In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN

(?N6:L7556N

N 
N ' N

N 
@N "' "/" .%%2N' N,N 1 .-(+,N( N-! N,-- N( N' ,,N((@N

  '
 @N !$N


 N 
 N  

@N 
@N ' N 
N 
 
NNN NN@N  '
 ?N IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN

)) %N +(&N-! N'"- N-- ,N",-+" -N(.+-N (+N-! N (+-! +'N",-+" -N( N %%"'(",@N,- +'N"/","('?N (?N68NN=>;;NMN 
 @( ?N IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN

N

N6>@N756;NMN N
N9@N756;N IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN

 (+ N
 @N@N' N @(   (  ?N 
 @(    (  ?N !"% N %"/"' N "'N %%"'(",@N ' ,,N((N., N-! N+"-3N0 ,"- N-(N(($N' N)2N (+N N,-2N-N-! N+ %4N (,N(,N% N %.1 N"'N 1" (?N
L - +N++"/"' N-N-! N!(- %@N((N," ' N.)N"'N"-,N%(2N (+N'N (-(.+N() +- N2N' !(N+",./N02N +(&N-! N!(- %F,N )+ &", ,?N.+"' N-!-N-(.+@N-! N%%L- ++"'N/ !" % N-!-N((N 7N (?N6:L7556N

0,N+" "' N(/ +-.+' @N' N,! N " N +(&N! +N"'#.+" ,?N!",N ,."-@N .' +N -! N "'- +'-"('%N "/ +,"-2N #.+", " -"('N ( N 7=N ???N J6887CDC7D@N , $,N & ,N +(&N ' !(N +",./N )%.,N + %4N (+)(+ "4'N &)+ ,+"%@N N )'",!N (+)(+L -"('?N! N (&)%"'-N%% ,N-!-N+ %4N(0' N' N() +- N -! N !(- %BN + %4N '" ,N -!",N ' N &"'-"',N -!-N "-N !,N '(N (0' +,!")N "'- + ,-@N "+ -N (+N "' "+ -@N "'N -! N + %4N (,N (,N% N %.1 NC'(0N$'(0'N,N2--N"/N (,N(,D?N ! N ",-+" -N (.+-N " N '(-N " N 0! -! +N + %4N (+)(L + "4'N &)+ ,+"%N !,N '2N ('' -"('N -(N -! N !(- %N ((N (($ M(+N 0! -! +N "-! +N ' '-N ",N .%)% N "'N ! +N -!M ., N "-N (' %. N -!-N ' "-! +N ' '-N ",N ,.L # -N-(N) +,('%N#.+", " -"('N"'N %%"'(",?N  "-! +N ' '-N (' . -,N .,"' ,,N "'N %%"'(",@N ' N -! N 1 .-(+,N ( N ((F,N ,-- N C-! N )%"'-" ,N "'N -!",N ,."-DN ('L N -!-N ' "-! +N ' '-N ",N ,.# -N -(N -! N ,-- F,N ' +%N #.+", " -"('?N C 'N "/ +,"-2N ,."-,@N ,-- N %0N )+(/" ,N -! N ,",N ( N) +,('%N#.+", " -"('@N' N %%"'(",N 1 + ", ,N#.+", " -"('N-(N -! N%"&"-N, -N2N-! N. N+( ,,N%., ,N( N-! N(',-"-.-"('?N  N <8:N N :K7L75>C D?DN (N )%"'-" ,N + %2N ('N ,) " " N #.+",L " -"('?N  N # (   (   (    %( $
$( !$(  "@N 686N ?N -?N 7=9;N C7566DN C ", .,,"' N -! N " + ' N  -0 'N ' +%N ' N ,) " " N #.+", " -"('D?N ! 2N ,2N -!-N ((F,N -!N ",N ('' - N -(N %%"'(",N -!+(. !N N .,%N !"'N  "'L '"' N 0"-!N -! N ., N ( N +"-3F,N 0 ,"- ?N /"' N (($ N ' N )" N +(&NN (&).- +N"'N %%"'(",@N((N0 '-N-(N (,N(,@N -(($N 'N ( +N 1- ' N 2N N " + '-N .,"' ,,@N ! N 'N  "L '-@N' N " ?N!-N .,%N !"'N,. " ,N (+N) +,('%N#.+",L " -"('N"'N %%"'(",@N)%"'-" ,N"',",-@N / 'N-!(. !N' !(N+"L ,./N!,N'(N ('' -"('N-N%%N0"-!N %%"'(",?N! N ",-+" -N (.+-N 0,N'(-N) +,. BN' "-! +N+ N0 ?N (?N6:L7556N 8N

(!$( @N689N?N-?N666:NC7569D@N,!(0,N-!-N-! N) +L -"' '-N*. ,-"('N",N0! -! +N-! N ' '-N!,N%"'$,N-(N-! N#.L +", " -"('N"'N0!" !N-! N,."-N0,N "% @N'(-N0! -! +N-! N)%"'L -" N !,N ,. !N %"'$,M(+N 0! -! +N -! N %(,,N %(0 N -!+(. !N N .,%N !"'N +(&N -! N )%"'-" F,N ('- -,N 0"-!N -! N #.+", " L -"('N( N,."-?N'%2N"'- '-"('%N ('- -,N2N-! N ' '-N0"-!N -! N (+.&N #.+", " -"('N 'N ,.))(+-N ,) " " N #.+", " -"('?N %"'-" ,FN (&)%"'-N ( ,N '(-N %% N -!-N ' !(N +",./@N -! N,.))(, %2N .%)% N)+-2@N! N'2N " '-L+ %- N ('L - -,N0"-!N %%"'(",?N ',-  N)%"'-" ,N+ %2N('N& N ('- -,N 0"-!N %%"'(",@N ' N -! 'N 0"-!N +"-3@N 0!" !N ! N N ('-+ -N 0"-!N + %4N C(+N (' N ( N "-,N ,.," "+" ,N (+N %" ', ,D@N 0!" !N % N ! +N -(N N !(- %N %(2N "'N #N %" (+'"@N 0! + N ,! N & -N N + )+ , '--"/ N ( N ' !(N +",./@N 0!" !N )+(/" N L -"/ N *.")& '-N C(+N " " '-N ,.) +/","('DN ('N N &(-(+"3 N -(.+?N . !N ('- -,N + N / 'N &(+ N -- '.- N -!'N -!(, N & N"',. " " '-N"'( @N"'N0!" !N-! N(.+-N! % N-!-N  / N (.% N'(-N 1 + ", N#.+", " -"('N(/ +NN %"&N2N(' N( N "-,N "-"3 ',N -!-N N + ," '-N ( N  (+ "N ,!(.% N !/ N $'(0'N -!-N!",N -"/"-2N"'N (+ "N0(.% N"'#.+ N-! N / '?N '%2N -0(N &('-!,N  (@N "'N (  !  (
( !$(  @N68;N?N-?N8>5NC756:D@N-! N.)+ & N(.+-N %-N0"-!NN !"'L( L .,-"('N -! (+2N ,"&"%+N -(N )%"'-" ,F?N +(%N  !,@N 0!"% N %"/"' N "'N %" (+'"@N ., N -! N '- +' -N -(N ).+ !, N N .+"%N ,,N +(&N N -+/ %N  '-N "'N ,, !., --,?N !"% N .,L "' N-!-N),,N"'N
.,-+"@N !,N %%N-(N-! N-+ $,N' N0,N"'L #.+ ?N! N,. NN +,(' '/ +$ !+@N-! N
.,-+"'N+"%02@N "'N %" (+'"?N .-N -! N .)+ & N (.+-N (, +/ N -!-N -! N ,L , +- N -(+-N ! N  'N (&&"-- N 2N 'N
.,-+"'N .,"' ,,N "'N
.,-+"N' N! N'(N ('' -"('N-(N%" (+'"?N!-N !,@N' N -! N ,% N ( N -! N .+"%N ,,@N ! N %" (+'"N ('- -,N " N '(-N "&)%2N -!-N -! N +"%+( N " N .,"' ,,N (+N (&&"-- N -(+-,N "'N 9N (?N6:L7556N

%" (+'"@N ,(N %" (+'"N (.% N '(-N ,, +-N #.+", " -"('N (/ +N -! N+"%+( ?N((F,N %"&N!,N'N / 'N%(' +N .,%N !"'BN "-N ",N *."/% '-N -(N  !,N -- &)-"' N -(N ,. @N "'N %" (+'"@N ,(& (' N0!(N ., N! +N (( N)(",('"' N('N(+ N-! N-+"'N "'N
.,-+"?N %"'-" ,N ('- ' N -!-( (  !  N ",N ",-"'L .",!% N  ., N -!-N +"%+( N ",N N ,-- L(0' N .,"' ,,@N 0!" !N +"' ,N -! N (+ " 'N (/ + " 'N &&.'"-" ,N
-N -(N -! N (+ ?N ."-,N  "',-N .,"' ,, ,N (0' N 2N (+ " 'N '-"(',N + N )+() +N('%2N" N-! N '- +)+", N!,N '  N"'N (&& + "%N L -"/"-2N "'N -! N '"- N -- ,?N 7=N ???N J6;5:CDC7D?N ! N (.+-N ! % N-!-NN +,(' '/ +$ !+N! N'(-N ++" N('N (&& +L "%N -"/"-2N"'N-! N'"- N-- ,?N! N 1 + ", N( N) +,('%N#.L +", " -"('N .' +N -! N ,) " " L#.+", " -"('N ))+( !N ( ,N '(-N ' ,,+"%2N -.+'N ('N -! N 1",- ' N ( N (&& + "%N  -"/"-2N "'N -! N'"- N-- ,?N.-N-! N+ ,('N-! N(.+-N / N (+N!(% "' N -!-NN +,(' '/ +$ !+N! N'(-N '  N"'NG (&& + "%N  -"/"-2HN "'N -! N '"- N -- ,N ",N -!-N "-N ! N '(-N '  N "'( #N -"/"-2N"'N-! N'"- N-- ,?N
N-+/ %N '-F,N,% N( N-! N .+"%N ,,N 0,N  -"/"-2N 2N -! N -+/ %N  '-@N '(-N 2N -! N (+L " 'N +"%+( ?N .,-N ,(N 0"-!N )%"'-" ,FN ,."-AN ! N  -"/"-2N ('N 0!" !N ) +,('%N #.+", " -"('N ",N ," N -(N + ,-N ",N  -"/"-2N 2N ((N ' N +"-3@N '(-N 2N + %4M' N '(-N / 'N %% %2N 2N' !(N+",./@N0!" !N((N! N' / +N! + N( N.'-"%N ,! N0,N"'N 1" (?N(&"' N-! N+-"('% N( ( (  ' !  N0"-!N-! N% %N,-' + N( ( @N' N-! N+ .& '-N (+N) +,('%N#.+", " -"('N"'N %%"'(",N /)(+- ,?N !",N &$ ,N "-N .'' ,,+2N (+N .,N -(N ('," +N + %4F,N ('- '-"('N-!-N"-N",N-N&(,-NN)+ '-N( NN 1" 'N!(- %N()L +-(+?N  ?N  (
( !$(  @N 689N ?N -?N <9;N C7569DN C'(N #.+", " -"('N"'N-! NN-(N '- +-"'NN,."-N, N('N -"/"-" ,N( N (?N6:L7556N :N

N (+ " 'N (+)(+-"('N-!-N",NN)+ '-@N,.," "+2@N(+N "%"- N ( N N N "+&N ,.# -N -(N ' +%N #.+", " -"('N ! + D?N %"'-" ,N 'N,. N"'N 1" (@N' N&2 N"'N)"'@N.-N %%"'(",N",N'(-N'N /"%% N (+.&?N
  N