Texas Supreme Court, 2015

Morales, Moses

Texas Supreme Court · Decided November 20, 2015

Opinion

,A 5 i ^-02_

.*§_ ""*

Vs.-«

~V^—r ^ o s >^->-^ A^^^ C0UBT0FCBIM^>-APP "MOV 20/2015, This document contains some pages that are of poor quality at the time of imaging.

M>el Acosta, Clerk ihlQAiWl *^"5fe %s 2015 tfiust, Ho. 0IDCI£3<*73& Ah *'Ac Rtte^ v.

&«&p»f\CA*/^'

Of'Vue/ IWu) M,(tf£<£ AA^rf/^ MjtKU^Ud* - ^ &vv4 fiUed WW) j RetebT A^oL Ale .c

SM) OojL«G CftUA M%S fled-" Sejf- fo*> (A Te$3^ \#, M©5*3* AA&^-LES +H«. Ck^e, ass

TM ^*u SMe&f ft? At lto**a£jf»-«te- ©^•e"?J

to 4kAie ojk»a M^ue. *3rfe«^&/vi8«f jsk " &'• -y pa/^t^tfr Mj^tshr^taA Aac^o^ U^U/1 .jut ^ft**^* o£. 4k@xS Gt&e $&coj*&& \WA~ T' %&W • & ftrgVb^ -#^ ^k^v- ho^ ^e- AlSro^y At W&S tk. fc^4 , Awl B/*tA- ^ £r\^ ItvCL

Pa, W t^i^-M^A±)^Ujnjl^j tfas*^1*^ ^=£T-r^rtfr-1 ii i |.u, „1UI|I . ,.,„„..., ,. ui„'.. ,,.,«

p^rsuLe^ -fa Te*«ii >KmA« ^P-Z^pp^it^e

^Uroar^fK/S^^^^? ^|\4so^ A/U^k\ AAo-^yU/t Moses AAur^va. A/^^v^ Ccc*ue.As>.OtOClS33H??

' *-— 8 e^/v. <^ u^e/-L- <^u>0f^KH--( Ot&'^v^- ^^s^J^ M*~4 4o g*^ By A/Wl Otfo*vf^

Add^e^s^s oP- Pes* S^/vtCl ICl«Hfc f.o.Boy fe^GO* A^sWTv - TV, 7£l0& Co^^ fe-f G^.l«^^y\ %)P^5 P'O. \A/ftlT OF MAN DAM CAU5-6. do . 01 DCK2oV73g XIV tka, (W/**{-

D<_s<J-rvt<f Trw>.s Co«-*y\AM v-»U ts p^cft?Vv$

Scv.i3 0**-^ Ct&AA jk$ He^ Sejf fe^ Hee^rA^ +or Keller f^eou*^ whch, "XS / •^L&Ky 'A55UMT ^V 5V&PtN& Ui/WtaSKj ^ fe*c</eMvij MM ^CetMtfe PeCccW^ Skxt/3

4- (Vat * JW, He*- R*0<a*M ^ f?*T<J®

to 4k0j^ oOk*i i4xi0a ^^I^W J9T AAm Ov* q-^ "t^e 0^5 J^-jo^ Dol~kjc\^ Ofo^'A, +*^Cl^*^ ^aiM. £^<x4<-e CwWt>v SKe N/V*- i^l"^,

JVlCowe^ Alc€33 "to ^ G*~^ 3*1 ^e <PosA

4o (\Q A\^j( ,, T^ Sc^o v^rtV- (4ttj <2^<a^ A*W ^ 0*-H/5£ 4g/> o<^vt A- ^>WK- J5^f^fe£Kr~y^i£^0=fo:::&^*#

% fceGU^Sfcled £^ j2^(<i4o^ t& Ar4£/Wt ^O

54^. ft ftgW -fhtk &*-^ ^Vs^ 0e ASr^fe

ft* , u Q IrH 6^ *ta fete C*P G^wvjaqA Pro g*£<gW/^6/

ivv^

f o-l$-IS e-t iJ S Wd£to£ to mi

^puau# \ or m« TO TIC W&Kfo^ftfcljF OW362J 6f~ Tt€ C^sr

4ufoqrai°K/Src,in4wff ^|Vks^ M*^ Morx/LtA Moses AAa^va AAj^v^- 3bN 8< HfVct Rj .

Del vAUrf* TV. 6&n3 ?aui.i.aHi..^vcti«B-'wiaw.

_ -ft u> ^^ 4i^_ Ae ka#. j6l-\ o^- -iJcdf^L.

_J4CJL_1L__ AttcJl^jsis ©^ Pe^jcr^j €«*/v<.cl IClerfc Co. Boy b*?cj60'3 AujVwvTv — Cms*, flo. 01 D6K20*738

A-?*eak &v^ Steed IMecyij RtlsofoT A*©*- Ales ff-v-s. Ap^l' ca4j«M -ft*. oO^ c*f ^la^t^yu^ 4W fU- A&*/6 # G^uuSi© D.^>^ec4ir\n teapot Criu^ 3u4g«- -&a <fke 3St54' 2UX>-cW D'jJrVaf- Tir*/^ Coo^m vpU ts p^ctc\/v$

4kL vWV ©^ Met&erf Co*#uS WK>--cV uu^4- rKe w U©^ rvg * X , -r was Arr^s.^ &** 33 aoiS SiAt* 4-M. We ©^ A*^fta*--fe^ W ^%^ ,,

fcS*«4-. tKt. 0-3 **Ash£« £*0tT /W to &w3l Ht^ B**a dW^^utt^U; Re-b^etf 4^ AJA tovitf to ^tKo4^ ojK^ !4<Mje. **rfe*^&/*«•/ -*»r l^ Or\« q-45- -fie oci £.<&•'&i .!kk>L~Kjdt 0^*A u/Jko K^tAj or- Sk>uicj fckMe -|vio>jkv "p r^f~ Ph>W- y*Lp*iF f*mi #**& r\&i~ »*>»*,**•«**. f*;w , fakL f&v».

4 fch % -&• S^a u^tJ

*t?

<fc 1

JVt(oeA/e^ ftccC35 "to ^ C^^ 3^ *^ <PUsA (y^d^A Off fi^ke- 2&^ ^H^j u^cmj R^CL^ei^v^ Vm Sowv^ 4o ta-Kv 0'f" ^^j Dot-QfyzsGl ^^2.

% Re Q*Aj&ekdi Bj <2e-(Mc>A -43. Ar 4cJW^ 4o ^ h MjiAish^iaA -£w<4& o*"i IAjasA^^

5^if. ft ^3^ -fyctk C^«v KjJ &e Afiro^cw Ac 0€&5 +W. Ce*A/4 , Arc* £Av- ^ ^At- ^£- Wi-4- ©-P UodSesu Corpus Av<c\ Oej>erwL«-

ft* . u Ll*0' ft (Tv JL *!

Oh^

JSe »ll

Q UM 6r4^ *ta Ckte C*P G^*v/v>\qA Pro c^cWr^e/

Mb^—Msj/^^ | o-IS-IS f&v stswi*.^

S £R LgVf TO ftU V* pur^ *\ £«sMfrfl»L AP##- ^pueW ^ op TU« T(? TIC W&Nte^fitr OW362J orTC(Wr C"c"^v<j Homj A/W^. A^otdb^o-Ada^i^ ->• Pro Se

4ufoqrc\PK/Srcin^f€ >»lVfca>Ai M«>/4*'n Av*vW< Pro, 5«-' ^^ <* M^fe^ ^Pfe(t$

De4 vAU^t "TV. 6&>n3 / O *%? gn.Mk»ffjjr;ssiw.;^y«ffi

$©eA SsajS- to Ga>w-4" q-P- Cr-^wAv^etX •H J-m*^, D^^-M ctuJux o^ Jkz±j^_

^^v-€.c| iCl«r|t f.o.aoy (3*?qoo^ Au*wTv- \A/ftIT OF MAK|f)AM Cfsust flo. 0I06^3<TO$

v. >. 0r- wsWvA/i kpptMs

Te> fte floWA£ir luo&ts of A-Pkyk Ay^ Sued »VWijRe!rtAy A*«l Ale-S gfWs. A^)f*« CCt4jcM <ft<^. uoM- e*£ «Ma.^M^Vbca i4W 4W A&*>© # G^W^ D^^et4i«^Q &au-iof D'-j-J-r-^of Ti^A^t, CouyV^i vpU tss p^c^M^ 4"K», &'j&0\/4, ifet <D^u4£ Kj«s5 P^AX^e^t4 fo Sc4- 4vA yUe^^a €k #eies*^> 4Kfc. fceWfo**j 4kL. NM^ ^' 0*~ Wettest* Gsml§&uS W^<^v *U So*<Q D«X"& 6>cmX |4<5uS f\®&" ScJ- tx>A. p5 |^ct/e^waj Mm •& ComWS: @ec*H4t9A Sk»u^s 4fc£ C© uu^4~ -rke to Heu^v rwj i S*ao* -^ 4^e ©^ A/v^>4 -&^ %& A'Btfye

to t ook^j I4tnie. *3w»^&<*8*( J»\ *^y Ov«> O-^' "t^fe Or^i &Qg'C%, Xfc«-A.c(, Qt&Jt'SX •T

«| JW- % -b^ 5^2 ^^a

^m^#%4 -W-wiO 4"*yvu£ "+W^' ' w ^ItD^^^^^c^^^ ^VaiM^ Cc(ajJ>^ (>A)Vwt>v $Vve

JWsweA ^ce^35 "to f^ Gx^ 321 ^>e <PusA p^rf&ir^fW M^trfaja/f -flW^o^ tytuiuv*'

S^lf • ft f^W^ -{fa* C*jks ho4- ^e ASr<j^ Do^m"^ Gta/kj -4&L. W>l^^ 4q

ft* , u tf^&& srr

J> ^

CJP \S?^5^oia fc

f m<u%ou «***&- *&\ 4**s, &***.*« yr*Y Q AiM 6-t- "ta- ^^ ^ G^wjasA Pro oeetwve/

pAo^4 AAto/t j 0-1S-/5 rU$3 C\A«t a' ''64 SIAJUj gpy 'f^J Ar»pU£*'* ^ or U^ loTICWdMs^slc q\ao62j ornco^r Ccj'k^ ^W AA>-^ M^J^a^U^^ - fro S< pbursute^ '-fa ^*>*iJ "K^M?. <^' ^p ^f i^e

P^.c4'A^^ 4vfooj rc\fK 'O^

M©ses /VWM hfanAej

Del v/Urft TV. Dg^nD ^6 lfe^!aj!va>«!mg3ggp^g,,w

^©eA SbAjt" "to <Q>-w~4- aP- Cr-^^^V1^6^ -H J~U2^ 0<w*-<3( C^ecVv 6>K_ JtX^.

C-, Qkr£.?~L- -3 cajQ i c cci ( 0«.S $rv*t/4- Cw<

oihA. Se-rvitt ^Ke^lo^Gl -o\ £jw-t4o >^wu, kddAas'ed. on, -+k?3 o^ M-fr -/J S^v-tcl iCl«rfc f.o.Boy G>900^ /WW Tv - 1^1 lit Co^i• c»-f G-.Vu(/U'\ 6i0P<<<v{5 9' &±±£\ XN tk<^ (W*b£

Te> -Hie HoWAfitr luo&ts of

D'jJ-rvcf Trcu/*£ Coo^V^) vpks tS p^^c^VvvA BeCaM^V,®^ 4ft ^X*k ^-^- ^#.-fc-~ SM3 fW<& Ca^mX f4%£ Hfl^H Se^- fbA.

Pa 4^4. Gs uut4- tW to Kouov r\a * "X, , "X was Atr*es{&} Au» 33 a^iS S*ac* 4-ke. 4-vy^e ©^ Ai^*"&<* %& &B*ye

/Wo*4-- tKt $•* o^ ^h' ^^ ^oi to Sww C*v**>utro erf g ^«* ^^^J wsHt.^ A>^ ft».jtnt SW*y«|P fVel. bfeu>e f\©4~ **>»*.v-eei l^cu , fi«a iTAaJ? 4U& V^v^t*A "H K*>* ^v^oyu4 sk^v-cM 4-t/uwfcc -W\qu W«ux. Rj-^ W-3

A^f a<y\fedt ^>4H^uJ jA^| CV^^yy- P^H^ttui/?

$«kii^( M^ &*& *A**" <*tt« (4x^<e gee^t JVlCou/e^ /Vcte.35 "fe ^ G*~*4 3*t <fl*e. <fWsA

^fen/ G*rfcj -&*- R-e^ And Rje^M-e A4£^oo^ «4- £^*t -fSA -|t^ #8b^ j£fc Caui^yP TTo tike &sp>^u^)> ^dltt^e 4© &J- P^f6*^, At Mmtrrrvct/f -£w<4? o*n CWU/^ 4us 4*u^-j ©^v:-4k*vs Gt&e 6e.ow^-e- "VW^- T< 5^if. ft &$VA-- -fkei- &c*v Kj4 0^, A6ro$& Ac Ws.5 "H^ (W/4 , A*>( 9»^t^ £ Alt. +KL

n>«. u L*A> h ,^- "\4- #*"'?! ^M"'

Q IrH <v£- "^ ^^ ^ G^wv^aqA Pro o^eWr^£/

M^^—^^A±id^J^n4cS j o-IS-IS m /n£,' tt ^ m Lm

To TIC"WwJb^A^r owo6^ ^rccwr 0P"C^EMSMftL &PP£At c

puJXULC**^ -fa t^y><U ^

Pro.5^' ^^c^h^m^^" ^#JS3^Selcl

Del v^Kt Tv, D8^n3 G^+fftccoie of &cvut ^? Tin: ii-ji»v-im,P^i^^'^*^-

a>£~ ^ I^Bou^. £a/4444<2cI AAo^<?^ M^j $@eA SbAji"" "to <Q>«->j~4' oP~ Cr-K^^v^etX "H J*-^^ D*-^e( Ou^Vt ^(^ l<-fr~l4 *d~c-, qux."t,~ J'u4^-ca( 0«-S^^o4 C.-U<s,<j^

Bif "^ ^^ ^ <*! 4u tW- U^4de( STne-t^f ^o«M setv> (j^ §,K!yW>s&j2Jj ~£*\ ZfKKj-tAofi^ pt-ofyV} kdj^astd On, -+K93 O^ci _—-L _T_—. ArddAe^s^s ©^ A^cmj €««/Vt C{ 1Clerfc f. O. Boy (a7<? 00 "5 ftyU "TV - K^»XI i^So'fe" A^j^a^ 7fJ|/j ~t75 hA£<>gtuf>fa Vo^At <&£ A+|^Avg-^| -23^ ^f \A/fiXT Cms*, fto. 0IDCK2OV738

d^spoAcM/^ \

A-f*e^ &v^ fiUed ^W>4 Renter A^l Ales Ayr fw. &&\/Q # Cv+M btr**Mr\a C^amoi D<j<bvt<f T>w\i> Cq^^i \>A& t^ p^of#Vv$

S**C JW*C CttuVV M%S fW" Se*f~ fx>^ Pa 4fc& G& uu^4- TKe to Kocv/v r\^ ^ X , "TWOS ^mesW AujO^'AO/S A** fef&T^ sW^*^ Me, * -As A fVMM •fhu \M<o. SMtSi ft? A- iM^^fr^e can. on t ffttJ-- tKe a^ *£ A»*5' £^3" /w to SWfti 14** 8**a ^n^M^M^ ^^^-^ MA tovtf to 4k*x«? ojk*j I4«^je. ^oa^^dWil J»\ ****

&qfatf fiCMul M* Slot*d^«->***> wf*At* pfi&s*** ,. s&

<\ %4~ % -fiP- S^a <*MJ

*\J\r t.

AW tW> ^ B^^^ &>^ Tan CL^^.^e^ 9&wve 4oK-r- o^ *h)4t^j D*2><h&cslsv( t^s

A4^"oo^ <4- {b^^x f&- it^e. #gbu^ Jt Cou^yP

P^-P^fM, ^ Av^trf^#a4 -^Xv<4« o^n lAnJUs* 4u 4Ll^j ©£ 4-kis Gtg»e fezcoA+j,® -VW4-1 - "wKi he 4s ReS^A^ |o 80 ^ ts^dLge .

5^|P. ft &9V* -fkeJ- &*^v K)4 g<e A6rO£<* Ac oess ita &>w4 , /W &4t^ £ &*- ^WQ- VwU-.o^ l4o.^ecu ror^t^s Av*©\ CteJ-eAA^-

% AJcWaI^oI darvvjOA.4- s^- IfcJSevi &<*A App u ca^ o*v *

Asr4^cJ^ Q -<im &i- "ta tsde Ca=P C»^<a^>vaa ProotcW^e/

Jr^t^e. *<L*

fA*

/^^l^^ | o-.15-/5 y^

s for irtvr to m -\ ^^A/W&t AP#£t 0e T14T .STOffT OP' TbA^5 TIC W&Kb^SLC QW362J 6f- TIC Cdt^T P Cf££M SNftL frl°P£AL5 Cw^^» CW> A/u.^ M^^^-A4a^d£^ -~ Pro Sq Ou^e /W ftet ftol&M. N' vg^ 4i-j-j 6jw^-

yw-4- of- Mo^\ cIcuwwk; ^ 4urDQraPK/^fQn-W,f£ ^|Vkssy> W»^n Aw</L^

=# )S 3^ °19 3bW 8»M iVct RsJ.

Del vUft "Tv. 6&>nD o QiM-?^ C(#e of- Ssrv vct **& au. nat"" uffxawrtf-.w -jff»fi»

^ J-M^^, D^^v^(3( £>*uH (?k. li P^^r-,. cj^e-L- -3ou3iK-c-&{ { Cks^^c^- Cx-t€-«<jL file ;m 4w_ ABka<? jft_A en^v Jdz^zl9

pr-c^Uj Ard^W^s^ On Ht^3 O^ ^«ft/vtCl ICterK f.O.goy (»7W2 /WW "Tv - 78-767 . 3\a,a^a, O^^^Gc^yN 5c?<j| U/. H Si- fes-usthi^ "tv, 1^1Hi Co^t fe4- G-.Vu.^ ^pP^,f5 ,r> 0'" . \N(dT OF MAMftAMi w>mi^tfa^i.lj.liLj^|UTffntywl!l!gU!lWii^^

CAuse Clov 01061^2^73?

dtloot1*^ -7 r r „ /« v. >> °r- Waaiy^ kpptMs

"To +te HoMO^tr Juosa of A-f^^Av^ fileocl WWij Relisor A*d Al«4 S(W H^ ^fiwe # CaW)"© D^^e«>trv» teapot D<j4rvt<f Trwi^ Coo-Mm \pU "SS p^cttsW^ £ui4~ •&* {4aetW/\a f[& ^?eieeeJp 4k& £eWfc*\) 4ke, \m^V o*~ &%&** GaapuS \a/KxA^ <U S*,G /W«& CrwA {4*a fW" Se^ fo* ft' z'Kris'-&& •£« l&eJ^w^

4nl Gs uu^4- rke to Ueu^v rwj * Swvue 4^. W. ©^ /W*^-&a %& A8«ye A** *d£i*u **(&*•**?*- Me * -As A ^fgK, m^ tK«. &j *> Awig,- a*st5" /w to Sw«a to 4kaj^ o^ka i4«^e. ^w^Wrf -Js*\ S Ov* Q-45- "f^e Orv<23 £-Qg-'£&, j)ouA_€^ Cf&Jt'/X £,oW* fiCMi4 M.^.!cV«dQ'€ *>*"*> w.***W« >, TE»»3- M « MVZtl m fVMHWx"' £™T*>.tja 5S*"

^^+^^•4^) &o*v Ccouj>*-e C^Wt>v &^&

g^kMjf |AA^ 6cd^ ^ A^ Ote* (rk-us- <el i£ee^ ScJD W"m^©"£ OK^scti £s>^p£tj • Sa "YW, Sowve 4o&-r- o4-- it)4tt,j Do^<a§A/*e/ tH^e

% ^(V^fcied B^ @eM&A •&. Ar^Jv^e. 4o 4u 4*«4-j eP\ 4-wis. Gtg,e Saaw^'6- "VW4- ?

S^IP. ft ftgU-fkfcj' fi^w ho4 g<e ASro^fe Ac ws.5 ita fow4 , Awl &^tA ^ ^\e_ |k£, Uvi4- o-P I4cd^u for^cwi Av«o\ Oej-eru^-

r>*. u &fr- ^jAAi^ri

\/arv4' ' ^ffs*©*

oA£}*aJ

is?- s^

CI IxU <ir£-~ "H-e CisCte ^ C«^v^\jasvV pro c*jbIwv£/ ~+W^4^ ^ IL^Jc^o^ -p^j-i "H^ &>-^

J o-.15-/5

S furrow Wj£AVr TO f ^rc- ^rmr Arpp^cou^- 3 op TiK«5 TO TIC'M&Nb^SUT CM06&- orrJCGsK^r 0PCKtM3£lvrftL &1°P£AtJ ' <Cw^^ Homj A/U.rai A4A£^xca-Aia^£^ -- Pro Sq G^uO€ AncA ^&t^.C^u^M NUxsgj 4k>j Gj--/^ prooecUr^ 73-1 4u Gr«u^f !»£<we. 4b 4? jf (nj«m pec-r^A-^W Swb^v •pe^f /IwiOcih Pro. s«-' ^^ oh^^ -^r~ |Vto5€S /VWfivl Kfawttj =# h 3^ ^ D-«4 Y-U4e Cor-1 Carr>{i^ 3bN &nf^ct.zj.

Del ^Mt "Tv. 6&&nD QtAM&tevte, of Suvwe ^TJ-:.^.^'-..jg,Jag*'^-'r'!yg UW-—flWWBWMWf

"f^v6 *2> 4tp G^r^S^y ^fW4- <3>£~ <fV\o ftfiuv^- irJr^HecL M*> 4»*t Mkj t?»eCA Sb/\4* "TO <Qa>w-4~ ©-P-- G^'v'V>^e*/(' •H J^^ 0^c{ O^V o^ Jl £tj AAoul Ana( 4"Q iWe<4< q Me^^-^ (2u to*-4 4d gc^ By A/wJ bcpoSi-f'&gl jg<j -TU e>4^ c ^J ^ ^ Uvv-W SW^

_^_^——_—_ hdd^ejsts ©^ P^cr^ £«t/v* cl_ i Clerfc f- o. Soy (a7<*G0*5 *WW "Tv - \A/ftIT OF MAMflAfAl CAu-S-e. r)0v OI06^2oY?3g IN tkfi, (W/*4- U\bfr*. 7 e r <• ia

A«£<aK &y^ fiteocl sivwi j Retesfor A*d AW 4W 4w fr&we # CW^6,e Dt/Wnr\a tiauiof C/x»^ 3^,<- 41a <fke, 331s* £TllO*cW D'j-J-rojf Ti^v^t, Cou.>iAm vpta "ES P^ChffVV^

4ie v^V o^' \kxim$ Ce^uS W^-c^. <U So*o fW'^ CrewA t-ks fW~ Se^ fo* P5/ Te^j \/5, Ate5-FJ M6iCAt.es 4-H*. CUc^e ^^

4^4. C© «-ui4- rfce to K©ujv rva * X , "3T vox ^^cesW Au* 33 £.01S £,>At« 4^. 4.^e ©^ kr+4rir-$*r %e ^fi*ye *H %r^ iW^^ Me. * -As A » 1>iU vA>«U S4sUee? ft? A- (M^>f»-6£^e <sw o/| ^•8om4- tKe. ft J 0* Avt£- d^k5 /W to Sw« (4t^ B**a Can^AV-M/W Re^^-4^ AJA &Mtf A>vm owe Pooa^f. c/\& &*- ^Sk/q ^ CW4-C. ^*d H> 4k©j^ ook*j Mw^e. **%hi^$br+ejd os^ ^ ;4ov^a^ fA#j 0»c| %4~ % *s^ Sk2 u-*u WWf^ , ^ t^vtp -rw .™a -; *^"4-6^cl^*.tA> Qr-oA^ Ccuswe CwWt>v S^e L **&*V %

PO" V f^^KJU*^ H^5 &^WJ "te> <W-* a<la /W^ *^M $4l 4W--J & £*>» totsvte £nhred ^v A4^^c^ »4- -ft^i^, -^ it^e. ftSb^Q, ^fc Cou<^*jP

% R«Gi*xefcJed By QeJcuk*^ -q A-4cJWt ^o

54^. ft f^VO- -fky- &v^v Kj4 -0e A&roe^ rW (Wved . fw^lWr J" VWx- /V (#gfosi- 4o Ac w&5 ita Ce>^/4 , aW S^tA l 4Vte_ iv^ ^ ^AJbfsk^ ¥& Cof\$p^r^OA % X^'eCrevA. ft

A f> *V 4- £?*? a\ !• <*« W\/ fJ.fO^; 9

W#e.«u> CoApvu »/" ssn -H-e M^cr^V^^, &eAt$v* M*

tr o^e tooibc^s&on^fc} ra*v e rite- -srwr ) OP Tb4A5 ^ fcr )c^r c 0PCl^M30^ftU fefP^t Pro $q

ys/r^-' 0^ Mow cJ<Uvvc<£ <.

R>&<$ (^C^^P^^VUj Swb i^ P^^f 4uf.D< Pap, s«-' &****»Nflk*&j ^C^ /Moses /VWM hfawte4< =# )S 3^i 9t<* D«M v«4/le Oa, (ampy&jO Dei vu/it Tv, 6g'n3 CftW£<^e 0'.i'UJ,Jii''.W''*

T^v5 3s5 4e> Ge-A4e4^A <^W4~ A- Lofu e>t- fac k&sj^ VsMk^ed, M*j4»^ Nkj $©eA SbA^" TO G-ow-4" o-P- Ca-^<a^v^s<X to <D^«ty^ b*^~& ' CAtcVt e>(^ __L±r_ir^T $^ Moo 1 Ako( 4to lWe{,<Jl ^> -ft k c&-\ 4l~e_ AE *va£ A.A Ofv !-^llr^_^

^^vt ol 1Clerjt f. O. 8oy (a7960 ^ /WW ~Tv — 7gioI, Cov^i <a4- (w^^ %?p<£/,(5 Pe>. jq^^ " A/UJjm^W fr.fr rv. A^l/Q*"X^€•,./ Cfiuse, fto. OIOGK2oY?3g M^f^ VW^ jft^>™,AAt 7 TJV Tk«, (W/feJ-

"Te> -fte HoWA£tF JuoGa of CfetM^avAi k?Pffi(lS ; A4V$k &y^ fileed WW) j Rtt«?fo/* A*<A.

4W 4W &&*/0 # CcoaA<Q, D«^eo4ir\a &a-u-»(?f CnUi^ Ow^t -&a <fke 351*+ ^ujQ-cW D'J^a^ 1>w\.£, Coou^m \pU ts p<^€,cit?W^ 4'^JL &§0vM it6u*Jf KA5p(h^oU*v4 fo B«ca^t ^ t^43w^ P^CTvW, •lie NM^'O^' Wetfe** Gsapug W^^^H S<mQ (W*C C«mH |4<^ fW" Swr fo^ p3 1/16 S^

1^4- ^Wsk # 4?U>0€J J^W> ~4Vewvv^ CVv4^»»^t'^t*^»

X , -T was Arr<&s^ Au* 3l3 3^'S S.ac^ 4^ 4^e ^ /W^-^ W- A'Boye

A"Q<m4- tKt. ft J fl»> A*£« a^t-T £W to Sw«sl |4t*£ B^«-A C©n^AM%4^ ^U^aa-4^ £M hhM te> Tkoj'e ^J^i WtiOa ^ ^ ^ ^ 1 -Js^ *^U4

,JJko KimPiaJ ©a SfouJdj W*wC •b^«>**\. "p ~ef~ tvjuti suuycip iMj* fckct/e rv©4- mj^^«j, rwr , fna ^huQ^-r^

sTV *s/V»- „**ma> '^Voac c^^e CwW ^ S1^ \J(%UJ

f^t*4P\ £Al^*W*^ L &j K^^>a^ ^o -qa^e /^ffe/* Al/I fW> ^^ ^W»a l&^ve -x^n G^^.^e^ JVlCocA/e^ /Vcee53 "to fte GxW- 3*1 *^ £osA S<M^ve Toh-r- o"f- to4oJ Poa«§q^ ^e i^ol |W\ 4t^4^ & &>< o^ve^ £ntaro^ -£k A^/^ct^ A $y~f»x for- it^e. #&m*, it Ccaa^&P

% R*(W©fcled 6^ £e-ta4o/^ ^3, /v^/W^ 4o 4u 4eu^i ©4- 4irs*s Gns.e SecoA^.4^ +W4- i'- ^^ ^ ti Ce>®wA^ ^ 80 &• tS^dLge .

IFUaJiol* :fc Hc^u^ |V ^,xj^ 4t> &ef»-ea>^vo^ 54^. ft &s^ tW 6^^ M- 3& A6r<j£<t.

Ac ws.5 ita few4 , Anol S»4tA $_ 4^\e_ +K£.

-*.- J^."^ i&^twto'* Caw. Cle^ta O^^vwowgdo^e & wfiWAl^ai ^tvvaJa.4- &P M^&e^a Gsr&Aj' a^tfAaJ • ft **y?l St. ft <r% •^gjv* -w ^ C«J*fL, I *4.

H*v« c^^fi^M "V-

,jw«UfawuBWwff.W,WWsm»J^

le?

« CHr &

Q ArH 6^ 4Ve GsCte C*P G^w^wqA Pro c^eWr^e/

/V? |o-15 ./T 'e€

s loTlC'^i^TO^ QVA062J Of- TC &c4T

4ufi Pro •54-' ^w^ wi*w^a^j S^f frosts AA-u-A^n h/a^Ae^ D^ v-^-He G?A« Corfr^f Dei v/^wt lv. 6&'n3 rs*afe=n©rn 0C:\S33)^:§-%^—- ntyw"lj T*" pi^iarem** *h«rw"'JW»*vy

•V* J-^^ D^^c3( Ca^v cpk_ hzjSz^f^

_ _ , /VclclA^fS£5 ©^ P^Jcmj St/v-iCliClerfc f.o. goy (97^ 00 "5 /WW~T^ - "fa, 7870 £ Co^/i fe-f- Gm'*^h^ &pp<Ky(5 P o . i&»xi isisov A-viJ-,/1^ 7g-7|/| /Wo^^pin rb»Mr &•£ A4taAve*j «sek <Wf \A/R1T OF MAMflAl Cms*, no. 0ID6K2oV?3g P\ } Cc*W^?t*

4W fVju Afiwe # A^^^ D^^ec4]r\o fica/ici CrcJtis\ 0"^*- -&a tfKe. 3IIs* CXouQ'cW D'j<bvt<f- Tr^AAi, CouW^i v-^ "^ p^<ex.ft?Vy$ £uj4- -&/1 (>W/W\q f>£ ^ei©^ 4Kfi^ BecaM^ ©^ t^€T4U4^ p«crVb««l ^n, 4f^ \M^" o*~ Mst%^£ Gs^v^5 W^-c^ *H S^C JW'^ Oewl |4«%s fW" Sei- foA.

Pa/ Te^j \#,, Ates-rj M&tfAt£$ 4-Ht Ckkv&e, ass fefo/e^wij Ma/« &Ce*M$e @&W»a Sk^u^s 4i^ G» uu^4- -rke "to M»«</v rvg ^ s^o*. +**. We ©^ /W^-&a %& as**- ^ A*3 %L (W4*^ A^ - -As AJ*Wg£, •f ^ep^ei®^- fl/tf&ftlA $ fay .fw^-Hj +..

A'Qom.4' t*vt ft'-i *^Avi5' 3*)k3" /w to SW« ^Vmwa« f3oga/d.</\* ^*- f^UQ V* Cbaa+I, Kd k> 4kai« o^k^ i4^0e. ^orfe^ife/W js?o._ AAy ©a* 0-45" -He. o^j Jog *jD£. J>x~v4_ &®*A. m>\*| r>A#tlH Gw| l^h % -sP- Sta uj^J

^•^tWvO ^a*^ Ccou&e CwWi>v swe.

JViCoov/e^ /Vce«5 "to ^vg GxW- 321 ^e <PUs£\

*\ 5(^K to ^t ^^j <4_ Avt vjJa., J- cd^P

.^?

So^vve 4oW~ o^f- To4a| PoAego^ ^H^c ^M Ml 4U4-* # £^< ®*svte £nhrod -S^

Jto -tie ^Afo^cX^hs £jL^ 4o As^ % RjjG^^eijed £m j3e.fa4o.~- -^ At4&tVoa^ 4o 4«-« 4i«.^4 o4 4k* s Gig,e SeauK.4-0 -VW4- I "fc-Wtu»A :fc Hau^ & &gfar 4z> &ef*~^vi£ S^jf. ft £,3^ -jrktk 6-^v K}4 fi^e AlSr^G*.

Ac bo&s +W. fe^Af- , Anol &^tA 4 4^\e_ it^

pNt4th^-«M. V4<2» O-*^ And V.ulitW U«i Q/MV y A^^^ Y^taio^ Caw CIsg^aIm O^/vuJKgcla^e %fcfer*~f>*^^^ o

l'|^\4-€

Jfe <\W* Gbw# ^M TX^A^wktc tCsf't-O'l^ «SP ,i*V Cw •3* H^V C

€4 ^v 64^ *ta CcsCte C*£ C»--vv^jaqA Pro C*ejeWr^e/

\*au&*j*± CoApM.4 ^Z1 s-n ^H?.. M?^H£^V"«c^

ficbpUcoiM oe rn-r ^rm-r -v OP Tirt*5 to TIC WwObWL=r qwo6!j cf- rue O^r

Cgj*J& A»uA (b£f (it-Cni^uAAx. hAj>uQj 4t-Ji 6^-^" p^ooecWt 72.-I 4u Gr^^vf !«^e +0 4?|p 4ufc>circApKArciA*iwfp ^/VWai A/Wd-^ Av^L^ /Vlos-es A/Wf-in tywAts =# )E> 3^S cit D«M V6.4ie Oa. Cofip^ Dei v/^i/ie Tv. 6&'n3 ^rwroTacTS^d~7T8~~~~~ ^-ffftcq/e of- Sm/we ^^t^.uc.i'^jigtfBiw^Bi't!9»!g'aii»S''

&$- 4k2 &&>u^.. £/\Ai44£cl /IAo4k?^ M*u

to Ja^^ D^c( Ca^V e>(^ UZjfcrU CUS i%j f*ju\ 4d &l^ By /VW4 Depo^.f^ % ^ ^^ c**l 4o iW- Uvw%et Stne^f

,Jk::S^^ Acidosis o*-- ft^onj £^ utc( i CUrK •f. o. Soy fe7<? GO S Au*Wv Tv - 7*1 £>. \NtCLT OF MAKIfMU Cmsa, ftov 0ID6K2oY73$

To fte Houo<?A£ir Jucto of

4W 4W kBo^Q # C*>v6<e D«Aec4irv» 6ewr»0f CrcJiA Ou^e- 41a ^jke 3sts4- CJUQ.cW D'jJr^-f Trw^ Couyv^vi v-fta "fcs p^c/-#lv» 44n&. AScKAe ^ 0*-*^3£ Kj^5p^hroU-^4—fo Sfi4- A* \M*>sS/^ €k ^eisG^ -jKe. KeWfe*^) B«co/a^ ^ t^4U4^ p«crvUel^?v' •lie Wa^" o<- I4a^£ Gs^mS W^tK, 4-H Sm3 £W<& CreuX |4<^ Hef* SW- foA.

H«2*a*ag -fv?r ft^lt-eP ft<eQMX4^ \ajKcA, xs Pj3 ~ j^^ ^ ^ ^ :~ U&pu-S (yd 3> &e4t«ae M*- \*Aoaai M*>4~a- (VAo t^*M2 Te#3^ v/£- M©5*3" Mfc«eAl£S 4+v. Ckvae. =S5

4-m.. C© uu^4~ 4W to l/te«*/v rwr * Swvi* 41*.. We ^ /W^-G*1 f*& Afi«ye

-fhu ww«u S=Wee| «H> A- W^^h^c can-. o/J ftg***- tx«,. sls o^Avt^« a*3i<5" /w to s&m AnmO>A« PoOOU^.^ ^ m^Q V» Ccua*«, A^ fo> twk? o^ui WtMja ^n-fe^&yv*** 49*v ***j ©rv« 043- -He 04s J<e§. ^ XXxaxJ. (Vtt»j^\ _ &oH** a cKWM M 9dA«dg« - whd ^ f\y %a^cvu£ a ^v^iej -VWwfcc "VW-/ I4«tu- R^Hh$ %/G w %£d *&3

JVtCouW ^cc€35 "to ^ Gx^a4 3*1 ^e <Pus£\

*\ Sep4; (j© -$. oO»Vj J^_ A>4 UJ^. 4". &P KW* $4i 4Le4^ £ &a> o*^ve£ £mhrQiA zyy A4^oc^ ,4- -Qy^x for- i^e. #8bu$„ Jfc Ccka^&P Jto *%e Q^fo^cu^s &jL^ 4© AiJ- % R« a^tefcled S^ j^e-MoA -45, a- 4cJW^ -$o fLtrrrva/f -^w<4? o*-i [/WU/^ 4k*s Gnse teeou^^ -VW4-1' iFwtfk*^ je H^, fr &§bk 4t> Cefx-ea,^^ 5^K- • ft £3^ -fkpJ- £*^v Kj4 Be A^SrQ^ce.

Ac oe&S "ita. fews)- , Awl &4tA £ 4^\e_ h^L Uyv4- ©•£ I4cd&£su Torpt^s Av*c\ Oej^eAVM^-

r>a, u g^t^t^

it L. *p< *-AV i- A,

App ^ t^'r°A- * agnuiajniBngimiut

j*»y -\Vw i ~X^^v^^te4«' 'I i^S s. ysjlf 4

<U 4iM <s-t- 4*~e. Usde Cs*- O^^a/w^iA \Jf~o o-e^lwA/

^A^AoletAvva Q» Ae<L^"- <*} U^o^ ^ UAC4>vO fU>^UA4r€A^' +^ Se^-^r t+GeirAXj UkJ^4^ ©0

/^^^ J 0-1SW5 &c v^jt # "M -fti ii in in iiir'nuH'ii'i ii rvr to mi

o e ri4T ^Ti^r o r TiNAC T0 HC WwJb£ \$ OW36& 6f- rwc 0^~~ Ca"^^<W ^aj A/U-raj Ada£^n^iAa^d£>

proc^cWt 72.«I -k> Gr*^ Je^ue to <£! le

4uf<D< jMo-^es AA-t^A|-«va Kfar-oAt^ =# ;s 3^i °it D-^ V'U4^ (V< Ca^Ptyf bW %< MfVct. f?d, Cfc&ffft c<^e, of Szojut (Vv^6 ^> 4t? (5^a4s4^ <iw4~ A- ^y^ <*>£- tk2 IkifWe, gA^rVted M*j4k*i Mki $>©€A SbA^"" TO <Qa>w-}- €*P~ Ca-»^axV *°6»X -H ZM^, D^^e( CaccV c?^. ilc^^_

*2y AAA," I -+0 Cb^ Jgy /VWl OepC.f^J™' gcj OX* C?4& t, q,| 4^ fj^. Uvwfe( StT^Cj -o-&*-f 'cUa^ss^ On ~i'Ks5 O^ — Acidosis ©^ r^on.j S«£\/*cUcl«rfc f.o. Boy (a7q6o^ /WU'tv- 78-767 . Jvj*^ O^^G^ 5mw. H SJ- /W^

Dh*£ ifrV' fcfr f^V QryWj. &P$*fagtcip!/\ Po^Af ©*£- /VWt/Vi^M tEk. ft|c.f NAJKLT OF MMlflAI Caus«. Ho. 01 DC»S2o03B

v. ^ o#- Gs^i-y^ tkppsMs

Ce>ifi*jet YVmO hAbi^A AAw4i'a MnV**Ud. —

4W 4W frftwQ # CW*6>e D>v/Wnr\a ftcwnof CnJi<s\ 3v*^<- 41a <jke 111** juo-cW D'j«h^Hjf Tir^At, CouyvS vpta t& pr^e-ciM-VS 4^vA. ^So\M ifc&u4f Nas^^ax^**^—fo BecaM^ ^ T^eT 4*c4^ p«*crVb«t sx-' •fe Wa<^"0^ fcjfa* GsHfivS WK*cK,*U 5^0 fW,,Q L>eaV\ |4<jl,s fief- Se^~ fo* p<3/ 4m. Gs ou^ Tke to l/towjv rwi «, X , ^ v^x 4aa«^sW Aust a3 AOIS <w i iw rv^ too**** rw jg*^ A*g -|7v.i uo+**k~ Gv^&l , A-S<m4' tKt fti *> Am^« ^^T /W m Sw« S4i4 B^*A dWf/vuM^| Pe.^tid-lci AIA fcKtf *o tWk> ojk.5 WtSje. ^orfe^iAyvii*/ as^ ^U* Ov«> o4^ "He ov<2i J^ *£>§, jft^-A.4, 0^*X^

ft* ,ci^4>L-4^B—

o NA-t^n^c^o ^Voav Csux^e CwWl>v S>^ SJ^. gn **- to^Jie^ •* ftf BA- ^sa-

Ao^ i-fcu^ ^ 0^eA ^rt>^ift*d /Wj Get vus**amM a 5^7 to ^t ^i^^i ^ Avt UJ'W f~ C9^P

C"* mW *ft fca^ +ky- 6^^v- ^ fie. Aero^Ok Ac bQ*>s iW. fow4 , Awl &4tA ^ i^ ^rwt Wrii of I4cj2esu Corpus. Ay«\ Oej^u^-

« c

r>*. u •&L C®f\$f't*KQ>A % X^cUi-e. OW*i &

tei.^ &Hr ^ ^^ ^ wrt" ^*&f ct+f*j ^ <^w* "*0°*^ w" r AppUteyb<*\. » _ ^*- i& -V^ i juuA.stateRko*'* i0 .aOiHf lysf¥"*t

Q IrH 64^ "^ ^^ °*^ Cr-wvjr\QA Prt> c^eWj^£/ ^AAt^ifa^ck Q.Aeci^-^ vK^tf uac^.vo flo^A4r€A4' +£ Sa^'-^br h^cita^ uj'rv4- 0p

Afe^_iVU^ J o-X$ A 'd Vr TO TILE ^g^-Cttas«B«4t.nua^MtttjB)i

/Vbp^cw^- op Tb4*$5 } T< «WC qw)6^ 6f~ rfC 0><£r

Pro,$^' ^^c^^v^^.^ |M.oses /WA^n hAa/^Ae^ Del v&.44e Or. G?/a>(?-^ Del V^l/lt Tv. b&'nj GA+fftCq/e Of S?fyut *Eg;'AmzTtt#s&'**^r&*v>'

|Cv^6 ^ ^ Ge^4s4^ <s<faeA- A- 0*fu >£- tW2 !W>e £a444-^cI iUo 4ksvi Mkj ©€A SbAjS"" 4"© £_vw-4" oP- Ca^VV^V^iX •H _ua^ D^ei ca^v c,^ J±jtjSL |_t 4-> [^ £>x 4j^_ A'B KAg j6L A C»ia_ ~——_____ (2y Ma^I 4o &kt,R By AA^t4 Depc(^g/ By "^ ^^ t< <*! 4o fW- Uvw4^.c( Sfne-^

Wv*c( lCl«r|c f.o.goy G7qoo^ /WV^Tw - 75767 . 3uj^, QtwvflG^ 5o^ \A/. H SJ- ^qjS

pyv

<a/xrtCX *• J=^ W^vJfei. S-

AAjl/>€^ M^ «4-t^\_ fM_^-tA^ C0V3BT RECEIVED IN u0>J £0 W* C°URT 0F CR,MINAL APPEALS ,be^costa,C^ ^NOvVm Abel Acosta, Clerk Cc^se rtoQlbClSJon^fc} T*jt f?

0 a- ti4C _rmr /VppUCcu^ 3 o r Yty\*C ilC WwJb^SL*" qwog^j cf- rut Gsx^r Cw^_^ Hokj Mu^gj Mafch/a-AAaS^ -~ fit) % G^ot /W t^p«c4^AA.u fiAjxsQ 4wi 6—^3" prooe.clu.rt 11.) -k> Gn^vf fre<u^, +0 4? ?p

/Moses /VWI-n hfawte^ D«JI v^4le Co'"- O ^ ^ Oe4 vAuMt TV. b&fe/^D cs^3"ern^:oTcrcTS"""3oh7-^" fckrffiCcvJe ^ myie<:*.-r.•.'••; jw.'.'iwit.^ iBaagjeHe*!* OSA/U^ JVv-5 *2> 4tP Ge^4^PcA ^fW4- A- Ce>fU $>©£a SbAjf" 4o G?"w-4 &•£-- Ct-<*ssv ,/^X 4d J-m*^ D<^d Cao^V cpk.

2.. -fik ^>\ 4t^_, Abka^ j6l\ ©f-v .-______ ^j fo/url 4^ 8^t4\ By A/Wl Depoc(f~£^ & -^ g>^ <^! 4o fw u^wfeg( St^e^f '•• i% bk£lo s^gJ "^^ c*vvc4

£*avt ol 1C Laic f. o. Soy G7H00 S /WWi "Tv

Dh*£ \A/RIT QF Cau^ Ho. &lDC-K3o\f?38 j&jJ&aWA ..pWnAfel 7 v. ^

LB" JuOto o F

f^s App^' cct^^M 4»<^ «-0/^ ©^ Mx^L<yu<^ -(W fW A&*« # G^uj,^ D.^ec4iry» &cuj-i0i Cmto Ov^«- -&a ike, 1U*+ iJufl-cW D'jJtvtjf Tr«AAt, Cq^a£m v-<U "££ p^c*?VvA 4"4nS. A'jga\/4 ifc Co«^i4 P Kj«d Potox^v4- -+o 4k, Wa< ^ ©^ M«%&*1 Ce*4pu5 W^c*v *U Scv.^ /W<& CnuA 14ns Hfl^r* Sei- fbA.

ftg»w«4- tKt. £i *>£*£• 3*30** A^. to SwW H<4 B^*a C^^M-H (^U^ea-4^ ASA &ks( £W, owe f3oo<t/rf' ^ «Al2cK/e ** CW<5^ 4o 4k*x«? o^uj i4^0e. ^afe^^../^^ as^ IM^ ^ ^^^Dd i Ugtd A#4Wrj w,Ht<j^4- /Oi^

ft* fjty Co^S^^^^kMjlA^ 4J | *—

VVB^^|^^^ ^aiM^ C^ct4^6 C^Wl>V S*^

AM tW> ^ ^^*a dj*-ve -xsa G^sp.^t^ WW SAA^ ^k <* A^" <*tee t4^A.SL S&efci/i >vl[ocA/e^ Acc€33 "to fte G*^ 3*1 ^e <PO§£\

a S&pJi to ^t tjaA^j ^t /Vt U^ ^ <5fcp

&fed # *n -ft^e. Co^y^ ^n $ ^ ^^ $il 4U4^ & &/» o^vtf £nsf<AQ^ ^&v A^/^o^ A £y^ fo^ 4^e. #!Sbu^ ^ Ccv^yP It* tke ^p>^u^ £jL^ 4o /U- 4^ +cml4-j ©4 4k*s Gise G^ow^e- -H^%4- Ts Nvk4 He. ^ &mWa^ \o do & t5^dt#e j "kWw :£ \ku^ & &g(\4" 4b Cefr-eg/^ijt 54[£. ft ^,3^ -iketA- ^-w ho4 &e Agrafe fW (Wvei. f^Aifl^A I" VW>t At (C&gfa- 4o Acoe&s ik, 6>>w4 , A^ol &4tA ^ 4^\e_ ii^,

/£, $oGAA£Ai ^toJl tfcrv va)a •4- &<P Wo,iSe^4 (& ap^j ^^tJ^Ah W V^««"i^ Ce^*44-W Aj6(9U td4't <k. *

C4 (xH &i- I^L ^^ C*^ C^^vjaqA Pro c*jcUaa€/ (^^ -k^ Appi. cg.4* - Ak* t3Su* £ w*v* vr to n x&MKcaa&MWtuam

/VbpUccu^-

To TIC WwJb^jF OW06EJ or- rtc Oc^r Co"*~«W Hovo MbJSi A4iili^aJAa^i^ -• Pro % CftA^e /W fix* f>*c±hM% t^fi^t 4-K.i 6--^- prooecWt 7i. I 4u Gr^vf l^**^ "^ 4? \e

4ufoc »"c\fK/Srcj n-lwfP •> j\4*ii Mte/4-f'H /VV^fc-'U-'!

Pro •5^' ^w</ ^(""Wo^ ^Miaaf Moses /VWI-in A/^^di D^ V&.44e O^ (jsrC\^^f 3bin §< mrVet pj, DeA vAuMt "TV, Ofc'n3 c^^e7n^:oToic"rs~33)^3y .4-f£*cc(,ie of vSsa/k^ **gpaLj.'L'^j'-y^rwgwt—rryyyr-

<s>£~ <fv>c fW>e, £/\Af44^ci ^4.o4k?^ Mkj ^>®eA SbAjP 4*o (Q><-v^4- ©-P-- (7-i^vvv{ AppeetM ok. ^2r_±i____ &j Mec4 V Jw^ve, D«^a"oI CaccV g>^ Mdi^if_ f^ aW| A-n<s( +o fW,4< a A/W^~lc» jP* d-a- <j u,c••-^. <J tA.<i /ciu, ( 0«-S^ ^-c/f C.-U(g..<

jgt, -J}J C?4& o, <v| 4^ f^ Uvwfect StT^Cf

__ £LrL£__ A-clclAejs^s ©^ Pc^jon^ ^^°( IClerK f.G.aoy (9773g

v. -v °r- ^fwiW IkpptMS

Ce'^w YW> Mm^ AAw4i'a KAartiAM. - A-f^tsk Av^ Stood IMx/ij RtUsfoT A»^ Ales Cau^ a^t -&a tJKe 351** CTujO-cW D/jJ-rvcf T>«<aa.s (^oo^i4m \*t1i& *3> p<-<e-cj^V^» £a4- &#. \M**si<w Ck ^eieet^p 4ke £eMc*\) 4k?,, WA^ ©^ \AeJksnf G**4>u& W^-cK. 4"U S**Q {W<& Crawl |4<a flsnf" Se^- fo* VkciiAr^o 4\>r freVi-eP k^QMit^' va/KcA, "XS p5 re^j vtf, AJoJEsr MG»(At£$ 4-He CK^e, ass f^UNy ASSUfttT" FV 5P^rK6 UI^TEQK) ^ fWct/eMvw A$>/€ &CeAM%e PeWc»A Skj»u^S 4fv£. Gs> uj^4- rke £» 14©<a/v a# ^ X . i" "was Atp^sir&d Au<a 33 AO/S S*ac* 4ke, We <^ Ai^fi4^-fo^ w A8?*- , , *• &m* * IW«, Ho*- R*©*/**«< tor- /fW* A^-'W^a fW^ M*. -As. ***"&*.« m*jr- tKt aj o^ Ah^- 3*3k!r /w to sw* ^g>4tA C^^M^ f^^^4^ ^ *** +^ 4ko^ oJK^ i4^0a sarfe^iAs/vsrf -is-i lM*4 Ov<> o-^ T^e. OGi J^*£)e DoL^jdi Cf&-*ffi fc5i*l 6Utp*|P frml t*s«>e rT«4- W^«4. fW# , (6qH*r GC^I M.£WW^3« - >***> w.i^Aut ^aj\4 ^ly CM JW- % -HP- Sta uJ^tJ dC <uu€t£ •s/v*--1.' \A)W lK 6Wj6

VO^/^8

JVICoca/^ Alc£53 "to ftg Gx^^ 3*1 ^e <PusA Q'&g<Q<i "He ^^cUe^iev\A a£ A&ue^^£W»€, a Se^7 to ^t oiA<i ^t. ^4 \^j^ ^ ^f^p (3^cUiA o(^ ^n4e- Jf"1 Ak*j t^x*^ Reg CLreJ^A ArVG

£w>i AH 4t<^4j $• &>* o>«^ve£ Sntaro^ -33^.

% R« GL**3iJed Sy £ek4oA ^ fcr 4cjWt 40 4u 4t^» ©4 4k* s Cnse fia&wA^ •H^- Ts •wtoci he ts fe®w/^M. 4o 8o & ts^u%e j S^ff. ft &3U 4-kei- 6*-^ Ko4-' ©e fk&tQ^G*, Ac w&s "Hm. Csx^aI- , aW &4tA ^ 4Vte_ ^t^

0<4yM^ci Du>e. "fe Dkwi'a CrA/WJ -4«L. V-cA^_ 4a, '< c , ^ 4^ y3*.,.k4o/v Cav\ Cte<kr-\M 0^rV^Kg4c^e Pa . U ^-v <Ha4-« ivp^ *' Kelt*** ** ^ wuj^w^wiJi^'pfl^tagtsffiHgBffgi^

w.k«"if <f> ^ i$^ *\W£ Q&*A* WM ;yslV I

c op TirtAC } TE" WwJb^/^r ow)62j sr- rtc O^sr Co'^vey ^W A/V^ Ada£^^J^»^£^ -Pro %

?bW 8/M f°A'6t. Rgl.' DeA ^Mt "TV. 6&'n3 QtMf&cjcifa, of- Swuz ^^-i„^^^L'n_^tf>re''.^:,.v^'t3w

T^v6 ^ 4o G^t4^a <iw4- t p>e£A Sb«\4" TO Gis><-vJ~4 &P-- Qt-ov*^ *^<A.

n cp k . hAoU \ 4*-ef-.cJ "X^ ^A, QU^/-£- <3tA.4 / Ci-GtA CkS *rx/ ...A.-I:

*"> k. ;Sa. Ti*e~ At£ 0^.

^Oc^" y A^GIa^€jStS ©^ #£/3<m^ £«*/ V* Cj i Cl«r|t f. o. Boy (d 7<?60 Jl /WW TV 7*767 . 3«^ Ot^G^ 5^^ w. H S^ /Wrt^ "7S», 7f70fc Co^f• <*f (w^u</U/\ &i#p«vf5 P.O. / 7*7 H \#Q3U2Eit6blflAW Cms*, ftov 01 DCl£20*73$

CftEMwAt AfPfA'LS.,' A-Peak &v\«\ Stood IfVW) j (RttateT A*<*. -Pries fK-S. Aqppt' cq4»«m ,A^ ^^ ^ jMa^Myu<^S 4W fW A&\>e # Cc<M&*e D«^'^c4-ir>a 6cm-i0t Cawvi^ O^*- 4a <k€..3U*+ <2lcQ'cW D'jJr^?f Tr^w^c, Co<->\Am v/jU t& pr*jc*cbw 4'4vjt &go\/4. ^fc-0w*u3£ KA5pshox^*t4—fo Sc4~ -A** (4*uiW>\0 f[& i^eieEt.jp 4ke, &ek>fo^) He. \M^ o^ WeaJfea* G**v^ W^t*v ^s4- vajIscK xs Pa/ Cof-p**S (yd

Te^Ssj v/p Atet5TJ M&«e$rUE$ +*-<e Ck«^e ^ fWo/tMvjj A^u« ^CaMtte PeCec^tsA Sk^u^S X , T was Ar^zs^ A^«a 33 ^01S s,wo« 4**. We ^ A^^-l^ f^- *s«ye

*o "fkate uoka 14<Sja ^oa-fe^-i^A^sl js^ ^y Oa« o-P -fi^e o^i ^^'joe, J>x-m^ Cf&*£\ v>Jfco tWwj OA S"K>wld tkw€., ^t>**A. "JI Mef- \JkAi

kj CM f& % -s^ SKst t^xti

„j***+i &*o*a~> CaAxs^e 0^Wl>v Ske •^t^L^% k vow

A^^£°\ £Al^<x^vd^ L- 6j k<D<^\) -\o -^^je a%a

JViCou/^ ftcc£35 "to fte Gx^ 3ei ^e <Pu§£\

Oa S&p^ to ~t ojAo^t An KjJ^^ &<£ M^tnJ Corpus •-&*- fce^e£ A*4 fce^jae (fd^f- Q^ /^4e- JtT^ AVUj U~*^J Reg CL^ei*^ VH

A4£aoc^ <4- -fiy^a -fi^- 4^^ A8bv^.#= Ccxa^zjP

4-K's Gi&e 8eow.*£ -Ha^4- t ' S-j»l£. .ft ^3^4 -fke4 ^*^ l^o4 &e AfirQ^a Ac ws.5 "Hve, &><^/4 , aW &4tA ^ /Ae_ h^d

-« c>

*a ^ t^^1 ^-^°^ ^a/v CleciMu 0^AAon.g^a% ^ AoG^e^i^ ^rv vaJa.4 a^- M*jSe.«ui £ varv4

1% *\ws Q&+S& VWi "X*^a ystif C >\dta$aAJW*$' BS5HA 4#%^ £*t*v£»V £\ IrH 6-£- ^ ^^ °^ C^^^A^A Pro 0^cUa/^£/

LO'rv4~ ©P

Mg^ A^Mn fiAs/Up r | a-25-/5 Gi; Vr TO Till a c^iv^^t AP<^/^ of T*tfr--srcpir OP TO THtWwJb^wr owo6£y of-rtC Gsx^r- C^vujy novu AAhJai A4^^-Maad£^ jj Pro % pussuuw^ -fo r^v»«ui iSW^f <s>A /b-ppgrfMe prooecWt 77 J 4o Gn^vf tea^e +0 4?

Ra<i P^.4-/Xa^/U< Swb A^vi 76 4ulio< fr*S

fV|o.^s /W^n AA»a<v^ EM v&.4le 0>Ai Q>mp\ej0 3bW &MrVocRgJ.

Dei vu/it Tv. b&n3 &MTf»cc(^e, of Stfvut p&Btwsrxv*!*

(Vv.^ ^> 4tp Gev~~4s£o) <^W4- Cej^u

kpp&kM OK- Jx- V- It &4 MmJI "V* J^t, bc^(A CA«cvK 6>K. JUz^tzJt df^-i Cj^CfL- fty to/ul 4o £&u,|\ j6m Ma.4 LVjOort-fe^ gy <nJ C?4& c^. a] 4^ f^. Uc^teet St?\6-^f

£^v*c( tCVjt f.o.goy (37900^ /WWTv - •V/ 7^702. Co^yf fe-f Ce^','^v.(,o/\ /^pPwv(5 ° '•(0'" .

v. -> Q#- Ca^aaiy^/1 ArpfsM?

CftxfMswAi &fP?At£; ^Ce>/vv^/ IfWo t>AM%& A/Wf<A MtfAi^Ud. -- . - w-~ ^6 D^Aec4niir\Q l^cu-noi DajJ^^ Tr^A£> Co^aM^s vpU tS p^ofeM^ 4^ ^ova4 ^C^uJg "T^ptmxTU^—f?o

S^6 /W'& C^mX H*a fled" Sesh feA.

Pcj/ )7i6T^^ ^< :~^

Te^ \/c, Ate^ey Mfr«eAtJES 4+v. CK*<^»e_ 2ss

4m, G&uj</4- -rke wl4sus/v r\$ «.

S,«Auft 4Nt We ^ ArA^-fo/1 W Afij/e' ©l^-Pm* ^? Mm/4 fccp«t/*edAv}-.- *S4*r«^LTW«* Ag***- tkc ftJ ©AAuig,' 3*)t5" /W to SW* to ^fkaw ojKai 14«X^. 3»rfe«^^vie«/ js^ *^ Oa«> o-£ -fi^e CA423. J^.jd$. Xbu^.4 Cra.v\ PY»jt.i*l (UuyifP A*»ol |fe^e r\s4~ M>^-eel #%*a/ .

„****> ^Voi^u CccvL&e C^Wt>v ^^

^aa^ £Al^x*\d^ L 6j K^^aj ^o ^js^e a^a AW tW> ^^ ^***a id^v^e -x&n C^v^^.^ve^ £ekMj( t^ &*£ 4, fyr Ol^e t^ue.SE: ^>e*A JVifocA/^ ftcc£35 ~to fte Gx^^ 3*1 ^e fusk ih. ~X5 ft £<2^L£ -£U**JTSfe( ^A^dii^^^M^) A S^f^ to ~t ^iA<j J-t ^ \^J/^f ^ ^^P 4-0 flO A\/xJ\ ^ T^ £buQ V^-r-eV" (^ •t5^Tfi O^- <k He^s—^(1^- to^ s we - Ar*t"

A4^o<^ <4- -Qy-rvx for- ty^ #Sbv^Q. #= C<xa-<,zjP

psAp^^!^ I^VK^XTA#a,4 -£^wc4t o*^ t<WWiA 4u +cml4-j o4 4k*s Gt&e SeccMN.&'g TW4- IS >/vK4 he ^ ReXSwr^ To 80 ^ tS^dLge j "fcWtoL* :t \\u^ fa &ftirk to &ef*~c&*js$; %%W • ft 1^3Vv4 Tke4 &«>v Ks^ &e Afiro^a- fbr (W^ed. fvHUr X ^ A- ftigtwh 4o Ac W&5 iW. (W/4 , rW &4tA £ /A«_ W, \wt4 of 14cJ^a Tor^c^ Av<4 Oej^eAVA^ - 0<«yo <a.<^ D^ce. "te> tX^t'a Ci^cuxj -4»L. Vj>_a^ 4q •' t

r>«, u t ]AAJtAfe

v^rv4~

Ajo fi ^ teyh <*V ♦ „, HiayKlA:*!IKyirP«J-ll

H 4rH '*£- "ta ^*C ^ Cr^/v-w$A Pro oejsWr^/

/vioMy AAtyi-jt A^iei" fo-25-/5 «•( ^ Csh

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.