%KK *K%$"/K $K%($K- * K;K;K
&&;K;K32;1

United States Court of Appeals %(K* K,$* K (+ *   %<K"" $% )K60604K +# **K +"/K20<K2018GK  K +"/K30<K2018K K K  %( K  
K;K
 <   K K K 
K;K
  <   K K K
K ;K;K<   K K K %;K17H2567K
&&"K (%#K * K $ *K **)K  )*( *K %+(*K %(K * K  K
KK

<K %(* ($K  )*( *K % K "" $% )<K K  
<K )*($K , ) %$;K K K ;K K %;K16KK2H1K 
K <K  (")K;K %( "<K;K K  
 ;K K  K K %$"K%-$K&"K + "*/K*%K*($)&%(* $ K "K&%($% (& /<K18K;;;K F2252
>?>1?<K$K-)K)$*$K*%K15K/()CK #&( )%$#$*;K K"$ * K% K* K)$*$K &$)K%$K$K$ $#$*K+$(K18K;;;KF2252
>?>1?<K-  K&&" )K*%K$/K&()%$K - %K )KK%$, * %$KD+$(K* K"-)K% K$/K**K("* $ K*%K (,*K).+"K+)<K ).+"K+)<K%(K+) ,K).+"K%$+*K $,%", $ KK# $%(K%(K-(<K%(K* K&(%+* %$<K KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK GK
*(K .# $ $ K * K (  )K$K * K(%(<K-K ,K%$"+K * *K %("K ( +#$*K )K +$$))(/;K K;K;K
&&;K;K34>?>2?>?;K K %;K17H2567K  K2K

&%)))) %$<K( &*<K# " $ <K)"<K )*( +* %$<K) &#$*<K%(K*($)&%(** %$K% K "K&%(H $% (& /<K%(K).K*( ! $ K% K "($E;K+)* %$K>?>1?K&(%, )K %(KK# $ #+#K *(#K% K15K/()K$KK#. #+#K% K40=K- * %+*K* K$ $#$*K* K)**+*%(/K($ K %(K %-$K-%+"K ,K$K5K*%K20K/();K
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
"* %+ K* K%+(*K#+)*K$%*K$ $K* K)$*$K+$(K)+)* %$K>?>1?<K *K(H # $)K (K*%K%$) (K%-$C)K*+"K%$+*K- $K.( ) $ K *)K )(* %$K*%K( *KK )$*$<K- * $K* K($ K% K5K*%K20K/()<K %(K* K%$+*K% K-  K%-$K)*$)K%$H , *;K
K + K )K&(# **J $K('+ (J*%K%$) (K* KD )*%(/K$K (*(H )* )EK% K* K $$*;K18K;;;KF3553>?>1?;KK    <K576K;3K400<K 403K:K$;2K>7* K (;K2009?;KD %K" # ** %$K) ""KK&"K%$K* K $ %(#* %$K%$($ $ K * K! (%+$<K (*(<K$K%$+*K% KK&()%$K%$, *K% K$K% $)K-  KK %+(*K% K* K$ *K**)K#/K( ,K$K%$) (K %(K* K&+(&%)K% K #&%) $ K$K&H &(%&( *K)$*$;EK18K;;;KF3661;K %;K17H2567K  K3K

K*(+)*K* *K- $K$*( $ KK$-K)$*$K* K )*( *K%+(*K- ""K%((*K* K + H #$*K*%K( "*K* *K%-$K )K$K%$, *K% K, %"* $ K18K;;;KF2252
>?>1?K$K $%*<K)K* K + #$*K$%-K()<K18K;;;KF2252>1?>1?K@) AK$K>?>1?;K 

K
K
K