Caldwell, Robert Franklin
Caldwell, Robert Franklin
Opinion
. » 1 ‘ % ¢,\@`\O\d/\O l`\)o 007~&1@(9<?-<1') ~@ W“’“° 4“""""° @OURT‘§F.:Z§.'MV.§HL"S.»EALS hint {,\,7;,@1uvo142o1s @ w N:S A£e| ACOSI&, C|erk ' G\a\\nq\ \Bpp?,m\s _W)e §’ab ¢N 'Te»:<m » W\cwuy\\ .Y“or \)€A\i€ To S€€\< ah ug R£u\m »QND ” W\o“nm joe bank T) ila pape: &e€€d\m as 3\\&:\3 wis %/\)0(1‘5“1 Qbda€ G`cu\\\\~a,\ (°umss nw R@brr¥§.@x\dme\\ mc¥}\w\ H\a ("mr\\)<¥\ di Hus ‘Wnomi>l» (“w¢~'c ne Fnm\m\ (lq)<zn\s §Lr\<§@ rur\u\\€s <§chxs WM\)L» Q)Lw’< \io_&§\§\<ew §§ m¥ de~h»xx\b Feu`<em °\~\¢Mra‘oh (°wr=\\n§c.s\\;n\ \\a\xecs §e\\e§. lhjs W\mwo\r\la (aa.u\k mg Cr\cn\\m.\ \QW‘&\S ls§u€ 0 (;_*>P\Ax mild mm \O`Q"\~&ON .H\& (§?n\\aj m\’d\ uu’c \ur`§t‘r@x\ ore-lew w even u)`\f¥\uu’v di~'°f€rnx`sm§ u)'r\~“dr§\»u~‘. ¥ c\» silk @\ mvla¥§ c.s\)o\ck¢o. £(Cg\\ ’c}(\}:<`\§new\ec$p§(`c;`;\s@r¢j €\:}J:)i:/Sr\co.u;))&s \/rr~ci§\c‘mr&aq Q{G‘vj\; 131 $`r.\}¢.e u)tm\o\ W\K Q»\Am bn c,c\:il$e.»er\¥ vem\¥ u cmu¥\\~a~ \:v\'¢® hicks r@c&m N\<¢\ (R@o<a»\ 5. (°¢\A\»s,\\ 3'2<;\<: m\ elk 0 J®mz Qu\ew. (V\\'r}¢u\d few \38\\)& b\h£.\s iY 8~¢<:€€¢1`\ 23 l is S§mi»¥ .?. Q~\A»;e.\ Prsaan\ \us §$A\\u\\"u\uo \V\m'g \\As cm:ah\xk¥\\m r~\ov\¥s diem usa oQJr§/¢r\& reucew % w‘§]\'e A\~\\Q\;\ (`uw\a 053 Crim\m\ \C\gpu\\s 3m mae 1&\361\3 power ,h> §r<)<\’< ve\\e¥. um Sc)v\e<x&$orax\u-¥%\m<j\nux§ E§S:€n\’c»¢§ <; c:g§rum‘nb \\a\)e_os Co)rg§, c\eclw\é_ M\z .H\'<: c.rw>KcaKu/»Q¢\a, /\)l. M\e QQQ.A@\...\ 13 c.’§r§'orkkk§r}\m )/\m»wo. % ‘ msa magnum dow [email protected]'e 136 \\.0'1§3<5 '<)»Hv)c\zod `\@Aoe K‘€rr¢§ l._[\uuss'e'.\\ _§b<e.\n QQ\¢‘A\ 09 eaja Gwl Co'r\(‘ln&'\m §§ \ouo .mJro ns§'a] c."v\'u\c\m§ (Y\\c)r\ae\<§.\x)‘e;~¥ .\v»£\m! §\w=\m §§ md cm\c\n's»~ /D?'\ D .Gu), ' ,~ N€‘¢`\~}\e¢~ Q\ur\ s w approve G(L¢”ornei,§ (S§GEM\QS C.Ccuw\pqia\n\iu@xh d Q,A\¢q(s% P¢A§ mv cmch@wn 01 m umw cwa m no w~z\u°,,<z~¢rwc._ &u&b`\a.r amax ark um 35 mrk%\csv'\ud @)r §§Ns‘ ‘}\uw\u\c\\dl& Q)ur¥ 09<» G\a\\m\ ‘€3\\ jo \reu»<e*m M\a v”ec@rck <Qur r€ASu:\\ \Q\Cb€;~¥ S\ Q\\dma\\ p;€a<znw his r(`c\§:`“r\`)§r\\;€§::@€i\& m b:e& Y<wm% §%~¢& ¢MA Mm J\s)ns¢m ‘<\a repwesw¥ u\)m\&s\¢j¢\£ ' §‘<;&')`v’h\a;\}>m m\\\ S€\ upun Cl§r‘s€min\\ 041 .l§d\s.ss bu€i<}‘a(§) md bg ~ Q\‘EAAM\<R,Y\QYIC€ §§ S))bnrr\c$§\f)w\l "\\‘a).\€ b€€/r\ pims\rled. ` \»G\\‘£Si§ot€ l 54 \f u'€.§\ G`urr\\m\ AW‘€A\S @§§ni\‘<§§\nw gaf U.X\K :§‘j¥~=ww\"£ f Q\l(€uo \r\c.b§f\§ (‘\&\m Cew\ &.\s cm c\ \J 35 MQ\<§Q\;\¥ \¢»\ §§\& €Quwrv\ UJYAQ~QM .H\AS \\or\cxf'c\\f\\e couc\ Qr\m\¢\a\ Y\\p<zn\s .jfo% Qca}\wn .Ye\\e§ Suu<§\’x.
A @B{,€A&\\g mma ®b&v§* \Amd\ (§W§;\c¢»\v$<-~ p.ro (Ua\)dmm\\ 586 \Mxpvxjiam£. jj (’\@`\os»¥ LY\QQ\A u)e&\"` 95':0% To'c\\icb hung c¢n\g¢\e Lu&\w\ _‘H\e wa&k ¢§% P¢»\m‘<\.$ Uc\`dv r\icmvz. mds H\z perm 0*>» (>Q»\\M\,\ Jd\<r& M\‘a ¢Q¢){¥C§o\v\cj __no'rc<_»\\ \SJCHLQ Qrv~d€o¢v€c“i _&\\t b'€§\ ~ mmi G*>§:\x\'g. <\\,\1@ §,um&k=<~a Q~)»@»x ge <MM>\ QQ(§;\N_C<M¥ ~~ Qz)'s».
CQH:~%\<A’W¢»\ u`§»§zru\`a.
J'_c\cx,\m» M\¢S= c\;ua. end cmrec§ wm 0§ q\dou~¥ § (`A\»§we`\\ .)’\01\0¢\\ ha A beams T> Saa\< OLA <>$Z%T\mz ()\'a\j\ew wi }’\crau»a jan bmwe 75 _‘?.h» Pépey S»ce<a~ o\m as §}\zz\s cum seyu€@\ u{)cm .Qjf ‘¥\mno\)&. ¢\m\cve K&\zcc~e b.§\ua:>e\\ and §L .Qe <~Ac§y€ss §§ 100 M. /‘!L€Jl."('¢o¢¢as "\$’10\~¥>13~.9:}\€ wang 043 g HS.U"\AA m Mus H\; 655 €9¢:13 Q‘Q$uv\§a mm fhwa §§ Q-\rm; W@\u>@\\"`$:zo% Aqp\\c<nr\¥ z pro s)~ fpo\urt\$\<\>\rl¢\ l\_e]< n SJV\ 350 3- ` ¢L)vr~`l,v§§'m\._,'g/; ’\’_\BSW
__ \;_ §"\‘<t 'R‘* C'ar \ ` E§I\,=. , \ ¥ §§ @M\yv:s \r\jwy*af£v _ 'z a@@@ 3 Q»\M,\\ mm M.,)@m Wv ¢Um»,e, w 09 w /V}uv)¢»o £»» l>€)'~\\>z.`§v S'ie\\m§ €,Q`Bme .§iu\ew m3 y\o~no¢\\ gm \ )<an\xe§r» £\L» pages €_\<;c'aeé\\\~% 95 B`r\€r'_k umw SQS`\\Q@§\ upuv\ .W\'evgz\\unv~cd fig WRFES‘\.
758 ')Am\ma\>\@ §w\q~e K&£wu LWS:@\\ "D ei\lm§< §§7'70\12; Y\\c\<\anl \\.\x\es¥
loo n).%rocé§m»».\~e nn I\).'\`:so<.~.z§u>@\j _` C//e'i°@x¢@as /c}`¢er. / as "‘7$701 °75")0/ EX éicw?m @,A`. br [»~ /Z@ w o(o€r\l' {»{ {66107 ~ ~ D/`O€~v., "[`e:r~os Cnuc)§ § C»r`\m\r\u\ ”RD.B)\¢ \33>0% (`_o\>r\o\ 3 ci<;m\ \\u§§\<\,'_(_w)~e.& '\%‘\\\ m\m\\\'q Cc»r&”rzismo\ 33 h\¢ §§ on ` (zu)& Y€Mlvem% \'~\Qfe [email protected] mm 08 §§SU~S?. H\i$ GE¥\¢\:\\!`Q€ ujw\\\`\n ¥§ve Qlsm\ 6¥~\§\`\$ (\\sms\d\\s ol{»cs\u\u\a\ ‘\ppee»\s ]c¥‘§c Q\'c`. C,p(>\\cc»n)t \\eve `is n\ue\\€\rq axes (_°¢>n:§fchi\\m ¢S¥'e\-§c~ \§\B"', \§ \@\°*@,A \§9.'|3’ ¢Porcn cu¥<);%`\`mm\€; ¥‘c)o\em Porjr]\L \Xig\r\er Q)u¢'\s §b§run)¥ c.@p\\<nr\\‘ Q()P\_"xco"hm\ §§ \_\»S at¥`x<§m\ tim LGP\'M\ £»\QA \h?sh\ssoi\z§ Cmu\\ 'uw\er \u?\m qua \S°r\o md was 01 v\o “Bm\e ~lod\’\ ~§:\\€ oppowhxn\ fn Cl)¥\m'\ar H\£ m%r`\)ts o"g op(>\\cc»r\\‘ \\.L)‘? u`-Q C\ciuo.\ \¢\rvocer\oe »_(Y\e opp}.\ccn\¥ a\so `\r\\n\\\< \us ?@u¢~i§m¥)\ Gax\m\dmm¥ <FH}\€ Ul\&ee\§§a)c\ Qsn§\`.\\l§e\ux\ m§\ilc§\ \3 rele\xons\)€ m~c\ €c<)\\@bm‘}.a rui\)\ T>x..(§m~s\ CH \§\Q~. 'rhwm m mgm \S wm mg \Wd\\\ am §z @m,\\m\ AW@\; {n‘m\§e uvz\es §'iz\¥ Cm\mc\cr Q°Gu»\ é&\'is §\-Y§\Ac.\)\)s §§ is {>FQ.SQH\°CSA \o¥§\\s €a)\v'\., * ` i\s\\£§c\o\§\\ \e\\ amc es w “X"&X\'\s`\&§£\&»\»\ >’rad\\; ar\shh&\mnk § ¢§. sec‘cc\m~; <»Y§\ym;.“ review §\\€ ‘§§¥%€¢M \:>%C<§\'\v\ H\v 3161 o w 'lT\<»,eqa\mm¥\n beev\<§ 931 &wa ¢)’Q ~.’r}\ec\ `bui sine gus 551 \)\: H~<.¥s enh‘c`z¥ka ¥oe§nv¢k\z¥re*§§\l;“:%w»&£ »¥ mma coawu$, "l\\e a \¢cm\¥ rezew\ e r\\'zn\>\m @)n\m u¥ QJ¢A \¢\r\ocer\co, \r\\\x§ \\.o") urv\er
/ul. 7@¢.(`<)1§¥ ls\§k;u\ Qus~‘v"ws\md \nummm§ pxmmwwér '\j\mu\v.¢§l`»gh»% '° (§xmec/m£$b.
A).:).Tm(`m»sk \§\ "'w‘ci\zw¢\ o R\v:~.i<€xss!c\q\lmc\mp\m ,,.hhs»'&»vpmp».r\'»g.,.. . i. mm n ~ .\B\»J¢\ R\»$)nw\ e.):§?,,\.("`:¢me<\<w€§a§:§'[h m‘k;zm\ 3\~¢§\3\%\)¢§&\»`)?:’\<3 w e¢c_na\)h w~am\s\r elk conw- bh .’,f»<§t\\ay msu\mm\ gm~,md @Wk»`j» w\uw’cc>a with law \S.Cm~e.k ‘\*L"(\os§<.§.¢ % ””Rm M`§;\:arnm<\mér n\¢;nr\e\r.n¢»:£§§mmx\ca,,m 0§\,\\1' \>Lxrpc)§s.
GS\L 3 ux u\ .\@m` 1 mg §§MQMMMTMKLHSXWYMQM \ $@H;mLMWmWw“”““ “ d Cl"`)ns\%s T:¢\;.[‘ma§,mv\`?i=:‘v~\aw even \h .\:\\.\s 'Wd`om\)\n G\.ur'\ :}\\?. c_\u?. €_&33 r kress 3d e€c&me do v;\c <£c\mf; S.a§~ md ha\°or~'¢ a 6 Gmc.v\*c P:op?; mr \¢b€;v§z;-S?r\'\i:& \s~“<\€§r:uuu sm flm~rm:§_`v§§nh QO.S§M 3d ;1<:¢..3@% CT».¢JLW ~ managers ;umb a‘auvtum Ced?»c @,8545 . , .~\\\Z due ecause was \!\&\QU u§i\€n \\.o l.\\dir<{\§ \r\)¥ts-z§§ L\)FH\ cmi euu~\s;osu \:»s;uq c>`§ii=.r€,! ec\c.ms¥ \n£m ur M\z uqr?ov'li\m°.uj 4:0 p)`€a@s\‘x é`;u\r\ec\c». `\v\ \u`s \ae\~o\~\_. , » ' TF\@ eqo\>ecr§r a\so \u>\n¥s ‘u\\\`\s §%~e_c<rrv\ .Mlmo\\) \\"m \¢\Q\.usun\ dev i§§e@cg§$f' _M\=\ .M‘€: ¢\\zd'\é: Qm~‘c n\so me \m\eA .¥<>c\€;s\\QA \u°§ r\uepmces§. ‘D\dn‘¥A-\\'a e.p\o§_\cc~x\¥ o\ao. z‘in\\ ¢>c_onu J»Q~¢h!s u.m .H~<x¥ um§\a¢\ m FH\€ él$kv‘\& C¢m~\ urv\€s cnm¢a.m. cn'\®\lio<%~‘%‘\~€ G’ci€d\ \»H\ <z\ocuw\es\‘v§ '°/ h p:m$v\e 6a \'L`).S ended \v\w;!.€c\l.`.~€.-LF\» \QN% c\\ €P\ Q§C§ro\i€knc$ Goon.a,\\?}\ :H\‘E, §l\c ’ hoc »?e>vc~z, 'upm cpp.%\xzc»m\‘<'?:\sr\“c€§\ao me .§»\~<¢L .Hus W§m\cmbh (‘w¥ o¥ @n`m» \'-\(:pe<x\s re z ..\w>db.¥h jue\\cn}. who urh» €uev\ \v~c\\§\\'e `\r\°m» N\&Ycds de ~ wis mae ¢S?.¢\A\s m€:`ch ,p;‘ssewbrx w » \¢orv\% \\.m \z, see % \ Hvaxe ‘\cs eng m mw\>h lamm m‘\w\ch~a l).ccm*c has psowzm d &i\e pyepmde;or\c<>. % ende:sm .¥M qp\\<az§)q:p)u'cabm\ mm z\\¢ma czs¢\‘bo\|' %.e.r~ssj \s:us heath A-»>be reso\\m\? \sn“\~ £’rh\s ‘Wm)rah\n C¢Luv‘v .
Fes\)m\sib\\_\ .r\z, \v\r§¢,»\ mem \r\‘\o em(}‘hn$ \ns\r~o€em<>, (‘h\`m md lhn§r)\ ' ` \'\e\)e com a M\e 3d \\m `\v\ m¥\\ch umc\civ ’Gvwsm\?lke& di laws app Ucan¥ le ibi cme ,.§'\~a\ § ccn\‘< S&rrr”c caso¥ l\~co~\v\ e&\'c¢c}\ w'\ S€CLM mu~nom .Ym \r\\c\mnm 5-¥ search w "D\c\n~)c .Vru`s `V<sm\a\>h (auu~“v A:A u¢@\ab @Qohcar\¥ T>»..Qrrt'§v m~jc \‘a`\$) md \'L`\s »P¢wi§m$d\ Gmm~clmer& \zs$clem\ed c@o\\c_on\ \\0"» o`°v <\z‘hxd m\nvxm¢‘.@. o _ ~ - ` z §°\C\.\m ux~P\Ac~}\ \s cer§v\\‘z.o‘nh \¢\ a \\m. , ‘DA¢'\‘)< _\-\x`ss ‘\Ns‘a\lna\)h ,-Iz.~-...\~.-\-:-/»~;.~;`..'.:..» di (°s\»n\u\c.\ A(x\>€o\& dol\\oz! :N\S, G(Ys~ \\cur$< \\.\>'\ usmg%é m~<-\ \sso€; o\w¥\\\» Caad. c,\\¢\n‘\~ H\c> ’\Nsm\o\>\o C<zm~‘v ms.-Hm §mmj _V\o~nm.F/m \\~chmm d c d <B~\'u .Qwm D¥:`Y\m. r\oé§r"\c§ QU\..\A. ,» .SV\¢_§:\ \ub Pmel su_bvniihr\c§hdujnx.m¢sfvvvlxc‘)€- \\;:¢§\,'%\H&°F\s\::\\\c§`\»hifk\cw Cmt¥.\r(j£\id\m\ Mldm\vv<¥», a o cpphem\ ;m\¥ .H\» am L)\M ' \\\m nw .\Anrl ‘-~H\» d)»¥r <9< f’vuf`* du un;i'cch.%».¥§¢\ m v»\c.pphs;m% m%c\ar)o»\vn %\~v¥~ w<r>€/¢\\\@f!\i-
§ § § § § . / @;~ whe\)ar mdne.\, ono\§jzd en\§\<:\»> 3m £v. ends s1 q'plmm& Cnst. ) ‘Doas:c+¥ due guess c\mn'_e .~)¥M~e iiwmn&\ mn\mvkw\€rv?\- mm \r¥\w~<§&! 133 pr~eucm§r qu\>arnmern\ vi c£ou:»\r»£ §\r\zxs mower or €ns\\>}. `\r\ 'mS)r\X ¢S§rqzpr€.'s:,\isn.lm t~'.§h v.lx§\nvns».b 0 aim ¢18‘1?)3 \2»<1,\9¢., lo<z§.(‘} Q<r‘a,zo"s L ad am (\Q&` .
/sh)c xl~a\so #énm’ci\s rcco<z§ .H\r\ *.d\s oépphmjr moa bar :H\S ’Cun'r§r_§'.'_h~. ` ( mm 60 7 `c\ pr€$mlr_ 5a \u=~\an~c». jo §a...\-Po'\`\ \H\uv~ F`,\enu »Por Uor\\ _ ` )sn¥ ibm nr\ao¥ f\h urr\'e@\'vow 0@ ’rs>$dso 8 c<¢x\"s Gms`lgcu‘liurn r~`c§\¥ vi due groer:s§ §§ T@@ (Zn\s§..w)c» l§ 1<% md §m‘l§m§\ mw>m\ n\v¢€\= sr+\ \X q\sor\su» }\<~<& Mus o\sv \r\$’€\& Gmo§ owl ur\usuo\ §mr\`s§\\n\s,¢$v 1391 u¢@\abm\ .N TQ,L. (`ms§m¢& \§\z>. % L\osn)t -.¥\'£qpl\cuv<\ se§r Lm\)\\r\ ~H\& l,\)€\\\s TOCA gov o Cn}u\&. ¥~¢m\`k never been com/nw nn crlequzds \r\\)sa\i\cah»». elk <;\\.‘\=\ca\\`\ Mu's c‘a\u”r has %X\& Foua’€§ `\r\\d?.$§£z-\ m :H'\€rm do V`&V erse :HL{.S (Y-\S€. ».;\'o mc\€` ibt _ c\.xs\:~<é< uu.r‘c.¥d »L&E&)r<i ° re\.vs d .
752 Q(;\;ccmi: \sc§`s)‘\hg OQ¢F\:~¥[:Y \lq;§\s€f)',\\x> §\-Qil)a\ucrb .~¥\\e <;W\nz.m& mae expend \Sv.x\\mn 01 \1)'§ \\.0'\ u\\z\_\.)' u\?\m AL..\szm~xo. ¥ ) }\mv\§ \-03 \r\\\`xs\\m md.§a<sn~e\ .V\:ncN jim \\\\`C§u§\m\ cyr R'aeend _ \ws$vas ./¢nw’xs md \\:S \>\\r<\€)n <)5\ ac&n¢d. vwm<.vm<s. _ Uc\mnam ®<ac\gg§g§;_»\_% " \. L 'ZI b<a£¢\c~§ Om~&ne wrU\\n -H:\'\s _. 'em\ TDC.\`XD c§o`¥\€$€\uc§' C\£r§m§€. 'L\<`c\if ;\'\\€. rig PUAUCL§ 3:}¥<\ ~nll$ \,l\ is b'aa§: §§ mx§_o\:u\<¥\jmvl.ib \a'aa% of<‘»~/<» A Y @\@p\y\fqn¥~~@n)-z.>~
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.