Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 1905

Sheffield v. State

Sheffield v. State
Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas · Decided June 23, 1905 · No. 3005. · Brooks
89 S.W. 274; 48 Tex. Crim. 481; 1905 Tex. Crim. App. LEXIS 238 (South Western Reporter)

Counsel

C.E. Spalding, C.E. Dubois, Wright Wynne and Tayloe Cornell, for appellant. — Where ownership is alleged in the general owner, and defense offers evidence tending to show that at the time of the taking the alleged animal was in the actual care, control and management of another, it is error for the court to charge as complained of without qualification, since if there be a general and special owner, an animal upon its accustomed range is in contemplation of law in the possession of the special owner. If two charges upon a material issue be given which are contradictory, and which have the effect to neutralize each other, the jury is left without instruction upon such issue, and it becomes the duty of the higher court to reverse and remand the case. Bibby v. State, 65 S.W. Rep., 193; Blair v. State, 26 Texas Crim. App., 387; 9 S.W. Rep., 890; Arcia v. State, 28 Texas Crim. App., 198; 12 S.W. Rep., 599; Schauer v. State, 60 S.W. Rep., 249; Ry. Co. v. Robinson, 73 Tex. 277 ; 11 S.W. Rep., 327, and numerous cases cited as supporting it in Rose's Notes. We believe there is no question that the animal alleged to have been stolen was shown to be on his accustomed range at the time it was taken. The testimony of Billings to the effect that the horse was gentle, never strayed far from the house, and watered every day at the ranch house well on his twelve section ranch, which was uncontradicted, shows this beyond question. We do not doubt the correctness of the proposition that an animal upon its accustomed range is in contemplation of law in the possession of its owner, as a general proposition. The decisions of our higher courts announcing this as the rule are numerous. However, it is just as well settled that when there is a special owner, one having actual care, control and management of the property, that an animal upon its accustomed range is then in contemplation of law in the possession of such special owner. Clayton v. State, 15 Texas Crim. App., 348; Prator v. State, 15 Texas Crim. App., 363; McAfee v. State, 14 Texas Crim. App., 668; Curlin v. State, 23 Texas Crim. App., 681; Lacey v. State, 31 Tex.Crim. Rep.; 19 S.W. Rep., 896; Morrow v. State, 22 Texas Crim. App., 239; 2 S.W. Rep., 624. On the question of misconduct of the jury: Hambright v. State, 84 S.W. Rep., 597; Dixon v. State, 79 S.W. Rep., 310; Ysaguirre v. State, 58 S.W. Rep., 1005; Blalock v. State, 62 S.W. Rep., 571; Sims v. State, 70 S.W. Rep., 90; Mitchell v. State, 33 S.W. Rep., 367; 36 S.W. Rep., 456; McWilliams v. State, 22 S.W. Rep., 970; Terry v. State, 38 S.W. Rep., 986; Tate v. State, 42 S.W. Rep., 595; Lucas v. State, 11 S.W. Rep., 443; McKissick v. State, 9 S.W. Rep., 296; Anschicks v. State, 6 Texas Crim. App., 534; Wyers v. State, 13 Texas Crim. App., 57. Howard Martin, Assistant Attorney-General, and W.A. Anderson, for the State. — Simpson v. State, 85 S.W. Rep., 15.

Sheffield v. State

Opinion of the Court

BROOKS, Judge.

Appelant was convicted of horse theft, and his punishment fixed at confinement in the penitentiary for a term of five years.

*486 The charge of the court properly presents all the issues raised by the evidence, and there is no necessity of reviewing it in detail.

Appellant also insists on the misconduct of the jury as ground for reversal, ivhieh is presented by affidavits pro and con. The court has passed upon the controverted facts, and resolved the same against appellant. We do not feel authorized to disturb the finding of the court. Furthermore, the misconduct consisted merely of immaterial-matters dehors the facts, and this was after the verdict of the jury had been agreed upon, though before reduced to writing. This was an issue properly presented by the facts to the court, and he has resolved the matter against appellant. We are not disposed to grant appellant a new trial on this account.

There is no error in the record, and the judgment is affirmed.

Aflvrmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.