In re: Lloyd
In re: Lloyd
Opinion
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT
__________________
98-21076 Summary Calendar __________________
In The Matter of: CLAUDE HUGH LLOYD, doing business as Ancient Oak Sanctuary, also known as Big Oak Materials, also known as Claude H. Lloyd Enterprises, also known as Hugh Lloyd, also known as Yahweh Kingdom People; In the Matter of: CASSONDRA JEAN LLOYD, also known as Cassandra Douglas Lloyd,
Debtors,
CLAUDE HUGH LLOYD; CASSONDRA JEAN LLOYD,
Appellants,
v.
JOSEPH M. NIXON; THOMAS JACK PEARSON; DANIEL E. O'CONNELL,
Appellees.
______________________________________________
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas (H-98-CV-1281, H-98-CV-1282 & H-98-CV-2734) ______________________________________________
November 1, 1999
Before JOLLY, JONES and BENAVIDES, Circuit Judges.
PER CURIAM:*
Claude Hugh Lloyd and Cassondra Jean Lloyd (“the Lloyds” or
“Debtors”) appeal from three distinct orders of the bankruptcy
court: (1) the dismissal of the Debtors' Chapter 13 bankruptcy
* Pursuant to 5TH CIR. R. 47.5, the Court has determined that this opinion should not be published and is not precedent except under the limited circumstances set forth in 5TH CIR. R. 47.5.4. petition; (2) the bankruptcy court's refusal to reopen the
bankruptcy case; and (3) the bankruptcy court's denial of the
Debtors' motion to withdraw the reference with regard to an
adversary proceeding which they filed but which was subsequently
dismissed. On appeal to the district court, the appeals were
consolidated and all three orders affirmed.
After a careful review of the record and the arguments
advanced on appeal, we reject the Debtors' appeal and affirm all
the orders appealed from. The appeals border on the frivolous.
The bankruptcy court found and the record supports the
bankruptcy court finding that the Lloyds had willfully failed to
prosecute their Chapter 13 case by failing to file all due tax
returns, failing to appear at a meeting of the creditors, and
failing to make required plan payments. Indeed, the record
reflects not only that the tax returns were not filed, but that the
Debtors have no intention of filing the returns or paying taxes for
religious and political reasons.1 We find, as did the district
court, that the bankruptcy court did not abuse its discretion in
dismissing the Chapter 13 proceeding.
Likewise, the appeal of the order denying the Lloyds' motion
1 Mr. Lloyd testified that “I'm a de jour sovereign expatriate. ... I have declared that I am a citizen of the household of God, of Yahweh. ... The Bible says we're ambassadors for Christ. I claimed my ambassadorship. I have special diplomatic rights and immunities as an ambassador. I've notified the president of the United States and the secretary of state and all governmental agencies, city, county and state.” Mr. Lloyd also testified that “the Internal Revenue Service does not have jurisdiction to persecute me and prosecute me. I'm an expatriate. I don't grant them jurisdiction.” Mrs. Lloyd testified that she agreed with everything her husband said.
2 to reopen the case lacks merit. As the district court correctly
pointed out, the deficiencies that caused the dismissal had not
been cured and there was no purpose in reopening the case.
Finally, the Lloyds' motion to withdraw reference of the
adversary proceeding became a moot issue when the adversary
proceeding was dismissed and no appeal was taken from such
dismissal.
The Lloyds' conclusory attack on the statutory pre-
confirmation payment requirements was neither raised in the
bankruptcy court nor properly briefed on appeal and is therefore
not properly before us on appeal. For the same reasons, the
Lloyds' stated error of the trustee in failing to convert the
Chapter 13 case to a Chapter 11 case is not before us and will not
be reviewed.
The orders of the bankruptcy court are affirmed essentially
for the reasons set forth in the order of the district court
affirming the bankruptcy court dated September 28, 1998.
AFFIRMED.
3
Reference
- Status
- Unpublished