Court of Civil Appeals of Texas, 2021

MRC Permian Company/Point Energy Partners Permian LLC TJ Bar, LLC Tubb Memorial, an Oregon Limited Partnership PlainsCapital Bank, Trustee for the Debora Jackson Revocable Trust Bank of America N.A., Trustee for the Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M2, Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M1, and Family Credit Shelter Trust Part B Vortus Investment Advisors, LLC John Sabia And Bryan Moody v. Point Energy Partners Permian LLC TJ Bar, LLC Tubb Memorial, an Oregon Limited Partnership PlainsCapital Bank, Trustee for the Debora Jackson Revocable Trust Bank of America N.A., Trustee for the Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M2, Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M1, and Family Credit Shelter Trust Part B Vortus Investment Advisors, LLC John Sabia And Bryan Moody/MRC Permian Company

MRC Permian Company/Point Energy Partners Permian LLC TJ Bar, LLC Tubb Memorial, an Oregon Limited Partnership PlainsCapital Bank, Trustee for the Debora Jackson Revocable Trust Bank of America N.A., Trustee for the Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M2, Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M1, and Family Credit Shelter Trust Part B Vortus Investment Advisors, LLC John Sabia And Bryan Moody v. Point Energy Partners Permian LLC TJ Bar, LLC Tubb Memorial, an Oregon Limited Partnership PlainsCapital Bank, Trustee for the Debora Jackson Revocable Trust Bank of America N.A., Trustee for the Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M2, Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M1, and Family Credit Shelter Trust Part B Vortus Investment Advisors, LLC John Sabia And Bryan Moody/MRC Permian Company
Court of Civil Appeals of Texas · Decided April 28, 2021

MRC Permian Company/Point Energy Partners Permian LLC TJ Bar, LLC Tubb Memorial, an Oregon Limited Partnership PlainsCapital Bank, Trustee for the Debora Jackson Revocable Trust Bank of America N.A., Trustee for the Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M2, Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M1, and Family Credit Shelter Trust Part B Vortus Investment Advisors, LLC John Sabia And Bryan Moody v. Point Energy Partners Permian LLC TJ Bar, LLC Tubb Memorial, an Oregon Limited Partnership PlainsCapital Bank, Trustee for the Debora Jackson Revocable Trust Bank of America N.A., Trustee for the Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M2, Janelle Jackson Marital Trust Part M1, and Family Credit Shelter Trust Part B Vortus Investment Advisors, LLC John Sabia And Bryan Moody/MRC Permian Company

Opinion

COURT OF APPEALS EIGHTH DISTRICT OF TEXAS EL PASO, TEXAS § MRC PERMIAN COMPANY, § Appellant/Cross Appellee, § No. 08-19-00124-CV v. § Appeal from the POINT ENERGY PARTNERS PERMIAN LLC;; TJ BAR, LLC; TUBB § 143rd District Court MEMORIAL, AN OREGON LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; PLAINSCAPITAL § of Loving County, Texas BANK, TRUSTEE FOR THE DEBORAH JACKSON REVOCABLE TRUST; § (TC# 17-06-869) BANK OF AMERICA, N.A., TRUSTEE FOR THE JANELLE JACKSON § MARITAL TRUST PART M2, JANELLE JACKSON MARITAL TRUST PART § M1, AND FAMILY CREDIT SHELTER TRUST PART B; VORTUS § INVESTMENT ADVISORS, LLC; JOHN SABIA; and BRYAN MOODY, § Appellees/Cross-Appellants. § §

JUDGMENT The judgment of the Court issued March 15, 2021 is withdrawn, and the following is the judgment of the Court.

The Court has considered this cause on the record and concludes the judgment of the trial court should be affirmed in part and reversed and remanded in part. We reverse and remand the portion of the trial court’s judgment concluding as a matter of law that Appellant’s leases automatically terminated on May 22, 2017. We affirm the trial court’s denial of Appellant’s motion for summary judgment on the Appellees’ counterclaim. We reverse the trial court’s granting of the Appellees’ motion for summary judgment on Appellant’s repudiation defense. We affirm in part the trial court’s ruling on Appellant’s tortious interference claims to the extent that Appellant brought those claims against Appellee TJ Bar based on interference with Appellee TJ Bar’s lease with Appellant. We do not rule on the portion of the trial court’s ruling on Appellant’s tortious interference claims to the extent that Appellant brought those claims against Holland Acquisitions, Inc., because the appeal as to that party has been severed into Cause No. 08-21-00065-CV, which is currently abated due to its bankruptcy filing. The remainder of the trial court’s judgment on the tortious interference issue is reversed and remanded in accordance with this opinion.

We further order that Appellant, and its sureties, if any, see TEX. R. APP. P. 43.5, and Appellees each pay one-half (1/2) the costs of this appeal. This decision shall be certified below for observance.

IT IS SO ORDERED THIS 28TH DAY OF APRIL, 2021.

GINA M. PALAFOX, Justice Before Rodriguez, C.J., Palafox, and Alley, JJ.

Alley, J., concurring and dissenting

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.