Ali Rassouli v. National Signs Holdings, LLC, National Signs, LLC, Louis Girard
Opinion
ACCEPTED 14-15-00353-CV
FOURTEENTH COURT OF APPEALS
HOUSTON, TEXAS 12/21/2015 4:57:50 PM CHRISTOPHER PRINE
CLERK No. 14-15-00353-CV
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS FILED IN
14th COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FOURTEENTH DISTRICT OF TEXASHOUSTON, TEXAS
AT HOUSTON 12/21/2015 4:57:50 PM
CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE
Clerk ALI RASSOULI
Appellant v. NATIONAL SIGNS HOLDING, LLC, NATIONAL SIGNS, LLC and LOUIS GIRARD Appellees and Cross-Appellant On Appeal from the 133rd District Court of Harris County, Texas APPELLANT’S AMENDED REPLY BRIEF ON JURISDICTION
Lloyd E. Kelley Texas State Bar No. 11203180 THE KELLEY LAW FIRM 2726 Bissonnet, Suite 240, PMB12 Houston, Texas 77005 Tel 281.492.7766 Fax 281.652.5973 [email protected] ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT
ALI RASSOULI
APPELLANT’S REPLY TO APPELLEES’ JURISDICITON BRIEF 1 Appellees1 again want this Court to “fix” this flawed case by inviting the Court to enter a final judgment by referring to it as a “ministerial act.” Everyone agreed at oral argument that this appeal is defective because there is no final judgment. Appellant never agreed to any final judgment because Appellant has always asserted that the matter should be sent back to the arbitrator for a final award. No one disputes the fact that arbitration award has a blank that needs to be filled in by the arbitrator. Appellees would prefer for a court, whether it be this Court or another, to procedurally decide the case with the award forever left blank.
Rather than simply agree to voluntarily dismiss this appeal, send the matter back to the trial court and then back to the arbitrator, Appellees again want this Court to spend time writing an opinion dealing with all of the clever legal arguments made to date, plus add another dissertation on how to fix the jurisdiction issue at the appellate level. This appears to be a great waste of time considering the proper and expeditious thing to do is to dismiss this appeal and send the matter back. Appellant filed a notice of appeal out of an abundance of caution so as not to miss a deadline and forever lose his right to assert a claim for the money he is owed. If it remains possible for Appellant to proceed with another arbitration before the same arbitrator and still receive his award and said award is an offset to any amount awarded to Appellees, then Appellant has no objection to any course of action that ends this case. However, to the extent that Appellees want a final decision by this Court and then attempt to use that as some waiver argument or res judicata argument, then Appellant strongly opposes any attempt to make this matter final without an order sending the matter back to the arbitrator to fill in the blank on the amount owed by Appellees or language that clearly evidences Appellants right to obtain a final award amount.
However, it still makes no sense to Appellant for this Court to spend any time on this matter and make the interlocutory judgment final and then everyone still has to return to the same arbitrator which then Appellees would appeal again creating simply more work for the courts. The parties agreed to arbitration long ago under the premise it would be quicker and cheaper. However, Appellees strategy is to try and keep the litigation lasting as long as possible. What should have been an easy resolution of the current issue, both parties simply agree to dismiss the appeal and return the matter to the arbitrator, has now become further briefing on how the appellate court could perform a “ministerial act” and decide this appeal in a manner in which Appellees could claim they won. Appellees should have agreed to dismiss the appeal and return this matter to the arbitrator. The fact that Appellees have not agreed to the simplest solution indicates they see some advantage to having this Court work to issue an opinion that would have to address a multitude of matters and may even involve having the Court guess as to what the arbitrator intended. Rather than guess the most prudent approach is to simply ask the arbitrator what her award says or should say. The arbitrator occupies the best position to decide the issues that were originally submitted to her.
Appellant request this Court dismiss this appeal and remand the matter back to the trial court at which time Appellant may request the trial court send the matter back to the arbitrator for a final decision on all outstanding matters.
CONCLUSION
The arbitration award contains a glaring whole that Appellees have gone to great lengths to keep from getting fixed. National Signs is trying to avoid paying Al Ross the money it owes him for wrongfully terminating him. National Signs opposed sending the matter back to the arbitrator so that the parties’ post-award motions to clarify or modify the award could be decided. National Signs filed a lawsuit immediately after the arbitration hearing concluded and then when faced with a motion to compel arbitration non-suited the case to keep the arbitrator from having jurisdiction over the parties dispute.
As consistently advocated by Appellant, there has always been only one real solution. In the absence of an agreement of the parties to send the matter back to the arbitrator to consider and rule on these issues, 2 the obvious solution is for the District Court to order the parties back to the arbitrator for a final decision on the amount owed to Appellant.
Respectfully submitted, THE KELLEY LAW FIRM By: _/s/ Lloyd E. Kelley____ LLOYD E. KELLEY State Bar No. 11203180 2726 Bissonnet Ste 240 PMB 12 Houston, Texas 77005 281-492-7766 telephone 281-652-5973 facsimile Attorney for Appellant
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on the 21st day of December, 2015, a true and correct copy of the foregoing, Appellant’s Amended Reply Brief on Jurisdiction, was served via e- mail upon the following:
John H. McFarland Joyce+McFarland LLP [email protected]
_/s/Lloyd E. Kelley_____________
Lloyd E. Kelley
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.