The Seaboard
Opinion of the Court
The Blue Line stakeboat, a tug which had been dismantled, except that the deckhouse was retained, owned by McWilliams and Kellers, was used for mooring barges in the Bridgeport Harbor on arid prior to October 26, 1916. On the night in question, which was dark, after 3 a. m., the barge Donald was tied up astern of the stakeboat, with the barge J. A. Roe astern of her. The Donald had a light, and the Roe showed a light on a pole at her stern. This tandem was stretched out across the channel. The Donald was about 116.5 feet long, and the Roe was about 112.9 feet long. Both were light. A southwest wind drifted the stakeboat near the west edge of the channel, and the barges with their fasts drifted across the channel. The tide was ebb and tended to carry them somewhat down against the wind. It is claimed that there was a light on the stern of the Donald, but that this was not burning at the time of the collision. The channel was 17 feet deep and 200 feet wide, and runs southeast from a point above the Seaboard’s pier to a point below the place of collision. The stakeboat’s location was on the west side of the channel, about a quarter of a mile below Fairest Point. The Seaboard left her pier on the Poquonock river, Bridgeport, about 3 a. m., and proceeded down through the channel. The lights of the stakeboat on her starboard hand and the white light on her port hand were seen, and the navigator took the latter to be that of a vessel anchored on the east side of the channel.
The captain of the Seaboard was in the pilot house directing navigation. His pilot and the man at the wheel were also there, and the
On these facts, the court below entered a decree against the owners of the stakeboat and against the owners of the Roe, and in favor of the barge Donald for ha|f damages in the order named. The court below held that the privileges of the stakeboat were regulated by the harbor master of Bridgeport; that the Donald was at fault for not carrying a light; and that, since the stakeboat owners so moored the boats aS to permit them to stretch across the channel obstructing navigation, they are primarily liable for the damage sustained. The court found that the captain of the stakeboat placed the barges in this position.
“A vessel under 150 feet in length, when at anchor, shall carry forward, where it can be best seen, but at a height not exceeding 20 feet above the hull, a white light in a lantern so constructed as to show a clear, uniform, and unbroken light visible all around the horizon at a distance of at least one mile.”
We think the Seaboard, in navigating as she did, was also at fault in bringing about the collision. The claim is that she was unable to stop her headway in time to avoid the collision. She struck the Donald a hard blow, and this must have been due to the fact that, after being hooked up, she was going at considerable speed. It is conceded that the navigator saw the light, but the claim that he mistook the signal for another boat on the opposite side of the channel does not excuse the vessel from fault. We think the Seaboard was at fault in undertaking to go at hooked up speed, with a light directly in front of her. Due care and caution would have avoided the collision. The Yucatan, 226 Fed. 437, 141 C. C. A. 267; The New York, 167 Fed. 315, 92 C. C. A. 627. On the testimony of her own master, she saw the light in ample time to have avoided the 'collision. We likewise think that the Donald, placed as she was by the captain of the stakeboat, in such a position as to drift with the wind into the channel, was not at fault, and that her faulty position was due solely to the captain of the stake-boat. John G. McCullough (D. C.) 232 Fed. 637; Pocohontas (D. C.) 217 Fed. 135. For the reasons which absolve the Donald from liability, we also think no liability attaches to the Roe.
The court below is directed to modify the decree by awarding full damages to the Donald against the Seaboard and the stakeboat owners, but without costs in- this court.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- THE SEABOARD. THE J. A. ROE
- Status
- Published