Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

FORBES, DARRYL EARL Jr.

FORBES, DARRYL EARL Jr.
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided December 21, 2015

FORBES, DARRYL EARL Jr.

Opinion

‘\ev.AC Cw¢fr 011 CQKM§HAL APP\§M,& CL/ws\; m>. \1‘\*1‘1.*1'5 \>~-A agung \~vo, `\\12\15‘ A "D-Mrz\\\. E\ Yonf§?,§ 32 Il\;\,MorL REcr-;\\/ED \N ~ -~1b 'couRT oF cR\M\NA\. APPEALS \H> ‘D-£'_NM'CT CL\ZP~\L.T&`naAn‘T Cou»w~) R\§Qp¢»\ 1>\;,»7, ' DEC 21 2015 \, j w ' EA~\’€_ T:~vn/ A?PLKCA \ze>\~\ VDB llan %\tt'e Mg%t%f?§rk£ W , 0 ma ‘\=lwon/uzmjunc;\z OF SAL'I> (:Dm>_‘r' v CD*"'|E \lb\/_l D il F § z 2 A’i il in Ai' § ‘Si `H/$) AR_ \l\./ §, ©£LR- VZ f j $~\¢gw\¥g‘\§ 72 ( A\kf¥ /} }313 i")o`\h§ TH’\§ C,c:\,x|?,i lbo- \LHLL( 95 \')A"’"BA w lui pd h g( ,),4}3 O 'E A§ C% `{ C¥?,E 75 L (LOC{DL,\Q.£ 2, `EC\/E H <[ \ § gL l> GF w 5.\;4» P A ‘\ O‘] §>\§CTL¢>H 1 C<:\) E\Li¢¢s’€' 110115:| ,4+3¥> 81&0\1_|‘+'1+\», C TTL§ vile {, \:DLLBVJ`KAG' `Tu`-r>_~\;'§ ch<_(‘fo*~\ j j mm C¢` ' d j d *\HN \<}AS Su@?j`{cj' \~J? j ¢TWQ, ;Y ARTUC\/€ 4 g v t uru;§ l>‘;;ch;ov~\ 45 118 \ ' § _;\( ) Ec‘rm>.¢ 105 -Ae.<rr.g.\.w: ), Sgcrgw \~1 A~ u M£…T va "A`J\;ic row \@\ jB;;\/L eF l€);f.>`c<h’s K)§` `\'QMS C vis Y “€“;( aquch jj \§'M>M£m' . j ` 08 £ q jon \\j v Tb m H, ma vegan QM.EMBM§M Am> T"W@<n;\§,mm A\\,,\:§m:i:;'“ m:‘€\§l> gw‘-r_d\:,s\ CO»¢M¢;TM `Vgo\~\ \¢)F l@r\~/\\§QECA j j \?-§1,1:12\1 gov com 1411 Cw»uv e>'F C\zwcvw, A»p 1>1_111L<; ass umw 11 1111--111;911:1§1\, wm 110 onl>£"n, T\b; biswch C\,\§P,\L vF TA»Q:LMJW C,¢um’\) To EHHEI>',;AT\»;L\] `Foav;m,b_ 1111 SYM€€ APM<:AT:DM mm RELA“€€D macoth \>1,111§1,1111 1"0 11111@ am 911‘,€;11;111111\. Pnec@z>uma wrach 1101 31@1@11 3 cb)_, *Przoc § 13111?_£ )‘\1 1;£ \To\a\| “Q’é-"LA"T<>Q \L)Ag Con\lzcw.b` 34 W/€ `.Cou'rz'i' 3;'~1 T\~h€ I:e§l>_‘\'?% Qm;b“\r.'\‘&\. _ bg€~rm:c\r CWM gm `VArLRAnT C@qm.\l "°\“1§1111£ ‘1;14-@/11131; 141111¥31§2"11\*1<1‘1$“[) 19\?1>1>§§1;99:011 1>1= 130 Pom.sl>s QF'MML~EHQAMA 111;1> 04\1£1; 1411\4'131;12/ ` 11131115 OY ?0$§1§$§1;0\4 11`)1;1\=1 EI~WEN'\° `\`O D€LKA€R ~A Cn\\‘¥'rzo\} SuB£T» vwag Ecg‘mc\l 1415 C@um ~As§§s§€b Pu~):§\wmw 111 112 \11§/1122 611 EACM C@um“ eF A»~\ EBDICT\"\%`QT §TH~€\~»,E-»A\r 1>F 11+1§ 611£\€ L`“ §1€1>1<€11@1§11 1613 fhame FE\,\;)> 4 21111, /4~1$1>11;¢111;@1~\ ‘Focz whch \44@1£/4£ Cav)_pus ):LS T141Y_ TQEAL Cmm' 013 E>¢<rbg.gp, 30 9_0`1§ _ Yl\¥'\=; 81,11’1: r§sm; Al~\ 442ng "1'111~"1 Wrz,§. 1411,1; no CO\¢T/zv\\§rm“l§l> ‘ Pn,\§\l;ous‘)_\) umugso\,\ml> 1511st To TL_&\% '\_1§.,@1\,1;"1'_1 OF "HJ\§ Il$,LA`FvQ'§<>' C@~PEAM\§W 11.1\11;111 Q§QU;M; 411 §\1:1>1§1“):4@\) 141§1(1114<2 4111> ,.rL€L,@W/\§Ab¢ T)M"~r’ T\&\§ 121»:'\,1;1§¥: 212&1,111,3*1 1515 13151`1;1§1§; Q»\Qo\L) `OV CAL\S‘@ \11§'1_4%11 Azcu\€£ TL,L§ Dgs\\'n,gc"f (`;\.1;11\¢ NAS’ 1~‘1> AQTA©Q"L'C‘{ ’Vo C`¢»~STKd mm `\’O ‘_'WOU> Tl\>;LMow.’S APPLn'cATr_:DM \:111'}4~/1311_1: Cop.ms R€L):%F g . , "., m ui~\b§"h. 4 viz 4‘1;;\'§§§4L bu`r\i To ~-EMH§`D§A`C§W 1504\¢_144¥3 m "R`FPLBCNK¢>H "4»3\> 'Q§\_M§D ‘r).§c@§§ n miss Cou@r @.i= CMMW'§\’ A'PP§'W~ P”‘“W/WT T° Y§Ms Coi>»; §44~»;44§ P§§@aw¢§ MYKCLE '\\,f)"l S§_c:‘fr;o;\i 3 Lci) Y_`\L,\Es‘i' lw\§"_],' §’)C_Qm€é_\,v ¢HAMDTONI gm .S,\u._ §'1@, -;'~iq U§»<=C§. 499 iq<m, §’)de \i.~i441/1L;4,15 g&\L;‘ 30\ "HE) "i\@i I"Y\§‘Ai Ciz.. 499 E),D§)C)jl `,'Iz§LATm HA: mo A§§QMA"<§ R§'M§l>\l AT L4\Li T§ _Purzsu§ TW§ P.§Qw §§‘\’§D R§Li;§i: 0§14\§2 `*@W) "\'144*¢ `Tl¥gs -'\/Jc>.i;‘r <>F \`/)41~\13‘»4\4§¢£, ‘\~UN'§!L§ Fov_§) R§L»Noiz i>rz/NQ TMT TL\/§ 04qu gs§u§ 4 \uiz§'\° DF \\’»4'4'>4»/\§1.§ bm)§c=rz;»lc, W§ bramch C\,f\;r§\c §§ §\’4§114§\§ C,owN\i Yv §HM§{>§ 4“\’§\,~1 ‘Forz,wm)_b Ti&§ 443\;4§ APF>L@CATK¢>J ‘To gm> Cm,;\*\ ®F Cm;v~‘) 1;1)4'\, 49?§4Lg Q,{Q P§cTR\,L\! ' 'D4n%i_ \§. °FaizR\'/,s C‘>§UEFMT§ f>\‘ wmch ""'“14§ TL§LM’\>Q 14\2§§§# an:\’xi:\i “ri+n 4 `\’r».u§ 445 Cm§§c_‘r CQ-P\l ¢'>\; W§ Fo§§cw wm 41><>\.1:c4<r):¢>~ Fnaz, \Lh;;;\’ \04§1§4\1)»§¢ mg B§§u FOQ'\L)A'\'ZJ> 34 UidT>T€D QTA;`C\§£ `\~»'\,43;[, Pog\AQ'§ `Y'o `Y'll<§ Cou'a_'\' OF Crzz:i'i§w¢\, 44>¢>§4\,§ CL§w\<'§ OFFJ:-c\€ P.© B@>ci’z'go§ GAPLTQL QT k°fgoid Au€f§i~\ T\§M<~¢ "\‘l<"i\\ §§§C@r§!> D*J 'DEC§MB§\L \U¢) 9.°\5 = ` §§ss>~q,c<r§,\u\) `AMJQM¢> § 54@6\)§§ §44@§€

' T§¢A'g CW§\' oF Cpg\,/\,;»m_ 41>+§4\»$' @Aug§ MD. \H"\Ci“`\§ l> 0;4\1<9§ 'Hi>. i\\?i'\$ DA»\'LU\}\, E, T:QILB§£ TQ, .\,' "~Ti%§ mmch C\,§'§l¢,Tm§-nw‘\` Q,OM\N me-,;DM gm §ugi>§.`\g);oi~i QF' \Zu'\.,§ WBTH 4§§;;§4_\\1:1’ w QuPi>e_r;`\' ' ’\'o mg 4§441;41>.§§ du Dcz,§~"vi: £;Mi> C,wm“: C°/ow§§c 1~\@\/_1 Di<me\il. \Z@nees ‘€frz F».'z@v§€ -Au 1:»~\\")4’\°§ Ai~\ld V):L§b Hc>'i'§o§i §§ gus Pgusgr>u @F iz§\\,§c umw 'SHPPONL»SG» 4PFSI>4\\§T Punsu/%‘<\T T<> im\,§ 1 wm 499§\,§4“:§ Pn@¢i§i>mz§ §\U\;s=rzoi§] 4411 Qz§\u. mg FD\,LM/ms@'. ` ` i-':J,` 340\4,)1;»3€, 4'\= 04\,»4§‘. \. §§14"(°"“ R§ngs<r n §£\§ @4§ o-§£QZML cow §§ umw HA~»J§`A\~/)u,s \m~ci+owr Fi;§i;wc§ ii C'Cfi'>_<.;>¢s §§¢Q\§"\W§ 4 §1“41‘:§ Prz§som£i¥ 445 W§ T§>LM 1>1;1>4§4\41§44 §§ Q@:MKML zu-s<rsc\§ .§MSTK'“CM°\_';\>AA'\_ br\ii§£§bk\ H-oi§%€ F4C,B\,'£“_N YI>D\>,§ idoT Prco'\))§b?; C@i><>;\zs ron P§-\;go»_\.§ra ` \Li 1415§§§4§§ §§\.4¢0¢2 13ng mm Wk§ wm mouth @Q‘rz4»d‘1’ ng, ‘P\g,uggou §§ il Coi>~i:§@ AM> 4LLO\L1 §§Lmoe irc `F);L§ f>\°i§ 01»13€4§154\, wave e\: W)MM>AMLLQ, CEr>.T`i;FEckT\»; eF 21§11\\ FSC\S*Q \Qe'rz\;s\\ C§mm;m T)"&A“v A Trm\; Am> (;O\L¢\;<;T C»P\; '<>\: mg S»»QP\§HSEDH DF W\§‘ ML\; \~'10"'50\1 umw $uPPorvrg% AFFKDA\$KT \/_m£ §;'\§'n\\‘§. upon wm Cwn°r QL\;,Q,\L P.<>_ `Qo;c '\’).30%,<1/4¢>;10\» QTA-Tgou, A\,»s<rgu, TQ_)¢AS `”t&`<‘}ll ..E)v\§<;w”¥\§'> wl l>x>;ca;m;x§n\w, low ` l 4 ramss>ac*r\fl&\,L\; , g; ;, _ mfaqu §\ %DR<B%!

ORb§m <>»<\ w»;: mg _,___\)M oF__,Qv\S, wm w w mg h\.§mb Q\;LM°Q§ 'Mo<TEO\~¢ ‘®F '$b\§ P\§ i~‘S):'o»J Q\= Qu\,\§. '\U\;“C\+ QupPoU'):*~\<‘o AFFI;BA\VL`T AHD A'%"TEQ `Dq\§ Cgus\;bamwnod OF W\§, SAH\; m w 30 same TH'A'T Tl<}'>; “")o%'gol~l §§ ConA'DY€$D/ Dg i$;\`§b; );T §§ go @Qm§;z A \+EM fm "'B\§ §\§T \§>Q, ______ 2915

FTUDQ>§> Prz\'>s§i>~sl~\@ `TE)LAS' 'C¢u\z‘\“ OF Cu,EH';;\AA'L A=I>@\§ALC llng Mo. x\\*m-"\'SI> Cw££ Mo, …3\"‘5 bmw\i\_‘j E. F¢>nm£s 'Jr;~ %wmu AF‘F<EL\AMT mr . `”§ w l>/mm~ »\:,- \=@r-z_.e\;& :m 'W\§ dss<m;c‘f -C°/\)@\c., `Un.rmu\\' Cz>u»s‘\'~l … \$»,…~§ m mqu \:, mem ‘J¢z,. 1 Av\ e\\\§w\g wm @F Ac,-@, JIAH A \?/¥§Q):ba§wf €>F CH\-:n<>\¢%l§ Coqm\a' T\§><A.c Acm> §§ léfe\\\§ cogan mg STA»T§MEM QF m own Fp_x§'\; \)_r/Y>LL A)ll\ W\§ ‘FA<;\¥§ STA*C§;l> mg“r\<h;d mg §§\uon.\~‘ /H=*F§BA»¢;;T An.\; Tn,u\§ Am> Co'ruu>;c\' To gym e>\f `\~4\{ \USD\L.K'\/E®Q>E T%Lz§ Sw'r\§ @F Y\§)Mc bow AQ\\‘ 'PA\| nn Ppggou~\grz’§ ForL W.@~¢Lkm¢c, "l’¢mv;\:orua f A\»/) ')mr>£c,\;‘~l‘r man \>o mr \<¥A~m Fn.m§vwg en FA\~/)Ew To ng> M'I> \~’)ML\€. COM\ZL’ ms A Q,»:Asouk;s\,\; TEVH; TAB\/\:, U+\§ _’YWA@ D\§PQQTV\\§AT DF Cm;\~’s'i;m¥\, jug‘§'gc,\§ '\<}D;>Q,\; u;yg'*\' ’L»Q(\Ll `L§'BrLA~Rv D<)\§§ “OT 43@\\»§!>\; ‘Cz>?i;\§€ ‘T‘n ' P\»ngov\\€rz.’§, DECLAQAT:DN § \+§m;@~) \>§ wm wl ben ma P§~» »va 911 P\;n.zruw m A.QN-z, Fon€@o~§% 1;; `Frz\u-; A»N> Cor>,m§m Yo R»gcf QF wm knew L\§M,E PWIL§uA-)AT TO S\§L". \3‘_)_,¢>00, \‘31.»003 Tl§`)l,€;;\\; ?m¢c_ R£M, 'Cob§, 'EMOMTE'> D§Cgm@\znw) ‘Lp\S .Q ' §:M§; § v 'KM'T DM~DL 1§, FD¢LB\§§ ;TR` _ iv

SHAREN WILSON Criminal District Attorney Tarrant County October 30, 20_15 Mr. Darryl Earl Forbes, Jr. TDCJ # 1588949 Hodge Unit P.O. Box 999 Rusk, Texas 75785 RE: EX PARTE DARRYL EARL FORBES, JR. C-4-010610-1117975-A, C-4-010611-1118175~A Dear Mr. Forbes: Enclosed please find a copy Of the State’s Response to Application for Writ of Habeas - Corpus and a copy of the State’s Proposed Memorandum, Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LaW Which have been filed With the Tarrant County Distriet Clerk's Offiee, and an unsigned Order Which Will be submitted to the judge for review and signature Sincerely, Cindy ra v POst-C viction Legal Secretary Enc.

401WestBelknap - FonWorth,Texas 76196 ' 817.884.1400

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.