Coles v. Portis
Opinion of the Court
This is a suit against the appellants, as adm’rs of the estate of John P. Cole, dec’d, for alleged professional services rendered by appellee. There was judgment against the appellants for one hundred and fifty dollars. The petition was filed in April, 1850. Appended to the petition was an account charging one thousand dollars for services, but not authenticated as required by Art. 1158, as pre-requisite to its being presented to the administrators or Chief Justice for approval. In September, 1852, the petition was amended by averring that the account was presented to the administrators, their refusal to allow the same, and a copy of the account was annexed, showing that it was proven by affidavit before the Chief Justice on the 11th May, 1849. It was proven by Mr. G-iddings that he presented the account (accompanied with the affidavit as set forth in the exhibit to the amended petition) within three months prior to the commencement of the suit.
The principal question in the case is, whether the amended petition pleading the account as authenticated by affidavit, was setting up new cause of action ; if so the suit was barred by limitation.
The Court instructed the jury to the effect, that the amendment did not set up a new cause of action, and that if the original petition was filed within three months after the account was presented, it was sufficient. In this it is believed the Court did not err.
The account was, throughout, the cause of action. This must be presented with the proof, and disallowed, before suit can be brought in the District Court. These are pre-requisites to the suit, but they do not constitute the cause of action ; and if alleged at any time before trial, it will be sufficient. It is very questionable whether the suit might not have been maintained and the evidence adduced under the original petition. In that the refusal of the administrators to allow and pay'the .account, though often requested, is alleged. Under such allegations it is believed that proof could be adduced that the claim was pre
The other points in the cause require no comment. It was for the jury to determine upon the weight of the testimony, the credibility of witnesses, &c. The jury were, at the instance of defendants, charged that if the plaintiffs fee was conditional, to take a part of the land if recovered, and the suit was lost, he was not entitled to anything ; and with this charge and the evidence before them, their verdict cannot be held so contrary to evidence as to require reversal.
Judgment, affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.