Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Gutierrez, Jose Alberto

Gutierrez, Jose Alberto
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided December 18, 2015

Gutierrez, Jose Alberto

Opinion

A//) M-Q8- ao&xc; -r/?L .

WR-70,885-11

c/tv^ /?^<&<?r'e~7r<9 sZtyrxiT/e^-Z-s y-, RECEIVED \H COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS DEC 18 2015 Abel Acosfa, Clerk

Bex*** fev^ty, T&XA-&

/^tee-Ay ^ ^ ^ ^ </V<»r<r^/"/"g^A^yaS *7&z#-j£, ^ ^ / f ^ . , /f^^^ssr

^^^ />• /g »y- z r*>r*xei Ate********* #*s6 &7#: /tfw;*/*^6M^^ Yr&UIzz^T* S70 TASf /1/0AS0^#<S/£' faatAiTr&sr c^exj^er^^^ s&/»<*mJ- 1

/&w/**>efS"ty Ce/*fe& A-roe^*, c^2Ze ^ *G*A/rrse* **/&£?&/><// a /****/%$ /*firmer- f/sZ^iJ'S^ty o/Vw//^ (?«}yfy^fAS/y )/&>/>* c/VvAvte a***/? t<d S*/r/?Z'c./*sZ&,

/AtffrZpj, #cf ^/^^^ /*/<*er*6*>, ^///Uv 7*0 <=/'t//?/£e^O>f/)'J/ f/Vrf/; /s^t/ns^ <pfc& /*C <?** &€•?/$} g00$-f /?**^/K, She's/- <pTytt/lAfOte S?at**/ssZfS^+/>2«J S^/cTs-t,/^ . /%tSAAt*jL ^6 /9iar/W- /+-/ /^'A1//^ s?/&te//*•*/-^s>#£ <T'6'r/'-/&eeotr0tj, 4y&*»s &**- CetrS- a*y /8?y#r~ fav+tfys V&x*^ q£ rtt* $e>e*fr"e»'*4'/<&, $//?**&& a>/£ —&h/&'"m V^— /*y fante. y/0. afftf-C'—S/f£, (fty/**! cT/0/e */t Ar**?*? XT. &/**&. ^/£es/Crfis/Sersri* .

C&<re 6s^#-& i^rr,e>*/e<t>v<r4y y?y"/?,^*-t. &*>, &evss. 2eof,

.2L. &£?/?&$zc<j£ /retS'i'rAf /*0ts*i*r 0A *?<&&t>r&i£- y^rfxTf jg/^^Sir' „

y>yyz**<C <!?4-*v> ay <f/ve'"^«y //.fr /%y^/^'t>ry ^<^*y>/»»*/r~*> /&ree*-<s>f ^>^rZee^cc^. £*ta/ 6**x>-£ gc<&yse~'M<i/c>. —C£&j**z<3&<i&.J —A/as/% ?6'S, /*r*<-*£/*&/£ <P/^<P*r'-%r<s//'eSfc^obe /fe a~

S*t**«t&. S~e/st,*4>-/-<*eC s**£c*«y*& /^ *W/<U. #>*/* £L ^e/f/&y>°-~^f*//Atf /fee. y^hes/V^y* Savr/- <p£ /P/o^e*!, <?£**•&, sjefstAssst/xtfaa-S /e> ^£r/«wy <£ee*/C cS/9'eg yf/zsss+g* <y/4!t/4s, ttaatrf" £Y¥- Z&J&'XT/sigZ/sy C/4*s%f, 2TT- MAfe c^Ao*"^ Ac s^eAeetiL, /&*/• />er-e6y s//Z0-esS£>~^f-

£?€*/$ €?/#y/& A?'f**s'>"eSS*&&*'S' <&Ay*y 7*0 Am. ^•^/rc^t'^T^- /////y £ //?///*? ^eye^F*

• c/yeefys'^s/y ^^ y>-^yt/cty/- Si/01^06, z^ef, y&w*-** fwy- <?c Afy&*#'*iv/<.c/etg^y //A/^^/.^i "• /"/$/***>rbrJ —4/?/?&e/ys»*'fa' y£?>?>£ - /-eyu#<r,~SA yWeA/cJ' /Py^/y^^y- ^y /^^Ar,^y^rly>c //-/s*i*y/<sy*-/<Z J^j^f /y^^/-^^^ ^yty^ 4iis//y**Y af/>*te y*/^e^//&/'''/*^"'y<^,?^&'~^/^'<:£~ s*y#f-!' .y~<r<r*7ise: a>~<yy^^s?^ S$>*sry~<?y s&y>/0<*#tcr vl^/^ Zeef S&*"?£~ <0sv£yr% yfr£ />*<**-' S&Aty S/tysvy*srA& /*ee//rc/-%r^y & &/y^/e"&y "&(&,...&%m$? /Jy&e^ *£?£J£"*>g/s&u)s*y £ty/%f s**/ C/)ey/9//>ye. /*/yWeyVcJ, &+»4#/9/i/&e//0<yA &s»& €^o«t{£*&., ?4p y£s*/?/~Af0^j fey/tf'yyv-^— ^y^y yt^aye/*^f*^-yfySoi yy^^yy^^/- y~y&r /<y^^^~ yiy^yyy^^' ?£> ybs^t-e-^y <^fe 4^*y/&ey c/y&te- /O^crc^ ywJyyoe^ ^ +~* ** -Ce^^e *£*uy*r <M***U- /V'*, ?«%ry^"/-A~ re/,**/''''** /***&**>/^-^ **"'<£• tf*y£*"& /?J?. /;y?4"/Z) £**+'*'*'/+&*'•'*#: 4fref*«*fi>- ) / * sf/ffiiyAvrAyT&j

0 c//>*e°y?e*'y 0*s **~ yty>*>**-, 0cy?s* ^eof", y^evsynL *"&»*& #y yy/w&AF yet**/* /rrfsrvS-er <?*set' P**ty**-€c£. &y0*je0tx* — £tdZfr^&At^d^J—' ^yZA/Xe"-*''^^'yy/»e/y***/y& S~yr*j&J y*jw?1-g4, ge>«£ » '^#r?<r*/*7#-c t&f&rcT<f A/a^zeyr*/=?y/>yy»£~ ytteTz*^^ &&£ fa yyyeyyrcy're^ef'/L/t/e /9yy*~/yy<z<s6Z yyy«?yytr/& t^oe/s^yey-, &y/fc>< yy yyyy*ey+s<£ *> •» -8 £tSy>& s$<*dy yr&s&r® &y ytfyytpy/y**//--S/^J' SWVJ*•#/?/,,*y;*te*y-• /y*gyt>r/e<F &ye*/£e/Sr&. y/y/>*//*)»'&' s/sy/ttoysy* • &f/e4/'f —s/vafpe #***s£~yis*+*yv><,cj&. g>y?yas^^^y-jy<?*r&. C"*e.~e.j"—- (f^<r^«»Aal y£. l/f-ZfaiMbKC) ~ f70yv*y/y?,\s/& /^«v<s /'oV^^y /c 4>y/'y/'^'c^^yy/y//,e/L~ yyyoay^S&py Cets^v^Js y/y^fky.^ £?—ytte&*-<£.* y/y- SZ7*S>'-e^/yW#//*<^0^ o/y/f/-'z^Z-Z^d'

Ss"'^***^-ly''*/**'*'£4!?'*»'/S £9.4**+*&f*efi+mt-». fy^ y^etr^r^y^^yyy&**yA- f***—- 0]C yS/>S*e44eft c/f/J^Sy ?£er/£f /$/'#„& T. &/>*c,y-, y?ys*c£yMe»te'f6'iyllybs-y*'& W'rrr"^«**v>^,.

0r/**y*€£ 4y ^ds. <?<?«?»'&*.#»**• <?£,ty»"-?y ^/yyy^c/- ftsrte, /%&!*/<//& —tr&^c^*/-^ st/V'^ fy'/>**£ y^yy^z^y zecr, y/yy yy<*/y*>j y?~,yo~,?0 yy^Zs-yy,^ f'*~~<,*yu£«*Jrf- yi/yyyy ffV/z/; fff/zz y^^t^^ yyf^e ^a***^ yfsy> yy, A^»ry^^yyy~~Zy*c cyt^^y/cjz. f*c>sA cyyerye*^ 4?~rae y?r#t'a't'y**r*£.y /PtRy/fyj/<o yZa £*raTy? /£?&*•*,- yemn^yy cTfaie ftvrt* <gfyfye*«r &s?yj»0t,*~y*sy cy&>'e &^'~'^*C y^^Z^^^c^-y^y?^ j/?**-o/y*t« f/n«ce. *sa. ePeef-C/t-y/ft,; Zoof'C/e-//<??. y^^y^^c/y^y^y —)/ax&-yy^^,J/J»ts*4i$=S'9 C/•€•/ y*'LJrec£ STy^cf/yr£r?r*t*Lc£- ytY^fy^/y-^-yc £?&&*&•y&?4Tt>y-cyef y^C££&&€&/?£<•/'**'**•'**'''***& Sy^iryyery-yo^r \ O to * c? 1 ~ is? fS) g^SM jf^/J^^y/&**^ y>'yys>y'ry**'<p£:y s**y-er/e*yi••*•£— S?y t^ftTvy cfMfG y&yy*4>y~y*-<? 4!><GL <?&>6fi&4i.<L.

C &A&tyt-*^$4y<sfS^^^^¥4®®} &J'"Co//*ye foyt) /**»-cfArZs^ey- A*hp{ y^c^^y*,^*^^ ^Tyy y. />. y. y> ys/- VZ- yz y^e^ /S, <£*voj -,Ahyz, /Prvt *//*>»> e<lTj>Uzy/Ay '#* f<w****~(f%eA*»&c~. yZs-//j)'<!f y<t>e^ce. £<yf/Ay /&/?* &yy<0-cje& S/'/tw^'c^—Csy/ftgzry&ytry^ -—y^/ye fy^y^^*uz^^ -/rfr/.y ,///?* ycsyrkjcje—- y?/~ & c£*fy*~*tganB€^ y^/sy ysv£>£- yy 0t/y Z>s^^?£&y^y-yr^cyi'*~4!ry3 dfcog,'y^y^/y-y'yc-yp^^y^y^^y^l^r^ey^^^- ://#yY0f4&L, y/yyryy-^^c/y^y^^^ry^y^ye^'^ —<• -/.c t^^y/z^y y?s9y' ^y'^cr-t-z^/- &;-&'*'*'*./?, ^^f^ffcr/*-• yyyi#'#*"*»-y*f&& </& &^y<f>&-*'s*<*y>sy<*,&£+ j *sy7y0&<s/***:*>*s7&: —— y>yJ srr/yy/oS*, yfyyr/y^y^A- yj*t??s- yyyoy**ey <ffis--a,<urysr e-<L+j>Mf*&~ /iy- yyy /t/yA/~ Sx/5/yZg. c/Yyte (21 /0 y>y*J*yv/J yey-eAf/vr«s*S'r'y'sa*<J^y/,^7////^,.-; TAeye/r<»*~e 4?. g&. ZC6}€&)j y@ g&.'gbf) &y*wf£ +**•*• s9/tp*y+ <f/M<GM~y^J yiyefe's- yryyoysocS y?y gts^y/*^y*Zf^~sst*jy yX^y'^/4!!Jt/ef^/>*^e> &*>#*»— fcty+sAy &+&/ y$?^nJ0£*y/+sp^y y%/4tys?0&£ yp+s&€ ^/ec&t&&•&£ 4?^ tziey/yar yy-yryyyevi^-r y>yyt>/*s/s*ie*y *y /TetsMfi-t-^/^r- y^^Afy^ye, y$9t>/fy& ?*» fb#yyy*f &*>//*£ *4ytf <y°ayi*y>ey. y**y>*~£l ^/*>d' y^<py^/c^. y?6/yjy,4<f ys*se-yyyyf>c d*&cyr# A$e#yyZyp> ^e y^rrry^" /re0y~6Se®<^4?^*/&3^&,G/y>*u^ssyy^ — ^ ^teefl)

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.