'. '~ ' CAUJE #d cct _,,- 'LI73'1A § T£&£ Y fAVL DE LOB.D IN THE 52 II() "J"UOI(.IAL § OI.ETRICT CrJURT fJF TlXJ"-.ID :t~ 7 69730 RELATIJR § CoB YEtJ- ,COI/AirYJ 7lXA5 v. § 1Elit:IV!d.) II\ ~OURT OLl= ~QmmMAB APPEAlS TRENT FARRELL 51 vo D151Jf1Cf JVD6E § MAI1 23 2017 TM H£R /HIS cFf'lUAL CAPACITY"\ § t<F5PfJ#DEAIT' § Abel Acosta, C~ark A. PWNrffes oRIGIAIAL APeLTC/ITJ()Jt 811< wl(]r f)F!VIAAI&A1JJs 1/J TilE fiOiv'PRABLf JVJ:r,f of SIIIJJ UJV!lT: CO!VlfJ AI&~ T£/(((y PAVL DE Lord. Relufoy, pro .fe.. ,/7 lhtahPII~ -f/yh,/andnulhbt/~d CJJrJSt. ofi flcitiJn /lllclAle.s /A~ tJnj/n1./AptJI/ur/Jpn FPr u01 IJIJMI!tblhvf 1 purJugnf IP 1/rtc./~ //.OJ ~e.cl/l)n 3 (c) orfl .fAt 10'tlf {ph Pi Cr,Jt,,lutl #IJc~lurL, un/w~uVs/u;w/lutiPvr/IJ,i /v!loltllnfl: iTVfi.ISDLc lilJA/ Rait~lol" I11110KeJ Jur:sJic:li'on 011/h/f Cilvnl /)Ut:J'U/11111-oArlit.k £ 5Lc. i- 1 ~x. {anfi, I 8. RfLitTofJ. ·T£&/'?.Y PINL D£LOP.D , TIJLil# 7b9ZJ o /s fJII olhhlu /11citYttlel/11 lhl 1L~as o~_parlmtnf t>f Criminal ifucfiu. ohrl /£ ap(Jtttr/ng (JfiJ SIZ , Who C/Jh bf !tJIJibLtl al IJ!g/~a liu.k11Jn/t1 1'1-0() ~;_Valloa. ~ci !<otAJ1 Mtv;~sola, G,./mRJ {~unfv, 1i11S 17 fill. _ 111.1 pc.f .£1Jtlql,l io hR.. colhpll/leJ ,1_$ m,'n/5h1"/ul1 nof tt:St.rel/ollnry /11 ndurl. 7:{,f./? . · Arl. 1/.07 5~cl:on j (c).

C. Rf5P~I//JENT. TIW{r P/1/lJ. fLb , /11 hu-/h/5 Gtpoc/ly liS 5"2NP 1}/,/,/cl iTuri9t Pl Llrye II [ounfy, -Ji.ias., Jl4,'n/.sfRr/u/ Jvdy {JtJfSHtm/ 'T.t.. {,/! II. P71 Stc, .3 [c). 7JJl a/lorhi y ftprt5l1Jftj,q 1-hL Slflft /sa !luwec/15 dAys /11 wA/th IP nz SfJond, Arl I/, 1)7, 3 (b)~ AI/~, ~ t. ttpira/;Ph t~IIAe Hmt lor lht {/oft. fo lntltinl c.tJvrl/s nllowttl J..~ tMV5 /11 wn/ch Ia thlt.rnJtil~ lltlSWt!.Y} w~eiAu IJ,t apfJh'ulli'on UJnla/n".s olltgnlio11s ol Cf)/llriJJ/tJ'IeJJ prtl//tJltiJ!y uhre.stJ!vel Au:h mcl€.1/a I lo le.Jali ly ol .fht. app/,'ufhf5 unAntlhUJf. /11'1. II. {)1, !J (c.). ::rllhR- l/ial uvrl J.de.-tl»illtl~ dll t¥tilu:rlio11 lZr Wr;l dl !lr~bursCrii'PU~ tloe.s fJftftllf5Lith /.5Sues, /1/s lhe clvrly !JIIIJ~., lnlll t.LJutflo ettfy- 1111 Oniel' w;J/,//1, IJJt iO lay plltiP) ulhr lYpr'rt~I,Ph ofl I fhe... t~ln~;,;!IPwul./;r fA-t J/AIR IP rrt.plv 1 dli/ph«l,'n~ IJ~ 1ffttlf PI Atc!J It, lu r6PII/~/, 1/r/, If. OJ, 3 Cd). -1ht 5/td;;ft_ loa nd?!Jup!J/y dJI#,Pr/ly /r; lh~ lr/nl u~rflo lrhh/ IAe lim~ .; l~'nl/tl/oh5 /l?lf)tPSM J;y !JR. Jittlttle 1tJ!Atr IJ,on ht /,m~ Miry tJIIlh PHkr dts,!nt~lt/1~ /s5tlt.J fiJ he.. rt.stJ!vttl. · 5fu-h RtZ.SfJtJSf. lo lljJ/)h6,1/PIJ /i;r l#hiPI!IubM urf}u5 I 1 ' ; UJLZ Jtl~f 5 .fesjJo.JR W.fS 3 J 3,1011, wA/dJ PJ/t?r /a/)ufl),l )..(l tby ptr/od pflltr ap/ro/i/;11 tP/ #!l 1/lfliiiiiPwd~~ llu ~~~ lo lt;Jiy, wild nP~ti/,4,-1, //,tJl~ 3 {J).

ISSUES Pf(E5EIVTEfJ: (J) Gu/llv IIIlA wf/5' illt/IJ/vilry /111/V//;J,hlt?MI/11e h /nel&ct'l/1! t'l5v~tftllCL t~l-uu//.ft/ (2) \,1oh;lt>l7 t)l hurlh AmmJIW/Jir,911/s /)ilh.t u,/hJ 5/~s ullfl:iufi'pn lhrPUIJh a Wl!/lillllllfs IP/~olclrttw (3)Aclual J.nnoCIW.l unl1rly1np /nt.lltc.I/Ye PfJ/'fhht~ tJI-uullftl Pllvi .5htk §/n&!Pry v/o!dliJn.s pitAs !ultra/ Cff)nsl-:l~.~hPnl)(/ vlolllll'tJIU F<.elalor c.let~r!y 5kltt /11 h/f or9llmet1lt /11 his h~ti:JIPf CPr/)11.5 !J,~tfh/.s L4'111fl/lit/i(lhdlr/~h wJI'r~ v,IJ/alitl Jhruu.t)h .5f~tktfes 72</.IJ!j 1 72.1/-. {)/.5, 72.'1-.P31 1 721/-. P31 7Nils,aJd,tfp/J ~h ~ Atlt! lh~ sluf~ Ia //ul .fo ~.ul/rm hv prt~v/np, IARIIAiltt s!PIH/u Wtrt p~fer/y Pddtt.Jtttl /n. !?t/nb,J llahus (pr;JI/.5, !?duiP1 alsiJ /)rtst?!tlda da/J'n .Jh:.d-h/s lf..ffilllhLII)m.tnf wA'.5 vl~lald;;·wLII bledllft lhui wus .A/!1 W~Jrrdl11 /.ssvtl; dS /nslntc.IL//11IAt 7:ZC,/? lid /ric}, ...

7hl.Sl ~d prtJ.rfllfR.a'ako /n /?eluftJff Jlubttr..r Uf,lhU 1 A.f ~MIInf h/.J 0/J"ctwttry ~ 1ht .?tid Pt7.f fit: lc1d llJ pro/}e.r /y at//ucliudi 1/u.fl cdt/m!.r PlldAt/It//; f'/J/e ~;A~,. P £11/JY ~ /)u/r biiJfl ~~ &h dnl{;,p11c../us /o11 s &I Law-, VIOLAT1/JAI OF DVf PiOCBS i/. 07 TEXAf C!{IM:IAIAL [I)[}J: l)p c.RUIIJ/AL fJRtJt.G/Jtll(£ . -rht! l?e.sf)DI7denl V/tJ!ctld Arl. //.1}7 5«., 3 (c) tJifht 1lKIJf tt?b. PICr/111/nal /fpC.i)vrt~. hy ~a,'//n9. lo (Jr&vd a CO/JV tJI- :Is ~'nrl/11p ol6cfr uhrl &Jncfus/tJnS PI &w, Ru./alor c./a/rns !Ar~l RRS/)t'hriUII VJiJ!alt.rJ 11/.J !Jue. !focffl ~~' ntl Ail~wt'11! 51tt/uft //,1/lf«, 3(c).

5u ~ Dole.nz. Jl, 'kia.S 8{). of Atfbl,t.al Exu/11, 9f/ S; w, 1/ '1-fJ, C~t. Ap~, - /IJI.Jif/1 Ifill' ) 1 rJistJ 1dllf GoveAnm12.nf ca/t ?:,J/,013. wlllh uust ol ach'rJn t!Pr~'yes J.Pm Sfpfule_ .1 s/afufory pr~t//s/o/1'" art rnandalorv onrl ~xtlus/vll. r-untoly, un/ mvsl ht. UJIJ?pti/ /All~, l<t!alor also rP1f.ulltll tt 0/5L'tJtlflYY wiJ/c}, w//1JJrlrt.I/,Pf/ fhut- wns 17& w~:~rrtrfiJI/1/1. lt:t?i. /.t,C,I. anrl-rianspo~h'on udl 72..tf. fJI'!J, 1?.:f.o;5, 12¥. ff)J-1, 1J..'I, oJZ .. J()dt,lot n'pAI:J- whtrl!. v,'IIPhJ Cf1al'n9- a LJ..I:iiAh?lllri. v,t;kl/on fJ11L flpci.f5, · .:RtiA~r re.queskJ /n h;s· E.v/Jodi'aty !IUtt/119; 9en ertdlv, tt nllbt11s pe//~'rJnlr t5 ll///;'1/£/ fo dl1··~v/rli.11f/pry liMt/nti /11 uvtf//l),l pt.li'li&11 1\allef1tS 5-u!-lt./fnl prtJ?ulltiJ' ftJr rlll~llft 1 r£LI~d.~l lac-If are. /n d5;vfe 1 lfhlllu ~/ali cP11rl r/,j nPI h11/rl a lull 1111rl ktfEI/,/lj}/,'tn-'1 #ltttt'npr'~ A!(GUMWI + AVTIIIJ~ITY Mdndo~mus /s tJn .e.xtrd4'lf'd/nctry r~u!ly 1 ln~f w!!lkstJt Ptlv ~ c.Ptltd d c/ur abu.Je PI · d :sciill:on tJr tf v/olrxl:()n ol t1 d.tf"ftlhp&sd hy lqw whl/1 1-Ju!ll /1 no adequvrlt. te.mdv hy tl/JI'efJ I. \/, T, c. A. ,bOiiflfhlnUII &11 1_'L '11./ [J,){/) ' AllahJtUnu.s /.s ah P-XIraortl:nurv rllrlttfy ~d v/11/~S/IIe PIJ/y h CIJ!ftcf P c/u/ ~ti?Jff~ PI dkcre.l/on t!J!!IIt Vtdllnlllfl ol cA l~.pctl duly wl!lli lhtf'l /J /lfl Vfth(tt/J'ft rO?dV 1)1 lt!v/ 8dh5 v..

M'T/1 fltJAf&.$ - TlfMJ 1 L, P. I 77 5, w, 3 J W'l (_ 7Rx, liDo,· -1/()uffon ( iPO;sl )2..tJIJ5) Mandamut; rJ/tl /!;. 11vo/ln!Jit onlv u/,t/1 1-ht r~u;t/ e.slu6t5lu!J; CI) lh.tln'ti/ Ctntrl t.!ur/y rJ.bu5ed /Is rh'.ure:hon ol v/&!tth.d 11 dtAf,t /thfJIJSeJ by l11w ~ nhtl[ 11 fAe abJtllCe 11/atleq_uaft rtmt. dv btf appuf, TAl !?E DAZ§Y MFG, u,, '£Jic. 17 s. w: J) 65 t1 C12¥. 2JJI)o J, . ihu.{ lhe. RtspiJntleJJf has Yh/hi.Shr/al Jufy 1JJ.S wt!l11.1 iAt 5/nluiPrl(11n/ &nsli'IHiiiMI tJtlllhor/fy /n 01 #ohll1s ~rp!JS procee.Jihl. /he. /(e./a/Pr rbf.uesf f)Ja/lhi.s uutf /nvt?kt 5 ;'/J- JtJr/sltcli~n \./, T. C. A, &&vunm~.nf &li. 11.~11/ [b), . , .

PI<AYEI< \Nhu'llore..., fh.nu5es ~ns/dt_n/ ~t!a!Pr prav~ 11"5 Covrl fhtiiiiA/s (JtJili/ln In &~II{J/I!N, /5stltlll9 vlr/1 oJ ll!tU!damus lv rLmand back lo 1-illlr,'al c..r;vri..PoraJJ;h'tJng/-Pfllrlln9 lbUAurl hu lr/q/ uurl did nof pr&pP..rlv aJuc.alt. c./aim tJn 1-ht. fh~/lf a11tl Ar./lullo mteflht hunllll tPl {JI~Pf hv prt.stllf,'n9 -lht Wartahf pur.suanf lfJ T C,.[, f 1/r/, !tf{c} tJilt:i/b;illplo p!tJduct.!J.t rtJu!& tP/1-),l bl(l()l.fptc/mtn /)ilr.£1Atihf lo ·71/f. Dlf trt!ihf/Jf)rlalion Cor/1 1-tP {JrtJtll lh11t wttf alc.tJlJupf/n bltJtJ/_jlri!P'bl 1 J?Y / / ih.trt vvas any Yt.sull!s/cd 111/.

,· . · CER7I/=I[/IT£" IJF S!ER.l/IC£ ' l€rry !?Au I DtL L~,-J.. I<~af~r uri/It 1-hof 011 filt~rch 1./J, liJ/7'1 11/rwt A/71CPrrui copy ~IIJ,t al?Pi/i and Porq_9olng PILI-.'f,'oh c! Wr/1 ol lf!dnPPI'h/1.5 was ma;leJ ftiJ Ullrf rgf (r/lht hflfl 1,/.pptal/n !lusl/n 'UIP£

~&dfllllll Tf/.Eit!T J=ARfl..fLL -1trrv fnul Ot. Lor/ · 5ltvtJ D,~lrit} :Tucl1t TOC:f,. IO #'J~ CJ131J. of GPrye/1 Counfy Walku fitck ()nl /Jn/f Gt1tes 11t'l/t t TeXti.S 765U lWJO ~/lou Pac.k ~ad · llavrJsofa ~ ~ta.s ?7tf6K'