Daugherty, Robert Brice
Daugherty, Robert Brice
Opinion
jzis-ts izk-15 iz^i-ts lna.1 Cf (\o*7 %&<\rt 1S*IS$ X&%%6 Courtc£ AppW: Die-itr-ooostctf 0(,-IG-O002><}<:i£ OL-l&~oooy&<L£ PbRnos'. iTJ\g--L<r nU-i«r W7~/s~
, -„. In I he ORIGINAL iSWs Coari of Original (XppeaJs a+" Q us f»Vi (o^fls 7 /
Rolw+ thrice ^r «ce DaucUr4u Pefifio/>s*RECEIVED wctuc^rTt^ ^e^n^g6URT - • OF CRIMINAL APPEALS
w DEC 112015
T • n n i Abel Acosta, Clerk Ik* Side or Texas 4 Kes>pondeflT-
n D - n FILED IN Pro-se, re-f-jfion Tor l>t'sc nrfiort a<Tcj fo t/ i> <<§0URT Op CRIMINAL APPEALS DEC 11 2015 t-Roim Tl^f clour b Of (Xpp<>aJs> Abel Acosta, Cierk
Utfnn LXml
Oral (Xrcamen^ Plot rlecues^ed I734? Idcn^iru 6t P<xr~tte£ cxnA (Zcrunscj
Jad^L i HorxarolnU. 8» (! Morris, presiding <Sj*K <D»sf^'£"t Judicial C.oat-i~
rd4mwt Koberf o^Ke O <xuck^^k| T7
Co**se\ Dor\ 13>to.^d £ra+t kW f\o. MoH 11 &S~ 6A CHff>ea\: 33 Pirsf Norff\u)es,\- PaHs , lexas 15*4 Co Tel: foo3>) !%S--I6>6t> Px*;&OB>) ISS-755^
$|-fnal ! tW\ Weekarx sW* &a«. f\o./3m700
"Tel: («lc>3) HXl-HSm Fcjc'. faoz) m7WC</? tTyyio* (l d (Y\e<\r\ou/\(@ valor r\e\-.Corr\
[*\-cx+br(*{< t>icu\f\<f. ^>pragAe £We Bor fto. 1^61780
111'(9^) a^-fcHl ftuf:(302)*78a-977/ £"/**»/: dSpra^uz- @ sadcM 1*v t mcu I. Co<n « ProsaaJt*^ La^ne K.PoHol^J. SUJhi £W Ac OOlZll^ Oiss is hs-wf' County &f-+o<rne^
T<l\:($o3>) IZI-MIO Pax:$03) 737-WST S/wktl: Ipaila-rd @CO.lcxfno.r,\-\LUS>
TL SW*oP Crof^i Hoan^ 5We £x^ f\o.O>7t?*i%
ra«K$, , I -e-y-as. iSHCo Tt\\(Q&g) 1^1-XHSt Fax:(3°3) 131-MSS
Jue^.W UoiaO(r<5-bl€ Ji>sk R. POorrjss flu
SivH. Courf of Ckppea4^ af Texc* r ka^a. Te xas table, of Qc>A.te<t\Vs
MeK\T"i^ o "P Pa^-K^s ac\c| Couv\€,e\ ')-// T~<a-bk_ &£ 6-on4?/vf ^'i'ii-i^ lnc(ey or Oiu,H\o^ Cfi-e^ v/ Cor\$>{ i Tuhoftcd Proimion *_ y( Aofd on Co^kiPt^J Brnr^1 yii
Suh[eci~ n0a4r<?r 6p lsst»^ Pr<*s*nf<?cf ^j oismmafM or QrcU^eAT vii <Sfataner\r- or *Bv<l £as<L , yjjj 5fc[-« mr\fi«.r negcroutv^ Orel Of cwprie/\\~ i ^e4-iho^\ kotr UiSCfehor\OiTu Keuifu} / Pr&CecHuai Hus. k>ru . 2.-3
P^Xcf _^ 3-<3
ISSUe AO. ( DJocu^ke^kj toas clenarcH Kis Consffiuhov>i ri^kf 4o e-fP<?cWi/-P assi'sW^ o-p counsel a+- +no.l u)Uev\ kis a^o/i-ififj -frfal counsel -Pcx«.l<?c£ 4e> Corn rnuoi dol^cl ^ ^Ua o PPer, ^ &\a*vXoLrd of ^efieu3 .6-7 Qr\a lusts, -},<£
-Ml- LXrcM.rr\ey\i-~ <£-[k Qr^ft/nwr on dr^nf ffsT-___ H-~Vi C^on alu&l0>\ 2.q-ZS~ Prot(^<r --^xs--zfc Oeciarafcovv o^ iriobili'kj X4 060o«ro C)^cloi^CL.fio>v id,
Ce?rfrWcof~e o r Service --27
-11/- Inote*? or dm H\on hiv-s
£x pa.rh dc^enh ^q^ &u} 3rC{ -?<gl 734 (Te>r, £r/^. ^p 2>0«iJ J^n.lM Er park CrWZ. ITtS SU) 3U<i ^3 €*(j**Xn~ PlfP \W~l) - ** Warrtuj f Carri'^ M77 U€> 473 (l^^J ^ „? Johnson • Due IrtOorfh 73><i P-xd <sq<S (7 "K C.* ) 16 Etpar-k&uP^ COH SU> Tlo\ €~tl(Ter.Cri^ Qpp. IW) £> Wiisoar. 1/ PrHe iVl S.cf 13,^ (^oii) <g Ex ^ark L^mke i2> Su3 3<* 7°/ Gctf. Cn^• &*op. ^°^^) S Soa.^ ^ ^ac DouSa 11 Ms</ U^ 36V 1^ Etf pa/-ie l^&nckaca Sb"*r ^n4 nt (je*. Crt^.Qfp. J^O 6 Twigae t/s &cH 6>o P 3ra [G^Clr 1<W?) ^ io (-UnylWi/ SWit k*x so) id (Tex. Q^p- QasU t^gn) /<> H^rrvmcWz 1/SWfd 7%fe Su3 0c& 5"£ ,S"7U cy.Cn^ .Q^ l^t) k H*f/\Qv\oW V$bfe ^"S Ski a-** 7T0 (lev. £f i^x. Ckpp. lW)___ £> /^Wfm (/• 'St-afe a£ ScO^rcf ^IS"" %\% fO jQami^ez i/ Siaie (\<n sa3 x^ ^SS" 34s~ ,_7 Tur^^ i/ SWte a-qq-4(6-c-£ , ,0
Ex faAr 6Jilso^\ "7XM SC3 **Jt 12 (j^Sl] <? S+nckUwl VlJ&*kt^Wv M46> U.S. 6£2 (lW) £> ,7
-y- C^on^hvuriono 1 Pro Uisicw
Slk'fh Ql metKclme^i~ j U\r\\.r^A ^W^-S (Co/vsb 4u.fi ov\
Poaf+f^K\~H\ OflifJ^m) Ltmtvcl €>to-f?_S C^or\ ^ Vt Vuchtr^
Qrficle X [O Tetos Co^sri kxfio>\
OrficU X \°i Ti^as donsfii"u'h<rv\
-v«- T~he. COfUsicfxon^, foeiooO 6uere_ -Piled i'lA. irAre^. &e.p>aLf&f~e CcxS?S i^mbe^ C\ccorc\ m^iu, "t~ke_ appeal -prom ecu-k conVichon /\as heev\ a^s.i<^ned ql SeparoAe. £<x$e namhe^ m "H\fS <^jurf. 6U| £<a.Sf=^ tfre_ beiri^ dt^neJ +o£fH\er* OS r~he. i~£>SUe£, G.t<uumenh aw$L Cxu-HiortUj presented &r^ idenrico^i -pot- <fack cas^.
Subjecf POoHe^ of Issues Presented IT. I^augke^kj u>as denied e PPecf<t>e CLS-sf^fatfee of coaitsel ^f- ~frfol because kis "Trial toansef failed "f-o commantco-te^ CL p\*<x
Summarcj QT (\r<:umeir\\- Tkc_ SVcL-fe mode <x tol^a oP'-Tcr +o Do-u^Wk^ ^o^/is.fP Tke Siajhe C>fPer UOcys, Do_u.cke^kj uoouid file<xd Cat IK* fo o Pfen&rs LOi^-K piwdifKj Or2 clru^ fV«?e Zorte. aftcl hc^bi+ual o ff*?»acW. \v\ evccha^ce £>o_u^k^*-rif u)oulci receit/e (X sentence. o-P Mo lj^o-^s f^ r-u.v\ coneari^efirJtf. D>ocu<cke iota's counsel n&ueir corr\mu.ni<ioJ~?& +-Wv« o PPe*^ to ht^K. rfo^eu^r, he U>ouW ho-ue <&c<:e£Jt<?4 +i\is 6-frVr- JW ke teeev\ atOo-re of iT, "Tke €>-kxfes oP^er ^^s lePf open -for- c*. sp^i^i^4 -kime. PurHv?^, Vk« rec<Ws skoco a rfoso^oble ^fdbdxbifity -H\e +ria\ Coarf uJoutc? |\aw excepted H\t oP-P***. (XccorAnr^l^, Dau^^kf uJas dented ePCecfTUe, DSSisWt^ of counsel.
-VM- Aai-urt o~P Pka. of Cruii+L| +0 +u30 cKa^p' oP Posse^sfovv un'Hi 4ta Co^e * jnfenr 4© D-^'iVe^ a Controlled, ^a-bsfanc-e. <^nd One DeliVer^ oP a Coty{ro[\eJL <Uxbs>\-a.Ace
Trio.ICout\; HoiA^roblei Q>ill Harris, (ba assign men+"J «£urM Dfsfricf- Coarf-, Umar GoanKj, Iexa£
•rial £ou*r "Tie "fri<xl Cour-f .senfenc*^ X)auck<p^^ Disposition• -\-o (i^e j/\ prison
(yppodljoC^ f-iled Ckppeo-l on /neP-P<?cKo<2 £X^s (\sfeLttc District I Cf C-ou.v\s.e\
(\fp<[\<&*. Mono re Me J^b £, rY)orri<> cUr Cocxt-r- ', ChleZ Ju<>kce j S»*K Coa.i'1-oP C\pp*a{$ .
(3^/kkf OtPrVVvx "Hve Prfal courU t)i5pcsifion * jacAc^ime^f OLtnci ^e/\[ence
-Viih $i*hemer\h Recardi'^ £Wl Or^a^e^\-
TT\e Pehr-ioner^ Kobe^k Once Occu^ke^kj anil
uJaije oral Qrcuiri^f,
-IJT I* The, T~e.)C<xs Court o-P Crtminoi Ckppe&l^ af- Husfin , I -e£o£.
RD. nos i^<\s-i<T i7^~is i^q7-ib~
fVob^^i Li>r ice l-^aucherKj , Pnhhoneir VS.
»k-e- Sko,fe. of \ etfOuS , Kesponder f
Petihon Por {^iscr^h o^arct Qeoieto Prot^ T~ke Court oP Qppeo-I* Sivfh Oisfrief of Tetfas <&) Texa^ka^a (Xfpeois nos. &&~lS'-Od02>%cg 6l>-l'SD00 3>qc& 66-/^-6)00^6cie
m) The Honorable £ourT~. LO^es HouJ, libe^f r^ouA^ke^f^, Pro~se> Pe.htiov\e^, Piles 4"kis bis Pe+nfiota Por Ofscrefion^r^ ReVieco <x/\cJ ^kocOS +V\« Pollotom^ in Sappcnf' Unless ott\eruuiset iinolicoicd , Qohert Daacli^ cm /1 n tt »' b€ re+WreJ -to as Do-t^ke^k., . Tk^ <£4o>e oP i e^4 L^U be reperr«?cl +o O-s "Hu^ S^We. or- rnssecaio^ On &agas.f- l^t XotH t Do-Ug-Acirfif uoo-s indicted -Por -P^lonu c>PPe^s<?s posst?s£»io>x i^Hv i^fe^f |t> defter fY\eH\o.vr\phe f&mind o" f more. Hvxf\ Pocl^ crams jin. o„ druc rre«_ zone and ^osSfSS/ov, £p o/t^z.^p^K\ in an amount fefis "Hxq.^ 7s§ crctmS in o cfrq.^. Pr-f«- lone. Q,v\d as cx kc^bifi-t^ oPp^^d^,
(H>n September f|, Hot Hx Octa^Ae^ fy UX>-S jKoli'cfecf &r Pe lo*.tf possess*o^ ^'H\ th4~efvt~ -Vo deliueir mef^OL^npneftLmine ot More, tour crams j^ ex o4rcc<^_ >Qr-ee 2<y\e and ^oss^s-s/ota ^-f: hifCfnococfme (n +~k^ ai^oa^f- (-ess -H\o-i/v O.'g (vram^ . dtnd as a kabifwo-l o £9et\<A-er In a &eparoTe_ iKdictrv»<?iA;f- an Sefot~e.rv\h<?r~ n, aoi^. Oa-ugkerft^ W<LS jnol fok?^ -Po«r -f-ke -PelcmJLf oP\eK\s€ o~P deltue^u o-P oiefkat^phihcmtne. in 6- ciruq Pree 2,one_ ^u/wl ^^ <X kaJotfuoi OY^endes: On ^brarc^ ut%oit>~, 4-&e cclS^l proceeded ft> -fn^/. TK«. <Sfr>-f* eiecfed1 fo cfto«o +~k£- possess/cm ci\a>K<?s #/fc|) Do-U^ke^ plea. GihItij 4-o «Ke re^nain mc^ cf\arcfs oP cAe.\ioeru qt me-W\GL<?nphetsmMe Q_ncl 4uoo cko-A^eS" op possession cu' K\ cnpen/k +o oleliut?»r jfneflna^pkefo.miK-*\ TW £>V©-le droj tke clru^ Pree 2.o^e a_lieo,c^ko>v tvitk rec^uavdl 4© -fiA->e) r-fmainint Cka/tGes.
0 CR XSZfy pfrl ®C*e 7^ Iff p^S
-2- Octucke^ftf oUso pleou 4-rue +o "He. bo-foituet a PPev\o! <?^ ade^cfrov fo all Changs, D&uc^nerkj e* levied h hatr*, +ke Court (XSSeS punishment The. t-riaJ Court €>entencej J^au^net-Uj to life imprisonment- oP each eAaroe mi ti\ Se«o fences +c run concurrently On ^at| is, TxOi s~, T>au<^ker4tj -£ill<?<£ app^a-f ^cnK Hae -£t*M Appellate Disfricf oP T^/aS* at" Texafkatna, loas^ Solely on /nePfe-ckiue O^sisffliic^ cP (Toans<?I. ^* Searember 3>aois"" ^<y/-A Q. pp& llde -DisfrfckoP Terns 6) aPPirmed -f-ke trio.I Courts \udo.emmt C\^4 sentence
Packs The, Pies Offrr,
Do-tKyke^hj t^as in italic. tAdicfeJ -prom ti^o oP Pems»#>.s "Hva^P 0<rcunrej On June \%otH. On Qucju^t S, XO/</, Tk« Sfoie ottered a p[ea ba/jrat* of ^O cj^ars iwpr i3anjyie^f i£• Daacjkervfw ooauld plead eui Ifi^ ko -Rose oPPev\se£ anJt tui6 addiKovial wnincUcf^ 0ffc^s WiHx druc Pr** zone and Ka.b tkAtvl oppe^cier Pi*\oU*K. .Dauck<rrfcjs "Prt'al coans<( commuiritfi:ctftfc( -Bus go t^&xr oPPer 4a Daa^e^ <xnd be Coaiater UJtH\ an oPfftr oP is~ ciears u->Kick -\tVjl €>Wte rejected
g) ^^mo^ancSm Qpiv\\cr^ @ /?f?Drr 8x3 (fe) &pp<? a*\h» GrifP p^ l-lU (J) Cie 1^86 ^ 7-S P^ -3- T~kc_ same daij Hve Sfate countered usiU\ an ofPer- oL Ho uears,— This o Pfer- uoo-*> kc) expire* On Qugasf 2.9, *2>K - "He dafe &ef Por Dauc^ke^fys ^^'^ +r,^( *A iix€ oPPe^s^s aJkick occ:urr<>d on Jane S, p.oi<*. On /Wemke^ 7, 7c3^ , t"ke fpiol Court held ex hearing 4o detersive uJhefW Daju^kerf^'s appointed Counsel should be alloooed 4o uJikkdra-io c4ue +t> c.onPkc4~ aP infer^sh and appointed Aeia krTal counsel. Qt 4~kaP Keann^ H^<_ pa/ihes aCsauSSe^ +ke flea. otPer -hke SPaie ba^ K^e Dcu^U^ +rio-l Counsel. Tk« <Uo-ke reiTeraJei 4-kak it" kaci inttaU^ oPPere^ an. OpPer op So u^ars and k©c$ redact 4~ha> k> HO UPCi^S, . Oaucke^ky peskj^veci), Under oaPk i "it\<x4 be had f\euer leaeneJ o-p »Wk MO Cjear oPfcr unkt aPter |T - j © expiree? Ofi g|?tf|*(MH,
-kriol Daa^k^k, ei;enkuall^ made an open plea of ^udfy k> -kbr^e oP 4-ke ofPeases and eUoteA 4o hai/e "Ha* 4-ri<xt c:oufr O-ssfs pttnrskn^e^T. dt t^e pumskmenf hearm^> Dauc^kerttf's r\e<u3 Prfa.1 co-ans^j acain raised -f^e. issue oP LoKetke^ or Y\&t- his aPkornew
© R6 D*f. Ek3 ,oc7 <® 6ft DeP. E*3 ££> MDef Ed pS7
-4- had Communi cated H\£ S^aJ-es HO uear p lea. aPpe<^. Tbrotx^k £>t~ipulad~ed te^ki kvxoau Dava^h^f^ tesPi Qiecf Pkuxk ke had nah been hold o£ €>hvk?-S 40 u^r oPfer until aPher \,ir expired. Q. dd ih&no-lt he. teskiPie^ Hv*i- bad. he foeen jn;Porm<?^ of i"Ko-P 0 PPe*1^ Uritkin ~Hve- time rro-nn* s^f loq i-h* Sfcde he cooulal haoe accepted i~ka3~ o ^ . OPteir kearm^all of 4-he ei/folenee, t~he trial Court tolloujej ttte Sfaf^s recommendation a not Senkenc^d him to life /mprtfsonment On all 4rk^ chxrcM. to run c oncurrently. On /Y)<xu t^QvOJS". Dauckerk, P Wd appeal U^'tk fh*. S>i xH. (Xppellate Disfrict c7t Iexas ok~ TexarkaAa bo^<4 aw. ineffective cissistance of counsel.^ Dn September 3>, TvOtS, 4-k^ £»yfh (Xppellahe- D is trial- o£ Texas* affirmed -the. +rial Coarfs jud^me*\4- and Senh?flce Of\ Se^ferwb.?^ :xo, TvOiS, C^aucWe^k^ -p-i led Por e^te'lSfon OT tirke and +0 Suspend |Qu.k 4,3>(b) recuardin^ ^jS Dtscreticrno.ru KeC^feuJ) txnkk -kke_ Courk aP Cri»v\mat CX^p^als - Or October l, ^d>(S , t"fve cWv^V op Cnmt^ Qpp^ats arantel eefensiak DP time and suspended rule 3. 3 Ob}.
© k& ft <H- (q) rNppella^ts (in^f p^ MC (f|) /Tl^moranduvw Opmio>\
Reference
- Status
- Published