Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2018

in Re: Joseph Smith

in Re: Joseph Smith
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided June 4, 2018

in Re: Joseph Smith

Opinion

CAsE: OS -18- D0+8i- Qv "0ose.pl,;r.sM.+... ,APPello.n+ ~INTH£ COURT or APPEJt.5 THE STAT~·orT£xA~ ~ i=IF'IH DI.ST(J:ILT OF

5th Court of Appeals FILED: 06/04/2018 Lisa Matz, Clerk 16:01:43 MPe-1\e-e.. ~~~~WPt:APs I I EXAS A-t DALLAs JUN 0 4 2018 ON APil~~f'uoM n\s 3~1o1 " Jud:rc:r=AL Dt.ST~T Cou(t"f C.ou.:I. N (.OI.J NIY/ /Ei<AS T'RD..L (ouP.:I CAusE N0.""5rDCo-goso..o- ~ot0 .. APPELLANT'S ProSE. Mcrr:LotJ To APPEAL f.£.FTt-J C..OU~T oF= APPE.A L~ ~\.>LINE:} ON APPELLANTS WRI:T OE /V1ANf2A M\JS ·' TO THE t-\om~Af'L ~ JvS1::CC.E- S OF TH~ (Du(l.'l: Co.Mss NovJ APP£.LLAJJT EN PP..o ss,~D~~~~~~L, r/) The.. o..loo\Jt. s+ylt.o 0..1\.d f"\u,.v,~(...("{...d Uk.'.>~ I A.tt d Mout..S, ~ .. s Court" +o ~ro-.1\+ APPt-\lO\."+s Pee S,e., ~~a."' +c A Pfc.Al f=,·FTH Co\.) r\ oF ft; ~~t=,A\S A.u \: ~ Ot\. APPS.LCAN\~ W (ll:.T of MAAJ DAMv~ C\"' d In .Supfor-4-- V-JOu\d ~~ow .J~ Cour-1- o.~ ..Pot\ct.vS: _r_. t Ju g:r:S DJ:(:U.o AI ~TAT.ME!VlS C)F FAc\ Orde-r- do...-kd Mo..1c.,'-'. ( S 1len('A Co..v~ tlw ,'11\ ~r o~ -\q.-ooo54 -ce. t"'' ~ Gee:.; rt- 0 r d e.r~ ~ e...\<A.+a r-s Gou 1'\ Se., l LA A.A _E. . [S (lA (.A AAoAJI,;. -1-c P<o,,.de_. t'e. io_-+c.r w '~ "'- ~_Pi o~ +~ '-ll.\ P~e.. Auys+- ;l.q1 'd-ot C. Go M pe" ~Y h uu- 'j · j_ AJ +4- 0 r- ',~ , "c. \, fl roc.,'W:J "'i C::A {LA . t:::_ \)~A c..A..ito.vre.. (2. e.. Ic,:i-o r C..o tv> plo....- " eel A?f e- tt "'-" .j- C..O l.l 1\S... l ~r-de..r- c.(: ~ Cour-+- Se.."+- Quc....-\cr ~ \l"'-f!E..IL CoPV oF THE. · Cj~ SuppL~~~---~-~ ~t--:~orkrS ~~('-d wl+~ S.TAre.s 8<~-r:> 2- ave. (..4 -1. /J\ 0 I' o- \) 'y -toJ.. v ' d e.o d 's k. (\...e..\ <>.>\o a... i s :t..,~-lcd (J....r.~ 0... ~ ~ ~ e.s.u t *' C. 0...1\"C:>-t <AL c. e-s<::;, C..o p~..o ~ 1 .A cA- . .;c_+e.c/ ScJ ~c-..re.. r'VI- 0' ~\.c...rd (.A.)o..~ k\o..~r S:e~~ c.. W c '"\ e F /v\ AAJ OJ.\ M S D · +~ \ c.o...\ C..Cur-~ +c Pf'c.\,j\de.,. ""-~ ~ l.....)\~ c..... \<'o..A~·. b~ l'~c....f.-:J P"'iu c..cp~ cl -\-~ S-\a.-\e..s &L-..b,+s 1 . a~ ::2-A /Jc~OAJ~ (_2_} A~ ~o.~U (_c~~ t:>\ 4-~ 44- P~ ~vpp~ ~-k\ \~ l't-Ur ~ 0~ -\v-.e... Au_j"'" ~ ')..9 I lo I" (.oM. riU\ k.nc'I I-tt.= ",j II ..

By or-du- do..~ f1 o-~ 1- 1 ).0 I J 1 f~r,, -.. Cour+ or de.' hJ +~e.,. Cle..r k. o~ lt,tS Cour ..!- -to ~<LAd (Le..lo..-~r o:?~~r GC>f' c::J 1-"4_, 4 1 p'(f- ScypLe.. """"'-\.c..\ I e..~"" t -k.rS f'~ <:. er-cl .

0 \ +~ .A~ }.Co, 1 ;}_a b CoM ff.A-1-er.'j kr ·J QAJ 1:J-- {) e+ o... CO{>j o\ +'4.. S'lA-te& ~·lo·~ -2- o.N 2- A too..-\-~ ~._.-..; ~ Q/1. d w ou\. 0 {\ e£.-c:l +o ~ ro~e-n/ a Ab~> .&<.. C \{.. ()..A

e, \ D1~c..rc..~, or. b~ +~ t\o M "cJo\.L A"'5e..\ o..lw c.Lt-...r -1 o s~ }Jte__r-.~-cv.5 bf'cu"-d.S C>~ {Lfrcr 01\. +~ {'-{..C...ard (..o~9''~ To Me-'v.,e.,"' ~ ~<J" Q\' ·c..,~ \'e..~5e... 4o Ccvl'..&e.."> L\c.. ·""' e'- 1\.Jc M-e.. • . "r •o v s. .~t" .o ""d , o t er raP-- ,"""~A "" 11. de r-s IS r . c. f' -....1 \,c, S 1.o...l.-c.ci II\ +~ At/\.Cv--s B~-{,~ ~ .\e...d 4-\t-.c..~ &4.- w~~ 5,\.)L" c.c.ce..~s 4-o e..' -~-~(" • -s \.>S +'ce. .s: g r . dje..s I Br-ow I o..nd B~-h s<~- I)

\1\ +"'-<.. /4e.M&ro-.." d u ""' Of . "' 10..U /3 cUed . . +~ r op .".o.v ON -+"'<... .Mv..~ -::1.. 1 J.o,8 or des d '~d.] +'-t... C )uk o-("fh.s LoU\~ ..fa pf'O\J\.dt.. re. .1tA.{or w \-\-'-" 4 q PC\..ff-" ~vpf'c.~f\..f-c,.. \ 1'~<--kl's r-ec..ord cJ;' ..\-~ A "J"i>~ )_c.,_ 1 :41" 74CD""'f~'i heo..l 'J w'lr-cc.IA \e.lc..-k>r wo..s A\ t<:-o-J~ '" ~c !.~S.o.-- <l? -l ~ 1~5\.)c._ ~<:>r (tel·,~.\' l-J"' ~ ·+~ U f\ a..c.e.-ss .\6\t. SIA\e...)

E..~HI\3.!- T~ 2- (A~ 1..A ILe..ic. ..A-or 5 w r C\ c\- f\1\o-_f\drAMu) v.::o..s. De..N-e..d a...s MOOT w N....v ~\ 4 S.cu~"'-.\- wo.S> r J {\e.. v e...r v \,~ r- o..A-k.d -t\...e. o A::r iJV'\ \-l.o-6 ~ .::..

-,---- - . -+~ ,::-C.C~\ /~S\Je...S 0....\'C.... \-"'\ Cc/\ 4-rovt.rS,"-/ O.."~ C..()\_"" be.. b\J -1 \,.,, ~ (cu f' +- +"'-L W r , .\- c P.,;1;1 o.JV PA~ ~ ('c;..lt-~'1 w ~ \ ll\ r-v.-c.-4- No-r Moor (L.e..,\~:·\-or n tL.v c.,l tee., C.l.k_,C ~~r\"' ~w\\ o.ue.s.s +c ~ \e.c..ol d Cov\6 f"tcJ/' -\-,\t:_ 0- 8rt~F Wf\ +eb+-"j Coun~~lS C\o-~.1\A of JJo fV\.e...r-,~'ovs. ~r.rcr tC>r j \00"-'~s 6"' J , He..~ .A-pve.c..) '" ..\-'-L. ~ -'-Ld A..-d<-r'> ~r-o.--...~ d.'-'\.e...,A..l. of g r '"L +' ~"'-"c..-\A.. ~ <> e./\1'-cr o . . . . p<l.A..:--4

A9QU~ ~~ (.o,H,~\ Lo.-\c- 'c . ~rc;..c..o... ""'-0"'--'t. (J..A ~ A \~!'~'1 II · v~e\~~\CA. 01'\ ~\.~ (.ou\~ '£_\J\OQ....t\.£,-IZ- \CS Mo...~r:-·CJ-\ l.V\~-~ ~ t-A,e.0-1,.u i'. "'j 0~ l!::,('o...d.y W ~" -\"~{"(... \, S \e.~~e:./\e>..\o~C.. ~f'c\c~'o. \~+~ '"\-""-~\ I \-\o-.d ~ e.:v~t--"-<--t.. ~e.e.-¥" J.~c.\.c~a +W.... ~bu\.~ ~~ -\-\-t.. \)t'CU.~d':S l,uC;>~\.,d ""c...v~ \JULf'\ d,~~\ SM.-t~ v. c...AJ_N \ n J- s .c....\ l).Q- ld--<::>\)..) (.._,.,. ,."'"' "'o.~ ~~ "G-~~-e(.,~·u'-~~ Q~\'\-- Q...d \0 --\--'vt_ t'L\ c._~ ~ \t \ - • ·w~\~C~t.. ~~cN\,S(.;? C...cl'$:bt~ 1 A~ .J:tJ\*"\E- IJ0T()_~ST o~ -svs-r:rc.c.., Q~~e.\\c.. 1\.\ ~ t-o-. f> --\-~ (..ou('-~ ~\a.."-~ ~ ''i> I ur," <-!rt- For .A~~~~o.-"*' ~~ ~<L. Mc\\C:>JV -t-o A~~~, f,~-rt-\ .

Ccu<LI" C:>F A ~~€-).\~ <?--\..)\ otv A~~ E.,\\1'<1.!\S '"'J \tJ \\-~~C) F fV\1\JtJ \>A.M\J<;

\ L ~ Q___'f'f- Fr UA\S ~(-~~~E~-~~F~Q~\~I~lC~~~----~ -::r: Ur ~ . ~ 'l -\-~.\ o-.. \ -r u t- Q-./'d Co\('ec-\- c..o..rto ~wu Cof>Y &t --t'vt t.A1o()-~ ~ to~ f1CvAS Mo~Lovt.) -\c ..A 0 Pi3A Lt "F \. ~-+"'- C:..Ou r~ ci' .A (Jf f..IJ.-\~ ('- u l'L "-'1 0"' A()~ F-J ~A is. ~ t- '"~ ol' . M cAN o A- vV'l u <;, t--\o..,S r:z e.-e.-A .+'o t VJc-rchd 'o" uS. D<L...- P~\. \,> ~ \ rb 4-- C...lo-..-~s tJ/>CA. .. ' To .AI\'c)rJVe-y "FOIL-~ ~TATS- -soh..v. 0-. f_o1o.W A;.- d. \DO gro""' OWe... ~ t>. 1 Su, ~ ':leo .f'J\c.Lt--""''-'1 , T~ Q.-Soo.\ d..o\~ OJ\J \\\S \\\€. ').C, Da_" I 0~ ~~ t:J~ "Sos.ep~-r ~f\.-'\.+ lA 4yvhL,Lv _ 7p._Q_\a__\CJ r p('O~e_._ I Awe''"'"' (, \ eA'"· e.... iv\-s U t"1 1.\ T\)CS~ D~\() %\C..

C\Cec\ St'urS'\1 .A~: \\CJ 1 )i Qc\1-.c.r.t -'tC,o, l Ll~ MA\2-.L\e...-D-~ oFTt-\ECouCL~\ Q_e..:. [()ur\ () r AQ~~l> CO..Sc_ Jvo' s D ~ llJ,, OOQ?G/-cfl- \tt,l.~ \ c.ou r~ Co_.c.e._ JU o . ~ GC -cPo5q6-- :Loti ~lyle... -· .__~erh. ~' . S..vt '+" RECEIVED couRr OF APPEALs 1\--\EvSlJ\TE ~le.Yo-.S. JuNo 4 2o1s USA MATZ C\e..o..u.. f.AJ f:.rc.Jo~ .1-\()~t.\\D..A-4 c:, 91'c k VV>a+'o Vl Cl£ftK, 5th DISTRICT

4-o A (?pee,_ I F. ~Th L.C>ur-1- 6?- APJF.AIS. (ui .."5 cllJ w r ll 6F /Vl AtAJ D.k.k'lu S:. \)...e.o..bt- -\,\.e. o...l\c;:) b r. "":r -to -\+e., ~ 10 V'\. (!) .(' ~ COc_, r-+ pf'o M. p-\-\ v flt.-Sfec:+ r utlt Svb,w.J«-d /f_r~~~ Sc%epl/t . I . ..>~ . '"f-t-, Af>f~t 'c;"'·.J f fC; Sr<.....

T/Jc..:s vV0. o~to?ct t- C/e~,/\.+s u/\ t + 'fc;o/ ~('vr 5'f.l A N.c....~· "' a ( T>< ~ Lor;.. / ~<J~v-....;· <; ~ ,+- ""- d-... \Oi en <,.. c \.e.,~\~ u (\, ( \ /!c~'·'l.C~,RILLO T}( '791 C{Go ( <;fvr SC\l 3() ~v:i !;},"<( 2tl18 P~'r:a ::!. ·-r A lj'ACJ..-r --· G 0'>' q_c.._-1-o r+ - q (d.j'

RECEIVED COURT Of APPEALS

JUN 0 4 2018 L C,O\., Mo...\2- ::\ ...<"\\ t_., (OU e_:.. -,.- ~T-1-\ C),~+<'•<- I L1 SA MATZ \ 1. \ /\(.,\!A.- <:)'(' \ -c L , . ~ - ~ 1 ~ M D. A\\~S CLEftK, 5th DISTRICT L 1\ 00 c.c.\ ~ ~ ?5202$GG04~!Z:~~~~~!~~J~5~ L ' .

L CC)v\L-( c:>Y. . ,, . ' ..

MA(

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.