Texas Supreme Court, 2015

McCarver, Robert Lynn

McCarver, Robert Lynn
Texas Supreme Court · Decided November 24, 2015

McCarver, Robert Lynn

Opinion

' . ”/i; rsz E/¢r/< mc :A;J GW% " ' v ' ~ REcE\onlN ' -Oum-QFGRWALABPEALS___..._

/?£" 7%£. $7[&/¢_ A 7[ %)(M* ' l `\ ' NQVM 9n15 ~ f usf ` l

AberAcpsth\erk

` ' 4 /Za£¢/z/’ L$/m Mc['ar'l/C//

hear Z/a//<' '

7Ar_ mcer m fAP/§c. //107 Maaf (;RFur‘/@mcz£¢/mgs $L¢ca ?ZAf ` 7‘/5¢ wz/`f 153/ed 7§;“ éme A/¢,/nécr’ LTM_/°?éz 75 /)}_/m»; am fla 6 /`£C'br*c/` /AL’I'£` Z¢ZZFC 7§71/' {§’) (J&c//c?[/Ar)$` l(é/) L(///(A 7.4[¢;/ ($,/7 [¢/l/?/§ d/{/`€ 7[/6<3/ /?/C_&Yd /¢5@7{’1 7%£ A'éa'”d /}7€//7;8/76 c‘/ MA_?Z . aha/ 7[/c ///,{//7[ 7%¢ ¢§/Ac/ 7%/`¢‘6

/?b&/z)¢ ///m /7£ (7)/‘4/¢/ ~ /c/¢@/`c/ ///f/lf 3_??`7’ 5797[¢ _/$/h// ?f . /l/e¢¢/ /?¢;x/Wz `_7€¢\/45 75'§;,_'¢'; ; `

35 05§ @\ 02 03 RECE|VED lN

' '* 1 n » (" \ ` 1 ~` ,` ' _ t ` , ' CouRToFchMlNALAppEALS . 7 7 1 £nu__$e_;s_N¢>‘._._`L;g olg_\£ '~ H a l f l 7 n NQVZ‘*, 2015 - l Z g olzz_%- H`L| ' ` Ab€lAcosta,Clerk_ . _CL olzzq- H£l b 3 _ R¢.-> aloed*_\__}i/uu_ M__£_£nau_e£_ x - § . . Iu H\e_ Ba}ud£ohd' ' V. »‘~ ` § n Rm` _&‘__\\¢6¢._ £»uM{TLf T\m-_ €+n{’r_. bp T€_X&S '_ § few Juo\)c_ml D_:sh\¢¥

TZ> +L.L Hm…l_§g@ _Co.me_s__ AJo_w_ _fl:)¢__lo_:,/:/bamc£._ Kaé)m/' _\_'5111110 Mf LAc/M___h*_ .__61_16/ 6651066}_/_(1,'1./[;/..5¢16”)1//_5__/)/_;_0 0(661_‘1@:65 75_ '[¢_)_6_~ _F»€O/F_O_§_EO/ /LJ g_$_d//6/ /MU/_ 60416/¢/.>’/0,¢!_< af Z./?¢J /V_A_JQ/ l_'u__§ujqa€)¢f__{/) 366166>_£_ wad/c/ /(6_§06(££/{?/"1€6§¢165 /_'___ "116_[01..,67_ f£>_ /)MO/ HA)Q/_ 601/_6/11£;/6_ 1_4_5_1§_//01‘).,/0 ma E___£_£Q__L;_H h Q_u{r_ ._5 3 £L)) 011_\~}_<,11.¢__96_|0__'2_00@! M; Me_e.l/m~ was /'\1'1).66_>/ f'o __1£_6,0665wf /\']e M dam/66 66 I’l}za \Q//ow/ua eha if66s 7 ___L‘_J_/l_L/l-_ 0_€_€_£11266/ 1151 ,Qmm O_/p 6700€¢_ 9_@@66 \/EA/&j _fM_/'O_A_.. _[A,m,g_c_s_wh/ch we¢e_AlQ/_ LJQ_/_'_ cf_c_c/ _A'_£Maé€~_ fh6 é¢>_a/< 1660¢_0/ f/M)L /\7,€ /7= /,'MLMA Q/1J AM/ 7 5£001£ ml @A w 71/_)6_ 6//_`6_€_¢°/1¢/~/ O/f/)c Abu§€

. l , L/Ma/QL_£.¢/¢_SZ.Go)_ov(_+l/le_MeAA/__La/e_oi[_CQ/m_w¢/__ 1 ` _&m_eaé¢a_fi¢_c_/jna[/_¢A»_IL_£/¢S_é/ZS_Q£_66'{[0_11_4:&_1:_/’1_6_5{_&/;.>' ' 1 ' ___EAOI_¥[email protected]__&A._€O_[_£‘Q/:d_£,/_u'.5"1:0-.6.5__&£_[_A_w_da.£__`il;:£{_£_l_`/¢_J______ __ ` d , 366L_:_.§,b_o;[o_u£aus_£uol_€m$,oi_C,rYaq_s[cj_a/c&;_f;h@)£_ié'_e d ' _T@@_[_J_u_o}_ci_e._61107_]060$6¢11)&,6_6)_666_@{666/_1_1_P_iu; ) t _ 66411_7:61\1611_6:6;1 '__/_A_E.//_c’/Q /`_0_64/_6_7).56/1166 @)[1'/16 446/1267 v v ~ ,¢.}r:_e__l'_ _H_§$l$gu_€_¢_i§_d€,{cc)§hg_/`715 l - 6 l _ ~` ' 5 v \06 rl§_i_'&i`:e._$f_;\§$__'h_fm, _o_.$_€_€&¢`m»`u/)/ 1165/174 '_ »Q/\_'J_H,Riaéa\nd-’_S"l. p&é_m .57107',.5`_\[:‘1_66;/7 ila mD///[[mw?¢` d ‘ '

dz_`.,@_e`c.f_‘/_l»_;d_,_uz¢_"r_111_5»16)1),7_/_£_&/_./_%_66_§;,~_)_=11\./_53(6_€6£$6 01[ ‘ ___14;6/7)061'/'6,( w/')fc,/?)_'/;sh lEA'Q`u:,EAM cc/ alia/o fp 771&1€;)61£

fb_e|'-_Hz)_e_éackmaw,r_m[ _6:'5__ _u115_6“6/6/16_Al_6665‘/1 , _/:Q____'__I__ _Z.Sfmé/r'sA._é_C`/§/i¢n¢_CAAZOQ_QA/efzz;_bb_d »0(”'7`7)6 ['1)6[:11/§ d _Q/:/;if/:.;DalA_C£u§_gzus_-v__ _£1_»1_5_@619 il i_s_ub_?i_éu&cé)_.__ ` ` * _\)_L_¢_+0 116 .F»_,.~.._¢_rm'1,¢/,_6_#'__5_10_+_,_/£1¢0/ £1,»1 ' ' ____§/)_1_47/_66/AéEA_Qunf_é_$¢_[_em)_/Qé_/a/_g_£_///_L_Q\_LS_ééc/_c’._ l :A/d ug_/W/w@{e/pQSSZ///fu all ,€/`60€})6/'_5, }_mF@_SAz _ x ._ ‘cm"m,m/ 11116_7)_1_`/67_#_/1;6 #_ @M,d$_mQQ/Q/_Mw_c_A__ mgm£¢c_m_¢k;AM/`_q_g¢¢;/f_a/_¢$H`c_< » mw/ fha»_¢e/v A// ° ` _//n<_/_/}b/C/_/»; _6_1_`fl_zm§_wM_§mH[/_£§AA_'AQ€_` u/_\i._$_., _Th_@_mu¢__&& _+_1..11_11¢_11¢{,;11;1_‘5111@/ 1116 - th_e__k_¢l_/_676_[:&;7077»6;/_6_~»6;¢<>did _11._6__5}_1176_666¢16¥ 'I‘Z)_):m0_65_6_._661_`64£1»1_6/_'7_1_21721/_1774_611/_6__/_€7_`60_<;/_?)6!_7_7)_)9£1' 7 ' *‘I`J_I_Q_NQT H mm 1 ?~'?`

.._____U_AI_ D€thc‘i£ c‘>/ 07007;, M6 /\4 £Z)q¢¢/¢;z w,q§ ' . _/_mchQ/c_c/ )4,6_ :/;h/L_c;_ dhn.g_g;.§)_`l_w¢ ah wh/¢,h 66666_66“6 +h6 _56@6_3;D6»¢)/[‘ _[6¢"616/661¢_ £/{DI¢§?LS'?_Dectqi//' [,6~6/6 ' » ` ___+L£QJ_ZJ~_§ /9/1/6/£’ ' , ,- _ ' _w~A// w_h_/ch c.)€/LC 1420/w 67%€ 5;&/)06_ £/mmw/P]UL<@¢/¢ . Aua/ fh6 ££__$Lz/JZO/_Shafz_ 56:`/;?_ jua/A/A ['A,€ ____th/_ w»¢_§ wh 066¢//6/66_>_/

i>_ .Iu /9_ LQ/f/\f_e.§$_§_ho/cm 694/§ L_c@w) /`7 0£6466 c/eA¢/¢j_ __<_h/¢_/<_/_ fh§_/ whe¢/~_sh6_A66¢_i/_6a/ /)f fhe_ fhc hvu_:z:’_ _j_ 356_+666€60/461% ihecchc¢v;c::wA _ -_ 4 ken é“hehsm eu/ wh/):;h /`Mc?/;'cA/;J/_/_’_hzih_hh,cj['_@wh 6__. . bumpeL_/u;a/_w//uc/th/a/ w/)_S_ 1['6/ z_ __f_h6_ haa.:£_, 66__ ` Z) MA MC fha/66 Ld/‘L§ /M/€&§f£c?/?z)£ _SA¢DZS_ who fh6 FMM/;_ wuuc)')c€h6//6/6¢>)é_fl1.66_6‘/96 ,wh/6h____ ' 1)\1@/1_`6@/66/ fh/))L /`76 /`10[,46466 wo_§_h6fw_6w fh6 ____/)Qu.:6_ m_lc/ £h6_ 606_ wh_w h6_ _.jho/ '/,1/ fh.e_ 64661/ %hc_ 6/6/46¢4/)¢/ ` N61L6 :€ Hmé. 666 wou/c/ hm/6 hhch-/`/u/‘o '

`00;_5'£’, 7 §§_M_ //' MM_S /\0/5//11/£667¢3661‘6€/ )»l ?Lh6 LJ£/ 6//)76,\11£_5

weF_F__ puo/ 1'11 o(11 ua/`i¢¢¢w/; 054£01£/0111 /1/4Y0/17__ /_h_€._ 5/0¢1_5€, v ~LS '/'/v_ iad 7"/),4/; Ou N,ou‘cm£e/z 15 JOD¢ 111 Dwu/u /7{4114121¢’_5 100/126 Ataoaj' 515 031`11_/`¢:£_1/_31;1/ fho} file 55:3_}_5_00¢1/0/341/7

1 l ./’)1`_/' /'Lm /41>35: lif f/u:% 11333/0/. 50¢/:_ _é.r;___z_'__océd

0110`¢£1`_1_01.1.'3

N__o__+¢;__[l_&{;n111¢u o{§uled'l€l`" …m&w `l_'c _¢1/)&_@

»33___1'_\11111111_1_/1111_1§-111111_111111_ 1111_ 1131 5111_11 `_ (<SL) 1")\1 H£le d11;c'c._hf3110 315 t{/l_e_ Hou_sc lp 1561 :ii_LMr’;tS imide 13_!;11;30_\11;1' 13_1511_1`1+' .Wmoz.e_§ 1mp[qg55‘i?lcO/_~U’1_\Ou“d§__ wou_lol 1’\6\/€5______

13 Q,L\nuq€_ H\e_ diacch`o)~o +l/le'vwmshbf 1`/\1 13 11//'/'/1€ _ ,

5__|'13_11.5_€.1(_.51%1)11:11~11 +l/)A/'_Mg,_b_u//e£s 131£141: Awf_$/vd d 32.

1 _ -. - 111 fha a//Lcd/M_O/_f_h e,_/%m_$;ci/nmwua /7L /`Z €é¢ycl_ LS Aj_£> Gu///z?i_ [+_§_£504?iQ/ ` M_@_ M=_‘CAA\LCL_ w_bi_$ibidu_/__<ec/ 73§/_€119/_[,71/1"§1 bi £éJLH_CiélC_dIb/__ /.\io_i£ C‘O__mm;i[_5t,11¢ 31/_45_ R/€ou/__&Ls`/S(: ___,_L¢/+c/ 713_5€1//€1/2._/1:__£050_7/;)1_1_`11€§)_/3#1£ 034/wa 1940/l l’i/i&/ /'D p/C/?G/ gun/113 513`_/-'15£2/¢/:311£€_/4/”}0¢1\1€21 550/vi s 1 ____Qbu_/`w_si/ 1\.1&1€/2_ /_£€._\1_/`1::33_€@§/7 111__1>3 536 1325 %/1<:13 wea¢_x_'_lq 15_11/¢¢/ _,45 1333/133/ 13 f/ze.` 1343 j

\ n -n'\u; |F| `5{`1,;>€£.€/.' Mo‘|’ 154 Cow~e.$€[s 1£40111103_5” r` ' . ddlc€_ M»@_ M@Gi¢¢/¢L.L_Jou/o/Mi£ 501/d 116/ch gal/1131 19410/ _

~` would /’l A_¢&_£Afhe¢¢;éma_&ZZ/:H/jz)fo`_zécce._él/ls__z_`)s)@qce,s¢f_§,¥___." j g ,'W`~§_ _ .. v T\o;_u_\j'._l`_me_h__&u_<;\t£a_\.\_i,g_‘:ll`_cl£l#@_”_§_c./.la,z`§e'_'$ .

` ma § f /01_<0_</_'¢ +Z)` gayle'/_'/:l'L,_STng%A¢_/§;Llj;_££%wbae/maul- Mc*LM._mala/z_@£g_@aé%dééfé@¢_o¢_mf ` ' Slw£$ . w<.’/Lfi 7{:'4€0/_/?/£ OL /_"M M_e;_£_?_//chf/"JM 01[7'%£ l . Hou..S_'€___QC_C_u_Fl`C'Q/ LFL./ le/%A/$ du 0/ ¢;JA/’ch ` _1 ' lM¢_/¢JM_;/_LQA,M.,;_¢L@£_514£¢_&!/¢3®411£/_'_$11@£§ _ ~ 1 ` '_ LJBC_M?£/LC§/ H_/L will fha fillkea/éb/w Qéikl,€..§kla¢¢_$_€.; n d " - ?€zzm`/~lcl q dcgac)/_/_lg_dpmdaa/§:@MZZ,/Z/_'£Alazw w;.#.¢,:ez.e,<_¢//’ ‘ Mé "_ ___/70.`//2_:41`_/.)&'/:¢3>_/_'41;[/:).&_./;)ads.cj_é:_u‘l;[:l.o£b_€ha§;é_ l d_o[fh& /’lou,$é_,l 4 ,` y ' ' ' IL_€§_d;¢A@£- _m@_le&¢é;,oM¢@@£zA/_ %014/_<¢/;{ - _ '_'__C,./_@l'z):l_f/:l_1_4_1£_.5h_o_f_s_g)_;/L£_é/;:c/;A/jlla_/A_JE lib "/p/`/C `___'_Ll ’;,,'{1;¢/_5_6_6_{119 _ _&s_j£§ ¢Yzz'A;u§/'_HA/_af`/)M_Ml¢/_f_h'_c*_`____;_ » __.PLLA/r_`c__éd lim/14 z`ozw 0_.. /’hc: jac/zan/_j_nyM_/€LZMU____ _j+A/_€&Jl`ew__£)AzQ/L_€caa_s&/_D/_/zz/_fzer_ch',gzga¢§ '_ M nl¢,z,'_»_| +z>.,_%_¢*m,_»,il_¢_c,lz@ ‘@_M_m@_£@:@_/_`~lp' . ` "`TV\C 5}1?,'£°.5__'{;1;1¢6€.11 op Ciw""{' 'l`_s'mLJ/lef_h_c;z.»cm MQF~ _ :S/Ic>f_§ L,.)c/£.c’_' !Z@cf)+'f @'1€. ')}\i fha O{Z<¢/‘}Zo/w- ¢9/ 7%€' , ~ .' - - hou_¢e.’,»$'c¢cfl LS. ch/)f)@/z£/`/)/ /_`ssmi ,¢Ml"'/'w¢_'s/"ée.zéa/ELJ -

v .~__”lL\l`woM€A{'bliesa/u_e_.f'hc__CLW/Zauezsdl'i.$suc/.Jhme ° édS_IO£CCl//MJE_S_JL¢MMA , _<./u'a§,/nex_¢/£ * ` 1 ~:, _ ' , f__w_.___,_l.qlél_;fh`@_cze_uaf_ih_c__s_ o_l;s_w_c¢c_~c§fze_a/_&)f"_)f/\L_;_;_; ~ v ~ ' b/leu.S_e__ik_A_Maf;yd;a/th/eaz/QQ£A@&'¢_S 150 7%_¢:' . ` ._ __lU/_;;A_Qg_§u/[?_éE/Mz_LMJ/;~¢/_Z¢//¢ocz&d//;(_méoé,jhu.$ ' _‘

. im_):}§_e[££~_ *z>;`caau_;cj/b/l/ /z> ép/% MA£@:..< fé£_ _ _ n l. O/I`L;@)Q'Q_/_w /'h;’_ 51¥)1£5 wa/Lr_ [/,`aco/ i`_S' /€é<§¢a/.'S`/`/(/q - ,_ ` `N£bzx_g)_/_zal[ 143 z`__sl»?lé/c 4 za/__Ag l/l:’-,zQ//‘c'f 'f/lc;gé¢c_ ' , ' 'i~_h_¢_L€Z_q.z'¢)__m.w.hs_@/£AA}§,_/:,_l`$:}z,o_s_@oLéc €/~/ vi¢'le)". , '

M___é_`n\e__@¢’.j'a{’l0»._2&¢._,0£.¢41¢_$_'{1¢’\/9I'_+l/\E__Aém/CHZA,)(/Z/€a/_* _ ' l _.*_'__.___CL/:w_d__z;-<_S_£_a_Q//`_(m/ls_{_ca;/;AMQ/_AMWAA_ZW}A/ A£, 1 ' " "'i`/;z.£c/z' 4 '@_ " 1 '. - . " `(‘E)é-'e/\%_ 797£`¢"“ f . ` ';¢L£_/Q¢@gc_¢z£___§g@/!"é¢l l l `,&°|9_£4-¥ \.__u/u~ NCCAMc/L~. a./o hci€éu £eA!/`/[L`l 5 - , Hm% /+ fzu;é;~_'/_Q;@/__aaa¢eéaap%_a[_£?¢_zé)l:;%* ‘ }M;.s haw ‘_{e:,w/ /z> _#le.'_§l‘/+/c A/")Lo¢u:%{ 0/ , HK£QL{L¢££L_/;au_é _A_/th,£_€au¢aé£hhz@_elj€émé - T/’lLS 16 Q/_AM ¢91[ A/v\/em'be/L.__‘_ZO'/fj" z ‘ - . ` _ ' " _, °l ' ;7?15»/14/17»72?¢;¢44 ` _ ' . 4 * _ _ peake -p¢/,_'//M<:.e..

-¢,,,»,111

Red River County Sheritf’s Otfice ortense; 062175 5l6 Deputy Hamric and I were dispatched to #65 FM l95 i<rissi Green s ONl l/l 5failed and said Robert McCarver had assaulted his wife daughter, shot residence Green c up a carin her driveway and was armed with a pistol attempting to break into her home. l arrived ind we checked the area for the suspectl He was unable to be found l posted Deputy Hamric outside on a perimeter The family was scared to stay there and asked us to escort them out of the area There were several small children throughout the house The were also teenagers and two young women inside the trailer. The female on the couch was Cliasity McCarver She was crying and looked to be m a lot ofpain. Her mother, Leona McCarver was frantic and wanted to know where the ambulance was for her injured daughter l told her the ambulance was refusing to come up until we had secured the scene Using our overhead lights and spotlights, we lit up the yard area and escorted the victims away. Some in personal cars others by ambulance . l spoke with witness and they all said the suspect would kill them. Idetermined that due to the suspects behavior and having a gun (and using it), l asked everyone to leave to a safer area. His wife hald minor injuries from his assault and did not need treatment His daughter was bleleding from her mouth and vagina from his assault She could not even walk on her own_l, she had to be carried to the ambulance due to her injuries She was transported by ambulance There appeared to be several holes 1n the windshield that looked like bullet holes (Due to tile lacklofotticers, darkness', children` rn the area; no pictures were taken of the le_ l`\lLeM.l' L._\mclshel`lr..l °,/. n 0_“ ,Hm+ car that will be done at RRSO by the investigator handling the case) The kids left and the victims came to 'RRSO to fill out complaints and give statements (s§e yideo from RRSO) lam ` ' " ed l“ lb l-ML l first inierviewed Green and one ofthe suspects other daughters Lacey McCarver Lacely was at work at the time but felt like she needed to tell me how violent guided .1,\1 limit he has been and lhow he had refused to get ajob and that they had no electricity at their home Lacey was at work during both assaults Green and l spoke freely for a few oh file l`lou_<& minutes while she detailed the night’ s events (Seei uterview tagg and written statement).

Green stated heihad assaulted his wife and daughter and shot up a car that was parked 111 front ofher house She said that the bullets could have easilv_gone thru her trailer and \ h injured/killed her or her kids lagre edz especially on glass that rs thick and angled like car _ ii it mauch hilt/ti glass, ricochetsl are very likely with smaller"" calibers She said the suspect was wearing al /UCOCM££S camojacket jealns and possibly a red hat or red shirt He had a small dark colored object in his hands thai looked to be a pistol (this_ is also, what she reported to 91l) Lacey stated that the suspect had a pistol that she knew of; it was a dark colored 22 that had wood grips Lacey stated he carries it everywhere on him. Lacey also stated that she wanted him to remain iii jail for her mom’ s safety Green stated that during his crime at her house, he attempted to break into her back door and she thought he may have hurt her if he could have g'otten inside She also said she heard the shots that he shot into Leona' s

De_i\/c=_t_.snu mud

car. ` Next I ipol<e with the mother and the other daughter after they returned from the Clarksville ER. They stated that Chasity was kneed hard enough (tive times) by the suspect that she had vaginal bleeding and blood was in her underwear l asked il`it was not too much trlouble could we save the the undergarments as evidence and they were placed in a paper bag and tagged They both wrote statements and spoke with me about (l` t'~: s §§ ‘ ‘.‘.~ d l ~ .`eeso/ ' `\_,,,.. both assaults (see interview tape and written stmts). The mother was adamant about us catching the suspelct Both agreed with the other witness as to the camojacket and` jeans being the clothingllworn by the suspect The daughter was visibly shaken and upset Leone- said that Robert and she had been arguing and at Krissi house it became physical tie choked her arolund the neck Seeing what was happening, Krissi asked him to go outside and do a chore for her (hoping that the separation would calm things down). The daughter advised that earlier at her house 1s where she was kicked, kneed, punched and choked to the pollitt of almost passing out Chasity said that Robert was mad at her mom and tn`ed to take ilt out on her During the assault, she was trying to get loose to run away but he choked her to the ground and she almost passed out They then went to Krissi’ s and that when thell RRSO was called Both women were sure that when the suspect gets released that he would assault them even worse. Irepeatedly urged them to let us give them a ride to Farlnily Haven and get them some help The suspelct was unable to be located despite officers looking for him hours after the offenses occull.rred Victims were given family haven/family violence packets and strongly urged not to go back home until daylight Case is open awaiting warrants The panties (with blobd) and photos ofvictim were kept at RRSO The suspect also has a valid llprotectivelorder against him which prohibits him from possessing t`irenrms. (102" llDist Ct.) lRoden 604.

,-.1,9'1§"~/- `]11 3 - wITNESs sTATMNT .

1115@;,11\\5§<1411 HOME PHONE 1111 1251 ADDRESSC' § 1§1_' . woRz< PHONE _. _.“… 1~'1/§1_-' AGE_§<'/ DL M1§11/1/13 SS#§// / 553 51£01/ rwBl 7/&71

cASE NUMBER 013/m I realize that it is a violation of the Texas Penal Code, section 37 08 for me to make a false report to a peace officer That means to report an offense knowing that the offense did not occur or knowing that I have no knowledge about the offense 1_.1.1.`/1_'_:-11~1§ 151 /5<11)5115/'¢1515 §11;"'141-\#1 11641111/ /1/1‘111//131"'41511§2~;011<191\1)11'

1111 941'4/11\1 1111 411 :-}§1'111151' 111/1§_ 1`.» /_11_511,./' 511&{ 1;‘11_51 §§11 \1’/1 5,'5'11111 1`§)'11_111 151/1161 11 l1/~ / `/ §:/,t§’{_,._/ < -:"~/?11(1'11. "(/l\ /U/'/"'1 '-"1'§{ ted/11 §91"1`14.19`J _S<1"11 55 3144~~,`/`_ 9 )` L§',)l`\'iAJUD-i§_§§1/€»»5-7[1)~17{?{‘§L</

f ' .1. 111,/ l §` »,1/?9 /97\£',\,\§_1;_5,5 f§//:i_§ 111\.`§§5\<»' .§W L~/`\'( \§1/.1§11"9'1._/ l ' 111-111 1111 1121-11 14111111111,1/ 1141 d+. 33 1 1~"_1’ 1`;»/1/9‘§.1'1:'3 §_11\/1’ /1" '/5 1111 t/1§11~/§\ /\C§:’§§ 1' _)11'..'( -1.11/1,'1. .11.1_'.-~)11 1"" 11 C‘k/ ' 552/11 §_[..'/ 1131 1114‘4( / ["("1’;.§`)1 \~ v 3 -:'<',9.§“/5§"(.;1$_)1_9 L //\§_/ [9(15<11 l:Y` // 5 LF} 59/1 ..`1£1`]9 §(.15§’~~'9'95-'§9 1 §;L- L9 Z:@§.(9/l1 §§/-’9,}`/`0‘§-9'9 f C/<~`~'¢" 1' l 3 11514/; 511 &/'.1141"/14"§ 4417:_

._, \ ,_.. . 1/" ? \ '\.

)"._".'»___/_ § 1119/g L1!§ 4'/.)/1'<'. §'111;' v.:§'l/`~)-(/:'_'|L, 1111 ll §:")é,-§» {"1!:§_ §_9_§ 05 _>/¢)"§Ll Cl.§ {J~'»"l 513-35 /\ .)\C.’§ 9..'.\\.1-'1." 52§11.\1".-1\ § /9'1'.§ j`§£\ /[)` `/ (C'f L ./"* '/31/[[ (7[~9\ 1111 §`§1". §L`§r§ 1\` 11515€' 191 §11(`1 //6_1(4 11 §2/\6 51“;;,`[1'//; __1'1‘_1';__1 L1. 1:1'1/\/151 Nc § 111 111:1° 511 51 /15/15/551:515 th _1/) L,Kh {(_;`~_*)`__t 57§/\1§5§ 1,1\_§`11 §§ 151' /5)1`.‘-915.`511/51 //\Lj'§ir{ __2_5[’,1LL/ 519 §`5)5'1§." fL§C/`L§L 33§1052/ §X §§ L§ffll‘-§'E-' 5~5)(“- '§5\."§§`1 §9/9\_,"§ 1§\\5 159/l \lj\lz\lylal'~\ /‘§K__;.C/|( -| §.LL§. //§;r/j\(w|/l'§\/ (1151§\111 §11' \11( §'\51'. §` t §\\’5'-"'1~---/ 3./1-1€_5 511/195 1 4 9 ' 1~<:1\11--§1`1111-'111 1116111/11"

§§5§ §?<1/1§1\\ The above statement is true and. correct and to the best of my knowledge accurately describes the events as I remember th em am 1114 A%/- sIGNATURE INVESTIGATING oFF:cER_ me AM/PM DATE /l-§§-d ' PAGE § OF 2 OF STATEM'ENT

011,159 ‘\.,!Sy‘ wITNESe sTATMNT

mec ~ HQQ:PHME ADDRESS woRK PHONE AGE DL SS# cAsE NUMBER DOB I realize that it is a violation of the Texas Penal Cc>de, section 37.08 for me to make a false report to a peace officer That means to report an offense knowing that the offense did not occur or knowing that I have no knowledge about the offense ___'_\1`~. '{':___\_]`\ \L_' k 1 }\l L- (JL~_ 'L L:.)Ll.‘. lb 55 !/\f»l" <._ L,'l( (` .-Ml'r [£$[} /L']` {/ 1b1-1~ )111“ _1 11;¢,§ ((11-¢ LM111; 11\1111)\11[¢/!¢1 § "'/\1"1 })1\,1$<(?~‘/“/»£!; 1/11~.7‘:“/(@;~ `}(/]//L?(L)//¢' //11€1 >(11< j)\t1(1"ML1?@A1111t1/1j01 ule 1111-11 11_@ §11,- 1)_11\1: c;C’111111\,@,11/1\111»,,L` //M/ an//MNMLCN/{yw' //1, /11/ ;/\1/ 1'1""111'.. "1€ /- )/1(-1 L../l/'f\) 11/1{‘ J\‘“L(-S{ /`H 441/1 C’ d *L :(A'//J_’//" 1111 1 1511ch /X 11/'\1’;£1 11L // /l[/</)z~.("{,f'e/ ." O/z // >-111Lu1~ /1121‘¢/¢111@1€1}11 1517§3 Cf#¢¢?»O/; 11..-11'.11 !1.~£1'1 1 1/11%§~»i1~ //£ c ///1//)//`21"`%=~1£/ `TYQr/MY/}HJ b é~1cv11PQM&r@/ 5041211 1--1`»':"`1'"_`1- \ jl{‘ 11 'C1 " `U\r-’ 141 -'1 11 1`@€3¥`1-.1 11 /'{‘: ch/I 1511/111 1/_)1/<.'.,1~ 2 (1~1<1~1//1/ ¢'-., 692 1611¢/¢1(¢/1 1/1 411 .1\;,11;1 .€Z'~Hdz _5/'\c<1 11111 11 111¢1'"=1“111 11"'1' L J" J\\'~y " (:L1"§1`\C--/5C' 3 ti°\f 'C(Q(LLI /l‘iC'L />/({:{L (,{r`[[) H`~]UJ (_..11'/'( 115 11ly 1111((1 Cfn1w_ 1§1 (.~L`E c-(lt j}l\> l 11 7.‘11`:/LC/'C'C(..1‘7 551LC-('(/)C<1{}]`_//1L 1’,]~"-/».`-`|_'!1~..'§§ 1 _,-`6." 11 611111...11\13 ~/11¢’ 11 [. CU/ 11 111 /"WP

The above statement is true and correct and to the best of my knowledge accurately describes the events as I remember

1them . .. n \'£ [,~\ _ l1"1\~"\ j \1" 1 "'('»1'1'/ W~Y/\ ,M‘_‘ SIGNA) _.__ ,-~,` INVESTIGATING OFFICER nam ~ N$Fl Tnm mvmd

PAGE 2__ OF ’Z/OF STATEMENT 9115§ 1© w

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.