Intercon Solutions, Inc. v. James Puckett
Opinion
In the
United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP
%=P24M4259P P >P =>P % ."" >P ',P
P P P$P P >P %$."" %$=P IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP
&&"P (%#P* P$ *P**)P )*( *P%+(*P %(P* P %(* ($P )*( *P% P "" $% )>P)*($P , ) %$=P %=P23PP7925POP >/ &=P IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP
P P29>P3125POP P P3:>P3126P IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIP
%(P >P >P $P >/ #& %/
&$=P >/ #& %/ &=P $*(%$P %"+* %$)>P - P &(%, )P (/" $ P )(, )P %(P "*(%$ P , )>P $ P )"P* %$P*-%(!PABP*%P,"+*P *)P+) $))=P $*(M %$P )!P P *%P (* /P *P )P $P $, (%$#$*""/P ( $"/P %&(* %$=P P %$"+>P %-,(>P * *P $*(%$P ) &)P 0(%+)P-)*P*%P $>P*%P (#)P* *P+)P#* %)P% P )M &%)"P * *P , %"*P * P &%" /P % P "" $% )>P - (P $*(%$P )P 3P %=P24M4259P
)>P$P(P $%$) )*$*P- * P $*(%$F)P&+" P(&()$M ** %$)P %+*P *)P &(* )=P P %##+$ *P * )P %$"+M ) %$P *%P *-%P $ )P A%$P )**P $P %$P ("BP $P *%P * P &+" =P $*(%$P ()&%$P - * P * )P #* %$P * %$P +$M (P * P ,() */P +( ) * %$=P P %#&" $*>P )P %$P "" M $% )P "->P "" )P * *P F)P )**#$*)P (P ")>P $P * *P P!$%-)P* #P*%PP ")=P PP )P P ) $ *%$P %(&%(* %$P - * P *)P &( $ &"P &"P % P +) $))P $P **"=P P &(* )P (P * *P F)P )**#$*)P -(P #P $P ) $ *%$P +*P -(P (+"*P - "/P $P "" $% )P A $P * %$P *%P $ P )$*P (*"/P *%P *-%P $ )BP$P* *P "" $% )P"-P* ( %(P %,($)P* P #M * %$P " #=P +*P $P $)-(P *%P * P %#&" $*P P ))(*P P $)P )P %$P ) $ *%$F)P $* M P )**+*>P P KKP5=35=621>P5=35=636=P* %$P5=35=621P )P* P$* %$F)P ()*P$* M P "->P $*P $P 2:9:@P K5=35=636P -)P P $P 3121=P P %$*$>P $P * P )*( *P %+(*P ">P * *P "" $% )P A- %)P "-P %,($)P % M% M"-P ))+)BP -%+"P ,P P * P $ *P % P * )P $)P +$(P ) $ *%$P "-P +)P P )P)P $P) $ *%$P$P#P *)P)**#$*)P* (=P :7:P=P+&&=P3P2137>P2145N47PA==P ""=P3124B=P P)*$)P %(PG)*(* P"-)+ *P $)*P&+" P&(* M &* %$=HP $/P )**)P ,P %$"+P * *P )%#P * %$)P %(P #* %$P A$P P -P %* (P *%(*)BP (P ">P $%*P *%P &(, ">P +*P*%P #&%)P%$P* P)&!(P* P%)*)P% P $)>P- P$P P )+)*$* "=P P %#)P =P +(!>P % . / % % ! P =P9PA3125BPA%""* $ P)**P" )"* %$B=P$P$* M P)**M +*P )P P )& " 0P ,() %$P % P * P *%(*P % P +)P % P &(%))>P ) $P*%P(+P $)P%)*)P/P(* $ P$P)%"+*P%(P '+" P ##+$ */>P$PA $P),("P)**)BP/P('+ ( $ P("/P )&%) * %$P% PP#%* %$P*%P )# ))=PP $$*P* *P&(, ")P %=P24M4259P 4P
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
* P #( *)>P )P $P %(*P *%P - $P %+*( *=P P $)P ()P (%#PP%""*("P#**(=P>P= =>P %/%%$/',/ ! >P 546P==P961PA2:89B=P $)*P% P )# )) $ P* P&&"P ##M *"/>P %-,(>P * P %+(*P ((P * %$P *%P ,P * P &(M * )P * #P *%P )!P %(P (* * %$P +$(P 39P ===P K23:3AB=P % $ 0 $ P* *P *P P*!$P) )P%$P$P #&%(*$*P$PM *"P ))+P* *P )P%&$P $P* P,$* P (+ *>P* P )*( *P %+(*P(* P *)P%((P %(P $*("%+*%(/P(, ->P$P-PM P*%P&*P* P&&"P%$P* *P)**+*F)P+* %( */=P
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
=>P ))$* $ P (%#P* P$ M "P% P( ( $ P$P$BPA%$"+ $ P* *P)**P"-)P#+)*PP &&" P )P -( **$>P - P +)+""/P #$)P * *P )**+*)P )+ P )PK5=35=636P$$%*PP+)P $P ("P%+(*B=P 7P %=P24M4259P
) $ *%$F)P )*P%+(*P$%-P )P*>P$P%+(P)P )P(/P %(P()%"+* %$=P' $/',/!)>P3126P) =P P679PA=P *=P ) =P /P 39>P 3126B>P %")P * *P K5=35=636P , %"*)P * P )**F)P %$)* *+* %$P +)P K5=35=636A5BABP ('+ ()P P + P *%P()%",P *+"P )&+*)P* *P&(%&("/P"%$ P*%PP +(/=P P%+(*P&(%P $P* (P)*&)=P ()*>P *P)!P- * M (PK5=35=636A5BABP$PP+$()*%%P)PP %(#P% P)+##(/M + #$*P &(* =P A,("P ("P %+(*)P % P &&")P ,P *(*P )**P $* M P )**+*)P * *P -/>P $P P )P )!P+)P*%P%P)%P*%%=BP P%+(*P "P* *PP)& "P#%* %$P *%P )*( !P )P $%*P P ,( $*P % P )+##(/P + #$*>P +)P *P ('+ ()P + )P*%P()%",P#*( "P *+"P )&+*)P%$PP&M &(P (%(>P - P * P )+##(/P + #$*P )*$(P &(% M *)=P3126P) =P P679P*PJJP26N39=PA) $ *%$F)P(+"P%$P - $P)+##(/P + #$*P#/PP ($*P )P $* "P*%P M ("P&(* =BP' $P "P* *P! )/# P P# )+$(M )*%%P K5=35=636A5BABP $P %" $ P * *P *P $P P *(*P )P P %(#P% P)+##(/P + #$*=P %$>P' $P "P* *PP('+ (#$*P* *P + )P()%",P *+"P )&+*)P %$P P &&(P (%(P , %"*)P * P ( *P *%P *( "P /P +(/=P 3126P ) =P P 679P *P JJP3:N47=P A $>P K5=35=636A5BABP -%+"P P &(%"#* P ,$P P * (P -(P $%P +(/P( *>P %(>P- $P$P ))+P )P%## **P*%PP + >PP*( "P %(P ( $ P % *$P - ""P P $))(/P *%P ( ,P *)* #%$/P $P ,"+*P( " */P *(P%&&%(*+$ */P %(P(%))M.# $* %$=BP $""/>P' $P "P* *P* P()*P% PK5=35=636P )P$%*P),(M "=P 3126P ) =P P 679P *P JJP48N4:=P $P %* (P -%()>P * P )+)*$* ,P $P &(%+("P &(*)P % P K5=35=636P $$%*P P M %#&%)=P)PP#**(P% P) $ *%$P"->P* P +""P)**+*P )P +$$ %("=P %=P24M4259P 8P
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
&(%+("P)&*)P% P%* (P)**)FP$* M P)**+*)P-%(!P $P ("P%+(*P- ""P ,P*%P- *P)%#P%* (P)=P P &&" * %$P %(P ",P *%P &&"P +$(P §23:3ABP )P ($*>P$P* P ) %$P )P =P
Reference
- Status
- Published