Texas Supreme Court, 2015

Pena, Allen

Pena, Allen
Texas Supreme Court · Decided January 28, 2015

Pena, Allen

Opinion

tjj ^ -7

m»V.o^^/p\WMiW . I #v-r ri«n "• 'I RECEIVED IN ,^ 1 ^ MOTION MOTIC si COURTr OF OF CRIMINAL CRIMINAL APPEALS Al FOxK I\ DATE", Jc " j J •. BY:, THEste of Texas rJAN 28 2015 ^^^"P°^icbsta,CM I»^ of Mbd^ |ao.Si.|n)sl, Kl ^X^ JUtoV -I^>fo\^l_..^o^r-tillflv\\]-vi(iHl; ^y^fe.^ -BhM,A -IAhx- ftafrff V-t^'-- X\mma^\^[-T^i^l -1*1: XoRdE*.* -t^^MiA^ .^ht Ctel^w -lYo*-- SerVe*-

1^-«...««*. -i^i...+te ^ -T^.ni.lu4i;hTv5r?t --^ L motion U\L wwM<rV^ ft VRoGK&oRfll tt&EfHWEinESS cf vjY\CloV\H'^o+toY>V\ I

Deei Jm^ fEin^ >f. Wi\Uyyi sH^i-ins . iM 4He \mita Mu-ta t>'»&W,4 (Lo^rA - Ifol Ue &.o\)¥UKRm bi^^-ia+ of te^s / Q*£pv& cvmis-fi ^m^oy\ . c.^>) fos^cA

n • feif -IwoVvoxvl -tv^U" -liAf^- Xte* -XM»o W-.ni", srf ^Uoyi^.

1^4 ^tiW^i^oWiS&wi... REf \e(^U^-Iv\a1 .X',m^i] otfiU(L*lw-

TU1 t ^-\: X<Ufc&+l <^1 •^^^]se:^^+< b"iM&Cf MioRin^vi'^ off iC^ . ^ootvi *Zo(o .®*(LoftY>\)$ CHRiSf\ .TEXttS "7t^ol ITEI. 3G1 -^-o^\o ..

tain pEYMfl

4L\*\ ?W. %(A Ai- XoHlft RlflRlC ,YEXY\S 7£,;S&7

frl \\v I -To.Jpro Se! WEC'.of^yi -TAw.w7 *^ , ,7J ** nK R'M- te4y}RM ^^NfiGE fcE&ffcCL+falU ttiirn pEm J fEfiAioiOER. f £p &E •z\o\ Vm l>fe°i ^.

Xo "ff&oRH of CfViWiMBl HffRWS,77 I of TEM& )i

TtT^ifil|c^-f]cflo&E ^o.^f^-3337 411 ; PEV<fon^ YflY^tff V. of|\m\CoTnS>-\\\viV»o^^ G^xm&^-fi/WtCH' Will" the ^4b4e of-rt^;

••• 7

W

«$•! — -7 —ji" XWvxtoi^

l {«*•• Jif^-toTH^f>fe*-X fR«toW^ii&,^^ XSET1 foRV -XwC^U.oiwTJ Ctows" -Iw^HU* -SU* -X a.a. ^ Ao] -IMW^H"-l>c/ - X*teH\inCK*s^ "]l.Wfl\vj^w~£&o^iS4»CKH^\a*- ] J wm\M°RN We* Xirt'l1,^],.. of-•l(U^-^4-.on«5 Utfj"- fm te«lE* :^Ro^ /^tSf , mf- o^^^^/lU^]M^^^^^: lmA'iM^EflW' .;X^mRiM /f^Xfi/^eR].... WoMrt'Hfl>lE"-Vpo^i^VEl^-Xp^Mi^RE^-inl; .X&^W ~ IveR^'C^0^^ lE^k^d]' 'XfR'fERy'J^E^ fEf<4'.oYlERV- JiC^&Ell-TL^'-l^E^TwE^.. pf* ;|TRmi] - X>^H^Hw-i^Wlt>\^\>*-X^^^-^^7w»T\6^3 • , f ^..^REEtV\E^f A.

IUeeoXwoW^} ^ Qfi^'tER . HI"? x)-S. (^ .^ Xin^l. i£EE X vwfoRi v..v\&Cto44i . s37 \).&. n . zi XRoo^7 , X^EE; IR-iCHIeR .lW\{ 1%L .X^ofmi] 2 v|flR&0RoO&H W. KWwRt^o . S^» V>-&. ^Z. (o(J\ fZ^] iSEE;iETiti& ^. x&hgc . ^ v).&- \°7 , ^ im^l .

I&Efc ^YltttnvWto X. ^ikE$> -^33 si.i. "7^ X^^Tl . te'KColEw&M V. TtW^SoM . \>o\ vj.&.f,^ 7^5<k

Xw^*-X&«<iHi-XvJvxKAvx-tati\Jwa-i&C^^c-vX...X^&w^m* Xon>V J\mE&3*.X^w Xfrje-^.c™/] - X»IIe^3irC4&1 -X^l-IlR***-I.^T^^ 6flT^of' fc^HP-XU^ pHEi^oY^^^o^^... Y\^ -^CKj, ^i&^X0^ -Xotbiio»M^ -X^VJWyjWH^^-X^E* C\eV|RW J, ' tf\W\lERRpR&] ...Xl^VoWi^-tftRoxmrl^^ TXd.G.1ft^Ao.l... ^"!W-IU&dnl^ X»^-tteift&o^«>\ ' ,lv ~ . . —- lHri\. X&\M\..

T^-TmI -IiRte^mteT •ILe4\v^ia\e1 iftCf.on"]...*o^-Xtr^*-Ito*-^REW^m"f Xf^- t i«E&M( ow.s&torfj ,..I0hV\4w -I^\lEv,-tUf^fJ,-lT^K)EA)l- lpMi] *.X\4HVuaI" .I&tti*- )T(1 C-V'J^ 1 I WiGU* -I«E^ 'IHEfte&S* ;|hE* PfcfWeR* -MeW*'^'...Yo* •lEMSO^oSl,^:" t^# -tt^" jX'^URi^rX-Ipl^ml^RRoR,^ -,.Ur4fv"-lH^^*-X(^f^w-Xi\U^H^,v- XPRpK^^-X^-to^^-i^^ jt^..4.^^5ol^t^VXs»/-Co^vX/ioY^ _^ XlV ..Xexe^«^" -X4h.ElE* ^UCl«Srt*: "X^^'^M '• Ie^^eR^C To* J>vMCH '-iREf!*<&•-I&^H] ~Xv^o/4M^4>.o^l1nE^l ...^ l^^^t^iut \\\m\V !&££ •xn \j.s.dA ^s4 teIM. l£EE:t^£k V. VV\d^MiEl . "SR,°l U.S. ^73;^1U.oool I^-tn o.i.c.^ 2.2.5^.ui.W.

XtoiiiMk ;5R7i v./.^f^U.

TCte:XH*\)SER V. dRjcHOl ; -S^s F-30 ^o; ^z Xs4h g\r.. ^^1. pE^;t'EX pnRk to\]o .1oi &.W. ZA \%<\ . H3 XTEX.dR»w\.^pp. \^l] t'iEt ^X E* Fft^E WdCflin'. <o7 &-VI. 3i RoV. Ro7 xtex. dR\m. nPf. 2^0r7

tSo^^Rjll M4R^4l o^'-XTEx^/tCotL^lCH^Va^-.S-iofl ... iW.<LRH*te^*U«- ^oYeRaI^ XTHWi-X)i4»^>tel ^oo^]...To* 'XfvEop^"]-\U^ERW • ] LTHE Mfcter -| REViVi^o^l ^e(e/4Se] -l^ol^EUi^^^XiCiE^'l^kR''', U^3in u.s.ci^^^.lai.xi] IUeE •X^&Ell Nl. Ro\f& .vt3 r.^ ^33 _,o35; .^3 ^+H ^,^-j U^:l9f1R4lEM..WloR£lflAi\ AioS.o'l-°W\V. 01-^^13 XGoMSoV.^^^ Sl^ oP ^ 17 *** Xv).S. Kpp. LEX\S> 2-fo^1,x>rfllo-e| X^H cR.bEC.^. R7,o^. ' XtHe &4Me-s- -1^1-5^^^ tef^J- U&M*\* -lHUM\l-lnteii\ I/Ue iX^o^feoRiERlTEHl , J ^SEE-XWRRRiS V. o'KUHoYYllfl . <Yl t.&\. WW* • X&E£;X\>IHWM >f- -v).$. .loo &.C4. \^2-.

X&Et:^, o.S. V. £rx^e . l6»o vi.&. iRDD.D.d. el .3^. ^M jr ^ \\{^ tsu^XfeH V. U.S. 7s VcT (oto .

ICthe ^^:lx.c.^f^^^ , X&^: tr.a.TRlc\M/^cH^J] -XH^taMs] v.m^,^. ,4s r.30 iik^o^w] : XI X^ee^0^^^ h+h '' Uee :XTEiX.^.f. s\ .T&7 X*L" I^ee-XFE^R'C\^.p. G\ .

iClftCdoRamilyV-X'CE^R^i] con&f4uf^w\]- &4tfv>to , R\!l£$. ?RpCe^r^ -irf -^<vrWe* XfRXdFjE/U]... toLAbnil? ~lMl-°^^ -XCoM4R^i/Aiw -XHR^^l'RE.UEf1 . W^,-X^dRX..pvX\iEfw - XW^-X^eReKj* -X^wrT]. rf-X^wxtoCl .^e"X^'^ &Hte XdoWifoW"]. ^r^K'X-7

XfhE* pfef.4-wnERw -to^Y -XRe^eM- .w^RM^R^-toi^ -d*uR4 --To'^Wrf]-., SH"^^ X^tedl^.oYq.XdvnE^-.^ XM*-XE*4*t\Vi>ixy -tillainlj jl^vl ...To* XtHtc \imtefc s^K&XdoT\s4i^V.o4]...Xw^- X^ \J.$>.di 11^1E^-\)-\^ °TV. \-\V\5 infWP f.&.d:s. Mo-IT^W V . , rr , , ^H^ER; fRp SE i- X-1\\\ifcWHlo inI -irwiL& s• Wftcfc vrti'rt *A6^K e^h"^ ^ fB^ -^«s^ t'*tfe^*X^o^E& , tfflfcw .^^4^EfiR.f- viYikR*X^Tl|4uL..of'il^vi^.7!..^ VUH] of*|fhEV fotee0-,^v- XTo" -fe? ;X7W<U **** -Xd.RREd4l fe*£fi^ i«0

Xi^XGow^l^jOt^... vr.4h*Texas l^hvte. Mte&. rf pr^re 73 3-\s* ^ y ^ t^vh^:%v.i o$»-x\^&i__v,4 ^K^-x^'ti^L^>niwx-vs,: %^. j J" t^ vj.&.d.^nklEXE^vH-E^ oyw wv\5 ^ ^ J T.^.(L.-5- Mo.\1^oU7 M\ WeR , pfc» IE IWm^i V- ftllftd \)YVi4

t •' , %^jb. c^fta^E o^iEd'»^l :

Io?*-X4>ie* -JSo^Lo\^ -X^'Hu^dW]'!.. m&* -XwwIeJ* Y>* -X4hE* -\orr^AC[. twkj* -XoA*...4hE* Xexf^^I totewf&eU]'_'_. ^ft-t&oCX^.ww* -Xw.\E^t>M-__. tPRE1 Pfl\**. ..IfR64 -<W -tv^4*fe* "lO •& •ta&f,£J -IwBifJ .

' T.^.d.x 40. l-Ho£77 WlAWVfiff ; fRo ££ 75lATV\£S> >/. BHRE^ V>Y\i-(- ^ a / 1\o\ TW 3k°l H. |n o.s .a.% m<y ^ ^ on -. Hv\s xow PfiRk tex^ic&i l\.i - \XjV uLvifc^ ^ <UmM WRiMsTf \^h% Of tKXA* . A\ \Cd.d.¥t]Al •lKR^\;3'St-o\|; . & pft^£ W I.V Xtrjia\] (iovftfjcmosE Aol'.. ^^ - ejt_ sr,7., ~ ^ fM= MeM p^^^ . ^4i4'o-nER./v^mf^ THe Mb4e of Ttey.R& tefsAWf / R£ipo/4<kn4 •.

E-XEGirted or\i js^ « ^ T>ti°ftAfei •3vdte"Vteiiam<fC of i^nt . %,

fRfiVioYA / pWTvflfp .

Ttr^(U,r4] t^tt 4oJ .XJI- dR- 3337-if( v. TH^ S4lft4^ of TR)CTftS bE.C,\wRlf\-T\o/{j \ H^m^eW' iMCoRpoRMmi-IflSEp^EJ7 WeWoRWc^W . Y\|^vJYY\EY\f K\Yliv I&lAvJiAe] f^C^'X^ppoRfm^iRo^a] aIo.^7 - \Sj xMEffEC-fWE Co\m&E ^ of Tftfll ^

&1 ILtht" ^dWttM'H^^^ ._.or .Is.u^l„.f^V"-: XTO* FRfiWE^X^W^^Y X^-Xfi«RR3LC4l^ XEXEdu4E,Sw •4tev %\^\wf~ lpRot\4sl-g,ET^oT *..„U**iXMfc^iM*]-Xoh*-Xp^^-^,^&*..of1" •XMf •t^Eff^WElC^seTI i4E]

ty^^l-UEW^l^-^X^vil -Xvir-tteX'Xr.^ ofwjXTft«\] ^pifi^'X-VW ptanW- XC^n&E\l-XlflffRopR>lfl4E\^ .Y^Rop^eW11 zl°hjMt$\..MV- '• I of^E^T .. M?lv"- oR^XWo^lEV--.l/44ow' oRvyv -XtWo^r... "i/44ow X-fA/^l]," X^PPK?PR"#K] AwT" .Tv. «„„_ ^ -.vU.,T _ tL(f^fw£]v\(!4..o/{( -XwMUiCH*..4hE*X^^ _Xmm* -X4hE* s4«te* fRoSidoio^ -X^Q>4Al^-x^Vto4E\^X5.fftR4E^w -Xtowxibfc^ XiA'* .XpRaSEdo4oRi^wlSdoY\^df] /^H* Ho\6iY\^l ^lEfiEY\dE]V!.X^^l'",-XW^n -XC^KaM] ...

M jXfcfenEl^TRiTfiljV'X'^HiCM "-X^^-X'iAlftGfJ- V<^EcT- Xfo* XW XdURRYIYl^dHfiR^l- IerIor] ...

XSo^-XBiff-TYol'-tWERE^,7XSWviy,,TJEp^Ev( SKeT pK,4iUK^-W ^^M--. t^-U^H^Xft^l: ^^EffEdf^-XpSfitril^RRoRl... *!$<> -Xi-,w\»\<"XK^lE(l4EA*-XlovmiKV&*- XftCf.oTns* Xto* -be1 •£ fREJ^lG^!lHT'fe^slnl..Xtedfiu^ -Xc^^-£o^ H*te* X^We<1 XW^l i« -XM\ib*m~ ^hU\iorl^ -INHERE- -iTo* • lffi.il ...Udoin^' So* -MfXW XlUflEfi^tt-XCoot^SEl^.Xt\orw-Iv4w4Uiw_..To*-- Y.Rvf* -X4hs* -ito*]. ,U*aHdil«dH-fi[- i * V £&We* -lpR,^d^^" -XtettfctoteY -XdoEidf^T- Xwi* - of*-I4He* -IsMe*

XX** •XpER^R-yfL^^ui^w-XX^c.'r\Uv-I(1^^Me&* jXiAe^rMw^T- JX). WARjYHfv(ioK\ vJtl^Xo^hl1 X*>1 r Li" ttE^*-XdEa\nte*-XoAkti.w-tPK^H^.-.ofXlpE;RjoR^ --XoR^-Xv^-.-oX''- X4hE* -£foR&^inix\..T7 ^ -XiEM^«^\^TLTROEl....MV" -XdoRR^df] .

• PEff oV\Rjt. pro se ^'TftWES N- H\l|R£d W>4

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.