Freed v. State Farm Automobile Insurance
Opinion of the Court
Appellant Kathryn M. Freed, a Florida resident, filed suit in federal district court against the State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company (hereinafter “State Farm”), an Illinois Corporation doing business in Florida. She sought damages for injuries she sustained as a result of an accident that had occurred in Maryland when the
In answering this threshold issue, the lower court posed the problem as,
[w]hether [Mrs. Freed] under the facts delineated in the complaint has a direct action against [State Farm] prior to the establishment of [Green’s] liability by judgment or otherwise.
Characterizing the issue thus presented as substantive which under Florida conflicts law is governed by the law of the place of the tort,
Freed asserts that the lower court improperly characterized the issue presented as substantive because at least one intermediate Florida appellate court has stated that the Florida rule which permits a direct action against an insurance company is procedural.
Assuming arguendo that the direct action question is procedural in Florida, it is apparent that Mrs. Freed has misconstrued the applicable Florida cases involving a direct action against an insurance carrier. Florida permits an injured party to join the insurance company as co-defendant with the insured. See Shingleton v. Bussey, 223 So.2d 713 (Fla. 1969). No Florida ease has ever held that an insurance company is subject to suit without joining the insured as a party for a complete resolution of the allegedly tortious conduct. In Florida the insurance company must be sued jointly with the insured to withstand a motion to dismiss. Kephart v. Pickens, 271 So.2d 163 (Fla.App. 1972).
In this case, appellant failed to join the insured, Green, as a co-defendant. Thus regardless of the applicable law, Maryland or Florida, appellant has failed to state a cause of action.
Accordingly, the judgment of the district court dismissing appellant’s complaint is affirmed.
. Calhoun v. Greyhound Lines, Inc., 265 So.2d 18 (Fla. 1972).
. See Beta Eta House Corp., Inc. v. Gregory, 230 So.2d 495, 499 (Fla.App. 1970).
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Kathryn M. FREED v. STATE FARM AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
- Cited By
- 2 cases
- Status
- Published