Donald R. Kurz William Anderson James E.W. Beck William T. Bergen Charles W....

U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
Donald R. Kurz William Anderson James E.W. Beck William T. Bergen Charles W...., 113 F.3d 432 (3d Cir. 1997)
1997 U.S. App. LEXIS 10830

Donald R. Kurz William Anderson James E.W. Beck William T. Bergen Charles W....

Opinion

113 F.3d 432

Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck;
William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown;
Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco;
James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J.
DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante;
Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.;
James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian;
George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P.
McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A.
Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B.
Myers; John J. Nusspickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B.
Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow
E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C.
Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young
v.
PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of
Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz;
J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr.
John J. Divalento, Jr., William E. Drumel; John A. Morse;
Samuel J. Mullen; Stanley B. Myers; Dominic C. Viglianese;
James J. DiLolle; Benjamin J. Kilian; Charles W. Bowden;
Elmer D. Greim, Jr.; Frederick W. Winterling; James W. Beck;
James H. Hair; Robert C. DeMarco; Alfred G. Schumann;
Richard Cahill; James W. Patterson; John M. Hoopes; Hubert
A. McKown, Jr.; Robert E. Miller; James D. Sutliff; Henry P.
McNamee; Francis T. Golden; William T. Bergen; George C.
Linthicum; William W. Anderson; John R. Young; Vincent J.
Dimaggio; Shields L. Daltroff; Richard O. Folkman; Alfred E.
Stavola; Robert H.C. Less; Samuel E. Bell; Donald F.
Washington; Frank J. Gallagher; Maurice M. Peitzman; Harry
G. Turner, Jr.; Robert I. Friend; Donald C. Robinson;
William J. Leaman, Jr.; Augustus W. O'Malley; Dallas S.
Scott, Jr.; John S. Stillwagon; Robert C. Heckesser; William
R. Travetti; William B. Horlock; James States; Thomas W.
Rayer; John H. Vonrhine; Walter Allwoerden; George C.
Wiedersum, Jr.; James R. McCarron; Salvator J. Destefano;
John C. Garvin; A. William Lancaster; Joseph A. Focht;
Robert Mitchell; Joseph P. Subranni; John F. Crawford;
William G. Taylor; Kenneth R. Sedgley, Jr.; Irwin G.
Blackburn; Charles R. Carey; John R. Young; Jessee E. Gray,
Jr.; James D. Derstine; Allen H. Braid; Paul L. Thomas;
Stephen Micklosh, Jr.; William L. Gibbons; Russell B.
Murray; Roland J. Markun; Ernest W. Beam; Raymond W. Scholl,
Jr.; John F. Parker; Joseph F. McBride; Vincent S. Boyer;
Martin M. Morgan and David Monzo, Appellants in 95-1795.
Donald R. KURZ; William Anderson; James E.W. Beck;
William T. Bergen; Charles W. Bowden; William H. Brown;
Richard Cahill; Armando L. Capoferri; Robert C. DeMarco;
James J. DiLolle, Sr.; Vincent J. DiMaggio; John J.
DiValentino, Jr.; William E. Drumel; Victor J. Gibialante;
Francis T. Golden; James J. Granger; Elmer D. Greim, Jr.;
James H. Hair; John M. Hoopes; Benjamin J. Kilian;
George C. Linthicum; Hubert A. McKown, Jr.; Henry P.
McNamee; Oliver K. Messner; Robert E. Miller; John A.
Morse; Samuel J. Mullen; John A. Munley; Stanley B.
Myers; John J. Nusspickel; James W. Patterson; Alfred B.
Schumann; Joseph C. Sharkey; William H. Smoyer; Woodrow
E. Snyder; James D. Sutliff; Edward J. Vetner; Dominic C.
Viglianese; G. Earle Watt; Frederick W. Winterling; John R. Young
v.
PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC COMPANY; Service Annuity Plan of
Philadelphia Electric Company; Charles L. Fritz;
J.L. Everett, III; John H. Austin, Jr.
Peco Energy Company, formerly known as Philadelphia Electric
Company, Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric
Company, Charles L. Fritz, J.L. Everett, III and John H.
Austin, Jr., Appellants in 95-1796.

Nos. 95-1795, 95-1796.

United States Court of Appeals,
Third Circuit.

May 7, 1997.

1

Prior report: 96 F.3d 1544.

2

Before: COWEN and ROTH, Circuit Judges and CINDRICH1, District Judge.

SUR PETITION FOR PANEL REHEARING

3

The petition for panel rehearing filed by appellants Monzo, Morgan and McEntee in the above-entitled case having been submitted to the judges who participated in the decision of this court and no judge who concurred in the decision having asked for rehearing, the petition for rehearing is denied.

1

Honorable Robert J. Cindrich, United States District Court Judge for the Western District of Pennsylvania, sitting by designation

Reference

Full Case Name
Donald R. Kurz William Anderson James E.W. Beck William T. Bergen Charles W. Bowden William H. Brown Richard Cahill Armando L. Capoferri Robert C. Demarco James J. Dilolle, Sr. Vincent J. Dimaggio John J. Divalentino, Jr. William E. Drumel Victor J. Gibialante Francis T. Golden James J. Granger Elmer D. Greim, Jr. James H. Hair John M. Hoopes Benjamin J. Kilian George C. Linthicum Hubert A. McKown Jr. Henry P. McNamee Oliver K. Messner Robert E. Miller John A. Morse Samuel J. Mullen John A. Munley Stanley B. Myers John J. Nusspickel James W. Patterson Alfred B. Schumann Joseph C. Sharkey William H. Smoyer Woodrow E. Snyder James D. Sutliff Edward J. Vetner Dominic C. Viglianese G. Earle Watt Frederick W. Winterling John R. Young v. Philadelphia Electric Company Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company Charles L. Fritz J.L. Everett, III John H. Austin, Jr. John J. Divalento, Jr., William E. Drumel John A. Morse Samuel J. Mullen Stanley B. Myers Dominic C. Viglianese James J. Dilolle Benjamin J. Kilian Charles W. Bowden Elmer D. Greim, Jr. Frederick W. Winterling James W. Beck James H. Hair Robert C. Demarco Alfred G. Schumann Richard Cahill James W. Patterson John M. Hoopes Hubert A. McKown Jr. Robert E. Miller James D. Sutliff Henry P. McNamee Francis T. Golden William T. Bergen George C. Linthicum William W. Anderson John R. Young Vincent J. Dimaggio Shields L. Daltroff Richard O. Folkman Alfred E. Stavola Robert H.C. Less Samuel E. Bell Donald F. Washington Frank J. Gallagher Maurice M. Peitzman Harry G. Turner, Jr. Robert I. Friend Donald C. Robinson William J. Leaman, Jr. Augustus W. O'Malley Dallas S. Scott, Jr. John S. Stillwagon Robert C. Heckesser William R. Travetti William B. Horlock James States Thomas W. Rayer John H. Vonrhine Walter Allwoerden George C. Wiedersum, Jr. James R. McCarron Salvator J. Destefano John C. Garvin A. William Lancaster Joseph A. Focht Robert Mitchell Joseph P. Subranni John F. Crawford William G. Taylor Kenneth R. Sedgley, Jr. Irwin G. Blackburn Charles R. Carey John R. Young Jessee E. Gray, Jr. James D. Derstine Allen H. Braid Paul L. Thomas Stephen Micklosh, Jr. William L. Gibbons Russell B. Murray Roland J. Markun Ernest W. Beam Raymond W. Scholl, Jr. John F. Parker Joseph F. McBride Vincent S. Boyer Martin M. Morgan and David Monzo, in 95-1795. Donald R. Kurz William Anderson James E.W. Beck William T. Bergen Charles W. Bowden William H. Brown Richard Cahill Armando L. Capoferri Robert C. Demarco James J. Dilolle, Sr. Vincent J. Dimaggio John J. Divalentino, Jr. William E. Drumel Victor J. Gibialante Francis T. Golden James J. Granger Elmer D. Greim, Jr. James H. Hair John M. Hoopes Benjamin J. Kilian George C. Linthicum Hubert A. McKown Jr. Henry P. McNamee Oliver K. Messner Robert E. Miller John A. Morse Samuel J. Mullen John A. Munley Stanley B. Myers John J. Nusspickel James W. Patterson Alfred B. Schumann Joseph C. Sharkey William H. Smoyer Woodrow E. Snyder James D. Sutliff Edward J. Vetner Dominic C. Viglianese G. Earle Watt Frederick W. Winterling John R. Young v. Philadelphia Electric Company Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company Charles L. Fritz J.L. Everett, III John H. Austin, Jr. Peco Energy Company, Formerly Known as Philadelphia Electric Company, Service Annuity Plan of Philadelphia Electric Company, Charles L. Fritz, J.L. Everett, III and John H. Austin, Jr., in 95-1796
Status
Published