Smith, John James
Smith, John James
Opinion
J« TH E Looflt -\0^ ORIGINAL C>£ ^cJ^9> —' REukr <-^ o o COUP* OFCMN&APPEALS VWV\T V£>OGT MAY 13 2015 ^* /-j AbsSAccsla,Clerk
—' Acosta. nflrf. ^p^V^oO ^r\)°\^cre.V\o^w^ N^oVio 9cnWevA c^>V\o^^ ONCOSIS, ^foWc\eo\L<SP-£*i\s> o£ Vra, case.
Sictowi c£ regard vc§ oroA a?cvroents
a^neWaJkS}^ Vbwterror 0 ftWefto. U.S>. lOTTm uqO, n ii. a. \54 (VS%) .. . q fibber u.SWssk U\S F. 3^1"5 O^Gr-WW .— - ^ fem%S% \u <^ua 50 m,&vw-\r© £&; &W- FV.b3oAblQ-bS\S\^ D60^ awd \gq ao.^bera<xe*.(jW w?v.-soo\,\ .... b gspMD \J. ScMV M5V-5(Ji 8nio/8l8 O. \C5^Gr W &£Q&*2_U£2k&& \at S.bO. 3D ~}°ti (lex. oW R^-^OCD• -\8 CQ\eo^vek^_^nq^.b0.3\),wbC^G^^^w\ ....atf*> * \«Y(^v.re£^ .. ...... \5 tXVf^V, kKpv^V\WA 8sA SU3. ^> \38 "feKWTO..-^ Foster oCpAxWi-m^ ^ _ Tsn _-*w usMmo, m s.cx \\3rf,aau5> ai^cotvttPfr —^ boVVniygfoV, eR-^jL,Cr3,^ 32Q S^ 8fr (\eY.Cow ^W. - \cq\^ —^ GikftVh o,^t^ y&^fcssi CefcW?A^ \)*A, - W^oio^-BBt) — Ab
t V^so tBW l^A-A - m<s (i^.r^d. •••^ VWs^AA A^-Wre, Qm SU>9d \0Q (Aex.(A\rr\ rv^p _ \Ac^ • ..<-.« \0/U Unoe, i \ SsVftAv. AcA SLA 9id. ^"30 j^.^VF\V^ WAM ~TO0V-.\M(o An,oPtAAAA.m VWpWS A8AUS>.a^\A08 SCX (fAb, as v.,F4 9d 5b& cvq<am ...... \2. £"0 VIA (\>C.. (Ar, ~ \Alcm .... ^ ^\>. V^oScerV dettai ^v£A& \V\SCX*CQ, a-59 us %/AVi ^.a sms .Sb us> a\) tarn) £S
3^0S8°&, SI ^.CV.\Alol \^^^ WftAT ^7\^iaat^) \w v°rn > ^° ^ . 0D "V^ XN ' ' ;° \fb\e OA ^oAVidAAne^-^FAoVaa Ael-^CfiOD./^ec. \StAS (AJercoo-SQU\ ..... 1 lex, CCj^M. \^ql. /fi^T. AA.8R(b^ (AksapSMV) 9KS$ as. C^vo^tx / kvfhv^t) \i, ^ v.io ........ en."55 C s> © * *
A^.^fiW.WC£_.SA w jg^Q^P, ^pAA?b. B(O iH -^AZ^^\te.A^5.Cb^ A^ Q\, 9b, 33 a^.f^.'v^oc.^b.c^ ^<aN'^ /3;
Vp^^gVVAr\eQV)\\: eAA\& °\& »v> «ppep\°«> *\ CrwV^ cj?ee W^eWftT
(^ nAWo^Vpc XI•SOW, Ate toe\WV atere^ RV^*\°\ Avm\ CDva&ed-wa. ^soeWetfV ftvxa Abe*Au*A Ca^L -Wv^o^A Am, ^PpelVuA Ao ^5 Ue^ tfypusoa
T_. ^.~. ^ev^eAed-Wie\a u^rAAcrx ^obce^cP a\^£A QOfewW \^.SOvACAe^A^ooW^A\ \A^s, C**5& WM^AVAtov^ ^bv^tA Ac
AtvVV \3cmuAS G<?-erc^r cpusejci A.
£xme5T^vvc\\^ <?\va& TiV^Y avx\> toa' V^ooe^ ^^va\L^u>oW\\ -W^Vi^ejA ajsjAWV ^<A\e^0^
tea t e V ^ e ^ . ^ r \ -vv^, VLrvvve^ xo w The. c**££. ?WAcl Ve. rei^pr^e^i %~ p\ mo AvvfA
li^vw yrovn^ 9\ s\Scr\ vajxvq, vbvcT p\A-"^ GO> <p>m. no Oee.\3 Tho. iu^d resume^ c\e\\W..
r>eov9>xoo r ai
e to ft «& NNE.N«£fc£> OVT^XF AVjRM'.
A^\^o^V\ o^ Ant^ Aa^ \b£u u^sjA^ Vje rec^v^ \^ vaVxVVvxv^ AW. dv^r^Ao&6v Av^e dc^^L '. w^VA AW^C£>b&X DOF2> ViOT KT V^^-YST y^'eA- TV\^TTV\^-A^A VXab^b^^T^) K^V^- 1£^A NJc^QrXVX OFTAVK^ \o $AAAa eW\Wre A\\€l-pa=£M\ftu cA? As bam we,\o«no€; •&*Av& aeee^bte^ ft\WH&f^vrv4 v£ uou cjc\o 08 so <^\AqgoA Anim o\o\eBC£, to us*
So* «tU«VK,^to i^-^ <*"*
vmv^.^(A^.vAc\m.V^^-A^). 0 v a desaci\C<lX£a .\U«SOP Wt^V--3^ .^fAV^GdcTV^<=. Q: •, ^ A*^A Abas
Ate,Aas\,Cpd^qw^^=> Ar»^V \V vs*\pgC£g3&Yv\ ^>c revest, cmi=LLEX} eYwra b&=re. AVc-W aoes>
^s^^^^'^^" o
fOCVxOV^)' v o
^feu:.,.WW™* jsp*^#QneQc\va r» -A * ^c^
CxT\«X5e ^chJS^csJseel^^ ^ gQ V**^ ^^^ ^x% Pte°\W4c Ay^us ^^ ^- Ccu$i_ ecAer Ab^AAbe lucfcicverA aAa^A at^ AAe, setfre^s^Xsjbussed c^ a b£LG Vr\^\ oeckred. ~TKXA?.9SS? WT, ASTi bl Ai^ Abe- c^eruaA^, rWe\\aoApem& AWv AVJk a v£xb^ Av\^A ©V2> Aw, ^pAW c£ wvi^cnycA: TKOi^M^CC, ^X^.miV,AA WY^-ftDb^ TA^Oj^3Sq£\ A^>. h KUANWT^\\AV^BLR^HAV\£T^.\^_ (LOJA \JQbKA £KTr\t: TVA^b. ^mOAATOAlHWDVl^O^S OF TE^CbC£\M,AA£Op Aa5$M XM \A\Q\ V\\AX) MOT RH^SV^b WYWbA^ \Vi5VAXvXT\0^^ F£OU\T\A£. Ar£\ftY. bXAKAA
. U.Wr Ao v^e e\o TF "^& ctabA p\\ qc ftm \\sevOcbX Q^vv^ Vo carrve Ao c\ Ov»u\raoa& ae^ THJ A"M\^^OL-1-5\qAId (\)\^QMDbX ^feVVi ^^bv^e.AbsAr- QPw> W\o am. «ipA WaVk ir&&0
Are, w>1^vOTR^ Q&XiCia LvixxA voaoVi bov^fceu vV^TVVTVF R ST\ N\<V Xbe_9 CVT ^A Ab&u u3ere> \OwCJr vO^ft\ecV »&Xs»e£ c&cirs
lik£ixa^DbA
^WeVVQV^c fx^W^: WfeW\ C5^er tA^ Ave, &A av*u. A^\ c^^> <***> Ate>*V cciAs 3^YA? fcT>V.\^CNC^3:3&> TAo AA^ a\Wo*W 9ta*>\Wfc £[?^ ^f At^AlA^\C\2^ ^^XuVbrK ^F^CAVxT OF Esfon^ AW X^\bYuCoOtT C£VAM\TYK> VOVSft -KVAFX5Fr\X_F^VO^\W ^WAVC^TO XUSV^GV l^AOWOV\TV\^V^CAX)X\VV^VAFOV \^f X~ vJ\Tv\AAS^ \mAX\V\(X\X\OV\TV\A\T \rAA\VXAA \JfcX*£fc xAMtWF ^ \A)EV\C\A.
^ * - p°\i£gzV^A^y\AA- \a<X oALc^SV4 k.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.