Smith Bros. v. Hardin
Smith Bros. v. Hardin
Opinion of the Court
There is nothing in the Constitution forbidding a suit, in which the county judge may be disqualified, to be brought in the county court. It gives the district court original jurisdiction of such causes, but does not take jurisdiction from the county court; for it provides for their transfer in case they should have been instituted in that court. This is the proper direction for such suits to take, if brought in the county court when its judge is disqualified. When this is done, the original jurisdiction of the district court attaches immediately, and the cause proceeds as if originally instituted there. Even if this suit had been improperly begun in the county court, it reached its proper forum when transferred to the district court; and there was no necessity to dismiss it from the latter for the sole purpose of beginning it anew therein, and placing it in the same condition it was in at the date of dismissal. The case is different from that when a suit reaches a court by appeal from another tribunal. Then the jurisdiction depends upon the power of the lower court to hear and determine the cause. But the district court was the only court that could hear and determine this suit. The jurisdiction exercised was original and not appellate. The county court could receive but not retain the cause. The only order it could make was to transfer it, and this was done, and the original jurisdiction of the district court brought into existence by one of the means provided by the Constitution. We think the cause might have been tried upon the original petition, and there was no necessity for the amendment. But if the court had no right to proceed with the cause upon the transfer from the county court, it certainly could do so upon the amended petition. This set up everything necessary to bring the cause within the jurisdiction of the district court,
Affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Smith Brothers v. J. T. Hardin
- Cited By
- 5 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Jurisdiction.—Though original jurisdiction is conferred by the Constitution on the district court over causes which the county judge is disqualified. to try, such suits may be begun in the county court. 2. Same.—When the suit is brought in the county court during the disqualification of the county judge, and is transferred to the district court, the original jurisdiction of the district court at once attaches, and the cause proceeds as if originally instituted there—in such ease the jurisdiction of the district court is original and not appellate, and the cause may proceed to trial on the original petition.