in the Interest of J.T., a Child
Opinion
In the Court of Appeals
Second Appellate District of Texas at Fort Worth ___________________________
No. 02-20-00056-CV ___________________________ IN THE INTEREST OF J.T., A CHILD On Appeal from the 323rd District Court
Tarrant County, Texas Trial Court No. 323-108806-18
Before Sudderth, C.J.; Gabriel and Kerr, JJ.
Memorandum Opinion by Chief Justice Sudderth
MEMORANDUM OPINION Appellant Father appeals from the trial court’s final order granting him only supervised visitation with his son, J.T.1 Two days after Father filed a timely request for a reporter’s record, the court recorder notified this court that the record “was taken by digital audio recording” and that “there are portions of the audio recording missing,” rendering her “unable to prepare a true and correct transcription of the proceedings held in this matter.” See Tex. R. App. P. 34.6(a)(2). We abated the case to the trial court to conduct an evidentiary hearing and make findings pursuant to Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 34.6(f).
Under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 34.6(f), an appellant is entitled to a new trial if: (1) the appellant timely requested a reporter’s record; (2) without the appellant’s fault, a significant exhibit or a significant portion of the court reporter’s notes and records has been lost or destroyed or—if the proceedings were electronically recorded—a significant portion of the recording has been lost or destroyed or is inaudible; (3) the lost, destroyed, or inaudible portion of the reporter’s record, or the lost or destroyed exhibit, is necessary to the appeal’s resolution; and (4) the lost, destroyed, or inaudible portion of the reporter’s record cannot be replaced by agreement of the parties, or the lost or destroyed exhibit cannot be replaced either by agreement of the parties or with a copy determined by the trial court to accurately duplicate with reasonable certainty the original exhibit. Tex. R. App. P. 34.6(f).
At the hearing, the court recorder testified that the audio file was incomplete and that she believed a significant portion was missing, although she did not know how much because she had not been at the trial. When asked whether there was any way to replace the lost portion, she replied, “Not to my knowledge.” The court recorder explained that the trial judge operates the audio-recording system, and she agreed that, to the extent there was any fault to be had, it was either on the audio equipment or the judge,2 not the parties.
At the conclusion of the hearing, the trial court found that: • the trial proceedings from the previous hearing were electronically recorded; • a timely reporter’s record had been requested; • a “significant portion of the electronically recorded record” had been lost or had not been recorded; • the failure to record, the loss, or the destruction was not the fault of any party to the case; • the trial court could not determine whether the missing record would be absolutely necessary to resolve the appeal; • the evidence in the missing record could have been material to the trial court’s best interest and placement decisions and thus “probably was evidence that was considered by the trial court in making its findings”; and • the lost record could not be replaced by agreement of the parties.3
In his single issue, Father argues that he was deprived of a true and accurate record of his trial and that he is thus entitled to a new trial under Texas Rule of Appellate Procedure 34.6(f).4 Having reviewed the trial court’s findings under Rule 34.6(f), we agree. See In re S.V., No. 05-16-00519-CV, 2017 WL 3725981, at *3 (Tex. App.—Dallas Aug. 30, 2017, pet. denied) (op. on reh’g) (applying abuse-of-discretion standard); see also Low v. Henry, 221 S.W.3d 609, 614 (Tex. 2007); Cire v. Cummings, 134 S.W.3d 835, 838–39 (Tex. 2004). Accordingly, we sustain Father’s sole issue, reverse the trial court’s judgment as to Father, and remand the case for a new trial as to Father. See In re K.B.A., 145 S.W.3d 685, 689 (Tex. App.—Fort Worth 2004, no pet.) (“An appellant is entitled to a new trial when he timely requests the reporter’s record, and by no fault of the appellant, the reporter’s record has been lost or destroyed, is necessary for the appeal, and cannot be reconstructed.”).
/s/ Bonnie Sudderth Bonnie Sudderth Chief Justice
Delivered: April 30, 2020
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.