Haliburton, Harry Jerome
Haliburton, Harry Jerome
Opinion
236§1<~11 11111,\>@ 1111 @\Qd@\@ \?>?>@\&Qi’>$§ 1 W©\~U¢© %<%‘1~®5 110 NZ 03 \10;©`&1\‘> §19@1)\ e,$\&\°»\c»`n_\@~) §§ I.v\)/Y\r\e. Q\O\'\A~X<f\ §1;1§>@1£_& 31 511§11:1\<_§1§@1% \) § §§ F 101er @Q 111/wm 131 ` 1\\1§><11@§®»13 M§©EH@EM\\ 1 \pm;'> @©URT 0\§ CRH MDNAL APPEALS JUL 21 2015 QQ§F\A\-O n QQ§` g ®\Do Q!‘§§ 'M§@`"?; § ’~"»"““" - \@\§ r\\ QAQ@QQ@NQ… b §§\1&\.011§ C,D<\<:;\MB 1113 QCMQ¢QWQ we Q©P,c\ ¥\)\QM©C@,\/\Be§/um V`\c\>c§\s\)(‘@ §\®&m<;§v \$LQACD©C_>\LAW\ @.\)% c>& LC\L)\> Q/\)c§/QA\P\©©QFS :\§;Zbué?_&`\»(-\€>(` t\)\@\/\JC§OA¢©Q§Q 51\§§@,.\&\]\3‘§<&€_)@_» Q€LS\ \€>[@\SQ»\@,?> §§ ?13'? §§ 1111 \.0%(\1\.( \\1{&\ <1~3¢§ \ LD\ Q @3(1\\`
/V© /R\w@.\<\©.o©c@\ \1 <\W a_c>§ 31 F\CM@<»" CQM;& 111 1111 \\1;:11\11\ \11¢1@[0 511 @:r>'\> v OAQ mgm 131 luna 'QQQ$SR @c§§¢\ 5 \,\1 5 @111310.\) 143 \\<\Q, SXAQLB \1_91$ /QE>ELL@ \,\f 3 \ &QL\ @ \ \ <>> \J\Jljv C>Q_ \§(G\GELP& C_c;)r` ?u?> [\JA ~Qr>r C:>c>c;§ CQU&:_.< \\;`§L,®KPC\‘ \\5<1\1 31 1\ \C§ (:©\\0113;/\3:;'; . mm &\{U)> WGMA_ AMQ“ § \ Q \ O'%CQ v MQQM §§ 111@§111511§ 1131@,1>1@13§13,11 11 _11)1011€, 1311@1913@”` \ 3013\11133@ Go§m) (>1§:\ 1133 1013(\'\(§}§131~+&11@ 111»;331@§ 1 p::@§_,s>@,\> @1§§:9, 1000 031 131/30sz 1)\01\€\0: 1110 QQ~Q€F DQ Qm>c'>Q% \ 3 ' ;Q:§§@§ 111 1111 1111111 1311 1111 931§11311 .
110/§ 0013\13301\191) 11113@111\ 1131@£’;311310®€010§1 n M\Q§~ ME£F\>M>\EQF£$A>)€:§ 010§3§1\3 011,\1\4,€0\\_ /§10‘1.1.130§ 1360 \3 131>9151§18\ 9113 w L,\.\JQ. 23)`1(§9.13><101 \_\10@1\8 1QC1 Mé\bd’\\M v-Q_ 0§ 3€013 ?~Lh»>\130\5\013 §§ 11)° °1&11\\19_11€_3/©0111§1103 1313 ?D:c§ 313 13011393031@1\0\&\4;1 1310§11<_):§1`11.\§11;(/{:0°§.€3§)@§1 1113 1119 D/YY\Q\TF;° °11\@1330‘1 Malp§\a\&\£x@§\@a§a\ 301<@ 131 13030\: 013:§:\ §32>11§1&1 1133111311\11 1313 §§13’1§1@_31:;" 11311§ 1 3 31 55 C_LM.\_°>@.LD [3$1§ 01”31»$3211»@1\.13@&€_1)1013\€3§£0130`°1£§3\013 1131\@31§ 351\31€3 13 `1>_____,___113_)0_0 3101-3100 1\\§ @§11>0 MQ\Q@_§$R©Q@A` §§13\€.1313\¥ \31@31\)1 011 1\\[email protected]/ 13 3§)\/@, 1311 131 111/331 331\,@_(€_£0>11\511 § §§ 011'€1>01§3101\ ev~g 13@13§1§11 001111€,@13010101 131 011\)
331ng § 1113 3 11111§11;1@, 1113 131 1131 11 1113 Qr©r§¢u(‘ 31 0§f M&\&U 01\\\/ %\11@1032©0§`§012§21)® 01\)(‘_.1€,011\)0§1 /T@ 1§(?11011>\} \3<?1@1§1.100_¢3 \13 3111€001\§§\01/30§1 11302§@€131\)1\ l( 1:@1§131~'? 003`3§ 10031,3; mg ?3\1313§» §\01@\1§91'123:£11) 1010 111331@313&€1§1\131} 01)\{113 1311113112§\<\0¥1§1 &31@ (`_3\1‘° 13 123 1011/363 313 \\Xm>_, 1011 13§ \\1\&3 @§ Up 13 1 151\\€.01@_¢§ \31\911\@3§'131§ 10§1)1013¥ \¥3§.]0§,3300‘1§\1{1112@ RLQ ::_£)J&R¢\B\©% 015 &\,@_C@<`Q._)u\)§& c>§ \X§A\Q,\_QO_£\§R®¢\) \3103§)§@\\303\@331013\5@§>&§ 1513 305 ~ @\:10133§ \\3>\£\01>\3_\©3_310 &\1>\@3,0]1::_3\53®:§ ` §§ 3§5§1@10@&‘ 1_,005 1353 013§1 1~)1 bQ\CJz>Q?§mQ§R\>\€__ :(GA_,\(:\ :MQQIM\S>§?\>\Q. \\J\§Q§F\\C..G§D\D::>§ 1>§1:)3§£\;_\1\-€0 ' ` Ou_\)f§ vc(`&mc§\& 5(;_%\~@&€§ 013 gilmer \C§lc`>&£/\YC:\ 031)\0§\1§@§ D\ anchS>S, 010 991wa \\\ 011 103§\53 513,10\\?_10€£@\ 01\30§1\33(§)0515 0§ \~305\03<\310 CCM' (o\` UQQWA}:§¢PAQCSuL/\ \`)\[;>10§’> 'Cl\?@ /YQ)Q~)&& \) _'§;03§>_€_. 551 05 15 11105\1\ \6\1131\ l(&@ U@ C,(D\\.)%\P\'\~\_»X\Mm@@\ 'D\.$ (QD¥\,£)JQ_J`; :.§CQD:\)Q(QS"§§%D Q\“\ \r\&<\ §§ 105'1>3,35 100 550 <\< RQQ@.~¢\\% m?c@¥@>\€\@0 1 11~ 01301\3°\ \\>0 13"§§1(;,€,`1) \§15;\1.0 0\ C.Q,SYQM5\O§3@101 115 q 1\103,0@1`\;>33 10 353/§ §§ ~\B&{\l R")G &c& 06'0& \1::\§11\/1\(`::1\\§\\_1\\§\15. \1§§/@5<">11&11.1 C_ b\`\§@€ l\§f)\§~em\\ \1 O\\(\ Q\ u‘€_b§€§b¢§!\°\_°§ j111§ 1351
“ w 0&13>5M 0 ~\§1\€,\\`§\>\"\\1<) ;U`~§©ov-\§G\Q 1§\ 1_,(`_,`€§):\3.§.€1€;%~\3,10§¥ 2°(§%° §§ ;§,@1:@ 301 113 01>\>;€13§03<>1>11135 1531 01,3@1§ u§M€, §03§1.1\>1\©“(1,\1 135 @§L§A,Q,N\€@§€L§<CQMQHP@€ 1\)@§03>1\3, 5§&3\09 1¢3>§3. 31 10 /§z 303)\1\<>1~3 €, 01 173 OMARAL Q(€ 1~)\9\ 5€,> u%c_'m\) \,_>1£\10>5\'1 5 R\\p \>330 1550 1105 §@0@03§1<3&3@ 3 °\€ 351 ;u<§<r\€,-\r`\\ 511qu 9§1§\@_, §@r<&f\ QQ>\`?CL&\ 3 ~ 31(§103/01 50<113`%<>7\ 131 2~&/\:°1\3?1_%@5<3@11\\13§@35 &`;v\\\§§\`€_ 5 €/\R` 1\,¢»\1\3 033 o§ LQ ' ‘Q>W\\Q-O@-Q\ \52‘\@_ ‘l\_w§§ D<§S\ m\©m><>§ <>QQ®\D@§ E>K§\A~X@@X) zpewwx\.e_m el @@\ .\>\q &\m>@ ek M>\ gmacm§¢§,@§\ C_@Q\§v\m@€.\@ee_@ &&L@&x\=z&\¢\e_@§\@. z -» bey 01 u\)@m%% a 105 ¢\)Dlv AQ/\ Q. FQ&A\L£\ \[K>\§);:[§)DM§ ;`:&§:LMQK m\\ &A`> umw A§,\ @__m\\ €_ €C§; \>m§< M&@@_;k, ,\>z§v ama ZB. q °\&_\\\Q§<,Qw©/\>\CO¢\C(§@§R\>`¥`°\§\QQRE& §§ \§&1\& w !;C\(l)€w [;O?\\K \»\€@ B:\ D\FKAC M,&\` L)_§ll\`;\€:£\ L\AQ>@\(§. \L\ \L @,\&(ng§ ©(`£ L)\Fm,\y’£\ S`\l\f_£.`€~¥ 1)3&83 fa§c>\$.@§®%m Y<&\%Q\i Mr\<>\\- A§{\@\me_ U\_\a.£\ Z>,©M.»£, \Q\r\\&&\. Q. _ el m ~ /\ o \ #?Q§/§z;ec§) ©QY\\Q@.$@@Q\L\\€L u%\d€§<§§@§& \;YD ,\)\Qc§¢ ~X§<r\»_€$?i;_@€§vm_& R\D \\3 €_' N(;L ‘}:W(§¢c@ M€BJV Z`M\ \Ux@v\¥ C\r\>£l- &u\§§§©c'§vqu§w&: K;Q§maj:¢\m\d©€_)@ ,'\§€_>Q\_O \\/\i\/~Q, P_a§?\\&@ row \Qamm. ~)\Rj a Qu@$l¢\@§ rmie») Su%‘ \‘>F§A_T ®\MCQQ£€§.RO€> 3>3>`{.°`\§¢&¢\)@;€_» r>§ C_®L,¢ /\)&&/\ G /\)&k (`GSE_£,Q,\“\-r>r?_€x\ r~)w°\i\£.® roc§w£§v 5\, C,BJ/Qf\ €/\ @&§ C_\ €G»r§v%; § ¢Q»QRQ 9_£§3\@ &\©\¥ Q®¢bl‘_/Q£L§,@QA 3(%\[€_, LM\,¥ §§ Qj\wj@ QQ@Q<§;Q&\&\X€Q@§R __ §§ c>@ed§ \\~(") $§N ‘§ N)X¢€\`©BZ\)\Q§RC`>Q OQ QQ\&€J(;GQ§(§ \A&E§§)dm§;§§<§j Ag¢\pj ~:§\v:>%m` C_§s\mv©§&, §§ , \m oc§¢@,<§R\@\@\§ \F C,@L.USR /\) %@.&zu&?b <;£§!\>\+ `\ (\\:SU \v\{`, 445 ch /0 ?;\Az@¢§\\l, * `/-T\l\\Q/QQQ§& &3> \(\&\c &°\ '\B §Q(€_°\~€,\)\@c§ &\J&EQ®G§~MMQ \ \\>Q,@e.£»§\“»¥ s 01 a gm . Q\r YO\C§\AQ\\~»\QQR §§@v@@@&e ©Q €:»/\\\\0\¢\3§? old 6>§@~@ fe_{’._®\rc§< omc§l §§ ?&A ’\c>\\>®(` ` (Q&`D\ § \\§<f\o`§‘v A?\\(°g 3d 0 ®LMS`¥OQ m 135 \Q\?\> ~\ A§I\)Q~`Q©HAM\LO § &@A@B \A'~>\§ .QX@:’; ..)\5 ¢>m§ \X@:;§ ¢>“\QJOKC§R ~\ §§ & °\S\C.ckv f`°\ ch E_.' D§ u&\°°\.@_,€_Q/Q§ \)9&0§3\.\\)\ QSSD@\J?Q\ § Cu .\>0§:@\… p &0\\ @@&<- me 35 a ,\Y§ Q@> r A§W,S\E_R\Qc>&e>® §Q,\§\Yo \\Bé>_f §ee/\[)\§> R\~L\°L P_§ / _ §§ » q o §o j§&@;jc@&mm\& \&\pm§®r€,§(w%&a%€@o§£®@m§§$?¥\ bm,§©®&§&$mjv @NAE\C®@A§DQM\[IM\Q, Q\VX“KQ Q§§ec§m<&\e:§>\)\? ¥§<1\€, RL&@@¢QS@J\ 0. /\>_&A§lc\o§“@_\&@_ Q\ c§©€u)\)\le> C’;LD@~>A&NQR\! mg \ @§MM SQ£> ::SQ, \&3\11<>2> L\@\@Q_ 633 D\ Qe§> 0.3 \,\»Q/\r\a§>\ §e@§ o./\)<§)`(` Q&C§e$ \BR\\G§< wc)v FQ. S\@¢\»Q,Q>&M£)C?§ -,C,\?_”)C <‘§W_ Q@MQ@;\. \Q\% 3 \,3 ;1:_> 445 4\\\@€&~)\ R<P% \<4&\ §L¢S¢~\§\c§ §§ °\ 0 Qu£\ Q_\QLCM/Q§ec§ \mdr\&v@> AXM?_; \ /’C< &\ C@Lm§v §@> FQU §§\s\€f§\e@ 0¢ @§>R §§w@\)§mk( \QQ&`\~Q>@AA)\<Q&§\XS©@€JS` &/Q Q,§¢c> <;\X\N Aw§p\, ¢\S<L% \,3 gm S\OC\\?F\\X RP§;,¢\M ,_ a %\ 6§4%93\ Gu\)¢§)‘ §§\1°»§\<>\\ \) §§va L\QY>% 33»;> ;LD S’<Y>Sl %3\© fym\ A§>P \,G\?<:), l I§_ ` §M"\. (XZQQ`K\ ::: C;\Q_c§ Q\{( M»\§\N@_, §¢O@ bk \‘§Ym%>_ 04 Ax§§:<)>*\r@?§ »\v€><k§€<\e:,\@@&\ §§ kw[r\§\@ug Q§:§;\K »~/\Q\fi¢>,\d ` 0)\1\)£§2(?§€§?@>§. - _L;/_` Q.€)s;;v& ca§@_o§geg; g § : \@Mc\v\'[ `\Q§DM»Q_\$Q\\DMP~\QA) C)Q(§i ¥{MQC>F€ c>\r\)<l\ b\& K€Q_§£\C>;B 0,1)\3;§ M&©M \_®?C,XQ\ QS§\@ Q \__@:,:,\>CK‘ &Q@`)@ \/z§>¢eé§)lr@¢§r\&,@ §§ Rx\e. &w§v ac§£§m&%€¢§)
S'OQ`\~Q[ § <r L L\\Qr\é\@&€r'&\¢m/\SYCDJ /<\>lo»\.\€¢§ Q.
LQA§L; Qog\@ c\e §<@@@ &K@»\)AR/\ AR/\Q» W_M_ § \ 3\\£ how § j{>x\ \;L<s§/\$z
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.