'H H!, H'&$1H!&H'* & H/!, H >H>H
((>H>H65>4

United States Court of Appeals '*H, H . &, H!*-!,  ! '?H $$!&'!+H93937H -%!,, H 1H47?H5353FH  ! H 1H4;?H5353H H H  '*  H  
 H>H
 ?$  $ H H H 
 H>H
?$  $ H H H 
 H>H
?$  $ H H H '+>H4<G5455H=H4<G5<78H  ,!,!'&+H '*H  .! /H ' H *G 
 H

G
?H *+H' H, H'* H' H %%! *G H   ?H ,!'&H
(( $+>H H H H >H '>H
3;:G<7:G;6<H 
H>H
?H
,,'*& 1H & *$?H H   >H H  H H /'H1 *+H '?H, !+H'-*,H &! H-$H$2G%!* 2D+H( ,!,!'&H '*H* .! /H' HH !&$H '* *H '*H !+H* %'.$H *'%H, H&!, H,, +H,'H 0!'>H ! # !$ "$   ?H<3;H >6 H5;5HB:, H!*>H534;C>H !$ H, ,H( ,!,!'&H/+H( & !& ?H$2G%!* 2H !$ H/!, H, H '* H' H %%! *,!'&H
(( $+H', HH%',!'&H,'H* '( &H& HH%',!'&H,'H* '&+! *>H H '* H &! H, '+ H%',!'&+?H& H$2G%!* 2H ! H&',H+ #H"- !!$H* .! />H &H H H FH
, *H 0%!&!& H , H *! +H & H , H * '* ?H / H . H '&$- H , ,H '*$H * -% &,H !+H -&&  ++*1>H  H >H>H
((>H>H67BCAH!*>H>H67B C>H H '+>H4<G5455H=H4<G5<78H  H5H

!$ HH+ '& H%',!'&H,'H* '( &?H'&, & !& H, ,H H!+H&'/H, H , *H' HH !$ ?H/ 'H /'-$ H+- *H * + !(H! H *H , *H/ * H* %'. H,'H 0!'>H H!, $ $ "$   ?H 46;H>H,>H5438HB534;C?H!&H+-(('*,H' H !+H* )- +,H '*H& $$,!'&H' H* %'.$?H, '- H H ! H&',H 0($!&H '/H, ,H !+!'&H $( H !%>H H  H'* H &! H, !+H%',!'&H '*H,/'H* +'&+@H!*+,?H, H+,,-, H& H* -$,!'&+H$G $'/H'&$1H'& H%',!'&H,'H* '( &?H/ ! H%-+,H H !$ H/!, !&H<3H 1+H' H, H'*! !&$H !G +!'&>H;H>>>HE455<BCB:CB
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
(( *HB , H -& H8?H 5343CH'*H, H$, *H '-% &,H+ ,,!& H, H *!& HB , H -& H49?H5343CH *'%H+,'((!& H, H *-$H' H,!% H,'/* H43H1 *+H' H( 1+!$H(* + & H!&H, H&!, H,, +>H H!,+ $ H ' +H&',H * ++H, H)- +,!'&H/ , *H,/'H '-% &,+HB'& H/!, HH *!& H , H& H '& H/!, '-,CH&H H'%!& H,'H1! $ H'& H.$! H',! H,'H
(( *?H/ ! H+,'(+H, HG *-$H' H,!% >H/'H'-*,+H' H(( $+H . H $ ?H '/ . *?H, ,H H!%($! +HH& ,!. H &+/ *?H/ !$ H,/'H', *+H . H $ H, ,H,* ,!& H,/'H '-% &,+H+H'& H.$! H',! H!+H ( *%!++!$ >H'%(* H   $ "$
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

+H/ H . H $ H* ( , $1?H&H$! &H/ 'H$'+ +H '* H, H'* H'&H%-$,!($ H *'-& +H%-+,H'&, +,H$$H' H, %H!&H, H'-*,H' H(( $+>H
H '' H* -% &,H'&H'& H *'-& H ' +H&',H%,, *H! H&', *H!& ( & &,H *'-& H+-(('*,+H, H !+!'&>H ?H > >?H    $ "$ ?H<73H>6 H<9;HB:, H!*>H534<C>H H*  &,$1H(($! H, ,H(*!&!($ H,'H !+G %!++H&', *H$! &D+H( ,!,!'&H, ,H* $! H'&$ H/ !$ H! &'*!& HH,!% G& G&-% *H (*'$ %>H H $ "$ ?H'>H4<G59;5HB:, H!*>H *>H7?H5353CHB&'&(*  &,!$H !+('+!G ,!'&C>H H+% H'-,'% H!+H((*'(*!, H * >H H  H'* H!+H * H,'H (,H&H-&,!% $1H'*H&-% *G** H%',!'&H! H, H$! &H(*'G .! +HH '' H* +'&>H ,H$2G%!* 2H +H&',H'&, & H, ,H, H'* H-+ H!,+H !+* ,!'&H!&H'&$- !& H, ,H H$#+HH '' H* +'&>H.!& H! &'* H, H,!% G& G &-% *H(*'$ %?H$2G%!* 2H +H1(++ H&1H'(('*,-&!,1H,'H* - H-+ H' H !+G * ,!'&HB! H, ,H+-" ,H!+H'( &H,'H* .! /H-& *H, H((*' H' $ #  C>H
& H!,H !+H ! !-$,H,'H+ H '/H$2G%!* 2H'-$ H . H  HH '' H* +'&H '*H/!,!& H+H$'& H +H H ! >H
+H/ H'+ *. H!&H  $  $ "$  !#
  ?H<86H>6 H844HB:, H!*>H 5353C?H, H)- +,!'&H(* + &, H!&$ H  H &H#!#!& H*'-& H '*H1 *+?H& H, H '-*,D+H !+!'&H/+H+ H'&HH+,,-, H &, H!&H4<<9?H$'& H '* H$2G%!* 2D+H * %'.$H(*' !& +H &>H H  H( ,!,!'&+H '*H* .! /H* H &! >H