Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

Shea Palavan v. Brian McCulley, TBW Development, LLC, and Boulevard Realty, LLC

Shea Palavan v. Brian McCulley, TBW Development, LLC, and Boulevard Realty, LLC
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided December 31, 2015

Shea Palavan v. Brian McCulley, TBW Development, LLC, and Boulevard Realty, LLC

Opinion

&$6( &9 '$7(),/('

 FILED IN &$6(7<3( 1st COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS 3(5621$/,1-85< 12/31/2015 5:39:20 PM 67</( CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE Clerk 6+($3$/$9$1

9

%5,$10&&8//(<%28/(9$5'5($/7<//&$1'7%:'(9(/230(17//&

25,*352&

12

75$16)(5)520



75$16)(5,1



75$16)(5&$6(



75$16)(572



75$16)(5287



38%6(59,&(

:::67&2$&2857667$7(7;86

$33(/ / $7 ( %5, () 6

'$7(£ (9(177<3( '(6&5,37,21 '2&80(17 $33(1',; >3').%@  5(3/<%5,()),/(' $33(//$17 %5,() >3').%@ 127,&( >3').%@

%5,() ),/('  25$/ $5*80(17 127 %5,() >3') 0%@  $33(//(( 5(48(67(' 127,&( >3').%@

$33(1',; >3').%@ %5,() 5(&(,9('  25$/ $5*80(17 127  5(48(67(' $33(//$17 %5,() >3').%@

$33(1',; >3').%@ %5,() ),/('  25$/ $5*80(17 127  $33(//$17 %5,() >3').%@ 5(48(67(' 127,&( >3').%@

&$6( (9(17 6

'$7( (9(177<3( '(6&5,37,21 ',6326,7,21 '2&80(17 &/(5.6 5(&25'  $33(//$17 £ ),/(' > &267%,// 3') .%@ >  0$1'$7(,668(' &,9,/ £ 0$1'$7( 3') .%@ > 127,&( 3')  .%@

027,21 )25  5(+($5,1* :$6 £ £ 127),/(' 027,21 )25  £ £ 5(+($5,1*'8( > 0(025$1'80 3') 23,1,21 0(025$1'80 .%@  £ ',60,66$33($/ 23,1,21,668(' > 127,&( 3') .%@

>  -8'*0(17,668(' £ £ -8'*0(17 3') .%@

 68%0,77(' £ £ > $33(1',; 3') .%@ >  5(3/<%5,()),/(' $33(//$17 £ %5,() 3') .%@ > 127,&( 3') .%@

 5(3/<%5,()'8( $33(//$17 £ 6833/(0(17$/ >  &/(5.6 5(&25' $33(//(( £ 127,&( 3') ),/(' .%@ > %5,() ),/('  25$/ %5,() 3')  $5*80(17 127 $33(//(( £ 0%@ 5(48(67(' >3') 127,&( .%@

&$6( 5($'< 72 %(  £ £ 6(7 $33(//((6 %5,()  $33(//(( £ '8( 6833/(0(17$/ >  &/(5.6 5(&25' $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') ),/(' .%@

>  /(77(5),/(' $33(//(( £ /(77(5 3')  .%@

&(57,),&$7,21 2) >  :25' &2817 $33(//$17 £ &(5,7,)&$7( 3') &203/,$1&(),/(' .%@

> $33(1',; 3') %5,() 5(&(,9('  .%@  25$/ $5*80(17 $33(//$17 £ > 1275(48(67(' %5,() 3') .%@

> $33(1',; 3') .%@ %5,() ),/('  25$/ >  $5*80(17 127 $33(//$17 £ %5,() 3') 5(48(67(' .%@ > 127,&( 3') .%@

$33(//$176 %5,()  $33(//$17 £ '8(  5(63216('8( $33(//$17 £ 75,$/ &2857 &/(5.  5(63216('8( $1' &2857 £ 5(3257(5 >    /(77(5),/(' $33(//$17 £ /(77(5 3') .%@

'($'/,1( 72   &21'8&7 £ £ 0(',$7,21 > &/(5.6 5(&25'   $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') ),/(' .%@

  &2857)(('8( $33(//$17 £ &/(5.6 127,&( 72   &2857 5(*$5',1* &2817<&/(5. £ 67$7862)5(&25' 12 3$<0(17 $55$1*(0(176 >   0$'( :,7+ 75,$/ $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') &2857 &/(5. )25 .%@ 5(&25' &/(5.6 127,&( 72   &2857 5(*$5',1* ',675,&7&/(5. £ 67$7862)5(&25' &2857 5(3257(56   ,1)250$7,21 &28575(3257(5 £ 6+((76(17 >    /(77(5),/(' £ £ /(77(5 3') 0%@

12 5(3257(56 >   5(&25' ),/(' ,1 &28575(3257(5 £ 127,&( 3')  &,9,/&$6( .%@

> 12 &/(5.6 5(&25'   ',675,&7&/(5. £ 127,&( 3') ),/(',1&,9,/&$6( .%@

  5(&25''8( £ £ '($'/,1( )25  3$57,(6 72 6(/(&7 %27+3$57,(6 £ 0(',$725 2%-(&7,21 72  0(',$7,21 £ *5$17027,21 ',6326(' 25'(5 > :,7+'5$:,1* 3') 0(',$7,21 .%@  25'(5:,7+'5$:1 £ £ 25'(5 > 127,&( 3') .%@

> 3$67 '8( &2857  $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') )((127,&( .%@

 &2857)(('8( $33(//$17 £ '2&.(7,1*  $33(//$17 £ 67$7(0(17'8( >  2%-(&7,21),/(' $33(//(( £ 2%-(&7,21 3') .%@

> 0(',$7,21  $33(//(( £ 2%-(&7,21 3') 2%-(&7,21),/(' .%@

> 25'(5 3') .%@  25'(5(17(5(' £ 0(',$7,21 > 127,&( 3') .%@

> '2&.(7,1* '2&.(7,1*  $33(//$17 £ 3') 67$7(0(17),/(' 67$7(0(17 .%@

>  /(77(5),/(' $33(//(( £ /(77(5 3') .%@

> &$6( %(*$1 ,1  £ £ 127,&( 3') &28572)$33($/6 .%@

> /(77(52) 3')  $66,*10(17 127,&( 2) $33($/ .%@  $33(//$17 £ 5(&(,9(' > 127,&( 3') .%@

127,&( 2) $33($/  ),/(' ,1 75,$/ £ £ &2857 -8'*0(17 6,*1('  %< 75,$/ &2857 £ £ -8'*(

&$/ (1'$56

6(7'$7( &$/(1'$57<3( 5($6216(7  &$6(6725(' &$6(6725(' '$7( &,9,/ &$6( :,// %(  5(7(17,21 '(6752<(' <56$)7(50$1'$7(

3$57 , (6

3$57< 3$57<7<3( 5(35(6(17$7,9( 0&&8//(<%5,$1 $33(//(( -2+1'+(5%(5*(5 3$/$9$16+($ $33(//$17 6+($3$/$9$1 7%:'(9(/230(17 $33(//(( -2+1'+(5%(5*(5 %28/(9$5'5($/7<//& $33(//(( 7,027+<53/2&+

7 5, $/  &2 857  , 1) 2 50 $7 , 2 1

&2857

&2&,9,/&7$7/$:12 &2817<

+$55,6

&2857-8'*(

+2125$%/(-8'*(&2817<&9&2857#/$:

&2857&$6(

 

&28575(3257(5

/$85$&87+(5(//

381,6+0(17



Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.