Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. Dawson
Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. Dawson
Opinion of the Court
This is an appeal by all parties from a judgment of the district court of Brazos county, on a motion filed in the case of Anderson McCray v. The Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fe Railway Company, to retax the costs of D. D. Dawson, sheriff of the county. Both the plaintiff and the defendant in the original suit joined in the motion. The findings ■of fact in the court below are not complained of, and show that the sheriff received the citation in the principal suit, together with seventeen other citations in other suits against the defendant corporation, at the same time; that it was necessary to go from Bryan, the county seat, to Allen Farm, a distance of twenty-five miles, to serve them; that Millican is in the direction of Allen Farm, twenty miles from Bryan; that the sheriff took all ‘ the citations at the same time to Millican, and turned them over to his deputy, who traveled to Allen Farm and served them, and returned to Millican and there mailed them to the county seat. At a subsequent time five subpoenas in this case, each for a different witness at Allen Farm, and also other subpoenas in the other cases against defendant were placed in the hands of the sheriff, and were served and returned in the same manner. It was contended below, and is now contended here, that the officer was entitled to make but one charge of five cents per mile for the distance actually traveled by himself and deputy in serving the citations, and that this should be apportioned among the eighteen different cases; and that he should be allowed mileage only for one subpoena, to be divided in like manner; and that no mileage should be allowed for returning from Millican to Bryan.
That part of article 2396 of the Revised Statutes which relates to this matter reads as follows: “For traveling in the service of any civil process, sheriffs and constables shall receive five cents for each mile going and coming; if two or more persons are mentioned in the writ he shall charge for the distance actually
Two or more subpoenas in the same case might well have been put.upon the same footing, as one subpoena for two or more witnesses; and further legislation in this direction may be advisable. But in the present state of the law, we are of opinion, that even in case of different subpoenas for more than one witness, the sheriff is entitled to his mileage in serving each. The court below ruled in accordance with the views we have here expressed; but held that the sheriff should not be allowed his mileage for the return from Millican to Bryan. Upon this latter point we are constrained to differ from the learned judge who tried the case below. The sheriff by going to Millican and placing the writs in the hands of his deputy secured their
The judgment will accordingly be reversed and here rendered overruling the motion to retax and allowing the sheriff for serving the process thirty-two dollars and ninety-five cents, as originally charged by him. He will also be adjudged to recover his costs accruing by reason of the motion both in this court and the court below.
Reformed and rendered.
Opinion delivered January 24, 1888.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- The Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fe Railway Company v. D. D. Dawson
- Cited By
- 6 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Sheriff’s Costs. — Construing article 2396 (Rev. Stats.), held: that a sheriff, charging, tor service of process, can only rightfully charge for the distance actually traveled in any case, but be is entitled to charge the amount specified in the statute for eaen writ, though he may serve a number in making one trip. When two or more persons are mentioned in the same writ, he can charge for but one mileage. The fact that the sheriff in executing process, may go in person a portion of the way towards th.es witness he is required to summon, and, before reaching him, mav deliver the process to a, deputy, by whom it is served and returned by mail ■ will not affect the right of the sheriff-to charge mileage for his return trip.