In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

'=O49L579<O

 O  >O  
 >O O

 O
O
 OO  >O  
=O JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

(( $O *'%O, O&!, O,, +O!+,*!,O'-*,O '*O, O'-, *&O!+,*!,O' O $$!&'!+=O '=O48LL8:4L L ONO  
   >! =O JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

O O49>O5349ONO O O5>O5349O JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJO

 '* O 
 >O
>O & O 
>!  !  =O 
 >!  !  =O '*%$$1O O !+,*!,O '-*,O %1O * - O O *!%!&$O + &, & O '&$1O /!, !&O 47O 1+O ' O !,+O !%('+!,!'&=O =O=O*!%=O=O68BC=O-,O! OO(*!+'& *O(*'.! +O +-+,&,!$O++!+,& O,'O(*'+ -,'*+O , *O !& O+ &, & >OO !+,*!,O '-*,O %1O * - O , O + &, & O ,O &1O ,!% O '&O , O (*'+ -,'*G+O%',!'&=O =O=O*!%=O=O68BC=O &&! *O !*#O &L "'1 O'& O+- O* -,!'&@O, O !+,*!,O"- O-,O *O+ &, & O 5O '=O49L579<O

B '*O%!$O& O/!* O *- CO *'%O4;;O,'O443O%'&, +=O !*#O'&L , & +O , ,O + O (*'.! O  !,!'&$O ++!+,& O  , *O , ,O * L -,!'&O & O !+O &,!,$ O ,'O O -*, *O * /* >O -,O , O &!, O ,, +O
,,'*& 1O +O $!& O ,'O !$ O O + '& O %',!'&O -& *O -$ O68BC=O !*#O, &O !$ O, !+O+-!,O-& *O, O
%!&!+,*,!. O *' -* O
,>O 8O ===O K:35>O +#!& O O !+,*!,O "- O ,'O + ,O +! O , O (*'+ -,'*G+O !+!'&O &',O ,'O !$ O , O %',!'&O , ,O /'-$ O( *%!,O, O'-*,O,'O* - O *O+ &, & O -*, *=O  O !+,*!,O "- O !+%!++ O , O '%($!&,>O !.!& O ,/'O * +'&+=O 5349O ==O !+,=O  O 8:656O B==O $$=O
(*=O 5<>O 5349C=O !*+,>O , O "- O , '- ,O , ,O / , *O ,'O %# O O -$ O 68BCO %',!'&O !+O '%%!,, O ,'O  &1O !+* ,!'&O 1O $/>O *!& !& O !*#G+O$!%O/!, !&O, O+'( O' O, O 0$-+!'&O,'O

O* .! /O !&O 8O ===O K:34BCB5C=O  '& >O , O "- O  $! . O , ,O , O *! ,O/1O '*OO(*!+'& *O,'O',!&O* .! /O' O, O(*'+ -,'*G+O !+!'&O!+O1OO'$$, *$O,,#O-& *O5;O===OK5588N& O , O

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

,& O /!, O ', *O (*'+ -,!'&+=O O +,, O , ,O , O ( *%!+L +!$ O *'-& +O' O* .! /O* O, '+ O, ,O(($1O,'O$$O 0 *!+ +O ' O (*'+ -,'*!$O !+* ,!'&N+O O (*,!$O %,, *>O * O !+L *!%!&,!'&O'*O', *O'&+,!,-,!'&$O,*&+ * ++!'&+=O837O==O,O 4;8M;9=O O$+'>O = =>O ! ! !
>O84:O==O789>O 796O B4<<9C@O !  ! !  >O :<6O =6 O :45>O :4<M56O B:, O !*=O 5348CO B &O &C=O  -+ O , O !+!'&O / , *O ,'O !$ O O -$ O68BCO%',!'&O!+O* .! /$ O'&O, '+ O *'-& +>O!,O +O&',O  &O'%%!,, O,'O &1O !+* ,!'&O1O$/>O& OK:34BCB5CO , * '* O ' +O&',O '* $'+ O* .! /O-& *O, O

=O  0,O-(?O' +OK5588O(*'.! O&O )-, O* % 1O& O+'O $'#O

O * .! /O -& *O K:37AO  O !+,*!,O '-*,O +! O 1 +>O !,!& O,/'O !+!'&+O, ,O .$-, O, O+ & O' O-$ O68BCO %',!'&+O -*!& O '$$, *$O ,,#+O -& *O K5588=O !  ! ! >O:3:O=6 O;<;OB:, O!*=O5346C@O ! ! !   >O 88;O =6 O 9;3O B:, O !*=O 533<C=O  ,O & !, *O '(!&!'&O '$ +O , ,OK5588O!+O, O*! ,O((*' O+OO & *$O%,, *=O &!  O , O '-*,O , '- ,O K5588O &O ((*'(*!, O . !$ O  L -+ O, O & &,O'&, & O, ,O, O(*'+ -,'*O  O'&L !,!'& O , O !$!& O ' O O -,-* O -$ O 68BCO %',!'&O '&O , O L & &,G+O/!. *O' O !+O*! ,O,'O(( $O *'%O, O"- % &,O' O '&.!,!'&=O O+/O, ,O+O */!& O!&,'O)- +,!'&O, O.$! !L ,1O' O, O'&.!,!'&O!,+ $ >O& OK5588O!+O +! & O,'O$$'/O L & &,+O,'O'&, +,O, O.$! !,1O' O, !*O'&.!,!'&+=O &! >O ,''>O, O & &,O* - O, ,O !+O+ &, & O/+O-&'&+,!,-L ,!'&$>O% O !+(*'('*,!'&, O& O 0 ++!. O1O, O *&,O' OO -$ O68BCO%',!'&O!&OOO+ =O O $ O, ,OK5588O/+O &',O .!$$ O ,'O %# O , ,O * -% &,>O '/ . *>O  -+ O , O & &,O  O &',O +'- ,O * $! O -&,!$O , O 1 *O $$'/ O 1O K5588B CO  O 0(!* =O 7O '=O49L579<O

'*O%'+,O+!,-,!'&+N' O/ ! O !*#G+O!+OO '' O 0%($ N K5588O ' +O&',O(*'.! O&O )-, O/1O,'O'&, +,O, O(*'+L -,'*G+O !+!'&O&',O,'O !$ OO-$ O68BCO%',!'&=O O!$$-+L ,*, +O , O (*'$ %=O
'* !& O ,'O K5588B C>O %',!'&+O %-+,O  O !$ O/!, !&OO1 *O' O, O"- % &,G+O !&$!,1=O ,!'&O5588B CO +O +'% O 0 (,!'&+>O +- O +O & /O & O * ,*',!. O *-$ +O ' O $/>O -,O &'& O (($! +O / &O O (*!+'& *O '&, & +O , ,O +-L +,&,!$O ++!+,& O "-+,! ! +O O $'/ *O + &, & =O  ,O -$ O 68BCB5CO -, '*!2 +O + &, & O * -,!'&+O $'& O  , *O O 1 *O *'%O, O'&.!,!'&G+O !&$!,1?O ('&O , O '. *&% &,G+O %',!'&O % O %'* O , &O '& O 1 *O  , *O + &, &!& >O , O '-*,O %1O * - O O + &, & O ! O , O & &,G+O +-+,&,!$O++!+,& O!&.'$. ?O B
CO !& '*%,!'&O &',O #&'/&O ,'O , O & &,O -&,!$O '& O 1 *O '*O%'* O , *O+ &, &!& @O BCO !& '*%,!'&O (*'.! O 1O , O & &,O ,'O , O '. *&L % &,O /!, !&O '& O 1 *O ' O + &, &!& >O -,O / ! O ! O &',O  L '% O-+ -$O,'O, O '. *&% &,O-&,!$O%'* O, &O'& O1 *O L , *O+ &, &!& @O'*O BCO !& '*%,!'&O , O -+ -$& ++O ' O / ! O '-$ O &',O * +'&L $1O . O &O&,!!(, O1O, O & &,O-&,!$O%'* O, &O '& O1 *O , *O+ &, &!& O& O/ ! O/+O(*'%(,$1O(*'.! O ,'O , O '. *&% &,O  , *O !,+O -+ -$& ++O /+O * +'&$1O (L (* &,O,'O, O & &,=O

O %',!'&O -& *O -$ O 68BCB5C>O %'* O , &O O 1 *O  , *O *O + &, &!& >O!+O 0,$1O/ ,O !*#O/&,+O, O(*'+ -,'*O,'O !$ =O  ,!'&O 5588B CO & !  O + '/O , ,O K5588O ' +O &',O  '* O *O&O )-, O% &+O' O* .! /=O & >O /!, O ** O 0 (,!'&+O ' O , O +'*,O !$$-+,*, O 1!   >O K5588O ' +O &',O  * ++O , O (*'(*! ,1O ' O /!, L '$ !& OO%',!'&O-& *O-$ O68BC=O ,!'&O5588BCO(*'.! +?O '=O49L579<O 8O

O (*!+'& *O !&O -+,' 1O -& *O + &, & O ' O O '-*,O +,$!+ O 1O
,O ' O '& * ++O $!%!& O , O *! ,O ,'O  O * $ + O -('&O , O *'-& O, ,O, O+ &, & O/+O!%('+ O!&O.!'$,!'&O' O, O'&+,!L ,-,!'&O'*O$/+O' O, O&!, O,, +>O'*O, ,O, O'-*,O/+O/!, '-,O "-*!+ !,!'&O,'O!%('+ O+- O+ &, & >O'*O, ,O, O+ &, & O/+O!&O 0 ++O ' O , O %0!%-%O -, '*!2 O 1O $/>O '*O !+O ', */!+ O +-L " ,O,'O'$$, *$O,,#>O%1O%'. O, O'-*,O/ ! O!%('+ O, O + &, & O,'O., >O+ ,O+! O'*O'** ,O, O+ &, & =O

!*#O ' +O &',O  .& O &1O ' O , + O *'-& +=O  O ' +O &',O +1O, ,O *O+ &, & O/+O!%('+ O!&O.!'$,!'&O' O, O'&+,!L ,-,!'&O'*O$/+>O, ,O, O !+,*!,O'-*,O$# O"-*!+ !,!'&>O, ,O , O+ &, & O 0 +O, O$/ -$O%0!%-%>O'*O, ,O!,O!+OH', L */!+ O+-" ,O,'O'$$, *$O,,#I=O *O* -% &,>O*, *>O!+O , ,O ('+,L+ &, & O . $'(% &,+O &,!,$ O *O ,'O O * /* O '*O ++!+,& =O -+,O +O ('+,L+ &, & O * ,*',!. O  & +O !&O , O  &, &!& O -! $!& +O * O !%($ % &, O -& *O 4;O ===O K68;5BCB5CO*, *O, &OK5588>O('+,L+ &, & O++!+,& O,'O, O (*'+ -,'*O (++ +O '-,+! O , O +'( O ' O K5588=O
+! !  ! ! >O493O=6 O463<>O4646O&=9OB44, O!*=O4<<;C>O'L + *. >O-$ O68BCO(*'.! +OO% &+O,'O* - OO$ $$1O!%L ('+ O + &, & @O / &O , O '&.!,!'&O !+O (*'( *O & O , O + &L , & O$/ -$>OK5588O!+O-&.!$$ =O -,O !,O * $1O '$$'/+O , ,O * .! /O -& *O , O

O !+O (L (*'(*!, N* .! /O , ,>O !. &O , O . &- O (*'.!+!'&+O !&O 5;O ===O K46<4B CB4C>O '-$ O '-*O !&O %-$,!($ O !+,*!,+>O !&$- L !& O , O !+,*!,O / * O , O (*!+'& *O !+O '& !& O & O , O !+L ,*!,O ' O '$-%!=O 'O %,, *O / ,O / O %# O ' O K5588O +O &O  )-, O * % 1O '*O , O (-*('+ O ' O K:37>O !,O /'-$ O  O &O -& ((1O . $'(% &,O,'O+($!,OO*!%!&$O+ O!&,'O * % &,+O & O . O!++- +O+- O+O-$ O68BCO%',!'&+O$!,! , O !&O !+L ,*!,+O, ,O ! O&',O '+,O, O*!%!&$O(*'+ -,!'&=O 9O '=O49L579<O

$, '- O K5588O -+-$$1O !+O O (''*O /1O ,'O (*' >O !*#O '-$ O . O !$ O&O'* !&*1O%',!'&O!&O, O*!%!&$O+ O+#L !& O , O "- O ,'O '%( $O , O (*'+ -,'*O ,'O !$ O O -$ O 68BCO %',!'&=O  O !  ! ! >O 6<3O =6 O 4336O B:, O !*=O 5337COB-+!& O, !+O(*' -* O,'O'&, +,O, O(*'+ -,'*G+O !L +!'&O &',O ,'O !$ O O %',!'&C=O !. &O -$ O 68BCO , O "- O $#+O -, '*!,1O,'O* - O !*#G+O+ &, & ! O, O(*'+ -,'*O !$ +O O %',!'&>O -,O O + '/+O , ,O , O '-*,O +O , O ('/ *O ,'O '%( $O, O !$!& O' O+- OO%',!'&O! O, O*!, *!O '*O* .! /O' O (*'+ -,'*!$O !+* ,!'&O . O &O+,!+ ! =O -+O, * O&L &',O O&1O '-,O'-,O, O !+,*!,O'-*,G+O('/ *O,'O &, *,!&O O %',!'&O +#!& O , O "- O '*O , ,O * $! =O
& O  -+ O , !+O #!& O' O%',!'&O!+OO'%($ , O* % 1O '*O+'% '& O!&O !*#G+O ('+!,!'&>O 8O ===O K:37O '* $'+ +O * +'*,O ,'O , O

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

O!+O&',O, O*! ,O/1O,'O+ #O&O'* *O'%L ( $$!& O, O(*'+ -,'*O,'O !$ OO-$ O68BCO%',!'&=O
  O