e K 'Hx ' - @@‘§Of::-§@§ CW O\¢ ‘*PP@‘~ »(AU%+.M,`Y'US mem D€>:a)r N\r. 'D\ae\ P\e,o§*\'a, T. \"'@|C`\C\_)@QL \¥:ur Lmld, S+a+} q»\*na+ ` ou, hai Y€C`zeve<) vf\/\ app\'\czd’ioru r \\.O'l \¢)\~`¢+D \-\ab €SS rj>ue 010 11/30 /;1015‘, bu+ qOUL A`.JM s+a#e+%a+_q@u re<;`¢z,\)ed a\sc), ML\ ¥\ab.ea$ Q@rpu§ \\.0'1 `Supp\-em;u%:*\>,qou `c\,ic| Mo-f \"€,C\e»e `\+,`Lam %€wd'i/\Jq> qov\. a dup\{csfe dam O¥_ -W\e OM€+\\§.'\' 1 w~@`\\.'¥o -H'\€ HQ`Fr`§"("/OUM ®\lfs\'r\‘c~l- C\€s-{, _'\{\lv;v. C\\\:\€;x/!DN"¢¢B.'l-? ha d\cl._ 3@,\5(1 €, QQP;@S O{'. ~`\\4 _'e,~em,.» ~ ' M€W\WWKSJC\ 7 1_ P'e' ; gm Cw q<:+ »~ ` Sn\)oer@,lq , " MWJPWM _S_UQM x¢>_: \/\I 1\ \`\ém &\311 guard \;re€me#@,§m. \ 10@113 00133~€1~121> 533 13 1131 3111~' 10111?1 01 1311>1;1319 ' 11123"1 311011:131, 1319 911?13'1 01 3331/19 d ., 133 1101193©11 °“11>1139 ' - 111/1 L11131\/1 1/3§1/\1131\1) 111312_\1\/31\1 912 ppe\_\aw3, 319 ..
Y`Hi¥ STMT 013 TE)"\AS 1519’139.\1@
ON 131513&1131. 11"1201\/\ CAUSE 01132 561 11\1.`131§ 1921~19 13193"1<1€$1 C©MY 931 HARR § 1:201)1.)‘11"11:\119 111212131/111’1 g 11331»;1391:0121>11911019111>1211:111 111
\/1IILL1A1A 111\\’ 1\1'/11€\:> 112111\/\131\1 911 11)1,11 1310 1%7?§21’5 1201_1,)\191<1 1)1111 32721:1\/\ BS'O~SOUTH ,.
L1\f¥i\!691©1\1 1151- X¢\S 7736‘ ' 1212 0/93 '
.1_»»\¢~
*.'r
ff '?i
,1..~`4.,,_\.\.....,,__
......
4 333/1 353qu \NQ~?'L 3§\1€1=1453_>§$~46/\1€€ C)11141 500/051 ¢§" \5,§€”4 1. 533 84 13141 ;-§>3€>5€3.574@5¢ 3;5;5+ +L»e_ @/é 1 1' 1513 ¢“4»3435)5\¢9 Q\¢¢M)B.~. _ `?"5~@4&@4,»1»€» CQu/u%el 1 .
O +4)(>4`§51\> 5)»%;)35)@ (3).
334 40 3\.'~3 54.».1)4 544€» " o" 54 z:).,<:;@mpam+a :¢'35"== 05:4»~15; a 31!4'125' ,) fec;<: 333 3{~+@3 t:‘:\)~{' 363th am <‘@M¢
41,.`&\"`£33“4¢`,; §1<:»¢\§!:4_1§ Zg) --¢.\4 §11§(0 CJIO1'JC4W)€!S*~4 '\/ 5+54@ 240 ‘»:>w:>d 505 N\@m 55 \~/,». 555 555 33 vs _ _ ~ ’33¢<3335>) 495/mv 555 v w 110 §" C:4‘ 474 277 \;_ g '1154‘4(_' H¢D ALC_G 7(3.4/ ‘33"»155¢1 553 333 53 1215_-,.%’3 3<;4;:.;1;0 d 331€¥4!‘"* 3 455 354 u;:_$ wm 531 543:3:732?"5¢'1:7 nw ¢»¢`c‘ 670 (¢ 513 " _ 5 v 335/535 413 w 37 353 330¢.»¢33 1515 23sz 9!
",..e .»
€<:\ 410 5‘1-.;2 349 470}(€4"1'//0¢;111?09:\3€3 qu//O\/ ‘;0.434;! 54.4:+€3 405 444 1545 100 04 34’2443 31'~13@14 €~J"° §§qu LSNC!€F§ ‘~f 3'¥€2+(’ §L§z`('p C:, 113 3¢\ (1_‘1§." (“()£ C-r.i'rv:) b",\AlY)D 2009739~<1'>"`~€91‘~1\/ 50441\)00:0 3553 113¢133,4(0+13 """Y:‘.~F; 00@35 §43¢»;` 44;-44-4 _\1 1003 ;~3,3‘103 1’1 ?<1%@ £'~\Q>,~’i 1\‘}0;1/».~4 4»<\1,4€, 03"?") 11 V("Zc?rw‘~'~$ 1113 F 503&'](¢{-+11£1\»"… 00¢3314.)..% VT0\)~04~07§<“1 3130’?0*='(€4+4~ g`)r ;0\3) ~ .4.~».~§.\€*3,»4@ 6404444~4440,\,, 333€3 40 334 4715 c,+,~q map v "5:\\§4.44`43 3304)03 1134 00¢4,’)3 34 \4'1:>14%4> /\401\3\1 03 ' 1403 414/400 `~1*"’ ;¥C’ €., 1153 v1:; “'4..:4“;4\¢44 404\_44_,€', 404 4r .E.'~)\ Q,GL):Q`,&\,@,41{4 \1\04;4~3 440:0£4 03 400 maeqd'c)t~ QC<“`~WS+ 430 003¢>»)¢:4:~40 ` 1004 ‘:"0\0400 5»$€4$,~..01@,0‘§‘0 0433)@.€. 02 '11~¢40333{, 04€><:4 0 \1404.;4 . 400 04~ 444_<~: 0300<;01.;;401‘ 343 04.\)54 +néz.'€» ~' ¥@Nriaw 1335 é\. xi:""`$@¥<'~¥ (W.,>‘§i~“ru‘§"©f\)i¥\ C£;§:m)<,§’" UJ€_{\€“ 530 §.L)§_§m{\ \,,1\§3)3? 14‘;)1\) 841 543\”0`(“ ’3 '1?1`3?#+¢\}€, 4,‘3£‘¢6~"’4 01 00 t'€u-.>‘¥' €€% U¢\_)rj€i¥* 311 U;‘$V *§":4&. @¢':T“L§h 851 4:§;)\~.> 3,`~;~”’§"14`£"4`"\3 413 l 4 ':.\\"\..431¢§4 64 "4’”0?&`; 591'"1`£741\)0 45 daqu 433 1033 §`4§€0~‘}' ¥“`“'§'L\€M~<"`!r" 1 ' ~'\*}“4€?..~ 4crm@q3.= 0404\44%1 4{04¢~ l 0\1{1.:0¢\!4 1>’~"‘\)"4' 000 <-_-i})` ;»'- ` 000+ 030‘§’€> 1904 5000 >':`D m \’004“0 3004'44\39 34 C:\aeam~% _\'3§\4,0;§3_4' 041;,44_4, 40541~ 0<4411<;€"1' 0 4704 4“00:4~4_@€ 0414444'~0§;\~<_,<€ "’i`}r\@ \mli\)q€\ 93 4 §"L.¢{a¥é, `C,l\\{"(“{ ~'11'¢__3‘) 4a Ur$(;"€"}§)'+ (:,C)f\/’\;E) §C-{w" e, ©b`:c,&`hm\)?§ ""1’\€0' ’14)43'~: \0\,04.1€.\' @u.)€-_€= 40 ar C\ 10 440» y C'_;i;;, 1303 535 &;1<:340$,,4 44\»& c:`lu‘l*¢€;$ 04 1040 PV'\)¢£"T§# 110\1€%'0~» qa:¥m ammech 1 '§_ 1033 demccl mg V\c 340 *'1"0 444€ €4~$4,;44\;0 &€4§»'- 45“1<51¢\3<2<’/ 554 Qouz\/:»e\ 333 ~4\"43: 44\\,404~314»401\1 034 040 1¢~11» . @+1\ &Nd 1004/4 34\\£04,\"[email protected])*}4 ’§_""3 41414»;.; O-(`-+'\(~?. L)"';> CU:\) "$‘4+444-1@411 ‘§'10<0 Tc=x.;>¢ D<>N..¢h 1"4)1¢~3~ 1‘\4~_+ \F;"*€ 433 1341 W\C_, *4*\“\“4\ ~ Co\.)&»+ <SBQLFQC 1144 01-»‘§";€2 1100) 4401\;441 0104,011)1*1<9 §pr\"€$,> 1\”\]_4.451\),_$!~)_¢44”'/\1€£211433<‘.1{\/\;;>04~\91@¢20< 4~<`.¥\¢\»\1»~}”`4-1.1\.) 5” -'
.§-`\'r;)»\rzG-‘~v"i'-Nq_~'é¥\`~\‘~-@-\l€
§~'\§N:i ` a"x'\¢-%-» w-N-.»M@,..;@-.K.~,% '~D~`\%A"r=}<;-; §\:)j_~'¥~o~q'_’~»'§§(i'~:¥e- ;;ha:ré;l‘$' h €_Yi?ifd 33¢1\“)°@“"' \¢¥~\'-"v&¢v§-e:~i-`-s-d_-»rd@""_ ' ' "\Z'\'_Q\"&"%":A“““"="%‘ , ‘ ,,_. pas$',,-.B;SG.Q_L-.)_.fé N@W.`¢..,\._,q:.! 35-;;).$£+05"=%@__\»3€ +` ' admzt%\)b§>oe/\)a..f\[\a \ “-\ ‘ :>_@.; <1 wf§f »a¢'~“~>i am F~)+h /"
db@€’_._»\.o.u;)._._.;,¢-___~,,-____,__.___
e,;.;§£;.;-T\q.g h-Li§.,§_€& a,u,$~¢. __§.' \;_»,» 3 d€£€;véa.wé§,_®ig:\&i1_d.¢_C!~Al.._/w ' 5 §§ :~‘<L\€;¢§z§('<`:f§e;»¢.cia,m?}:, c ' - ' ‘ . _ `( ms - l \/.'}'_Q‘i@.ér._e_s,;\g@:;>,co~_ccss.. ' .<?~.;~,:\_"_X)~£_g;m;~z§§:.!»';f@£_,l. 1.
c ,¥. éu+ +e ` "P" 9 V’\`L) S')f' SEWI`V€.) 33'L)“Hx :3:\)<.3 `BU-°>”H ‘1€, ";'U‘S+ 4#\€.`\‘¥" :){.B\o `l<; Mo~¥ 3b LQ}A/J lou+ 333 w'sri §§qu ins 5+<1¢\3/~.Jq w)~H/j)_';\) ~Hq€, W,`U\€... él:\l.<:l Mi;r\' 'Pu“¥‘r`¢¢\><:{ usc nwer 3 Co,\;ul`c~f/`@/v \§19@\/€_33»\€¢`¢' <~J’Hw}€e»& Ob!§c~&~Ho_/\l'.",lm order +0 uslw E_Nd ilwde qu" l+¢{ he ‘F€’:\u$e.»:y'% ~*?ull~c`\$\ -H'»e; orr_j¢-_=j~g q./'L/QN +¢1;?):4¢ 3 b ‘J\“\/] Q_ C@'JY'!L'S_, §'l'€ \`€3:1:)";‘)€(* 'I`O §OprE`/\/,? '#79§@ _(4:»,~'1¢,(./5$=__;/ LJ~,`,¢:L, 5%0@)¢:> ‘m», `\'=.~.'\:»Qf,w .C>QC.Y~@~i-er w gm v<;~.LP$ u\) " '~%}z¢ €,€!3@. 14_)€»§':’}) *\/§o\f£§€d 'rm_, ‘\_riq`¢¢»/s 30 a ~?.a§,~ +r;a,\_ ' 533 Q.-_-§`:£..._'i C;z_,<'§.*‘+~¥<®, 'f:;»`ss‘ ‘F». =Fs.<:.~‘ 3,;1"‘1 ”`¢441»_~» C_}r.._._:),.o ;>,_j Q¢H%.\/.
1\?_~_»£1_<;1_@`_')!9 11 236 '7@5'" ( /.D+»». <':'3,»¢. lezfz,)W a );~, r-C,Sé @M, r. §bé\_y\;?§@/\J.€LC{ "H’z€\\_r~ G`Dl;q€.l+cD/\l 310 §>€€\< L)S+¢\C€/jg,(\.\f;l -_Q'_oe ua'»@€§ ©M_ u.f\)c;»zzv~ i@apéed x\'\czl,§»,@<€§,~~j@ Uj,~/~\_; m -\}`(@\BLVW '@‘F p\Z)A 'M\O <*:@\ Ru\@g.%. . x 1 ’ . MH’\C"». D\'@:'>@CU+&Y‘ ¥'\3»5_3:4.1€ burnley O~,¥ 1gm;\/,,\}q~~~§~L,`.)e'_ d@*e@h'<l§¥¢¢+ v303 \3'1»1\,31\)3 bfi W\uS-}' do ~':>0 b prz>`\/`i:v<>,\ each @“3<3 "'3-'\} @§j‘¢,i Eé.§€v'»f.-Qfd*:"f;`)-(x: ~\s~iv\'@ Qi;`$¢'§/u§@, C \/\3. \`AQ d b@,'L @M_¢l 3..\"€3'50#)@\01'& C~{‘~®ob{j E~l:\rj 19 \'\'€ 333 (<3` 36 c{.o E,SQL{Q(L, m 1)%3~ '3£@,¢1/"7'" »+£~\<»; 39 *€r\'c`{@».`)-$r . ~ ~ c _ - _ , ` `V¥"~€ ,/;\L,-.¥ . ~&o Cm‘-re.c;/' i~”~;\,)o¢,u.~r£§)s~.€, €:\)\dr._=.,\)c.a \SNO~!- 39sz ? PY"@$Q c.\Hr-'?D/\:Ql @Ma,,\az,»+ a c-.@,U <¢-+;’+;»,)~'~:¢~;g,§}@,\ ""”{"'<»~"U" *"@F"'*€N')T}'~E»€e mo mix-ev \[. Ho\@ `L'\QMI, (,;~__c;¢,L US', wig §§ ~ 5'“(5*:3'¢0) 7“3& E': ‘?Ci`l(_a€\zs);&.‘.§o %»<-:.e 'p\{!<~: \L t&¢w,<@g) 357 ' \)1‘=`>~¢'1»‘3/ “’3 3~~<'»`~"-1*?§~,-€7<@~ 'E.¢§,,é¢`»\‘l» (S<H.;z); N<:c)r~%~a \/.TQ"»<@€, 35"'5>.'" L).`E§`. '~‘?'3, 733,<:1+. 1'::-5~', °1\. §,¢€`;..;j <"j (;<, g~¢,§ ;'_,',.dc{ M;~‘ HQ .¢ `(>é'+°"" 393 13 S' " 93 "=`°*C"*‘~ 'f"?§‘~, '."r L- Ec/ m <Q <'1‘0(¢%17). :~\~ , ' ' does N@+" !\\.'~H'+€¥` -L\)li\ €"H/\ E‘r -H\`_€-'_ Pry~@ S€C_`J+©r` C.:)C+USi , 1 K‘\k>u-’S M€’+"wa» E-\)_‘sc_|<:wc..e \<S. '5\~;'~).\5€, \\“‘c `\ 8 '@_N¢O U('?,}» ;`;\\a+ '!'\e Ghv_f;'~,ZL\_¢:~Sho_u.scf\'\'&¢\/€;K°RCOquze,-'H\_¢ m‘\g§€,_,_q C/;M., _Ma+u{e ' @`QMC">&V’°"€NC@"S@@ U ' S*MIUYS., .“~17 L)?:~>-Q.?, lowe %, c+_. g'-zq\l"~`;?`§q?"%'q L'" Ed'w' 5("!'2) 349 (36\7\0) (. °`\+`\`(\)'1 MO@M€'TQ$ '$D“.’ 1 ‘?"M‘@\.Q'..‘WWU\)€ gm C!€.SS 1% \!»@(a.+e wlqu ;~(_<`é;\'sjq, '€\"' C‘"C""~‘"I'~‘»”€-S .L‘-"?"~‘"’C@,'f:¥‘ 3@3'€‘3 k?@{ <“~.> (s~vc>:s.r:cu+w~" mm . ..Kwew ©'» zs\n@u_gd. 'y\a__\z@, \<Nou_-H\) , g¥~,|+\@_v p€rjmq{> 627/fo v' \)|13¢3`€”:.©} $\'5}3?£/ iiing @+ ,5~4_ q‘;k 304 <3+ ?(<{N 3 ua &d‘&‘f`/Oq (\'fW)-,'e:.~M/\er,gn'ef ww`d.\$k{@§or€[`§ ap w_$u(+ §§ _ . t ,, 9
lleeq!-\\qemce m.d;§~` qm);_'r ‘,q, +!»:@_ re;e;.ploy-oig.\;>.h-&\;/:@qf+he.v prog@@_\w+or~). E"\ D&\"\”EL BY'¢£\MC§\ €)() -H?! S"…'Q'J ggé)’ -' l IMPF_OFQ\, game »`N\/@§zj-',.qa.};\,@ pmc.e dura w‘)a)/~re`§>u\+ m d€|\§,a\_._.‘;©g; 3%(¢,5@65 v,qb~.+g, 40 due igroc,€:€=%' 03 tend USQA _CC§;\\S\: Ame.l\sc{, l‘h LBNACF‘E» \/.53'53@'-25 /" S¥\"\l' §d, §q§(~r£~z..`,c: Y‘, ~\ _ App. ;¢o cab § NO. _P.D~~ lower - Q 7\ b 13-9@ rior a ‘~ ms€_:_c.¢»+`.@~ a%+@rc\>eq +@` SLL>`\+¢B. '-:>rc(es ’_ £¢\) . j¥k.e`,@.a.m.€:¢...&_v:).,mflw a.!....CTéSe `i.S..a.¢\;___dci_u al _Q@M§:j`l;_.»#; Q£` j H\H'€ reg-ir @`N;l Qo';\_)g¥n‘@+e$> a due 0&'0@€¢5%' \/c`{)|@+')©fd €\'€‘.\" w`»+hou+ é> SpQ/C.`\§;c. Slmwm`q 0£‘/;;¢@_J.JC/,‘CE,+‘@»‘,S v 1 _ ha$. beam QSUBC/ a \ha~r;; SNCj-Q@ 3+ w 19 Oi$_d'.%guau_{\-'U_HM __
~INEFFEC,Tc\/f; A%<.;_ISTAN_QE 01: C@Uj\/SU; UNDz;~?-R* ' TH.\.; \/10_*\".».?10») 01 STA?T‘:-EHW§\/L COUN 3\;¢¢ , 6\ _I\RANTE E.% uMD…m@z'/‘THEGAW @'\" mw ’ ~ `!W@ 'RN w , .1` vew@‘»*"@*+@w+w\ @++<>Mwo:z§d m wm ma w ' r'\/éH@ \m\/es+`¢~qi@+or +_ofv\§a"l' \».M+@<jowq _ ‘H/\`)w¢zs ¥‘/\93 l a.u<@¢‘\)+e_d d.om€, he_~¥-@'i de `ne bmwde he `+o id mm@,_~§%_ar+ he Wr€d C,\/wH_,/; 1a ~-V@'t\+e\'§or\) 30 '{»eilp ‘I\/\€i, b Q,\/:\)+Hs& 96+39\'5010 \l;%"+<-;‘,Ql ma"n;)f§~\r\€,t(,`,<":)L)/\)'\LZw 364 $_ ON Ta¢\wary 33 ,Q©l§) @+ §ee)s+ 556 ¢Njii\~c,>.d wm €Fs€l~€ age I;U"}'Hla pc'}`H€’/\/SDN,I d~d“)\-+ gee MO£>US"M€S$ `C&vc!j . v Iwr©*}€ hev»a\e+&e.v +.c> subpoenas m @X;w_,_€@ l S.*`z§_\.j/v*§;v"€@ma/V, N\&\:m\ \<'¢\)`»¢\\\#€N ~+L\.€ €<ca'wd moHo@s 037- 3"‘"€' CG€\[\D‘@~:N@-<\£+, \"~b@_\_\).»\ \uh‘n*,€. , N\@r\>`-»® uj§\`,~}~¢») mw.~‘rl~er O-¥ Y:bD_N£/j j rp@` \ C,Ej `(`E.P@F "` D$» _\\»~;{_)/ 5,€)§_`(_§@§§ _C'§ 515 E\U wfqu U€S\»\au-(ud~ra C_~;;bo\c¢amb£`s,\‘€,?,§, §“@(;"@»(-‘¢I<$.)QQ)°,';C,@ \”€ §;0¢¢;4‘:<; Q-\`» me SGL.UG\\¢,` 3352\ z)\+)z\)c'q '{:bog._;L j,.§,__;_g¥\`\“¢€"f@,j\§g qav@` her `\M "H\€ `€'.jr_'~\€¥, c)."|r€Cf+;-.(>N away 30 q€'.+ ~~\_»0 "_v'\ -€VL’WW.Q P\<>-u_€>`€/ , +\\e §;»~c@~c..~|`»-ow mass no »‘c\¢\;;;_ ;Y€C~@M g]bv++\q¢' \e$-H’\P m a_$»"§\:\) .-"r\q a \'€C o w 93 g ‘Z'>e_e,-é:)<\f\`zb_')_+ 8 l P@(`@; §, __ _ 9959%.»¢.%= -W\@a.w$r `\4.`+ waz% a 'l:@.-Her~' ~.Lc) c{l‘m<»z_ i%<z,,r.-"w,s¥r_-.QQ+'~ \f©w)~ @,_AJ' G\)\_‘fv€r+ 1 kwa:\>_-¥'@cl- her +¢>c\c>. ` . D}¢ll ”‘§.‘5\,@/ P*“iv 346 IMVQSY'§F`(CQ+C)F C w*)‘“}>;é~ 12’,_:n'*+§¢eh$:¢)/\!` €Y“°.» mr `Oq-N@"_~*' d@i¢\)q. cnth 31 ask hee~<+cd@¥@¥~"\’-\"?H ' ' _`I;M\"\@ g» '\z\._l(\‘;_-¥€§r.\)`,.@qu 'S.QQ €zL\;~»`;‘o`r+ \;, P_€¢/.j‘€' 3`,:§,_5\.€; N\e.~”~.~$~`}@/\r 931 =.3\"¢?;~",4~@, l dc>.\f+l V\r\>mo w here 553 ca q©'§“-"'¥?'\S&”F' Ngme.&c)p>§<;"_f N€§)a\" had 3a w_\r.§e :\)€).na\e pa uf,e:l~i‘¢`€-»ZQE _¥\\.€\I.@\”=: Kmew a_)\).-p;`c)i\¢@ ¢\>€lme @é>/v\el~w- ` ' _9 ` .\ 3 ' .
S\\94 ;N'»L€.F~\j`:€we‘<:§ H'u :@)Q~U)') 156 /\/,\Brhl"‘ /l/:‘ ,"¢e€'rv¥>l\/*V©F ' kow \Oi\jq 03€.,`- l,\'_)<~>¥‘€ ¥Y\,Q\"¥‘-`I`€d;¢`:i.¢\'.!év Q}D.® L)+f=' @U("O};VOVC'€"` ' w\~\'\c,\/\ ¥165 mi<o-¥h`;iw%~¥o \~£,c]wk~¥\r.\ (\,\y» Qa.;@`, ac~`@`,,\~jj §00`3<1” §§ ' @\Q(A.`~ 54 i j Qaqgj \ \],'p."-,~H\`.la. PQ.}»},¢;S"G¢J cf»'.<§im"'$ ‘C§'@; S.N=" 3 _ , -+\/»`,¢\).'q laSH€r ,+@ D/@. :;~e@ Bmok'b`®'~+ _y’.:i'é¢\)"sf>}_,,,.B_S.‘& .
U,S.\,”`Y_’-§> L_\‘_`+.(p@"©lf)‘~Txé§>\/;`:\)<j}` ‘H»\<y+ <j \‘€».~,\jg€_.z¥ \.)""\US“{`.'~ (\JU+ ' O\).€.ij`rd.<b W'»-Sl CL\`_¥§_W"?‘€>.`:<<J`QS`)V €3.\)¢§55\3<:,£'\ 'h€ O'»';d~' ~ . 1.@ nn 14 +»r~', 99 q '.C§LH§Y ,\>'Q~, ;}1,'" 399 mm haw ’\f‘€q{ U'€;S-"+ec£ ; 555 C'> ' @'¢='N,gj\'e ¢Nq€g#;qa+h r"v/cf§;,@l@‘$"b:é/\J-&¥~\'-’n€ Q€Op\§?. -G'M:¢L \”@Cmd,zs I agw»@&@ »H~é:;swv~ v.@»<f»‘<;+¢@ov.).=/,zj&\,@ , b{€€”~:cj~)¥$@*;@m~¥; ' a 3 §605? 'p€.,v*$o/J §£:'L:_hn-f}++€.d“}t>"(3`|"§5!¢5~»'¢€...€; \dw 35")<`))4\»/,‘3”"0§`€ _ \f€;c,\@.wwg g ii.;'€Ws@/.)+¢z¥<@ ’.d.'¢\.) O&H»~\. ~Wn"e=. perso/u. Lo}i_i‘ Szupp@w+ ~L£ae G,@m;+?+u+_}.@/\)Q cr$: +\f\,€f U:N~i:¢'é:<i 543+¢$ ,'<§A)_d +L§_‘,;S. S+CJA»¢»}_ hom,<=:;s#S-i »d€,m<-;w` MM; se,.l`¥@; i§w;~+(/»€"` . pra@;wc.“¢,@; 941 \¢1¢,~);¢&/\)¢35 d\§ct»arq.€%w@~&=H@.;/\,Qv;§,d~`o_~l»*q ' we el;em+o%e weak 09 +he aim m'€f'¢;$" QW i+f 515 v §'SPF€€:Q:\J+§NO;_ 8--@!3§»J4j' § fa=u)§/cr S.Pw&=l,!\wb+;N§ec,ie;» ,"S ‘ \9_99.§, mwe» 919-439 §'+@¢J' 49»#3'_@‘ 99 mm .¥r€i @4/>‘:./¢4@1»¢ ' +-O Qr&yp.l @(j’f" CC_.-,P\€~§Q)(,)`H`€_ Qb\\c,|&";'[@fd$! (A) ;C"\\¥\C dl‘€!‘, Nv+<l,e.., ' ~ 3 . ' ` 3 N\‘\/ ~\»\»33\ a~HDY/u'c;{ web &u\),;)ré’/ 01 +b€¢~ 3 60 9 13 :OSRBCZ \\`3)~)\- 40 Sub PD€A) a be'<;&v$@ 01\)3 Ta.wzua,rq?l$?¢ibf§~,&/\/J;' J@‘o\/Uarbj éL.q',,=>?.O/'§ 59 5'€’\/'.-[ LU Q\J*‘,' W'h~”-";">z) UZUL{"'@T H')YP' , _ H@M@ r¢) b/@ 399 \)D. @vrweH `u\)“ \“\\C ng¢.z CO¢)I~% HJW/) 99/\/ .~ M€S&'Yd@ C@’§ 1 5\…` ..""‘U/D' ~
1051 _/9\6 LU_":‘}N’€’$$ 655 c/"/,'g/‘/v"¥ 5{')_'€7 - 916 wv~@+e am ap';@¢e» 01 p@per, sea €1%;9>34 ¢> (p&`@ ¢._:.} dow ~5'0””’@ 134 “*’ ®G@P/<§ 919 1 L:QQNM+@; 191 " 3 “*JPP€”#"”°") 55 W?*(»?§€»~" '*C> 50 @<>,@~<1/¢#»»¢1¢ ~»/,~;c?/ W/. v m `_ A$S(»é) §§ f::€/ €/<.!¢9{;>;;+!) p&c}»{, ;;`:) \,"E\f.£g !',}L?r%\";€a( §HV?A[EL$ . mQS 69 L)J§L‘l`§;'-G~`c WWB "3':"¢€, PYO_S€CU/~,;;?. Wo;§ D§,C§@§,z?_d_f.& 334pr €"(3).@‘ i"`vgm:“\q 453 _;33?`0";'“/‘3£1`0{9€" §1~3)1 49 c;"i 09 @/.~JC//;z),z{ ; - 'H‘.@'* 19""";'9""`»"3€1 91€~'/\)"%@15>)€<;+, bd~§- 1915 ¢*\~»¢,9 +9-49;,3‘,1._ , 91+5@~:*-§~1»<:'\»»+w<<»$w;. ' , _ 1 . , _ » _ z 09'§’€`“9<3“95 903 @"@C~€,Sja Y¢cy'/r*;éwerc u'~@¢__a~} ed kuth am MOFMM; ~§€§)r€se.wrz; 9 chem+¢, N~C/ 1999/9 "`\ '1~"-\ "'“ _"" l~~. 33 -,L "3) " paa‘"§"€"'p&'~€$' "”" H"@ "\"`(Q»`PVCU'"‘!'UM @'v£‘ ’H')~f}' C//€/\/ / & -. , _ v . ‘ _ - l v S.@~M €~… 91 @~9*’>"-‘1&»1+@»1 w»»'rsz», 9 »»5<_,1§+;1“11 . ._\;"_€':’%Ei.“"¢"zC?P~.€?nt'\,'g{)»}~¢>"5"5’1€§l¥”§'{:*\i:.$fn k CUN &_). An}£%k:l{;/' "' _ . , 9 us\)..,wMDEu/Wmm 1 mg ‘:MUGWP)<AS " - C©uNT-i:" 01 .D©\;&<" _ , §M;&w;\§:wf’_°i"-C);F"THE EVEN.TSSUMO» ' 9 U~NMNG»"THE'¥‘\€>3<;11\\.PR‘Q€:_:L§.§\¢<E;@»J¢S ARR~.‘;:€;Y m W\\.\,\Aww¢\>w+\m Y:RUWH, s»‘<,,,i\>>r>a»uwm ' ' Amr) \m'c>x AT_X'QM °i>"F' $E'>‘SUM; 5%5€1€1 aff \/\[ARTNIN <'>1_ ».
R§ez»w;' _ 9 9 1\,~1:_111€\9 esiA\'/‘W;Wz 0"§~“1>\111\/\11,§@;9~9¢;99999 999 39999111¥215 1999 ,”§-. c)¢'\.»x we 3 '§¢.51-¥`1\9\` `1`\§;»:€!§€ 19 4 §_1\_3§.?1 1912 1999 ”HQC M\€w_ 313 $O\»U,N 554 §.D:€ 1351'~,1’@;..1:_§;>~6\€5€0»;) 11 why 9954\ 99 "‘»"~1>4€»-`3"?' CI‘D:#¢ 111 €1@?9"1~1 \.M`»s~,)¢;`s~§“m~l, 99 1135 h C',r.wm~».,i; ;"fi~"e:»,x.-Q.@_}'fz.'?:r;€§ 39 "j;; ¢1¢;<,1 999 u'¢..)(_~§e,;»» @;9,9@ Hq*@~(;, [email protected]';;\.)¥'v'; +§/\a”\'+\f\@€’, 156 Cg¢;?sr\,l.:.'§ 35 -r\_.»»&_;r;; ama 9_~@;-‘.€€,1,9?@ `W\e b@,s$¢@¥ am UC@)\\€C»‘;'E@;\)_ ‘ ' . _ _ ;
~a`-; m 11‘\1\.1;1:1‘ vw 555 01 1111 5";'@12Y §§ ‘"H\Q pm§G.c,U+m” won 33 115 6 E>ubp@@wg !<a|ise, R%C$'\&\‘oi$ 3,¢1)\:1 1133 her 40 ¥€5"1“§~?\{ '\M»Qr¢>,\,+ Q$ 4115; f jurq, her ~\'5,5»+111.1\@¢\)19 would wave beeu, h€, +`v\€ de -1)€19)¢.~1~ 511ij 9 \\}ev€,'r~ ”\`Ouc.b» me
§§ 1116 mo§e`w`i'@r 1001)}¢1 mm 511 1315 \<@\>5!11.1)*1 R£<:\nard€>, L\)'\\"\Q.`\»,`»e. {<a\`s.§<i "“OV“@",- V~-’UUM €;"j@' 4'€§4'5£`"€°/ _§§/‘B \JU§,W.;$.W 56§,9,9€.-11§/99999, be.§<;.a, ug.c~.>. +`11");>+ §§ bmi/1311 her dm)qw~‘r@w 1015 hen baca-1055 15€1116!’1&*<31~)<1‘5"\-’3‘{° 'TL§'"\€.,H`.
191 .\»1§@ @';~ogec.\)+c>r U,>Qu\d¢ have w b seems N"\@m/ §1<:1J`»q11+e=/\1,<`)9)11`1c.i(» `ss't"b'».€ ma 116 mo%€rj 531\€ would 1151/11 '¥Q~<.'>Sr}“¥`:; ed ‘§'5.‘,(~§'“\` C:iOt`!\}ci "§`\#\€ °\`;MC".- `\*)9' d‘g+€d} dom)q MHQ`€' '4.‘\\!\.1'\€¢, 151.¢~.1 C} e?-§r>"?€)“ C:'_L) 1' ~AruJO C!/\`\ ;C!f“€“/\/` Ud@ 3 b@m.') She £..L)C)\.lic)' b&*\!€}'“\'€€'§\"i»fl)€€:ic:, 19 *H\€ ;Wm\)"'§'l“§‘/+':[ \"Wid W"H’ mw§ 11111~§@, Man\bw Fr@cw\a¢\l>.©w "\"~"'€>`<‘" ‘@M 5+§`&`€"'£> "`JL’""” would h'».z-.z\~'@ \*\” 9`\:\/\§)©551`)\51!@ 1101 me 410 have 11512:1\/ oct/1111 @ 1 1'1,111"1 m am ’13,51'\;>'1*11)1:1+1).»)1‘4"~'1> 11>'1“4 1\1_1091\+;.11~ 3 `\,0<;<1+;1)/\§`_`\` 1161ch \/`1~5`»+ 1111 \`19;51,(`€.`)€=5\-*13111‘»'5{1@ (5§:)11<;!55'»~11<;;§`3.“'1`-'1./\ 5§§€&£<".¢\)€§ ¢1,100¢¥ 323 `)§:f' ` ‘ .§:_§1: l§,WV§,_{.\§F§E,§ MD_§: ,\_§@.,\/ U\§@U\££ hg§,@ 135-db pp €;")\JS hay {js'?" U~J`\ )")_ ¥\!`\m~} }\ N "\"""\°~@m">"~_’; 23%€" WO”&‘?"I have ”§`(`)'§'H£:€ 'Y"‘»;H' dum_)/ Ou\~ !\!\arr~}€z.€vc’. 1341 15 M€¢'i""j 'SW""‘ {G*WF'" "qq$‘ l €\3€.’.\1€;1~ i`\.`\r'é¢i C`Ci Ou’i'c")}` .!\'M\qh'%' '¢mm h 0¢\/\.€- 1111 wa'hxj€.&‘§ LA)FCJU\C( h?s\.’@ b@»('i'\/ SFU{D¥)GU“B“ jfk-wa OKM(:@MS~ C§, 419;§§ \/€;Yc.{ic+ 1000/dl 913 1153 ic>€iew" C§}“W'C".r@¢‘j%; E`»LC\'J+€C] 913 ‘H\G. M/l , O}"/q O*Y (>C+O b<i\” 510 !S; WM¢!//') ~` CHMMJ&}TLL ~g,f\.Q_,M>/\¢CL/W) <5'\» - Q_O> ,....`_"_' v *»'.w.., _` ¢\:@._..3 c>./,.»‘Q.€-.Q.Q»it:}é)~ ,...*-w.w.--._._-w...“..-§..~...“-.~_“-_ -,,-....~_.W_,....-`._m.¢ ._
.@RAVER \/\/HEREFORE,PQ&_N\\SES <;QNS\\>ER, Ap;>€:\&<aw*r, regpec~\*‘+u\\q vec§uc»:s+;\'~$m Cow~¢ +@ Y'€*,\/C~z YSQ, a,\)d"rar\iq)er ~‘rH;<,' gauge wi+\,\ `W§A.WC;!-Wq_,\o Ci&'% rv\`iSS 'H°;€ \MC.{'¢C'&'M€,;~»)JF U§C)I\S -‘,:".r\)d;,\/q 4'\03+ ll U)SQ '\:\r\\orc)pev/L` \’Q.GF€<.;,€.;\~¥¥@A -\'\\vouqh s\1\3\€$$€<::¥€\/@ 0-$`»' C..c>U/\.)_<Je \ . I‘£r`l wovicl have beard re-pr€sea)+ed \~@pe,vlq map r€$u\~&¢;, Lu€)ul<%.' have beam di¥femw+', u+{n#ewxore):\: p\‘.-QL(»+~\~»:>‘\- ~.L~§'\`»='> HoruOrél',~le Co¢)r-i~ ¢,\)/`/I §MS\'mc+ 1906 O"s+r"»c.-¥ C.Our+ 319 C'f:\'€ie»ge M»e 39an i€\.\ “‘r'\m€, C`»\)S“$~O¢iq C~S- »{-"ne. H g_\~¢~`\§ C.@u,'~‘_t+¢{ 55\€91!"»¥§ O-F-{~`/`c€,
R §§§EE{-`¥'CSY\ U`5 [,~ §§ }\R'{~§`~Vé" : umw m ` """" " ""`" ""7“""" … *~U§.;:£Q;\.@m§;"j'VM¢U/MMMX \N§ g \‘<3“’\ ,3?€)§1_;1_§§,~)..€:.\¢.<1- .§K“e.§_€v:.\_&).€>! ,-S~_vr-»-_._'.m_….#_ … v
-,~,»9
_, _,`¢l b-...;._~.
_`A,::" * s
._.~..` ~_...,_..-4»..\.\~“ -'-- dr » c ..v»=--'x»\ _ 4.¢,»_"`. c }`L,»r' l
*Q_@R"m:\c)>?rr§. ©\`- SER\I\CE .T%e De-Vewéa¢d,: \/\Wi.“`¢aw\ Ha\,\warc\ 1"\~€e¢v\a»\b§'n- c\,o d e§.\ar@ ur\)<ier-+%e penqu 05"¢ §r€fwr<( +%&4-¥¢/\€» ZJX>O\)& -15'”\`\\)€>/ &réd, C,Qrvecs\~‘}o-Hne <>,S+ D-P !N»f ¥_§Mr>_u)\¢q|q @)MM\a-\¢ ~Ha`)$ u)a€>_prepaxed wt’\`»\e ]: UUS%"\¢\) N\L{V`\qw\“ 6,‘\&+@ .é_>-§l m`\a)<i 3;,\)&_{>\3 ' d /M *H/\€, \.)`¢S, !\/\a§\\ ~\»Q`~Hn€ Ue)rK-YQY"\'\/\edoud' o'»ST-__- p cab 4 ' W\§'?-§\;)e; {\co::<`§§ alj (_PHAO Ezj: §A%_O§l ._pfg%£`wgy`.€><a§ ’1 , >L@c; 030 €.`C 0 ` ecw ,QO ` &\'~\~\/\e‘ N\e\`) %. po\\).r<>ékq .U r\$v\’, 3 ‘?Q`\""N\.?>SD 89 > , . l_`)_u`\:\)a\$¥oc~_§.,"\_€>&a§,.'??%§l \/\f`\\\}am'Haqwa¢d¢\:r@Z/Y»W,SM l ' `
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.