Caldwell, Robert Franklin
Caldwell, Robert Franklin
Opinion
% `E v\por‘c» Qn\ c§\m>_\\ . § _,, 4 q@,\@/!U'(c) /\sn.c>o'\-%\L¢L..@\~<>\w-Q» y D,N \'“V‘NO~ L'L° \\°‘A"\ "m ¢qunrRcE¢%E\\sY\E/m APPEALS» ]UN 1 4 2915 w (\.pp\\c.c,r\°c~p<o~ss_ ¢ _ § |'° -T‘°' 1 Gl k vs_. . - » _ § .CDTX U£AbelAcosta, er w B*r h 1 T § l 'i' °‘ R;Q(N:";:§ (:r\m\r\cx\ Ai>f)e_o\s Mr>"r\z:>u\\ §'0(’~ "I\BDU GY\\A gm (\?_Cufd& T\e_ (\?\<>noro\s\; Suz§qe_ §§ md G>m‘\. % comes nom ()\¢Sb‘ir)t . Q\émg§\ `\r\ ~\\\€ G\dz)\§e omA , v \ymlg M\ m ~.m\ wvm mma xvi ¢me<,. .91 m \W&\»\. cwa H-e§¢ fha c.§p\;;ns\¥ \a os¥f\»\~e` *r\\n Wvvs\~$\z\» §uz\g<»_<sd in or \nx i\\e ‘\`“/` ® \s’fr\'¢-\ (“\?v\`\ §§ §m€d\ (`ouc§» jo pf¢su\z\r. jr\\£ c\@pllz<m‘c \u\.”§c’\\ 3:\\€ Y<?>\\oua'\c\<§ USX_M\A u.j\\xc\\ u\$o \r\chmz\e,cl 0£ (‘0\11§0`»€ recorcl&. ` m`\'\\ 3\:\1.¢ I§'\\S \\Lrnmo\\\n G:u¢~\ :X\~c¥ a\\ fbi ?\?rmws\"ts §}\a\c `\s p;ms\c\zr\ m §\\J$ ]"\unm H*&v \s .@resw‘c»r§ 3m ¥ms Wws\el‘n\, bd \z amd 'H\i<e¥orj§\\ \Cc,\e\aors\j§_“m~é <§Ux\m§irciz fm .H\€. Couc~\ .H\eé< §\\& o\\er:.€é c\@p\_\mv\)€ max Q\\AYG§. `i& \IL>\<\ m~@l :H\?. S\<:`v `Q‘c@\ u.»\¥\\ vr\c.\\ou- » §§ ab ¢\&9;\\».¢_ arm @W\,m.\§~ §§ Q. £<.\Hw@x. urge Ec>\\bbd'\w§ C\C)Cumen`\(s mt ’. \. \l\<\\cf\’mut\~ ;l. \}\`d\m §‘\c,>(mvne.\\§r C$u>or~r\ or ur\suoorr\\ . 3.'\`90\'\¢¢ repor°c ‘*. \Waz\\cn\ (\epur)t ` 5- §\c:hn\er§< ¢)`K.Y<a<§\’s \sc>\ \ \lo\& ‘u\\¢\er came m. m'\-i‘\uus~§'\ (». i\e.\)occ.‘um\\ec\om 'lx~e\e~r cause \\c:>.am~%\L»L»Q-QW dot ‘¢-:LB-aoou> ‘).(` vi W \\¥ umwa \L\X _ S. (`¢c:gg vi T;;\o§\'\q;v€wcnx.:exm¢‘)\§ §§c§>o(ic§m S;ic\l~¢¥ \r\uesb<¥fu& ike rpsa. q. G,P.§ 01 G\\ fumes w mr sx<[email protected]§"w m gm ¢AMM. '. ida é\-\eur`\r~<§ §§ em.\ eu'\r\e,x\c§ 'mi\\ gnm\z\o_ de <m§ `nw e.(p\\c;m¥ ‘\s e.s\\\\~q §-\us ‘\Nsrm\\\z C>w~\ 61 (°\ppm\s ja (G»Ao :H\€ tm se in am .z& w <w \)@v.-¢ di S».\A&\\ ab MW\.R w @whm“x m°\\:\\ "Unfase; _Sm`r\ c\ocx.\mw€\§. _(P;a;;:& mg \ ’W\£ §\\'_\s ¢.£ Crvm»¢\c.\ Gpp€/A\s \_\.»‘\\\ qrc,n\» i\\:s }"\§»:`;v ames ¥\~z Clvy\\ 01 §\\e ‘v“»'héwr& (‘Q\AA 01 Sm%ch .Cwn\:j iv +'re\\\\c%_\\s\\ ~H\tsi §Q_\A C\ocum\€/=€cs.&\`o<\~ ma v\e§e\aox\\ dz> .~H\i C\Q<_)§\_\ccr<\\_ Cns% . )c.\zp\\c_om¥ o.\so p:c.\js }\m\ Hu's °T%\zs\c.\:l» (°uu¢~\» (`rvm\m\ C;}p‘:;\s \1,»\\\ o»§cm\ euervxr§\ux‘q '\»\*d\ \v\ Hus I"\uv\m\) oml,m\§ L&`\\$: <:\wwnks is r_é$'e'_\s on€c jo gus m~c;\is;r. » b b 7 Ul\\%um¢\\ (`-DSC\OJG\')¢::\.
I ,§. Q&\¢\\A€\\ Cls`c\g\r\e. L\A\“\.\\\ & €rm oil TBC;\~IB .c’\\o \\€§a&s ”Asr\me under \am~¢x\»` 139 \)€.rxm\§ :§r\~<r\ M\e rec§o{r\q Mnn<z¢§or `\(MDIS\L%JM m~e\ gov (X£Coro`_\. '\\\€. ‘£z§~ §§ \m\.. a\d\\_\j_ni jo :P&\£ o`£ mm ec\cw, ' Ex¢=»_cz;\t\& ` . § \'>m¥}'\'£d » 1.~ 4 ~)L» Cm\ Aus€l\ F\o\>uusm `~~ Qm s1 C<;r‘c\§’~\c&c\uv\ § Sec\s\cz l S."`CQ\AMQ\\ ¢\€C\C»re c,$tm» md curvu»)ré§ cn\\\.§ u`~§ ;H\¢.
C»\)u\)% lv\c~f\ur,\\`:’oc \s\>\s\‘:{~ lxi‘bv\c§ §'or P\SCQFAS mem \m\ck\\ in Z\:§\%.
T_\me G>ur\ § Crvm\m\ (`%Lppzs\\a ‘D.o?zm \930% X`\c:¥\m\ §\u§n..\ ,`Tm_as '1%'1\\ ’Fb~€ A<apué.;\`\ns\\. ¢§v‘~&'aw~z. \`M {\\a @o§w\ U§}\a: on -.H\e @o\qx\s.\\»\`llau\ :\¥\o§c ¥}\232 SmA i"\§t\m is Y\ss¢.\\§\ \\<x\~c\td ‘u> £\z %pr\szm o§$\c\¢.k o\b be mv.,\\
_\Y\esc ¢=\omm¢.»,¢\‘\; mm m~c.\\ u`vm 6”' <LLA am__L@__\ CR¢»;,¥ &. ()AA.,¢€A\ _<>3:»4<. ~ (\W\'\ca'<\"< ~~ pro -s.o. 7 /uz>. m‘)~<zcc.,uq»q')[email protected] @Wt\r\uz. #)¢.. \qa~n> @\@b<;¢’c 3 . Ca\z§ma\\ ' § in The N ‘opp\\cc.v\\ ~~mo 51 _ w C>u.\» .& § vs.~ ' » ‘5' 4 1 m 3\@&, 31 TM z C~m\m\ \\W@A\§ opp'¢\\ee \QES\\U\\C\%\ § moen z>§ m C@UA @r\ M\`@s §\r\e ’ c\c.\§*\>'; %.__________a@ \c., come low iv be cmmz\avc¢l }\\)s pm-:» flaum jur \M\)P>< big md .Y~.:»r R€curds b G\~A \~\‘A\>'Yv<)y§¢au§am 'H\t mmc . \¥ \s ux 3:\\& L)\)`\c\'\m\ 43 £\)s Cou¢'~)v i}‘e@\' :H\rs P’\mum S\~o\~\z\ be ls £u`\\\er`.
-):}\+; A\§\r\c§ (‘\‘€3`\\ §§ §c\\?.."\""_(\§v\§(\`\c)s Cm¢‘\ ug G<\¢\m\~:s) mm\e:o.
Tr|s:j~w um¢~\er ha musa r\um‘nu 00'1~%\¢,@<’.-<>\'\ u\~¢\ p;\e@c\re. ¢H xc{v\ A@¢Lmm w w nw m ._»<px\@¢\ mm.m.m Q\\ A<,mmmk n xmm % m~c\ \a prescr\\>n¢l \r;v\c.u¢ ¢}‘v q\\\\r\o§o(\o:\)\ccn% occes§ id couc~\. n \s £u'\')\tr ‘. adam m sam nw wm@ @.\\ mma mm cwa gi@y@hm ma ¢1}\2 n<s_aasx'a:\§'\<\:~.`\r\.\¢m¢m\j 493 sam ordm
'_\uo<a\; (\)r saying €zw§\ laws q§xg\m~ Q)m~¥ r\>.£us€- :h> er\’€nr`\tx\rx»@\©>‘a»~\ §.. Gc~\d\n+a\\ @(~pen\ o£ \\.°\s \\.o'\. Cow\:q¢ jr» H\a \c\o§¢\`\ o`¥r ')`sao §410363‘13,`5?0(£)5)»¢ (_`vw»».&no \Q<io¢‘.}§@g; v. LB.\ csc Gw\ 344 aoo§.mad lam (!3¢\®. ¢?uc»:sv»¢m '. M "`M» Cc“m c. s’s@éc» \)uo\n§u §»¢.R.(\[email protected] sa.\\€cd md W)b»o\ 5a Q@§@\\»M w wwx\<§~u\\\§sé m p¢'\szm w%wn ~§~}\v.s§ab% PQ\\ md \\o§ haw §u\)m\“th$ maj €u\A/e/<v;s. §§ Gs§§ra\ra’(ac%’ &SS»QUI Umrq__€< chc.c\\cj LST\ ~&D L)..)\)\'<'J KN¥Q,.;<,,_,_ '\.\59>'3,~`;, '\G_§_,_/_g=_;;_w \(J S`\_,\}-;cq 35 4;@,3=] ®wxno `_%
~\\c»nahs»\ [\\»\ \‘)“s§\avo\, mdz.x+)\ mar s». CQ\AWA\ r@@u¢§x% w saw ,,,@,<\@§m nw U\£ 0¢`\<3\0¢\\ 01 H\‘i ee\\u»o`\r% `d\Qfxc\\i\cx ~ \. W’X \<\m\)c 70 A\\rr\cl.\& v § 05' T>XA$ C)\\EVT\A'?\):T\¢)¢\\. 70 REQM‘EST 9mm \\'a\u€% '<"€\\€Y occ N’¢un\ \N\\docmc€. \m‘n\ l .‘?\M_Aw§ of funds amd car\ch)s\m § \c.w Q~. .)/Icrr/om ._j’i)`cr have 70 S£€l< am w `T\m€ (’\N\Uo »"3. Mov`»m S’o¢» humana bs“(u\§ v@\umes ex §»»pp_\‘a¢mzm\ .»Qcu<z\ w\kh \)@\uvf§\ \d»d a md \u*_~s plaaémq ;\v m u€sX-_,Mus'%wnq\i.\»(fw¢~\@_éb asme mo (D\LOW _ raq_;,{w\’n &‘¢\e T“?Lm Dm’.&r\c:\ \`)€s~\\ 0€3&)~1 \\A'°'Dcs*t)\c} (`w~»'* 40 prdl)\d¢ V ;§)$s. c ah .munz\s under \‘ng»s<z m cn'\-z\u.*\~‘%‘\ §§ app&\¢<.~\¥ \a?o<»§ ’Cv\'<»&. \A)\\e._reeure, f§,`c\g;,)_e_§\ ..`x<ao&c€.§:\ M\)S °)"\lsj'\c$[\o\>\e 0£ fix grc~\\ \*\;'S_i:zq\`xes§<&v¥\b cna tow o`¥ \\)`s Q»\.a/ocl\`x\<§%'\¢\ “l°§;,@§§;p "°`§§fvé’f`f.,q` `*§§;‘,’ M"“`“§`;,‘A""”°°"‘,;M“Mll m w w w mw ` diaz 0 ` w m bn cvu;=\mth &~jmlgum\y§»c¥§nvimv\o_exiecvk§j~c@ c gg_r§crn (°¥\c\rq.¢ ;\>~.C\Ss\\)\ 'upm\ \w p\sc\ w'\§ho\%\ u_§£>w\\‘¥.nu\zl\»mj¢.&alp‘)<rd .H\. &w<\»..¢~.l-
\e\&\\o:§u&».h».vv\*fw~o<\xm m\d.wm <Rasz`}sa§$l.\\»& §u\>\\\w ®Mw <z…m CP@Q 5a @A€\M\\w>;»,w<, (\Qf)\\(_&r\)¥ *‘Q(`O_'§-‘- Q»L'ons§\‘¢` zem `&.r'\ m 3 C`>'?»uvw§xi¢n\ ,`K< 'Y\BS\ w A _U/umm¢\) ‘B<ed/s<mjrm ` 4 111 @\@b€s\¥ §. CQ\AM\ \>&;i¢\<§ €csr\£\r\e. wA)\\‘r\ &}\e.mjshm<`.¢§*`{'©£§~fnb do ‘r\‘€reh§ ds;c)!=.czzuc\xc\<a: M\z \;>m\\x§ nix ptrjurq H\& ,£Q»'¢GAL°>\N§ J‘“\cwl')»o for .. ~ `l>€!~d\)£ §1»£\\1 M\E. u!~ p\&rr\\t§<j `va`\?u£ <’/wd Cuzr\rt@. &ec»dzd ~ _ ` &1*5“\`?§3’3 . ..___._______...5* 6 "H” §\ (:a\c§me\\~ » Q\_<€- % , l P\@b<a§<p ja @\\c\»)‘ek\ c§is;\¢>.cas. c, °<5\»,» cm\ ;Q<HA~ €0\)\3 01 352 drum md Q)re`qo`uvi _3"\01¢<»\3_5/¢>¢\1 \_£n\)<a`)(v frb owe cows of m \’\’Lm\)\\\£s wm S&¢W) _upur\ H\€ Wwnci\>h Aur§<}€' \<€mzsz~< L\‘?\\>S~`:Q\\ 0~& (\§.(§s\. [§'11’~ \T\\c)‘oe}\ ~\.\»\\%¥ mo I\) ’ 100 f\rh%.svor§uoavj "`/"-FT€!* _ ' i f ,‘7’@/)5 ")570\ ' l ')5")03 }Z\ annum t U\u a ~ o ~ m - w ®o&~¥j`&kiwe.\\ cab be Parf& \°\§o'ir¥ 5a (Yc.\z\me.\\ .f<.\ns \m F\m\m jur \usm)z b §.ls=z§mafc‘b<>:\ 0$' {hs, p\ms,»<g ‘M\A;MA serve all p'ar‘cm §§ \¢\‘\:ere£c as f.,~\\u-.@‘»
‘l\srvs\a\»h »§ue\@_\s \{Qsu\\< \».P\usaz\\ /lsS_DwY-A_v'-' `-/V\CH\A€L S~\»\PES" ¢ _ mo l®.‘\?)$uc£u¢cg _ , _V 199 M\w‘xd°~"*§) ¢/{‘i¢£il,§/@.-»as l v ~ . 7?19\»7‘ ’@`75`7‘57 ¢)s')ol ' Ex'lacj,~v¢-.Q @\f\. ' 6- 0 w~/zo /\JG. Ldo‘d~-‘B|L»l»<i~ ‘i"l- G\ ‘ wl\c\x>.uu.i<€~\~\o % j E 1 h C@\A m . mayp\)\\cdv\\ :D\\ppc\\a¢\xf m DEDS,CLMA vs~ . d 775+: §fnh 0§ % &m“c`q APFUA\S Appe\\+.<a," N’\M\ m ma C<>usrr =<'9~ +m a L&.f_____@@ am ab ha fcsr\s)z\z;z;\ c, \;m-s.»o:§\m»m jun l.e¢v\»z:`l§) ink ama mpg o?`rma W£Ad\¢(»¢_\ Gw\$;¥us @oue\ fm\m §am\€. 1a 033 M op`u\'uiw\ Mvé< Sm`d J/\m¢z):_\\ shaw ha @i\w\wex> m °Bm\\-Sx>, @Y\DU\ 0\ .§X\a Clis\\ ..’n>%pfep‘arz gm H\a Cow=\» o¥ Cr\n»\\m\ c.ppmk Au;=§ ash
*.mq<\cr\lme. m ¢>H?s\a r\¢;csascm§ \rw°_¥mmvv<¥ du ’\\i¢\o_ p\mc»»»<\v oppa 0£ \m \\.m us- cmm muow~s»\m§a~fz'\~c», %
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.