Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2015

David Raetzsch v. Barbara Lovings Horton

David Raetzsch v. Barbara Lovings Horton
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided December 9, 2015

David Raetzsch v. Barbara Lovings Horton

Opinion

December 9, 2015

Q3-/~S-O0 3/y~„CY TrA I CnuH Ca,jLse.A/o.C~/-/.\/-/'/-nc> 7?a6,

*& ]PlVfJ) Afr£TZStJ/; x JV tmu CoMTy ftfor/i-r \fipf€>/(g/ift fir* ±C / /*T.jm$. »"«<?& <?*/£, Y> X T%#i/a Csn^J-y , /£Xrt>

5T#Tji 0? Z£Jt*s Appt*UA t* +/><, C0VAT W /?PP£#LS £r Aa, TMIAJ) &fSTX/cr vf TSXA*, *t AWAf,/ TZxfil

fro Jd flap^/tcA^ ~7)Q) A/, J.tf&Tw. Ap-h, CIA flu5+r'fi ,'T*SSJ!> 7&7X2-

Pr* A<. Af/Jt/U'C •JJ A/~ PCroK Lot/r'/ifJ ^ /fffrfos) ft-4* 3*x /WJ7 $U3?/a , 7X**jr 7^/f/-;o7 (Te^-fry U Kyfc ; £/W Cnv** e£ &/*/> *-* k 77) }r& JJ / SYoV £rf 7^tt6 <T PO Be* /Z.SY7 A *s -h/A T7.* *$ 72V/- _ir. b"y/ f.

CQrusT/j-vr/^AJ <?£ tA* __fir/)m_ &£.. .7£xft)j (/#?*) Przczmklt, , ft/u^/yy /V>^A/*< -+A<- k/<m>'*< &£ /J*iM*y G-n/f •+kt jDCfSpU <?4'+U J-ftfl. *f 7^**6 J<? 0r&,* *JLe,s-A*MSs/ 'Lil j-h>> Cj0M+W'St't0A c f\RTiOJ£ jr. /?/// ,4 dUAts. — c?

AKK\ Tr-&> /jcr c/r^/i m^a^ m*y /6g- re (-0cr\ !zjl& */y% *J-fe6/n4eJC . KSZ, cLlcU ClfLCld'-c c ^e.L. H No r-i/SjStt/j '/•at-r j/\*tf ev&c /?& r^^'/</(^ ex. Gtra/sYfaf.*^ -f& a>*y 0l£cic4-l at- /Oi/d/^c rfrff+, /a •mh ij+trhc floS- j/&//g-ny */\e. ht, €x^/>4/^ hc(Jt,'Ai erHiU ok arr^vA* ft *A/Af reZ/etrtAjJetrtoti-K grpvMiJL /c &t,kf\o"l<jdl*ffe. *xtJ-fa>6C a/k /j/mLkCy (k&jL {ec, & hU men f\*»/, & n^-f^^af **dl /r>$>,&,*/-6/?. n'jAt- /v Worship fl/toutey CroJ. a+tord/y rh? +U J:ct*7-<?s *£ ^b/r~ 47At/A Ca/iir/fAo^ v Av0 /W/g/7 ^sna/A 00, Canys/fed? -/r? —flj£ef&- / Pirtfrt £)/ *Wj^y** any aAtts. <rft utartAtyi f/a- -/ft /*6>4+*/n any J_ m/fl/j/iyj acaA/>i4- h/s Cense*-/** NO nu^an A Ae-mprS/yj mc/& . A tny <c*s& hAa** 'hfii-ejJ&r jtll Cpn-hraA ®r /n+tf-fere. w'-fA -me, r/jA/l #A' ConicUrna.

W Mfirtffri &£ r-eAij/p/9 i ffiflJA OC7 r>r*/ere*c.€r ^Aix// ever Jl e n/iJgy) Ay /au/ ~fo a*\y r^e/rj/t?e/J _<&c/e/y &r ill. &U+ f* JAst/ fa -fa. ^fsrAr 14£/li Ati/vn* Ac tiaa JucA /au/j tj m*y far /Jec^s^ry

X ££l—(/Ij'vry £au CW*&_nilrn t/i i \ny—cs~G((& //> /Lj?_A^^-; mm u± /;/.? /A.n^L5^ -z/Z&sk span / / pe^sr*. pesens or repy-fa/AdA </>&// hat/a remAjAy by *£*& r^j^r fiAAur. . J$C- )$, JSlp yn<?.r.ifr, ^Shfi/A wsr Ale^ Ar+prt^eAt/ ~A?r rAlz-b+.

AS^A^Jly^ji^^C/^^ &A* jAjf jA-f-tte/ _f^#/A A7& ctep<nWft 0/ P'iei A^^/t l$rop>£rjyJ f po/S/yeij c>r /m/*>*«/-fSet; qr ir\__a,f\y ry)^im£jz d>< Ar^rtch^tAL / exc&/r/' Ay ^4 J^^ C0uri& frf -rk, AahJ oA'rfi^ Aa«JL* S.£L.JJ.± T%€ C/A/z.Cn-> J*6// have, *A* r/J-f- , A/> & n^dcyt/kk/^ manner; /~0 &sseA\//c -rxPcer/tr -far Wie/t ys rtA 9/t aptAJsr ^ Q0c/er-A m€n/~ A# r r<zdlr<z<3 < &^ QCf^ya-nc^S. <pr afh&r yr/rynej . Ay *?pYs'-S''*?* / ixJUlfzst &r rernon^/rcu)c<z , 5-ec- Z& A\w t6 0Kjgr crA Jt/jy)eicx/Af Atu/j //? y//-c v.^t^?-/^ jAtf./A &&, &x t^rc/jetx ^xc<?/3/ by -y/g/ L&a/j /c\~/csres*

Mj>^JD.&rh^ro~ L^^„j^iiigA_;. Appg//p,£. »^ .<*} o^Aim^uA iVi Air c.lvtl ^cfLoA „JS~ cV- )^r Z_33^S, Ju5+U*q{tU P*,ll^ Pr^an &^ f^jst-j -fln^ Ae.

Vip l&frA ]ft(il£Axjli^I1^ /extA.s CTQKJ^{\^f\j_jLsuL^5^c^lpn 2Jj2£^JI^K^_by_ £ C o Q±±$UJLh SjlA—\JJfiv1"C(L Ka&+ 2rScUt—n&ft&hjzndtls pro .5G.f proaer-ty ,

ntr ia return ctt+er ever a. y<*ar. Jus-f 1^ rt ±D iSnoW wKg.fr "fc±n& rrf Or\ Ho\y M!r\Is+ry n Ppe |1 fln-f On? je n^ no i'cIp^ .

N\ Before +Ke Jnoe-f on App^l PP a. VJor+h 7- flote. on Loving fare Hom&5 M/rt/^fry, ownrj! ftO(L fllirficfgfA, Iw \D <^<" b^HlL Lavi'oc.s h/nr'fon ( f)xr>e.ilee.

pro ,-se , Tke vjo<*S-^ rrslnUlry ckc-is 0c/f- re-fen -fp c f pnySiVftl b^il^W W+ £. wlir?U b«?g4v rrf jfteJi^grs In ^Pir/<f.

£b ft^gr^Mv er c.D(\ry<zccMon o£ ^go^le, J/>>5nv/^ jL&iJe ckpp^e -yjyy, r^b Aw whpnj ye^ wMl 5ecv/e.y/ >Jfrjtrc/& 3.lJ ft p .

\ he gflV&r nmg/W S^J^Z^U &~ S\fh'nar CV\olce- \\e.cov5e. )\<^

C^<y\-\^^/L—GLfsL &££la<&, by ~Af iS4<vW Corporal ^n 7 5 /a

y^^P ^ p£&p_l£i cv(Kb)<\<zcL inio pr pctf** as on*- VioJZy L*£ Corpus whi'&ti ^g-^fii p*>A/ « fVKriJ+i'f?/! C(m/rJ\ /<? r p\\o\<>\*y, Corpus Ah^.ii' dc hft^y ^f 6Arf^r /)\7*fr prjfy - Arom 115 \lLgjJL x •+"& OSfen wAL yic+orlou* 5oT\ q/JAJzoAL /^ertke<"<, coven aa-t^ -tocher ~h? Au>r+ker CMsAs lA^^£z>m l pre.^ch^ -tks Cy&spe-l anjL AL?sdp\iry oA *t^e odieai jAjk-VleW 3Lff? |«?-g.S , T^e rrvln 1Serves *rprp0c*-fe ,&*+vs " A Vv)g.ll e5fabl^kejL> I^A&tLn/ /£(/# . I G?r:ft4^ns IX\ \X-H . 17 £oj^jjgA^ )'-ZZ- t j^J Z3b t 30 t ggU?3>^/i5 / :?fr ^ ;Z.'79 JTgsvi f/iVs«/f j$4^4-^j /M^ /^WL/vi is rterf oC-fkJ5 \Ajor\£L \J^AaJJ£±3i Tex ^6 Gynsi.'-k^i'on fl^. L jec. 6 No no an v5^g(f ^ e cp/vipelfgJ? is2—(kH-er\(L | e.rec-Ht or ^i/pporf- any plme. &A u>oCssb"ip) or •to matn*fWn any j_ rh/n 15fry J cua/ns-P hit> Consent P-Cl l\j*)(lf\ Ip.a mart'\y J Qu gii£-) ''l /£ny Ca^il \s>l\*+<?</* r

1Q rY\(?--H"g^6 n£ rel»'g ig>A * ...

^ ft) t ftRoR , VoL 2, Pj. 7, K„g. /3 -to 1.,'n* /7 II jjWWra. Lov/j/igj Horf^n^ went- o-ff +ke recordL |Line.l3( the ^H^Q -f^e <Tourf Awarded. Mr. £&?+*<Ji llwrA.5. ^ ^js^^mg^s^MS££i^z 11-135$3\ ^ no + an ra,pp_£&J er -trial Je npugtf LiAg \L? flpp* A0 + Dbleci-zd . objection not ruUJi nn~ /Lp.p-£lUnt did not rgg'gve a\) t>-f rn's property nVt>\.l} flj. gt Line A-3 ^-tne Court-, Console, nt.'A jwe.

Ms. M&ffaA . iNfpticg lHRRoR, Vo_L2H_-^J4-t_Lne \^-\!> Barber*, lovin<\i> Hortor\ t nz^/zr CoQ/rt-er JuedL} n<^y)'nr.

VoUjJ^b L'n^^—O^jecK Ofi, Pg.^ Lino, U- IH Qbj>_c-h,ony Ko £ou*ltgr 6vlt. O/irruUti, * PEJERROR, VgLz^ r} ig Line 3-J Sc^bar^, L<}^^C3 j4of+ori , gcj/\ went orf record ~fa test^y about ^ej^££cie>_ij,u-j.t:, Ng. ttjL<^-W~^5&3i M property jKe. frtjlrni'-H-ecj ^teal^g Texas Qr^^ernMent..

Q°&&< Section 130 h. 673^ Aor hUeteA Ctnj- T7V)fRftpR t Yo>. 1, g. )8, Line ZZ-Z3 Perjury Barkers L&v.'nci Hor+prt does e>W/i Lo^lnc, Cere. Holies /v)..nl54 t Vol. 2 , P!lD , L/nft Z&-XS Czhkr^on hloi/se. of Ke<,torr^\of\ Ministry t is -i-he, n&^ > L.\Ae 3.-5* /s Perjjry

&. jg^EflfiOft. Vg), Z, Pa. 11) Ln. |X»/g T>ie lourt, Hc?Aor^.ble "YodjH T* Wane ) j+c?oaeiJL -fhz, pr&cefZcL',ACj$ to AmrL out exactly what -tnii ' T^'fi-I J)&- Ms^o " v<J^S all frkout ? Ju/iL^meot * J~5~ CV- IH' 1^5S95' lf 8)8, t>l+ CC w/frrf. <2>R/E o(5% MhlOH or rTuAymen-i ^tt-CV-lH- XZ583J # HOO.o^ +Cc w/TqJt G> RT£ of £% AMUtA Wh^ck wo^ not- ajyeaJeaL ^ge \/o/, ,2., Pj, 11 , Ln. f?-JU (C^rrdct Qhject)o n

In -fctt see p&cks ^7- 3A ?) FRRoR t Vol. Xt Py 3^ L.V *i- z5" tt$_ 3^W^ lp^5 Person testi-fi^- 1fWi'& £ounyfy ^.r?min^| vj^^t^e. J-n.5 ?Aa Out progr&vn Id 30 <£cnys rent. Tne -£V3t 3D ^y^. "^ ERROR .\telly Awe 36 The: Co^f is UcJl.'ag n$. D&r}) kre^ Li?v"^6 Ho^fon tfttc7 pep d^ucel*c. C^I^c^lA. Line, l5 X -f-nov/qA-t fn&t If tvo ^ ol&an -cut thU £>u '/ toJ ^ Knov^l Ch l/pl'l,, Py3?; L.> g, HrR^et^cA, flfpelUM~ g&kd! ~£r wr/tten ruj/nfi^ g>n ^bject/onj' to /}({gQed£ ' Lease frftrge/ngnY-j nA tKe. Hoo^rfllale To^ft T Wpo^ 5t^-feg< he* wpolc! OfW <3

Wf »tteo {jjSiUCLjS lA. B-f-fteA&JUt e*J>ke& Ao<r tro<nscr\ o± Appellant ^lc£. revest -frao.<gf/p+, Tfterg- are ^st,7/ no wr.'-Hen rull^, L»^eS ID- IX @) hRROR t Vo). ^, Lines ^2-ZS- ^Le^se" W/^e ^ fl^W, Lpvlf^y 1-t^tpn^ .siaAdL-^Ae^-WiLS owgj &lmftvf .six m>nn +l\<, rg^nt| an^L T<-Ryis £&v<Yty df/M^g.) Oj/vti^, A-nu&& Qvj pF-vc-rum s«?i<L \\

7.

Hnrfprt, <^!A yr>^ return tks. Hem*, ( nTs ncepec+yj ) al[ h' S Lifems_j person3J Ifpm^ g.-f- the, time, you remeve^L. irri rrpm :»i<?.yr pr&jp&'iy » :p"f/- b;», KK. HoH»>n - )ki £ er _ , u f.

JjcmA Kfi.ftfg3&i property uA-t.'l he. p^pzA m^n^V or TuruJU ovs/e.dLt VWft.t^4 I&t±s GfaMtMAt CqJz A>-^Jf'^n 13 0^ T lyeAt. (XL) ERR.0R .,. \f_oJ, A,__.o^.e^ ^-57^g Afp »!)„*♦ vTL^ Rket/scK fczypj^ned to +Ae Coocf that 3<^h*r^ u>-^*y porfon an&- TrgLy/is C«yv<\-fy Cr^,\<^\ Uisj+ice. - Ja>!JU. £W* «~&/n 7 W ko gw JXv^ P^p>z.<cA \a/^.«s cA\i&k\*.JL ) A^ no money -fc> g/7- )€>£% M XE,) ERRbfcyoL Z} LiWs \\-JLS-\ On lAarth 1*tIP I* hen, the. cLayAD^id. K^e-usck aoi out oAS-fct^ALli, 7 v //

/^ oxtQ.gr to_ stay, -t^ecz< TravK Ct?i>t>+y f*i<*Ua.\-Justice. ~lniiJU Out payeM- re/)<t -then} a*6L M^...Jjoxfeo. Ji^t^/e^L to fLf. >Seg VoL ± ) fpxJL 34 , l{n^Jl("i.y Mi. tiorfon -tes+jfioA. Inslfc £\rt pc.'cl 30 days, 77\*d\5 /)pr,7 20 /5.

00 ( \/i\\zs3 Ali. Ho'-cton cLovklt- clips J vv.A.n+5- to CoUfc^t- trtlr.e } -frnrm TrwL_CooD+v fl.nA -f/ig. Federal «< &overnrA<sn+ { AoAni Szc vri+y \D tSaJn Ifty ) j-h&ie. />/ia< were blank f>jL<. Sjj^'.riL K*eJ-z*>ct\ -ttLst'iA'tertl. tv> Up^ vlarkeAL oxjt- rA a Ja.ter cAate.

Ac+unly ft sicte* { The £e(eWf/^ rtwte. ' "L e^sc Pitchmen-}- \pc*d Rai^z>ch resiJU** t ,2)&H /Ja^he^s-4- j>, t q'fcO yn^t 1*+ **tke. rnry^k , "** <lf laU- -fee. „«JL ^ «5>* ^ fcfi<r~ t^*. 5Vrf|oj 3-^,?- ^ -fit* r£y ,LnJJ. #*e+rr,l ^j**- oo± J. /frgfe vX7- ^ S** noi+htx 7J J UlAJLAt S7# ^5" X 6 = /^ #Y 320, not * 2-,8)8*t>7 + cc w/m+- ® ftr£ erf ^^/9a/a>l;/vi^ Qr ^ome-M/Ae u/tterjy ri^i cu/i>t».s . ( jig) Vp), 2 jpzj&Jpl l.i'pes 2,3,^,^^,7 £&ffOft V0I2 +-p*y ££ . Lme £-/Z Tbe C^f\vrt rGauWes mJ ft**' <^ fv&efzj^A tg>~^ agy Ms. Norton flof C^'^bration Ho^se <*?•£ K^pr^/on H/nyStry * Not" a. ministry * S g ^Q nt>c 5

vAp-p-g-M ff ant already/ ^owe^ ( Vp/.2 H2^ p^^ ^^. L; ne

a Mirti'str f

9, Prevfau^y ^ J, stated aaX proved by r.fi,^el^p, :T3~ C\/- H- *3.5"g31 'X MoKoa Ta N/Af<rfy Tv/a^ment v dLenlzd ] * A/W/te Of Rzstr UteA flppeg)' AenJeclr Hs, He.cton ./©e Tenant- w^s noti-Aud _A -phe Con^tc-Me Precinct /7ve.. ano*- -the Co^rj-m Ta e j)efencb/rf- chof>e. no-f- ^ go +<g Court, Tn-e. VL^eten^rtt ^n^.s^ • n o £ ta_,a4^p_ejLL>. ep-pgcu t JuL^got >iS-CV'lH-Z5SS3l U £n*\.

The lo^rf g-f Appeal/ ; / hirJLADtS+n'ct cA Tex^rj n ££ ±h^ County Court No> /; hgLJ \xjfUii\cjtlon to Kezxr or re-hear tha.t cavse. . k\& apveal, . A/a Bgxi>Afta. Lp*/*j.s H&sH?r>] T)esAen ALcc* +~ yJS'-cV-M-2bSS3) j£JJL riot- CZtprn &\\ qA my , CDa^/^L &ufr*ttfgA,5 ^rpf^crty , gnil *:^^ In^jL no n'Af -h? t/?kft rf.

JSot -jor one, oL(Ly} one W££,k} one. mPt+h^ &«e. ye.txf not for ay time- at &Jl„ \$L*t<> Crov.Co&P, ^ect'^ CL* . -n./ I .M 7^ A 7 .fl^ef'cfln CDA^fa.' l/1t-/e< flif ^ I Ol ^^Ae^dL&K^'t Cc?nSiSt&itJy C-& r**\'tS perjury anJL Contempt of court u J-A prps acvtlen X Ua^e^ ShavJn rf . Look &+ Ph^nti-ffj £x,A.'j?/f /\/p. ^ -j^&+ skoun JW&yJs. County ^n^;*4\ \TojHc^~ Tni'de O^t Oc/dC Pr^k,^ t-w.'yj /tor-ton iM^CtciMrisfrle.tlHc.^l??. SO jsb* /.< try}** to Collet tw.Vg..

L/nce-tron /rtfvVi'.s CownK #*-v#. a^i^ -tr^/rj -Soc.'a I£etisr,'+y "yDi'saii /! fy ^QgJ^.[&_ ^»ppin.^j,...br ±h& ^LeASfZJple.r.z^mtnt^ l$ no cjo<od to, Pft/W£R 2a (XoocL -fait-A gr\dL t&r Q&oA Cavze^ ^A)(kstl<SL Ra-etz-ScKj flppe-lUn-t-j pray< -the. rnur4 te/QoIlK T^d B^rb^r^ Loviog< Hortfrn^ flpnglUa. /'n Cont^^ pt ^)t co^rt- cl per \ur or unl&wAul In her evil w&y.< . clS t^e gndLs <^T justice, may 30 f d- ¥ n^Awrtf I eSpZCffvlls J^nutttcL ^ uSajIA- /?&e.-/z-scA 11-5-/5 7/01 AA XH3S! Apt. /U ftu^ttn , /ex^s 73 75-1 C£RTtF)CA7£ OF J£#V/C/L S.^Da^rl KaeAtsi.li t An* w <l IUaF >f<znl Ay 'A- (yJM4/f LljIttt fcyt- /)r& fies?*W-t-/ire- yl< ja&., -A Q/i<Zs AO ce?/yy erf H/$ // Ajotce^ AjrJ*-f Qt\ r^ayy^aA; ,60 ^ha-f sAe. may ressxon or arts*/* 7^ ihrvfr\; gjt^AA^ *H& ^tA rAAay o^ Vyec^Ai^^/- ^o/Sj A/Ca, AJfisJi'Al fcAtxryJ- z-sc h tuu ±a; sQ(frhtx rs* LoUr'nji /V/7 /<-//;r\ /°D,P\0* J135A1 ftuAh'n. Tfi.x.^ 7*7/*/-.?S:3?

II- 03-IS' OO^j?-cV TRIAL COufiT CfiViE NO. C~t-t. V~/V~0O 79 6.

JtAJ THE CnuPT OF APPEAL* Trf/P® -Z)M-rrt/r-r OP T£XA < AUST/A/ / , TSXA.4

T)A\/l£> Aft£rZJt.tf; flpa e//a/i+ 0r*7 .<*. )Cl. BfiAftMA kCS/NfrS tf0J?rOA/.'j H 0,>«*//**. />* e //-ge Are />. :<e.

BR/PP 0/J APPEAL." Atm*&UL. (DP £XC£/>r/0N&* TO TPP t/PA/£>PP8L£ Vup&gJ. IW fMA,*, C0t/*r CP PPPPPL5.. TS///ZZ) <DMT/$/sr 0 f TZX/fJ t COMES NOUJ. -J)*v/d /2a.*.*£.icA . Ai*«'.//flA+ ase 5e, f\dre/n , anp/ an or ^-hoist -^Ae /£+£ &P A/cnemher . 2.0/.<r tfUJ. a. &// o-f £xA*.a/-/on$ 7& Record /)n Aa***/" Ay *PeP///c>r> /C- lVr,'S PS //aJcaj )/ 1 r^ram" . „ ' '.„ Oajo.i/ /-#] , '. a/n#a <x * Sn'^F &r> <2 , r- *

.ftRl£f 0A/ PlPPtflL .Asu't^n* nf£-rror< £ 0/1 }f/fv-//0/i etf fte ^feJe, k>/Tex-as . /)r^,'t/e T.

Sec V, jet, b Jec /3. Set, /%, Uc, /9 , Uc X7. a*J i-ec. XX.

RECEIVED KC 0 9 2015 j^ vgg ERR6AS <><ue 6- // Error •£* f p rror J2. ; Errtr 777', / £rr#r 7P"V ErmrZ^T.. Errr>r~VT..^ Error T7T, , Errar ~F2ZT,; Icrror TIT . Error IXZ , Error ILL .. Srr&r ZJ2L /

and £rror JUT, >

JLUPfJQM Y p egsUJL £M£M£ n»j*,// r.FPT/P/CPTP- CJ£„JP£v7C£ n*,.*. //, / ^/

The error6 3Ae>\*; l/g/um-e P&&*, y and. /-/r>-e.< .

I&y}y£±£jj^.JdLmi±t&£+

/rflO e/ZavE Pltv.se

~iy< •

L V ,lv ^y 3 O N

«- -r c 4 <3 •V tg § V

L CO Mr I* 7 O

cs/ _r o N

<=i r <^ CQ

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.