In re Gregory Sophus v. the State of Texas
Opinion
15-25-00029-CV
~rt~o,j JDfhu.S \I. __, Ij D1t1:.cJor 1 : l b'.'CllS 't) o~rd ~~ 0_nW\ \lA l\l tAshu:..
TextAS btra.rtMtv\t- D~ lnw\\V\rJ Jushtt, DtfDlv+Me...Vl~ ot ktW\tvtlstrahve., Kt-~K te.\lltw Mb.v\ll1tMu\1
Ut 1\Zt\ Vf R_E~ ~I~ N\\~N\ U\ T6 Tl+E FlFTl! TlEII LDllfcT b!= APrlEAL .! fl~ Au~+ nJ I Ta£11~ FILED IN 15th COURT OF APPEALS AUSTIN, TEXAS
MAR 1 8 2025 CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE CLERK
~rt_~orJ s~rlus R_e_lCAtD( i,{oLJ FM 3418 µUltl'~ U1II t I /dbf S 77J2d-33:J..iJ.. fhont : 93fL;-JJJ/-t/-JOO .i.A1Elv1[/llf OftA-St f e /._+ 0V /lov,( few hi~ ,.(:- 1VLt..v ,_sf Si.Lb I\\ f -\-\\,Is U \ Wi:L Vires N1)..\,\ ckoc1"lu ~ 1 \ • +t tel'vle.-d r_J +hL M6..~'r D+' TtXttS boa.vJ Dr LV"lm \ !/\Ct l J\,~St\c.e., DweQ_~or Cl;dltU ~e.xl\S. krtw+wV\~ o~ t v1Vt1rnCll dusheL bw12-ct6V. fe.sfe.c~+u l\J- fnv e__xce_td1vt_Y -fu m .9 rIU'!tul /ill4h~ VIt':I i o'1IVI te.v Vrd OJAJ ~ f PLY 11 llLW / ll.ul d A ,I11/\!J hi !tr~)1i\,J + liS Do fu bmd or 1\ ~ A-d 11-11 v1 JJ.rt< tl ut 1u de l(._v twl 1-,t ~llt'lUt\t'rl + +, • JfA-rE Mr-Nr orJurz1st'J1tnorv ml~ L\)vs~ \ttus dunsd1c,t\o\A ?u.{~LLCLvt~ h \ %2~ 1ex si 1045 J 1eva.S C.DvLsf~ Ar./-i b C(\t\d Tet Cr\)1-t- LDdt 2..1 , 121. P!lrl,IIIL V. Jv!C /)1JJ1td J12 S. W, :Jd 865{ Cnurl-- uP lX\rJ1 1vw\ ~~?eitls lOD,~)., ru1d ijru~_il U. Mah .2a1c/.7P_x Lv_<; JtJ7ff.. JoJlltsv.Turnt.1--- 01/0 S'. tJ 3d Jtq (Tex 20.2;i.l ISS /JE f f_EStJttrE/J lldmfDri &II ts~ 11,1u} fu TexaJ AdMM tslr11/u;e, f.»rk 37 rA1J,,25q_567J ho~<llvu- lli b1rtdor~j -TtXv1S Board ot & 1~1nu( J1Asttt~1 A-dM1ltl1S'~raf1Ul ·Ri~sk K~ 1e_w h-1 cota__ti e.t,u PJ,'lt 1AM J le.x11s DtrM+IM ll/1+ of /1,n 1M 111ml Ja s!1 tL J dr W!.;J a~ rd, vtJ t\1\1 \Ctw.s Stl tl'W+V\ b:J +ht_Tou5 {l91sicd-u1.rLjlJ1A CoMPltavtC,L +tJ S[tUJ? i VL4 aYPJl_J ~ v (lSf ruJtJ f __s hb\if ~c1JJ WI th In The__ TiY 11S J)~/Jtrftfl1~1Jf o+" Cnw,10.a f Ju.shtL .
0TATE1'1E/\!T 6F FAtl-.5 + ·Re-s Id lVlf Yi aS bffj;] hbtA ~ uf ai hL fsIdI.e.. /Jt11 / 111 ll1A1vi fsud(.e~ lextui 11-muJ <;t of lrus Vv\ldtcLd ttf_1) t-~~+ 'Plal1; l/1A t1cd~S"1s: ~rtu+ LMtvt+ i~iti&\ 1s l, -~t- 1 C<_ +hm1+1nJ 1Zt111rA f b15taSe.. . · k hDuS In 1 At1...otrv{ bvtiKldtt t1otr1s 0vr-e.. t1;Jo tltLl~ fo a &JI 1 -1-hof 15 qy5 3ifJJarl f;-1_/ &ta.tJfY wh,ch Is oul of L~trJfftttviCl -fn Hrt1__ !rdM ,vi I sfvtttlUl 6)da_ .IVLL D1re_elor1 : leXt1J 13otlrd of U?tvt111tt I !lushct1• A-o1 rvtrltt l s+ra~u l 12.i~k ·'R_e_v1L>m KYLVlll9e Ne.11t a.Md fexft~ Deln-1-me.IJ} oltn11111Ja/ \.Jl!lSfrte.., ~ttUt rt-Pu~~_1J -hJ /Mfluu01f Df'IL MtU/J ltJ a {}_e_i/ ltJ Jttttf llz£ J///111/J!/!Jtl///J oi- l/[) S~uue led of CIRM 1io1Jr S/al!.~ -Ar&/J10'/6u,n/c JJ/us I& S~a.ft kt_,+ !Jf clfllu/ -Floor' SI'~ ltJr f!ar_JJ acld1l101Jal bu11!< ~ 7!,g l!D711P/JA-ht:e a;-JI/ Scf~~ wl _<:l ll l d.u I111.LS t1Jltd t11 ~if .suJe.r fur hu I Id, Hj f nci.Q s to k a.11 ckd !kl~· O.vtcl to eyisw~ te.slm.Mrs we..lwf,, OJArt waJl \t)eJv,,.q, 'lli ~Mov~ o~ -Hi 1 . to f b ks -PVD rv1 wIth +k uJI vdfl.L Es ~-e,l/t un J bnnj ~Li1 I VI s () +ht UV\1t ·1Vl\-0 [or1fllRhC£ f-6 -- ~ Te,XOiJ 1+clr11111s!r-11l1vt /volt_/ a110 \ e_ ~ \~\ ~ttAYt.
I ssut D/JE' t:e_/4/4 r5 &II / s /2 l?td 1-h Te.x11.s /J o!M1111 s/r11 h!It UJah, J 7 /A-L ~ :J51. ~07J h6WeVlt Tlru_'.h 1v~+ori: TextLf 13oar-d D F~nm1n1J) Jus-ttCL DOM'I Mf.JJ! o/ Ad r1 MI slntfiVL R.1 ~ I< l?Av1 E'iV Ha 11 ct-1 cNt11 f IA n rJ Texus bl!JarlM r flf aI ll1m11!1/ rlusf;l'L.1 dis fej'/f rd1 /rt r !ht hws Jd lvrlh by TexaJ IU!s-/4/u5 VIA- tn /;v/ pI, anLL Jo 5 laJ'/113 t:UZtJ s fbr /ZS!o/ljJrs Aow tdturlh /Ill Tht ID'l1f !Jth✓lft1-1,11J ol U7JtvJ!ndl flusl1ce _ . /41<&/J/VIFNT Rdalor h;J bt2l!fl tiJ'rl.:Jnf>d al -7/i/ f'j~fo i/411 ,cfvc /4 Mtd6it/ frt/Jf MeJtl fl !Ak IJl!t DtaLYSIS 111,t/ hlJ!JJ'eJ 1,_IJ/h I H tl qx5 Sr}j(,{~ ht;/ (l// wrlk 0f1 oHu_r f ~s.o 11 /if, !Iv lJ tJ!ll fli!_SiiilLH I +o -fh R111 l 1/, frfd/l 5D3 F. Ju Pf';2h ti; t:!15 I-IA/1- (5DTX I'180) OJr,J 37 /AC 5 /JS/567 1b ne_ fl4 PLi-1 1s fey1111 fkd 1/6 ~Wuart'.. +not ot S!Uf'i\lL'I /\\'Pa J~/J\."-P 7h.e__v\ 1'U1s 16 c'S'!Mre. t'ob+n. 4L Yex bu..VL l D\..O...Q W Df Wl t¼ tl/l +vu_ j ~L()\\J\_,_~ {)_,\rec\_ .sRc\._CR__, _lfu l) 1,cc.-\o r ~s I\U\Ve_ b bclu rttJt,ttl 6e.e Vt (e.,fuS\VLJ +b od_ \u_x-e_ ~D -\-~\\( ll5eJ~\U o\1 wcr1 ut (;l V\J ·fvu ·1/t { . 1Ze5 fuNal~Vi f.s ul.YZ !Pl fr/11:JJJl_f U/J()/1 -fly_ R'Jrt.e.,J l1U1/_/ L1POh Rv /L V. f's +tJ/ L JtU1 rJ /l.1/5 Itrt/1 rf!.. bf' IttuJ b LJ Dtcu 9,~ I VD +IA.JD !?r:_!LL /11 l~ a_) 3Lltfl n11.J SP1AU -1 ,U oT CL~ 11:£.d ND r clv s ~-1 n wl ·fu ~ 4\ru e:t\fct_c.,1 +_'j w-f 1~ o P0:) 1lL, · -Re.\o;\-ov- r\..'.\h .\:-~u.\ \ ':J br-\ V\JS 7\ru Ll HrCA. V, v-u / Mti 11d l1tvJu5 becitu sl h (l__ hC1 s rJ o of/ur te c11urse., t1I r&l1t_J!J lb Ju th f1A t1-th'/r t.es PrJ n di h f:; at c 1J//LJrt Th l- ft) wu 10 M1i ke_ LtJr ru floh r, Y12,}, w fu h -fh~11,/ Jtd~"JIJ J1S' /4 rt 11 ol!1Yrlz/ ·lh. u a,re t1(J+ IN +/u_ ltdJ1JJ// 1xP /4 _rt>I/MU/1. ~/.qf£Jr3 illi-rA 1/;re.s IS /Jl)f A..J1 tL-!ftfl1!I -lo tX•tJ-i to11frD ID UtY +tu JfAfL, bu+ ujf-c)Yf/JI lo ~11.sse_rJ IL l'fJY11r0 I Dlilr' -l-tU!. aJ'e_n Is. Alf-er111.J _1oVtl?) 111lLk1J Pol, 0 / ~ 110! ·tliL .tc::rSL a .J hlutlla I 6uJ 6/;lrJv~JW,U\ t 0(/!,/Jn_f fhru -/-/2.t Jej/J!a+urt, Clw1c;·f,-fuftDV1 ,TeM s Ad1v11f!L<!:ln1e. &It., 7e.YJ5 lfD11et111110! cock a11clsh-k laws flw~ 111,JN ls&JePtt.deh IA)!J s. bw It oL1 -th.L fJrtf fJ!la_ nt > oVLtJM LLl!l -hl ~LL qX5 SJ utlfL -foo.f _f/e.£/IJ n_q sPat..t area /..
Ve.f--1--fu b1rr!£IDrf. a.JP- !lthnlf Juf5~1dt- fh.L [(:}rtec·f dlt-l5'1Dfl5l~/ lll'e lo Vl'hclcl liur) d .fl) JI Dj,J, llAVEe ht 1<£L!Ef' f(e_/4/or J'ub nh/ /J.Y lh111Jr£M &ttr! /4 b'J.JJ,/7 !llfn, f//kf a.11dhr Nsft>Y1duih .fv &tra!N hi!Dw flu_ /eJ1>lafure.. ol /,a,w a.11d £111z 1/.Esfd!t VL1rteMmt dlSi5nat1t1J L/iJ Srultle lo~! f l s!te.fllllf 5PACl ttrtJL tr fAt hr.sl h11n/! J lo/us It Stu«rt ho! /)f S!ee//!lj S/J1iu tlflA nr birnk Wt+h Iv\ Jk Ce../( s, Bu1ld1111J [i)k 111sre.t.lo1 llff!}JJ11-!lil /y_y -fl~t ttUArt fo oVtrsu l/2t_ torrtcf1on 0/ rMlfftr bYIMJIM.J fht t11l1rrt tslzi!L -/211/c/_y 1ul1J ttm1t/Ja11ct. w1f'1 -lk 37 ;)l J' MC/, 5{)J_; tlhd f_ U/1 U[sft!IL Sl-tPdak aJrt!fJ11tkt Shau Id ·~sPovirl£-VltS k J fo t:11forct_,J StU1cl!ulAr /Mttsd /Jy 1/u f!tJliff a f It ffJ1£Utl!Ja/ tltfMl of ( :ZS ) ·1tJ/}J/)f!) /2 ( /joJ l!Mlrtd DtJIIJYS a_ cltllf Un/1/ {',,m//;a11ce_ ;s J!lf'~/ b!J J fuPondiY1fs .. ()of/2 I umtY J-/u,f -fie. u bot1e_ JS +rue C£Jrrecf ltttd UMfle)e. under PtHhlf Y Dr (JirJuc/, J8 IJSC l7t/-h y )//ujOhJr/ fr~ frreJor:J Soi1)uJ1S .J-0~ f MJY7 8 #wli V; !It /J(xtt S 77310-33 ?-,2, texl-1f1 etc~e. of StrV(Vt b I .J o v 1 I / te;r-f,-f:j .f-JuA & uh1Jvl uf+rt1 Vll"tJ f /l//1111dciW1WS as at~ V\ V'vl0tl lv1 rrtf0\101 fi-rsJ clIA S \ lA S f o~ f /4.3 l lo -1-iiL fo_!Ji) LJI113 : Dlfl ·BotuY'd of l!nm1Mt1! Jushtr_ Dlf DetarlM1!)1f ol t11111111J1! Jusf1tt f rJ~BoX 99 !-lut1fs 111lk1kr'11f 71312 J)Jf Dt!ArlM-tt1! o-l AJ141111sfr1l1ve K1~k Rtv1eAAI Mttt1/c.itlf;fl11J/ f.O.HOJ qc; !Ii,, 11fw;//t, krH 77.3 l/:J. f b ,I J(-k) Nff1 !Yo/ II MWf'A1 9..DJ. £: LTrt:JoCl SoPhlA ~ 2lotf F/v/ 3478 HuJ1h v1//t 1 ·1ex11J 77326 Phovil: q:xo-J9/- L/:J.O0 -~I_,,~-· ·- - - ~J w ~---=-·.: __
.i~1orq ~1PMS if'!l)tJ D23iJ25g . •HOUSTON. TX RP[')(: 773 I/ii fl13L/7' ·14 ·MAR 2025 P M 1 L ~ ; If!!!1751JJJIE.1 TirA5 1.12• !
·112 2() ~33 22. .fiffetr; loutf of 1Pfl~,- J35 rReceived f tJ 73M;d-&!J2 MAR 1 8 2025 Aus-Ti Tex.Ifs 7811J 11/ 15th Court of Appeals
~-- _se2~ (Vtl/1, l J ..-r::; .· ·-~. .;. ·-··:~.:::...::._.:_..::....... ,ii I',• ·1· .,-lij. t'il' H" ,. i .. ·1,!ifidi.,. lP.' 1 ,l1'Hi"1· r· ·J,d 1 1,i ,. ii." .. ii. , L p. ., '!,i. "i.H J l tJ ·:···:f 1I JJ Ji1· :!: 1 1'
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.