Baynard, Cling Mark
Baynard, Cling Mark
Opinion
l ` 19 ~8:9.:,1¢/1@-‘/»: O:l, 4 (;<;)\;;MQ CQ'/R?"/‘/l'$‘*(l)
§ .Tu Tl\<» D\%Tf`§<‘..\' daur'r E)< Par'f`<_, § 1 C'§~jM“'/( B&Y~W § sz@’ anml 015-nm App);€a”+ ` § `H"~Jaja CoM?:/, ?('e'>ms
. ¢ u°l;-N Op Fa@fS`[ OL ctcop_$ T:J Sra{'é,$ pl 25 4 dGLT‘ A/d 515ng u$-E@NS G'p La m// duval RLC¢JMM e/\/ 0
T TA¢,H`@_Nmz,/¢ cwn’ cf Cr¢‘w~@' W@'F?
M’-`& /<@Q Q"°l '~`PI`O ge Ap/J/»Ica,u'r \"’ C@*;e$ ~€/':a.)r- C',:g)#£;$f/`;CT COY)/;`)‘lr$ add 1415 ap -QQC,TS/ c |Nj' O"J’€C/" z)J(a-w v Re/EOMMc/Vda_+r'o,-U gal/01 O[*c/p/{\ """"'.Z:',:"`§:.:J cogsa +@ Ap@ /:'¢4»%$-_w»1j0~€¢;:§eas g;l`;w$ &F.t' /[¢07‘ ReS/)QaT'-'p.;'//y dsk.a)¢.u,~,uj .»,S #5,`,@¢\@6[¢ cau/\`?L 7`/\3 'Qa//éu.)¢A/j c
A ww+' w 1'<~<‘@ J“Y: §’::€;‘;:;Z“”?,F:i§ " -l;$ Tk¢ €}~ol:"’§ ap ‘P“° fpa _H\Q 934/wl recital ola:(`)o./\/ O`.AJO{ 0/`0{@!` A {`O’M`.R‘A@ 75(;[('9(2) :}e:’éM/":(e~@\$+ric'f'@ourf pul`$ua-r-()T@ 7:_(_ é.-@ c[~<.,.$j 1 d v icc ,,' 10 '["'Ae ._€i)pol§p § o ` d`(’, Aj N f nos T(.z" Oé)`j eb-‘,_ ; I`CCLG»MMe;_/u £>L§,"{`}@A/, \/\/A~c{/\ b&a$ ‘Q{I;¢_£k 0 La“-)"SOA;L(( §§ ~e,¢]@@/‘e~?;;`l L)/Jvolj€ De'€,`_’ 7 No“`)"“{%§:§@{‘/ /D¢Cl"<§ inan al> [Q § /4' [§»'Ca»/;q(`:c;:/\/; v or " ` " " 1 To e<'»"" ' a `\ ~ " Iq,wk»ck web l-».M_, ` _ -[L)§:. ;:l)d :)`:+Ious Pvf`§$va~`t"‘f@ 'L'H.A.F, 73.L(CL)Q).
F)'Mal;)\!`g]~ U‘p FacT n ' ' ’ a ) a{'e a)g 01 _LL> App)fp,¢w‘/' does Ne»'t' O£>_)e¢,+ + 5+ S sz) g
0 , , ` ' g . ariz 0/\/@‘ Tl\@ '~O('JM w RE El \LOB.;°H,‘U§ 50 g {)QC+ l couHT oF galv\/l/l‘r§\)gL"\/ijEALS '\/| 0 d c JAN 07 2015
1 ` Abel Acosta, caerk
.Q_b
’ l" L‘ev{`$z Ou S'?La{es ftc,ooseol cluqu O‘Q pac'i' # 'Two/" ];T S`/"a{`€$ \\T/`O@p@/` Wa$ dfl`ec‘{`e¢:>! §§ §_u}‘/`/o.‘/'e_ 61 5’+@;> ajal~§T¢epp//aa,u'i's female é»e¢:<w$€ five ;uue,$'l-'l' 4+3~§ _@'Q@."`¢ef` had l‘€a$o»/ '7;_¢¢’ é®//ci/e.#a'(" “/`/Le midle Z'S'usj)e¢`ll’s Vehic[e) a~v{ 71'/`4;/€'* was _i`rw/sper+?j‘ Dru§$//
_ WA:!@ .-'~ fm m you /¢»..»>mr fmc/mw 5+,1+'¢,“,,+ £R~/? P,|S. L Il*lé. e><A;L;‘I‘,I,' T¢ST¢M“~Y v~@le¢ <>@\"“`_`Tkey
TO':.! M€ T‘\C i"£¢l$c>;d$ Wk>/ I A/eep[g¢,l Ta» Ma[(c Tl\e, ST'OF,
Bu`r T`kq. disc.¢~c’.`t`c`c').u `Te> p}uo! Tl'\e, />[“oéal:)le gauge was U'G `IbO Me:{ 7"/£5 S,‘fa.‘f€_Mc,¢J`/' i'.~ T/Le federal p/‘m,‘e£ §{'a"'é 7‘7@@,¢\@»~ la¢/<e»[ fwéaé/€ 5~1.<>~1 T`o S‘{`¢»p \/¢A-"¢/e, whe/¢ O-O`Ofcer ,:‘,Ile¢[ Vek$<~.l»¢ @u@,/‘ usl.uj exT'<W,/ed’ us¢ 0-€‘ j'U/`AJ §;S,u¢l as Sué`/~e.¢'.`,':\/v_ i%y\/`('eu+fea$c,ui*uj 70 Mo./(e §‘/'op¢ ‘Tl\,’s fs /1/¢>7‘¢\ Vf@/Q{`"@»U 010 ?"'e¥“.s 5{'4'1"¢ Lav-/, 560- ll.§_ `\AM.`II@/~ /‘{é F3vt @Aélji;$:‘/I WA»'cL\ M,'{\;/‘~@rs g,l.\pl§c,a.u{"$ C¢Lsg/ C'Ho/J}uj \\ S/Nc.e }\aV/,uj 0\ Tul‘,u S,F$N“,.( OAJ w§','\'\@u+ 1'\21`»3~ §§ N°T g_\/,'@[q,`[",`@,u G-P +e.><a$ law[, :+' does ,Uo'[:pf‘a>c/]ole CDZ>Jec.lL,`\/e éaS}S »perpr‘oé¢.é{¢ Co.'usc Ju.sT/~p)/;Nj S+'o/A ap \/e,k\c,le,) _
Al§@l L¢j¢,,( J‘v,¢,l\';@.`(,a+\`o.u ',M,y$`l(' 176 @£J¢ec`,’.'¢~¢i\/ 'Pov~»l@-c{, S¢ei \A/l')f\g.g Hé $gr@l77if{; S"-@ “[S‘”/ `?§¢WAW:~ v J@lws.,~ 132 1534 141,173 Q;W~&»/€‘f&),'\`§@ I@Nj q_S a ha~‘p-D.`C. law /f/\pr&éf"¢`@/J fA“fwav/d Aavé, @é_jec`[’:vzl Jus`f'{'€.‘¢ol Tl\e. S'/'a/o 7'\@..)1 '{"al(€uplac.e, fhe, .FJA¢‘{' l\.a»`{"j"lxe- f>a[/CC 0-{)-¢7.`€ e/\ __MR}/ hai/6 Ma¢{e S‘{"¢./¢ P,,/~ /`€a$e~._u'$ 07‘/12,» i'Ae,u fha OcCu/`eA/C€ ap 1" &_ frap@;c_ ,[¢JQ/`A.¢+ir@/\J ;5 ;ffe[eV@y+-(Sf /)i)/`PQS(_’. ah `li'l'\,e. -C)@w~“t'k AM€NJM¢y+//(€M/)Aasfs 519(0/@,,,[),.7/¢»¢/
iva/v T'k»{'_kw/,»j a vw §i ,~a,l ¢,u ,"s M»'/'a v,’@/af‘bu
(i~c `f'e>(a$ law N@ §§ @¢`H\/€, BQS}‘S 1030 p/\@ éaé[o_ C&USO. JQS`{’§~?/c¢)l ‘/’/1,.¢ Sf¢/M per ca, pan cou?L/'A)UU¢M 0-@ law @~ "f’he 50 J¢c,{' (/$;,uj S?“af¢/ (3<»,¢[@,/~@,/(§'7‘ Cirféultj,~ duval §upr~eMe, Cou/\?" Case, /`a¢.u,v$ce hip/fka haée.as CO/`pv$ MeMa/wwdu,u drjuMe/-'?‘L?>)a~ol("/),
32
ON' 5`{'&1’€5 f)/`OFO$'~’/'=( p/uou/uj 0‘(>€0.¢+ #771/`&9-/. GUTH`)/ -n'/u;JP./o_$ lay Jur>/ 165 Oév}eus,
GN 5+0.`['£$ pfopo$e.bl pl~.#ou/u§ op pac+ »#- poupi /('fpel(a`{'c C@u,use,l glad au AM cycl€@( AA/J€(‘S l-:)N"¢»p /.»/ g,@o>h'oa~f$ Co»$é., Af(¢)//wy'{` GLJ<¢¢+$/ phole O_p cac-fs ;NC¢:»M }<»,+C, becau$€- 91`)3;410~‘ Lr}e'p lack 7 eu`|"op }O Re,~u£s§+e.$ ap Br§e-p 7:£./¥.?‘ `33»/ §e_c exh.`£¢"f' <Q C)dl‘)<'$ L¢H€»/` rur`l"[¢\:z¢\ prevj~j UNFMSOA/¢aé[e' P§O~peSSZQ/.ral repfe$e~`hz'l",`¢,~ as g-]~M»eo[ fig wd{* ap habeas fwva b'~~vl M€.va‘a.~o(o/~/ &/‘ uMe»T SJ`TAZS CASC 1145 puNoZaMe/J`{'a,` cruel Co»ds%}"fu ‘l","(,,\,,_?,( c{.,~.af‘_S-_, AfNP/[a+c, C“vas¢/.S paii~)res piling uMeM*i'f) /b/‘i¢\[)jwiclc¢l n¢ lzirhcbv'r+ o pi';v ;"/`5 /r,ucl¢pe~opav+ 1"€\/¢(¢3~.;.!,,. l
ON S`):a'['e`:% Prwpc)$col “F’/m&§,u§ e-P PAcTs # ~p}ve, Afj)ga/ av£’\[)/'FM£J //$ déV/¢>U_S’,
O,AJ §+a,{"e§ pf`o/>o$eo( pldrl;¢*-’j o"p`@a'c"r§ # S"‘X /;/>p/;'ca,./‘l"§ f(‘@) Se. )Oa`/'i'+.’e/u 1000 B;Scre f/a,u¢L/*}/ /"€V/f£u/ Wa$ !`e-@usepl §§ Ol>v§<ws,
(5)1./ S“+a'fc."'$ pfa'po$¢zol p)NoU/.Hj’§ @‘O p¢c+§#§eVeA-/ .M¢WO[@+¢'» i_SSUcal is 651/foust
UN 5"‘/,2:‘/`65 pi‘epo§e.a( pinol}A/j ops@~c{'$ #'e'e I\T er' of habeas pr@$ duval Meu¢)/‘a,u¢lu,v ~C’f[`¢o[j a,v JvNc»‘,"Q"/"' QOIL{ `M/;'?LL j§$‘ue\$ I"*§ is oévj¢>ds
@N S+g{`¢‘g loroposeo! nudle o-()-()o.cf'$ »# A///A/€ Co».~‘¢"awl erea»( applfea»i’.s 'f'/Mc».( C.’ou~s¢l To faspo,v@& 779 ;SSU€S raised by way op apf,"@lavi‘/’ ar Ie§a/ docuMe,~/`h AP;J/i`cd,u?"@£ ecf$ o\~d W}/( SAa>w 771/5 Cour`l"i/.S}',vj 7`@7¢¢//7£/ €v}a/e/\/<:¢ ,'AJ 7'/¢@, {‘@@@/\0/ @Nol perp@,»./J@/*a:,uc¢ ap /¢2¢.¢) /H'S /aw>/e/* 'Wa$ vu/`co.$o/~/aé»/¢ ami `/'¢1€ H@/ £va+ Qéuse@/ H`$ discrc‘l'/a/J'oh) /’SSo/e§' /\a¢'$eol,
3
?¢_@
523
O,u g+a+£\$ PI`O FGS¢J 'O),upl/'vj <r<P -\Oac+ ¢#"}'¢.4/ /E~FQEAMH'-@{i@-»( i$ O£W""US,- A'FP/"`<‘-ow'/' 614/ech T@ /'T`,g /‘&a$¢bpaé[e,A/QS$ dual 7"1‘¢.)#'£»,,
0 wl , 22:.
§qp/¢'Mu+ 03 ¢' ea`('$: ,op[l'ca»'(` acl/ed 0~ \A/I‘l+ op /7[4£5¢1.$ Corpu$ our
11107,. bu}"i"k 5 (‘£,`Vc) S+l`uc,`{'c)c.,( auo( CoA/$fi??"`u‘h'@.d)al §Sjue,$ all ap which K'e_ proves /N }\/5 wri{'a~'ol ,MeMo/‘aw(¢/M al@~ w.`"i'h Tk§ fecc»»rai’,
S`i'v*vc`t'¢»'¢~l o.~r§ Co..u$‘/’;?('u`f'/Oua,( ef"f`@r$ af "h""al €N'/'i'+)e app/.'c,d,.fl" 7'@ rel/cf iff/covey fp wf`f'f' O~p /\o.b¢a.s forva A#'('//,@`?, App//ca/./?L-»p//e/ § §§Sde`$ fha?La/‘e. Prove,,\) wl+l}\ Cu»~r~¢~'(’ CeMp¢Te.vf'/aw §’L~ci fide feca/wl /’A/ /\/S wm'{'a,.,.@l MeM@/‘a/uo{¢./M¢ /H( 5 cir‘i`e»r\'$ owe agafvs'/` C/ear/y €S?"@é//_skeo( pea/oral O\/u¢;)( gupr\€_,M.e, Cavr»`('/a,“;, §e,a/ 7"/‘,’¢,/ ffu_,u$c/'//>e$,. er' o‘p haéed,$ Co/“/>U'S, awol /14£/4 0/`¢{/\/0(¢).¢" ‘\C:»/‘ fom,‘+/ cf C:rcuMs{'a/uwsiA,¢p/`,'¢a»wé¢e¢+s,
ar ‘ + 5 +S' O,U S+a`f'e$ proposal gouo(v§s`o.d ap auJ # TW@. 7¢;€'/`€ C/d./(MS aia/l/l/Cd~% eX¢)/`€$S_ ly w"‘H\¢l/`€W )`\;5 S'UP/\O/~+ gram `/'/L¢M@“f,`e,u 1b 5`/'/‘5/<¢ JUl\o/~#`71@o/ Cause. a,ud has ¢`A.'Ie¢;l 73 pfe.$<:l`v‘¢ ‘i'k¢jw¢,-,wl '@o'v" l`eview, Tkis .`5 T@‘f'a//y crm/v eau$, Sea l`ea@m@,RR\/,S, P,-H\, Ll$"'l§,.
A'P,o///£a¢,uf'$ w/‘r"‘f’ CaMp/afy$ op 670.5 \7_Ul`0f éo‘n*\ way`$ Aév$e op 055<‘_"<`(/"¢/~/ of ?’A¢, Cov/~T' Aljumeui' '.#’O/~/€,/ a~ol IA/¢P¢Pec+/‘VC A'SS',`¢S‘/'A,ua@, o.p Cp¢/,u$a.l ’ lrsume~{’#'j'u{o, _ ~
'/\/@ where iu rational 0/` éy wa e-@ Wa:\V@../` allot app{i¢»w+"e><¢>vessly wz+k@loew h;s Suppo»r¢,¢ MO,L,.‘W ‘TO 51'/\,’/{€ Jvrw/`/f Af,o//ca,v`lv /`eli¢ol o/~) Cou/¢Jg¢,,] ‘/'@ pf`@?"ejc+' }\]3 guam/pl l‘/T" U`S, Ca~s'lc, A'M¢mj. awol 72)(. Ca,~)s+, lyl@, 1.1'5 za~o( l.lq» _
?
l
1115 ).'w,/+ mm @1~1.~@1$ ~r'A;S cw+ n ksz 13111,113~2$ €Xl/\»E'.' 443 /- Wf`i{'op habeas forpus dual/llema/au@(¢¢“
wum_e~f#l Aéase`p{‘¢l.'scre ?L¢'Lw awol A'/jum e.v'?"#g~ IA/e-Fwec,‘f`;ve /{'$S f-S"/;a,vce G-() £o/u.vSe/, ~F)e».~ a C¢AJ+/'/uc/'UM ap law ¢’>A) 'H\e Su[¢)`je¢`l",
' 7.1\§$ Ju'm/~ was aug u:»,(§-Pi'e.l as a /vta?""f'cr 0-@ /aw; .See, LtCA.' Gav"`(' Cople €=l. l®$'§'/l: T¢Xi C¢J&,Cr$M.DM€-'r gm 3551¢ Q,>® gang cc)ca); game 1 ¢~s uswa 35;' swai& S'Q~EE¢XCNM app QCDH); "F¢LMMQM ‘\L S'/'g?('g 71 5w§i73§ C`{`€X C’¢;M.ML». ;1@~_@3)‘ SM:n \/, Qeg~ 333 sw‘zA 1915$7(1<¥. ' +~ `I" eve ' “ ~'al( 611 '+e _Q_£p_ `}'y/e/\ Q@c>/`) DBj,-J'I‘/],G~¢! DS`],Z’ 'Ir\/ZN \/ Dowrj 81 $§<-T 1634 (ml); Pmk¢r_\¢@/¢.AAM 337 5’ =v‘ - Cp{‘m'vM)-: gm,ol \/12"€@| \/. 01`¢+}<€ 446 F$J 599 (571`§/'1*.200€) _[Zl Wl\:c“l'l\ /'w[a'S, Cpu~alaMe;/+d[ NR+'~'"€» of ]'\o,é¢?.o»S peH‘i’¢'@,A/Ef`$ /":_§‘K`¢'T¢> 194 +/‘»'¢ol lay :M.pa.r‘t';ol Ju\‘:z was ;Mpal“/`ax./T'gu's‘d" 'QOS'{' .(.`~‘¢,1 COW\T§,§, ass’c$$,'.u`$ wl`\¢ her S‘f`¢»fe four`/'@le,u§a.l O'c l\,'»'$ z`.ue-@“pc)c+{i/€;~"'-‘-'€~§` 01$$5$'1¢¢1,<)¢:¢ a -p loa~§e/ C[a»'M¢ L,@`SQJ @N L\`.s +1\[email protected] a‘i'+¢~vey$ paflvr¢ fe challe.u§e. e£‘i’l\ef` £¢¢\ 61qu 01 O+k@,rwise.. venire perso»`s wlw fud$aa‘/'eol TA#+TA¢Y CoulJAJa*{'£Q--(Zz?bauo( :Mpar+;a[was\\OlQJe¢`(`zfva/}/
4 // . '
U/uf`ea$o;uab(€ app/mm ‘HOA/ @-{3 C/€a/`/y as+aé~»l£'sh@o( ~¢:»,,,laral ~ ‘AW, Sucl\, as coulcll be addrzsseol €v'¢'“ U”°la'r. "H‘e' d}(>@¢re/v`w..l S"‘{`auo[aéol o@rev}e»u Ma~ola‘f¢¢»[ by T'Ae A'N+¢’“'
`r¢r¢‘@r}$.v\ u~cl eppec+:°'¢ Dé°~'H‘ Pe")“[{'? ac+'(A'LD£'Al-QZ=`
._g‘;dc./h§ ;1;15‘1 (01>¢1),
/ + 0 ' $,’. 010 S+a`t’¢‘?> Cozd¢(w$;e¢u O-D law #7'“/1/‘_€€, 7`7\¢>/ ljuo‘f"e. "/'/1¢ 2 prop 5 op,.i`tm.gl(_[e.xel_b_(’ W@SU 1311 WGLS._£€£,'_AXZLLQ_&L/Z wde ka‘f'¢ 316 SWQA §§ 6'5»5§ ~7"’;:>(,~ CHM~@£ACL?_)_¢' 5’6' '- A,of//C£M+ /0/0\/@$ éa'{'k pf‘mvj‘ S,, 561 Wf;¢' op #“颓$ Cofpus £1,/~10( /I/leMe»-ra~alu/“ A'I`@uM€A/}'#:fw"a
A S’f'ruc_fw»( arrow has /\ap,o.w€¢/ 1`1~ 1153 CGS"~, B,“.-,._g J'-¢(~or, C<’.I‘?La»(u ef`f`ol`$ ;N `1'140_ +Mo.,{/b/`OC¢$§ heiden/115 ole,v§o,»( op 1`551»',` `/'@ ,~(MparT¢'Q/I decfsleau° Ma/(er arc 50 basic ‘To £a§r~ +`r~§a( a$' `l"© 012'0'}/
5
kMM'eSS €Fm/” review \/jr‘§{l 'v¢ Dr¢{'k¢ ‘/‘/é F$o[ 545 /';T“C;¢~ &@oé) 1;¢] @ 599 AP@/»'c¢w% l`€l;e¢" GAJ C@u/v$¢l 1b Ma.£(e. />i‘@ Pess?oua#l reaso,ua£/e olec:is i`o~s durf~§ \/@w diem 4 .Jw¢¢ S')z+e¢( }`(’. gould Ala`!"éc pa;{` U/d€ alvaca.// /.WA;'¢[,\ ol;_$ 'oa,[:#py`$ Jurar L~`[ law gee RRVS'/ R/lr(, L.) ",QS, £xkiL;"Z_g_, Tk‘.s is a. ‘Pv~JaMeA/'ra,l er¢`@r deuy$'u a leja//l/' Ca,us`{’§‘i'u`/`ej J:) r>/,_£»,_(M,¢_/__\/ _S`/"a, c 7[ 5 du B_LS'(?L€X __C_~»~.@.»,».awa): v:@'l ~/. QE;@ME;;£M_QO_©_ L@ok!~§ aj' TAo_ ~pa¢‘l"s amf Tk¢ ev}'ale,.v¢e, Svl"`vv~allu `H,LJ$ e.r(‘of` /"_u 7('/\<»_ record Pac,i #ON¢,' TN¢».{ fau,u$<>[ oli¢l uo`[' €yercise N@ S"l"rike$ olvf‘)~j v@§ l‘ o(`)r¢,_-)(;:éhcl,, _'H:£_;"i'k¢+c Wc\$ 31 J¢»¢~al‘>' Ie-@+.r/u pawl Wke,v ]'\e. pleC¢';-le¢l gai'.`l"¢ §`("m`ke, J.;)'Pa:\$t7 per Cause. or @‘/’herw{$e'. Q¢,'f"`#§ ', 'Jur¢>"#7 S+A‘l'eMeu't'waS and UA/e u§v@ca[ §`/\/O¢I/M §@(‘l">/[/}xe Coulol No`f'B€-pair.£_~g_{;:_£i: Tl‘}`a.l C@u,us@,l acl<,u°v_;[€,ol eS Tl'\;$ Ju-"¢')I` g;'o.$ )'AJ A;S a@c?olo.u;‘\’ 0~./~)¢>1 5[0./4€9 `HL€ S+"Uc+”¢'l e'.`"¢" ON his C,I:e,fi',/'\ §v.{~(:' admi+‘{`ecl UN¢ u;\/Oca.[ S‘f'a.`('e/Hé~`/'a~p B;a$
b a_ ¢>‘|’e_u+ia[`lurop olis ua/;#P`$ kim la law 011/cwip `H\Y:SJCMI` ou a/JY Ju?>' "§ UA/ ez,/“;CG[/ _é_c___¢.? +¢t)§e Tr`la? c@¢,~.sel [email protected] ;,, ms A»N‘:Jav)+ md hamm ~@T‘ 5~{'1\{1<¢: \Ju¢¢?e~#V as per My lill'&u+_§/de\@@,yola~+$ _ r@Zue:>‘T,,/’He S+af'¢‘s he acluis¢»,¢.l CISGuT/olepeuc_lav"` `onc.`t' if wav[ol 52 §.»~J A:_S L€S+ ;AJ?'/'e¢eS'/` 13 §7['/‘/'/(€ JU|`O{`?F?¢ k
A`I'TMS peiu"' a~y reaso~aéle /o.wye"` woo/al have pu+ kf$ Cl$e~‘l`c>~ fl§e becomiin é~}/ waiver*/ T)\a,'f'TAe, C/;e~‘fwa~l"eo( T@ WOLW@- G~‘QJA)c[aMeu‘/'o.’ Co,\)_s+$+u+£o~al f‘}§ k`l' `/'0 /’Mpar+)'a.( Jur>/,,I amos A/Q`(' SaV I wau+e¢l Ju{`of` 1457 op MY JU!`>/ q~pl (,U¢/["]'e$'r:@)/ u~ole~'\ peua|+'>/ ap pumqu 72 $aMe,
\A/£le./\/ I Wgu+co@ 73 go T@ Tr\¢»( ANO( N°`[' T@‘/(@' &(pleo. Ae,¢>,(/ "]'¢\‘,a,( Cov»$al »p.)`i’/v\e con T¢\e fecal\el gee RRV7, P,"f, L,Q~?>,~ P,i@¢ i.}g`z,. \A/L\}/ woo 1401 he No`r pu‘|’,¢¢¢ am f`ea.@¢~o{ a`{’ /uy Supp@$!olly PCZveS"" 779
39
Ke@p Juror 1'+'7., Lod>/(':)\Jj a'l"' a[/ M,"}’fj a'i`.'uj Cc'f(’,uM$+aA/ce$ S.)N\@U,~el,"»)j T'A.">' Sf'ru¢,i'uq[ €N‘¢»/` ginle C@.~v.‘.A/ce choy Copr‘(' "/'k.'$ e/`I‘O/` p/`€ UJ;C¢C£ ‘f’l\€ ep+£re `I"rial process and SLM\J fm ‘77\¢'$ 4 lael/ww?-z>!" eu+S§ol€. T/§.e /‘€a$opalz[@ NO/`M£$ ”‘() ‘3"/ ef"k,'@,@l a‘l‘"i'av~~e>/,
`r"ke Case /aw )/S 4 €¢)A+/'uuu/M duval §/~J Vl'o[a{';co.d op Cieafly es?"a`L/fs/\€J 57'¢17‘<,.fea/era/,a,/~)o[$)upf@#& C@ur`lrmyl$/u§ S §ee, Tc§.(:g,'!@.. C°r.'&.`proc,.» 35. 16 C®(S> =FZC>Q_L‘ qu.les v afge 353 Sw§£l jazéfexlcr,-'.…up/2¢//),'_&191¢4§; v\s+@:r¢ 71 swz¢! `73§(`1"¢>(@»/,4! § 7‘/@’_\&§
G@v"?"€ode. él.I@SC’"/),’ S,Mi‘l’lx ’\/ Dea.,ull?>;g §M§é 131 553 @12:,1 6a app‘@@rf Wm\ am); 51";1“¢ ./ 0;9{< 64 5“/3,,1 _élQ_,5133,543§[157(7`¢><.¢1/>,0, 7"y/e/~ ;2@@/)/" y‘//~Q;.'l \/\ D[~c_,:~[qg(¢k 444 Fjg §q§£s'mc;»g@@é)’; ‘Irv/~ v. DQUA"§ <¢,,1")§39 ()q 40 alia pmm v. alma e~ 6>7 s;¢.f ¢'/és(/q;z) (pe»
{‘:um\$ugz‘; 14 li edf Oé'ev/$ To The accw$ad‘ FJ`AfeMeu-[`Ma.ole.
Ly 1155 `VMQ,( Cau,vs@,l i.u k§s £PP.'O‘a\/§ , No Wl\erc_ §N T‘\e (`Ce.ot~¢\ <9¢` by S'»"¢j.uea( Wa,<,\/e¢` Uhol a.pp/-‘L'a.u+
t |`¢-;:ZU€§?"f/»A,+Ju¢@/~ ¢1;7 é¢ /€-C"f`a.a.) F¢LAJQ,{, Le@}(;/uj d
T\ge ‘l`,‘/'¢IF+Y op 7"')\< CH`CQM F>‘f`Q,uc'.@,‘.'> SuN~eup<_J.`¢ T/L"S error and 7"/»@. parpo/uo@ ev‘ aA/¢i€ op 7"/1¢ €V/o/e,uce A)@ Co.wpe‘l`e~i' 7'/~£'¢»[ 5‘/'/~¢~/'€3)/ C¢w L')e C@~¢/vo?e¢>¥ l>')/
PUH/,;:J.Z 61 é§o.S \)r.)/*cpr ou 7"/'\¢ fa")€[~ 7 , is 38 a S+PUC+UG-.( cu~'¢)lame,u‘l'#( 60~5`{’[`{'0"{70»)¢¢{
€H`@{` 50 é¢z.S¢`C 7(`0 771-c 471‘@1~¢1 /‘/ndhc/v//ze.~¢' r;jk+$¢ 7"/\;.$ `/v¢~vr was ahs gun/1455ch 571/ads By l‘wi$
v Ou.\,u S‘{'o.'['e,m@_u`(“\\/\/O. 1514 So/~¢~>/”ke C',w\ol ,u¢»T
191 foam RRV%. 'F.m, L:?_>-z§j: €,_&,;_y:rj:l v.f)p_¢_»,jl<e _ML.ELI @ 5'4@;§1€¢`1£73; I…~ v. DM¢,; -§/ ad 1561 (lqz,c)j 5&:+@ v nw 239 sw'sa@ mann ten 4 wi 5+¢+¢
V¢ D;C'k 6a1 591/301 A/Q (7*¢)(`@,”.,",7;/@¢ QM/):
52 &ge);cg“+ 012,-¢;;+$ `T@ 5"/'0\1’@$ C'@~¢.l‘u$é@,u @P[aw
#5', \A/ARF`¢»L» 57~“1'@\5, \ `H\ere ‘€X}$‘{`eo€ ;NO[@{;@ND[@N`#' ’1`0\)~@1$ fe £cw~/oovcj' The +enp@/~'a/`Y dej-GU{-JOAJ C)V@A/ W§+l\e»u'i' ’{`(',5¢1.¢`0\ Ta> Tlr\e_ €Mph_\>pe¢~ Ug¢ op a TUNJ SBSN¢Ll , Tl\ere'pO/‘<?,/ +Mo.( COVAJS¢?,/ Ca,/\J‘Uco‘{’$e, ;A/e.~Opee‘i'"V€ For poi"l'k)s C@¢;+e,<)`/'.’o.u dur}~§ ne gupp,e$$;ON L¢AM/u¢ // The:_ §7"4+€ ~po\l 18 1'¢> preseu‘f` /c§o./ au?"/\a/~H’>/ c>¢` faw. ‘jv$+;py}”j au '¢l`leg¢.l S+Qp, ar 7"Aa'/' his C`a~)A:.Se/S Fa§ lure 7('@ Gé\]ee,l" was a v§aé/e SIL/\a`['€jy ,
Apf)l(CQA/+ Cod+c’.v&€$ fire `Gou:erAJMeA/T'£&a./‘S ‘/"/,Q éu(`olO/J 013/ibewst Tlm,{' 7"}\.2_ `/`l‘a~»Q-P,'c. 57"¢)0 WQS, cOHS`H+Uj';ONa[ wL\e¢/u 7_//\,'€. Sf`o'p aNol gearc"\ we he CO/JO[\)C,T€£Q UJ;T"\@U'{F ab war(\g,`j+‘
/4%>/)’(;@.01"5 A'f?"oruey 01§0( N@‘l" Co.l( S+a.'l'e Tl`wper To Suppr`ess$e.u hearing ‘l"'/»g_?’ac,'/"ua//l, /jto.a/e TA¢ 77a-epic S-rdf). bd k£:/\/ +¢Le ,C@>NS+¢‘Tu+)@Na[f'/'>/ O-p ‘/'Aa‘f’ _S"/'@/] WG\S fm @U°$`H@/“» `f/w+a'/a,ue rig uA)/`ea.s¢»,\méle.» /\/@w/App/}ca,u+¢l;{`ec+ "Hu"$ COL)¢“+S a`/'?"e,u‘/'fc»,~l 70 fha 1700/530 S'f'n+£M@¢Ji/"a.‘/' T/*Fa / \>\/@7"// §uppf`€_$$}`¢p,d h£av'\!,.;j RR\/q p l§ L i;l""7, T/"dope/_~ S?"a‘i’e$ ou `H\e
'[‘ece¢~p\ na‘l"\‘|"ke. QZISCFG+}`@A) T@ final pfaéaélq C¢wse
was up ToM€.//Wl\§ok was effe~@[e¢i USC ap `}'ur,u §.'5»)@[,,/1/(0¢1()'4)3 T’l\¢ Sub`)ea"i`{a/e ¢'/J`l('ep'[' op ne S'f`cvp U,AJ Fau/uoleo!\ 'r¢\e r€aSO/») per +he S'{'e»pw¢;g /\}O+O\\/;o|a,'£lo/J 0-0‘{'£¥¢1$ $-\La'i'e /aw, 7
`H\p_ §‘l"ep epa V€,Lv.§cl€ A.No( ole`/'e,u+.`o,u op 'i'I'.S' UCCUP¢AM+$ do.u.s‘|(‘;+u+e$ 6a SeZ`zur‘e (/Nole¢ 7"/\€_ L/L\ AM¢~JMe,J+/c/.s. v. £»:51\¢… 333 F301 §@Q goé;s#\ QM /;!Odee/` L`¢Cl Po[§¢¢, o-€').{’,`Ce¢`/M.Ay S+OP &th'\;c.‘e '¢-(’ ha has p(‘béwz,S/€ Cau$c’. T'@ Le.[z‘c'\/e
a 1'/‘¢110-0.‘0 V,'oia.T'¢'a// has c‘DC,CQ/\e`¢»("`ULS, ’\/i {}Q{_Q, 444 FBA 58@594(9“ w awé)_ ci+,'~j WA»¢A_L_ U.S. Hé S`c.`{' l7éq (fqé°lé)f Tl\e rule a¢T¢'cu[¢z,‘l"¢¢( ky
`H/\e Sup'/‘c»le COHJH’ ,",.u \A/k/\eA/ fo\/,'Je law €N£qrge,//Le.u+ C>'@O~"C.cr$ bm& [,_¢a,Wa T`@ CO/Jald€+ SeAl~clL-eS dual §e§;uf€$ f`e,jo,ro{ [€SS op wl»\€/'/le/*
<gL; >
TL\@-i'¢` Sv‘°Je~¢+f'\/¢ iu`l'e~i' C@rres po.~o@s To fha L€§¢~\ Jus+'»@ic,a'(`\‘@,u$ -\E’¢,r 1"'¢`, e,’,~ a¢{-,-'@,ug ,J¢_S, \/¢M'!le,\ 1443 )'=.3@\ awle é>"* £;» m 93 mm \OI;p me mo +ha+ leeway is '}'lm+ flue [e al \/yg?"/~P,’caf'i`e,\/ /1/11/51‘ be OEJec`/'.‘ue,['{ 3¥`00/\/01€3//’0' CCH':A)§ \A/A/‘e,u 517 ('/§ [¢D 313-"|"(>¢ I‘p file alledj@ol +/`a-»()c¢((, :\;/'a/a.`/'l{o/`/ -DOI\M:A) T/\€ baS;S abpka ~S+O,A was /\Jd+o~ \/;0[¢»+¢(0/~/ 0'(2 S+a¥€, LavJ, ‘H\e,re {s .u@ oEJec`l'/ve La_s,`$ par Jus`f°,`¥())/fl;/j 716 sum Se.¢ /.,/ (cr~r/,/j QQQJW:N m J,_,zww~ 132 sol Ié;zi 173 (s""‘ c;» /Cz<as); cafe 144 F31L@éé‘)_,' di \/, L¢p@z, 179 FS¢I 283,1$8’(5`”`£;7~ /*]‘W), `\Tk¢ C@u:z+f{f.)`i'm/uaf§{'>/ 0’(`7`_¢\¢ c-p-é?»"cer$ $‘/’vp ap 4 fda-pcuol Q/J+$j V£l§¢}c[€ _ MU$T‘S+A/.)ap @J\‘pa[( §a.$eoe o/J w[w.`l'keo" `f'¢le, cale-\pe~@¥ay+] Vfo[a:l‘e$l fian [.a.w if cafe 444 F`:._g¢/@é?q.!
A~/)/)/a'a&'u+ dau+e:u‘v($' .»\J@`r /‘eZues+;uj\ fha 'é\/JolC'-‘»UC€ be Supp.~es$e¢( a §vpp¢~ezs,`e,d Aea#"/Jj Ly way G-C dl:ju$~j pe"+'!»-'d{`€ law calls avf`s;`ol.e `f//Le.w»‘ale~ f`a.u§v_ al(<bv-\@@q 'f"@ a'/'{'of~zy$’ a/u raa_s@u&l,l¢//¢s$" /DP¢»VJMl/dj {SOT)'L pl`D,uj`S o"p S'+r‘§`c[( 10.~0{,. l:sc€_O-'JS€ @¢)+'Co,ne op f/“PA,( ¢‘,L)¢>¢Jlo1 have é¢je,u 5(7,('\0'€)€/‘€.4/+ 555 ¢_',u+ 7"¢»¢ ev;olé#rle,, `/'/»al" would /MV€ 5€"-/‘/ .S'vpp¢es$ fed,
/4#/5¢¢1~`(’019`1¢5('$ '1"¢ 51"4{'¢$ proposeoi Co/~/c/vsl¢u O'Dlaw ¢Fé as$e/"l"f,wj ‘i"lw,'t' app/faa,u`/"was jive»/ a Pull a,u¢>( -pa!~(` hearing @,u ab M@?“/o,u 70 5’1,),0/)/‘655, w;+h@.,+ -H»_¢ f@:,+/M@~y op +h¢ §faf@, hamm nn Ma,ale `/'Ae ac,`{'ua,[ 51"0-/0\\& S’JB$`/'a,u+fa{ ~P¢v,u@[q,+»'a,d JUS+§»()>,[N§ Cad$a, ~.'~ ?QQ$+"O/~/// De-(>e,uo[a‘/\J"' chi@\ ,A/o“/L howe /?\ao[ 61 '1@0/ dA/o/ 'F¢L;/‘ /1€¢2¢/*/,05‘ WA¢`CL\ G.oU_$ Up fo dév$e'@'@ @/;sé/`c‘f"do,/~J ap £eu»*'/;Ml~ji/Mép+ ¢[;lop wp;_{' &N¢l ,j',./e-@-@e¢`{'fx/e 455.~"57€1¢/¢2@. 047
/
Ca¢,).'\/.Se( Ar§uMe,u?"#:l ap wY`;+`
_Z_)
'€V€\/`,
A .`)
B@)
_,_l/_P¢/¢dap+££‘le¢f$J B>, a/W@_//a?"¢ damage/§ 5:5..0¢¢,1'¢)¥‘¢>', 5’/{@, asserted a CaM/>/e,`f'e S‘fucly fdi/¢'¢’-u/ ami aM¢/YS;S »<,\L’ T‘A¢ rec,@¢p{ winch /‘csulf'eJ/'.A)\\No @Wu¢`é|e naou \Do(` appea‘~” §ee, f{'A/o/ers [~:/‘/e.()i /'/OW`° foupsc),l C',"l’eo[ +ha.`.(' T'H‘Q,{ daupfal dial /u@+ _/l/La/(€, AN>/ a/‘Fu/»L¢,u'('s‘ 513 TO WA¢/ `/'A¢ ec//a/@/UC€ Sjkvu[¢j
see AM,/M way P,z Lz»¢/ €.»<A:,<,:f_kL_,
A f/i!caA/`f'.a§§e.*'r$ “I"lm,{';_f' Wa$ TAI§' Vdr>/ /{,ueuJ/eolj'€ Thq,'(' gagle 'L\a.ue_ [email protected][ her re aljs/c Tr‘/'a{ C'¢:)u.u$el$ :_~e€@ea{'lva/ess as appos<wl 7’¢ C;+..',u "/\/@ arguable
*`@'~»‘Hvl$:/ céu,usel wa$ ;/~J €~p-€e¢+';i/e -('?>r P;"(f~j du duel@l`§ L¢*Je@wke/u A/@,~J"pv*£~/a)i@v‘.`> ;SSUQS exis+eo\ ~@O*‘ @~PF@¢~( L¢»Ml»¢wi \/~ 'y»~a'~’§l>\ §A§ F@»l 1‘(‘7§(§”‘j
°N`l 89
FA'.[\)(`€. Ta) R¢MS¢ i/'n` AMeM£Me/¢J+ V¢"e la.`{`¢‘O/Jf
Al),wZ/a'l'¢, C`cw,use(, /_)l‘a%um$~j COMF€,+¢,-{~_§k@d/ol kave. Co.u<’,luclecl T'ko.'t"§ reaSo,\/aél€ a'+‘{'&»*~ eY/wod/D( have FO..:$@J $0.44¢` '@0*“/\4 010 al" uMe/~J+S wh@,v»e, A(‘§UMeA/fs exis‘/'¢»! had "l’.*!a / C@uus@( per#@>/‘_M@<>Q &u' ;~V€§T;ja‘(_.-'@N t `\,Ul}»a,'t' ge €'\/é/` }N')`¢ L/n` /{Me~c>l¢, \/I@[o.+/o,u A/i/I/»'Ca,uf d§$é#f§ a?Lf/»\,`S`M@,¢/ze,u`i" App¢»,lla`{'@ _Cm,),u$e( dea/fell have A,J”{ §’\,\_,,_,(0( kaye /V\@~Og€ fire dcf'§\/M €)\J{' ‘g@/` l\e/` c{¢'c.u+ [>Y way OP`TW¢_¢' 80\)~<5¢:($' §,u@,-(’@e¢:+fveA/CS'S mud /o'f I`a`¢seol fhe,o{em"{’j ON ['\,€.{‘ @U)/Va
Faj'lvr`< 1b R@.’s$a §§a$ TFOF Gl`ou~ol:
W',H`;U A»/,p@,llai’¢ C;@u/Jsel§ /4-,00!@¢5 bMe,-C 5k2 ,ng'l'l@/Jea[ `hlfa,l Co~uus,@(‘$ /(/~:H'.~’a.{ Cl/uz(le.u§e Tw #7 Ju'rc>l` f¢\e/u l'\l§ W}i'l'\oll‘a.w, pfoM `{'L\¢ C'Lm-((€.Uje,. Sk¢», `H,Lel/ -QA¢((S +@ Ma¢/'\L'$G,~/ £/[ '7('¢»€ M¢+v$f£+;A/j CIFC¢/M ST'A~ccS §um\cw.urj ;~j #7 @>£as A~./ 771@. `5#;»,7£¢$ CoA/C€_/`A/ Ove¢` H§S €a',Z`Iv"<’_ 7"@ aNqueF Y¢s Q/~NO ANJ `rL`¢ 'Qa¢+ h€ Cou/O/ »UO'(" be /"e)aal¢'),‘/»r+a`rgol Up@,d 4 ZU@§+.‘;¢,L;S_ fhwa §`/'a‘/'é’_ a,.,,,/ C¢wf-r¢
19
'AFlo/'rcdy+rA/°W dir'e‘~°'+$ `/,¢\;S cou'.*+ rev //,ypH`\/§C>{Ua.[ V@ir 0(;/`€ RRV§, P.)@q, rita dovr'f¢{~pl pfo$¢(;¢»+e.l` b<§i,v T¢g f\£.l¢a.é}[:{’q,`("c'</Ufo’»* #'7 B(~,’+¢U€@// pp /@?'- 1196 TL‘¢}' joe$f"°'“ A'rM /7 7'//»¢¢’5, each w,’i'h pa d@£o.(/Vd*l!|/e @A/SW€F, T;\€_ O/u/y u,ue_gv,';/aca[ qA/jwe/\ was ~0 he david .~a* be pair 5a /?R\/§. />,1//,- L[B_“l$- ch'\/`"’;+__B_,__» `Hw’$ is a S+ru<-,`f'u@,( c'_»r/\@r` f'/»J' has Ae<»,,u averl.@ol<e,! £,-\ lamar C@u»¢'§ +A€s J.,»@r #-7 was disguall£;'@@€ by law 11_“/ ms ®w.~) S"'/"a'f'eMe.¢/T¢
§’L)MMa'i'¢-'QA/ 4/)p);£(’,0./U+S CB»$C kas_ S+FUC+'|){¢{ pupo‘a,,q,@,_u`['d( “~O( aous`l'¢"h.»'l'»@ua( €rr@rg,. -/'11;5 p“;{ure Wa& a Ma~§_p€$.t», ir.d\)us‘t'§c,a fe M@,M+éh.,ouj ,;/11/ éMaNJ !L/#\A‘We”a[)“eyj-S rcaa§cu;~?,eo/ 57 5'1"@?"¢/ £e.olél`a/(/ ar~ol §UpreMa C’aw.-("$l
"/'A¢, §-{'4'[’¢9 ées"{" ¢3\4`§0 M"'”T (‘a%,u?re§ TL`,'§ C@u/~'l" 179 digi‘e_,jad`a( `/'ka lozada/vol app /]c.a~‘l"$ Co,l.)§{”o'%’u‘h`buo[ NSK+S, fe ~/U$f"`p)' du }//@j&/ §71'¢>/0¢ PFO£)aé/<LC&US¢ was g_(\¢\@/ve@d$'(`)/ é>v$('r cwa 'Pa(§@, T/‘a-O-(),!e. V¢‘O[Zl?a'=`®.d
I+}S Ll)¢’/[( `€S+QL";S[¢£J (i.U £o.GS+:'("\/+z(!).h|al law op a deca»olau"¢`$ r\'@§k'¢' 'f'@ @.,u jMpa/+fa( Jufy, wham/lea )(Now~ lo$o.S Jol`@l‘ has lacey }MpQ,u<’_//e¢{ marie ;S ap ~€3;'0§]00$ \/i@/a,`['fc>,v ap fhaf /‘{5[»1',- "l"lie 5'“/'@%€$ c\f§u,~ne~+' @N<;e aja¢’,u r@@vi/\¢% f/\."§ 60er 7'@ dis re awol fha law ‘/'/u»‘f' p/‘@?L@¢:TS us a// \@/‘o,M ad ,‘A;d} 4’@&"€/~/‘1" C@v»“`t', 7"/»¢ Shz?"e and depe.uo{a.v?"@w/V CouA/Sal €O(U<>¢L+'@¢{ @‘t’ law whw C[a}M wi'l'|/~.@w'{" Pre»@£` or` racew! 'H»al" Th.»‘$ error/was L»»"s C/fc$/`V$/ depeuola,vf$ “Pau/'/_.
IN pvr+ker ‘viala+»'o»/ epa perso,us’ Co,usfi)i'vf,`oA/a(
f‘i§k"' '{'@ aMeaA/S.~F €ul( appeal wl».`¢(,\ Comj)c»>»u,uo/@¢/ egrej’;ou$ kam/4 v¢>O/\J €:’jv"@'j<°ods /'wch-¢ 116
l l
§+¢d'e, woulo@ aged/o hawaii C`,or‘f' ¢,[,stejarol A M,,§T' BaS}c f`§"$k"' fe) F@P/`LS§'“T“‘+""“"J é\/ aN a'?l'?"'afpey -l~".'i."~§» am A~o(ers bria¥)`$‘l‘¢.'l'/u§ S`L\e_ Co.)(¢>i u@T'.é’,‘_W( Ca.\)SQ//Ta l*apf‘e$cv+ 01 Pef`$¢>zv was au éjrejic')ds /,v\e,~£¢,[ ap bua pro¢l€§$.\ which lewa?l'i\er C[."e,»d+ P(\e,Jvcl&v,eo( Se@or€ `/'A¢_ 1371 Cou/‘?"O~P appea[$' duval )/\»`S Owu /A/e-{)-¢’e¢+,"ve /M‘@ Se repre$e,u`f'a*
-T¢"au d) id al FFe,e/`l"apf¢a,('
Pfo»yc¢
LU"Le‘r-c-p@fa prem‘\':>§$ C¢'/a.)s)'czl~»L/‘¢z:,=lj /'(',vllf)/¢»'Tcac,ujk /N`a\/S fAQ`/'TAF’S A@AJ¢»/~aé/e gourfw)'// Se.e f/¢¢/?"' He /@w 01@~7"/»¢. /¢q,u¢./ /5 fr\ye, a~a/ Corre¢+ dawn 750 7'%6 /d.sf al@`/ZL/'/ fe each of fée )]SSU€'S &PPHM~T Oé\; ecT$ /’¢ /ie,/~e,,"/~), fhwa {’are. appi;¢&uf/)/`¢L)/§ f/A,¢,?i"?"/\/'S' /1@,(/@¢\@,§'/& C§.-.)/‘T'c loeme €M¢:)/ )€e,./fe~£ 7¢'@ Agjra,yf’ea/ @AJ f/l"$ /-/aéea.s @0""/0¢/5 app/er ar‘f, //,¢3‘7,
;i pesloa<;`/’@)//y SuIsM}‘ffec/ C€i`ibip»'éa+é O@ SCWV¢"C¢C,
f CH/uj MA;K Bo.~l,uo.!~el §'/"a`('¢ UAJJ@,(\ PQN¢>.H“}, O.() Pur`)uf"\/.‘[’L\a.,+f¢\e.~‘pac`t'§ ke/`€§N' UL/`L _`{"r‘ue_ nude C@N*ac_‘(' "l"@ +Lce, ées"'/' a~@/vt}/ KNOw/¢'loej&.» 14 `['/\ve. swap Cwl`evj’ Copy ~a/pse.fi’ &><|/\€L-.M"S Beccwse N@ access 7’¢> CO/)Ie/‘ has [)ee.,u P@/‘war@(e@/ 7"@ OpFGSSJA)S par`f'»`es a*` Ao/df€$§ éQ/ow, CNM).A)¢.{ D)$'{‘f¢`c‘{' A'T'f'ar.ue}/ a-¢¥’v’ce ¢"/;a'¢»/jé> Caw,v"'f C¢wri'ko»us'e. /UO Nb C/esA/el\ ”SM -@la»e)" Ed-',ué»e/\j ']"g;<a,$ 75;5’§“1, b\Nol, Cour`l' D'p CI‘¢‘M.’MQ,-[ &ppo,.>,($ p`@~ 9>@_>< 1130 el @a,,:h,l §+@+;w// AC,S+;A,, ~7;/~7§71/
€_)(¢Qu`l'eolo.v `H'\§"> _Q~H`O{&Y ap Decem (°€J` 30/£/(
il M)¢ZMM
.,.,,)
15
l is that you came into contact with that person?
A. Okay. On that day, I got a phone call from our DPS narcotic agents. I was asked to stop a4 'vehicle for them that was a white Ford pickup with a travel trailer on the back. l was;toi%$that5£&e vehicle had narcotics in the back- and they needed one
.of the uniformed officers to make a traffic s§op.
""*--..~_.»_\-_. ,-',. . .._.
Q. Let me interrupt you right there. When you got that call, did they tell you for what reason you
were going'to make the stop and how you\were going to
make the stop?
A. They told me the reasons why I needed to
.13 make the”stop{ bugmthe discretion to find the
14 probable cause was up to me. -
15 Q. So, it was up to you to find a traffic
15 violation if there‘was one?
17‘ A. Yes, ma'am.
18 1 Q. Okay. Go ahead.
19 A. Once I met with the narcotics officers, we 20 were ~- they already had eyes on the vehicle because 21 the vehicle kept going in different directions and 22 they wanted to know exactly what the direction of
23 travel that vehicle was going to make before I go and 24 make the traffic stop. At the time they told me to
25 §o ahead and make the traffic stop, I was on FM 1015
E)/A;é,-‘?L # 1 m
RENE GUERRA __ W ~ ._________a_____a_a____________________e;=:;;l__:============
June 25, 2012
Ms. Dorian E. Ramirez, Clefi_ Court of Appeals Thirteenth Sup
Judicial District y 1thOUR-TUFAPPEALS
Hidalgo unty Administration Building Edi rg, Texas 78539
RE: Cause No. l3-ll-00740-CR, styled Cling Mark Baynard vs. The State1of Texas
\
Dear Ms. Ramirez:
Appellant, through counsel Brandy M. Wingate, submitted a brief in the above- -referenced case on June 13, 2012.
On June 15, 2012', you sent MMS; a11/\71ngate a postcard noting that ; pointing out that said brief Wcomply w1 h-TEX’ Rj , _ W138 1"% W) Wb)hKC)F(dW;KYFJYh» , - 11and asking Ms. Win- gate to submit an amended brief within ten days of the date of
.351\'_`1 pOStC ald.
On June 20, 2012, Appellant, through Ms. Wingate, submitted an amended brief.
The State has reviewed said amended brief; has not€d that Ms. Wingate has indicated that she has reviewed the record on appeal in 'this case and has concluded that 'there are rm) issues which would warrant appellate review; and has observed that Ms. Wingate has, accordingly/ submitted an Anders brief. ~
It has also noted that Ms. Wingate has met her obligations under~ Anders V. California, 386 U.S. 738, 87 S.Ct. 1396, 18
H|DALGO COUNW COURTHOUSE- 100 N. CLOSNER, ROOM 303- ED|NBURG, TEXAS 78539- (956) 318- 2300- FAX (956) 318- 2301
€>1111+ 1152 1051 1009
1131/0 '"1-'~0 L.Ed.2d 493
The State has likewise observed that the brief submitted by Ms. Wingate includes a request that she be allowed to withdraw from this case. '
Based on the fact that Ms. Wingate has filed an §nders_brief and the additional circumstances mentioned above, the State will not be filing a formal brief in this case at this time. '
_ The State, however, recognizes that Ms. Wingate has not yet been allowed to withdraw and that Appellant Cling Mark Baynard has the right to file a pro se brief;
Accordingly, the State reserves the right to file a brief re- sponding to any pro se brief Appellant might file, any revised brief which Ms. Wingate might file, and any brief which might be filed. by any new appellate counsel who might =be appointed to handle this case. ' ~
Furthermore, based on its own review of the trial record, the State submits (l) that counsel’s assessment that this appeal is frivolous is accurate and (2) that Appellant Cling Mark Baynard’s conviction and sentence should be affirmed in all respects.
Although this letter indicates that the State does not intend to submit a brief in this case at this time, it deals with the 'State’s response to a defense brief. Accordingly, I have enclosed 'five copies of this letter along with the original{ adi§§§§-~
By copy of this letter, Ms. Wingate_and Appellant Cling Mark Baynard have been notified of this correspondence.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Respectfully Yours, J¢é€Z//
§§:Z;Z:HQ¢& fcij?.i;;&é?/
THEODORE C. HAKE, Assistant Criminal District Attorney Hidalgo County, Texas
511/111 1a 1011-010
111_
10
ll
mean, I understand that -- you know, l will try to be fair obviously. I'want to be fair to the <-, especially both sides. l n
MS. SALINAS: But we do have to envision a scenario where it would be close maybe and' you did not hear evidence from the defense.. We do
`__',-¢_.._*"" need an answer one way or_§ggwg§h§r$ yes or no, as to
whether or not you could be fair. We wish we could take, "I need to think about it“ or "I'm not sure," but we really can't.
PROSPECTIVE JUROR: I would have
_______` ,.
12
13
14_
15
y . :; 11_6.'::..“ j_,,_.f:.,.~,‘.:-;',.. ~
17 18 "19. _20
21
23 24
25
Ms; sAL;NAs= rou'think at this time
you would not be able to be fair in this case because
you' re doubtful?
PRo-sPEcTIvE` JUROR- 1 guess 1'11 igan ii_i_wmiw
-_towards»saying~that ib'would b§ diffigul§ to be f…air,
.. rsys.,,»..,t,.,___'_¢__. ._,.. ,.»
yeS,-ma'am. runways
MS. SALINAS: Are you saying you would
~ WW-\»,-,r _-_?,».~\--v -»m».. _H- n'~'~ -*~'\-‘-"" ' ` M '-' not be fair? And I do have to commit you to ask you
\¢.~'-~, .. -J
Mm.»t,ee. .W*“"""' "
to answer yes or no.
W_M.Mz-r-:;“_h ______,__ .
1., _ ` PRosPEcTIvE:JURoR= _No,' arm sorry. MS. SALINAS: Oka_y.‘ That's fine.
Don't be sorry. There' s lots of other jurors to
choose from. Don't worry about it.
E>/A:')>;t;lij
No error was preserved with respect to the admission of the video of the traffic stop, Appellant’s statements on the video, or the marijuana recovered as a result of the traffic stop .` suppressioneitheman]ua_` j ` motions ‘ln any event, ;.Alr)pellant's counsel admitted during opening statement that Appellant was driving the truck that was carrying marijuana.~ 8 RR 147. Appellant’s argument was that he did not know that the marijuana was contained in the trailer. 8 RR 147. During Officer Villafranca’s testimony at trial, he twice mentioned that marijuana was recovered from Appellant’s truck, and no objection was raised. 8 RR 181»82. The State offered exhibit 4 and iiA, which was a copy of Trooper Tijerina’s in-car video showing the traffic stop. 8 RR 184. When the video was offered, Appellant’s counsel stated, “We have no objection.” 8 RR 184. Additionally, when the DPS crime lab reports were admitted into evidence showing that the bundles discovered during the traffic stop contained marijuana, Appellant’s counsel again stated he had no objection. 8 RR 224; 12', RR SX 28, 29.
When a pretrial motion to suppress is overruled, a defendant need not object again when the evidence is offered at trial. However, where defense counsel affirmatively states that he has “no objection,” any error in admitting the evidence is waived. Holmes v. State, 248 S.W.3d 194, 200 (Tex. Crim. App. 2008); Swain v. State, 181 S.W.3d 359, 368 (Tex. Crim. App._ZOOS); Moody v. State, 827 S.W.Zd
875, 889 (Tex. Crim. App. 1992) (statem.ent of “no objection”_ to offered evidence
gam+e% ”
Cling naacl`l<' éay,ubtf_of 1730[759 COURT(§ECEWED'N
%al spur 541 v . JANO”/‘zms A/pl@,/Lj/f@ / 717( 76;/@7
[email protected]@; /;1 v sav 30/~¢/
C/&i`i< op Courl' per _ Cout"l_e-pc/`iw\l_va( appeal$ P,@, gas isaacs
Capif'@f §l’a‘l"fo/\/
A'vfl"'~/ frx, 7?7//
Abe| Acosta, Clerk
RE‘ -€'fffNj O[>Je¢‘i`..‘o,u§' fe »Ciusf,c'iwbs ap -CA<‘/_f'>", Coiuefusi`e.us o@[mu, Aw)/ /QecoM/¢@M@{ei';b/‘s' 72 Z/l//`}f'@@/smées$ Corj)u$ //,@7 1(/\/ gauge ,A/dr CR-/Qs»/-~/!»s'é/)/f wlz»ga,¢/@s{-a li
D e_c)cl\ C{@~/‘f(
please .C);(e. e~c(o$e¢)(_oé»Jec+¢€o/~JS fe Sf'a+.g,j p§,-'¢>UN~SS O“c 'é)‘%\""/'t"/ C@M"’lus"osu d'@LQ‘-Qr d..uof /‘QCOMMP_A/o[e/T'/"®A/ @,A/ ,4/1>/ w/`c:f"¢)‘-\£ /lad€ma.¢§ def-905 UAJofe/‘ aff //»59“7,l ,{,./ a,颻e/e §a.’¢~/ fause.
F CRIM{NAL APPEALS
ponsow+ to views 73.¢/ (LB(§D _/% S%a+es .Z` /LM¢ \
/O afaY's' `/'@ -¢@,'/e OéJeef/w/u'$ dla/of 7"'/1€ 5"`/;17¢ /Wa' so ahead eye/17 -'Q@s\u)a./\@l w/*/f' Q-F/méea_§ 50¢»/~+ 010 C/‘/M""'.A/¢~l d,o_¢oeat/$/§@j_”§efvc¢>/ §fa-,?Le as §aJc/( /",~J ger{`fié’»"d»t+.¢_ esp §@f`¢//`¢ L»- QMO( cuelo$eof /'S ML ~{)@mth/ odd ee?L/=@A/S,
F/eas-¢ £e/u-FJ\M .'l.’.ufzS-L/ way ap L¢#€,\ ar pas‘f'£aro/,o/¢asc;s 7"7/{.@~,</)/0¢/ 100/\}/0¢//‘ he(l£¢~
/€esféé?é£//é/ 505/m 7£%2,/
Reference
- Status
- Published