After a careful examination and consideration of the elaborate decisions of Mr. Secretary Noble, Mr. Secretary Smith, Mr. Secretary Bliss, and Judge Locke, all found in the transcript, and all adverse to the claims of the appellants, and a study of the very able briefs filed by eminent counsel, we are of opinion that the judge of the Circuit Court properly ruled in sustaining the demurrer to the complainants’, bill; and therefore the judgment appealed from is affirmed.