Keefe v. Worcester Trust Co.
Keefe v. Worcester Trust Co.
Opinion of the Court
This case presents the question whether certain machines in a paper mill were so annexed to the realty and with such an intent as to become fixtures, so that they passed to the mortgagee of the realty.
The referee in dealing with the matter has classified the machines into groups. The first group consists of machines which both the referee and the District Court found the trust, company, as mortgagee, was entitled to under its mortgage. The second group consists of what is called the second paper machine. This machine the referee awarded to the trustee in bankruptcy, but the District Court reversed the referee and awarded it to the Trust Company. 249 Fed. 260. The question involved, as to each group, is a mixed one of law and fact. The parties are practically in accord as to the law; the divergence is as to the weight to he given the evidence and the deductions to he made therefrom. The case was very fully presented and carefully considered in the court below, and, after a re-examination of the evidence and a consideration of the arguments of counsel, we are of the opinion that the findings and rulings of the District Court as to the annexation of both groups of machines to the realty were correct.
A¥e think the question of fees, costs, and charges was rightly determined.
The decree of the District Court is affirmed, with costs to the appellee.
070rehearing
On Petition for Rehearing.
The appellant’s petition for rehearing is denied. If the record ought to be corrected to show that the appellant duly excepted to the exclusion of his offer of proof, and if the proof therein disclosed was competent and should have been received, we are still of the opinion that, talcing it into' consideration with the other evidence in the case, no other conclusion should be reached than the one arrived at in our opinion handed down October 22, 1918.
The petition for rehearing is denied.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- KEEFE v. WORCESTER TRUST CO. In re RUSSELL FALLS CO.
- Status
- Published